0:05Can you read the uh chamber emergency evacuation announcement?
0:09My activation of the emergency alarm signal, all persons should immediately exit the building.
0:14Please use the exits to the left or right front of the council chamber or the east or west there, where outside the rear doors of the chamber.
0:21Do not use elevators or escalators.
0:23After exiting the building, proceed down 9th Street and into the assembly area located in the former public safety building parking lot.
0:30Able persons should assist visually and hearing impaired visitors with exiting the building.
0:36Individuals wishing to speak during public hearings in the public comment period are generally allowed three minutes to speak.
0:42Persons appearing before the committee are not allowed to campaign for public office, promote private business ventures, use language of a personal nature, which insults or demeans any person, including comments directed at public officials or staff members that are not related to their official duties or address a staff, address or question staff members directly.
1:02All questions are to be directed to the committee chair.
1:05Failure to adhere to the guidelines may result in speakers forfeiting any remaining time and further disciplinary action as necessary, which can include barring from attendance at future meetings of the committee for a period of six months.
1:17And Madam Vice Chair, all members of the committee are in attendance today, with the exception of Ms.
1:22Lynch, and you do have a quorum.
1:33Can't speak on until she gets on.
1:39Um can we move with public comment?
1:46Public comment is now open.
1:48Is there anyone present who wishes to address the committee regarding items not on today's agenda?
2:02Come forward, state your name for the record, please.
2:05Good evening, everyone.
2:06Jacqueline Johnson Wilson.
2:08I would like to address regarding RPS budget.
2:14Is that something that I would comment on now or at the some other point?
2:20Now you said your name for the record.
2:36Good afternoon, Richmond City Council.
2:39Cindy Robinson, principal of Richmond Virtual Academy.
2:43I am here to speak in full support of the school board's budget request.
2:48A city's budget is a statement of its values.
2:51I acknowledge the proposed 257 million local allocation is a massive investment.
2:58But a record investment is only a success if it achieves the goal.
3:03Today that goal is strategic excellence, ensuring every Richmond family chooses us and every effective educator stays with us.
3:12The landscape of education in our region shifted this week.
3:17While our neighbors in Henrico are retreating and limiting their virtual options, Richmond has the opportunity to lead.
3:25By maintaining our comprehensive K-12 program, RVA becomes the premier destination in Central Virginia, perfectly positioned to become a VDOE approved multi-district online provider.
3:38Why would we shrink our vision just as our neighbors are narrowing theirs?
3:45We must dispel the myth that RVA is a cost center.
3:49In reality, we are a model of fiscal efficiency.
3:52As this council reviews a facilities report highlighting nearly 40 million in urgent deferred maintenance for our physical buildings, RVA stands as a really evolve.
4:04We educate our scholars at nearly half the cost of brick and mortar schools because we operate without that massive facility overhead.
4:12RVA is actually our primaries, our district primaries tool to reclaim the thousands of families lost to the private school market, homeschooling, or simply no shows.
4:23Every family we recruit back brings state revenue directly into Richmond's coffers.
4:29We are an align item to be cut.
4:32We are a revenue positive asset.
4:35So let's be honest about the stakes.58 mandates that this council carries the weight of our innovation.
4:43Failing to close the final $3.8 million gap is like building a world-class home and stopping before you put on the roof.
4:51Now to the council members.
5:00You are choosing to protect our veteran talent rather than exporting it to the neighbors.
5:05You are choosing our kids and their families.
5:08And I encourage the rest of our council to take a stand with us as well.
5:14Listen, the community has spoken, no gaps, no compromises.
5:20Show this region that Richmond doesn't just keep up.
5:24Fully fund RVA, fully fund RPS.
5:34Good afternoon again.
5:38Jacqueline Johnson Wilson.
5:41I'm a proud parent at Richmond Virtual Academy.
5:45I am here to encourage fully funding the needs of RPS.
5:49My son, who has complex health, sensory and behavioral challenges, is a student in RVA's intensive support class and has attended since its inception.
6:01The administration of RVA has created an amazing learning environment where parents are involved and the needs of vulnerable and disabled students are being met in their least restrictive environments.
6:14RBA has been instrumental in facilitating a virtual least restrictive environment with wonderfully skilled specialists and therapists.
6:24IEP goals are being met with meaningful and measurable progress.
6:30RBA has been identified by the VDOE as one of the divine nine schools leading the way in K-12 virtual learning as represented in this chart from VDOE.
6:43The demand for virtual learning has increased year over year.
6:48RPS should embrace this accolade and lead with RVA into the post-digital future.
6:56In addition, RVA has a 100% graduation rate and low instances of truancy.
7:04The per pupil cost at RBA is half that of in-person learning.
7:10Supporting and growing RVA also offers advantages to in-person teachers and students.
7:16Why not build on this?
7:18This is an opportunity to take advantage of built-in savings to the division and multiple advantages for students, families, and ultimately the city of Richmond.
7:30An independent audit should be conducted to confirm that funds are correctly assigned, expended in accordance with budgetary intent, and leveraged to achieve the greatest impact.
7:53I'm the instructional compliance coordinator with the Richmond Virtual Academy.
7:58I didn't expect I didn't prepare a speech.
8:17RVA is not a detriment to RPS as a whole.
8:21It is actually an asset if we work together.
8:25I wish that people would just unify and work together on this to make sure that all scholars are educated equally.
