1:48I'd like to call this August 19th, 2025, City Council meeting to order.
2:00Councilmember Sheeley.
2:02Councilmember McBride.
2:04Councilmember Mitchell.
2:09Councilmember Waring.
2:11Councilmember Seekings.
2:13Councilmember Tinkler.
2:14Councilmember Balden.
2:16Councilmember Appel, Councilmember Parker, Mayor Cogswell.
2:21I'd now like to ask Councilmember Tinkler to give the invocation and lead everybody on the Pledge of Allegiance.
2:28In memory of Reverend Darby, if you could bow our heads, uh, allow me to read an opening prayer that he gave to a session of United States House of Representatives on May 15th, 2003.
2:40Gracious, merciful, and omnipotent creator, we thank you for this new day for our grace, for your grace, for your wisdom and your mercy.
2:48We thank you for the blessing of democracy and for bringing us safely to this present hour.
2:53Bless and guide all that is said and done in this deliberative body.
2:57Bless the members of the House with your judgment, your strength, and your compassion, so they may they will make decisions with an eye not towards what is politically convenient, but towards what is right for all Americans.
3:09Bless our world and keep all nations in perfect peace.
3:12Bless our nation so that what Lincoln called the better angels of our nature will prevail.
3:16Bless our leadership at all levels so that public policy will be made in the light of the truth that shall indeed make us free.
3:24Have mercy upon us and help us to celebrate the diversity of our unity and the unity of our diversity.
3:30Let the words of your servant Amos be reflected in the decisions made here, so that justice will roll on like a river, so that righteousness will flow like a never failing stream, so that we can really become one nation under God with liberty and justice for all.
4:21So it will not be taken up.
4:22So I don't want you to have to wait through the uh the meeting.
4:26Uh just to realize that it's gonna been withdrawn.
4:29So now before we get going, I would like if y'all will uh humor me a little bit to take a moment of personal privilege to recognize an extraordinary leader in our city.
4:43Chief Curio, if you would please stand or join me better yet, up here at the podium.
4:50Last month, our chief was honored at the Southeastern Association of Fire Chiefs annual conference in Franklin, Tennessee, where he was named the 2025 career fire chief of the year.
5:07This award is the highest recognition given by the association, and it is reserved for leaders who set the standard for fire excellence across the Southeast, measured by their leadership, innovation, professional development, integrity, and their lasting contributions to the profession.
5:27As you all well know, with our chief having over 35 years in the fire service, the last seven uh being at the head of the Charleston Fire Department, he has guided our firefighters with steady leadership, a clear vision, and a true passion for protecting our community.
5:46His experience and dedication continue to strengthen not just our department, but the fire service as a whole.
5:54The Southeastern Fire, Southeastern Association of Fire Chief represents more than 2,000 members across 10 states, Puerto Rico and the U.S.
6:02Virgin Islands to be recognized by this by his peers at that level is a tremendous achievement and one that makes all of us here in Charleston very, very proud.
6:13So on behalf of myself, city council, and the citizens from Charleston, I wanted to give a hearty congratulations to the chief and thank you for all that you do to keep our city safe.
6:39Well first off, thank you.
6:42And what I would say is uh I got the award, but it is clear that it's a team effort in the Charleston Fire Department.
6:51We have such fantastic people who move things along every single day, and I am happy to work with them.
7:08All right, we have uh two recognition uh presentations or recognition.
7:15Councilman Tankler mentioned uh the Reverend Darby, the first is a resolution related to uh honoring Reverend Darby.
7:24Whereas the City of Charleston extends its deepest sympathy at the death of one of South Carolina's most devoted civil rights leaders, Reverend Joseph Darby Jr.
7:35And whereas a Colombian native Reverend Darby passed away on August 8, 2025, at the age of 74, just one day after his birthday.
7:45And whereas for nearly five decades, he faithfully served as a pastor at African African Methodist Episcopal Churches across South Carolina, including Nichols Chapel, AME in Charleston, demonstrating unwavering commitment to spiritual leadership, community engagement, and the better betterment of those he served.
8:06And whereas as a tireless civil rights advocate, he held leadership roles as first vice president of both the Charleston branch and the South Carolina State Conference of the NAACP, working as an advocate equally and justice statewide.
8:22And whereas Reverend Darby also served on several statewide education and civic boards, including the African American Achievement Committee, the Racial Cultural Advisory Council for the South Carolina School Boards Association, and the Board of Directors of the Daniel J.
8:38Jenkins Institute for Children.
8:40And whereas his leadership and advocacy earned numerous honors, including the Top Achiever Award in the South Carolina Black Male Showcase, recognition among South Carolina's 25 most influential African Americans, the NAACP Southeast Regional Medgar D.
8:58Everons Award, leadership award, an induction into the South Carolina Black Hall of Fame.
9:04And whereas his legacy is cherished by his wife, Mary Bright Darby, his sons, Jason and Jeremy, his grandchildren, and the many congregants, colleagues, and community members he inspired throughout his lifetime.
9:20Now, therefore, be it resolved that I, William S.
9:24Coxwell Jr., mayor of the city of Charleston, on behalf of our citizens, extend a heartfelt condolences to the Darby family and trust they will find comfort in the enduring impact of his remarkable life, leadership, and service.
9:53I wanted to thank uh Councilman McTinkley for the prayer that he brought reciting the words of Reverend Darby.
10:01I want to thank you, the city staff, all involved with the resolution that you just read.
10:09As we all know, whoever came in his presence, we all were very fortunate to have a man like Reverend Darby in our community, but frankly our state as well.
