OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Detroit City Council Budget Hearing on Public Lighting Authority and Department – March 13, 2026

City CouncilFriday, March 13, 2026
BodyDetroit, Michigan
SessionCity Council
DateFriday, March 13, 2026
StatusFILED
Video Record
0:00 / 1:26:17

Transcript — Verbatim
0:16

Public lighting authority, public lighting department.

0:19

Come on down.

0:22

Because we need to make sure we have all those documents provided to the team in advance.

0:26

Just saying again to all departments, make sure you give us all documents so we can hand them out so we can move again that word expeditiously.

0:44

Good morning, gentlemen and lady.

0:47

Thank you for being here.

0:49

Please introduce yourself for the record, and the floor is yours.

0:52

Do you have any PowerPoint that you are looking to provide?

0:55

Hopefully so, because I was mentioning we want to make sure the public has an opportunity to review what we see.

1:02

Okay.

1:14

While we're doing that, John Primeck, PLD.

1:16

Good to see you again, sir.

1:20

Bo Taylor, PLA.

1:22

Good day.

1:23

Good morning.

1:24

I'm Janet Anderson, PLA.

1:26

Dr.

1:26

Anderson, thank you.

1:42

Let me get on.

1:55

For the sake of time.

1:57

Um she's not able to get online yet.

1:59

And uh we'd like to start and maybe have a few comments that uh aren't reflected in the PowerPoints while we wait.

2:05

Okay, you may proceed, sir.

2:06

Yeah, I'll I'll start.

2:09

She's gonna get the PowerPoint here in a minute.

2:12

So uh I was just gonna I basically was gonna reflect on last year's closing resolutions while we wait for the PowerPoint.

2:18

Okay, John can start.

2:20

Um last year there were four closing resolutions.

2:22

One was uh um paying attention to uh McNichols Road and uh the lighting issues that were across that corridor.

2:30

Um we were able to complete uh a project to standardize the lights on McNichols, so that issue has been resolved.

2:37

Um we were asked to um look at smart lighting, and um we continuously do look at smart lighting, and um we have some ideas down the road uh that would be predicated on funding, and it would be mostly in the uh downtown corridor, and our focus is on the residential areas at this point, but we're not losing sight of uh opportunities down the road for grant funding and external partners to come in and uh work with us on the smart lighting issue.

3:04

Um I would say one of the major things that we could accomplish with smart lighting would be a reduction in the electric bill by dimming the lights at uh certain times and you know having a better coordination of when they come on and off.

3:17

Um there was uh um closing resolution that they wanted us to be more uh interactive in the community.

3:25

Um we have hired a new uh community relations person and have applied additional resources and um as we embark on uh moderate uh creating a new lighting plan.

3:37

Um it's gonna be heavily centered on community input feedback and uh um interactions with uh constituents within each one of your districts.

3:47

That will be the core of the lighting plan that uh we look to develop.

3:51

So we did take that message to heart.

3:53

Um and um ensure that the things that we were asked to do in the closing resolutions were uh completed in the last year.

4:02

Are we close?

4:03

We are getting close.

4:07

Okay, I'll just go through some budget numbers, such as a budget hearing.

4:11

Go through some budget if you guys so our total budget for uh PLT this year is 18.5 million dollars.

4:17

Uh we have revenue of over 2.6 million.

4:20

And Mr.

4:20

Prime, just so you some folks may not have caught that because you got PLA, PLD.

4:25

Okay.

4:25

So if you can explain who you're representing.

4:28

I'm gonna PLD.

4:30

And that is the basically PLD is the funding mechanism.

4:34

I was gonna go through that.

4:35

We uh support PLA.

4:36

We give them 10.5 million dollars.

4:38

Public lighting department.

4:39

Yeah, well, I should say yes.

4:40

Our our budget is tied to theirs, of course.

4:42

I just again remember this is a public hearing, and everybody may not be familiar with the way it works in them.