8:34Yeah, an independent audit would be awesome for RPS to have.
8:38Please consider to make sure that RP RVA is counted in y'all's budget amendments.
8:51Hello, my name is Dr.
8:54I'm I am the school counselor at RVA.
8:56And again, I still I didn't prepare anything.
8:59Um, but speaking from the heart, uh I work every day with these students, and having our school in place as a virtual option for those who have anxiety about in-person, who find themselves to state, I'm a non-traditional learner.
9:16This is not a COVID answer.
9:19This is not a budget item for COVID or out of COVID and let it go.
9:24This is a wake-up call from COVID.
9:27If we take a moment to even reflect on what's going on right now, just a moment.
9:37There's a lot going on.
9:38I don't have to list everything.
9:39So our students feel this every day.
9:42They found a place where there's safety, there's a place where they're face to face virtually with their teachers.
9:48It's not just something where it's async.
9:51Virtual Virginia is their safe place.
9:54And we all want to feel safe.
9:57It's a wake up call from what's going on now.
10:00And I just want to say, please fund RPS.
10:05And it means funding RVA.
10:13Do we have anyone else for public comment, either in person or online?
10:19Um seeing no one else in.
10:28State your name for the record, please.
10:30Okay, my name is Sandra Porti.
10:33And I currently serve as the virtual learning coordinator at the Richmond Virtual Academy.
10:39In this role, I also serve as the homebound coordinator for Richmond Public Schools.
10:44I'm here tonight to urge you to approve the full proposed RPS budget because doing so ensures that the Richmond Virtual Academy can continue serving the students who depend on it.
10:55We are a fully accredited K through 12 school with certified teachers, structured instruction, and a strong connected learning community.
11:05For many families, it provides a safe, stable, and high quality educational environment that traditional settings cannot always meet.
11:14But I also want to make one point absolutely clear.
11:17Homebound instruction cannot replace the Richmond Virtual Academy.
11:22Homebound services are temporary by design.
11:25The goal is always to return the student back to their school setting as soon as possible.
11:30Homebound instruction is also limited, often just a few hours a week, and it occurs in isolation.
11:36It cannot offer the academic rigor engagement or full curriculum that students receive at the Richmond Virtual Academy.
11:45For families who rely on the Richmond Virtual Academy model, it is not a convenience.
11:52It's actually a necessity.
12:04The community has spoken.
12:06Please fully fund RPS.
12:08Thank you for your time and consideration.
12:11I'm sorry I didn't hear your last name, but thank you for being here.
12:20Madam Vice Chair, seeing no one else, the public comment period is now closed.
12:25I'll read in the motion for Ms.
12:29Pursuant to Rule 3D, 4B of Council Rules of Procedure, Committee Chair Stephanie Lynch has requested to participate in this meeting via Microsoft Teams due to a family obligation requiring travel along the I95 corridor.
12:42The committee members present must adopt a motion to approve Lynch's participation in this meeting by letter communication means if it appears to the body that her request complies with Rule 3D of council rules of procedure.
12:55At this time, pursuant to rule 3D 4D of council's rules, is there a motion for members physically assembled approving Ms.
13:03Lynch participation in this meeting by electronic communication means?
13:09The committee is voting on the motion to approve Ms.
13:12Lynch's participation in this meeting by electronic participation means.
13:19That motion has been approved.
13:20Thank you, Madam Chair.
13:21We'll move to approval of the minutes.
13:24The minutes to be approved are for March 12th, 2026 for the Education and Human Services Standing Committee meeting held at 2 p.m.
13:31If there are no amendments or corrections, then the many minutes will stand approved as presented.
13:37Those minutes have been approved.
13:40Can we move on with boards and commissions?
13:54Pamela Nichols, Council Management Analyst.
13:57The vacancy report before you this being considered, um, consists of current and projected vacancies through August of this year.
14:07And so we're gonna dive right in, starting with the aging and disabilities advisory board.
14:12There's one vacancy for a resident who is is the current or past caregiver of a person with a disability, and we have an application from Brianne Francart.
14:24And then moving down to Lewis Ginter Botanical Garden, which this has been continued several times.
14:35Um there's one vacancy for a member of Lewis Gantter Botanical Garden.
14:39Um I will note that after several attempts, we were not able to get a confirmation from Ms.
14:46Forboda that she is a member of Lewis Ginter.
14:56You're saying one of the eligibility requirements is to be a member of and you haven't confirmed that.
15:02No, she has not confirmed that.
15:06I guess we'll continue it again until you confirm it.
15:11That's fine with me.
15:14And then moving on to the Richmond Behavioral Health Authority.
15:19There are three vacancies for individual residing or having a principal place of employment in the city.
15:25We have a reappointment application from Anika Richburg.
15:29And then an initial application from Christina Austin, Rosario Miller, and Katie Smithwick.
15:36And we did receive support for the reappointment of Ms.
15:42And also for appointment consideration from Ms.
15:46Rosar uh for Rosario Miller and Katie Schmidtwick.
15:52And then for the Rich Richmond Public Library, one vacancy.
15:56We have a reappointment application for Brent Braves, and then application from Hannah Jones.
16:02We did not receive any opposition for the reappointment.
16:05So it's our belief that the reappointment is supported.
16:09And then moving down to the Social Services Advisory Board, there's one vacancy, and we receive a number of applications.
