Sacramento County Board of Supervisors Meeting - July 8, 2025
I call to order this meeting of the Sacramento County Board of Supervisors for Tuesday, July
8th, 2025.
Madam Clerk, will you please call the roll and establish a quorum?
Yes.
Good morning.
Supervisors Desmond?
Here.
Rodriguez?
Here.
Hume?
Here.
Cerner?
Here.
And you have a quorum.
And let the record reflect that Supervisor Kennedy is not present today.
This meeting of the Sacramento County Board of Supervisors is live and recorded in closed
captioning.
It is cable cast on Metro Cable 14, the local government affairs channel, on the Comcast and
direct TVU versus cable systems.
It is also live streamed at metro14live.saccounty.gov.
And today's meeting will be repeated Friday, July 11th at 6 p.m. on channel 14 and viewed
at youtube.com forward slash metro cable 14.
The Board of Supervisors fosters public engagement during the meeting and encourages public participation,
civility and use of courteous language.
The Board does not condone the use of profanity, vulgar language, gestures or other inappropriate
behavior including personal attacks or threats directed towards any meeting participant.
Seating is limited and available on a first come, first serve basis.
Each speaker will be given two minutes to make a public comment and are limited to making
one comment per agenda or off agenda item.
Please be mindful of the public comment procedures to avoid being interrupted while making your comment.
Comments made by the public during Board of Supervisors meetings may include information
that could be inaccurate or misleading, particularly concerning topics related to public health,
voter registrations and elections.
The County of Sacramento does not endorse or validate the accuracy of public statements
made during these open public forums.
The recordings are shared to provide transparency and access to the proceedings of public meetings.
To make a comment in person, please fill out a speaker request form and hand it to clerk staff.
The chairperson will open public comments for each agenda or off agenda item and direct the
clerk to call the name of each speaker.
When the clerk calls your name, please come to the podium and make your comment.
If a speaker is unavailable to make a comment prior to the closing of public comments, the
speaker waves their request to speak and the clerk will file the speaker request form in the record.
The clerk will manage the timer and allow each speaker two minutes to make a comment.
Off agenda public comments will take place for a maximum of 30 minutes and the remainder of the
agenda comments will take place at the conclusion of the time matters in the afternoon.
You may also send written comments by email to boardclerk at saccounty.gov and your comment
will be routed to the board and filed in the meeting record.
If you need an accommodation pursuant to the Americans with Disabilities Act or for medical
or other reasons, please see clerk staff for assistance or contact the clerk's office
at 916-874-5451 or by email at boardclerk at saccounty.gov.
Thank you in advance for your courtesy and understanding of the meeting procedures.
Very good.
Thank you, Madam Clerk.
Supervisor Rodriguez, will you please do us the honor of leading us in the pledge this morning?
Yes.
Great. Thank you again.
I want to welcome everyone to today's board proceedings and just a note for those who
may be wondering why I am participating and sharing the board meeting today remotely.
It is because I am respecting the fact that we have a couple of our bargaining units that
are striking and picketing today.
And as a matter of regular practice, during my tenure on the board, I have made it very clear
to all parties that I do not cross picket lines.
So I am attempting to respect that and will continue not to cross any picket lines for their duration.
So that is why, while it may be a little more clumsy and awkward than normal, trying to chair a meeting
remotely, we are going to attempt to do it that way today.
And of course, I think we all are twitching a little bit, hearkening back to COVID.
That gave us plenty of practice.
So I am going to reach back in my memory to 2020 when I had to do it for half a year.
So I am sure we will get through it fine with the help of the clerk and others.
Madam Clerk, do you have any other announcements before we get started?
I do not.
All right.
Very good.
Then if there is nothing further, let's go to our first item.
Yes, that would be public comments relating to matters not on the posted agenda.
And Madam Clerk, because I have a little difficulty seeing folks at the podium at the moment, I'm
going to ask you if you can monitor the clock.
And again, friendly reminder to everyone, we do have a 2 minute limit on speakers at the
podium and that's there to ensure that everyone who wishes to address the board has that opportunity
to do so, especially given a full, very full agenda today.
But Madam Clerk, if you could monitor the clock and respectfully prompt speakers when their time
has passed, I would greatly appreciate that.
Okay.
Thank you, sir.
I will do that.
So our first speaker is Ryan Harris.
Hey, good morning.
It's a nice title for you, David.
Looks good on you, sir.
I didn't know all these people was going to be here.
I probably would have had something better to say and inform them about.
But as long as Ted is still their director, I don't know.
Probably can be in here a lot more, you guys.
Hard to trust somebody that's not even faithful to a wife yet.
You know, that's beside the point.
Came here to let you guys know that last time during the George Floyd protests, I was protesting
and did the, you know, hands up, peacefully protesting and was still hit by an officer with his little
stick, probably because he was shorter than me.
He did feel kind of short.
But nonetheless, I'm just letting you guys know we're peacefully protesting.
You guys are telling us, encouraging us to peacefully protest.
And yet, a lot of the peaceful people are being target practice for the police officers.
They're not shooting the ones that are going crazy.
You guys have seen it in the news.
They're shooting some of the people that are on the news.
So I'm just here to let you guys know that if I get peacefully protested and I get shot
while peacefully protesting, I'm going to shoot back.
Because you guys are encouraging me to do this, which means that it is safe for me to
do so.
And if you guys are encouraging me to do something, I shouldn't get shot, right?
So let's find out.
And to the officers that are shooting at random, random people, and officers that are watching
them do it, you guys better take better aim.
That's about all I got to say, is that if I get shot peacefully protesting, I will shoot
back.
Let me yield this time.
You guys got a lot of people.
Thank you.
Ronald Owens.
Good morning.
On April 14th, 2022, Department of Health and Human Services Secretary Harvey Becerra said
this regarding the COVID-19 vaccines.
We know these vaccines are killing people of color, blacks, Latinos, indigenous people
at about two times the rate of white Americans.
This information has been shared with your colleagues already, Supervisor Rodriguez.
And I'm following up by sharing this with you because this is the first time you've heard
this.
It's the first time that people in this audience have heard this.
My former employer, the California Department of Public Health, knew this back in April of
2022.
My name is Ronald Owens, Jr.
I was a public information officer.
Since notifying this board and the 57 other county boards of supervisors throughout California,
California, I've made 38 in-board appearances.
I've traveled throughout California, informing your colleagues throughout the state.
I've got 19 more to go.
What CDPH should have done in April of 2022.
I've also made public comment four times at the California Board of Pharmacy as well as
oral comment for CDC as well as the FDA.
Look, you have a statutory responsibility to direct your health officer to start promoting,
administering, distributing COVID-19 vaccines.
At minimum, your residents should have been informed that the COVID-19 vaccines are not safe
to be able to do.
I had a conversation with Riverside County Sheriff Chad Bianco a couple weeks ago.
He said since the COVID-19 vaccines, he has deputies in their 20s sustaining strokes and heart
attacks.
I have not broached this subject and my 38 other boarders to advise their appearances,
but I wrote a book that came out early 2024 called Muzzled Truth, how the California Department
of Public Health rejected COVID-19 treatment and vaccine health risk warnings.
Thank you.
And I am going to present a copy of this book to each of you, and I hope you guys will take
the time to read it.
Thank you for your time.
Thank you for your comments.
So I'll leave it here and give it to you the clerk of the board.
Yes, you can just leave it here with me.
Ted Samara?
Mr. Samara?
UTE signs up!
Good morning, Board of Supervisors.
My name is Ted Samara.
As you know, the Executive Director of United Public Employees.
And today we are initiating our rights under the law on a one-day strike.
This is a position that the Board of Supervisors put us in.
The County Exec and his negotiation team put us in.
You have on the table right now unlivable wage for our members.
Coupled with, as I've explained to you all before, you want to strip us our ability to negotiate
healthcare and to tell you no, we are not going to allow you to raise our healthcare.
You have other proposals on the table that are going to restrict our rights to strike,
to negotiate classification studies prior to going to civil service, to contract out our bargaining
work, and our members are saying enough is enough.
You need to do more.
You all got yours in 2023, and you know how much you got.
And you gave it all to your directors in those work sites.
And they got theirs.
And they all make over $200,000.
And you want to cut and gut our members' healthcare and offer them 2.8% or 3% raise when some of our folks cannot even afford rents?
You just approved a stipend because of these hard to fill county exec management jobs and give them what, a $15,000, $20,000, $25,000 stipend to buy a house?
Our members can't afford to pay rent.
Right.
Right.
Right.
They take care of families that are your constituents.
They take care of those most in need.
And it's not a lot that they're asking from you all to take care of them, provide them a livable wage, hands off our benefits, and do not strip our protected rights we fought for.
You want to limit our members' ability to grieve family members we fought hard for during the pandemic to put on bereavement leave?
Oh, because they're just in-laws?
Well, you tell that to our spouses.
Right.
Woo!
You tell that to our elders!
The families should be ashamed of themselves.
You want to talk about a family?
If this is how you treat your family, oh, it's a sad day.
Right.
It's a sad day.
Right.
We're willing to negotiate, but you have to come right.
Right.
Get it to go.
Hands off our rights.
Right.
Right.
Right.
Right.
Right.
Right.
Right.
Right.
Right.
Right.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Deborah Rocha.
Deborah Rocha.
If you would like to form a line.
If you see your name and you want to get in that order, that would be great.
Good morning.
That's a tough act to follow.
Thank you.
I just wanted to make a couple of points.
After I checked this morning, the national rate of inflation is 3.28%.
The county is offering us 2.8%.
So by definition, that is not a cost of living increase.
That is below the cost of inflation.
So we still can't afford rent.
We still can't afford to buy eggs.
Some of us are single parents working multiple jobs.
And I was just wondering if the board would be willing to share what percentage raise they were given.
Yeah, please share.
Just so we can compare.
No?
Okay.
Thank you.
Vanessa?
Good morning to you all.
My name is Vanessa.
I am a mother of two small children.
I'm here for the same reason why we're all here, letting our voices be heard.
And I just hope that we find favor with all of you to hear us.
It's been hard.
It's a struggle.
I'm here for my kids to support them.
Some of you might have children or not, but inflation is high, wages are low, and we're falling farther and further behind.
That's it.
Thank you.
Yolanda?
Yolanda?
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Hello.
Good morning.
I want to come to you over here.
I want to speak on, first I'm going to come forth with the Bible emphasis's importance of forgiveness, both from God and towards others.
Ephesians 432 encourages to be compassionate, forgiving, tenderhearted, meaning empathetic and compassionate, and forgive freely and readily as God has forgiven you.
Now, I'm coming before you because you're hearing the lack of income.
I've been in the county since 2000, and I have not moved but $7 in 20 years.
That's ridiculous.
I'm getting ready to retire.
I can't even afford to retire, but I'm getting out of the county of Sacramento employment and make more money on the outside.
That's sad.
And then you want to take away our health care?
No.
Stop it.
Stop it.
Think about us.
We're the lowest paying, and we put out the hardest work.
I worked in the jail through the COVID.
I want to talk about correctional pay.
Can you take yourself behind the secure door?
We have two people in the recreation department on the eighth floor dealing with murderers, rapers, and of the least.
My God.
With no weapon.
With no weapon.
And we're asking for a measly 5%.
The doctors, the nurses, they get 10, 15 now.
Okay?
But we're not popping a pill, and we're not giving a shot.
But we're there among them.
They could easily snatch us up.
Who's going to come and rescue us?
Who's going to tell our family, oh, we're sorry?
Please, I forgive you.
Good morning.
My name is Jolinda Broadway, and I work for Behavioral Health Services in the Quality Management Department.
So quality management speaks for itself.
You have to have quality services.
We have clients with mental health issues.
They need somebody to talk to.
I'm in the admin office, but I still get those phone calls.
I need to get them to the correct people.
Nobody else will take the time.
They've been transferred three, four, five times.
I'm there every day.
Through COVID, I was there every day as my office was empty.
I got the phone calls.
I was willing to do that.
