Alameda County Together for All Ad Hoc Committee Meeting - November 6, 2025
Alameda County Together for All Ad Hoc Committee Meeting - November 6, 2025
On November 6, 2025, the Alameda County Together for All (ACT) Ad Hoc Committee, chaired by Supervisor Nikki Fortunato Bas with Vice Chair Supervisor Alisa Marquez, met to discuss a response plan for immigration enforcement, a policy restricting county property for enforcement (ICE-free zones), and an update on federal impacts on Asian communities. The committee reviewed presentations from county agencies and Santa Clara County, heard extensive public testimony, and decided to continue developing both immigration enforcement items for a future committee meeting, while forwarding the Asian communities report to the full Board of Supervisors.
Consent Calendar
- No consent calendar items were reported.
Public Comments & Testimony
- Over 13 speakers addressed the committee, with near-unanimous support for the proposed immigration enforcement response plan and the ICE-free zones resolution.
- Many speakers, including representatives from the ICE Out of Dublin Coalition, First Unitarian Church of Oakland, East Bay Sanctuary Covenant, Sudō for Solidarity, Trabajadores Unidos Workers United, and the Interfaith Movement for Human Integrity, urged the county to take a strong stand against any potential conversion of the former FCI Dublin women's prison into an ICE detention center. They argued that detention centers increase arrests and cause community trauma.
- Several health care professionals and advocates from the Know Your Rights Health Care Working Group stressed the need for specific, detailed protocols at county health facilities, including staff training on warrant review, privacy barriers, and clear reporting chains.
- A speaker from the Alameda County Office of Education noted that school attendance dropped during the October ICE scare and announced foot patrol safety kit distribution.
- A former administrative law judge recommended establishing a clear protocol for front-facing staff to contact someone who can verify judicial warrants.
- Community members highlighted that the county's investment portfolio includes companies (Cisco, Alphabet) with ICE contracts and urged alignment with the ethical investment policy.
- The Alameda County Public Defender's immigration unit voiced strong support, stating that aggressive enforcement harms all residents, not just immigrants.
Discussion Items
1. Immigration Enforcement Response Plan
- Supervisor Fortunato Bas presented the two-part proposal: (a) direct the County Administrator to create a tiered response plan for immigration enforcement, and (b) adopt a resolution restricting use of county-owned properties for immigration enforcement activity (ICE-free zones).
- Anika Chowdry, Interim Director of Alameda County Health, described internal preparations since December 2024, including a modified incident command structure, building security protocols, staff guidance, and HIPAA compliance. She noted training for field staff is still under development due to union meet-and-confer obligations.
- Hannah Hamilton of the Social Services Agency reported that SSA established an agency work group in January 2025, distributed over 1,200 red cards in threshold languages, updated a resource guide, and signed an MOU with the Mexican consulate for child welfare cases. SSA has invested over $90 million in immigrant services since 2017.
- Mary Hannah Weir, Lead Deputy County Counsel for Santa Clara County, shared their county's 2011 non-cooperation policies, 2015 Office of Immigrant Relations, and recent steps including an October 2025 response plan. She emphasized iterative process, coordination with community partners, and a December 9 board report-back on ICE-free zone options.
- Supervisor Marquez requested additional input from the General Services Agency (GSA), justice partners (sheriff, probation, public defender, district attorney), and Alameda Health System regarding SB 81 compliance before advancing to the full board.
- Discussion also covered training timelines, union negotiations, and the need for more capacity in southern Alameda County.
2. Update on Federal Impacts on Asian Communities
- A working group of six organizations presented: Asian Health Services, Asian Prisoner Support Committee (APSC), Center for Empowering Refugees and Immigrants (SERI), New Light Wellness, and API Legal Outreach.
- They highlighted that 18% of ICE arrests in the San Francisco Bay Area (January–July 2025) were of Asian American and Pacific Islander descent. Many 1.5-generation Southeast Asian refugees face final removal orders despite having served their sentences.
- Speakers shared personal stories of trauma, detention, and deportation threats. One client was freed after community advocacy; another remains in a Louisiana detention facility without basic necessities.
- Organizations described unfunded or under-funded work: legal accompaniment, social bio-packets for pardon applications, mental health services, and participatory defense. They called for dedicated funding and collaboration with county programs (e.g., ACCORD, ACUDIR).
- API Legal Outreach noted success with habeas corpus petitions as a tool to release detainees, but lacks funding for removal defense in Alameda County.
- The committee expressed appreciation and Supervisor Marquez committed to meeting with the presenters to explore funding gaps.
