0:00We are back in session.
0:04And we are on line item 8.5.
0:07We're going to move as quickly as we possibly can, noting that the neighborhood and community services committee shall proceed as soon as we conclude.
0:19Line item 8.5 is property sale at 13100 and 13116 Kerchival.
0:26There's a request for a two-week bring back.
0:31There's a motion to bring line item 8.5 back in two weeks.
0:35Hearing no objections, that action shall be taken.
0:41That now brings us to new business.
0:47Too many things in front of me.
0:52Beginning with line item 9.1.
0:59And without objection, I'd like to combine line item 9.1 and line item 9.6.
1:11Line item 9.1 is contract number 6001511-a6 100% city funding.
1:20Amendment number six to provide an extension of time and an increase of funds for property management and real estate services contractor, Detroit Building Authority.
1:29Contract period through June 30th, 2027.
1:34Contract increase amount 1 million four hundred and seventy thousand dollars.
1:38And line item 9.6 is contract number 600 7947.
1:46This is 100% city funding to provide operations for the public safety headquarters.
1:59Total contract amount 2,554, $554,890.
2:10Is there a motion to send line items 9.1 and 9.6 to formal with the recommendation to approve?
2:18Hearing no objections, those actions shall be taken.
2:25Without objection, I'd like to combine line items 9.2, 9.4, and 9.5.
2:35Line item 9.2 is contract number.
2:39We actually had an amended an amendment that was provided to us.
2:45Pro Tim Young, I'm not sure if you received this physical copy.
2:50Line item 9.2 is amended and should read as contract number 6007959, 100% city funding to provide the economic development economic development services on behalf of the city of Detroit.
3:08Contractor, Detroit Economic Growth Corporation, contract period through June 30th, 2027.
3:15Total contract amount 2 million one hundred forty one thousand four hundred eighty-nine dollars.
3:24Line item 9.4 contract number 600758, 100% city funding to provide annual operating agreement for the EDC and supplemental programs, including the legacy business space, small business emergency fund, Detroit Startup Fund, re retail attraction gap funding, the Green Grocery Program, and Construction Mitigation Fund.
3:51Contractor is the Economic Development Corporation.
3:55Contract period through June 30th, 2027.
3:59Total contract amount $3,881,000.
4:04And line item 9.4 is contract number 600 6432-83.
4:11100% city funding to provide an increase of funds only for an annual operate operating agreement for the EDC.
4:20Contract period through June 30th 2026.
4:29Contract increase amount 150,000.
4:35Did you mean line item 9.5?
4:43So line items 9.2, 9.4, and 9.5.
4:48Is there a motion to discuss?
5:00Um, can someone just come on very quickly in regards to line item 9.5 just to ensure the contract period is correct through June 30th, 2026.
5:10And if this is correct, is this just for the EDC's operational budget?
5:26Miss Great, do you have anyone present?
5:31Um, Derek Head and Samuel Coons have both been promoted as panelists.
5:53Uh Derek here at DEGC.
5:56I'm not sure if you heard the question.
6:00Oh, could you repeat the question?
6:02I also understand Mr.
6:03Coons is with us as well.
6:13Please introduce yourself for the record.
6:17Through the chair, Samuel Coons with HRD this morning.
6:24Um, so my question is just in regards to line item 9.5.
6:28It indicates that the contract period is through June 30th, 2026.
6:34Want to be sure that is accurate, and want to, if that is accurate, confirm the contract increase the use or what the funds are for.
6:45Yes, uh, through the chair.
6:47Um that term is correct.
6:50This is a part of EDC's annual operating agreement that was set um in last year's budget process, but was um never included in that operating agreement.
7:03It was a it was a um mistake on our part to not include that 150,000 dollars.
7:10It's for um the B next program, I believe it's it's uh recurring annual allocation um that we had not included.
7:20So it's for work that's already been done through the year, but it wasn't for uh the funds were not added into that agreement at the correct time um last year when we were going through the same process, madam chair.
7:37Coons is saying is accurate.
7:39May I just clarify that's for the next up 313 program?
7:49No additional questions.
