OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Alameda County Election Commission Meeting – November 24, 2025

Board of SupervisorsMonday, November 24, 2025
BodyAlameda County, California
SessionBoard of Supervisors
DateMonday, November 24, 2025
StatusFILED
Video Record
0:00 / 1:10:16
Transcript — Verbatim
0:00

Okay, I'm calling the meeting to order.

0:08

Commissioner Butter?

0:10

Here.

0:15

Here.

0:21

Commissioner Fam.

0:23

Here.

0:26

Commissioner Ramon.

0:28

Here.

0:30

Commissioner Seabrook.

0:32

Present.

0:33

Commissioner Barlick.

0:35

Here.

0:37

Commissioner Wagner.

0:41

Commissioner Whitehurst.

0:44

Commissioner or Vice President Dieter.

0:47

President Lindsay?

0:50

Here.

0:51

And present.

0:55

And there's Commissioner Wagner.

1:00

Okay.

1:04

Are there any modifications, suggested modifications to the agenda?

1:17

Hearing none, we'll move ahead.

1:19

If nobody objects.

1:21

Okay.

1:23

We need to approve the minutes of October 2025.

1:28

They're on pages four through seven.

1:34

I didn't notice anything, but I'm not exactly the world's greatest editor.

1:38

Did anybody else?

1:42

Did Irene send you anything?

1:46

Okay.

1:48

I Irene is our best editor.

1:58

I'll move to approve the minutes from October 2025.

2:03

Moved by Commissioner Ramon, seconded by Commissioner Seabrook to approve the minutes of October 2025.

2:10

If there's no objection, we'll have them approved.

2:15

Does anybody object?

2:17

Okay, it's approved by acclamation.

2:21

Announcements and communications.

2:24

Staff.

2:26

No announcements.

2:28

Commissioners.

2:34

Okay.

2:35

I've got four items.

2:40

Commissioners uh Dieter, Felcher, and Whitehurst are all out of town and told me they would be here today.

2:49

So there's only one person missing that I didn't know about.

2:56

Just want to let everybody know that or remind commissioners that there's no December meeting.

3:01

Uh we just go with the way that uh Alameda County does it for the Board of Supervisors, uh, which is no meetings in August or December.

3:09

Um, and so the next meeting will be January 15th, 2026.

3:16

Um in January 2026, we will be electing new officers and our rules have term limits, so I'm termed out.

3:28

Um so we'll be electing a president and a vice president.

3:32

Um, and um maybe I can't remember offhand, uh like uh appointing somebody to be the liaison for new commissioners.

3:41

It can be a quite a quite a jolt to come on to a new commission and not know how to get anything on the agenda or you know how to do it, you know, what you can do and can't do.

3:52

So um so just think just letting you know you can think about if you're willing to do any of those things.

3:58

And the last one is that Zarbre's term uh ended, and um she has chosen not to continue.

4:06

So uh we're now at 11 members.

4:09

Uh the open seats that we have at the moment are the uh seat six, the impacted community seat, uh, that the um nominations committee has been working on, and now seat 13, which is the voting rights organization seat.

4:25

Um we will offer to the board of supervisors to help with the um uh voting rights organization seat, um, but that's not under under the ordinance, it's not.

4:39

We we don't officially uh nominate one from from the uh from the commission.

4:44

Um, so but we'll ask them if they'd like some hope.

4:48

My guess is they'll say yes, please, uh, because they all have it's very hard for them to fill all the seats they have to fill.

4:54

Um, okay, so that's all my announcements.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Public Engagement███████████████████████████27%
Elections Administration██████████████████18%
Personnel Matters███████████████15%
Community Engagement█████████████13%
Procedural███████████11%
Youth Programs███████████11%
Technology and Innovation█████5%
Summary of Proceedings

Alameda County Election Commission Meeting – November 24, 2025

The commission met on November 24, 2025, to discuss post-election updates, committee reports, and upcoming elections. Key actions included approving October minutes, recommending a new commissioner, creating a post-election assessment committee, and urging the Registrar of Voters to develop a technical solution for youth voting in vote centers by November 2026. The next meeting is scheduled for January 15, 2026.

Consent Calendar

  • Minutes Approval: The minutes from the October 2025 meeting (pages 4–7) were approved by acclamation without objection.

Announcements

  • No December 2025 meeting; the next meeting will be January 15, 2026, when new officers will be elected (President Lindsay is termed out).
  • Commissioner Zarbre’s term ended and she chose not to continue, leaving two open seats: seat 6 (impacted community) and seat 13 (voting rights organization). The commission will ask the Board of Supervisors for help filling seat 13.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • John Guerrero (public comment): Appreciated the release of cash vote records with each update. Noted that in this election, vote-by-mail ballots counted by election night rose to about 50% (up from 40% in previous elections). Expressed strong opposition to intermixing youth voting (16- and 17-year-old pre-registered voters in Oakland and Berkeley) with the countywide vote center system, arguing that software integration risks bugs and could jeopardize certification of the November 2026 election. Urged the commission not to pressure vendors to implement that integration.

