The Parks and Recreation and Urban Forestry Board met on December 12, 2025, at 6:00 PM (noting the agenda indicated a 3:00 PM start time but the meeting was called to order at approximately 6:08 PM). The board considered two heritage tree removal appeals, approved the previous meeting minutes, and honored outgoing Commissioner Steve Filios.
i will now call to order the uh december wednesday december 10th meeting of the uh city of mountain views parks and recreation and urban forestry board um allison can you please conduct our roll call commissioner bryant yes commissioner felios here commissioner summer here vice chair mitchner here and chair davis is absent it all right we'll now move on to approval of the minutes um just first amongst our commissioners are there any questions about the minutes or is there any public comment on the minutes these would be the minutes from our november 17th meeting nothing online okay i'll entertain a motion to approve the minutes. So moved. Sorry. Motion and a second. Let's conduct our vote. Okay. Commissioner Bryant. Yes. Commissioner Felios. Yes. Commissioner Sommer. Yes. And Vice Chair Michener. Yes. All right. We'll now move on to oral communications from the public. this portion of the meeting is reserved for people wishing to address the commission on any matter not on the agenda so not the two heritage tree appeals that we'll be hearing speakers are limited to three minutes and state law prohibits the commission from acting on non-agenda items if anyone in attendance would like to provide public comment please also fill out a blue card Is there anybody in the room who would like to? No public comment there. Allison, is there anybody online? No. Right. We'll close public comment and move on to new business. Tonight we have two heritage tree appeals. And I'm going to start off by introducing our two city attorneys that are going to be with us tonight. and i may introduce you again after before the second appeal just in case somebody's not listening yet um assistant city attorney diana fazelli will be representing city staff and senior assistant city attorney dave wilgus will be representing the urban forestry board for the procedures that we're going through um just to our first uh 5.1 is a heritage tree removal application at 3440 truman avenue and i'm just going to run through the quick uh process that i will be following for this appeal um we will first have a staff report um then following that the appellant uh we'll have 10 minutes to speak. And in that, since the appellant is not the original applicant, if the original applicant and the appellant agree, the original applicant can use some of that 10 minutes for comments of their own if they choose. Following that, the commission will be able to ask any questions that we have. Then there will be public comments. and then after that staff will have an additional two minutes for any closing comments and then the appellant will have two minutes again and again they can allocate some of that time to the to the applicant if they would like following that the prc will be make will deliberate and make any motion that is appropriate so let's start off with our staff report we have urban forestry manager russell hansen who will be making that report thank you commissioner let me get that presentation up here there it goes okay so again thank you commissioner um russell hansen urban forest manager for community services here to talk about the appeal of uh to me at 3440 truman avenue the tree in question is a pinus radiata or monterey pine approximately 20 inches in diameter when measured at 54 inches above grade and we considered the tree to be both in fair health as well as fair structure at a minimum the applicant had listed uh six criteria on the application First was tree is in poor health. Second, tree is in danger of falling. Tree is near the end of its lifespan. Tree does not have proper growth space.