The Urban Forestry Board held a special meeting on October 30, 2025, primarily to hear an appeal of a Heritage Tree Removal Permit for 151 Calderon Avenue (Eaves Creekside apartment complex). The meeting also approved the 2026 meeting schedule with an earlier start time.
Voted on those minutes. We had uh we provided input on the biodiversity plan. But do uh commissioners have any questions about minutes? No. Hearing none, are there any public comments on the minutes for our prior meeting? Seeing none, um I'll move that we approve the minutes. Second, may we have a vote? Bryant, yes. Yes, commissioner summer, yes, vice chairman. Yes, Chair Davis. Yes. Okay, um, on to item five. Oh no, I'm sorry, on uh item four, which is oral communications from the public. And this part of the agenda is reserved for persons wishing to address the commission on any item that's not on the agenda, so not the heritage tree appeal or our 2026 schedule, but any other items. Um speakers are limited to three minutes, and the state laws prohibit the commission from acting on non-agenda items. Are there any individuals wishing to address the commission on non-agenda items? Anyone online? Seeing none, we will move on to item 5.1, uh, which is the heritage tree appeal. And uh, somewhat complicated, or there's a lot of process. Um, here's how to go down. Staff will present a report. Um, since we have multiple appellants, the first appellant will have 10 minutes to present, then the second appellate will have 10 minutes to speak. The applicant will have up to 10 minutes to speak, and then the commission will have an opportunity to ask questions of the presenters, including the staff, the appellant, and uh, do we have to um then we'll open it up to public comment? So uh typically allow up to three minutes for that, close public comment, then we will uh then staff will have an additional two minutes to address any final comments. The applicant will have an additional two minutes if they wish to make any final comments, as will appellate one and two, and then the commission will uh deliberate, make a motion and potentially vote. So that's how it will happen. And with that, we'll turn it over to staff for presentation, please. All right, thank you, Commissioners. Russell Hanson, urban forestry manager within community services department. Um, this evening we're here to present uh the appeal uh information for 150 Rome 151 Calderon Avenue. Um, we'll go there. Um so in this case, uh Heritage Tree Removal permit application to remove eight heritage trees was submitted in connection with the building permit number 259390. Um the reason on the application listed was removal of eight heritage trees to accommodate the ADUs proposed under the building permit application to construct six detached ADUs. Um what we have here is a site overview map. Um you can see kind of starting down in the lower right-hand corner, tree number one is offset. Um, first and foremost, I want to be clear these locations are approximate. Um, there was not a formal drawing submitted to us that had both pieces. So I did my best to scale it and figure out approximate locations, and so these are the approximate locations. I can't tell you that they're exactly where they're going to be, but you can see some of the conflicts regardless. So tree number one, kind of that lower right-hand side you can see um at the corner of one of the ADUs as well as number four, number three and two are attached, kind of overlaying uh second ADU, and then tree number five that is out closer to the parking lot. Those red and blue lines that you see are power and water utilities, etc. And so the concern there is is that they were going to be doing root pruning or otherwise. Um tree number six, seven, and eight are all similar. They're either right adjacent to the unit inside of the unit footprint or over the utilities, but that is a very narrow approximately 10 to 15 foot path there between the ADU and the parking lot as it sits. If you get a little bit closer look, tree number one is a sycamore. Kind of a decent structure, fairly good health, no real major issues with it. Tree number two on the right, similar condition, has some other issues with the bark. You can just barely make out in the pictures where it's a little more white. Don't think that's anything significant or otherwise, but overall again, health, condition, structure all appeared to be fair. Tree number three, another sycamore, similar condition, a little bit over the parking lot and some of the mailboxes, etc.