OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Special Committee on Ways and Means Reviews PPSD FY2027 Budget – May 28, 2026

City CouncilThursday, May 28, 2026
BodyProvidence, Rhode Island
SessionCity Council
DateThursday, May 28, 2026
StatusFILED
Video Record
0:00 / 3:37:17

Transcript — Verbatim
0:07

Hi, good afternoon everyone.

0:09

My name is Miguel Sanchez.

0:10

I'm calling to order the special committee on ways and means.

0:14

The time is 5 37, Thursday, May 28th.

0:23

Chair Sanchez.

0:24

Present.

0:24

Vice Chairman Taylor is absent.

0:26

Counselor Davidson.

0:28

Councilman Graves.

0:30

President.

0:30

Councilor Peterson.

0:32

We have four president, one absent, we have five.

0:35

Thank you.

0:36

At this time, I want to recognize our policy staff, our comms team, our interns, our clerk's office, uh Etsy from our C Solicitor's Office.

0:47

Thank you for joining us.

0:50

At this time, anyone that plans on presenting before the committee, can you please stand up and guess what?

0:57

And please please raise your right hand.

1:12

Scott, uh don't you worry about Christmas TC is like directly partners you should.

1:20

I don't feel like the other should for the fun.

1:29

Exactly.

1:30

Scott, that's an operation.

1:33

Okay.

1:34

Thank you.

1:35

Um so we're gonna take item six out of order.

1:39

Um it is an appointment to the zoning board.

1:42

Uh this time I'll entertain a motion uh to move uh item six uh out of order.

1:48

Motion made by counselor Peterson, second by counselor Davis, all those in favor, aye, any nays, any uh abstentions, the ayes have it.

1:57

Mr.

1:57

Scott, Chairman Sanchez, thank you.

2:00

It's a pleasure to be here tonight.

2:01

How are you today?

2:02

So pretty good.

2:03

Uh I think everyone's pretty familiar with who you are and the service that you have and continue to provide to the city of Providence.

2:11

So a quick paragraph, could you just summarize uh on why you want to be uh appointed?

2:17

This is a new appointment, not a reappointment, correct?

2:20

So I served as second alternate since 2019.

2:23

I believe I took uh chairwoman Anthony's place, former councilman Nancy's place when she stepped into the council or somewhere in between us and overway.

2:32

Uh serve as second alternate though.

2:35

I voted probably in most meetings because you do have absences and refusals, things like that.

2:41

So I have a pretty robust voting record.

2:43

I I am proud of some of the stands I've taken and proud that we sometimes have had to occasionally vote against the recommendations playing department.

2:53

Something comes up in the hearing that you know wasn't presented now.

2:57

So it's in a way we could be a custodian of the city and protect their neighborhoods.

3:01

Uh I this term would be replacing Chairman Greenfield.

3:05

I would not be the chair, right?

3:06

Holton's the chair, but I would be the full term where I'd vote in every meeting.

3:10

And I feel at this point I don't need to find the front door.

3:14

I've been doing this for close to seven years, and I have an interesting context and neighborhoods having previously served as director of parks and recreation for Warwick.

3:24

Uh working at PPSD with the amazing friends back here, and especially Superintendent Martinez, where I got to ride shotgun back and some of the uh facilities work, some rate execution work.

3:37

Uh I've been involved with affordable health board and uh and overall enthusiastic about all things province.

3:45

So I'm glad to be here with all of you tonight.

3:48

Awesome, thank you.

3:49

Um in your experience in the zoning board, what have been some of uh your biggest challenges uh that you've seen the board have to uh work with?

4:01

I think the it's interesting.

4:06

Like we we really just call balls and strikes based on the the state sets the ordinance and you write the local ordinance.

4:11

So I don't think there's been a lot of challenge.

4:14

I think since uh Speaker Shikachi and the council subsequently revised the ordinance and they are signed it.

