OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Jacksonville City Council Public Workshop on School Millage Referendum - June 5, 2026

City CouncilFriday, June 5, 2026
BodyJacksonville, Florida
SessionCity Council
DateFriday, June 5, 2026
StatusFILED
Video Record
0:00 / 1:04:40
Transcript — Verbatim
0:06

All right.

0:06

Good morning, everybody.

0:08

Thank you all for coming.

0:09

And I'm I saw I'm sorry for not having enough seats, but I did not expect 300 people to come in this to this meeting.

0:14

All right, but but thank you all for coming.

0:17

Alright, good job.

0:23

All right.

0:24

We have a short 30-minute meeting today.

0:27

Once again, I did not expect this, but um I think we could uh we could extend it a little bit longer.

0:31

Should we have some more questions, potentially we'll find out about that through our attorneys here.

0:36

But let's start off with introductions to my left, please.

0:44

Anything there is that Tony Ricardo, school board district one.

0:49

Raw Aries, District 11.

0:51

Good morning, Tyrona Clark Murray City Council District 9 and 32-year veteran of Duval County Public School.

1:02

All right.

1:08

Okay, and this is currently being live streamed as well and recorded in case anybody wants to rewatch the video later on.

1:15

All right, and we notice it for an hour, even better.

1:18

So we have a full hour, guys.

1:20

All right.

1:20

Um we have microphones right here.

1:22

If you guys want to speak, just pass it along, and then we'll bring you guys some microphones as well, too.

1:26

All right.

1:27

Um, so this meeting is is very we could put one on this side of it if you don't mind.

1:31

Okay, thank you.

1:32

Uh, this meeting is really uh mainly to to understand uh the ramifications.

1:37

Should it not go in the botot on our end?

1:39

Um, what it will mean once it goes on the ballot in November, so it's more of an educational purpose.

1:44

Also, um, just kind of some point of clarity.

1:47

Uh, this was taken up this past Tuesday at our finance committee meeting during that time.

1:51

Uh, there was a lot of concerns, a lot of unanswered questions, and so I found it myself that personally I was not ready to take action on this until I truly understood the nature of what we were voting on.

2:02

Yeah, somebody could say it was as simple as just putting on the ballot, so let people vote.

2:05

Sure, we get that part.

2:07

But there's more to it than just that.

2:08

I want to understand what this mill rate, this this one mill would signify.

2:12

Should it pass in November?

2:13

Should it not pass?

2:14

What have we done in the past with this uh previous extension of I think it was like the last four years that we've had it?

2:19

How has that really affected our our school um our district?

2:23

And additionally, what would happen in the future should it pass or not pass?

2:27

I want to understand everything before I take vote on this.

2:29

So my train of thought last Tuesday was let me make calls, let me have meetings.

2:34

I'm I made a lot of calls, a lot of people called me.

2:37

I have several of emails from everybody from the community, all right.

2:42

So my questions have been for the most part answered.

2:46

I feel a lot better about everything moving forward.

2:48

Um the question is what how do we where would where do we stand next Tuesday?

2:51

And that's where I have the attorneys here to talk about where we're gonna be at next Tuesday.

2:55

So uh Mr.

2:56

Fapulis or Mr.

2:57

Factor, if you don't mind.

2:58

Uh thank you.

2:59

So uh next Tuesday, as it stands, the item is still sitting in the finance committee because that committee has not reported it out.

3:07

So next Tuesday, you will not see this item on the city council agenda unless it's discharged by the council president, which he has the ability to do, and that was addressed to a certain extent at the finance committee, and I don't know where he stands on that today.

3:22

The other option is to um a council member can move to have it discharged on Tuesday night, which if it receives a second would be voted on, and to successfully discharge it on motion by a council member would require two-thirds vote of members present.

3:38

So, whatever number of people are on the dais at the time, it would be two-thirds of that number.

3:43

If that is uh if that occurs, then what we would traditionally do, and I've already coordinated with the council secretary and um we'll be coordinating with Chief uh Smith of legislative services is we would essentially have a addendum ready for approval because that that's what gets it onto your agenda is we produce it as an addendum item, and that would need to be approved by the council, and then you would be able to move it as an addendum item.

4:08

If it is not discharged either by the president or by motion, then it would not come to council on Tuesday, and the following week it would come back to the finance committee for consideration, where the committee can then deliberate on it and take action if they so choose, or if there is additional discussion regarding deferral.

4:27

I have confirmed that the school board is obligated to get the ballot language and everything to the supervisor of elections by August 18th.