10:21I guess we stole him a little bit from Columbia.
10:25He's just such a I mean such a wonderful distance difference.
10:29And if anybody ever read any of his op-ed pieces, it would touch you.
10:34Um in the most serious way.
10:38So we pray thanks that Reverend Darby came this way.
10:45He won't be replaced.
10:46But again, we thankful that God sent him my way.
10:53I concur with my colleague and uh doing time, Reverend Darby and I go way back from the civil rights movement when I was really strong in the civil rights movement during that time, and then in NWCP doing that time when I was 14 years old.
11:08And um, he was always a person that was straight ahead.
11:13He didn't want no foolishness, but he always think about community and the people of the city of Charleston.
11:20Even wherever he goes, he's always gonna miss the city of Charleston, even when he was at uh Morris Brown A church.
11:27And I'm also AME too, so you know we all get together on that, but he used to talk to me all the time about it, and he was a person that really, really was interested in the community and the people of the city of Charleston.
11:41And uh, you know, when I heard got the news and I heard about it, you know, he kind of hit me, and I know he was going through some challenges with his sickness, but you know, God knows best.
11:51And I always say God knows best on everything, you know, and uh so we just hope the family finds some strength to keep going on, you know, even though he's gone, but he's still here in their heart.
12:06Thank you for those comments.
12:09Okay, we have uh uh another resolution or proclamation, excuse me.
12:17I'd like to ask Coach Spivey, uh, Councilmember Parker and the James Island Charter High School Trojans baseball team to join me up here on the podium.
12:29All right, good to see you again.
12:32All right, gentlemen, good to see you.
12:46Keep moving down, keep moving down.
12:59Councilwoman Parker, you gotta come up here too.
13:02Come on, come on, come on, come on.
13:07All right, we got the parents in here.
13:13Whereas the James Island Charter High School Trojans baseball team has demonstrated extraordinary talent, perseverance, and teamwork by winning the 2025 class 5A Division I state championship.
13:28And whereas this victory marks the second consecutive state title for the Trojans following their 2024 class 4A championship and reflects the program's sustained excellence and commitment to success.
13:43And whereas in a thrilling, hard-fought game three, the Trojans rallied in an extra inning to secure a 6-5 victory over Lexington High School, showcasing determination, resilience, and a never quit attitude.
13:59And whereas, under the leadership of head coach Matt Spivy and his coaching staff, the team overcame challenges throughout the season and in the championship series, earning admiration from their school, their community, and fans all across South Carolina.
14:17And whereas the city of Charleston takes great pride in the accomplishments of James Island Charter High School Trojans baseball team and recognizes the dedication, the sportsmanship, and the unity that they have shown.
14:32Now, therefore, I William S.
14:34Cogswell Jr., mayor of the city of Charleston, to hereby proclaim August 19th, 2025 as James Island Charter High School Trojans Baseball Team Day.
14:53Coach Five, you want to say a few where is he?
14:58No, that's no pep talk.
15:00Just uh um a heartfelt thank you on behalf of myself, my staff, and these players uh to the councilwoman Parker, Mr.
15:07Thank you for having us and recognizing us uh for the work that these guys have put in and achieved the success that they've had.
15:15Let's get a picture with uh with the proclamation.
15:17Who wants to hold the medal?
15:20I don't want to take it from here.
15:23Well, we're gonna be sure to stop then, right?
15:37All right, let's give one more round of applause to champions.
15:43Congratulations, man.
15:54One more day to that here at the next year.
16:08You want to win again?
16:09See you next year, right?
16:11We like half a day at this point.
16:24We are now on to public hearings.
16:27There are seven public hearing items tonight.
16:31Um items E1 through E2 will be as amended.
16:37I'm gonna ask Philip uh to give a presentation on each perfect.
17:27Thank you, Mayor, and members of council.
17:30So public hearings tonight um begin with uh this first item that is 835 Magnolia Road.
17:39Uh it's a rezoning request.
17:41The request is from the SR2 zoning to um that's a single family residential to commercial transitional CT zoning.
17:52Uh the property is located uh uh on Magnolia Road, it's in West Ashley, approximately maybe midway up Magnolia Road, uh, between Savannah Highway and St.
18:05Um it's really right adjacent to the West Ashley Greenway.
18:10Uh as you can see on the image, there's uh zonings around this property that's highlighted, uh including the the West Ashley Bikeway.
18:19I'm sorry, I may have said the greenway earlier.
18:21Uh this is the West Ashley Bikeway right next to it that's conservation zoned.
18:26Um across the street from this property, which is a church uh currently.
18:35Uh the the zoning across the street is uh similar to the to the rezoning request, which is CT, and uh some other zonings around there are uh DR1F, which is a diverse residential uh zoning.
18:51So the request uh is going from residential to a commercial zoning.
18:57Uh the church uh has requested this to add some flexibility to the property as they're going through a sale as they are looking to relocate uh their church uh from this location to another in the future.
19:14So a sale of the property would be um in its in its future.
19:19Um CT zoning is one that the city um views as something that uh fits uh within residential neighborhoods because it has somewhat limited uses, uh limited operation hours, uh, even limited size of uh the buildings in some cases.
19:39So this is just an aerial view of the uh the surrounding neighborhood.
19:43Um the um church itself uh from Magnolia Road.
19:50Uh this is a view into um actually it's a city right of way, Armstrong Avenue, which kind of goes into a parking area across from the church adjacent to the city's uh West Ashley Bikeway.
20:04Another view across Magnolia from the church is uh what used to be Pete's body shop uh for a long time.