7:52Is there a motion to send line items 9.2, 9.4, and 9.5 to formal with the recommendation to approve?
8:01Hearing no objections, those actions shall be taken.
8:05Thank you both for joining us.
8:08Thank you, madam chair.
8:10That brings us to line item 9.3, contract number 600 4747-a four.
8:20And without objection, I'd like to combine line items 9.3, 9.7, and 9.8.
8:32Line these line items are all associated with the grow Detroit's young talent and the DESC Detroit Employment Solutions Corporation.
8:46Line item 9.3 is to provide an extension of time and an increase of funds to support five years of the Grow Detroit Young Talent Program.
8:58This is for an increase of $2.5 million through June 30, 2027.
9:06Line item 9.7 is contract number 6007 349-a1, 100% city funding.
9:15Amendment number one to provide an increase of funds and an in and an extension of time to implement skilled trades apprenticeship.
9:22DPSCD DESC skilled trades instruction.
9:29This is uh through June 30th, 2027, contract increase amount 70,000 dollars, and line item 9.8 is contract number 600735, 100% CDBG grant funding to support the Grow Detroit Young Talent Program through May 30th, 2027.
9:54This contract is for 1.5 million dollars.
10:00Is there a motion to send these line items to formal with a recommendation to approve?
10:04Hearing no objection, that action shall be taken.
10:09That brings us to line item 9.9.
10:16So Pro Tim Young Without Objection, I'd like to combine line items 9.9 through 9.18.
10:28These are all contracts from the housing and revitalization department and the health and HHFS.
10:43I forgot what it stands for.
10:45HHFS for rapid rehousing, homelessness, drop-in, emergency, emergency shelters, and permanent supportive housing.
10:57Line item 9.9, contract number 6007185-A1 is an increase of funds only for after hours and weekend outreach contractor, Motor City Middle Mission.
11:16Contract increase amount $798,313.
11:24Line item 9.10, contract number 600752, 100% city funding to provide drop-in shelters, contractor, Cast Community Social Services, total contract amount six million dollars.
11:37Line item 9.11, contract number 600740, 100% ESG emergency solutions grant funding to provide rapid rehousing services contractor, neighborhood services organization.
11:54This will run through June 30th, 2027, contract amount, 980, 426.94 cents.
12:13Contractor, volunteers of America, contract period through June 30th, 2029, contract amount 991,250.
12:27Line item 9.13, contract number 600741, 100% city funding to provide rapid rehousing services.
12:37Contractor, neighborhood services or organization, contract period through June 30th, 2027, contract amount 410,000.
12:48Line item 9.14, contract number 600742, 100% city funding to provide year-round emergency shelters.
13:01This is through June 30th, 2028 for $587,240.
13:08Line item 9.15, contract number 600-7943, 100% city funding to provide year-round emergency shelters, contractor, Detroit Rescue Mission Ministries.
13:21This is through June 30th, 2028.
13:25Contract amount 2,348,960.
13:31Line item 9.16, contract number 600-7944, 100% city funding.
13:51Line item 9.17 is contract number 600745, 100% city funding to provide year-round emergency shelter emergency shelters.
14:08This is through June 30th, 2028.
14:10Contract amount 4004 434,600.
14:15And line item 9.18, contract number 600 7946, 100% city funding to provide year-round emergency shelters.
14:26Contractor YWCA of Metropolitan Detroit.
14:30This is through June 30th, 2028 for 284,080.
14:36Is there a motion a motion to discuss?
14:43If we can just have someone come on to share with us whether or not these contracts provide for additional shelter services, if we're able to accommodate additional families, if this is for more beds than we've had in the past, and the types of families that these contracts will serve.
15:10If this is for single individuals, for families.
15:25Tara Lindser, the Housing Stability and Innovations Division Director in the Human Homelessness and Family Services Department.
15:38A manager of the also in HHFS as the HS manager, homelessness solutions manager.
15:48I'm not sure if you heard the question, but we have a number of contracts here before us.
15:53If someone could just summarize the support that's being provided, and if this is additional support, uh then what we have provided in the past.
16:05Through the chair, um Candace Morgan again.