16:16Um, one being from Elise Black, Trina Davis, Lacey Hancher, which it notes that she is currently a member of um participatory budgeting as well as city personnel board, and then Sharon Walton Darby.
16:31Um we received a response that um the board supports the appointment of any of these individuals, but I would like to note that currently the membership consists of one member from the second district, two from the fourth district, three from the fifth, one from the sixth, and one from the seventh.
16:54So I recommend that we continue this one to try to get more applications.
16:59Okay, yeah, okay, and we're gonna um continue to the next quarter, correct?
17:06So just to know, so we're continuing Lewis Ginter also to the next quarter.
17:18Um, and so would you all um support the reappointments for RBHA as far as the library, ritual library?
17:28Okay, how many how many um seventh one?
17:40No, how many members did you say were on the social services board from what which districts did you say?
17:46Um from the second, two from the fourth, three from the fifth, right?
17:51We're not doing another fifth, one from the sixth, and one from the seventh.
18:01And again, we receive support for all um four of the applicants.
18:12So we already have someone from the seventh, correct?
18:18Okay, we'll we'll go with what's her name?
18:20Uh Sharon Darby Seven.
18:38Well, then I move that we yeah, recommend those appointments as we stated.
18:43If you second us, Madam Vice Chair, just for clarity, which boards are being continued into next quarter?
18:52The um Lewis Ginter.
18:58Just the Lewis Ginter.
18:59We went with the social services one, so we're good on that.
19:01Okay, sorry about that.
19:04The committee is voting on the motion to forward the board's appointments and reappointments recommendations to council for approval as stated, and to continue consideration of applications for the Lewis Get Lewis Ginner to the committees to the May 14, 2026 meeting.
19:25Aye, Vice Chair Jones, Chair Lynch.
19:34That motion has been approved.
19:36All right, thank you.
19:37Moving on to uh I'm sorry, just for clarification, it was be moved to the next quarterly review, which is not the next month's meeting, June 11th.
19:46Um, I will have to take that, but just say the next quarter review.
19:56All right, madam chair.
19:57We have two presentations.
20:00First up is the Human Rights Commission.
20:15Good afternoon, Chair Jones.
20:17Uh Vice Chair Jones, I apologize, uh, Chair Lynch and Councilmember Breton.
20:22My name is Samantha Galena, and I'm the Commission chairwoman.
20:32Oh, oh, I'm sorry, I'm clearly correct my kids.
20:35Sorry about that, guys.
20:37We appreciate your excitement, Chair Chair Lynch.
20:41Um, my name is Samantha Gleena.
20:42I'm the Commission Chairwoman, and I'm here today with the Commission Vice Chair, Miss Emily Wolfteig.
20:56And we're here to give you a presentation today on the Human Rights Commission and all that we've been up to.
21:06Good afternoon, everyone.
21:07As Sam said, my name is Emily Wolfteich.
21:09I'm the vice chair of the Human Rights Commission.
21:11The Human Rights Commission has a deceptively simple mission to safeguard the rights of all of Richmond's citizens.
21:18We seek to protect individuals from unlawful discrimination under 13 protected categories race, color, religion, sex, pregnancy, childbirth, or related medical conditions, national origin, age, marital status, disability, sexual orientation, transgender status, or gender identity.
21:39In 2016, the Richmond City Council adopted an ordinance to examine the need for a human rights council within the city of Richmond.
21:46This looked for the scope of the Human Rights Commission and provided the council with recommendations concerning the necessity for such a commission.
21:53They found that indeed we needed one, and therefore in 2018, the Richmond City Council adopted the ordinance establishing the Human Rights Commission.
22:01The commission is comprised of three uh committees.
22:05First, we have the community engagement committee.
22:07Uh, as it might suggest, we engage with the community.
22:11Over the last year, we've expanded that engagement, including expanding our social media presence, which includes elevating community partners and participation in community events, uh, such as an extremely rainy Juneteenth from last year and RVA Pride Fest.
22:26This year we're looking to expand even further by expanding more of our online presence, implementing best practices for community engagement that we've learned from other human rights commissions, and expanding community knowledge of the fact that we exist.
22:41We also have a research and policy development committee.
22:44Over the last few years, we've talked to established rights human rights commissions in Chicago, Los Angeles, and New York, so that we can gather more information about strengthening our research approach.
22:55We began developing internal protocols.
22:57We launched a partner organization survey.
23:00We've compiled a partner directed directory, excuse me, expanded our membership from one to four members, and we'll soon be launching a community engagement survey.
23:09In February of this year, we hosted a Love for Our Community event, which brought together nonprofits partners from across the city and a number of different sectors to share what needs they have, contribute to the community survey, and provide on-the-ground perspectives that inform our work.
23:27Our final committee is the intake and investigation committee.
23:31In 2025, this committee started drafting an enforcement ordinance, which would allow the human rights commission to enforce anti-discrimination laws as provided by the Virginia Code.
23:41Um, as part of our due diligence in investigating how we would um lay out this enforcement ordinance, we met with the HRC staff and directors, as well as city attorneys from the city of Charlottesville, Alexandria and Fairfax, as well as the current deputy attorney general for the public advocacy division over at the attorney general's office.
23:59We've reviewed the Virginia Code and enforcement ordinances from other jurisdictions in order to craft our human rights um ordinance, and we've worked to refine the proposed ordinance intake and investigation process, and we propose that to our commission internally.