With that said, I've taken pride in my employment with the county for 19 years.
I have worked in the Sheriff's Civil Division during the recession.
I had people upset because their paychecks were being taken away.
I had to calm them down.
I had to fix the problem with their employer who was taking out three, four, five garnishments out of their paycheck.
They came home with nothing.
The law is they can only have one garnishment at a time.
I took the time.
I would like for you to take the time to look at me as a person with diabetes.
I'm a brittle diabetic, and you're messing with my health care.
You're scaring me.
You want me to pay more or lose my health care, and I can't afford that.
But I can't afford to pay more because I'm not getting a raise.
I haven't gotten a substantial raise in 19 years.
I need you to hear me, to hear us.
We need a livable wage, 5% minimum, and we need our health care.
Please do not mess with the health care.
Thank you for your time.
Thank you, Cooper.
Good morning.
Just wanted to speak my voice.
I'm a nine-year department veteran of DTAC 311.
If you don't know, we are 365, 24-7, all holidays.
Our demand for us to be there, and I feel that the amount of work that we do for all county departments,
we should be compensated for that.
We're still trying to take care of our families, and we do a lot of work for the county.
Thank you.
Russ?
I'm Russ Olson.
I'm a decorated war vet.
I could stand here in a room full of soldiers and tell you I'm probably the most.
I did 27 months in Iraq.
I graduated high school when I was 15 and a half.
I have two college degrees.
And I decided I wanted to give up all that money and just, you know, do something good for the community.
So now I work here for the county.
I do, like, support-level investigative work at the district attorney.
So the jail's full of, like, I have 8,000 dockets worth of people that I have a lot of time.
All it takes is me.
That's enough for the lawyer to walk into the court and put one of those guys in there.
I don't know.
I just want to make enough money to, like, not be living with my mom right now.
So, you know, that's all I really want.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Good morning.
Thomas Delma, also with DTEC 311 for the last 10 years.
And within those 10 years, I went from working a three-person bunker in the branch center, which
not many of you know existed.
And within that bunker was the single-county hard line.
So if an emergency, such as an earthquake, mass casualty incident, terrorist threat, we
would be the only hard line that would be able to communicate with the county, such as
Office of Emergency Services, Environmental Management, other law enforcement agencies, including
the fire department.
311 has been set as a customer service portal for the county.
When I started, we were at the comm center.
Now we are 311.
Nothing has changed except for the workload that we're getting and the amount of calls that
we're fielding for the county, including emergency, non-emergency services.
They're claiming we're non-emergency, but every day we field animal control emergencies.
We field active Department of Transportation emergencies.
And we even field active sewer, water, and drainage emergencies.
They may not be emergencies to the board or to our directors, but they're emergencies to
the people that call us.
And with that, I think we should be compensated.
The last 10 years, I haven't gotten more than a 2% raise.
I'm basically making the same amount of money that I made 10 years ago when I committed myself
to being in this department that I'm making now, along with everybody else that's sitting
here.
We're not getting paid enough.
Nobody's getting paid enough.
It's disrespectful, and the county needs to do better.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Now, first things first, I'm the last person that should be standing up here, and I don't
want to have to be.
But there's a reason I am.
It's because a lot of people are afraid to speak out and share their piece about what's
going on within the county walls, within their own units, within their supervisors, playing
games and doing silly stuff.
I got people that aren't even in the office 24-7 while their workers are, but they're getting
calls about, hey, why aren't you in the office?
I see you on the camera.
Why are you watching the camera?
We're playing games that don't need to be played with people that don't need the games
played on them.
What we need to have is a little attention in the finance department.
If you've got to cut the middle weight out, do that.
My branch alone, I've been in the same department, the same unit for seven years.
In that department, my admin branch has bloated three times its size already in just one year.
Okay?
Look into that and figure out why, because I can tell you right now, the work has not
changed, but the people and the faces are all brand new faces moving up past me as I
watch them.
Okay?
It's very important that you actually start paying attention to what these people and
administrators are doing because they are doing shit behind your back you are not paying
attention to.
Find it.
It's not that hard.
I can do that.
I can do the math right now.
If you can't afford to give us a percentage range, maybe it's because my admin branch is
bloated by $225,000.
How about turn down the heat on the admin and give the workers some money?
We're going to get it done.
I just got there at the airport yesterday having a conversation with one of our negotiators trying
to tell me that the reason why they need more people at the airport is because they got too
many people on leave of admins.
We got too many people that aren't showing up to work.
That's not the problem.
Those people are underpaid for a job that is three jobs.
They're not paid for one job.
They're paid for three.
They need to be working for three.
Okay?
They got the 911, the 311, and the airport dispatch.
Okay?
You look at any other county, they're getting paid twice with those people off.
Look into this, please.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Good morning.
My name is Pamela Page.
I work for in-home support services.
I stand before you today as someone with extensive public service experience and someone who values
the work that I do very deeply.
I've been on from 911 dispatch.
I was actually a sheriff deputy.
I worked at the post office.
I have experience in public service and what it takes to serve the most vulnerable residents
of this county.
Every day I help seniors, people with disabilities, and individuals with complex needs remain safe
in their home and be supported in that home care.
Because I believe in the community in which I was born and raised, North Highlands all the
way.
And because I believe in the values that the county says that they stand for, equity, inclusion,
accountability, and service.
But right now I don't feel those values being displayed by this board or anyone in charge.
And despite the central nature of our work, we are not receiving a fair pay.
We're not receiving fair benefits.
We are being asked to do more with far less resources.
We are also falling further behind, like many people have said, from other counties.
Other counties are far more ahead of us, but we're larger than them and it doesn't make
sense.
But when the county asks us to embody compassion and service, we do.
When the county asks us to support vulnerable residents, we show up.
When we are asked for fair compensation and a livable wage, sustainable benefits, and the
ability to provide for our family, we're met with silence and delay and denial.
That is not equity, that is not inclusion, and that is not accountability.
We are essential.
We are committed.
And we are asking for you to live up to the values that you claim to stand for.
You invest in the people who carry out those values for you every day within the community
that you're supposed to serve.
Thank you.
Good morning.
My name is Cynthia Picard.
I did not know I was going to be speaking today, so I'm so nervous.
But I work for California Children's Service, DHHS.
We service children with special needs.
I've been with the county since 2012.
If we did not do what we do, then children that have special needs would not get the services
that they need.
They would not get the durable medical equipment that they need.
We are very essential.
We have, I want to say, about four positions that have been cut.
Our case loads are very heavy.
Every year, I think we get maybe a 3% or 4% raise.
I think 5% is BS.
I think we should get more.
At least 7%.
At least 7%.
Inflation is high.
I cannot afford to carry my children on my medical because it's like $300 or something
dollars out of each check.
So I can only carry myself.
Thank God that their father is able to carry them.
But then I don't have enough money to pay my rent.
I'm 48 years old.
Been with the county since 2012.
I should not have to work two jobs to make ends meet.
When I get my check, I don't have enough to pay my rent.
So I'm trying to scrounge up money to pay my rent.
Then I have to pay a late fee, $75 on top of that.
And then I have to find, I have to figure out how I'm going to make it, how I'm going to feed
my children for the next two weeks.
How I'm going to pay this bill and pay that bill.
So it's like I can't get ahead.
I just, I can't get ahead for nothing.
We're top heavy at work.
I not only have to deal with not making enough money, but then I have to be worried about
being harassed at work because nothing's being done about management.
So I have to deal with that too.
So it's a lot and it puts stress on us as well.
You know, so we're tired.
We're tired.
And we know how much the board of supervisors got over 30% raise.
Supervisors and managers, I think about a 14% raise.
What about us?
Don't you guys care about us?
Don't you have compassion?
Don't, don't you care about us?
We, we do a lot.
We do a lot.
We are, we are the face for the county.
Miss Cynthia, do you mind?
And you guys sit up here and you make all this money.
Miss Cynthia, will you please wrap up your comments?
And I understand that I respect it, but at least care about your, your workers.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Diana?
Good morning.
Diana T. Corona.
And I work in the Department of Health and Human Services.
Also for the California Children's Service Program.
That's my coworker that just stepped up here today.
Health Service Coordinator.
I can guarantee that you guys do not even, are not even familiar with that title.
Health Service Coordinator is a position that is below the median.
It was one of the positions that was presented to the county, informed that we are below the median and we are being denied being at the median.
UPE presented the county with about 25 positions that are below the median and the county came back with five.
Five.
Five. One of which health service coordinator is not one of those five.
Just like my fellow member, I've been working for the county for 23 years and I've gotten under $7 raised in those 23 years.
And at this point, I am wondering why I spent time going to school, going to college, getting a degree.
I'm 48 years old and we've got 18 year olds that are making what I make.
Fresh out of high school and they are making what I make.
And you guys are trying to take away our health care.
When I first started working for the county, I did not even have to pay.
Now I'm paying $300 for my health care.
When is it going to stop?
We are overworked. We are underpaid. In our office, we are discriminated against.
We are harassed every day. Every single day.
And even so, we are there for these fragile children that we serve in our community.
During COVID, we were there. We were all there and we're still here.
We are.
Hi, my name is Ashley Keller. I work for the Public Defender's Office.
I was not planning to speak today, but I will just, I don't know facts, I don't know numbers,
but what I do know is that I can't afford anything anymore.
I can't barely afford the gas to get here.
I know that I sit here and I look at you guys with your great suits and your Starbucks coffee.
And you're sitting here with a water cup. It doesn't matter, right?
Because I know that you got Starbucks on the way in.
And I know that you sat there and came in in your nice cars.
Because I watched you this morning to go to your parking.
You know what I don't, is I can't afford to pay to park here.
I can't afford to pay my rent.
I can't afford the suit and probably the tie that you have on.
I know that I'm sitting here and I'm speaking.
I don't have children, I'll be honest with you.
But I know that I have co-workers that have children that can't strike today because they can't afford to take it off.
And I'm speaking for them.
They can't afford to take one day off.
What?
A hundred dollars.
Do you know what a hundred dollars is to us?
A lot.
A lot of money.
A lot.
And we're asking you to give us fair wages.
We're sitting here looking at Panda Express who makes $30 an hour.
Panda Express.
Your lunch that you go and have every day probably go out because you don't bring your lunch.
Or maybe you're eating healthy.
We can't afford to eat healthy because guess what?
The dollar menu is $1.25 and we barely can afford that.
We're asking you to think about the people that are beneath you that are running your papers.
And taking your phone calls.
And checking your emails and scheduling your stuff.
That's us.
Because we are those people.
And you sit here and you look at us and it's probably going in one ear and out the other because you're looking at budgets.
We're not here for budgets.
We're here because we are the real people.
We're the people that make your job possible.
We sit here and we watch everything that you do and we wish that we can be you.
But guess what?
We're the ones running your errands.
You need to think about these things when you're taking these cuts and going, oh, okay, we'll mess with your benefits.
Guess what?
All the people that have mental health issues and things like that, you're messing with those benefits.
We need those.
Please think about that.
When you go and you go into your meeting, you talk about your budget.
Right.
Right.
Right.
Mr. Chair, that concludes your off agenda comments in that 30 minute window.
We need more time.
Okay.
Thank you, Madam Clerk.
So do we have other speakers though on off agenda?
We have three.
Okay.
We'll go ahead and take those three and then close public comment on off agenda items for the day.
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Barbara?
Barbara?
I'm asking for Barbara.
Barbara R.
That's all that we have.
Okay.
Let's leave Barbara's name there and we'll move on to Evan.
First off, I want to thank those who already spoke before me.
I was very moved by a lot of your comments.
My name is Evan Houston.
I've been a civil servant employed with the county department of finance for over nine years
as an office specialist and promoted to a senior office specialist here with the department
of finance.
As an efficient, diligent, accurate, and dedicated employee in that time, I have taken on ever-increasing
demands of work and responsibilities to the point where I'm often working out of class.
I am not alone in this.
I have always been very loyal to my responsibilities and supported the county's stated goals of serving
the public with honesty and adherence to rules and regulations mandated by the county
board and the state.