16:08Um all of the contracts for shelters that you have before you today are all providing housing, housing uh focused case management services, they're providing basic needs.
16:19There um are providing transportation.
16:22There's an array of services being provided at all of these locations to um assist um all individuals within the city of Detroit who are presenting um as being homeless or unsheltered.
16:35Um I'm sorry, I don't recall all of your questions.
16:41I was through the chair.
16:42I can address I can address the second part.
16:46So we when we issued um a request for proposals for emergency shelter in our drop-in.
16:53Um the applicants who applied were applicants that are currently operating emergency shelter and drop-in services, and so these beds will not be new beds coming into our system.
17:04Instead, they will be um funding the beds of these these same programs for for next year.
17:11So we'll not add additional beds, it will continue the beds existing in the per in the system.
17:18Um, is are there any plans to provide support for additional beds?
17:26I know we have um seen increases.
17:30Um, or at least I have received perhaps more inquiries in regards to shelters.
17:40Um, we are always um looking at the numbers and making some uh some decisions and having some discussions about um what is needed in the system.
17:50I will say that we are focusing on outflow this year.
17:54Um we know that we have inflow uh very well handled.
17:57That's the front door because we have a lot of people who are seeking shelter services, but we want to focus on moving people out of the shelters out of drop-in into permanent housing.
18:08So we have a lot of um programs, a lot of things we're bringing online to address that.
18:14Once we move people into the rapid rehousing, which is some of the um contracts you saw before you today, we bring before you today, that is going to clear up space in the shelter system for those new people who are now um um coming to the front door for services.
18:30So I I don't believe that there are any um new things um proposed at this time, but we are looking at the system and making the necessary adjustments so that we can adequately assess all of the people and um and uh um how would I say provide services to all of the folk who are seeking who are seeking those services?
18:57I do thank you, madam chair.
19:01I just wanted to ask you what is the shelter to housing conversion rate.
19:10Through the chair to um um councilman uh Coleman.
19:15I don't have those numbers before me at this time, but it is something I can get you.
19:20You said you wanted the percentage of shelter to housing rate, yes, the shelter to housing conversion rate.
19:26So shelter residents placed into permanent housing divided by shelter residents.
19:32Okay, we can definitely get you that.
19:34Um Tara, did you have something you wanted to add to that?
19:42I do not have any, I don't have that percentage off the top of my head, but that is something that we do track, and I can and we can um submit that uh by close of business today.
19:53No, that's excellent.
19:54Yeah, I I I I would appreciate that.
20:00Um, also, do we have a um average length of the time of homelessness?
20:03So average days from homeless entry to exit, and do we have a median length of the time of homeless?
20:10How many days people are homeless in the median?
20:17Um, so the average um number of days that households are in emergency shelter and from 2025 is a hundred and a hundred and eight days.
20:25I don't have the the median, um, but that that's the average 108 days is the average.
20:31Do we have the housing placement rate?
20:35For the chair, that is information that we will get you that percentage that move from a homelessness situation into housing.
20:41That is something that is um tracked, and we can get that to you by end of day.
20:46And do we, and this is my final question.
20:47Do we have the eviction to homelessness rate?
20:50So homeless entries from eviction to divided by total homeless entries.
20:58So how our data system, which is the homeless management information system, tracks people's prior living situation before coming into homelessness.
21:08Um doesn't note if they're coming from an eviction.
21:13What we what we do know through the helpline data is that households typically, once they're evicted, they typically have at least two situations where they go to live to stay with family or friends prior to coming into the shelter system.
21:27And so the vast majority of folks go from eviction to staying with family or friends, and then once they're no longer able to stay there successfully, then seek out emergency shelter.
21:37Um, so I don't have that direct correlation, but that is something that on the Detroit Housing Services side, they would track for not just folks seeking shelter, but folks seeking resources, how many of those households um are calling because they had a recent eviction or a pending eviction.
21:54No, no, I I I I appreciate that, and I and I appreciate that answer.
21:59I and I know in my mind, I know for us to be able to get further granular details, you would either have to contract out, I would assume for a certain service for you to be able to get that type of information so you know somewhere else that provide that, or you'd have to use some sort of artificial intelligence just for an estimate of what that is.