24:13Um we have the luck of having two attorneys on the commission that have been able to spend a significant amount of time investigating what the Virginia Code allows and provides for us.
24:24As far as inquiries that we've had thus far, um we've had many, many inquiries that come through our door and are directed over to our staff person, Miss Brittany Rose.
24:3670% of the inquiries that we have received have fallen fallen within the city's jurisdiction.
24:41Um 30% involve employment as well as 30% involve law enforcement, 35% include disability discrimination, and 24% include sex discrimination and race discrimination.
24:53And these numbers are pretty consistent with what folks are seeing on the national level as well.
25:00And we believe that all these statistics are signals that there is, in fact, a local need for an enforcement ordinance.
25:06This is just a map of what the human rights commissions look like across the Commonwealth of Virginia.
25:12So there are currently eight, with the majority of the enforcement capable ordinances being in Northern Virginia, Fairfax, Arlington, Alexandria, and Prince William.
25:23But Charlottesville recently received its own enforcement ordinance or work through it.
25:28And our goal is to be able to join those other human rights commissions and having our own enforcement ordinance consistent with the Virginia Code.
25:36And we believe that this will help all of the Richmond residents who suffer discrimination and give them a venue to offer them meaningful assistance in remedying that discrimination.
25:47To give you a bit of an update on where we are as far as enforcement ordinance development, we have been developing and enforced the enforcement ordinance consistent with the code.
25:56We have met with the mayor's office, and we are in the process of meeting with the city attorney.
26:00We believe that the work is in support of the mayor's vision of thriving and inclusive communities where everybody's rights are protected.
26:08This includes protecting the rights of immigrants, LGBTQ populations that are particularly targeted, women's reproductive rights and addressing long-standing racial inequities and health and well-being.
26:50So without the enforcement currently, what happens to these inquiries that we currently get?
26:55Yeah, that's a great question.
26:56So currently what we are doing, well, our staff member, Miss Brittany Rose, is referring those complaints to the appropriate state and federal agencies.
27:05So depending on the type of complaint, if it falls into employment, that would go over to the EEOC.
27:11If it's housing, that would go to the Department of Housing and Urban Development.
27:14And then all of these complaints would also go to the Office of the Attorney General, which is the state office that receives these complaints.
27:21As well, we we feel it's helpful to provide folks in the city that live and reside around the city with other avenues that they could access, be that sometimes health needs.
27:32So we'll we'll say that they should go to VCU.
27:35Perhaps they're having mental health problems, things like that.
27:37So other resources as well as legal aid in the area.
27:40And I know the percentage increases are here.
27:42Is there like a number that would represent an amount that would justify a level of staffing that a enforcement might require?
27:51Like do you have a target for number of inquiries?
27:53Are you hoping to get more by doing more outreach?
27:55What how many inquiries do we get and how many is a normal amount?
27:59Um, I'm not sure if I'm able to say what is a normal amount.
28:02Um I believe that through more community events, we are going to receive more inquiries.
28:08Uh, the way that we have our proposed ordinance set up, it is such that we would be able to accept an inquiry if we have the staffing capability or not.
28:16So we are looking to expand from a full-time to a uh, I'm sorry, from a part-time to a full-time staffing capability so that we would be able to address the needs.
28:24Um other commissions across the state have more, especially the enforcement commissions have more full-time staff, but we would be looking to kind of ramp up uh towards more full-time staff as capabilities and funding is able.
28:40Thank you so much for your presentation.
28:46Yeah, can you um just a quick this might be a dumb question?
28:50Um, but does the Virginia Code cover for the inform for the enforcement?
28:55Does it cover non-citizens?
28:58Or do you say like a it does?
29:01So uh so the Virginia Code covers all individuals that are residents of the Commonwealth of Virginia and all those that are protected under the Virginia Human Rights Act in uh code section 2.2-3,900.
29:15And then the specific section that we look to is 15.2 965 and 853.
29:21That gives us our power.
29:22So it would include non-citizens, anybody that would be considered a resident of this locality, so a resident of the city of Richmond, um, which I don't believe that there's some burden of proof for.
29:33Okay, so technically, so that could be our undocumented population or any other um population that's currently being targeted by iCER now.
29:43And I think that there has been obviously an increased presence of ICE in communities across Virginia, and that these human rights commissions are um are very powerful in their ability to deter discrimination against folks that that have been particularly targeted.
30:00Yeah, and that was my only other question was do you have any examples of ways that the Human Rights Commission can play a role in helping to kind of safeguard against some of the ICE activity?
30:16I know that's really tricky, but any any recent examples that you can think of being awesome.
30:22I mean, in my own experience as an attorney, I've seen several instances in which individuals have been terminated from their employment because of ICE activity.
30:34Perhaps they weren't taken away, but that it interrupted their employment and then they were they were terminated as a result, or instances in their housing as well that has been impacted, and perhaps landlords not wanting to rent to individuals because of uh potentially undocumented status.
30:53And those are instances, in fact, of discrimination under the Virginia Human Rights Act that have been remedied in other localities.
30:59I believe Charlottesville in particular, I'm thinking of one case where they've been able to successfully keep somebody housed.
31:08That's really encouraging to hear.
31:10And hopefully we get that ordinance out soon.
31:15Thank you, Chairman.
31:18Um I have a quick question, and mine's is more internal, so maybe this might be an administration question.