4:47

So and how it works.

4:48

I just want to kind of walk folks through the difference between the two of you.

4:51

So PLD more or less, anything else.

4:53

We're basically um decommissioner infrastructure in the city of Detroit as of now.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Engineering And Infrastructure█████████████████17%
Public Engagement███████████████15%
Public Lighting█████████████13%
Public Safety███████████11%
Public Comment█████████9%
Budget████████8%
Technology and Innovation██████6%
Procurement██████6%
Workforce Development█████5%
Summary of Proceedings

Detroit City Council Budget Hearing on Public Lighting Authority and Department – March 13, 2026

The Detroit City Council held a budget hearing on March 13, 2026, for the Public Lighting Authority (PLA) and Public Lighting Department (PLD). Officials presented their budgets and operational updates, and council members questioned them on mid-block lighting, alley lighting, solar energy, local procurement, artificial intelligence, and employment opportunities. The hearing also included public comments on BZA transcript fees and clean energy.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Several callers criticized the BZA's policy of charging for transcripts (estimates of $5,000 or $750 per page), arguing it creates a paywall and violates the Michigan Zoning Enabling Act which requires transcripts to be filed with the clerk and available to the public.
  • One caller advocated for clean energy generation and suggested the city explore options like hydrogen and solar, and questioned the necessity of the PLA and PLD.
  • Betty A. Varner, president of the Soda Els War Black Association, requested budget allocations to reduce the $1,500 land use hearing fee for black clubs and to fund corridor revitalization.

Discussion Items

  • Budget Presentation: John Primeck (PLD) reported PLD's total budget of $18.5 million, including $10.5 million transferred to PLA, $6.5 million for electricity, $900,000 for the Miss Dig staking program, and $940,000 for salvage and make-safe programs. PLD maintains over 500 miles of conduit, generates $1.2 million from fiber rental, and earned $2.4 million from copper salvage in the prior year.
  • PLA Operations: Bo Taylor (PLA) explained the PLA's $10.5 million budget is based on a 2014 interlocal agreement. PLA has replaced all first-generation lights and thousands of poles, achieving 99% operability. Repairs average five days for simple outages and two weeks for major repairs. A bond refinancing provided $10 million upfront and $1.4 million in annual savings to fund the upcoming mid-block lighting program.
  • Mid-Block Lighting: Director Donnie Johnson clarified that the $1 million increase in PLA's operating contribution is specifically for mid-block lighting, enabling bond savings to be directed to the program. Taylor stated the new lighting plan will be heavily informed by community input in each council district.
  • Alley Lighting: Multiple council members (Miller, McCampbell, Santiago Romero, Callaway) emphasized the need for alley lights, noting residents who enter homes through alleys and those paying out-of-pocket for lights. Taylor said the policy will change, and alley lights will be addressed after the mid-block program, with a focus on resident input. Councilmember Miller called for immediate action and possible reimbursement for neighborhoods that have been paying for alley lights for years.
  • Solar and Alternative Energy: Councilmembers Benson and Callaway pressed for pilot solar projects. Taylor expressed caution due to storage and reliability issues at scale but left the door open for small pilots. Councilmember Benson suggested a pilot in District 3. A public caller urged the city to explore clean energy generation.
  • AI and Smart Lighting: Councilmember Young detailed potential savings from AI (predictive maintenance, adaptive dimming, optimized routing) including $1.3–$3.2 million in annual savings. Taylor said PLA is evaluating software upgrades with AI integration and encourages staff use of AI for efficiency.
  • Local Procurement: Councilmember Benson raised concerns that local lighting suppliers were excluded from bidding. Taylor defended the competitive process based on specification, but committed to better communication and exploring smaller opportunities. A motion was passed to encourage PLA to increase local supplier involvement.
  • Mistersky Power Plant: Taylor confirmed the plant is being marketed for sale as-is due to high asbestos removal costs (estimated $2.4 million). Interest exists for potential truck recharging uses near the new bridge.
  • Employment: Councilmember Waters asked about Detroiters' employment in lighting. Taylor described the PLANT program (Public Lighting Authority Nurturing Talent), which provides groundman jobs and apprenticeship preparation, leading to wages up to $200,000 per year. He offered to participate in the council's skilled trade task force.
  • Jefferson Avenue Lighting: Councilmember Johnson reported 80–90% of lights out on the south side of Jefferson Avenue near Belle Isle. Taylor promised to prioritize the issue and provide written updates.
  • Salary Inquiry: Councilmember Callaway asked for Bo Taylor's salary. Taylor stated it is public information but did not recall the exact figure; he offered to provide a copy of his contract in writing.