4:35

So if there's an additional deferral, of course, we have a three-week council break, and if it gets deferred in finance again and is not subsequently discharged by the two mechan by either of the two mechanisms I mentioned for the June 23rd, I believe it is council meeting, you would have one final opportunity to act on it in July, where it would come to the finance committee during its July 21st meeting, and then it would come to council on July 28th.

4:59

And that would be the last opportunity for the council to take it up and vote it out in order for the school board to meet its deadline of August 18th with the supervisor.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
School Funding████████████████████████████████████████████44%
Personnel Matters███████████████████████████████31%
Fiscal Sustainability██████████10%
Community Engagement██████████10%
Workforce Development█████5%
Summary of Proceedings

Jacksonville City Council Public Workshop on School Millage Referendum - June 5, 2026

Councilman Arias called a community meeting to discuss the proposed renewal of a one-mill property tax referendum for Duval County Public Schools (DCPS), which the school board has requested to place on the November 2026 ballot. The meeting aimed to educate the public and council members on the implications of the referendum, address questions raised at the prior Finance Committee meeting, and hear from district officials, board members, and the community. Over 300 attendees filled the room, and the meeting was livestreamed and recorded.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Travis Acres (history teacher, Atlantic Coast High School, constituent of Councilman Arias) urged the councilman to make the motion on Tuesday to discharge the item, citing democracy and the need for stability for educators. He stated that at least 10 other council members would second the motion.
  • Tammy Brooks Evans (president of Duval Teachers United) emphasized that the referendum is critical for teacher retention and respect. She noted that if it fails, teachers would face pay cuts, and expressed frustration at the delay, asking council to pull the item on Tuesday.
  • Cammie Gabigan (19-year elementary teacher, mother of two DCPS students) reminded the council that their role is merely ministerial—to put the measure on the ballot—not to decide its merits. She warned that losing the funding would financially burden teachers.
  • Margaret Rojero Hastings (longtime teacher) said the millage had reinvigorated teachers after years of frozen salaries and lack of appreciation. She noted it helps her pay bills and buy supplies for students.
  • Asusena Leduc (school social worker) stated she would lose $7,000 from her paycheck if the referendum fails. She works multiple jobs and described using her own money for student needs. She urged council to let the county vote.
  • David Boss (Jacksonville Public Education Fund board member, retired consultant) noted that no county commission in Florida has ever denied a school board request to place a millage renewal on the ballot except Duval County five years ago (overturned by legal challenge). He cited examples in Hardee, Hernando, and Sarasota counties where renewals passed overwhelmingly, including in conservative areas. He urged council to put the item on the ballot.
  • Robin Reid (20-year DCPS teacher, part of a two-teacher household) said losing the millage would be devastating. Her family used the bonus to buy a home. She noted that veteran teachers saw only a $97 increase while starting teacher salaries rose. The loss would cost her household over $15,000 annually.
  • Wanda (paraprofessional, 20 years) said paraeducators earn under $1,000 per pay period and received only a five-cent raise last year. The millage provides a needed $400 bonus. She asked council to also consider support staff.
  • Alfreda Denson Butler (teacher) stated she would lose $7,680.66 if the referendum fails. She noted Florida still ranks 50th in the nation for teacher salaries. She urged extension of the referendum.
  • Shanna Maureen Russell (30-year teacher, Sandalwood High School) said the money helped her cover medical costs as a breast cancer survivor, including high deductibles and out-of-pocket maximums. She is single and supports aging parents.
  • Tiffany Clark (Air Force veteran, parent) urged council to do right by teachers, recalling how a teacher ensured she graduated as a teen parent. She quoted the Air Force motto: "Integrity, service before self, excellence in all we do."

