OpenPublica

Accountability starts with access.

© 2026 · Filed for the public record

Use casesAboutAPIPrivacyTermsLinkedIn
Home/Mountain View, California/City Council
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Mountain View Parks & Recreation/Urban Forestry Board Meeting – June 18, 2026

City Council — Thursday, June 18, 2026
BodyMountain View, California
SessionCity Council
DateThursday, June 18, 2026
StatusFILED
Video Record
0:00 / 3:12:12

Transcript — VerbatimClick a timed line to jump · ⧉ to share it
0:00

Okay, I'm now gonna call the order the June, or I'm sorry, the Wednesday, June 17th, 2026 meeting of City of Mountain Views Parks Recreation and Urban Forestry Board.

0:12

Allison, let's conduct a roll call.

0:14

Okay, we have Commissioner Bryant, Commissioner Davis, Commissioner Sylvester, here, Vice Chair Summer, here, and Chair.

0:26

We have this is our last meeting of the year.

0:28

We have a little musical company.

0:33

Let's see.

0:33

Uh, we'll now go on to the uh approval the minutes from the June 10th meeting, which was just last week.

0:39

So this is going to be absolutely recovered pretty well probably from then.

0:43

Um first of all, I just want to see if there's any public comment on the June 17th or June 10th.

0:54

With that, uh, bring it back to the commission to see if anybody would like to make a motion.

0:58

So we'll comment first.

1:03

Comment first.

1:05

Tell me if I'm the minutes indicate a uh this approval or motion to uh postpone the meeting.

1:18

I think so.

1:19

Yeah, we did vote.

1:20

No, I'm something.

1:22

So I probably mumbled it, so if you didn't know that, I can update that and I can bring them back the next time.

1:30

Well, we can do that.

1:33

Yeah, I can change that.

1:34

I'm sorry, I did not hear that.

1:39

Um it was to continue item 5.1 to a date to be determined, and you voted no.

1:46

Okay.

1:48

So I'll make a motion.

1:53

So, all right.

1:56

Okay, don't you?

1:58

Okay, we have Commissioner Bryant.

2:01

Commissioner Davis.

2:02

Yes.

2:03

Commissioner Sylvester, Vice Chair Summer, yes, and Chair Mitchers.

2:08

Yes.

2:10

Passage 5-0.

2:12

Um okay, we'll now move on to oral communications from the public.

2:16

Uh this portion of the meeting is reserved for persons wishing to address the commission on any matter not on the agenda.

2:24

Speakers are limited to three minutes, and state law prohibits the commission from acting on non-agenda items.

2:30

If you're in the room and would like to speak, please fill out a blue card.

2:34

If you're online, please use raise hand feature, zoom.

2:39

Allison Flynn will recognize you.

2:41

So this first one again is the items that are not on the agenda.

2:45

So if this is one of the two tree appeals, this would not be the time to speak.

2:50

So is there anybody?

2:57

Yeah, find the colour.

3:01

Yeah, you'll have an option.

3:02

That's not for now.

3:04

Not now.

3:05

No, not now.

3:05

No, later, yeah, later.

3:07

Thank you.

3:08

Thank you.

3:10

Okay, anyway in the room.

3:16

All right, we'll now close public comment.

3:21

Do we have any idea what's going to be this maybe?

3:27

Um someone, Diana is on, and she said, sort of hear the music, but it's not loud.

3:36

I've done it for they can hear what's happening in the book.

3:40

Um I think so.

3:49

Hi, board.

3:50

Um, it sounds a bit garbled.

3:52

I will say that.

3:59

Okay.

4:03

Do we have any opportunities that can't help it?

4:06

Um, if I think with IT, we have somebody here.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Parks and Recreation█████████████████████████████████████████████66%
Procedural████████12%
Historic Preservation███████11%
Engineering And Infrastructure█████7%
Community Engagement█2%
Economic Development█1%
Public Safety█1%
Summary of Proceedings

Mountain View Parks and Recreation Commission and Urban Forestry Board Meeting – June 18, 2026

The meeting was called to order at 6:02 p.m. on June 18, 2026, with all five members present. The board considered two heritage tree removal appeals and approved the annual work plan for fiscal year 2026-27.

Consent Calendar

  • Minutes Approval (June 10, 2026): M/S Bryant/Davis to approve as amended. Vote: 5-0 (all yes).

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Item 5.1 (560 Franklin Street): Appellant Timothy Lee argued the London plane tree provides environmental benefits (oxygen, carbon absorption) and that alternatives to driveway widening exist to save the tree. Applicant Robin Lynn, the homeowner, stated the tree is unsuitable under power lines, poses safety risks, conflicts with driveway code compliance, and that a more appropriate species would benefit the urban forest. Public speaker Bill Lambert supported staff’s position, noting all four heritage tree criteria were met.
  • Item 5.2 (2714 Preston Drive): Appellant Norm Steinberg, speaking for the family, emphasized safety concerns from a declining pine tree with beetle infestation and pitch canker, noting rapid deterioration and risk of falling. Public speaker Brett Steinberg (son) echoed the safety risk and urgency.