Key Outcomes

  • Motion by Member Benson, seconded by Member McCampbell, to include in the closing resolution a strong encouragement for PLA to get more local suppliers involved in the hardware process of new lighting. Approved.
  • Motion by Member McCampbell, seconded by Member Callaway, to move to executive session regarding alley lights and solar. Approved.
  • PLA committed to addressing alley lighting after mid-block program with resident engagement, and to providing written responses on Jefferson Avenue lighting and salary information.
  • The next full public hearing for the budget was announced for March 30, 2026.

Meeting Transcript

Public lighting authority, public lighting department. Come on down. Because we need to make sure we have all those documents provided to the team in advance. Just saying again to all departments, make sure you give us all documents so we can hand them out so we can move again that word expeditiously. Good morning, gentlemen and lady. Thank you for being here. Please introduce yourself for the record, and the floor is yours. Do you have any PowerPoint that you are looking to provide? Hopefully so, because I was mentioning we want to make sure the public has an opportunity to review what we see. Okay. While we're doing that, John Primeck, PLD. Good to see you again, sir. Bo Taylor, PLA. Good day. Good morning. I'm Janet Anderson, PLA. Dr. Anderson, thank you. Let me get on. For the sake of time. Um she's not able to get online yet. And uh we'd like to start and maybe have a few comments that uh aren't reflected in the PowerPoints while we wait. Okay, you may proceed, sir. Yeah, I'll I'll start. She's gonna get the PowerPoint here in a minute. So uh I was just gonna I basically was gonna reflect on last year's closing resolutions while we wait for the PowerPoint. Okay, John can start. Um last year there were four closing resolutions. One was uh um paying attention to uh McNichols Road and uh the lighting issues that were across that corridor. Um we were able to complete uh a project to standardize the lights on McNichols, so that issue has been resolved. Um we were asked to um look at smart lighting, and um we continuously do look at smart lighting, and um we have some ideas down the road uh that would be predicated on funding, and it would be mostly in the uh downtown corridor, and our focus is on the residential areas at this point, but we're not losing sight of uh opportunities down the road for grant funding and external partners to come in and uh work with us on the smart lighting issue. Um I would say one of the major things that we could accomplish with smart lighting would be a reduction in the electric bill by dimming the lights at uh certain times and you know having a better coordination of when they come on and off. Um there was uh um closing resolution that they wanted us to be more uh interactive in the community. Um we have hired a new uh community relations person and have applied additional resources and um as we embark on uh moderate uh creating a new lighting plan. Um it's gonna be heavily centered on community input feedback and uh um interactions with uh constituents within each one of your districts. That will be the core of the lighting plan that uh we look to develop. So we did take that message to heart. Um and um ensure that the things that we were asked to do in the closing resolutions were uh completed in the last year. Are we close? We are getting close. Okay, I'll just go through some budget numbers, such as a budget hearing. Go through some budget if you guys so our total budget for uh PLT this year is 18.5 million dollars. Uh we have revenue of over 2.6 million. And Mr. Prime, just so you some folks may not have caught that because you got PLA, PLD. Okay. So if you can explain who you're representing. I'm gonna PLD. And that is the basically PLD is the funding mechanism. I was gonna go through that.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com