Rockville Historic District Commission Meeting Summary - October 16, 2025
Rockville Historic District Commission Meeting Summary - October 16, 2025
The Historic District Commission (HDC) of Rockville convened for its August 2025 meeting to address routine administrative matters, review proposed alterations to the King Farm Farmstead, and discuss zoning ordinance revisions. The meeting featured reports from local organizations, public comments regarding the urgency of reviewing the King Farm master plan, and the approval of several Certificates of Approval. A significant portion of the agenda was dedicated to strategic planning for the FY2027 budget and formulating a unified response to the Mayor and Council regarding upcoming historic preservation proposals.
Consent Calendar
- Minutes Approval: The commission unanimously approved the minutes from the September 18, 2025, meeting (Motion passed 5-0).
Public Comments & Testimony
- Mark Bersheila (Resident, College Garden Civic Association): Expressed full support for the redevelopment of the College Garden combined properties, noting that neighbors previously supported upzoning to incentivize this. Expressed strong opposition to the rushed adoption of the King Farm Farmstead master plan, stating the document is too vast to process in a week and historically contextualizes are vastly understated. Position: Advocated for a formal statement by the HDC recommending that more time be needed and that the Planning Commission and HDC be consulted prior to adoption.
- Nancy Picard (Executive Director, Peerless Rockville): Stated full support for the enthusiasm surrounding the King Farm report but expressed deep concern that the commission was not included in the development process and was given only six days to review a thousands-page document before the Mayor and Council's consideration. Position: Strongly urged the HDC to request more time for review and to assert a role in the process "early and often" rather than just in the final review.
Discussion Items
- King Farm Farmstead Master Plan: Staff clarified that while the HDC does not have a quasi-judicial role in the adoption of the master plan itself (which is a facility vision plan), the commission must be involved in any subsequent alteration proposals. Commissioners expressed concern that the master plan effectively solidified the project before the HDC was fully briefed. Commissioner Seth Dimbo and Commissioner Peter Falseman noted the discrepancy between the presentation given to the HDC and the much larger document provided to Mayor and Council, arguing that historic preservation is being undervalued. Commissioner Anita Neal Powell proposed drafting a letter to the Mayor and Council asking for a postponement of the adoption to allow for proper review by the commission and the public.
- Zoning Ordinance Rewrite: Staff reported that Mayor and Council directed modifications to the owner consent provision for historic designation. The new proposal suggests differentiating between an owner who is silent versus one who actively dissents, potentially requiring a unanimous HDC vote only in cases of an "adamant no" rather than silence, though staff are still drafting the exact language.
- Commissioner's Strategic Priorities and Budget: Commissioners discussed requests for the FY2027 budget, including: funding for the installation of additional plaques and signage; updating brochures for the African American and "Lost Rockville" histories; and developing educational platforms or partnerships with colleges to engage younger generations in historic preservation. Commissioner Mercy Singate and Commissioner Michael Goldfinger suggested leveraging digital tools like QR codes in hotels to promote history to visitors, supported by Commissioner Anita Neal Powell's suggestion to utilize existing economic development partnerships rather than creating new brochures from scratch.
- Chestnut Lodge Sanitarium (Old Business): Commissioner Michael Goldfinger provided a historical overview of the site, noting the main building burned down in 2007 and was demolished. Staff confirmed that two historical markers currently exist on the site, one for the main building and one for the outbuildings.
Key Outcomes
- Motion Passed (5-0): The commission will draft and send a letter to the Mayor and Council requesting a postponement of the King Farm Farmstead master plan adoption to allow more time for review and commission involvement.
- Motion Passed (5-0): Approved Certificate of Approval (2026-145-COA) for 21 Martins Lane to install 36 solar panels on the roof. (Project Sponsor: Frank Stubachak; Staff Recommendation: Meets Secretary of Interior Standards).