Discussion Items

  • Councilman Arias opened the meeting, noting he had not been ready to vote on the item at the Finance Committee on June 2 due to unanswered questions. He since made calls and received emails, and now feels more informed.
  • Attorney Mr. Fapulis explained procedural options: The item remains in Finance Committee. It can be discharged by the Council President or by a council member motion with a two-thirds vote of present members. If discharged, an addendum would be prepared for Tuesday’s meeting. If not, the item returns to Finance Committee June 23, then council July 28, the last opportunity before the school board’s August 18 deadline with the Supervisor of Elections.
  • Attorney Mr. Fackler clarified that a Second District Court of Appeal ruling confirms the council’s action is purely ministerial—no discretion—only to forward the school board’s resolution to the ballot.
  • Councilman Arias confirmed the extended timeline (August 18) gave him comfort. He asked about salary impacts: what teachers and officers currently earn, and how much salaries have increased under the millage.
  • Dr. Bernier (DCPS Superintendent) reported that 75% of millage funds go directly to teachers, 12.5% to arts/athletics, and about 20% proportionally to charter schools. He cited a 97.6% graduation rate and an A-rated district. Average teacher bonus is ~$8,600. Starting teacher salary is $48,700; starting school police officer salary is $47,648. He noted 2% and 2.6% base pay raises over the past two years, limited by a low fund balance (3% when he arrived, now 5%). He expressed hope for larger raises as the district’s financial health improves.
  • Councilman Arias expressed concern that 2.5% raises are insufficient compared to surrounding counties and asked how teachers could see larger increases. Dr. Bernier explained that base salary increases come from state funding (BSA) and not from the millage; the millage provides bonuses. The governor has been supportive but more BSA funding would help.
  • School Board Member Balduk (fiscal conservative) said she has scrutinized the budget and found no waste. She noted 85% of the budget is locked in, and the district has cut deeply. She argued the referendum is needed because other funding is insufficient.
  • School Board Member Pearson (product of DCPS, parent of graduates) urged council to pull the item on Tuesday to avoid further delay and allow staff to focus on the next school year.
  • School Board Member (former teacher) echoed support, asking council to consider teachers who work second or third jobs.
  • Charter School Representative John Rood expressed support, noting the revenue helps retain teachers in a competitive environment with private voucher schools. He said charters helped the district achieve an A rating.
  • Councilwoman Tyrona Clark Murray (former teacher of 32 years) added that teachers often work unpaid overtime tutoring, and the millage helps offset health insurance costs.

Key Outcomes

  • Councilman Arias stated that after hearing the presentations and public testimony, his mind was already made up before the meeting, and he now knows what he will do on Tuesday night—implying he will support moving the referendum forward.
  • No formal vote was taken at this workshop. The next step is the June 9 city council meeting, where a council member may move to discharge the item from Finance Committee. If successful, the council will vote on placing the referendum on the November 2026 ballot.

Meeting Transcript

All right. Good morning, everybody. Thank you all for coming. And I'm I saw I'm sorry for not having enough seats, but I did not expect 300 people to come in this to this meeting. All right, but but thank you all for coming. Alright, good job. All right. We have a short 30-minute meeting today. Once again, I did not expect this, but um I think we could uh we could extend it a little bit longer. Should we have some more questions, potentially we'll find out about that through our attorneys here. But let's start off with introductions to my left, please. Anything there is that Tony Ricardo, school board district one. Raw Aries, District 11. Good morning, Tyrona Clark Murray City Council District 9 and 32-year veteran of Duval County Public School. All right. Okay, and this is currently being live streamed as well and recorded in case anybody wants to rewatch the video later on. All right, and we notice it for an hour, even better. So we have a full hour, guys. All right. Um we have microphones right here. If you guys want to speak, just pass it along, and then we'll bring you guys some microphones as well, too. All right. Um, so this meeting is is very we could put one on this side of it if you don't mind. Okay, thank you. Uh, this meeting is really uh mainly to to understand uh the ramifications. Should it not go in the botot on our end? Um, what it will mean once it goes on the ballot in November, so it's more of an educational purpose. Also, um, just kind of some point of clarity. Uh, this was taken up this past Tuesday at our finance committee meeting during that time. Uh, there was a lot of concerns, a lot of unanswered questions, and so I found it myself that personally I was not ready to take action on this until I truly understood the nature of what we were voting on. Yeah, somebody could say it was as simple as just putting on the ballot, so let people vote. Sure, we get that part. But there's more to it than just that. I want to understand what this mill rate, this this one mill would signify. Should it pass in November? Should it not pass? What have we done in the past with this uh previous extension of I think it was like the last four years that we've had it? How has that really affected our our school um our district? And additionally, what would happen in the future should it pass or not pass? I want to understand everything before I take vote on this. So my train of thought last Tuesday was let me make calls, let me have meetings. I'm I made a lot of calls, a lot of people called me. I have several of emails from everybody from the community, all right. So my questions have been for the most part answered. I feel a lot better about everything moving forward. Um the question is what how do we where would where do we stand next Tuesday? And that's where I have the attorneys here to talk about where we're gonna be at next Tuesday. So uh Mr. Fapulis or Mr. Factor, if you don't mind.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com