Discussion Items

  • Registrar of Voters’ Monthly Update (Item 7): Staff reported on the November 4, 2025, statewide special election and Washington Township health care district election. Turnout: Alameda County 52.5% (507,873 ballots cast from 966,534 registered voters) vs. statewide ~50%. The official canvas continues, with about 3,366 ballots still needing signature curing. The one percent manual tally was completed. Discussion included signature verification training, the curing process (letters, calls, emails), and the Department of Justice’s request for unredacted voter registration data (no official request received). The commission asked about a public post-election debrief; staff indicated internal reviews are not typically made public but major issues are reported to the state.
  • Voting Participation Committee (8A): Commissioner Seabrook reported the committee is redefining its focus and will create a mission statement at its next meeting (January 2026). Commissioners emphasized it is a long-term project and they will look at other counties’ models.
  • Nomination Committee (8A): Commissioner Fam presented candidate Alexandra “Sasha” Hernandez for seat 6 (impacted community). Hernandez has experience advising poll workers, ran for Oakland School Board, serves on the Alameda County Language Advisory Committee, and is executive director of Somos Familia. The commission voted unanimously (7-0) to recommend her to the Board of Supervisors.
  • Youth Participation Committee (8A): The new committee has a tentative meeting on December 1, 2025. Goals include working with the ROV to expand youth pre-registration and voting, partnering with school districts, and reaching youth in juvenile justice and foster systems.
  • Post-Election Assessment (8B1): The commission created an ad hoc committee (Commissioners Butter, Wagner, and Fam) to draft an assessment report for the January 2026 meeting. Commissioners shared feedback: positive comments on early voting promotion, billboard “thank you for voting” ads, smooth vote-by-mail experience; one complaint about late voter information guides; and observation that vote centers had steady flow on election day.
  • Recruitment for ROV Position (8B2): Discussion on the upcoming vacancy (Registrar of Voters). The commission will send a letter to the Board of Supervisors offering assistance and encouraging commissioners and the public to spread the word about the job opening. No formal action taken.
  • Youth Voting in Vote Centers (8B3): The commission discussed the need for a technological solution allowing pre-registered 16- and 17-year-olds in Oakland and Berkeley to vote in person at vote centers. The ROV is already in conversations with vendors (DIMS and No Ink) but cannot meet a June 2026 deadline; the next applicable election is November 2026. The commission voted unanimously (7-0) to encourage the ROV to work with its vendors to develop that solution by November 2026.

Key Outcomes

  • Approved October 2025 minutes by acclamation.
  • Recommended Alexandra “Sasha” Hernandez to the Board of Supervisors to fill seat 6 (vote: 7-0).
  • Created a Post-Election Assessment Ad Hoc Committee (Butter, Wagner, Fam) to report at the January 2026 meeting (vote: 7-0).
  • Passed a motion encouraging the ROV to work with its vendors to enable pre-registered youth to vote in vote centers by the November 2026 election (vote: 7-0).
  • Directed the President to send a letter to the Board of Supervisors offering assistance with the ROV recruitment.
  • Next meeting: January 15, 2026, at 5:15 p.m. (no meeting in December 2025).

Meeting Transcript

Okay, I'm calling the meeting to order. Commissioner Butter? Here. Here. Commissioner Fam. Here. Commissioner Ramon. Here. Commissioner Seabrook. Present. Commissioner Barlick. Here. Commissioner Wagner. Commissioner Whitehurst. Commissioner or Vice President Dieter. President Lindsay? Here. And present. And there's Commissioner Wagner. Okay. Are there any modifications, suggested modifications to the agenda? Hearing none, we'll move ahead. If nobody objects. Okay. We need to approve the minutes of October 2025. They're on pages four through seven. I didn't notice anything, but I'm not exactly the world's greatest editor. Did anybody else? Did Irene send you anything? Okay. I Irene is our best editor. I'll move to approve the minutes from October 2025. Moved by Commissioner Ramon, seconded by Commissioner Seabrook to approve the minutes of October 2025. If there's no objection, we'll have them approved. Does anybody object? Okay, it's approved by acclamation. Announcements and communications. Staff. No announcements. Commissioners. Okay. I've got four items. Commissioners uh Dieter, Felcher, and Whitehurst are all out of town and told me they would be here today. So there's only one person missing that I didn't know about. Just want to let everybody know that or remind commissioners that there's no December meeting. Uh we just go with the way that uh Alameda County does it for the Board of Supervisors, uh, which is no meetings in August or December. Um, and so the next meeting will be January 15th, 2026. Um in January 2026, we will be electing new officers and our rules have term limits, so I'm termed out. Um so we'll be electing a president and a vice president. Um, and um maybe I can't remember offhand, uh like uh appointing somebody to be the liaison for new commissioners.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com