Oakland City Council Meeting - January 20, 2026: Police Commission Slate Rejected, Business Tax Liens Approved
Oakland City Council Meeting - January 20, 2026
At its regular meeting on Tuesday, January 20, 2026, the Oakland City Council (8 members present) conducted a public hearing on delinquent business tax liens, extensively debated and ultimately rejected the Police Commission selection panel's reappointment slate, and approved a consent calendar with multiple resolutions. The meeting was called to order at 3:30 p.m.
Public Hearing
- Business Tax Delinquency Liens: Revenue and Tax Administrator Nicole Welch presented a resolution to place liens on 1,800 properties for unpaid business taxes totaling $5,186,449.10, plus $397,075 in administrative fees, for a total of $5,583,524.10. She noted the number of delinquent parcels had decreased from an initial 2,918 due to ongoing education and collection efforts. Property owners may pay through August 10, 2026. The resolution was adopted unanimously (8-0) after public comment.
- Public Speakers on Liens: Several property owners spoke about confusion, mistaken assessments, and financial hardship. One speaker reported 89 businesses closed in November 2025, and another asked for data on why delinquencies increased from 869 in 2023 to over 2,000 in 2025. Staff promised to investigate.
Discussion Items
- Police Commission Selection Panel Slate (Item 5.1): The Council considered two options: accept or reject the slate of Ricardo Garcia Acosta (full commissioner) and Omar Farmer (alternate commissioner). The selection panel had resubmitted the same slate after an initial rejection in October 2025. Council debate centered on the selection process, the low number of applicants, and whether new applicants (13 received) were interviewed. Public comment overwhelmingly supported the candidates, citing their qualifications and dedication, with several speakers calling the process a distraction. Councilmember Fyfe and Gallo supported the slate; others argued for reopening the process. A substitute motion to reject the slate passed 6-2 (Fyfe and Gallo dissenting).
Consent Calendar
- Items 6.1-6.12: The consent calendar included minutes, emergency declarations (AIDS, medical cannabis, homelessness), library commission appointments, early care and education grant, mayor's police commission appointments (Judge Griot approved; Doug Wong delayed), Montclair parking contract, Caltrans litter removal agreement, OPD-Santa Clara Police MOU, and several other contracts.
- Public Comments on Consent: Multiple speakers from East Oakland Community Project (EOCP) described severe impacts of delayed city funding, including unpaid employee payroll, service disruptions, and client housing losses. The city owed EOCP nearly half a million dollars. Councilmembers pledged to address the issue.
- Amendments: The mayor's office requested separating the police commission appointment of Doug Wong due to an incomplete background check; the Council agreed. Councilmember Gallo registered no votes on the Caltrans agreement (6.9) and OPD MOU (6.10), arguing Caltrans should maintain its own properties and that Oakland police are needed locally.
- Vote: The consent calendar was approved as amended, 5-2 (Fyfe and Gallo dissenting, Ramachandran excused).
Key Outcomes
- Police Commission Slate Rejected (6-2): The Council rejected the reappointment of Ricardo Garcia Acosta and Omar Farmer. The selection panel is expected to continue recruitment and consider new applicants.
- Business Tax Liens Approved (8-0): The resolution authorizing liens and collection for $5.58 million in delinquent taxes was adopted.
- Consent Calendar Approved (5-2-1): All consent items passed except for the noted dissents, with the special request to advance Judge Griot's appointment and defer Doug Wong's.
- Next Steps on EOCP Funding: Councilmembers committed to contacting the city administrator to expedite payment to East Oakland Community Project, which reported a $500,000 outstanding bill and risk of shutting down.
Meeting Transcript
Thank you. good afternoon and welcome to the city council meeting of tuesday january 20th 2026 before i call roll I will go over speaker card instructions if you would like to speak on any item on this agenda please follow speaker's card before the item is called for discussion or two hours after the start of this meeting this meeting was called to order at 3 30 so your last opportunity to sign up to speak will be at 5 30 p.m. or before the item is called whichever comes first if you'd like to sign up to speak please get a card and hand it to a clerk representative at the front or if you're looking to sign up to speak online that time has passed as online speaker cards are due 24 hours before the start of this meeting all roll council members brown present council member fife present council member gallo brisson council member houston council member ramachandran present council member unger president council member wang present and chair jenkins present showing eight members present at this time chair Jenkins do you have any announcements before we begin no announcements going to item three modifications to the agenda and procedural items including but not limited to request to reschedule items from consent to non consent items to the next council agenda speak on consent calendar register votes or change order of items or pull items held in committee To President Pro Tem Gallo, 6.9 Caltrans maintenance agreement. So in committee, you voted no, and the mayor's office attempted to reach you. Would you like us to pull that off of consent, or do you want to register a no vote on the consent? Yes, sir. I will continue to add communications with Public Works and other members of the city administration, and I will continue to vote no on the consent item, Caltrans Maintenance Agreement Amendment on page 10, S6.9. And do I need to explain it now? No, then the other item that I would like to consider a no vote is page 11, S.6, the mou between opd and the santa clara police department okay to send opd over to monitor the game okay okay thank you um we will register that at the appropriate time uh anybody want to pull anything off of consent if not we can send the staff members home that are on consent thank you number three going to item 4 which will be consideration of items with the statutory public hearing you do have one public hearing I need a motion to open the public hearing on the motion by councilmember Gallo second by councilmember Houston to open the public hearing council member brown aye council member fife aye council member gallo aye council member houston council member ramachandran aye council member unger aye council member wong aye and chair jenkins aye motion passes with a vote of eight eyes now reading the item into record conduct a public hearing and upon conclusion adopt a resolution confirming the report and notice of liens for delinquent business taxes with penalties interest and administrative and assessment charges and overruling any protests and objections related to the liens included in said report and authorizing the recordation of liens and directing the notice of lien and assessment charges be turned over to the county tax collector for collection there are four speakers on this item Good afternoon and Happy New Year everyone. My name is Nicole Welch, Revenue and Tax Administrator. I'm before you. Staff recommends the adoption of the proposed resolution which will authorize the placement of liens on real property for unpaid city of Oakland business taxes and authorize the subsequent assessment pursuant to Chapter 5.04 of the Oakland Municipal Code. Should the fees and charges remain unpaid prior to the transfer recording upset special assessment levies to the alameda county tax collector and auditor controller for inclusion on the next property tax roll the liens will be recorded against the number has gone down is 1 800 properties um parcels in the amount
openpublica.com