Pre-Agenda Interviews for ALCOSAN and Pittsburgh Water Board Appointments – March 4, 2026
Pre-Agenda Interviews for ALCOSAN and Pittsburgh Water Board Appointments – March 4, 2026
The Committee on Hearings and Policy of the Pittsburgh City Council held pre-agenda interviews on Wednesday, March 4, 2026, at 1:30 PM in Council Chambers. The purpose was to interview two nominees for board positions: Shatara Murphy for the Allegheny County Sanitary Authority (ALCOSAN) and Scott Kunka for the Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority (PWSA). Councilmembers Schlossberger, Warwick, and Gross participated. No votes were taken; the interviews are a precursor to formal consideration of the resolutions.
Discussion Items
-
Shatara Murphy – ALCOSAN Board Appointment (Resolution 2026-0128): Ms. Murphy introduced herself as Assistant Vice Chancellor for Community Connected Economic Strategies at the University of Pittsburgh. She emphasized her background in community impact, economic stability, and governance. When asked about procurement, she expressed a focus on local procurement, increasing awareness of contracting opportunities, and connecting vendors with capacity-building resources such as the Institute for Entrepreneurial Excellence. She stated her lens would prioritize workforce and community impact. She committed to learning about the ALCOSAN clean water plan and ensuring community input on major projects.
-
Scott Kunka – Pittsburgh Water Board Appointment (Resolution 2026-0136): Mr. Kunka, a retired city finance and budget director (and former PWSA board member), described his extensive government experience. He expressed opposition to privatization of water authorities, stating it is “not necessary” and should remain under citizen control. He advocated for a budget approach that prioritizes available resources over rate increases to cover all needs. He raised concerns about non-billable water loss (historically ~50%) and the need for transparency in the budget process. He noted the challenge of small contractors bidding on large projects due to scale requirements and suggested considering workforce diversity in contractor evaluations. On the consent decree and stormwater management, he acknowledged the need to study current plans and called for community engagement.
-
Councilmember Questions and Discussion:
- Councilmember Warwick raised stormwater management and flood mitigation, noting the defunded Four Mile Run project and the need for community input on ALCOSAN’s tunnel project. She highlighted the Panther Hollow Lake restoration as a potential low-hanging fruit for stormwater improvement and community asset. She also discussed the problem of water bill evictions, where tenants not paying leads to landlord-tenant disputes, and the difficulty low-income tenants face accessing rebates when bills are in landlords’ names. She urged board members to advocate for redesigning the system.
- Councilmember Gross explored privatization history, referencing the Veolia operate-maintain lease that led to infrastructure decline and inaccurate billing. She questioned Mr. Kunka’s past role in the parking asset lease proposal (which Council did not approve), noting it was considered a privatization scheme. Mr. Kunka defended the parking lease as a response to state pension mandates and argued it differed from Chicago’s deal. Councilmember Gross also discussed ALCOSAN’s “big dig” project (EPA-mandated tunnels under rivers) and its cost burden on ratepayers, urging the board to seek community benefits and green infrastructure investments. She highlighted the need for better coordination between utilities and city paving to avoid repeated street cuts.
Key Outcomes
- Interviews were held for both nominees; no votes were taken. The resolutions appointing Shatara Murphy to ALCOSAN and Scott Kunka to PWSA will proceed to a formal council vote at a later date.
- Councilmembers’ questions and concerns—particularly on affordability, procurement equity, transparency, stormwater management, and privatization—were noted for the nominees’ future board service.
Meeting Transcript
Good afternoon, and welcome to the preagenda interview for Wednesday, March fourth, two thousand twenty-six for Alcassan and Pittsburgh Water. Would a clerk please read the title of the bill? Bill one twenty-eight, resolution appointing Shatar Murphy as a board member of the Allegheny County Sanitary Authority for a term to expire January one, twenty thirty-one. And Bill One Thirty Six Resolution appointing Scott Conka as a member of the Board of Directors of Pittsburgh Water for a term to expire January one, twenty thirty-one. For the record, we are currently joined by Councilman Schlossberger, Councilman Warwick. I know Councilman Gross is on her way, and others may join us as well. If you would first introduce yourself, tell us who you are, tell us why you're willing to serve in this position. And then once you both have presented, we'll turn over to members for questions. Now we can. All right. Good afternoon. I'm Chatara Murphy. I currently serve as the Assistant Vice Chancellor and Executive Lead for Community Connected Economic Strategies at the University of Pittsburgh. But the focus of my career has really been working in critical roles at the intersection of government, large institutions, and community, and helping to be one of the individuals that really break down systems and policies and help to drive them into outcomes that really improve the quality of life for our residents. Prayerfully, I will be done in April of 2027. But I believe that my background and community impact, um, economic stability and economic resilience will make me a good fit for the board. Um that governance um lens that I bring from my other board service, as well as my time in government and large institutions will be very beneficial as well. Thank you. Thank you. Uh my name is Scott Kwonka. I live at 525 Lloyd Street in Point Breeze. Uh I'm a constituent of Councilman Mosley. Um I thank you, and I thank the mayor for the consideration for this position. Uh I've lived in the city since 1974 when I came here to go to the University of Pittsburgh. I've raised three kids, all of whom went to the Pittsburgh Public School System, and they've all graduated uh from this public school system. Um I care deeply about the city, and I did spend several decades working here with the city and with the county in various positions, and I hopefully was able to make some sort of an impact during that time, uh almost 30 years with the city, seven years with the county. And uh I have been retired for almost five years now, and I really would like to continue contributing. It's something that I missed uh during the retirement. And um uh when the mayor asked me to join the board, I jumped at the chance. Um just a way of background. I retired from the city as a finance and budget director in 2014, and I spent the next seven years at the uh Allegheny County as the chief investment officer. And some of you may know I also spent seven years as City Council's budget director in a previous iteration. Um with this appointment, I will have work for seven mayors during my career uh with the city. Uh I also served on the PWSA board previously for seven years. Um, and so I'm very familiar with the operations of the authority. But it has been 12 years since I've been on the board, so there's been plenty of changes, I'm sure, and uh plenty of um changes to the operation. So what I do pledge is to do my due dil due diligence to study and learn about the current situation. I think I can offer a fresh set of eyes for the board and for the authority itself. And I do I don't have any preconceived notions about what is going on. Uh as I said, I would like to learn, uh study and do what's best. But the one thing that I have learned during my government service is that the financial means always are less than the needs than the resources that are needed to do uh what's necessary for the city and for the authorities, and in particular with the PWSA, the ratepayers' ability to defund the various items that are that are necessary for the authority in the future. So having said that, I'm just available for questions at this point in time. Thank you. Thank you very much. With that, I will turn over to Councilman Schlossberger. Thank you very much much, Mr. President. Thank you both for your willingness to serve in your respective roles in different agencies and authorities. And um I you know I welcome both of you at to the table and your um again, thank you for your for the time that you will be putting into these these endeavors. Um Ms.
openpublica.com