OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Fairview MAC Meeting – June 9, 2026: T-Mobile CUP Renewal Approved, Fireworks Ordinance Update

Board of SupervisorsTuesday, June 9, 2026
BodyAlameda County, California
SessionBoard of Supervisors
DateTuesday, June 9, 2026
StatusFILED
Video Record
0:00 / 1:11:16
Transcript — Verbatim
0:09

Cool.

0:10

Good evening.

0:11

Welcome to the June 4th Fairview MAC meeting.

0:13

We'll call the meeting to order.

0:15

Start off with the Pledge of Allegiance.

0:17

Member Higgins, will you lead us?

0:43

Thank you.

0:44

Can we get a roll call, please?

0:47

Councilmember Farmer, excused.

0:50

Council Member Higgins.

0:52

Here.

0:52

Council Member Philbin.

0:54

Here.

0:54

Vice Chair Rhodes, excused.

0:56

Chair Anglin.

0:58

Here.

0:58

We have a quorum.

0:59

Thank you.

1:01

And we'll open public comment.

1:02

Three minutes to speak on anything not on the agenda.

1:05

Do we have any speaker cards?

1:10

Or anybody online?

1:35

There we go.

1:36

Sergeant Fenton Cully with Alameda County Sheriff's Office.

1:39

I supervise our real-time information center.

1:42

And I just wanted to let the uh board know that uh and everybody uh attending this meeting that we will be uh moving forward at the unincorporated services meeting on June 24th.

1:53

That'll be uh down in San Lorenzo, office O'Brande.

1:58

And we will be presenting um automated license plate readers, our drone first responder program, as well as our pan-tilled Zoom cameras, um, and that will be uh eventually going to the board for a vote on June 30th.

2:15

So if anyone would like to attend that, you're more than welcome to.

2:18

We want uh community input, and that's all I have.

2:22

Thank you.

2:24

Yes, sir, it's it's June 24th on the uh unincorporated area.

2:37

Committee, but the board can board date.

2:41

The actual Board of Supervisors vote will be June 30th.

2:44

Okay, yes, sir.

2:45

Thank you.

2:48

Thank you.

2:52

I have no other.

2:53

Oh, I'm sorry, I have a caller.

2:56

You're on the line.

2:57

You have three minutes, Kelly.

2:59

All right, thank you.

3:00

Yeah, just uh the uh county administrator and the county council just uh talked about some new law that's coming in, and it's gonna give uh all the Macs the um opportunity or option or possibility.

3:16

Uh and I think it's your choice.

3:18

I don't, I don't think it's um that this is something some other somebody tells you to do this.

3:23

I think you have to choose to do this, to do a lot more uh remote meetings.

3:28

And of course that's lower cost, and that way then their idea is that maybe they don't have to send out staff person out to the middle of nowhere to meet to uh to uh you know uh work at one of these uh meetings, um, and that that would save them a lot of a lot of trouble.

3:46

Um this is I and I just want to you know express my little my feeling about it's because I'm not sitting there going to all these meetings like you do, but uh the you know if if uh if there's the opportunity to do more remote meetings, I'd I'd say why not hybrid?

4:04

Why not do do a few of these remote meetings or and uh do and keep doing the in-person stuff quite a bit because uh I think there's value in in-person.

4:14

And you saw what happened, uh I think the pandemic was a big uh big lesson where uh they tried uh remote things, uh remote uh remote what was it, remote learning is what they called it.

4:26

And all the schools were doing that, and uh that it looked great on paper, except it doesn't work and and all the the performance and all the educational stuff went down down the down the toilet.

4:38

So I think the same with uh with the in-person meetings.

4:43

Yeah, you still have to have them uh quite a bit, maybe not all the time, but uh there is there's a lot of value.