20:12It was this property was rezoned to CT in 2018.
20:16Uh it uh had been an office, I believe an architecture office for a while.
20:22Um, I'm not sure if it's being used right now, but um it may be vacant.
20:28Um this is just another view of the of the office.
20:32Um the city plan recommendation for this area uh is it's in a suburban area, uh suburban areas in the city plan are indicative of an area that may not necessarily have commercial, but it might be predominantly predominantly residential, um, but does not preclude uh commercial or mix of uses.
20:58And so that was uh yeah, 835 Magnoli Road.
21:04I just wanted to um set something straight on the agenda.
21:08The um I believe the council district was in indicating uh reversed from that from uh uh the next item, which uh was um downtown.
21:21So uh we'll we'll make note of that on the um ordinance.
21:25So the next item uh E2 is uh moving to downtown.
21:30This is on Meeting Street.
21:32Uh you're I'm sure all aware of Scar Star Gospel Mission.
21:36The request here is a rezoning from uh the uh I believe it's the two to two and a half to three and three and a half old city high districts going to a four old city high district.
21:53So it it is uh asking for the entirety of the property into this four district.
21:59Um the city is actually the applicant in this case, uh, given that um there there are rules built into the city code about high districts that would only allow you to do one step up from uh uh or within the high districts one step up in height.
22:21And because the project that uh has been ongoing now for or in planning for a couple of years, um it has been evolving.
22:31A little additional height has been necessary, and because there was already a rezoning and height a couple of years ago, uh, it was necessary for the city itself to be involved in the rezoning of this property to make it a map amendment.
22:48So an aerial of the property, so the height district um would change to allow four stories.
22:56Um this would be an uh image just indicating kind of a line of sight, indicating what you might see from either meeting street on the right or Nassau Street, I guess, as well, and um you know what what it might look like from uh you know a person standing on the street.
23:17This would be uh ground perspective along Meeting Street, and this is from the neighborhood behind from Nassau Suite.
23:32Of course, uh in this area, as you might imagine, the neighborhood district or a designation uh in our future land use in the city plan is um pretty prominent downtown.
23:45It's just next to also a city center's um designation, which is the highest and most intense uh use uh in the plan.
23:58The next item can I ask a question?
24:00What are they building there?
24:02Uh um I'll let if the applicant is here, I'll let the applicant go into more detail, but if there is an expansion of the car gospel mission um you know shelters.
24:14Oh well, let's get to them all.
24:17Yep, I'll explain some.
24:21Uh the third rezoning is on West Ashley Circle.
24:26Sorry, and uh this is going from a gathering place zoning GP to general business.
24:33This is owned by the city.
24:34I believe we bought the property a few months ago, and um, as you know, is is slated for fire department uh operations, and um the GB uh zoning was was necessary from a design perspective.
24:51There are a lot of uh design standards and rules within the GP uh gathering place zoning that uh would have make it made it a little more difficult for us to to build the operation center.
25:00There are a lot of uh design standards and rules within the GP gathering place zoning that uh would have made it a little more difficult for us to build the operation center or aerial property as you I've I'm sure you're aware there's um challenges on the site, there's some wetlands, uh power lines.
25:17Uh however, we're working through those issues to design the site to include everything the fire department needs for the site, and uh this is in the uh part of it is in the uh low impact conserved area uh because it is somewhat low on the air on the property, and um most of the property, my understanding is would be given over to stormwater um area uh to make sure it does not impact surrounding areas.
25:50Uh the other zonings uh I'll zip through these uh are results of annexations, these are all single family, so zoning the E4 Liverpool Drive.
26:06Pine Bark Lane and Riverdale Drive and one more, I believe, 234 Yeats Avenue.
26:20These are all single family zonings.
26:24And with that, I am available for questions.
26:33Uh we have 12 people signed up for a public hearing.
26:38So we have 12 people signed up for uh public comment on one of these items.
26:44Uh we'll give everybody one minute.
26:46I do want to remind everybody the rules of decorum.
26:49You're here to have your voice heard, not to ask direct questions of counsel.
26:55Uh this is not a back and forth.
26:57Um, if you go over the one minute or uh or do something that breaks the rules of decorum, I'll give you one warning.
27:06Your second warning, uh you will be removed from the meeting.
27:10So, Adam Clerk, who do we have first up?
27:13All right, the time is one minute.
27:26I need some mic help.
27:32I want to make sure my voice is heard this minute.
27:42Bryant, 2123 Courtland Avenue, North Carolina 29403.
27:47My concern is the the star mission piece with the courier square.
27:51And Corey Square is really an impeding upon the progress of everyday people.
27:57Okay, that whole zoning area is a bad idea.
28:01Okay, and and having Meguire Woods, a Dominion Energy Corporation, in which I filed a public comment on low-income folks and their power bills.
28:11As a result, the city of Charles Police Department came to my address at President A.
28:15Bryant Coop on behalf of South Canada Department of Social Services.
28:19It would lead a U.S.
28:20attorney, so I can attorney general against me, but I appreciate this today.
28:24Again, these developers that you support, progress provide support, you know, police officer full time in that area.
28:32I saw old folks walking up King Street with and that whole development that Pier Manigolt and Gray Star who got billions of dollars.
28:41Look out for these community people because they're here until now, until the economic wind blows them out of the next time.
29:15Mayor and Charleston City Councilman.
29:17I'm Marcia Higgins, uh president of the Maryville Ashleyville Neighborhood Association, and here to speak about the rezoning of 835 Magnolia Road, which is currently a church.