31:23I'm just wondering how does this commission overlap with like I see an ESA in the audience?
31:29How does this overlap with that department and the work that she's doing?
31:33I'm big on making sure we're not duplicating efforts.
31:35And then since you are moving towards enforcement, but um, how would how does that actually affect us as the city?
31:45Well, I'm happy to answer that.
31:46So um Anisa, as our equity and inclusion advisor comes, attends all of our meetings, assists throughout our process.
31:54I think she offers a very unique and important lens to the work that we do.
31:58Um, and she certainly assists Miss Brittany Rose, our uh part-time staff person.
32:02Without Anisa Smith, we wouldn't be able to do the work that we do.
32:06She's been particularly helpful, I think, in addressing how we are going to get into the community and how we are going to outreach to all these folks so that they're actually able to know who we are and what we do.
32:18So we've been she's been tremendously helpful to this commission's work.
32:21Thank you, because that was about to be my next question, because I think as an outside commission, you got to build community trust.
32:27And in not having that, I was wondering how we partner in on our side to make sure that it's not I mean, I'm glad to see the commission back as well.
32:36I mean, I know we've had talks about it and there's been a lot of concern about what's going on with the human rights commission.
32:42So happy to see it back in action, but um, even more happy to know that you are taking your time and being intentional about it because there are a lot of challenges amongst our community communities, and you know, oddly enough, we just left a meeting with Congresswoman McClellan on this very topic.
32:58And so wanting to be sensitive and really, you know, making sure that we are um approaching the communities with care.
33:06So thank you so much for that.
33:07And um I appreciate all the work that you are doing.
33:10Thank you, Chairwoman.
33:11Just wanted to add something on that point.
33:13Part of the surveys that we're doing now are not only to gather data about how people are experiencing human rights within the city of Richmond, uh, and then being able to provide that data back to them so that they're able to use that in their own research, but also as a way to show that we are invested in the communities, that we do care what they think, um, and as a way for them to be able to know that we are a resource to reach out to if they have anything they'd like to say.
33:40And one last question.
33:41You said I've thought I read it.
33:42You said you move from four to um how many commission members?
33:47As of our last meeting, we are fully staffed, so all 12 members.
33:52And we can find that.
33:53Where can we find that at the C Who's on?
33:55We can get that from you back in if you all right.
34:04All right, we have up next the Richmond and Hangra Health District uh presentation.
34:16Hello, while our slides are going up.
34:19Um, good afternoon, uh, Vice Chair Jones.
34:21Um, Chair Lynch um virtually, and uh uh Councilmember Breton.
34:26Very nice to um get a chance to speak with you this afternoon.
34:29My name is Elaine Perry.
34:30I'm the director of the Richmond and Henrico Health Districts, and I have with me here today our Chief Operations Officer, Deanna Crottner.
34:38So, what we're gonna do is just give you a very brief overview of the amazing public worth work that we do at RHHD.
34:45So, back in about 2018, the Richmond City Health District and the Henrico County Health District joined together under shared leadership.
34:54So we are still separate entities with separate budgets, but our leadership is shared, which I'll show more in a minute.
35:01And a lot of our work is shared because as you can imagine in public health, issues don't stop at a border.
35:08And so a lot of the things that we deal with communical diseases, social determinants of health are shared among, you know, among many localities, but it really does make sense for us to address them together in this area.
35:19You can see our mission, vision, and values up there.
35:22As always, what we're trying to do is protect health, champion equity, and partner to address local needs.
35:27We know that we absolutely cannot do this independently as a local health district.
35:31And so in collaboration with our localities, our governments, and with community partners, we are attempting to move forward the public health in our area.
35:42And so right now we have a one main location.
35:45Our headquarters are on 400 East Carrey Street.
35:48We have a physical presence in the research, we have six resource centers in the public housing developments listed up there.
35:56We had a seventh location that is, oh, sorry, I'm not sure what happened to our slides.
36:02Did I do that or did I know how to get it back?
36:09But we have had to relocate that because of some facilities issues.
36:13And so we are currently operating on the South Side, outside of our South Side WIC location.
36:21And I apologize, I can't seem to get back.
36:27So we have two women, infants, and children's locations, WIC locations, Southside Plaza.
36:31So our Southside community health workers are working out of that location, as well as other places.
36:36And then we moved our WIC location from our headquarters to the community hospital again to be closer to the community that they serve.
36:42We have about a hundred, we have 115 physicians, 15 of which are vacant.
36:47Those vacancies are spread across our different departments.
36:51We have more of a focus right now on vacancies, unfortunately, in environmental health, and in our nursing staff, but they do span many of the departments, and we are very actively working to recruit those, but it is difficult to get nurses, regardless of where you are.
37:06So that's one of the areas of focus we have.
37:09And then we do still have one wage and five contract staff members.
37:13So this is our leadership team.
37:15And again, these are people who are working by and large across both Richmond and Henrico.
37:21And you can see the areas covered there in terms of environmental health, population health, community programs, nursing, and then our business office.
37:29And so again, these are people who work to cover and support public health in both jurisdictions.
37:36So when we talk about what we're doing in public health, the model that we are using that, you know, hopefully is the most helpful and easiest to explain, is looking at some foundational public health services.
37:48So this is a model that's put up by the public health accreditation board or FAB, and Virginia is moving to more fully embrace this.
