OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Fresno City Council Budget Hearings: June 9, 2026

City Council & CommissionsTuesday, June 9, 2026
BodyFresno, California
SessionCity Council & Commissions
DateTuesday, June 9, 2026
StatusFILED
Video Record
0:00 / 7:39:33

Transcript — Verbatim
25:47

All right, good morning, everyone.

25:52

Started here for the 2026, 2027 uh fiscal year.

25:57

Uh let's go ahead and begin with uh roll call.

26:00

Thank you, good morning.

26:01

Councilmember Perea here.

26:03

Councilmember Carbasi.

26:05

Councilmember Arias.

26:07

Council Vice President Maxwell.

26:09

Councilmember Vang.

26:10

Present.

26:11

Councilmember Richardson.

26:12

Council President Esparza.

26:14

Present.

26:15

Six members being present, we have a quorum.

26:18

All right.

26:18

Uh Council Vice President, will you please lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance?

26:29

Ready?

26:30

Salute.

26:31

I would like allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God, indivisible with the liberty and justice for all.

27:01

All right, I'll entertain a motion for approval of today's agenda.

27:05

First, second and third by uh Councilor Arias, Vice President, and Richardson.

27:14

Is there any opposition?

27:15

Yeah, any opposition to approval of the agenda.

27:18

Seeing none passes six to zero.

27:21

All right.

27:22

Uh today we've got six departments on deck, capital projects, economic development, planning and development, public works, personnel, and the Fresno uh Animal Center.

27:36

Uh so we're we're gonna do as we did yesterday.

27:40

We're gonna take uh kind of a general public comment period, people off three minutes uh each.

27:46

And uh going forward for the duration of the day.

27:50

Um folks will have additional opportunity to comment on each department uh for one minute, uh some additional opportunity there.

27:57

But we will do go ahead and do the uh the main public comment up front here, and so we'll open that up at this time.

28:04

I've got a few cards here.

28:10

Uh so the first card I have is for uh Natalie Escobito Garcia.

28:14

Uh come on down.

28:20

Uh that's not no.

28:21

Uh uh this we're going in this order here.

28:23

There and there is there is no main presentation today, so we're just doing presentations on each department.

28:28

And um, you want to just do the one the one minute after a certain department.

28:33

Okay.

28:35

Oh, that's fine.

28:36

Okay.

28:36

Yeah.

28:37

Yes, you did.

28:38

You did actually.

28:40

Um, I'll go, I'll call that uh during the public works department later on in the day.

28:48

Uh next card I have is for Kyle Kirkland.

28:55

Again, right now you have three minutes later on for each department, you'll have one minute.

29:02

Yeah, thank thank you.

29:03

Thank you, Councilmembers.

29:05

Um I'm gonna speak a little bit later on the Animal Center, but I just want to introduce myself, Kyle Kirkland, K Y L E K-I-R-K-L-A-N-D.

29:13

I'm president of Kirkland Foundation.

29:16

Um I'm here to talk on the Animal Center budget.

29:20

I'd like to see the presentation before I pass judgment on that, but I'd um like everyone here to have a little bit of a frame of reference.

29:28

When I read through the budget, and again, this is my cursory review of it, not having consulted with city um city officials.

29:37

But what I saw was a nine point six million dollar budget, seven point set roughly seven point seven of which was earmarked for salaries and wages, and about three hundred and eighty thousand allocated to veterinary expenses.

29:48

After I saw that and talked with some other people in the animal rescue community, there was a candidly a bit of agitation about that because a lot of us there are a lot of rescues that are out there working actively trying to solve this animal um problem.

30:04

And this is no disrespect to the good work that's done at Animal Center.

30:09

I just I would encourage the city council to understand that there are rescues out there that are doing a lot of this work and taking animals that are being turned away from the animal center and actually treating them at a significantly more cost-effective rate.

30:25

And I would encourage the council to think about perhaps offering those folks some funding, and I'll give you an example.