- Motion Passed (5-0): Approved Certificate of Approval (2026-176-COA) for 301 Anderson Avenue to install an EV charger. (Project Sponsor: Akari Electric; Staff Recommendation: Meets Secretary of Interior Standards).
- Motion Passed (5-0): Recommended against historic designation for the demolition proposal at 15100 Frederick Road (College Plaza) as the structure does not meet HDC criteria for historic or architectural significance. (Applicant: College Plaza Partners).
- Administrative: Staff announced a special virtual meeting for October 30, 2025, to adjudicate three pending Certificates of Approval.
- Staff Update: A community budget survey for FY2027 is currently open; staff will submit a request for a consultant to conduct a city-wide historic survey as an enhancement to the budget.
Meeting Transcript
Welcome. Meeting information. Good evening and welcome to the City of Rockville District Historic District Commission meeting number 08-2025. Today is Thursday, October 16th, 2025. I am HDC Chair, Anita Neal Powell. I am joined by my fellow commissioners, Seth Dimbo, Peter Falseman, Michael Goldfinger, Commissioner Mercy Singate. Well, that was last month. Okay. And Commissioner Mercy Singate. We're also joined by city staff, Sheila Fazieri, Preservation Planner who is online, Cynthia Walters, Deputy City Attorney, and Katie Gerbis, Comprehensive Planning Manager. The historic district commissions are conducting hybrid meetings. Applicants and the public may join the meeting virtually via WebEx or in person in the Mayor and Council Chambers at Rockville City Hall at 111 Maryland Avenue. The public is invited to participate in person or virtually via WebEx. The virtual meetings can be viewed on Rockville 11, Channel 11 on County Cable, and live streaming at WWW. Rockville MD.gov slash Rockville 11. Each meeting is also available for viewing soon after the meeting is held at WWW. Rockville MD.gov slash video on demand. The first item on the agenda is committee organization report. Peerless Rockville, is there anyone here from Peerless Rockville. Hello all. Thank you for having me here this evening. And one of the first things is we have had some grants to do research and some context study on the Asian American Pacific Islander community here in Rockville. Specifically, the Chinese and the Taiwanese population will be our first kind of area we'd like to look into. We've had these grants for a while and it's kind of been on hold. And you may or may not be aware that this population amounts to about 23% of Rockville's entire population and as much as one fourth of the town center population. Yet we have very little kind of contextual information or history from this group of people, or really even the immigration patterns and development. So we did put out a call for researchers to assist us with this process. So we hope that that will move forward and we can begin more work on this exciting project. In addition to that, and an event we have uh hosted this past month was a talk by a local historian, Susan Soderbergh. She has a new book out called My Name is Not Tom. Um and it's a biography on Josiah Henson. Um the talk was very well attended, um, and people had a lot of good follow-up questions. It was very interesting presentation, and I learned some new things that I did not know before. Um, so I would recommend um following up on that. In addition, our collections have accepted several donations, including several paintings by a local artist and a collection of photographs from a former residence dating to his childhood in Rockville in the 1960s and 70s, to include lots of images, um, but I believe there's some from various Memorial Day parades over the year, which you would think we would have tons of those, and we really do not. So uh just a reminder that we do um do collections for Rockville history. Uh lastly, we've been spending a good bit of time reviewing um and following the master plan process for the King Farm property as well as the zoning ordinance review, particularly as it pertains to the historic preservation ordinance for your rent. So that's what I have for tonight. Thank you. Thank you very much. Okay, the next organization report on the agenda is the Lincoln Park Historical Foundation. Had an opportunity to attend the Maryland Nonprofits Annual Conference. I attended a session on bridging the gap, Capital Stat, Maryland Historical Trust Tax Credit and Resources. It's a really good section, and I'm glad I was able to attend. And I like the opportunity to learn more about how they would deal with nonprofit organizations. This time is set aside for members of the public who want to comment on any non-agenda item. Is anyone from the public waiting to comment on any non item on the agenda? Hello. Please state your name for the record. Yes.
openpublica.com