4:21

I feel it's a lot more streamlined, like it's uh the needs go a little bit quicker, and it's a little more user-friendly in the relief criteria.

4:31

You know, the ADA EU laws took a lot of stuff out of going there by right now, and they should be.

4:38

Uh there's smaller lots in the city, so it's hard to do a ton of the use, but uh, I think it's a lot more streamlined now, and you know, some of that's the councils could work by amending the ordinance.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Education█████████████████████████████████████████████54%
Budget Equity Analysis███████████13%
Fiscal Sustainability████████9%
Public Property Management█████6%
Procedural███4%
Homelessness███4%
Technology and Innovation███3%
Procurement Process██2%
Parks and Recreation██2%
Summary of Proceedings

Special Committee on Ways and Means Reviews PPSD FY2027 Budget – May 28, 2026

The Special Committee on Ways and Means, chaired by Miguel Sanchez, met on May 28, 2026, at 5:37 PM. The committee heard a detailed presentation from Providence Public School District (PPSD) leadership on the proposed FY2027 budget, which faces a $1.3 million decline in state aid and uses $3.2 million from reserves. The discussion covered enrollment declines, charter school tuition pressures, staffing reductions, and support for students experiencing homelessness.

Appointment to Zoning Board

  • After being moved out of order, the committee approved the appointment of Mr. Scott to a full term on the Zoning Board. Mr. Scott had served as second alternate since 2019 and replaced Chairman Greenfield. The motion passed unanimously on a voice vote.

Discussion Items

  • Budget Overview: PPSD leadership (Superintendent, Deputy Superintendent, and Chief of Operations) presented the FY2027 budget. Key challenges include declining enrollment (from 23,000 to ~19,000 students), rising fixed costs (transportation, special education tuition, benefits), and a loss of state aid due to fewer students and lower poverty rates. The district has reduced staff by over 500 FTEs since the start of state intervention, including 22 teacher layoffs for the coming year (total of 109 FTE reduction, 4%).
  • Revenue: State aid is projected at $211.3 million, a $1.3 million decline from FY2026. The city contribution is based on a settlement agreement. To balance the budget, the district plans to use $3.2 million from its reserve fund, reducing the reserve from $4.2 million to $1 million. A potential state funding formula change (increasing the success factor from 40% to 43%) could add $4–4.5 million, but the district did not assume that in planning.
  • Expenditures: Transportation costs increased 15% due to a new contract; the district reduced bus runs by four, saving $400,000. Special education tuition rose 8%, though 24 fewer students are placed out-of-district. Custodial contract extension includes a 3.5% annual escalator. The district reduced planned Chromebook purchases (saving $2 million) and eliminated some central office positions, including the grants writer and an MLL manager, through merging roles.
  • Staffing and Layoffs: The 22 teacher layoffs are primarily in areas of declining enrollment (elementary teachers without ESL certification, business education). The district continues to recruit math, special education, and science teachers. As of the meeting, there were fewer than 60 vacancies, down from mid-70s the previous year. Council members expressed concern about messaging around layoffs versus vacancies.
  • Charter School Tuition: Chair Sanchez highlighted that charter school tuition has risen from $21 million in FY2021 to $35.5 million in FY2026, and called this trend “unsustainable.” Several councilors echoed concerns about the fiscal impact of charter expansion on the district, noting that the funding formula does not allow the district to reduce costs proportionally when students leave. The district noted the enrollment loss transition fund softens the blow but is not sufficient.
  • Homeless Student Support: The district serves 133 students experiencing homelessness (7% of enrollment), providing wraparound services, transportation, and supplies. The district is required to transport students even if they temporarily reside outside Providence, costing $1.2 million annually. Academic outcomes for homeless students are significantly lower (e.g., 7% gap in ELA proficiency). Council members asked about data collection and federal grant funding.
  • UCAP Program Closure: The district ended its partnership with UCAP (a middle school program), affecting 42 seventh graders returning to the district. The district created a cohort program at Roger Williams Middle School with additional interventions at a fraction of the previous cost ($1.9 million for UCAP vs. much less for internal services). Only four of the 42 students have IEPs. Councilor Picardo expressed reservations about the transition plan and requested more detailed information.
  • Procurement Transition: Concerns were raised about potential delays in procurement as the district returns to local control. Councilor Davidson’s working group is developing recommendations to maintain efficient procurement while ensuring fiscal oversight.
  • Technology and Cybersecurity: Following a cybersecurity attack last year (no ransom paid), the district implemented new endpoint protection (Falcon) and applied for a grant for employee training. The district also discussed its use of Canvas (LMS) and iReady, noting that iReady is part of a broader Curriculum Associates package and that they monitor the class action lawsuit regarding student data privacy.
  • PCTA Facility: Council members raised concerns about the closure of PCTA for summer recreation programs (impacting 400+ children) due to maintenance; the district expects the facility to be available next summer. Alternative sites (Hope High School) have capacity and cleanliness issues.