30:37

Of that, about 260,000 was on personnel.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Animal Welfare██████████████████████████████████34%
Procedural███████████████15%
Engineering And Infrastructure████████████12%
Public Engagement███████7%
Economic Development███████7%
Fleet Management███3%
Budget Equity Analysis███3%
Personnel Matters███3%
Homelessness███3%
Summary of Proceedings

Fresno City Council Budget Hearings – June 9, 2026

The Fresno City Council continued its fiscal year 2026-2027 budget hearings on Tuesday, June 9, 2026, starting at 9:00 AM in Council Chambers. Six departments presented their proposed budgets: Capital Projects, Fresno Animal Center, Public Works, Economic Development, Planning & Development, and Personnel Services. The council heard public testimony, held extensive discussions, and passed several motions to reallocate funds, particularly for animal spay/neuter services and a land use text amendment.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • General Budget (Morning): Kyle Kirkland (Kirkland Foundation) spoke on the Animal Center budget, noting a $9.6 million budget with $7.7 million for salaries and only $380,000 for veterinary expenses. He urged the council to fund nonprofit rescues that are more cost-effective, citing his own organization spent $500,000 on vet services for 4,000-5,000 animals.
  • Animal Center (Dedicated public comment): Multiple speakers advocated for increased spay/neuter funding:
    • Brandi Sherman (Fresno TNR) reported her group spays/neuters about 200 cats per week and urged a $500,000 investment that could be matched by Dogwood Animal Rescue.
    • Kris Thompson supported the $500,000 commitment to unlock the Dogwood match, turning it into $1 million.
    • Mel Garcia (Mel’s Mutts) said her organization (69 dogs, one person) receives requests from the shelter but gets no funding.
    • Laree Holt (Paw Squad 559) asked the council to honor prior commitments and create a dedicated spay/neuter line item.
  • Public Works:
    • Nataly Escobedo Garcia (Leadership Counsel) requested safer routes to schools, including sidewalks on North Marks Avenue and North Hughes Avenue, and a crosswalk on McKinley/Hughes.
    • Mariela Fernandez de Vallejo asked for drainage improvements, street lighting, sidewalks, and speed bumps in District 5 (Monte Way, Montecito, Lowell, Liberty).
    • Margarita (via Zara Marine) requested street lights between 1st & Cedar and Ventura & Butler, and alley fences/locks.
    • Zara Marine (Power California Action) urged a 3% rent cap and increased eviction protection funding (though not specific to Public Works).
  • Planning & Development:
    • Zara Marine (again) thanked the department and requested longer-term shelter and transitional housing, warming centers, and water stations.
    • Giovanna Morales (Leadership Counsel) asked about first-time homebuyer program funding and offered to host info sessions on mobile home replacement.
  • Personnel Services:
    • Ariana requested a breakdown of funded vs. vacant positions by department; staff directed her to a recent vacancy report.

Discussion Items

Capital Projects Department (Director Anbiah)

  • Proposed FY27 budget of $139.7 million (0.2% reduction from FY26). No change in 140 positions (21 vacancies, 13 engineering).
  • Staffing challenges: difficult to hire engineers due to competition; offered retention tools not yet used.
  • Key projects: 72 of 86 current construction projects expected to be completed in FY27; $100 million GoBiz grant anticipated as last piece; water/sewer replacements in downtown; new 911 call center (37 phone operators, 12 radio dispatchers); Fresno Sports Complex Phase I; MLK Park delayed due to PG&E undergrounding issues; Fire Station 12 near completion.
  • Discussion on vehicle replacement threshold (100,000 miles/10 years standard) vs. running vehicles into ground due to budget constraints.
  • Councilmember Arias asked about rehab vs. replacement of sewer lines; staff to provide breakdown.
  • Councilmember Perea expressed concern about staff fatigue and suggested more outsourcing.