That I am here in person voicing my perspective on behalf of these good people is perhaps
a little bit out of character being that I tend to leave my employees and tell them to
get the work done that's expected of them and be on task.
To their chagrin sometimes when they feel like they're on task all the time.
And I see that.
However, I have found that the county's unfair tactics of inhibiting the union's rights,
stifling voices, and the deceptive presentation of the county's proposal is caused to join
this strike.
I have received flyers and postcards promising increased wages if I canceled my union memberships.
I have witnessed how email notifications of the union's goals submitted to myself and employees
that work with me have been stripped from those email boxes mysteriously vanishing.
I'm not a conspiracy theorist but it's a bit obvious that higher-ups of the county are
attempting to stifle voices that should be heard.
These are not examples of fair practices that the county should uphold to allow their own
working community to adequately represent themselves and gain the essential wages in our current climate.
Thank you.
Thank you.
We're here again.
We shouldn't be.
I'm not even going to be sweet this time and show you guys any type of mercy, compassion,
or even respect because you don't give it to us.
Thank you for all of my family that is here.
I appreciate it.
My family.
When I say my family, I ain't just talking about the ones that bore out of me.
I ain't talking about my siblings, my mama.
I'm talking about every family member here.
These are the ones I hearted.
These are the families you people don't respect.
You want to show on your passing to the ones who voted you in your seats.
You even got people who have the nerve to take time off and we don't get it.
You're denying it to us.
You got someone on Zoom.
Oh, thank you so much.
You respect us, right?
You don't respect us at all.
How many phone calls and applications are y'all doing right now?
You got the community waiting on us.
We're the front line.
We make you look good.
We make your managers and supervisors look good.
You can't pay us.
You want to take our health care.
You even want to take our right right now to strike.
You want to get rid of our union.
Come on.
What do you want to give us?
Nothing.
Not a damn thing.
But you expect us to continue the workload.
When's the last time you say the homeless is your people?
You here for homeless.
When's the last time you got there and fed them?
When's the last time you go ahead and got some drinks, clothes?
We do that daily.
My second job, because I got to have one.
Right.
I take care of the homeless.
Thank you.
What are you guys going to do for us?
We want livable wages.
Right.
We want our health care.
We want to be able to take care of our kids.
You, you, you, and the ones who are missing, you decide this.
Right.
You decide this.
Right.
Make some right decisions.
Right.
Because, again, you got voted in those seats.
Right.
We want folks to ask us out.
Right.
Is Barbara in the room?
UPE!
UPE! UPE! UPE! UPE! UPE! UPE! UPE! UPE! UPE! UPE! UPE!
Can you hear me?
Madam Clerk?
Yes.
Can you hear us?
Okay. Does that conclude our off agenda speaker?
going to check for Miss Barbara one more time.
Okay.
Barbara!
I think that wraps it up,
Mr. Chair.
Okay, very good.
Let's go ahead and move to our next item.
Okay, so our next item
is item two. This is a service award
recognizing John Kozitsa for his
35 years of service with Sacramento
County.
35 years!
That's all!
Did you get paid, sir?
Did you get paid?
Did you get paid, sir?
Did you want to retire?
Actually,
actually, Madam Clerk, let's
take a 10-minute
recess so we can let
cameras clear and give people
time to
get prepared for the next time.
We're in recess for 10 minutes.
Okay.
This is all right to strike!
Right.
We kind of like our email yesterday.
Order this meeting of the Sacramento
County Board of Supervisors for
Tuesday,
July 8th,
2025. Madam Clerk, will you please
call the roll and reestablish a quorum?
Yes. Supervisors Desmond,
Rodriguez,
Hume,
Cerna.
Here.
You have a quorum with those members present.
I'm excited, please.
Thank you.
Item 2 is the
Service Award recognizing
John Kozitsa for his
35 years of service with
Sacramento County.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Good morning, Board.
My name is Siobhan Katari.
I'm Deputy County Executive for
Social Services, and I'm happy to be
with you today to present John Kozitsa
with his Service Award for 35 years.
John has dedicated more than 35 years
of exemplary service to Sacramento County.
His journey began in 1988 as an on-call
typist clerk with the Public Works
Administration.
Just a year later, he earned his
bachelor's degree of business
administration and accounting,
marking the start of a career
rooted in both purpose and
professional growth.
John quickly transitioned into a
student intern role with accounting
and fiscal services for the Public
Works Division, where he began
building the foundation for a
remarkable career in public service.
Over the years, John has worn many
hats, serving as personnel clerk,
real property appraiser, senior
administrative analyst, and accounting
manager in the county's executive
office.
His trajectory continued upward when he
joined the IHSS Public Authority as the
administrative services officer, and in
2018, he was promoted to the executive
director position for the Public
Authority.
Most recently, John graduated with his
master's degree in business
administration from Sac State.
However, John's impact extends far
beyond the positions he has held with
the county.
He's known for generously sharing his
love of barbecue with his team, creating
community through good food and
camaraderie.
He also serves as a valued instructor
for the Leadership Development
Academy, which he helps cultivate the next
generation of county leaders.
One of John's professors actually sent a quote in
about him, which I just wanted to read, which
is, John is a living example of truly being the
change in all he does.
As a proud father of three, John exemplifies
dedication, hard work, and a deep commitment
to service.
Today, we honor not only his impressive career, but
also the countless lives that he has touched
along the way.
John, thank you for your unwavering commitment to
Sacramento County, and congratulations on this
well-deserved service award.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Very much appreciate it.
And for taking the time out.
And thank everybody else for coming.
I appreciate that.
Did not expect this.
Let me start with a classic beginning.
Once upon a time, there was a young man pursuing
his educational dreams.
He received his first paycheck from the county
as a temporary typist clerk on call in December 1987
during college winter break.
He later lived through four economic downturns,
nine county executives, nine different county positions,
was almost laid off in 1992 prior to the birth of his
first child, and later was actually laid off during the
Great Recession, returning to the county service two years
later, as Siobhan had mentioned, and still stands before you
with the tenacity and the drive to do the best possible job,
just like on day one.
All during these experiences, I still raised a family,
had a rich, successful accounting career, finished my MBA.
It was 30 years later.
I took a semester sabbatical in 1991 and met a lot of wonderful people
along the way, and some not so much.
All of these wonderful people actually made this moment possible.
It wouldn't, I wouldn't be here without them.
As such, this 35-year service award rightfully belongs to them.
There are too many wonderful supporters in my life to name.
However, a few come to mind.
Mr. Pete, my high school chemistry teacher,
who filled a void and helped me apply to college,
without whom my path would be very different.
Gail, we used to call her mother Gail sometimes,
she was always promoting employment with the county
and telling me about the job announcements, the job openings,
continuously encouraging me to apply.
She was a very wise lady for us.
And then, years later, came Katie, a major influence in my career.
She saw my potential and nurtured it wherever she could,
even if I didn't know any better, which sometimes I resisted.
She demonstrated the phrase, got your back,
when presented with an unsafe work environment incident,
putting her full authority behind a resolution,
something I will never forget.
To this day, I think about what she would do
when I have to make an organizational decision.
And then, there is Ms. Marjorie Albrecht,
who brings such a humanistic approach to decision-making
that individuals who promote out of our office
want to return and work for our office once again.
Or, they stay working for office
and sometimes even avoid taking other jobs.
Marjorie has been a key element in our office culture chain since 2019.
Without her selfless support,
I can't imagine any of the accomplishments happening with our office
to include our customer service quality.
And showing me how all of this knowledge and experience comes together
is Dr. Jennifer Norman.
I met her when our office began its culture change in 2018,
when I needed help the most.
Her knowledge, insight, and continuous encouragement
to persevere was invaluable in our continuous efforts
leading toward the work environment we have today.
At this point in my career,
I am focused on transitioning operations for the future
and looking for opportunities to mentor the next generation.
This moment was 35 years and a whole lot of wonderful people in the making.
On behalf of everyone who made this moment possible,
and that includes you.
Thank you.
Thank you, John.
And I'll certainly look to my colleagues here in a moment
to give them an opportunity if they'd like to say a few words.
But I've certainly had the good fortune to get to know you over these last 15 years
that we've had the opportunity to work together
and certainly appreciated your dedication to your craft
as someone who I think exemplifies public service
and never has taken for granted any aspect of the charge
that you've been given to do what you do for the people of Sacramento County.
And I really do and have come to respect you very, very much.
And 35 years is a long time to do anything.
And so, again, it's just remarkable that you're amongst many individuals
who have been before this board in years and decades past
that appear so that we can rightfully celebrate their decades of service.
But, again, I think it speaks volumes to the fact that there are these rare gems
that are out there that materializes as human beings that wish to give of themselves
as long as they do and as intensely as they do for the benefit of others.
And in this case, we celebrate that today for over three decades of service to this county.
So thank you and congratulations on this notable and remarkable milestone.
So with that, I would look to other of my colleagues to see if they have anything they'd like to share.
Mr. Chair, through the chair, thank you.
John, I won't repeat everything Supervisor Cerna said, but I agree.
35 years is remarkable.
Thank you for your service.
One thing Siobhan neglected to mention, which you've heard me comment on,
is you have among the top three beards in Sacramento County.
So thank you for that as well.
Thank you.
Any other members of the board?
Yeah, I do.
John, I just want to say I didn't have the pleasure of working with you,
but I do recognize and celebrate your 35 years of service.
Oftentimes when people know that I am a county supervisor, I hear so many positive things,
especially those that are on the front line about their work with the county and how the county does so many things so well.
But 35 years is definitely an impressive career, and I just want to thank you for your time with the county.
I can try for another 35.
Okay.
Something tells me you can do it, John.
With your help.
Of course.
I just would like to add on to my colleagues and say what an exemplary career,
and I just really appreciate the humility with which you stand at that podium,
and you give thanks to the folks that helped shape you, helped shape your career,
and helped do the work that set you on this path.
And I want to commend you for going back to school and getting your master's so late in your career.
It just shows me that you're obviously a man of deep respect and learning and continuous improvement.
So whatever your next chapter brings, best of luck and Godspeed to you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you to my colleagues always good words that great words that come from my,
my,
my colleagues and John,
I think you can tell that we all have a great respect for you and I'm sure.
if supervisor Kennedy were here and he would pile on as well.
So,
uh,
Madam clerk,
do we have anyone signed up to speak on this matter?
No,
sir.
Not on that item.
Okay.
Very good.
Thank you again,
John.
Okay.
So moving on to item three.
Moving on to item three is the 2025 state fair presentation.
Thank you.
And before,
uh,
we hear from,
uh,
Tom,
uh,
I just need to know,
do I have a goodie bag at the dais for me?
Yeah.
Or is that forthcoming?
I have that for you,
Mr.
Okay.
All right.
Very good.
Good morning.
My name is Tom Martinez and I've had the pleasure of presenting in front of this
board for several years.
This is my third state fair,
almost three years as CEO,
about 10 years at Cal expo.
Uh,
chair,
um,
with your approval,
I'm going to give a little bit of a background on our relationship and what Cal expo and
the state fair mean to be here in Sacramento.
So,
cause I think I have several,
I have several new supervisors that I,
I think I would enjoy sharing that with.
First of all,
Tom Martinez,
CEO of Cal expo and the California state fair.
We're in fair season.
We're about three days from the 171st anniversary of the California state fair.
It's the largest event in Northern California.
It's been the largest event annually in Northern California.
Sorry.
I know it's a little loud here,
but I'm going to try to just work through this at times.
I will,
we will hire on board about 2000 workers this summer,
not to mention the hundreds of vendors that come here from out of town.
They stay in hotels.
They eat at restaurants.
They stay here for the 17 day duration of the 17 straight day fair.
Sorry,
if you know this already,
I just wanted to make sure I shared this with you.
Um,
and this year we are proud of the fact that we have all 58 counties participating
here in Sacramento at the California state fair.
Um,
I thought I'd mentioned a couple of things that people often forget.
We're the only fair in state law.