37:57And at the Virginia Department of Health level, we're developing a core services model, which is based on these, right?
38:03So there's five basic public area public health services that no matter where you live, you should have access to these services.
38:10Some of them are provided by us, some of them are provided by our colleagues in our central office here in Richmond.
38:15But you can see they fall under communical disease control, chronic disease and injury prevention, environmental health, maternal child and family health, and that we would call access to and linkage with clinical care.
38:26So public health in Virginia, by and large, we are not clinical providers.
38:31We're definitely not primary care providers.
38:32So the clinical services that we provide are limited to certain communical diseases, including sexually transmitted diseases and tuberculosis.
38:40We do some family planning, but but by and large, our role is not to be the direct providers of clinical care, but to help connect people who need it to appropriate sources of care.
38:49And so that's where that terminology there.
38:51And then underneath that and supporting all of that work are some foundational capabilities.
38:56And so again, this is something that some of these things we need help with from our from our central office and from our community, but some of the things that we provide directly.
39:03And so an example of this emergency preparedness response.
39:06We have a staff member that that is their work to do.
39:09We have dedicated communications team, whereas some of the work that we do more in terms of policy development support, for example, a lot of that work we are we are relying on our central office to do.
39:21So that's again just a very, very quick overview of a way that we look at the work that we're doing in the city of Richmond.
39:28So these are just a few metrics that we had provided for the budget documentation and WIC average monthly participation.
39:35I do want to highlight WIC because it is such an important service.
39:38Um and we were very fortunate to be able to this is so WIC is 100% federal funding, right?
39:43So this is something it's a federal program in Virginia.
39:46The WIC services are provided through local health departments.
39:49We are so fortunate that this remained these services remained completely uninterrupted during the federal shutdown.
39:56Um, and and which we were very grateful for, and and you know, we're concerned, but that was something that continued unabated during that time period.
40:03And so, you know, again, we have a very robust WIC program in the city of Richmond and work hard to maintain it as such.
40:09Um, environmental health food inspections, this is another area where we are really supporting the thriving restaurant community in the city of Richmond, you know, helping ensure that when we all eat out at the amazing restaurants here, um, that the food we're getting, cold food is cold, hot food is hot, and everything is served in a way to try and keep our communical disease folks a little less busy.
40:29So, and then the last metric to share is just you know, we do have a family planning, a sexually transmitted infection clinics.
40:35Um, and which, you know, again, we do tend to serve more as um safety net providers in that space, but it is really important that we make sure that people have access you know across the city to be able to receive these important services.
40:52So in public health, as with all things, we really try to make sure that we are we are uh not only following the data, but but that we're getting the data from the people that we are serving most.
41:02And so um a widely accepted public health practice is to do a community health assessment, followed up by acute community health improvement plans.
41:10So we call them CHAS and CHIPS.
41:12And back in 2024, uh, we did the first joint um community health, so the first joint CHA for Richmond and Henrico.
41:21Um, and we did break the we can look at things, you know, by the two different different localities, but we did have um robust participation from from both of those localities.
41:31And what the reason we do this is so public health shouldn't be about what I think we should be doing or what Deanna or whatever thinks we should do be doing.
41:38Some of the things we have to do, right, that were mandated by code, but either state code or local ordinance to do, but really we want to make sure that where we can, we're doing provide the services that our community wide wants, right?
41:49And we're we're addressing the needs that are important to them.
41:52And so again, small slide, not going to read all the way through it.
41:55Um, our full CHA, and um, well, the draft is SIP is still in draft, but is available on our website and could also be provided as needed.
42:05And so the important takeaway from all this is that when we talk to our communities, the the communities spoke, right, and came back to us and said the three most important concerns that they have in this space are mental health, and in that we are including substance use disorder, community safety and violence prevention, and chronic diseases.
42:25Um, and so again, I think that those are surprised to to none of us that because these are things that are really important.
42:31And we look at um not just morbidity, but mortality, chronic disease, um, substance use disorder, and then community safety and violence prevention are three areas that uh you know really make sense for us to focus on.
42:44And so the next step after you do a CHA, you need to do a chip.
42:47You don't ask people what they it was important to them without then following up.
42:51And so our community health improvement plan is still under development.
42:54It's in close to draft or close to final draft.
42:57And each of those three areas I mentioned chronic disease, mental health, community safety, have had work groups, they have objectives and goals, um, and each of those goals then have um action plans that go along with them.
43:07And so, again, in the interest of my rapidly dwindling time, I won't read through all of these, but you know, again, not just saying, okay, chronic disease, that's huge.
43:15So, what are we specifically going to do?
43:16And in chronic disease, a lot of attention is going to be focused on blood pressure monitoring efforts, and nutrition access.
43:23So, heart disease, helping prevent the complications of heart disease, and then expanding access to nutritious food service.
43:30Again, you can see mental health.
43:31We do have a focus on youth, but not just youth.
43:34Um, and then um with uh community safety looking both at domestic violence and a personal violence and then reducing alcohol-related motor vehicle deaths and hospitalizations.
43:45All right, so at that point, I'm gonna go ahead and turn it over to Deanna to talk about budget.
43:50Great, good afternoon.
43:51Happy to be here to talk through these next three slides to finish this up.
43:55Um, right here, you can see our fiscal year uh 26 budget.
43:58Those top two lines is are the funds that the city contributes uh to the work that we do in the community.