Fresno Animal Center Department (Director Torres)

  • Proposed FY27 budget: $9.6 million ($7.05 million personnel, $1.6 million non-personnel). No new positions; 78.4 positions funded.
  • 2025 statistics: 9,854 live intakes (9,612 cats/dogs); 30,000 calls; 2,563 dog licenses; 3,354 adoptions; 722 returns to owner; 2,327 transfers to partners; 6,854 sterilizations (including off-site); 6,591 microchips.
  • Euthanasia rate about 27%, partly due to sick/injured animals.
  • Challenges: only one full-time veterinarian (budgeted for two); $100,000 budgeted for per diem vets; $350,000 for spay/neuter (with $225,000 for outside contracting, $125,000 from county).
  • Managed intake (appointment-based since January) has reduced complaints but still high intake.
  • Mobile spay/neuter unit expected July 2026.
  • Councilmember Maxwell motioned to move $225,000 from unfilled veterinary position to grant programming for nonprofits.
  • Councilmember Perea motioned to set aside $750,000 for spay/neuter assuming $300,000 from Dogwood match.
  • Councilmember Arias asked about property threshold for homeless individuals; staff to provide memo; also discussed enforcement of leash laws and breeding violations (50 citations issued).
  • Councilmember Vang asked about cost of temporary path at Jensen & Fowler; staff to estimate.

Public Works Department (Director Mozier)

  • Proposed FY27 budget: $98.98 million operating, $367.5 million capital (mostly grant-funded).
  • Key operational items: new milling machine ($?); 11 replacement vehicles ($822,900); $1.3 million contractual increases; $100,000 for school zone signage to reduce speed to 20 mph when students present.
  • Capital projects: Blackstone/McKinley grade separation ($140 million); Pave More Now ($46.8 million); Measure C capital ($63 million).
  • Discussion on road diets (criteria: traffic volumes <10,000 vehicles/day ideal); Council President Esparza requested cost estimate for Olive Avenue (1st to Cedar) road diet.
  • Council President Esparza requested a memo listing 70 miles of repaved streets, and memo on annual utility cost increases for streetlights/traffic signals.
  • Councilmember Arias requested memo on process/cost for converting Wilson Island neighborhood to gated community.
  • Councilmember Vang requested reimbursement for businesses on Kings Canyon/Ventura/California due to name reversion.
  • Discussion on residential infill program: $1.8 million total (carryover + new million), with $2.9 million in approved waivers/off-site reimbursements.

Economic Development Department (Director Long)

  • Proposed FY27 budget: $1.83 million (decrease of $1.2 million due to end of PGE grant and PBID studies). 8 positions, one analyst left unfilled to meet attrition.
  • Key activities: $400,000 PBID feasibility studies for Belmont and Blackstone (in progress); 58 restaurants received energy efficiency grants; 199 business graduates, 17 new startups; outreach to 100 mid-size businesses with 10+ employees via new visitation program.
  • Partnership with Fresno County EDC for trade shows and recruitment.
  • Councilmember Richardson encouraged proactive policy advising.

Planning & Development Department (Director Clark)

  • Proposed FY27 budget includes $7 million general fund support; 70% from grants. No new positions; 7.5% attrition assumed.
  • Key items: North Fulton parking garage completion (165,000 for operations Jan-Jun 2027); parking meter parts ($86,600); pay-on-foot kiosks; ESRI software for detention basin assessment; building code software.
  • Mobile home repair/replacement program expanded to include replacement (up to $100,000 or 60% of replacement value).
  • National Opioid Settlement funds set aside for shelter operations as HAP funds phase out.
  • Councilmember Perea motioned $205,000 for a neighborhood-serving ministerial text amendment.
  • Discussion on parking division: revenues increased to $8.45 million projected (from $7.5 million in FY25); deficit shrinking to $1.6 million; master fee schedule update planned.
  • Councilmember Richardson asked about relationship with animal center for shelter pets; Director Skye confirmed referrals for spay/neuter and microchipping at shelters.
  • 2027 Point-in-Time homeless count scheduled for January; staff will coordinate with council offices.