The California state fair is the only fair in the state's constitution.
We're required to do one thing annually.
Put on the annual state fair.
The rest of what we do changes with the business model.
It has changed over 170 years.
The last 57 of which at Cal expo.
That same law requires the state fair to take place in Sacramento.
As to when,
it's not clear.
In other words,
we don't have to have the state fair in the summer in July.
And I say that because I get that question quite often.
And while the weather might be really nice today,
it often changes in the month of July.
Last year was the,
we had more 100 degree days than any year on record.
Yet we still had a successful state fair and we did have an increase in
attendance.
And I mentioned those things because over the course of what my remainder of my
remarks,
you may have other questions,
but I wanted to make sure you were aware that we are required to be in
Sacramento at Cal expo.
And that probably I don't see ever changing.
However,
we probably will change the month or the timeframe of the state fair in the near
future.
I wanted to just take a moment to recognize David,
David Villanueva,
your County executive.
And here's why ever since we've had storms prior to his arrival,
we've had some fires,
we've had flooding,
we've had things take place COVID for example,
and we developed this relationship with the County of Sacramento.
I want you guys to know something that often gets lost when there's a storm on
the horizon and they start talking about storm of the decade or,
you know,
you know,
a hundred year storm,
that kind of stuff.
David and I begin talking in advance.
And I say this to you because in your darkest days of emergencies,
I just want you to know that Cal expo will be here for you and your employees
for whatever that may be.
We lately,
the last five years it's changed.
And the reason I mentioned all this is the state fair has,
has been together for,
I mentioned 171 years.
The only times that the state fair has not taken place were pandemic and world war.
So with that as a backdrop,
I just wanted you to know David and I remained in contact.
And as we get fires,
we get floods.
And in some,
some occasions when things happen in the parkway,
our people need assistance or a place to be moved to.
We come to your assistance and we appreciate that relationship.
And it'll be here to stay.
And especially under my tenure,
I'll make sure it's grown.
I'm going to add something here.
Since I was here last year,
we've increased all the air conditioning in our buildings.
In other words,
all eight buildings at expo center,
all have two new air conditioning units.
All of our biggest buildings,
all have new chillers,
our air conditioning units,
the pavilion building where the animals are does not,
but obviously the cold air would just go right out.
The reason I mentioned that is when there was flooding in the South part of
the County,
a lot of those,
a lot of those families were locked in and they were removed and they moved
to Cal expo.
But I only had two buildings at the time that had heat.
And one of those buildings kind of crashed in the heat,
but it has now been reversed.
And now we have all our buildings.
So in the future,
we're ready for whatever,
whatever may come.
I just wanted to highlight that and acknowledge David for his help on that.
Um,
this year,
there's two changes to the state fair,
two major changes,
horse racing,
170 years.
This is the first year we will not have horse racing.
It's not that be cause we didn't want to have horse racing.
There are just no more horses in the North.
When golden gate fields closed in Albany near Oakland,
there a lot of the horses had to move.
They had to make a decision,
Oregon,
Washington,
Arizona,
the majority of them split.
Almost all of them have split.
So in doing so we have a void enough about,
um,
enough about that.
But I wanted you to know there's no more horse racing.
The second one is in modernizing the state fair,
we recognize that it's hot in July.
Yes.
So as we look to change the time of year,
the state fair will take place.
We've also changed our hours a bit.
We've noticed it was hot.
And so we are now closed Monday through Thursday.
And we open up at four o'clock instead of opening up at 10,
we open up at four o'clock.
So Monday through Thursday,
we'll be open up till four and we'll be open a little later.
The reason why we've acknowledged lately,
all our research and data have indicated to us that we become a night fair,
largely.
We now have DJ stages that go on past 11 o'clock into midnight.
So we stay open as long as the families want to stay here.
What,
what the,
what the doors are open.
We remain open.
We have not increased our costs.
We've kept our costs down.
So we've had to be,
do more with less.
Interesting to know Cal Expo is a state agency.
Yet we are an unfunded state agency.
Just want you to know that.
We're keeping our prices where they're at so that families can participate and
come to the state fair and celebrate the best of California.
And this,
the,
um,
aside from the changes of the time,
Monday through Thursday,
I wanted to go back to something that was important.
As,
as I stood here in front of this board three years ago,
or yeah,
about three years ago,
I wanted to invest in three particular areas.
I wanted to make sure the fair was safe.
I wanted to make sure people felt safe when they came to the fair,
whether it be our clear bag policy,
uh,
our,
our unaccompanied minor policy.
The fair is now set the example for the other fairs in the nation.
They now follow our protocols and our policies.
And we believe we are one of the,
if not the safest fair in the nation.
Second one,
I wanted to invest in the next generation of fair goers,
our children.
As such,
I've tried to provide more programming for children,
for families with children.
And I've moved this programming indoors into our newly air conditioned buildings
so that the moms and families didn't have to be out in the heat when it was hot.
So a lot of our programming at the hottest parts of the day would be,
moved indoors.
Something to acknowledge.
I think people don't necessarily see that.
We've also,
believe it or not,
we've also in doing that,
have increased our,
our children's programming in multiple parts of the state fair.
Um,
so it's not just the children's carnival area.
The,
the third part of this three little,
three slow leg here is we've increased our investment into the big name
entertainment.
Most people have caught this.
Our state fair concert lineups have not been what they used to be.
Fact,
I put about over two,
two and a quarter million dollars in our big name concert entertainment on,
in the Toyota concert series on the big sky casino stage.
If you haven't seen our lineup,
it opens up on opening night with ludicrous.
I want to share something with you.
Shortly,
shortly after ludicrous came out,
he sold out without one commercial,
one,
one paid advertisement,
nothing sold out like that.
So if that wasn't bananas,
I wanted you guys to know we have another huge act on the same night.
We have a special ticketed event at our,
at heart health park.
You might've heard of him.
It's featuring Sacramento States,
new basketball general manager,
Shaquille O'Neal.
He will be performing as his DJ persona,
DJ diesel.
So the rest of the concert series,
the Toyota concert series on the sky river casino stage goes through and ends on
the,
on the last night with in vogue.
There are so many acts I could go into most,
many of which are already sold out.
So whether you're a rock and roll person and you like Tesla,
I'm looking at Phil,
but he's not looking at me.
All right,
Phil Tesla.
We also have country artists like the brothers Osborne for those.
No.
Okay.
And we also have one of my favorites,
Cypress Hill.
I know not the normal fair manager,
right?
Cause I'm not necessarily a fair manager.
I come from a different place.
I come from a different place than I think.
Hopefully when my records done,
people will see that what I've done to the state fair is I've tried to modernize
it.
The state fair has agricultural roots.
Every state's fair has an agricultural roots and we're the number one agricultural state
in the nation.
So I pay homage to all of that.
The animals will still be there.
The white garden will still be there.
The carnival rides will still be there and there'll be entertainment and there'll be jugglers,
all that.
But I've,
I've tried to bring into existence a new model,
which brings something for everybody.
And for a lot of children of color and people of color,
I've tried to bring in entertainment and children's programming that I feel they will be excited about.
We have a new exhibit.
It's for Phil Cerna.
It's called the California Lowrider Exhibit as well.
I've heard a little bird told me about this yesterday.
We have,
we have Cal,
we have lowrider cars from throughout California from San Diego through Chico and these California lowrider clubs and have their cars,
their prize possessions featured in one of our air conditioned buildings.
And I hope that you have an opportunity to see this.
And yes,
whatever you're into,
the California state fair is the perfect place to find it from family fun,
free exhibits that both educate and entertain to fair staples like hypnotist,
art shows,
acrobatics,
and animals,
all of which are free and included with the paid admission.
Right outside of your doors here,
there's a special going on.
It's for your county employees.
If you notice that if you buy tickets pre-sale,
there's $16,
which is discounted.
But right here,
right now,
those tickets are $12 for your county employees.
So I encourage.
So,
as I said,
we've tried to keep our prices down for everybody.
So all the families can come and celebrate with us.
So I'm going to leave my comments with you here is come join us and celebrate the best of California beginning this Friday through the 27th of July.
Thank you.
Great.
Thank you,
Tom.
If there are no questions or.
Let me just,
let me just start by saying,
I always appreciate seeing you before the board and before you,
you always were alongside your predecessor in person to give us in the public,
a pretty detailed accounting of what's in store for the,
for the fair ahead.
this summer.
And,
um,
uh,
I,
uh,
appreciate the fact you've,
um,
um,
emphasized some of the changes,
uh,
that we're going to see.
And,
uh,
I'm glad to know that,
uh,
like yourself,
Mr.
Cool,
calm and collected that we're going to have,
uh,
uh,
some better AC to join some of the exhibit halls and whatnot.
Um,
and,
uh,
yeah,
I'm,
I'm really,
uh,
looking forward to the whole experience this year and,
uh,
uh,
the low rider exhibit,
uh,
in particular,
um,
is something that I think is,
uh,
long overdue.
Um,
it's a very prominent part of California culture and,
um,
uh,
it's,
it's good to hear that,
uh,
that's finally being,
uh,
acknowledged rightfully in,
in our,
um,
state fair at our state fair.
Hopefully,
hopefully it's the first of,
uh,
many years to come where that's the case.
So I'll just put my,
uh,
two cents in for that.
Um,
and as you've mentioned,
uh,
relative to our CEO,
I,
I think,
our entire board feels the same way that we've enjoyed a terrific partnership with,
with the state fair,
uh,
over the years,
you know,
we've,
um,
uh,
especially during COVID where the state fair property itself was a fundamentally critical,
uh,
part of our ability to help,
uh,
protect,
uh,
the public's health,
uh,
with drive through vaccinations and,
um,
um,
and checking.
So,
um,
again,
just want to perpetually thank,
um,
you and,
and,
uh,
state fair,
uh,
leadership for,
uh,
that chapter of our,
of our connection and,
um,
uh,
appreciate everything you've shared with us again here today.
So,
uh,
vice chair Rodriguez,
were you about to chime in?
Yeah,
I was,
um,
Tom,
I just want to say thank you for the work that you do.
Um,
I can tell you that there has been an immediate,
um,
difference in the state fair over the last three years,
um,
or there were concerns prior to that about safety,
but I have been to the state fair the past three years and I have enjoyed it,
walked around.
I love the exhibits.
I'm really glad to see that you are investing in the next generation of goers because it is fun.
It is fun.
And there's so many things to do for different people.
And,
um,
I did notice a difference even in the concerts,
um,
that have been presented at the state fair.
I'm also a big Cypress Hill fan.
So,
you know,
I look forward to enjoying that.
And also,
um,
seeing that you're bringing culture to the state fair with the low riders,
because,
you know,
I,
I grew up in a,
in a big city that,
um,
low riders were a big part of the culture and people are so proud of the offense investments they make into their vehicles.
And so it'll be really neat to,
um,
see that.
So anyways,
thank you for all that you do and you are appreciated.
Thank you.
Any others on the board?
Yeah,
we're,
we're all queued in here,
chair.
I'll,
I'll go ahead and go next.
Um,
Tom,
first of all,
thank you for being here.
Thank you for your presentation.
I,
I,
uh,
really appreciate you acknowledging the agricultural roots of the state fair,
because actually all of the county fairs technically are the agricultural districts of the state of California.
Um,
and then that culminates in presenting their,
uh,
you know,
prize,
uh,
uh,
results at the state fair.
So I do support the date change,
but I recognize that you have a juggling act of making sure that the state fair comes after all of the agricultural districts have their individual county fairs.
Um,
and that it can be just as hot in September as it is in July.
So,
I mean,
you got to flip a coin,
right?
That's it.
You got to hurt.
Yeah.
An unwinnable task,
uh,
when it comes to that and unless you choose to hold it in December.
But,
uh,
I do,
uh,
appreciate your offer of utilizing that public asset for emergency situations,
whether that's,
you know,
as was mentioned,
the,
the,
the pandemic or,
or,
you know,
when the flood happened and I know people were bringing their animals and themselves,
uh,
to that huge expanse of space,
uh,
in order to take advantage of that.