22:18And that's not even a direct number, but just an estimate of what that could be.
22:23Uh, my final question I wanted to ask is what is your turn away rate, and will this uh decrease that?
22:32And what I mean by that is the person denied shelter due to capacity divided by the persons requesting shelter, and will this reduce that?
22:41And do we have a percentage of what that reduction is through the chair?
22:49So that when the um so when the drop-in center started in December of 2024, the program model that it was operating was that um no one would be turned away.
23:06Once we once the um we had that we had the tragic um deaths with the children in February, and we really started to increase our access to these services 24-7.
23:18We have seen a drastic increase of the number of people utilizing the drop-in centers for that immediate shelter, which we we wanted, right?
23:27At the end of the day, that's what we wanted.
23:29That's why we had these 24-7 services to prevent a tragedy that like a prevent a future tragedy from occurring.
23:37Um, because of that, though, we have had a lot of folks come in who have never been into our homelessness system before and seen a drastic increase.
23:47Those folks tend to not stay for very long.
23:50Um, but they do come in.
23:51And so what we are working on right now with our drop-in center is reformatting the drop-in center so that within the first three days you receive extremely intensive, very prescriptive services connections, referral connections to hopefully resolve whatever it is, the crisis that's happening with you, and they might not and you may not need emergency shelter, so that we have emergency shelter space at the drop-in for those households that really don't have any other options.
24:20That being said, the drop-in centers, because they have been so overcapacity, um, these contracts also will include um uh a hard limit where they won't be able to take anyone else after they reach a certain capacity point, and really that's just to prevent overcrowding.
24:39There's been issues, you know, with maintaining certain standards of cleanliness, all of those issues, and it's really difficult to do when you're drastically over capacity.
24:50Um, and so it will not guarantee that somebody will always have a spot.
25:00What we are doing, as Ken Jesus Candace has mentioned, is really working on our outflow capacity now over the next year and really strengthening that arm, just as we strengthened our inflow or access arm over the past year to try to move people quicker through the system, or honestly prevent them from meeting emergency shelter in the beginning by connecting them to those services.
25:17Um and so those are all things that we're working on overall, but it will not these contracts will unfortunately not be able to guarantee that there will always be a shelter space for an individual.
25:28Well, well, listen, I I I appreciate that.
25:30And uh I just wanted to say, yeah, I understand that, and that was never that's not the reason why I'm asking this question.
25:35I mean, between COVID, between uh inflation, between energy prices going up, between the poverty rates of it of over more than a third of the city living in poverty, you're gonna have a lot of people who are gonna have exposure to homelessness, and so you can't guarantee every spot.
25:50I would never say that you could do that.
25:52We financially can do that, but I don't think we we could do that just in terms of tamping down the need without other economic stimuluses and programs that would come into that effect.
26:03Um, but so I understand that I would just ask you for a number.
26:06One because the constant refrain that we hear that I hear at least of this committee, and when I'm out there is about what are we doing about housing and what are we doing about the people who are actually hurting?
26:16Here we have where we're investing in, and this is not just the only time we made major investments of tunes of millions of dollars or over uh in this project, but I think also not in terms of housing, but also in terms of homeless, but also how is this actually tamping down the demand in terms of homelessness?
26:35How is this actually being able to reduce people who would be being turned away who are not being turned away because of this intentional investment that we're making so people understand we're not just throwing money at this problem, it's being tracked in terms of how we're investing, in terms of who we're trying to get this out to, and in terms of who's benefiting from this long term, and then you can also talk about I'm not gonna ask these questions because we gotta get moving, but you can also have the discussions about the amount of jobs that folks have been able to get because they have them out of shelter, the income increases that they've had, the reduction of income inequality in the city from a macro perspective, um also in terms of upward mobility economically that these folks have had as well from this, and so people can see that just because you're homeless doesn't mean that you're staying there.