Discussion Items

5.1 Heritage Tree Removal Appeal – 560 Franklin Street
Urban Forest Manager Russell Hansen presented that the 24-inch-diameter London plane tree had good-to-fair health but poor structure due to repeated directional pruning by PGE for power‑line clearance. The tree impeded a proposed driveway expansion. Staff found all four removal criteria met: condition, necessity for improvements, poor form, and good forestry practice. The board debated precedent, canopy loss, and tree health. Commissioners Bryant and Davis opposed removal, arguing the tree provides valuable shade and that the driveway issue could be resolved without removal. Commissioners Sommer, Sylvester, and Mitchner supported removal based on structural risk, poor viability under power lines, and the opportunity to plant a better‑suited species.

5.2 Heritage Tree Removal Appeal – 2714 Preston Drive
A 38-inch-diameter Monterey pine showed evidence of red turpentine beetle and pitch canker. Staff determined tree #1 (the appealed tree) was still in good health with minimal beetle strikes and could be treated, while an adjacent heavily infested tree had already been approved for removal. The appellant argued the beetle infestation was worsening and removing both trees simultaneously was safer. Staff maintained that timely removal of the infested tree and chemical treatment of tree #1 could preserve it for years. The board unanimously agreed with staff, citing the tree’s current health and the availability of treatment options.

5.3 Fiscal Year 2026‑27 Work Plan
Community Services Director John Marchant presented the draft work plan, which includes ongoing items (e.g., Thompson Mini Park concept, recreation financial assistance review) and a planned update on the Biodiversity and Urban Forest Plan in June 2027. Commissioners requested adding a high‑level Parks and Recreation Strategic Plan update in advance of the full annual update, currently slated for September 2026. The motion included that addition.

Key Outcomes

  • Item 5.1 (560 Franklin Street): M/S Sommer/Sylvester to deny the appeal, uphold staff’s decision, and approve removal of one heritage tree. Vote: 3–2 (Yes: Sylvester, Sommer, Mitchner; No: Bryant, Davis). The tree will be removed.
  • Item 5.2 (2714 Preston Drive): M/S Davis/Sommer to deny the appeal and uphold staff’s decision to deny removal of the heritage tree (#1). Vote: 5–0 (all yes). The tree must be preserved and treated; staff will fast‑track a re‑evaluation if conditions change.
  • Item 5.3 (Work Plan): M/S Sommer/Sylvester to approve the FY 2026‑27 work plan with an added line item under #13 for a high‑level Parks and Recreation Strategic Plan update in advance of the September 2026 annual update. Vote: 5–0. The plan will be forwarded to City Council for approval.

Additional Announcements

Community Services Director Marchant noted upcoming Pride event (Saturday), summer concerts, and summer camps. Commissioner Bryant raised concerns about conditions at Pioneer Park and urged staff to plan for its long‑term management. The next regular meeting is scheduled for September 9, 2026.

Meeting Transcript

Okay, I'm now gonna call the order the June, or I'm sorry, the Wednesday, June 17th, 2026 meeting of City of Mountain Views Parks Recreation and Urban Forestry Board. Allison, let's conduct a roll call. Okay, we have Commissioner Bryant, Commissioner Davis, Commissioner Sylvester, here, Vice Chair Summer, here, and Chair. We have this is our last meeting of the year. We have a little musical company. Let's see. Uh, we'll now go on to the uh approval the minutes from the June 10th meeting, which was just last week. So this is going to be absolutely recovered pretty well probably from then. Um first of all, I just want to see if there's any public comment on the June 17th or June 10th. With that, uh, bring it back to the commission to see if anybody would like to make a motion. So we'll comment first. Comment first. Tell me if I'm the minutes indicate a uh this approval or motion to uh postpone the meeting. I think so. Yeah, we did vote. No, I'm something. So I probably mumbled it, so if you didn't know that, I can update that and I can bring them back the next time. Well, we can do that. Yeah, I can change that. I'm sorry, I did not hear that. Um it was to continue item 5.1 to a date to be determined, and you voted no. Okay. So I'll make a motion. So, all right. Okay, don't you? Okay, we have Commissioner Bryant. Commissioner Davis. Yes. Commissioner Sylvester, Vice Chair Summer, yes, and Chair Mitchers. Yes. Passage 5-0. Um okay, we'll now move on to oral communications from the public. Uh this portion of the meeting is reserved for persons wishing to address the commission on any matter not on the agenda. Speakers are limited to three minutes, and state law prohibits the commission from acting on non-agenda items. If you're in the room and would like to speak, please fill out a blue card. If you're online, please use raise hand feature, zoom. Allison Flynn will recognize you. So this first one again is the items that are not on the agenda. So if this is one of the two tree appeals, this would not be the time to speak. So is there anybody? Yeah, find the colour. Yeah, you'll have an option. That's not for now. Not now. No, not now. No, later, yeah, later. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, anyway in the room. All right, we'll now close public comment.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com