29:33The residents of the community presented a petition to the planning commission on July the 16th and requests that they do not approve this request from rezoning from residential to commercial.
29:53The planning commission did vote.
29:56Eight to oppose and zero to approve, which we appreciated very much.
30:04We do feel that we have to look at the long term, the long-term basis of this property being rezoned to commercial, having a business located there.
30:21So we do ask you to please do not approve time this property is rezoned from residential to commercial.
30:30Thank you very much.
31:03Well, my name is Ramon Washington.
31:05First of all, honor to the mayor and the city council members.
31:08I am the pastor of One Word of Great, or One Word of Grace, located on McNolia Road.
31:13The reason for the request is we've been there for 10 years, just giving you a short version, really try to do outreach with the community, try to uh really build up a local church for that community, but we just haven't had the support.
31:26Uh as a matter of fact, all the members that currently attend our church, they're from other areas.
31:31Uh so we prayed as a body of Christ to relocate and continue the mission further to hopefully leave to advance and continue to build ministry.
31:41And I could say a lot more, but I know I'm on time, so I would really like you to uh consider the approval, and uh thank you for your time today.
31:58Mayor and City Council, I'm Arthur McFarland, and I represent Reverend Washington and the one word Grace Assembly Church.
32:07Um, this request for rezoning is probably one of those that uh is most beneficial to the community.
32:15Reverend Washington did not say, but the capacity of this church are 200 members, okay?
32:24Their church right now has only 10 members, so it does not present a problem for the community.
32:33It um without the church using that capacity with only about a dozen parking spaces.
32:43So the community wants this uh church to remain a church, but if another church comes in, there's no question that it will present a problem for the community.
32:53And that's why I say that this is one of those uh zoning rezoning requests that really is beneficial to the community.
33:02Whatever business uh purchases this property, time will be in a position certainly to have a lot more traffic and a lot less parking issues.
33:12So we ask that you approve the rezoning of 835.
33:16Thank you, Edward Phipps.
33:25Thank you, Mayor, Council.
33:27Um, this is the first time speaking here, so it's an honor.
33:31Thank you for everybody's service, Mayor.
33:33Thank you for yours.
33:34Um, I'm here just to speak on behalf of 835 Magnolia Road, the rezoning, and I would just ask that you approve it.
33:52Um, I think it's Gwendolyn Bobo.
34:11Here requesting that the owners appeal to all the camp zoning our church located at 835 Baggy believe the road from residents to commercial be denied.
34:22On behalf of my family, the Gatson family who's lived in that neighborhood since 1954.
34:29We still own the same property and we still have family there.
34:33Most of the residents in that area are senior citizens.
34:38And for a long time, our neighborhood, uh, Maryville as well as Ashley has had a lot of disturbance because where the bike trail is, the railroad had a track there.
34:54Running trains day nights, you know, people were killed on the railroad.
35:00Uh a lot of changes happened in the past 30 years.
35:05There's a lot of different traffic there, there are more drivers there, there are people who use cut throughs so that it we just don't need another change.
35:14So we're asking you to let it remain residential because the lot really isn't that big.
35:21I can't see you know any improvement with changing it to commercial.
35:27Thank you very much.
35:34Mayor, City Council members and neighbors, thank you so much for your continued support of Star Gospel Mission.
35:41As you know, for over 121 years, the mission has been a place of refuge and renewal for men and women facing homelessness in Charleston.
35:49Your uh approval of our rezoning request to four stories would strengthen that legacy and ensure that we can expand responsibly to meet today's needs.
35:59And to clarify, our request is for only a portion of 474 Meeting Street, not the entire TMS.
36:07Um, by the second week of October, you should know we will welcome the first women and children onto our campus since Hurricane Hugo struck Charleston in 1989.
36:16And that reopening to families is a milestone that has been made possible by your ongoing support.
36:23And for that, I'm deeply grateful.
36:24Thank you, and God bless you.
36:28Idries, we called on you when you were out.
36:30Did you need to speak evening?
36:44People ready to improve and develop the environment.
36:48Reflecting on our councilman wearing Gregory and Seeking.
37:01When you look at the three, you see the sixth district, and Gregory, Mr.
37:10Dudley, he did a wonderful job bringing the television in here.
37:16Tell your vision, and they told it.
37:20And when we look at Consulman Waring, his father was in their seat before him, and he was a warrior, and he challenged Mayor O'Reilly, and he's in the 7th district seeking.
37:43And he's trying to be the king of City Council.
37:47When you add the three on up, you get 21.
37:52Now seeking councilman seeking time is an S.
37:59And that's the 19th letter in your house.
38:16Oh, we have thank you.
38:22As a member on the executive board of the East Community Development Corporation, we were in meetings with the Gospel Mission the whole walkway through council member and mayor.
38:33And um, we strongly support them from the east side uh with them on what they're planning to do with the voting.
38:40Because I mean, we already done walk through, we already see it, we met with them.
38:44So they didn't take a no short cannon or no pinch.
38:47Everything they say they've been gonna do, and they are doing it right now.
38:50So I'm just letting you know, as a as a member of the executive board of the East Side Neighborhood Development Corporation, we fully support Star Gospel Mission with them going up the four story.
39:06Um Terry from Council.
39:14My name's Aurelia Carr Olverson.
39:16I am a native Charlestonian.
39:18I've been away from Charleston for 33 years, serving our country in the United States Air Force, and then in corporate America before I moved back.
39:26And I have to say, I do not recognize this place.
39:31This doesn't look familiar at all.
39:33The things that used to be the rules are no longer the rules, and that's not why I'm here.