Personnel Services Department (Director Malhi)

  • Proposed budget: $6.2 million general fund, $93 million in internal service funds (including risk). 7.5% attrition; one position to be fully funded (senior HR risk analyst for training).
  • Workers’ compensation reserve increased to $9 million (previously $0) based on projected claims.
  • Youth Job Corps and Navigator grants continuing.
  • New recruiting platform (NeoGov) implemented; reports increased applicants.

Key Outcomes

  • Motion 10 (Maxwell/Arias): Direct $225,000 from the second unfilled veterinary position to grant programming for nonprofit animal rescue organizations. Passed.
  • Motion 11 (Perea/Richardson): Set aside $750,000 for spay/neuter services, assuming $300,000 will come from a match by Dogwood Animal Rescue Project (subject to final calculation). Passed.
  • Motion 12 (Perea/Maxwell): Set aside $205,000 to complete the Neighborhood-Serving Ministerial Text Amendment, expanding by-right uses for neighborhood-serving commercial uses. Passed.
  • Requests for Information (RFIs): Multiple memos and cost estimates requested by councilmembers, including:
    • Heat map of animal pickups/citations (Maxwell).
    • Cost of temporary path at Jensen & Fowler (Vang).
    • List of streets repaved under 70-mile overlay program (Esparza).
    • Cost estimate for Olive Ave road diet (Esparza).
    • Annual utility cost increases for street infrastructure (Esparza).
    • Process/cost to convert Wilson Island to gated community (Arias).
    • ADU approval/construction stats and processing times (Perea).
    • Rehab vs. new sewer line percentages (Arias).
    • Updated residential infill program status (Esparza).
    • Pedestrian safety solutions at Olive & 9th (Esparza).
    • Feasibility of life-sized chess board at a park (Karbassi).
    • Threshold for claiming animal as property (Arias).
  • The council recessed at 4:26 PM and will resume on Wednesday, June 10, 2026, at 9:00 AM for Fire, Police, DPU, and FAX departments.

Meeting Transcript

All right, good morning, everyone. Started here for the 2026, 2027 uh fiscal year. Uh let's go ahead and begin with uh roll call. Thank you, good morning. Councilmember Perea here. Councilmember Carbasi. Councilmember Arias. Council Vice President Maxwell. Councilmember Vang. Present. Councilmember Richardson. Council President Esparza. Present. Six members being present, we have a quorum. All right. Uh Council Vice President, will you please lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance? Ready? Salute. I would like allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God, indivisible with the liberty and justice for all. All right, I'll entertain a motion for approval of today's agenda. First, second and third by uh Councilor Arias, Vice President, and Richardson. Is there any opposition? Yeah, any opposition to approval of the agenda. Seeing none passes six to zero. All right. Uh today we've got six departments on deck, capital projects, economic development, planning and development, public works, personnel, and the Fresno uh Animal Center. Uh so we're we're gonna do as we did yesterday. We're gonna take uh kind of a general public comment period, people off three minutes uh each. And uh going forward for the duration of the day. Um folks will have additional opportunity to comment on each department uh for one minute, uh some additional opportunity there. But we will do go ahead and do the uh the main public comment up front here, and so we'll open that up at this time. I've got a few cards here. Uh so the first card I have is for uh Natalie Escobito Garcia. Uh come on down. Uh that's not no. Uh uh this we're going in this order here. There and there is there is no main presentation today, so we're just doing presentations on each department. And um, you want to just do the one the one minute after a certain department. Okay. Oh, that's fine. Okay. Yeah. Yes, you did. You did actually. Um, I'll go, I'll call that uh during the public works department later on in the day. Uh next card I have is for Kyle Kirkland. Again, right now you have three minutes later on for each department, you'll have one minute. Yeah, thank thank you. Thank you, Councilmembers. Um I'm gonna speak a little bit later on the Animal Center, but I just want to introduce myself, Kyle Kirkland, K Y L E K-I-R-K-L-A-N-D.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com