On Wednesday, February 11, 2026, the Mountain View Parks and Recreation and Urban Forestry Board convened to discuss a heritage tree removal appeal and receive staff updates. The meeting began at approximately 2:15 PM. Commissioners present: Brian, Davis, Sylvester, and Chair Mitchner. Commissioner Summer was absent. The board voted 4-0 to deny the appeal and uphold staff's decision to refuse removal of a heritage tree at 2415 Benjamin Drive.
okay i'm going to call to order uh the wednesday february 11th 2026 meeting of the city of mountain views parks and recreation and urban forestry board uh allison flynn can you please conduct the roll call yep we have brian here davis here silvester here chair mitchner yes here and your summer is absent All right. We'll now move on to item three, which is the minutes approval. First, is there any public comment, either in the room or online, regarding the minutes from the January 11th meeting? No one online. All right. Is there anyone who wishes to make a motion? So moved. Second. We have a motion by Commissioner Bryan, seconded by Commissioner Davis. Commissioner Bryan? Yes. Commissioner Davis? Yes. Commissioner Sylvester? Yes. Passes 4-0. All right, moving on to oral communications from the public. This portion of the meeting is reserved for persons wishing to address the commission on any matter not matter not on the agenda. Speakers are limited to three minutes and state law prohibits the commission from acting on non-agenda items. If anyone here in the room would like to provide public comment, please fill out a blue card. And for those online, if you could please use the raise hand feature and Allison Flynn will recognize you at the appropriate time. So let's start with people in the room. Anybody here for public comment? Anybody online? All right, I will close public comment. Moving on to new business. Item number 5.1 is a heritage tree removal application appeal for 2415 Benjamin Drive in Mountain View. before we go into that I'd like to do a couple of things first I want to introduce two city attorneys who are going to be participating or at least listening to the process assistant city attorney Diana Fazelli will be representing city staff and I see Diana on on the zoom and senior assistant city attorney David Willis will be representing the urban forestry board uh just to outline the process on tonight's appeal uh we'll start off with a staff report then the appellant will have uh 10 minutes to speak and uh if the appellant wishes to allocate some of that time to the owner um they may they may do that if they desire We will then have PRC questions for either the staff or the appellant. Following that, there will be public comment. Then staff will have two minutes for concluding remarks and the appellant will also have two minutes. Again, they can allocate some of that time to the owner if they choose. Following that, PRC will deliberate and come to some kind of a motion and a vote. so uh to start things off uh i believe russell hansen our forestry manager will be presenting all right thank you commissioners appreciate you coming this evening um again the item that we're hearing this evening is for 2415 benjamin drive it is a heritage tree appeal. The tree itself, actually, let me backtrack. You've got the aerial image up on the screen now currently in that lower left corner is the approximate location of where this podocarpus is located. As you can see, it's kind of right along the edge of the property in there between those two properties. The tree itself is again a podocarpus graciliar. It's 22 inches in diameter. It is what we would consider to be in good health and overall fair structure with the only concerns being a little bit of unbalanced canopy from prior pruning. Applicant had listed the following criteria as the reason for removal. Tree is in good or fair health. The tree does not appear to have proper growth space. The tree is interfering with utility service, for example, electricity, gas, sewer, or water. And lastly, that the tree is growing in close proximity to the structures and causing damage or will do so in the near future. So when we overall looked at the tree again, the canopy itself, again, we felt it was healthy.