39:37I am here to say that the look at uh the property on Magnoia Road going through Marysville and Ashleyville area, that it needs to remain residential.
39:48There's too much traffic that already goes all over everywhere, and that rezoning is just going to cause it to be a lot more challenging for the residents in the area to move through that area because everybody's here now.
40:04We don't need to put up any more apartment buildings here because apartment dwellers do not pay property taxes, and for the roads to be expanded the way that we need them to be expanded to accommodate the very people that we're inviting in, they don't help pay for that.
40:17At least that's my understanding of it.
40:29This is just for public hearings.
40:39Count is that as amended for items one and two to update the district numbers.
40:52Um through seven, one and two as amended.
40:57Councilman Mitchell.
40:59This is a quick comment uh so far as uh Stargard's permission.
41:02Uh I was working with Stargard's permission and the exception to what they're trying to do.
41:06They're gonna build this four-story building, but they're gonna have uh the buildings of space for women, homeless women with children, which is they have never done that before.
41:17But Stargard's permission has been in the business in the east side ever since I know myself, and I was doing that.
41:23I was working with them for over that's a long time.
41:26I didn't want to say how much years, but it's a long long time.
41:29I was breaking with Stargards permission.
41:31They have done a great job in that community and they'll pull up that community, and they help out a lot in that community.
41:37So this is the first time you're gonna see that they have uh uh building there for homeless women with children, and they're gonna assist those individuals once they stay there for a year or a little bit and a half to assist them in finding other permanent housing, and they will help insist on paying for them for over a year wherever they find the the housing there.
41:57And the other part of it, they're gonna also uh be able to expand a little bit with the uh with with females there because they have never done with females before.
42:07This is the first time they're getting in with females, always was males, and we don't have too many businesses around here that have uh house females.
42:17It's always male, male, meal.
42:19I'm a male, but you know, I still need the females there too.
42:21So we we need these companies, uh these businesses that do those type things because we have so many fee females that are here that's that are homeless.
42:30And if you come on King Street where I live, you can see them every day because I work with them every day.
42:34They come by my house every day, like one and two o'clock in the morning.
42:37Which I don't like, but then you know I started like my son told me the other day when he came down from Alabama and said, Daddy, well, you started, so I ain't got nothing to say.
42:45So you know they come by and I give them clothes with my grands give them clothes and I kind of help feed them and give them those change when that happened.
42:51But there's a lot of them out here that need a place to stay, but this would be a permanent place for them to stay for a long period of time and assist with the homelessness, and I hope some other uh community organization would do the same because we have a lot of people out here as on house.
43:10Any other questions or comments?
43:14Okay, we have a motion probably made and seconded.
43:18Um no further comments.
43:19All those in favor signify by saying aye.
43:27All right, we're now on to approval of council minutes.
43:31Second motion made, probably seconded.
43:33All those in favor signify by saying aye.
43:35I'm opposed, eyes have it.
43:37Now we're on to citizens' participation.
43:39Uh this period is limited to 30 minutes.
43:42Madam Clerk, how many people do we have signed up to speak?
43:45I think we have some people who signed up online and in person.
43:50So I believe we have I think we have 11.
43:56Okay, we'll give a minute and a half on this one.
44:00Would you please call the first speaker?
44:02All right, and just a reminder.
44:04Um, our rules ask that we start with speakers who are who have signed up to speak on agenda items first.
44:12Um the first speaker is before you get again rules of decorum apply.
44:16Just wanted to make a reminder on that.
44:21And the time is what a minute and a half thank you for allowing this um due process right to be allowed to object.
44:31Uh, my objection is that the South Carolina legislators and the 124th session allowed for amendment uh to title 50.
44:43The municipality here took that amendment, but they wrote their own set of laws and superseded South Carolina legislative authority.
45:00As few people in here know, I've been litigating against the city for a little over two years now and was successful in getting this ordinance brought back into the repealed state.
45:08But what they put back together is they just dressed the pig up in a different outfit.
45:15It's got new numbers, but it's the same rhetoric.
45:19Nothing has changed.
45:20They took out Officer Merrill's $300,000 liability insurance policy.
45:27But everything still violates South Carolina legislative authority, which is a constitutional violation.
45:35So their ordinance on the boat permit um will remain in federal court.
45:42I'm getting ready to pull my appeal back down from the Fourth Circuit and due to the activity over here in the clerk's office by preventing me to have a day in court there to get a ruling on the constitutionality of the ordinance.
45:57I'm moving back into federal court with that issue.
46:36I just filed my petition here uh regarding rate increases for low-income folk.
46:42Now the premise of homelessness is $20 in income, a wage.
46:49$20, you know, $20 an hour.
46:51Under $20 an hour, you're gonna have homelessness.
46:55So this quite the trick plate.
46:57$20 under $20, they at your house eating dinner.
47:01So let's keep it real.
47:03Now, when you use the South Carolina Department of Social Service, you did the building, right?
47:07Teddy Pride building, you did that building.
47:09And somebody calls your house on you on your business and your company, and at that point, no they deal with the IRS, U.S.
47:18Postal Service, Homeland Security.
47:20That's what they deal with.
47:22Attorney's Office, South Carolina Attorney General's office against yours truly.
47:26But I'm built for it.
47:27You dig what I'm saying?
47:28When you built for something, you don't worry about it.
47:30When you're not built for it, you're not, because you know what?
47:33And those who are black sometimes ain't black.
47:36So we got to get black people to be black again, so white can look at us a little more differently.
47:41Here's my information to get it to Mayor for the last time.
47:44Get us to the mayor because I don't have time to give it to him.