So I'm glad that you are accounting for the elements,
uh,
with the cooling and the heating.
Um,
and,
uh,
and then with respect to the horse racing,
I think horse racing in general is probably falling out of favor except for the very large,
very,
uh,
popular ones,
um,
uh,
back East particularly.
Uh,
but maybe there's a way to repurpose that asset,
uh,
with respect to motocross or midget car racing or something that takes advantage of that dirt
car,
uh,
track for,
for people's entertainment.
Um,
but then the last thing I would like to say is I just want to acknowledge that since last
state fair and this state fair,
you lost a champion,
a board member,
uh,
and a tireless advocate in Dr.
Sonny Chong.
And I thank you for,
uh,
making available,
uh,
one of the,
uh,
exposition buildings,
uh,
to hold his memorial services.
He was a diehard state fair fanatic and,
and thank you for honoring him in the way that you did.
Miss him every day.
Yeah.
Um,
chairman,
uh,
yeah,
I just wanted you guys to know that,
uh,
per your advice,
the cannabis exhibit has been,
remains open and,
uh,
enlarged.
We're moving it to the water park.
So it's in its own gated community and expanded.
Um,
and it does have the smoking lounge that,
uh,
Mr.
Desmond requested.
So I want to make sure.
All right.
Did you just,
did you just say that in a public meeting?
Tom,
wait a second.
On that note,
Mr.
Through the chair.
I was cute.
I don't go anywhere.
Tom,
I was actually just going to just,
uh,
compliment you on your great work.
But now I'm not so sure.
Oh my God.
Um,
it is the,
it is the largest agricultural cash crop in California.
Who would have guessed,
but the people.
No,
and actually I do think.
The people voted.
I have not partaken the product,
but it is a great,
it is,
it is a great.
All right.
The floor is mine,
Tom.
Okay.
Let me say a few words here.
Um,
I just want to,
and thank you,
super much for mentioning Sonny Chong.
That was very,
very classy and everything you've done to recognize him.
But I just want to pile on here.
You know,
you have done tremendous work.
I've been going to the state fair since,
uh,
in my entire life.
And,
uh,
you have done some wonderful things over the past few years.
And you're,
you're all around great guy too.
I mean,
your passion,
your enthusiasm for the state fair is really infectious.
And your partnership with the county has been invaluable to us.
Um,
I plan to be there multiple days this year,
and,
and very,
very exciting to see what the future holds in store for that grandstand area where we,
uh,
previously have had horse racing for many, many decades.
I think it's a very underutilized space,
and we can do some really,
really great things there on the edge of my unincorporated Sacramento County district
of course.
Stay tuned.
Thank you.
Stay tuned on that one.
Yes.
My,
thank you for,
for mentioning the grandstand,
uh,
area supervisor,
Desmond.
That's where I saw my first concert in 1982.
It was,
uh,
Carlos Santana opening up for the police.
Oh,
wow.
I'm hopeful.
I'm hopeful we can have,
uh,
some,
uh,
uh,
kind of reconstituted purpose for that,
that area.
It's kind of a very unique,
uh,
opportunity.
So I think,
uh,
you know,
people much smarter than myself will,
uh,
figure that out.
But,
uh,
Mr.
Chair,
one more thing I want to say,
if you want to see supervisor Hume at the fair,
go on the night that air supply is playing.
Oh,
there you go.
Right.
I'm all on a lock,
baby.
All right.
Yeah.
Chairman,
supervisors.
Thank you.
Thank you,
Tom.
All right,
Madam clerk,
next item,
please.
Okay.
Now we're on to your consent matters,
items four through 45.
I do have a couple of notes for item eight.
This is to adopt the first plan amendment to retiree health savings plan.
Um,
we're requesting to hold that over until 2 PM.
Uh,
that will go after the youth commission,
uh,
presentation that starts right at two.
And then,
uh,
for item 38,
you're introducing an ordinance amending chapter 16.20 to title 16 of the
Sacramento County code to housing.
You are waiving full reading and continuing to July 22nd for adoption.
Uh,
and that concludes my notes.
And I do believe the County executive will have some comments,
uh,
after.
We,
after the vote.
Yeah.
Yes.
Very good.
Thank you.
And I would also note that we do have,
uh,
four fifths requirements on items four,
seven,
and 10.
Um,
so,
uh,
hold on,
Madam clerk.
I failed to,
um,
ask you whether or not we had any public speakers on the last presentation.
We did not.
Okay.
All right.
Very good.
Uh,
with that,
I will look to my colleagues as any member of the board,
wish to pull an item for separate,
uh,
vote or consideration,
uh,
or to simply ask a question or offer a comment.
I'll start with vice chair Rodriguez.
Uh,
yeah,
I would like to pull item number five.
Okay.
Um,
I'll,
I'll read that into the record.
This is the authorization to appoint Florence Evans as county clerk recorder of the Sacramento
County clerk recorder department.
Let me ask before you start,
are you pulling it or is this for comment?
Pulling it for comment.
Okay.
That's it's all right.
That's different.
So what?
Okay.
Okay.
Do you want me to wait?
Very good.
Do you want me to wait?
I can wait.
No,
no,
no,
but I just,
from making the distinction when someone says pull it typically means pull it for a separate
vote.
Oh,
sorry.
You want to comment on it?
I want to pull for comment.
Okay.
I think the county executive is going to do that as well.
Okay.
After you guys,
you know what?
I will wait.
Okay.
I'll wait.
Oh,
all right.
Any,
any other members of the board,
uh,
wish to,
uh,
isolate,
uh,
item from consent.
Hearing none.
All right.
Hold on here,
chair.
Sorry.
I didn't have my microphone on.
No,
I was going to make a comment on item five.
I'm still debating whether I'm or not.
I'm a hard no on that one,
but,
uh,
that was it.
Okay.
Very,
very good.
I do have an item that I'd just like to make a comment on,
please.
Uh,
item 17.
Yes.
I'll read that into the record.
Get there.
Item 17,
approve the improvement implementation agreement between Taylor Morrison of California and the county of Sacramento for
Florin vineyards one and two.
Great.
Thank you.
Uh,
I don't have concern with this item necessarily,
except to say that the vineyard community for a long time,
uh,
has been slow to develop and a lot of the infrastructure that was coming and should have been in place,
uh,
is trailing development.
And I think that the community is really feeling that pinch,
uh,
particularly with respect to the school district and the delivery of the,
uh,
the,
uh,
elementary school that has long been promised and,
and for which that they are paying,
uh,
Mela roos,
uh,
uh,
uh,
taxes on their homes.
Um,
and so,
you know,
the roadway and drainage,
uh,
were,
I think,
uh,
some of the hurdles that had to be,
uh,
factored in order to,
to make that,
uh,
community develop,
uh,
in the first place.
And so,
again,
I don't oppose this,
but I just would like to,
for us to be mindful that we are watching that and being sure that these people are,
are given the amenities that,
that they,
uh,
bought into.
Thank you.
And with that,
if there's no other comments,
chair,
I,
I would remove,
I would move for the,
uh,
consent calendar,
uh,
holding over item eight until the afternoon.
Okay.
Very good.
And then,
uh,
uh,
I will note that we're all going to have comments on,
uh,
five and then we'll,
I'll,
I'll go in the order that,
uh,
I heard,
um,
for that item.
Uh,
so,
uh,
madame clerk,
do we have any members of the public,
uh,
wish to speak on any consent matter?
Uh,
no,
we do not at this time.
Mr. Chair,
I don't know if you can see it,
but they're,
folks are clearing the room.
I'm going to wait a few seconds here.
Okay.
We'll be back.
Thank you,
uh,
supervisor doesn't for letting me know.
We're going outside.
We're going outside.
I know.
I know.
I know
Madam Clerk, you let me know when the chambers are.
I sure will.
We're just about there, just a few more seconds.
We'll be back.
We'll be back.
Okay.
Mr. Chair.
We're good.
So we have no members of the public.
So speak on consent.
We have, did we get a motion and a second on?
On that?
I'll second.
Okay.
Mr. Chair.
We're good.
So we have no members of the public.
So speak on consent.
We have, did we get a motion and a second on that?
I'll second.
Okay.
There's a motion and a second to approve the consent calendar.
Uh, and then we are going to hear from, uh, the CEO on item five and we'll have comments as well from, uh, my colleagues myself on that item.
Uh, please vote.
I will go ahead and call a roll call vote.
Supervisor Desmond.
Supervisor.
Supervisor Rodriguez.
Aye.
Supervisor Hume.
Aye.
Supervisor Serna.
Aye.
And that, uh, is a unanimous vote with those members present.
Okay.
Very good.
Uh, Mr. CEO, floor George.
Thank you, Supervisor, uh, um, Serna.
Um, I want to thank all of you, um, and item number five that you've guys have pointed out quite clearly, um, in that we've made a recommendation or I've made a recommendation, uh, to make an appointment and I appreciate your confirmation on that.
So that item number five is to appoint our own, uh, Flo Evans or Florence Evans to be our county clerk recorder.
Um, as you may know, Flo has had a 22 year career with the county and for the past nine years, she has served as a county clerk.
Um, her leadership has been instrumental in being, uh, in bringing about improvements and innovation to the office and the processes around, um, the board's, uh, operations.
She's inserted a streamline, uh, meeting process from agenda creation, real-time access to documents and audio recordings that have gave the public improved access, uh, access for opportunities to view that material.
We are fortunate to have the opportunity to appoint Flo in this new position as county clerk recorder.
Um, I have no doubt that her enthusiasm, her education and her experience will serve the public well in her new role.
In addition to the congratulations to Flo and the gorgeous flowers that are coming out, um, I'd also like to thank, um, Donna Allred.
Donna Allred is your current county clerk recorder and she's been, um, with the county now for 35, 34 years.
I think she's been trying or at least threatening to retire for at least the last two and we've been able to keep her around for at least that long.
Um, Donna's commitment to excellence and her tireless effort to make a lasting impact on the organization and the community has been, um, fantastic.
Um, her leadership and positive info influence has all made us better and that organization better for that.
So I hope, uh, Donna's, uh, retirement brings, uh, some relaxation, some joy and, and new adventures in her new life.
And I want to just say thank you to Donna for her commitment to Sacramento County.
And with that, I'd like to congratulate Flo.
She's made her way to the podium here.
And, uh, supervisor Cerna, if you would allow maybe Flo a couple of words.
Um, I understand she has, uh, some things to share with the board.
So thank you all for your commitment.
I know that was a tough decision, um, to give up your clerk, but I have to say, I think this will be a great opportunity for Flo and a great opportunity for Sacramento County.
So thank you.
Thank you, Mr. Villanueva.
Uh, I cannot see very well what's going on.
Uh, so, uh, I don't know if the flowers are going to be a great opportunity for Sacramento County.
Uh, I'll see if the flowers are in your possession.
I think they are.
Yes, they are.
They are.
Okay.
Very good.
I want to make certain that you understand Flo.
That is from the entire board.
Uh, and it is to, uh, certainly help you, uh, celebrate, uh, this, uh, this occasion of, uh, your, uh, advancement to a very important, uh, uh, position in Sacramento County.
I'll have a few more comments later, but, uh, the floor is yours.
And then once you're, uh, completed with your, uh, uh, your words, then we're going to hear from Vice Chair Rodriguez.
I wasn't prepared for the flowers, um, and I just need to get myself together.
First of all, good morning, board members.
County Executive David Villanueva.
Deputy County Executive Sylvester Fidel.
Siobhan Qatari.
And Eric Jones.
And all of you who are here, my colleagues, my friends, my team.
I want to start by expressing my heartfelt gratitude for this incredible opportunity to serve as your next County Clerk Recorder.
It's truly an honor to carry out Donna's legacy.
She was the first person to be my mentor when I was appointed as clerk, and she holds a very dear place in my heart.
I am humbled and I'm excited to step into this new role.
Serving as the Clerk of the Board has been a meaningful chapter in my career and a rewarding experience.