44:04That first line is um by our local government agreement, the city is required to match 34% what the general fund gives us, and that's what that first amount is.
44:13That second uh line there is the 100% local funds.
44:16That's what we call like the above and beyond the what you give us past that that match level to support the community efforts that we do.
44:24Um the bottom part of this graph is the rest of the funds we bring in.
44:28So we've got the state general fund and that amount.
44:31Um, the second line is actual federal and other grants we receive.
44:35The majority of that money is our women, infants, and children program, um, but we do have some other grants that come in.
44:41And that last line is our estimated revenue, and those revenues come in from a combination of our clinical fees, our environmental health fees, as well as our birth and death certificates that we collect.
44:51Um, it's important to note that out of that grand total on an annual basis, probably 85% of those dollars get budgeted towards our salary staffing.
45:04And then this line breaks down that 100% above and beyond funds there.
45:09So you can see that while the majority of this funding goes to our resource centers that are out in the communities, there are a number of other programs that these funds support to help us deliver services in the community.
45:21Adolescent health programs, uh communicable disease and radiology services, and a lot of that is our tuberculosis programming, um, violence prevention, lead and rabies, housing advocacy, and tobacco cessation.
45:34And then this last slide here actually takes our funding and um breaks it down across those foundation foundational, that foundational model that Dr.
45:44So you know, 41% of that covers that bottom layer of that model and the rest of the funding kind of is broken down um across all of those services across the top of that model.
45:56Uh you can see that I like a flag here that access to linkage and clinical care.
46:00While it looks really small, it's not really there, it's a hard to tease out the the combination efforts here, right?
46:06So communicable disease, chronic disease, and maternal child health all provide some access and linkage to back care.
46:13Um, but as a primary flag, um that's why that appears to be so low.
46:17Um we this is relatively new model, and as we continue to work in this model, we'll do better at kind of teasing out those different parts.
46:24But um, yeah, that's all I have for you regarding budget, but happy to take any questions.
46:34Um I saw those three chips, and I was wondering um what kinds of metrics or goals they will be measured against.
46:41So the um specific metrics and goals for our chip are still in draft form.
46:46I mean, I can speak to again, they they they are definitely much more granular than you know, blood pressure and whatever.
46:51So some examples um specifically working with there's um part of the the chronic disease one is gonna be working with feedmore in order to provide um heart uh healthy education to staff at feedmore.
47:04And so some of what we'll look at there is in terms of you know, did it happen, how often did it happen, you know, what additional um uh events are they able to do?
47:12Um, blood pressure monitoring is again, some of it is is training, training the trainer, and then how to expand, you know, how often you're able to expand blood pressure monitoring throughout the community.
47:22And what's the timeline for like all those plans?
47:24That's the thing that's this year or multi-years long.
47:26Oh, it's multi-year.
47:28Um, so in general, we talk about a three-year time plan for for the chips.
47:33Um sometimes it's a little bit more, a little bit less, but yeah, our the the goals are written in a way that they would be accomplished over this you know, three-year time period here.
47:43So 25 is a lot of the planning, 26 and 727 is implementation.
47:47I do think though that there's some things that'll be into 28 and the but the planning is happening now.
47:52So if I was gonna say I would love to see what the metrics are, those would be ready this year.
47:56But the actual outcomes are what I'm gonna do.
47:58Yeah, the full the draft, like I said, it's in draft.
48:00It's getting closer and closer.
48:02But yes, and that will be available.
48:03We can definitely make sure we make it available, and it will also be um, we post those on our website so they're you know publicly available so people can see what we're trying to accomplish.
48:12And my last one is I see all these um different types of local funds or balance prevention and housing advocacy and house and health.
48:18Um, which of these are kind would you say are generating kind of the best like great returns?
48:23Like, oh yeah, the funding into this is is really outperforming.
48:29Sorry, I was trying to get back to there so we could so obviously we think all of our programs are very important.
48:34Um I do want I will I will highlight the resource centers.
48:37Um, that's a very interesting um, you know, just as an example of a program that truly is blended funding.
48:43So we have the city has been very generous from continuing to fund our resource centers.
48:48Um, and and so there's 100% city funding we get from there.
48:51We do have some state funding in terms of we have we provide support from that from our co-op.
48:56And we are still getting some local philanthropy support for those.
48:59And so that's a situation where the city is investing X amount of dollars, but there are definitely additional dollars that are coming towards that.
49:05And and you know, these are community health workers in each of these resource centers.
49:09So they're connecting, providing connections in the community.
49:12Um, and and you know, again, I don't, I'll be honest, you I don't have capacity to do ROI any of this.
49:18I know that's not what you're asking for, but in general, you know, we we do point to that as an example.
49:22Um, you know, again, you look at communal disease services, you invest in a certain amount of money that then is preventing disease from spreading further, right?
49:29So if if I see somebody who has an infectious disease and I find out from them, you know, where they may have gotten it from and to prevent that future um other infections, you are saving, you know, substantial amount of money by preventing future infections.
49:42But even social returns, you know, are also valuable.
49:47Chair Liz, did you have any questions?
50:00Thank you so much for the work and for the presentation.
50:04Um, I'm gonna be telling my age.
50:06You took me back here a little bit when you were talking about WIC.
50:09And I remember growing up, we had a little health clinic in our neighborhood.