47:46I don't have time for that.
47:47I don't have time to meet him.
48:01I am uh John Hughes.
48:04Mayor, Council for Sins.
48:06I live on John's Island, as it turns out in District Three.
48:10And um turns out I live on Coral Reef Drive.
48:14Now I don't think there's any coal reefs off of Wapala, Edistow, uh, whatever.
48:20Um, but I have a book here on science book for you to help you because I know we have um lawsuit against big oil, and um basically uh it uh something I disagree with.
48:36But anyways, just so everybody who went up in uh mayor, uh little Chloe Clown Fleet, she lives with her family on the Great Barry Reef of Australia.
48:47One day at school, her class had a special guest teacher, Dr.
48:51Ray Eel, a professor from Cook University, took the class, took the class, he told the class that their home and families were in great danger because humans were causing dangerous climate change.
49:08Morio said that humans are adding carbon dioxide to the air when using fuel, like gasoline and coal.
49:17Um I believe carbon dioxide is a great uh nutrient that helps all their plants across the whole state.
49:27And this book, um, I know it's uh it's a textbook, but uh it's from the uh CO2 coalition.
49:35All right, and I hope it helps your decision.
49:38And I know we're the jump in on the other Darren Lee Calhoun.
49:54Um, first and foremost, I would like to express my deep frustration and disappointment in the council.
50:05At the time of his removal, my family called me from all over, congratulating us on taking a step forward.
50:11Now I feel as if I can say on behalf of my family that you all should have melted the thing down when we had a chance.
50:17Now, if we have uh we do have something that we can do right now, there's a portrait back there of John C.
50:22That's really easy for us to remove that.
50:24We could just have the gives come and take it away.
50:28As the chair of the history commission for the hundreds uh for the 250th anniversary, we explored it.
50:32Now on our public burial ground.
50:35Um you can use your influence to stop the building on this public burial ground at 106 Cummings Street.
50:43We absolutely should do it.
50:45When I was a member of the school board last year, when the College of Charleston presented this uh issue to us for a letter of support, we never heard anything about a burial ground at 106 Cumming Street.
50:56All we heard about was the YWCA.
51:01We want to continue to call ourselves um the call ourselves the leaders in historic preservation and conservation and interpretation.
51:09It is up to us now to stop the building on this public burial ground.
51:14It's not just the African burial ground.
51:16We have white people in there.
51:17We have orphans in there, we have indigenous people in there, and we have uh uh enslaved people as well as for uh free people of color.
51:25We have to stop this right now.
51:34Mayor, members of council.
51:35Thank you for having me tonight.
51:36Um I I want to just acknowledge that you'll be hearing a little bit tonight uh during public comment about an item not on your agenda, which is the public burial ground that Mr.
51:45Calhoun um referenced.
51:47Um the preservation society, who I represent, um, is in support of the coalition effort to educate the community about the very significant history uh being discovered at this public burial ground at Calhoun and Cummings Street.
52:00Uh the site is slated for redevelopment by the College of Charleston.
52:03I think you'll be hearing more about this issue in the future.
52:05I'm here tonight to just express the broad public awareness by city leadership is particularly important giving given the previous the city's previous role as an operator of the burial ground in the late 17th and early 1800s.
52:18Uh, this includes the years when Charleston became a global hub for the importation of Africans prior to the federal ban on the transatlantic slave trade in 1808.
52:28We're grateful that last week the college released an important uh history on the landscape, which was commissioned by BVL Historic Preservation Research.
52:36I'd urge you all to read it on the Cummings Street Commons Project website, um, given, especially given the extent of community dialogue on this issue.
52:46Frankly, it's been surprising to me, uh to us at the Preservation Society and my colleagues with cultural institutions throughout the city how little has been known about the site uh for so long, um, and how much we're coming to realize that this is really not an ordinary burial ground.
53:03So thank you for listening and paying careful attention to this issue, as it will undoubtedly remain an important point of community discussion moving forward.
53:11And the next speaker I'm having a hard time reading.
53:14I apologize, but I believe the address is Bear Island.
53:19And they signed up after Mr.
53:22And can I get your name for the record?
53:30Mayor, City Council.
53:31Um, in 2014, the Y put up their uh property at 106 Cummings Street for $5 million.
53:37Uh former College of Charleston alumni acquired the property for $8 million.
53:40No development took place.
53:42Um, and it was sold 10 years later for $27 million by the College of Charleston.
53:47The college commissioned a report by the BVL that clearly states that between 4,600 and 12,000 individuals were likely buried on the site.
53:56During the acquisition process, which began in 2023, the college engaged with elected and oversight committees and boards.
54:03This included letters of support to demonstrate that the project had local government backing and was in alignment with the city's priorities.
54:10What the college did not make explicitly clear was that 106 Cummings Street sits atop a former municipal burial ground.
54:16In fact, the first time it was explicitly mentioned is in March after the college had already acquired the property and was asking for an additional seven million dollars.
54:25The college failed to make it known to the city to the county or the state that the site it plans to develop was so filled with graves that it had to be closed.
54:34On August 4th, in a community meeting, the college stated it was aware of the burial ground and that it did not do any form of engagement with the community prior to purchase.
54:43I wonder if the college had led with transparency, would we be at a different outcome?
55:00I'm imploring the city and the office of the mayor to do not what is politically convenient, but what is morally right and take immediate action to recognize the sacred ground, acknowledge the souls of the people resting at this site and see what statutes and laws are in place that empower the city and the council and the mayor to ensure that this eternal resting place and that these people are not disturbed.
55:33And we've been weak too long.