Key Outcomes

  • The committee voted to continue items 1–5 (budget items) without a final vote, pending final state revenue numbers and further discussion at the school board. The budget will return for final approval in September.
  • The appointment to the Zoning Board was approved unanimously.
  • The meeting was adjourned after a motion by Councilor Davidson, seconded by Councilor Graves.
  • The committee plans further meetings to deepen partnership with PPSD as it returns to local control.

Meeting Transcript

Hi, good afternoon everyone. My name is Miguel Sanchez. I'm calling to order the special committee on ways and means. The time is 5 37, Thursday, May 28th. Chair Sanchez. Present. Vice Chairman Taylor is absent. Counselor Davidson. Councilman Graves. President. Councilor Peterson. We have four president, one absent, we have five. Thank you. At this time, I want to recognize our policy staff, our comms team, our interns, our clerk's office, uh Etsy from our C Solicitor's Office. Thank you for joining us. At this time, anyone that plans on presenting before the committee, can you please stand up and guess what? And please please raise your right hand. Scott, uh don't you worry about Christmas TC is like directly partners you should. I don't feel like the other should for the fun. Exactly. Scott, that's an operation. Okay. Thank you. Um so we're gonna take item six out of order. Um it is an appointment to the zoning board. Uh this time I'll entertain a motion uh to move uh item six uh out of order. Motion made by counselor Peterson, second by counselor Davis, all those in favor, aye, any nays, any uh abstentions, the ayes have it. Mr. Scott, Chairman Sanchez, thank you. It's a pleasure to be here tonight. How are you today? So pretty good. Uh I think everyone's pretty familiar with who you are and the service that you have and continue to provide to the city of Providence. So a quick paragraph, could you just summarize uh on why you want to be uh appointed? This is a new appointment, not a reappointment, correct? So I served as second alternate since 2019. I believe I took uh chairwoman Anthony's place, former councilman Nancy's place when she stepped into the council or somewhere in between us and overway. Uh serve as second alternate though. I voted probably in most meetings because you do have absences and refusals, things like that. So I have a pretty robust voting record. I I am proud of some of the stands I've taken and proud that we sometimes have had to occasionally vote against the recommendations playing department. Something comes up in the hearing that you know wasn't presented now. So it's in a way we could be a custodian of the city and protect their neighborhoods. Uh I this term would be replacing Chairman Greenfield. I would not be the chair, right? Holton's the chair, but I would be the full term where I'd vote in every meeting. And I feel at this point I don't need to find the front door. I've been doing this for close to seven years, and I have an interesting context and neighborhoods having previously served as director of parks and recreation for Warwick. Uh working at PPSD with the amazing friends back here, and especially Superintendent Martinez, where I got to ride shotgun back and some of the uh facilities work, some rate execution work. Uh I've been involved with affordable health board and uh and overall enthusiastic about all things province.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com