I had the privilege of working alongside dedicated colleagues, County leadership, and a talented team.
Who deeply care about good governance, transparency, and public service.
The experiences have prepared me well for this next step, and I take those values with me into this new chapter.
As County Clerk Recorder, I'm committed to building on the department's strong foundation that Donna has set forth.
Expanding access to services and strengthening community trust and finding innovative ways to improve how we serve the public.
The office plays a vital role in people's lives and I take that responsibility seriously.
I'm excited for the Clerk of the Board and the team's future and I'm confident that they will continue to serve you,
Board of Supervisors, County leadership, departments, and community members with kindness, compassion, and excellence.
I'm honored and grateful to step into this new role, and I thank you for the trust and confidence you've placed in me.
I'm ready to get to work, and I look forward to working with an amazing new team and all that we will accomplish together.
And I want to say thank you to my mom and my dad and my family, and I would just be remiss.
The most important thing in my life is my Savior, Jesus Christ, and I would like to thank him publicly and honor him.
Thank you, Flo.
Thank you, Flo.
Vice Chair Rodriguez.
Thank you.
Flo, it has been a tremendous pleasure to have been working with you so closely these past six months.
And even when you were away, it's amazing the team that you have built that was able to step into this role and carry it on.
And it says a lot about leadership when people can do that.
But I just want to thank you for your years with the Clerk's Office and all that you have done.
I have a Chief of Staff that has said you have been his favorite person to work with, which means everybody else is not.
And that says a lot.
But I just want to thank you for all that you have done and I'm excited for your new role.
It's really neat when the county is able to place such high-performing individuals into positions that have the ability to continue to share your leadership now with the new department.
And so I wish you all the best.
God bless you in your new role.
And I'm sure we will still see each other.
Thank you.
Very good.
Thank you, Vice Chair.
I'm not sure who's next in the queue.
I'm going to go to Supervisor Desmond.
Okay.
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Well, Flo, you started crying before you even got to the podium.
And so several others were crying as well.
You know, I haven't been on this board nearly as long as our Chair, so I haven't gotten to know you as well as him.
I tell you, you have just been such a wonderful friend and guide to me and support network for me.
You have taken such good care of the board members.
And, you know, we love you because of that.
Because we know you love us.
I do.
And I don't know what we're going to do without that.
Those are very big shoes to fill.
But ironically, I think I will get to see you even more now because you'll be off American River Drive out there.
So I've already told my staff that I plan to do a lot more office hours out in the district.
So you need to find some space for me.
So I'll have a chance to keep in touch with you.
Absolutely.
Thank you for all you've done for the county and will continue to do and certainly for the board and supporting us and looking after us.
And really managing meetings with such an amazing level of professionalism and deafness through some difficult times.
And also, Donna, thank you to your service as well.
Congratulations to you on your retirement.
Yes.
Thank you, Flo.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you, Chair.
It's been alluded to, you know, kind of in a joking way, but these are bittersweet moments when selfishly we want to hold someone back.
But professionally we know that they have outgrown the current position and an opportunity is available that,
you know, unfortunately we can't be everywhere and everything to everyone.
So thank you for making a difficult decision that I know you had to make.
Thank you for all of your dedication in supporting this board and each of us individually.
And just I really appreciate the sincerity and compassion that you show in your job and the respect that you have for the position.
And I'm sure you will carry that forward into your new role.
And so congratulations to you.
I hate to see you go, but I really wish you the best in your new position.
Thank you.
And congratulations to Donna and enjoy retirement.
Great.
Thank you, Supervisor.
And thanks to all my colleagues for your great words.
So as was alluded to, I have had the chance to work alongside you, Flo, for several years and following Cindy's retirement.
You were very quick to do what you always do, which is be very deliberate and thoughtful about what that opportunity might mean.
Not to just your sense of career advancement, but what it means in terms of the responsibility that comes with the post of being clerk of the board of supervisors for for a large county.
That one that has a tremendous amount of not just the business before us on any given Tuesday, but day in and day out, which is what the public doesn't really have a chance to understand and appreciate.
And you've certainly taken that to the next level by doing things like wanting to include in the services that the clerk of the board's office provides the public passport services.
Right. Now, I know that's that's been kind of a project that you've been very close to.
And that should have been one of our many clues that I kind of figured that you might want to progress at some point to different post that is immersed in detailed provision of service to the public.
And I think clerk of the public and I think clerk of the public and clerk of the public and clerk of the public and clerk of the public and clerk of the public and clerk of the public.
And I think clerk of the office is the appropriate rightful place for you to continue your wonderful public service.
And you have you have been such a consummate professional, I would say to a fault.
And as you know, our running joke is you absolutely refuse to call me by my first name for years.
And you continue to do so. And and despite my lobbying to to that effect, you, you know, really maintain this even keel.
And this presence that is soothing at times calming when necessary.
You are a problem solver extraordinaire.
And it's a very, very, I think, very difficult job being a clerk of the board in terms of all the places you get pulled and pushed to and to do that.
And usually in a compressed schedule.
So for for those that are out there that are watching who aspire ever to be a clerk of the board of supervisors for any county, large or small, please take note.
Flo Evans is your textbook example, in my humble opinion, of how to do it and how to do it right.
Right. So while we will certainly miss you and you know, your.
Your service alongside us.
In your current capacity, we really, really do want to celebrate with you and look forward to all the great things you're going to do in your next chapter here.
And like my colleagues, I also want to extend my congratulations to Donna for job well done, very well done.
And and your retirement is well, well deserved.
And we wish you the best as that approaches.
So again, the flowers are only a very, very small token of of our appreciation, all five of us for what you do.
And also all of our staffs, the staffs that you that you work with, quite frankly, probably even more closely than you ever have with us.
And all of our staffs, our chiefs join us in congratulating you.
So thanks again, Flo, for a job well done.
Thank you very much. I'm very humbled by the flowers and everyone's kind words.
And I'm just so happy I don't have to clerk like another 250 board meetings.
So I think that's just about what I did.
And I'm just ready to turn that baton over.
You have, you know, an excellent pool of leadership.
And I have to thank our county executive and his leadership team.
And I am just I'm just so excited.
I know that coming behind Donna is a very big shoes, very big shoes to fill.
And it's daunting.
But I have a lot of enthusiasm.
I'm excited.
And I just feel so grateful and blessed that David and Sylvester saw worthy, you know, in me that and they're putting their confidence in me and that you guys are going to vote yes and put me in.
And so thank you.
Thank you very much.
Great.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you very much.
Great.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
So, Madam Clerk for the time being, do we have anyone signed up to address this matter?
No, we don't.
All right.
Very good.
Next item then, please.
All right.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Okay.
Our first 10 o'clock time item, let me just get to that real quick.
This is the tax equity and fiscal responsibility hearing for approval of tax exempt bonds and approval
of issuance of series 2025 airport system revenue bonds in one or more series in an aggregate
principal amount not to exceed $800 million and authorize the refunding of a certain outstanding
airport system revenue bonds through a tender offer for the purchase and or exchange of such
bonds and authorizing the execution and delivery of related bond and tender documents and authorizing certain other actions
in connection therewith.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Good day, Chair Serna and supervisors.
My name is Colin Bettis and I'm the County Debt Officer.
The item before you now is the recommendation, recommended issuance of the next bonds to fund
additional SMF forward projects.
The primary purpose of these bonds will be to issue nearly $412 million for the projects
in new money bonds for constructing additional gates at Concourse B, improving baggage handling
systems and adding apron space as well as improvements to the baggage handling system at Terminal A.
The requested authorization amount significantly exceeds $412 million for the projects listed above.
This is due to the opportunity to achieve savings from tendering outstanding bonds with a call date within the next few years.
Through a tender offer, the county will invite current investors to tender their current holdings for a price.
If the investors choose to take this option, then the county will achieve savings through what is essentially refunding of those bonds.
Additionally, we will retain the ability to issue regular refunding bonds for any non-tendered bonds in the following year or two.
The requested authorization takes into consideration the anticipated solicitation of target bonds and their tender candidates.
The size and considerations include costs of issuance, reserve fund deposits, and capitalized interest with some cushion for market fluctuations.
The tender offer approach to refunding is consistent with the county of Sacramento's debt policy, which permits refundings if there is a net economic benefit or to achieve other significant objectives.
In general, refunding should produce a net economic benefit of net present value of 3%, but we are targeting bonds that should achieve around 5% or above by series and approximately 6.2% in the aggregate.
The financing plan for the projects includes these bonds, passenger facility charges, and grant funds.
As of July 1st, the Department of Airports has decided not to seek another TIFIA loan for the current projects.
Consequently, the amount previously tied to the TIFIA loan has been incorporated into the series 2025 bonds.
The Department of Airports has determined that the benefits of the TIFIA program for these projects are not as beneficial as they were for the pedestrian walkway project,
primarily because this project would not qualify for the rural program of TIFIA and would have to pay the full treasury rate rather than half of the treasury rate, minimizing potential savings from the program.
As mentioned in the board letter, PFM has prepared a revised good faith estimate.
I hope I have that here.
The revised estimate includes a par amount of $500.5 million with a project deposit of $331.2 million.
The estimated all-in true interest cost is 4.908%.
The final maturity will be July 1 of 2025, and the bonds will be issued as fixed-rate bonds and will not be a liability of the general fund.
Today we have Cindy Nickel, Director of Airports, Brian Gallucci of PFM, the county's municipal advisor, and Jenna McGann of OREC, the county's bond council.
This concludes my presentation.
At this time, I request that you open the public hearing, hear any public comments, close the public hearing, and consider staff's recommendations.
Thank you, Colin.
Okay, any questions of Colin before I open the public hearing?
I'm not hearing any.
So with that, we will open the public hearing.
Madam Clerk, do we have anyone sign up to speak on this matter?
We do not have any public speakers for item 46.
Very good.
Thank you.
I will therefore close the public hearing.
That's the sound of my knuckles on my desk, by the way.
So bring it back to the board.
Is there a motion?
I'll go ahead and move the recommended action.
Okay.
It's been moved by Vice Chair Rodriguez.
Is there a second?
Second.
Someone seconded, I think.
Second.
Without a microphone on.
That was Desmond.
Okay.
We have a motion and a second.
Roll call vote, please.
Supervisors Desmond.
Aye.
Rodriguez.
Aye.
Hume.
Aye.
Serna.
Aye.
Unanimous vote with those members present.
Very good.
Next item, please.
Item 47, you're acting as the Sacramento County Water Agency.
This is the public hearing to proceed with projects and levy assessments in Zone 13 of
the Sacramento County Water Agency for fiscal year 2526.
Good morning, Supervisors and Chair.
Thank you so much for your time.
My name is Mike Grenstead with the Department of Water Resources, and I am here today to introduce
the Zone 13 assessment.
In 1987, the board approved the formation of Zone 13.
The assessment methodology and cost allocation have been the same since 1995.
If approved, the 2526 assessment will generate approximately $2.3 million for the zone.
The zone currently funds programs listed in the engineer's report, which is attached to
the board letter.
This morning, I ask that your board take the following actions.
Open the public hearing regarding the projects proposed for Zone 13 and the levy of assessments
in the zone.
Consider public testimony.
Close the public hearing.
Adopt the resolution instituting projects and levying assessments in Zone 13 for fiscal
year 2526.
Thank you so much, and I'm here to answer any questions.
Very good.
Thank you.
Any questions from my colleagues?
Hearing none.
Okay.
We will open the public hearing.
I'm sorry, do I have anyone time to speak on this page?
We do not have any public speakers for item 47.
Very good.
I will close the public hearing.
Mr. Chair, Mr. Chair, can you hang on just one second?
We're having a little bit of technical difficulty on our end.
Just one second.
There we go.
Okay, Mr. Chair, sorry to interrupt you.
We're fixed now on our end.
Okay.
Close the public hearing.
Would entertain a motion at this point.
I'll go ahead and move the recommended action.
Second.
Hume.
Moved and seconded.