55:35So we're trying to be, we're moving to be strong.
55:38On we're having an event on Martin Powell, cross-funded project at 155 Jackson Street.
55:49And you say something there?
55:54And it'd be uh from 11 to 6.
55:58The Bible say the harvest is plenty, but the labels are few.
56:03And we'll be calling on some labors to come out and work to try to do not try, but to get the wealth that we need in our neighborhood so that we can move out of the project and not be in a project and take advantage of the many things that Charleston have to offer.
56:27Charleston called itself a holy city, and we'll be working Saturday, Sunday, and Monday.
56:35And Jesus said the harvest is plenty, but the labor is a few.
56:40So we're asking you to join us because we have paid $500 with these three days, and that's a lot of money.
56:48That's a lot of money for a poor man like me and my group.
56:52So we're asking you all to help us because we're gonna be promoting culture, we're gonna be wanting education, politics, religion.
57:04And we will move on to our online list.
57:09And if you're online, you can press star six to unmute yourself.
57:26My name is Omar Mohammed, and I'm here on behalf of uh protect and respect the body's coalition.
57:34We are here today because the city of Charleston bears a historic and ongoing responsibility for the sacred burial grounds at 106 Common Street.
57:42From 1790s to 1807, the city itself established and managed this site as a public burial ground.
57:51That responsibility does not disappear simply because the land was sold later.
57:56Today remains of approximately 4,000 enslaved Africans, indigenous people, and immigrants are interred there.
58:05This reality should halt any development.
58:08Instead, it calls us to remembrance, preservation, and repair.
58:16There must be no disturbance of the bodies.
58:19Excavation, demolition, or removal would desecrate this sacred ground and erase the histories of both their ancestors and their living descendants.
58:29We call the city to support the forthcoming recommendations from the History Commission and HARP and to assist the College of Charleston in two critical steps.
58:53Continue silence is an act of erasure.
58:57Second, community partnership.
58:59The city must establish a commission that includes community experts to study the historical significance of this sacred site.
59:07This commission should also oversee the co-creation of finding community benefits agreement.
59:17And if you're online, you can press star six to unmute yourself.
59:35And HARC has been paying particular attention to and will continue to do so.
59:39Also want to uh share with you that Harlan Green, Chair of the History Commission, at their last meeting, history commission passed a resolution uh to work jointly with HARC to develop a set of recommendations in our advisory capacity to the mayor and council uh around the questions been raised around the coming Street Commons project.
1:00:03Um we think uh in our initial conversations that uh Charleston actually has a bespoke unique mayor uh solution uh that was applied uh in the Anderson Street burial ground project as relates to the development of the excuse me, Gilly Art Center.
1:00:22Uh starting from there, I think there's an opportunity to, we think that there's an opportunity uh to do some good work uh and move forward in a way that's respectful and bills uh community.
1:00:34Um we recognize that the council doesn't always have opportunity to uh deal with these matters.
1:00:40Um would ask you to consider uh possible council communications um session sometime uh in the next month or two, given the timeline uh that's in place to begin the demolition on the project, I believe, in in October.
1:00:56Thank you very much.
1:00:59Stephanie Favelle.
1:01:06And if you're online, you can press star six to unmute yourself.
1:01:12All right, I think those are all the speakers that we have.
1:01:15We did receive some comments online.
1:01:19Uh we received one comment from Mr.
1:01:22Babb, who spoke previously, and that was sent to council in full.
1:01:26Um we received one from Mr.
1:01:29Muhammad, who also spoke earlier, and we sent that comment to council in full.
1:01:34Um one comment was received from Brian McKendrick stating that the agenda item incorrectly listed the acreage for the portion of Folly Road being annexed, and that the item should be deferred until it is corrected.
1:01:47One comment was received from Travis Randall saying that more affordable housing was needed in Charleston.
1:01:54One comment was received from Megan Black Megan Bleisner in favor of the annexation and rezoning of a portion of Folly Road to PUD classification.
1:02:0385 comments were received in opposition to the annexation and rezoning of a portion of Folly Road to PUD.
1:02:09Five comments were received from Mr.
1:02:12One phone call was received from Gabriela Brown, opposed to the annexation and rezoning of a portion of Holly Road, and two emails were received in opposition to the first amendment demonstration ordinance.
1:02:24And those were all the comments we received.
1:02:30Uh moving on, we are now on to petitions uh and communications.
1:02:35There's one school resource officer agreement for approval.
1:02:40Uh this came in up to the last uh public safety meeting and needs to be approved for a grant request.
1:02:46This agreement is to add one SRO at the early college high school.
1:02:51Can I entertain a motion?
1:02:53Motion made, probably second any discussion on this.
1:02:55If none, all those in favor signify by saying aye.
1:02:59Opposed, eyes have it.
1:03:00There's several appointments for the commission on disability issues.
1:03:06Um one point I want to make out is that uh item C, the housing authority nomination is the the applicant has asked that it be deferred for 30 days.
1:03:18Uh so we want to take that one off.
1:03:20So can I get an amended motion?
1:03:24Motion amended and seconded uh for item C to be deferred.
1:03:28All those if no further discussion, all those in favor, please signify by saying aye.
1:03:33Opposed, eyes have it.
1:03:35We are now on to council communications.
1:03:38Uh Councilman McBride, I'd like to turn it over to you.
1:03:41Mayor, um, the the purpose of this will be to essentially report out to the the fellow my fellow council members who I know all of you except for myself and Councilman Tinkler deliberated um extensively on how to redistrict um Johns Island and other portions of Charleston.