50:15And when I first had my son, we went in there and got his little like immunization card.
50:19He still got his yellow card to this day.
50:21Um, but it just was the importance of like living in public housing and having access to those clinics and being able to not because healthcare has changed so much.
50:30And so having that in a community was so powerful.
50:34And I know a lot of my friends that I grew up, what we really took advantage of at our parents because they didn't have it, right?
50:40So, and then um the fact that you have a large um goal to continue WIC is so so important, specifically in today's climate with food injustice and you know, a lot of folks not even having access.
50:54I wanted to ask about this.
50:56Um I know the Southwood Center has been closed and it says that we are looking for you looking for another space.
51:04Are we any are we in talks about that anyway?
51:07I'm looking at DCA or Pope anyway, particularly in the night.
51:13So yeah, I love the hemo about that.
51:16Yeah, I I don't know if you wanted to so um yes, we um we would love to be um able to share space in the um city building in Southside Plaza.
51:27Okay, and so that's something I know there's still uh to with to uh work to be done, but um as again as of now, we are they are co-located with our our Southside Plaza WIC location, but um we will be putting on the state side, they'll be putting out an RFP.
51:42Um, I'm not sure exactly when if we have a date on that, but to request that.
51:46But our our hope would be that that would be something that then um we could partner with the city on to be co-located in that space.
51:53Yeah, I was thinking a community center.
51:57Um yeah, I was thinking the Southside Community Center could be a location because again, for what you offered at Southwood, I mean, it's a large community, and we do have a lot of stuff already at Southside Plaza.
52:09I'm gonna have to start like in the injected because we skip it right past us and going down.
52:15Well, and my understanding, the so we one of the things, so all right, so um most of the resource centers are small enough that they don't really have the capacity, and we're not doing direct clinical services and all them.
52:27And and there really does isn't as much the need because of the geography.
52:30The South Side WIC or the South Side Resource Center was an exception to that.
52:35We were doing a we have a pretty robust family planning and STI clinic there.
52:40And so that's so part of the challenge is that we need a space where we can provide clinics, and that's so that's not just you know an office and desk, right?
52:47There's certain plumbing you have to have a certain capacity that you have to have.
52:50And so um that would be the the issue there is we need something that is either fit for clinic or can be retrofitted to to allow clinic uh space.
53:00I think we got somebody that can help us with that.
53:05But um, yeah, I think this is I I um I have one other question as it related to um your you asked about the chip.
53:17Um I can't remember what my question was.
53:20And if I remember, I'll send it to the DCAO and then we'll follow up.
53:23But thank you so much.
53:24Thank you for the work that you're doing.
53:25Um, and hopefully, you know, when we uh we'll see you at Southside Community Center.
53:32Thank you so much for your time.
53:33I appreciate your questions.
53:35Uh Chair Lynch, did you have any questions?
53:43Uh and we will hear from our uh fabulous DCAO, uh, Miss Amy Popovich with updates.
53:55Good afternoon, Vice Chair Jones, maybe Chair Lynch, Councilman Bretton.
54:01Uh all right, a couple of exciting announcements, but uh on the heels of our human rights commission presentation, wanted to make sure you all knew that our one and only Anisa Smith was appointed by Governor Spanberger to be on our state LGBTQ advisory board.
54:15Um we'll have her voice and her presentation um and the city's presence on that board.
54:20Uh and one of the things that she's done is launched the first city's um LGBTQ community-based survey uh that will go out next week on the 20th through the Office of Equity and Inclusion.
54:30So once it comes out, we'll want to share it and would love for you all to help share that and promote that so we can really understand and know what our LGBTQ uh community experiences here in the city.
54:42Also, um I mentioned this a bit on Monday, but wanted to make sure you all knew we are aligning our registration for elementary school after school programming.
54:50Um, to our knowledge, that has never happened.
54:52That the YMCA and the City of Richmond's Parks and Rec program will um register together on May 1st.
55:00So that information has already come out through RPS Direct.
55:02And so we're not only partnering on that same day, but we're also partnering in communication.
55:07So RPS and the city are saying everybody register.
55:12And then that announcement will come out.
55:14And additionally, there'll be 10% of slots saved for newly enrolled children and rising kindergartners at the beginning of school because we know that there are folks who move or there are new to school kindergartners whose families might not have been aware of school after school registration on May 1st, for example, just to really make sure we're increasing access that any family who wants to have access to our after school programming does.
55:38So excited about that.
55:40And then lastly, just a bit about our Office of Aging and Disability Services.
55:44We've got a big spring fling event happening on Thursday, the 23rd at TB Smith.
55:49And then also, although you appointed one advisory slot today, we do still have a few more slots on our advisory council for that.
55:56So we'd love to partner with you all on recruitments for that advisory board.
56:03Thank you so much for that update.
56:13So thank you, Madam Chair, Madam Clerk, and all those that came to speak.
56:16As a brief recap of today's meeting, the committee heard presentations from the Richmond and Henry Coff Districts and the Human Rights Commission.
56:24From those presentations and discussions, I recorded the following action item.
56:28Councilmember Jones, you requested a list of human rights commission's members.
56:48At this time, the anticipated agenda includes an update from the future of workforce commission and a report out from DNCS on the inclement weather shelter review.
56:57That concludes my report.
57:01I lost a good one over there.
57:08So without if there's any, um if there isn't any further business, this meeting is adjourned.