Key Outcomes
- Immigration Enforcement Response Plan and ICE-Free Zones: The committee voted to continue developing both items and bring them back to the December committee meeting. Before that, staff will gather input from the General Services Agency, all four justice partners (sheriff, probation, public defender, district attorney), and Alameda Health System regarding SB 81 implementation. Supervisor Marquez will help coordinate outreach to justice partners. Supervisor Fortunato Bas will meet with the ICE Out of Dublin Coalition to explore incorporating their requests.
- Asian Communities Update: The committee unanimously approved forwarding the presentation and report to the full Board of Supervisors at its next meeting for broader visibility. No formal action was taken on funding, but the committee acknowledged the need for additional resources to support holistic, culturally competent legal and mental health services.
- Next Meeting: The December meeting date to be confirmed, with the goal of presenting comprehensive recommendations to the full board soon after.
Meeting Transcript
Good afternoon, everyone. Welcome to the meeting of the Alameda County Together for All Ad Hoc Committee. Let's call the roll. Supervisor Marquez present. Supervisor Fortinado Baas. Present. So thank you everyone again for joining us. We have a couple important items on our agenda. So to get started, I'll just review our agenda, and we have a brief slideshow presentation to give an overview of our work as a committee as well as to present the uh two recommendations. So today we have our first informational and action item, and that is a response plan for immigration enforcement activity in Alameda County. We also have another item, which is a policy that restricts the use of county-owned and county controlled properties for immigration enforcement activity. So for this item, we will hear a presentation from myself. We will then go to Alameda County Health, Social Services, and we also have a guest on Zoom from Santa Clara County. We'll have some discussion and take public comment before taking any potential action. And then our second item today is an update on impacts of federal administration policies and budgets on Alameda County Asian communities and recommendations to address that impact. And for this item, I'm really grateful that we have a number of community-based organizations who are joining us, including Asian Health Services, Asian Prisoner Support Committee, the Center for Empowering Refugees and Immigrants, New Light Wellness, and APIO, API legal outreach. So we'll hear those presentations and have some discussion as well as public comment. And then we will end the meeting with any comments related to items that are not posted on our agenda. Okay, let's go to the next slide. Just by way of background, the Alameda County Together for All or Act Ad hoc committee is a committee that was proposed in January and then formed with approval from the entire board, and we've been meeting approximately monthly since February. And our purpose is to coordinate a response to federal policy changes and budgets that impact our communities. In particular, we have been hearing about the impacts due to the federal administration's mass deportation agenda. We have also been hearing about impacts due to HR1, the big brutal budget is what I call it. So we've had hearings that have included immigrant and refugee rights, LGBTQ rights, reproductive rights, health care access, and food security. And there's a number of items that we have brought forward to the full board as recommendations from our committee, together with Supervisor Marquez. And that has led to funding by the full board with measured W Essential County Services funds in the tune of $7.5 million for immigrant and refugee rights, 16.5 million to food security, and 1.5 million to the LGBTQ community. And before I go further with our agenda for today, I do want to ask my colleague, our vice chair, Supervisor Alisa Marquez, if you would like to share any opening or framing remarks before we get started. Sure. Thank you so much, Supervisor Fortunato Bass and your team for gathering all the presenters and information for today's meeting. I really appreciate the collaboration and the partnership. And just want to take a minute to acknowledge the trauma and the pain many of us are still going through alongside our community members that were impacted by the increased activity a few weeks ago. Really sent everyone to react, and it's unfortunate that we're still getting these attacks for the federal administration, but I am really pleased of the work that we're doing here at the county to be prepared and respond because we know that there could be other threats to our community. Want to highlight that myself and Supervisor Fortinato Bass yesterday attended, attended the belonging in the bay convening with 12 other counties. So I know we'll be hearing from Santa Clara County later today, but just really want to thank everyone that organized that event so that way we can learn best practices, lessons learned, and our commitment here to strengthen our coordination in Alameda County. Also, want to flag and want to really thank our county staff who responded swiftly. And last week we just approved 450,000 for two positions for an interim office on immigrant and refugee affairs. That's significant. We've been waiting for that for a long time. So just really want to commend county staff that made that possible. And it's a parallel process, but my office is working to secure funding from philanthropy. And so far, we've secured over a hundred thousand dollars to initiate a study that will include community engagement so that way we can have a more permanent office in the future. So we're really tackling this in a phased approach. We're doing what we can immediately, mid and long-term goals. My primary focus is to sustain the work of this committee. We really need to have that vital infrastructure in place. So I just want to thank all the presenters today and everyone working in collaboration to defend every immigrant and refugee here in Alameda County. So thank you all for the partnership. Thank you for leading these efforts, Supervisor. Thank you to our vice chair. Um before, well, let's go to the next slide.
openpublica.com