4:49

Thank you so uh basically carl moose and i'm here to address where is the paperwork when we have a trip in fall due to a tree well on the sidewalk the county's tree wells so for an insurance claim where's the paperwork and how do we file a complaint when a bicyclist hits a pedestrian do you call CHP what do you do is it a is it a crash report what is it what makes it legal for a bicycle to be on the sidewalk scooters and e-bikes at the same time a pedestrian there's no room uh staff will follow up Fran you're on the line for public comment hi this is Fran Krug Chair Anglin you may have been announcing this in your comments later but I wanted to share two things regarding the fireworks ordinance the board of supervisors did pass it unanimously on Tuesday yesterday Bob Clark and I attended the sheriff's advisory committee meeting to thank Captain McMillan and Sergeant Imperial as well as Sheriff Sanchez for their work on getting the ordinance uh developed researched and ultimately enacted we were very pleasantly uh not surprised but very much relieved to hear there's going to be a major rollout PR program uh announcing the changes in the fireworks and there have received funding for a postcard to be mailed to all residents in the unincorporated areas of Alameda County um they also acknowledge the work that the Fairview Mac and Fairview residents had uh done to get this fireworks ordinance enacted thank you very much I have no other speakers for this item thank you we'll close public comment sorry chair before we move on um we do need to take public comment on the uh call the order roll call and pledge of allegiance so if you just want to open up public comment for anything on there and then close it okay do you have any public comment on those three items?

8:33

No I have no speakers for those items I've got that's something yeah okay we'll close that public comment okay no thank you next item approval minutes from May 5th 2026 we'll open it for public comment I have no, oh, I do have a speaker.

9:05

Kathy.

9:10

Kathy Langley, unmute your microphone.

9:13

Hi, I finally got through to you guys.

9:16

Thanks for being here.

9:17

I just wanted to make a comment about the housing limit.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Engineering And Infrastructure████████████████████████████████████████████44%
Procedural████████████████16%
Land Use Planning████████████████16%
Technology and Innovation█████████████13%
Public Safety█████5%
Historic Preservation████4%
Environmental Protection██2%
Summary of Proceedings

Fairview Municipal Advisory Council Meeting – June 9, 2026

The Fairview Municipal Advisory Council (MAC) met on June 9, 2026 (the transcript cites June 4, 2026—a discrepancy noted) to discuss routine business, public comments, and a conditional use permit renewal for a T-Mobile telecommunications facility. The meeting was called to order at approximately 2:00 p.m. with a quorum present (Councilmember Farmer and Vice Chair Rhodes excused). Key actions included approval of the T-Mobile CUP with additional reporting conditions and continuation of two items to the July 7th meeting.

Consent Calendar

  • Approval of the May 5, 2026 minutes: Motion failed (1 abstention, 2 ayes, 1 absent) because a quorum was not achieved for minutes approval. The item was rolled to the July 7, 2026 meeting.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Sergeant Fenton Cully (Alameda County Sheriff’s Office): Announced a presentation on automated license plate readers, drone first responder program, and pan-tilt-zoom cameras at the Unincorporated Services Committee meeting on June 24, 2026, and a Board of Supervisors vote on June 30, 2026. Requested community input.
  • Kelly (public comment): Expressed support for maintaining in‑person meetings while allowing hybrid options, noting lessons from pandemic remote learning. Opposed moving to fully remote meetings.
  • Carl Moose: Asked about paperwork for insurance claims regarding tree‑well trips and complaints for bicycle‑pedestrian collisions on sidewalks; requested staff follow‑up.
  • Fran Krug: Reported that the Board of Supervisors unanimously passed a fireworks ordinance on June 2, 2026 (actual date: June 8, 2026?), and thanked Sheriff’s office for development. Announced a major public awareness campaign including a postcard mailing to all unincorporated area residents.
  • Kathy Langley (on Item 1): Opposed the housing element, calling it “state‑mandated eminent domain” and urged local control and ballot measure. Referenced a wetlands area and coyote pups on site.
  • Chuck Meadows (on Item 2): Expressed no objection to the T‑Mobile application but raised concerns about the failure to track CUP renewals and the federal “shot clock” process. Suggested creating bargaining chips (e.g., undergrounding requirements) to retain local control.
  • Carl Moose (on Item 2): Criticized the planning presentation as insufficient, requesting explanation of power, watts, magnetic flux, etc.
  • Ashley (caller): Requested information on how to obtain details about the July 7th meeting for the D Street project; staff clarified that courtesy notices are mailed to neighbors within 500 feet and agendas are posted online.