Please, Madam Clerk, roll call vote.
Yes.
Supervisors Desmond.
Aye.
Rodriguez.
Aye.
Hume.
Aye.
Cerna.
Aye.
Unanimous vote with those members present.
Next item, please.
Yes.
Moving on to item 48.
Here acting as the Board of Supervisors, County Service Area Number 10, Benefit Zone Number
3, public hearing on the written report of service charges for fiscal year 25-26, confirm
report and fix the charges.
Good morning, members of the Board.
Joe Grasset with County Engineering.
And we also have staff from DOT in the audience to help with any questions that may come up.
So CSA 10 was formed in 2003 to provide trip reduction services for new growth areas of the county.
Currently, Zone 3 is the only active zone and includes North Vineyard Station, Florin Vineyard, and the Wild Hawk North development areas.
In May, the Board received a written report of operating requirements and service charges and set this public hearing.
And the written report summarizes the recommended fiscal year 25-26 service charges and the use of those charges.
Based on changes to the consumer price index, the allowable increase is 2.76%.
However, the written report shows the staff is recommending not increasing the 25-26 rates over last year.
So with that, just some quick highlights from the recent year from CSA 10.
50-quarter TMA continued efforts to educate residents about sustainable transportation options.
They hosted several bicycle repair events.
They hosted several community bike rides along the American River Parkway.
And they held education workshops and community engagement events at the Vineyard Point Apartments.
50-quarter TMA, in partnership with Sac County DOT and Sac RT, has begun exploring the possibility of adding another bus stop on Sac RT's E19 transit route.
50-TMA also contracted with Farron Peers to reanalyze the travel patterns in this area.
And the results showed that travel patterns have shifted pretty dramatically since the last time it was analyzed in 2017.
So as a result, the county is working with 50-TMA to explore other options for mobility services that have the highest potential to shift trips to sustainable modes.
So with that, if there are no questions from the board, we recommend that the board open the public hearing, consider any written and oral testimony and comments, close the public hearing, and adopt the resolution.
Very good. Thank you, Joe.
Before I open the public hearing, Supervisor Desmond, I will just let you know that you made mention of the top three beards in Sacramento County.
The gentleman before you represents the number one beard in Sacramento.
I appreciate that.
I'll take top ten, to be honest.
I think one of the UPE speakers from this morning is a strong contender for number one.
All right.
With that, if there are no further, if there are no questions for Mr. Grasic, I will open the public hearing.
Madam Clerk, do we have anyone signed up to speak on this matter?
We do not.
Okay.
I will close the public hearing and bring it back to the board for a vote.
Is there a motion?
I will go ahead and move the recommended action.
Okay.
Is there a second?
Second.
Hume.
Okay.
It's been moved in a second.
Roll call vote, please.
Supervisors Desmond.
Aye.
Rodriguez.
Aye.
Hume.
Aye.
Serna.
Aye.
Unanimous vote with those members present.
Very good.
Thank you.
Moving on to item 49 is the County of Sacramento Landscape Maintenance District Zone 4,
public hearing on proposed assessment for fiscal year 2526.
Confirm the assessment diagram and levy assessments.
Good morning.
Chair Serna, members of the board, Lupe Rodriguez with the Transportation Department.
Today I'm here to make a short presentation on the Sacramento County Landscape Maintenance
District Zone 4, the public hearing on proposed assessment for fiscal year 2025-26.
So a little background, the Sacramento County Landscape Maintenance District was formed in 1994,
consolidating many landscape and lighting districts in the county.
The district provides funding for the maintenance of public landscape corridors, roadway landscape
medians, and natural open space throughout the unincorporated county.
On May 20, 2025, the engineer's report was filed with the clerk of the board,
and resolution of intention was approved by the board of supervisors to levy and collect the assessments
for the district for fiscal year 25-26.
The resolution of intention said today as a date and time for a notice public hearing on said levy.
The proposed fiscal year 25-26 assessment rates are the same as those levied for the past 31 years,
which is $42.50 per parcel for residential properties and $66.51 per acre for commercial properties.
So the projected revenues and expenditures indicated in the property assessments alone do not provide
adequate funding to support the district operations.
To cover the shortfall, an inter-fund transfer from the road fund of $768,920 to district funding
is proposed and included in the Department of Transportation's fiscal year 2025-26 recommended budget.
To levy the assessments in the fiscal year 25-26, state law requires that the board hold a public hearing
on the proposed levy and adopt the resolution of levying the assessments.
So the recommended actions are as follows for today.
Open the public hearing.
Consider public testimony and objections regarding the matter and close the public hearing.
And adopt the attached resolution to confirm the assessment diagram and levy assessments
within the Sacramento County landscape manager for fiscal year 2025-26.
So that concludes my presentation.
Very good.
Thank you, Lupe.
Any questions for Mr. Rodriguez before we open the public hearing?
All right.
Hearing none.
I will then go ahead and open the public hearing.
Madam Clerk, do we have anyone sign up to speak on this matter?
We do not have anyone sign up for item 49.
All right.
I will close the public hearing and look for a motion.
Second.
It's been moved and seconded.
Roll call vote, please.
Supervisors Desmond.
Aye.
Rodriguez.
Aye.
Hume.
Aye.
Serna.
Aye.
Unanimous vote with those members present.
Aye, please.
Okay.
Item 50 is the Assembly Bill 2561, Government Code Section 3502.3.
Good morning, Supervisors.
Pleasure to be with you today.
Presenting 2561 as required by the statute.
We have to present on vacancies, recruitment, and retention challenges,
as well as any positions that are over 20% vacant.
So I've got some bad news and I've got two pieces of good news.
The bad news, we're on the list.
The good news is we've only got one.
The county's general vacancy rate is about 10%, just slightly above where we'd like it
to be.
Single-digit vacancy is what you want to target for a really good number.
But the good news is that this number is a decline from where we were two years ago at 14%.
So I think kudos to the DPS staff and our partners and hiring managers for getting that number down.
Our recruitment efforts, I think, are exemplary.
Over 140 career fairs in all five of our districts, 1,000 attendees at career fairs and events around the county,
training for how to navigate the civil service exam process, and our participation on the various social media platforms.
But there are opportunities for improvement, and they begin with our civil service plans.
We have opportunities to reach broader markets, to connect with more candidates, and to offer jobs faster.
But we have to revisit our current civil service rules.
And that will require greater partnership with our partners there, and our ability to look beyond where we are today.
The limitations for on-the-spot hiring are also another challenge.
Many of our candidates come with jobs already.
So any delay in giving them the job opportunity poses a risk to us in losing that talent.
Appeals to the minimum qualification process will have to be scheduled with the Civil Service Commission,
and that can take one, two, or three months sometimes just to schedule.
So these are areas that we certainly would like to partner with to get resolution there.
But on to the facts.
So of the 30 bargaining units, only one bargaining unit met the threshold of 20% or greater.
And if you look at this, am I doing this thing?
Oh, I'm sorry.
Oh, I'm sorry.
Okay, so this is the list of...
Thank you.
Thank you.
I can close my presentation.
So these are the list of all the bargaining units.
And you'll see on this...
Oh, my gosh.
I am so sorry.
On this page...
Anyway, it's the 27.5.
I can't see it.
It's the Association of Professional Engineers,
and it's our engineering classification that's giving us the greatest challenge.
But I'm going to commend all the departments who have engineers, DGS, water resources, transportation,
that have partnered with us to try and figure out ways we can navigate through this.
And I'm pleased to report today that that number is reduced by four.
So we're now just under 14% vacancy.
So that would mean if we were reporting today, we wouldn't have to report.
That concludes my presentation.
Great.
Thank you, Joe.
Any questions for Mr. Angelo?
Okay.
Hearing none.
This is just a receipt of presentation, Madam Clerk?
Yes.
This is just a receiving file.
And we do have a public comment on this item as well.
Okay.
All right.
Then we'll go to public comment.
Okay.
That would be Noel Pacheco.
Okay.
Hi.
Good afternoon.
My name is Noel Pacheco.
I'm an associate civil engineer with the Department of Transportation.
And I am the president of APEX, which represents Bargaining Unit 23.
I do feel compelled to speak today on behalf of the only bargaining unit that meets that 20% threshold.
I would like to start off by saying that I think APEX has a very good working relationship
with the Department of, or the Office of Labor Relations.
So I'm very happy to say that.
I do think that this problem requires some additional creative thinking on how to address this issue.
We've worked in negotiations to get in flexible staffing, which I think flexible staffing will be a big benefit
in terms of allowing assistants and associates to, for assistants to automatically be moved into the associate level,
Bargaining 23, which will, I think, help facilitate the vacancy rate issue.
I will say that I think that it will probably redistribute some of the vacancy rate issue from Bargaining Unit 23 to Bargaining Unit 22.
So I do have some concerns about that.
But I'm excited to work with the county on developing that proposal and that policy on flexible staffing.
You know, some of the proposals, non-economic proposals that, you know, I don't begrudge the county has some compaction issues when dealing with negotiation with our union.
They can't offer us additional salary without it impacting bargaining units above us, and we understand that.
I do think that there are some non-economic proposals that can also be moved forward, and I would like to see additional engagement with the Department of, or the Office of Labor Relations and DPS in terms of working collaboratively with the union throughout the year, and not just every three years in negotiations.
I think there's an opportunity for us to partner on what other solutions can be implemented.
One of the solutions that was offered during negotiations actually came from upper management.
It was not our idea originally.
It was upper management's idea was to allow highly qualified candidates coming to the county with their professional engineering license already to come in at a higher vacation accrual rate,
similar to what we allow for higher salary step levels.
This, I think, would be fundamental for facilitating recruitment issues for bargaining unit 23, and I do see that my time is out.
But, again, I just want to say that I think that there is additional opportunity to work creatively for the Office of Labor Relations to work creatively not only with the union,
but also with upper management that is seeing these retention and recruitment issues.
Very good.
Thank you.
Madam Clerk, does that conclude our public speakers?
That concludes your public comments, yes.
All right, very good.
Then we are at the presentation as well, correct?
We have one more item, yes, for this morning before you go to closed session.
No, I understand that.
I'm just clarifying that there's no vote on this item.
Oh, yes.
Sorry about that, sir.
Yeah.
This is a receiving file.
Okay.
Very good.
All right.
Next item, please.
Yes.
Item 51 is the letter on Senate Bill 802 regarding the Sacramento Area Housing and Homelessness Agency,
Multifamily Housing Program, Home Key, Homeless Housing Assistance and Prevention Program.
Sure.
Good morning, Chair Cerna and members of the board.
I'm Alicia DeBoard, Governmental Relations and Legislative Officer.
Here to request that you consider and all members sign an opposition letter to Senate Bill 802 by Senator Ashby.
The language for this bill was first made public June 24th.
SB 802 creates a state-mandated joint powers authority to oversee housing and homeless programs in Sacramento County.
It designates Sacramento Housing and Redevelopment Agency to serve as the new JPA, however expanded and renamed, with the current SHRA executive director serving as the head.
This board will lose its current decision-making power and control of funding if passed.
SB 802 redirects county-administered homeless and housing programs and funding to the new JPA, as well as the continuum of care and other housing funding and programs administered by cities in the county.
Sacramento County is on record in opposition to this measure, along with the impacted cities of Sacramento, Elk Grove, Folsom, Rancho Cordova, Citrus Heights, urban counties of California and numerous community organizations, leaders, coalitions, unions, because it usurps local authority and does not align with their ongoing efforts to collaborate on the delivery of homeless and housing programs.
This bill is moving quickly, and it can become final in September and made law in January.
The letter before you raises federal and state legal concerns and analyzes impacts of transferring federal local funds to the newly formed JPA.
So I look to you for input and approval, and I'm here to answer your questions, along with our deputy county executive, Siobhan, and counsel.
Thank you, Lisa.
Okay.
Okay.
I am suspecting that there may be comments that my colleagues want to share.
I'll start with Vice Chair Rodriguez.
Well, thank you very much, Lisa, for taking the lead on this.