1:03:59And uh after almost uh two years in the seat, uh want the opportunity to kind of report out to this council as to what I've learned and what the issues are that are are improving on on Johns Island and James Island, but um and where this the structural changes uh persist.
1:04:17Um, but I would like to defer this until November 12th.
1:04:21Um I'd like for uh some more time for some projects that the county is working on with the city uh and the state um to kind of come to fruition a little bit to be able to report out some of those things uh to you all on November 12th.
1:04:36Uh thank you, Councilman McBride.
1:04:38Uh we are now on to consent agenda items.
1:04:42There are two reports from special facilities and community development under consent.
1:04:48Um no actions needed, but let me any any commentary from you, Chairman Mitchell.
1:04:55See, we had two items and both of them was deferred, but we'll be bringing that back in Leon Date.
1:05:02Uh so no action items there.
1:05:04We are on to council committee reports.
1:05:07Uh let's start with you, Councilman Sheely, committee public safety.
1:05:11Thank you, Mayor Cogs.
1:05:12Well, um the uh public safety committee met August 12th at 4 p.m.
1:05:18Uh for the police department.
1:05:20We had an approval to accept the SRO grant with no match.
1:05:24Um we also approved um two SRO agreements for the police department with the fire department.
1:05:30We approve we had an approval to submit two homeland security grants.
1:05:35There's no match uh required on those, and then for the fire department, we had an approval to authorize the mayor to execute to execute a memorandum of understanding with Roper St.
1:05:45Francis Healthcare for coordination of mutual aid in response to incidents involving hazardous materials and other mass contamination incidents.
1:05:54That concludes my report and I ask for uh move for approval for the adoption of the report.
1:05:59Motion made property second for uh acceptance of the report.
1:06:03Any further discussion on this?
1:06:04If none, all those in favor signify by saying aye.
1:06:08Opposed, eyes have it.
1:06:09And I'll let call on councilman wearing for uh public work second.
1:06:14All actionable items passed unanimously.
1:06:17I didn't want to know if you wouldn't take the question publicly to explain items E1 through as you did it.
1:06:24The at the committee meeting level of we just um pass them unanimously as the word passed in committee.
1:06:43Well, all actionable items pass unanimous, and I move the adoption of the report.
1:06:48All right, motion made, probably seconded.
1:06:50All those in favor, please signify by saying aye.
1:06:53Opposed, eyes have it.
1:06:57We are now on to council member seekings for TNT.
1:07:04We got lots of good reports on what's going on.
1:07:06We did welcome a new code enforcement officer, which is welcome news to many of you.
1:07:10Um, no items, I believe need any action by this council.
1:07:15So motion made, um, properly seconded to accept the report.
1:07:18If no further discussion, all those in favor signify by saying aye.
1:07:25Councilman Greg, ways and means thank you very much.
1:07:33Motion made properly seconded as amended.
1:07:36Uh any further commentary on ways and means.
1:07:38If none, all those in favor, please signify by saying aye.
1:07:43Opposed, eyes have it.
1:07:44Now we are on to bills for second reading.
1:07:47There's one bill up for second reading as amended.
1:07:52Move for approval as amended.
1:07:56Mayor, you're honored.
1:07:58I'm back in court.
1:07:59Mayor, if you would accept an amendment to that motion, Councilmember Sheeley.
1:08:02Can we move M1 through 5 and M7 through 10?
1:08:06Um for approval on second reading and take up M6 separately.
1:08:13So there's a motion on the floor to approve M6.
1:08:18Do y'all want to add the other ordinances that council member seekings mentioned to that motion?
1:08:27I would ask that M6 be withdrawn from that motion.
1:08:33So we have a motion.
1:08:34We're going to take M6 separately.
1:08:35Uh we have a we have a motion made, probably seconded.
1:08:38So is the motion being withdrawn?
1:08:43That's so the motion is withdrawn then.
1:08:45Councilman Seeking.
1:08:46I would move to take M1 through M5 and M7 through M10 together and approve for second reading.
1:08:54We have motion made, probably seconded.
1:08:56All those in favor, please signify by saying aye.
1:09:03Move for third reading on same same items.
1:09:07We have motion made for third reading on the same items, probably seconded.
1:09:11There's no further discussion.
1:09:12All those in favor signify by saying aye.
1:09:15Opposed, eyes have it.
1:09:16I would next move to approve item M6.
1:09:19A bill entitled an ordinance to repeal and replace Chapter 21, Article 3, Division 4, Sections 21 through 67 through 21 through 74, and to amend chapter 22, Article 1, Sections 22-7 and 22-8 of the code of the city of Charleston to conform with state law as amended for second reading.
1:09:39So we have a motion made.
1:09:40Can I have a second?
1:09:43Motion made properly seconded.
1:09:45Any further discussion on that?
1:09:46If none, all those in favor.
1:09:48I think we need to do a roll call vote on that one.
1:09:50We're going to do a roll call vote on that.
1:09:52All right, Councilmember Greg.
1:09:54Councilmember Sheeley.
1:09:56Councilmember McBride.
1:09:58Councilmember Mitchell.
1:21:11We're enough here.
1:21:13Uh, can I get a motion to come out of executive session?
1:21:16Motion made, progress seconded.
1:21:18All those in favor of coming out of executive session, please take a moment saying aye.
1:21:23We are now out of executive session, where we got advice from council.
1:21:28Uh, and no action was taken.
1:21:31Uh and that uh concludes the agenda items for this meeting, our next regular meeting of city council.
1:23:15Next meeting, regular meeting will be on September the ninth.
1:23:20No further business.