27:27We actually have programs, economical development that's helping people get what they need, and then through the recent um employment solutions investment that we made, we're also making sure that we reduce the rate in terms of the skills mix match in terms of people that have skills and talent, but they're not um but they don't match the jobs that are available from them to be able to work, and so we're doing all that at the same time through coordination, through partnership and through investment.
27:55And so that's basically what I was trying to get at with these questions and these metrics.
27:59Um that's all I have to say, uh, madam chair.
28:05Any anything further you all wanted to add?
28:13Okay, all right, thank you.
28:14Pro Tim, is there a motion to send line items 9.9 through 9.18 to formal with recommendation to approve?
28:25Hearing no objections, those actions shall be taken.
28:32And uh we will continue, I'm sure, to expand upon the work that we're doing.
28:37Um, but appreciate all of the work.
28:40And I know I see you all in in different meetings in different settings, so thank you.
28:53Line item 9.20 is to amend chapter 50 of the 2019 Detroit City Code.
29:00This is for the property commonly identified as 11400 Connor Street and 11055 Glenfield Avenue.
29:17This is for introduction and setting of a public hearing to amend the zoning classification from R3.
29:28I am on line item 9.19.
29:31Did I indicate that?
29:33Um from the R3 low density residential district zoning classification to B4 General Business District Zoning Classification.
29:44Is there a brief motion to discuss motion?
29:50Discussion, thank you.
29:51Uh to Director Todd, can you just briefly share with us um what the intent is for this request?
30:05Certainly, Madam Chair.
30:06Uh good afternoon again to you and to President Pro Tim Young.
30:12The request that is before you comes from the airport.
30:18Um representing the American Institute.
30:35Um that particular use is being classified essentially as a trade school, which would first be permitted in the R5 district, but it was concluded consistent with their recommendation and supported by the planning commission that a B4 general business district location would be more consistent with the zoning at that location.
30:54Uh both um both for its context as well as the use.
31:09But the property will be owned and maintained by the city airport.
31:15All right, thank you.
31:17Just wanted to get that out to the public.
31:21We'll certainly have some do some engagement with the residents in that area for them to be made aware of what's being proposed as well.
31:32Madam Chair, and I'm sorry, I didn't speak aviation institute of name.
31:41Pro Tim Young, is there a motion to send line item 9.19 to formal for introduction and setting of a public hearing?
31:51Hearing no objections, that action shall be taken.
31:58Submitting report and proposed ordinance to amend chapter 50 of the 2019 Detroit City Code.
32:04This is for the property commonly identified as 15321 Wyoming Street, generally bounded by Keeler to the north, Wyoming to the east, Finkel to the south, and Watchburn to the West from the existing B2 Local Business and Residential District Zoning Classification to the B4 General Business District Zoning Classification.
32:30Is there a motion to send line item 9.20 to formal for the introduction and setting of a public hearing?
32:41Hearing no objections, that action shall be taken.
32:45That brings us to line item 9.21.
32:52Line item 9.21 is a request for city council approval of termination of the springing interest agreement.
33:06This is for the Detroit Wayne County Port Authority.
33:16Is there a motion to approve or discuss?
33:22There's a motion to send line item 9.21 to forma with a recommendation to approve.
33:28Hearing no objections, that action shall be taken.
33:32And I will ask for a very brief discussion on Tuesday.
33:37So that folks are more aware of what that is.
33:40Um we've had a fair amount of discussion about it during budget hearings.
33:48Submit a report relative to administration of Detroit Community Outreach Ordnance Report.
33:53Is there a motion to receive and file?
33:56Motion received the file.
33:58Hearing no objections, that action shall be taken.
34:01Line item 9.23 is property sale of 16 residential homes by reverter.
34:08Is there a motion to bring line item 9.23 back in one week?
34:14Hearing no objections, that action shall be taken.
34:18Line item 9.24 is the expansion of the Central Business District Area Renaissance Zone.
34:27Is there a motion to refer line item 9.24 to the legislative policy division as well as it to the legislative policy division and bring back in one week?
34:47Hearing no objections, that action shall be taken.
34:50Is there a motion to suspend member reports?
34:54Hearing no objections, that action shall be taken.
35:00And if there is nothing further to come before this committee without objection, we shall stand adjourned.