Discussion Items

  • Item 1 – D Street Historical Site Development Review: Continued to the July 7, 2026 meeting. Public comment was taken; Kelly and Kathy Langley offered remarks opposing the housing element and environmental impacts.
  • Item 2 – PLN 2026-00012 T‑Mobile Conditional Use Permit Renewal: Planner Maral Esmaili presented the request to allow continued operation of an existing T‑Mobile facility co‑located on a 153‑foot‑10‑inch PGE utility tower at approximately 2718 East Avenue (no address on cover sheet). The original CUP (C‑8558) expired in 2017, but T‑Mobile continued operating via building permits and equipment upgrades. Staff recommended approval, finding consistency with Alameda County telecommunication standards. Council members questioned:
    • Generator use (backup only, per applicant Joshua Hernandez and Rodrigo from Planning).
    • The 300‑foot setback standard vs. 45‑foot distance to nearest residence; Rodrigo explained it is a guideline for visual and noise impacts, not a safety requirement, and FCC rules prohibit denial based on RF health concerns.
    • Aesthetics: possibility of artwork on cabinets, improved screening.
    • Typos in conditions (page 6, page 9).
    • Co‑location obligation (Condition 14): first carrier cannot monopolize the site.
    • Request for periodic status reports to the MAC.
    • Concern about RF/EMI testing at the nearby residence.
  • Item 3 – (Continued): Continued to July 7, 2026 to allow Vice Chair Rhodes to participate. No public comments.
  • Chair’s Report: Chair Anglin highlighted the passage of the fireworks ordinance and the upcoming PR rollout. (Fran Krug had already elaborated.)
  • Council Announcements: Councilmember Philbin reminded of the annual Veteran Celebration on November 8, 2026 at 1:00 p.m. at Lone Tree Cemetery.

Key Outcomes

  • T‑Mobile CUP Renewal (Item 2): Approved 4‑0 (Farmer, Higgins, Philbin, Anglin) with amendments:
    • Permit status reports to be submitted to the Fairview MAC every year for the first year and every five years thereafter.
    • Applicant to explore aesthetic improvements, including artwork on cabinets.
    • Applicant to conduct RF/EMI and audio surveys at the nearest residence and provide results to the MAC.
  • Minutes Approval: Failed; continued to July 7.
  • Items 1 and 3: Continued to July 7, 2026 meeting.
  • Staff Direction: County staff to correct typos in the T‑Mobile conditions of approval. Subcommittee updates to be provided to the Chair in advance for proper agenda inclusion.

Meeting Transcript

Cool. Good evening. Welcome to the June 4th Fairview MAC meeting. We'll call the meeting to order. Start off with the Pledge of Allegiance. Member Higgins, will you lead us? Thank you. Can we get a roll call, please? Councilmember Farmer, excused. Council Member Higgins. Here. Council Member Philbin. Here. Vice Chair Rhodes, excused. Chair Anglin. Here. We have a quorum. Thank you. And we'll open public comment. Three minutes to speak on anything not on the agenda. Do we have any speaker cards? Or anybody online? There we go. Sergeant Fenton Cully with Alameda County Sheriff's Office. I supervise our real-time information center. And I just wanted to let the uh board know that uh and everybody uh attending this meeting that we will be uh moving forward at the unincorporated services meeting on June 24th. That'll be uh down in San Lorenzo, office O'Brande. And we will be presenting um automated license plate readers, our drone first responder program, as well as our pan-tilled Zoom cameras, um, and that will be uh eventually going to the board for a vote on June 30th. So if anyone would like to attend that, you're more than welcome to. We want uh community input, and that's all I have. Thank you. Yes, sir, it's it's June 24th on the uh unincorporated area. Committee, but the board can board date. The actual Board of Supervisors vote will be June 30th. Okay, yes, sir. Thank you. Thank you. I have no other. Oh, I'm sorry, I have a caller. You're on the line. You have three minutes, Kelly. All right, thank you. Yeah, just uh the uh county administrator and the county council just uh talked about some new law that's coming in, and it's gonna give uh all the Macs the um opportunity or option or possibility. Uh and I think it's your choice. I don't, I don't think it's um that this is something some other somebody tells you to do this. I think you have to choose to do this, to do a lot more uh remote meetings. And of course that's lower cost, and that way then their idea is that maybe they don't have to send out staff person out to the middle of nowhere to meet to uh to uh you know uh work at one of these uh meetings, um, and that that would save them a lot of a lot of trouble. Um this is I and I just want to you know express my little my feeling about it's because I'm not sitting there going to all these meetings like you do, but uh the you know if if uh if there's the opportunity to do more remote meetings, I'd I'd say why not hybrid? Why not do do a few of these remote meetings or and uh do and keep doing the in-person stuff quite a bit because uh I think there's value in in-person. And you saw what happened, uh I think the pandemic was a big uh big lesson where uh they tried uh remote things, uh remote uh remote what was it, remote learning is what they called it.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com