I greatly opposed it from the beginning, and I'm glad that we are sending an opposition letter, or we have submitted it.
And so I also want to thank you for your leadership on making some of this opposition and the steps that are taken to ensure that the county as a whole has, which sounds like it was opposed from every city within the county, will be present to share their voice.
Thank you.
And thank you, Vice Chair.
I will just tack on before we go to others that I want.
I just want to thank Supervisor Rodriguez.
Thank you.
I don't subscribe to, nor do I read the Sacramento Bee.
I haven't in years.
I have a couple of questions, but I'm told that she submitted and had published a thoughtful editorial expressing the reasons, some of the reasons why we hold the position and that certainly she holds the position that she does.
So I want to thank her for being as public as she has about that.
So we'll then go to Supervisor Desmond.
Yes.
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
And thank you, Alicia.
I had a few comments and questions about this.
I guess I want to preface any of my comments and questions with first just recognizing Senator Ashby.
I certainly appreciate her interest in seeing a more collaborative, coordinated approach in Sacramento County.
I think we all do.
I think we all appreciate that.
But I think we kind of captured in this letter that this language was introduced without really engaging with the county and with other elected leaders in Sacramento County.
I think if her office had done that, and hopefully she still will, she would learn about the tremendous progress we have made.
And I look back at a few things, a heck of a lot more to do, obviously, and Supervisor Rodriguez has highlighted some of these things both in her op-ed and certainly comments from the dais up here.
But the first place I look is the partnership agreement with the city and the county.
It took over two years to develop that thing because this is such a complex issue.
And we are looking at dramatic restructuring right now of the COC and Sacramento steps forward, providing more scrutiny of SHRA.
I know we all appreciate the work that they do, but it certainly calls for us taking a deeper dive into some things and seeing how we can improve that.
We're doing all of that right now.
And I think, you know, if you were to read this bill, you would not have the sense that we're doing anything to coordinate or collaborate in Sacramento County.
So I guess my first question to Alicia and maybe Siobhan, what's the status of our discussions with the author's office and with committee staff right now on this bill?
Well, we first met with Senator Ashby, as you're aware, on May 22nd, and she didn't mention this bill.
And we were talking about this particular subject.
We also had a follow-up June 30th with the office.
And the office was very clear that we'll hear you, but we're not changing anything.
So we haven't seen any.
Siobhan, did you have anything?
Yeah, I'll just add that we have been meeting with different legislators over this bill from both the Housing Committee as well as the local government committee.
Those will go to hearings next week.
And so we've just wanted to outline some of our concerns, key concerns with this bill, including, as Alicia raised, the legal concerns with the bill, not only legal concerns around the JPA law, but also around laws concerning transfer of finances, local finances to a new JPA,
as well as lifting up concerns about local control and ensuring that each of the elected bodies in our county, the county board, as well as each of our city councils, retains local control over decisions that are made because we know how important that is for our local elected officials.
Okay.
And thank you, Siobhan.
Yeah, the legal issues that are identified in this letter, I think, are really compelling, in my opinion, in addition to the policy concerns that we have.
I think we've all articulated in various discussions and in published documents.
What is the plan?
I think it's coming for hearing, what, the 16th in front of the Assembly Housing Committee?
Alicia, where else, what will be the path of this bill?
Someone told me yesterday it might end up being triple referred.
Can you just talk to me a little bit about the procedurally where it will go from housing?
Yeah.
So July 16th, it will be heard in the Assembly Housing Community Development Committee.
And then the same day referred to the local government committee hearing in the afternoon.
And then the legislature will be on recess for a month, so that will be the last hearing.
So after a month, when they return between August 18th and September 12th, it will make its rounds through Assembly Appropriations, Assembly Floor,
and then back to the Senate for either a floor vote or two Senate housing.
Okay.
So it's just the two policy committees.
Okay.
So someone had mentioned that it was going to be triple referred.
Double.
Yeah.
Maybe they were referring to approves or something, which is not a policy committee, obviously.
And I appreciate you indulging me a little bit, because I think it's important to flesh this out in a public hearing and make a record of this right now.
The one question I had, just the mechanics of the bill, is it, am I reading it correctly?
I mean, to me, it looks like this would really supplant all of our housing.
This would go well above and beyond just SHRA's current duties in terms of affordable housing.
This would encompass everything that we do in terms of our homeless prevention and response.
Is that an accurate reading?
Absolutely.
So currently, the Continuum of Care Board has appointed the lead entity as Sacramento steps forward.
What this bill does is it takes SHRA, it expands their scope to be the homeless lead within the county, making them not only leading the Continuum of Care Board, but also becoming the lead entity for homelessness.
And it directs the transferring of different funding sources that are outlined in the letter to SHRA away from the local jurisdictions that currently receive them, which include the county and the cities.
It also would redirect some of local dollars, not only the state and federal dollars, but local dollars, including impact fees, to this newly formed JPA.
So, Siobhan, our own Affordable Housing Trust Fund dollars that we recently used on an affordable housing project in unincorporated Sacramento County, those funds would be put into this entity?
Correct.
That is my reading of the bill.
And we are analyzing the fiscal impacts as well.
We've highlighted some of them in the letter, but we believe there's more fiscal impacts that we need more time to analyze how exactly those dollars would flow.
And frankly, the constitutionality of whether or not the state legislature could redirect those dollars without local decisions to do that.
Okay.
Thank you.
You know, I'm very supportive of the letter.
I've informed Senator Ashby of my own opposition.
I know that she's disappointed in that, but I really encourage her to maybe step back and have discussions with us because I think she is in a unique position to convene, I think, leaders here locally and have a discussion about what, and it may not require a legislative change in terms of this coordination and collaboration, but I think she could be an amazing partner with us.
My only suggestion, which I'm not suggesting a change to the letter, but certainly in terms of our messaging to both Senator Ashby's office and the policy committee staff and other members is really to highlight the amount of coordination and collaboration we have already done.
And that is in the offing right now.
So, because I don't think we put enough of a point or underscore that quite enough.
So, thank you.
Thank you, Supervisor Desmond.
Supervisor Hume.
Thank you, Chair.
First of all, I'll just say that while we were on recess, I had a text exchange with the Senator to appreciate her leaning in on this issue, but to ask that she put a pause on this current effort in order to work with us so that we are going ground up rather than top down in looking for solutions.
And that's really my biggest objection to this bill and what's being proposed is that it's prescribing a fix before we fully understand the malfunctioning.
And I think that we have taken a pretty concerted effort here on this body to ask for greater transparency and accountability and oversight from the agency which stands to benefit from this legislation.
I don't know if that was an impetus into why the sense of urgency of prescribing this bill, but the irony is not lost on me that in the effort to demand collaboration, the only collaboration that's resulted is that every agency except for that agency which will benefit has come out in opposition to this proposed legislation.
And I think it ignores the efforts we have been making to restructure some of the local things.
It ignores the efforts that have been made to address some of the issues within and surrounding how we address homelessness.
And I agree with my colleague that there is a lot more that needs to be done.
But as we are starting to examine and really put a microscope to things, I don't think going to a larger mega agency centralization of efforts is the solution.
And I said as much to the senator.
So I appreciate her zeal and her zest, but I support this letter, and frankly, I don't think the wording is strong enough.
I mean, really, this stabs an arrow through the heart of local control, and I don't see that as being beneficial.
And the other thing is the actual agency providing the continuum of care, which is a federally mandated function, is scarcely mentioned in the bill at all, not by name, certainly.
And so I think that it's an overreach.
I think that while it's maybe well-intentioned, it's not the solution I would seek.
And I think that we have asked for an audit in order to examine the efficacy and effectiveness of the agency as it exists and have yet to have that information presented.
And so to put more power and more funding and more whatever you want to call it, you know, authority into that agency, it's jumping, putting the cart before the horse.
And so I hope that we can just convince the senator to back off the gas a little bit on this effort, work with us, because for every city and the county and the continuum of care to all be opposed ought to signal that we're not interested in having our future foisted upon us.
So let's work together, would be my ask, and hopefully she'll be receptive to that message.
Thank you.
But I do support the letter.
Thank you, supervisors.
I appreciate always the fact that I have a chance to work with you all who give a great deal of thought to all matters that come before us.
But I think even while we're on recess, attempting to spend time with our families and take a much needed pause in kind of our daily expectations that we're drinking from a firehouse continually.
The fact that we have rallied around making it clear and assessing and explaining the rationale why we hold the position that we do during our recess.
I really want to first start by first start by first start by thanking you all for, in your own ways, being there to do exactly that.
And I certainly would be remiss if I didn't publicly thank all of our professional staff, Alicia, Siobhan and Emily, David Villanueva, and others who have been willing and able to really help us do a very swift but necessary deep dive on why this bill,
and there's no other way to put it, at least from my perspective, really represents bad policy.
And it is unfortunate that the author has put such a comprehensive, has suggested such a comprehensive change very last minute,
as a gut and amend to a bill that I believe she first initiated in the early spring, late winter, February, March timeline,
that at the time was laudable.
I mean, there's the language, if you look back was attempting to, I think, focus attention, rightfully so on foster youth and domestic violence, victimization, and some of the,
I think the well made points relative to those populations that we should be focused on in the context of homelessness and housing.
But really to suggest such an overhaul.
When, as my colleagues have just referenced,
we can look back and see successes in terms of cooperation, collaboration.
And I would say not just with the city of Sacramento, but with the other municipalities in Sacramento County.
And as soon as a month now, maybe not even that, we are going to have in public another opportunity to really understand from staff and hear from various interests parties about,
you know,
you know,
SHRA and their role, past, present and future, what it all means relative to how our continuum of care,
and our ability to support affordable housing,
would work best and should work better.
No one, no one, by the way, is arguing against the Senator that we can and should do things better.
I think it's really,
this is really comes down to how do we, how do we, how do we achieve that?
And so, you know, there is a ton of momentum, I would say, of interest in achieving just that.
What hasn't been said so far is the fact that through my office and working with primarily Councilmember Guerra, City of Sacramento,
we're eagerly looking forward to a, I think it's the first of its kind meeting, at least in terms of the parties that will literally be at the dais of the city council of the city of Sacramento, all five of us from the county, and the mayors of the other cities within Sacramento County, to spend a full day in public.
So, you know, we're going to have a lot of time to talk about this very subject about how to do things better, how to be more effective.
Ultimately, we can all agree that the, the goal here is not a different governance structure.
It's not a new agency, it's not even a different agency.
So, those should be byproducts of us coming up with a blueprint of how to be more effective, of how to make sure that we see fewer people that are living on our streets and our storefronts beneath our bridges and in our parkways.
And quite frankly, the other metric that we must always consider is, especially given the prolonged housing crisis here in the, in the state, is housing people more efficiently, quicker, giving them the opportunity to, to help themselves.
Let's not forget they are party to this as well.
So, again, very unfortunate that this bill overreaches the way it does.
I think we can all tell by the collective opposition and the very little support, quite frankly, that the bill enjoys and that the bill would otherwise enjoys from the very parties that need to be at the table, not on the menu here.
So, again, I want to thank our staff.
I do want to give some direction here that I think it's important direction.
The letter is, I think, has been carefully crafted to communicate the reasons why Sacramento County opposes vehemently this proposal, the way we do, especially those, those legal arguments that I agree with.
Supervisor Desmond, I think, are really kind of the crux of the matter.
But as to those legal matters, I do think because of our significant legal concerns that we've identified thus far, I would like counsel and assume Ms. Travis is sitting there next to you, Flo, to do more formal analysis on the bill.
And have it be returned before the board in public so that we understand just how solid we think those legal arguments are.
And that may actually take us spending some resources for for outside assistance.
But when you think about what this bill is in part attempting to do in terms of forcing forcing us to enter into a new GPA, JPA, that, you know, that raises and should raise a lot of legal questions.
And even all I will note, Sacramento Mayor Kevin McCarty, who, as we all know, introduced a bill last year that would provide some advice.
And that's a big distinction.
And that's a big distinction. It was advisory in terms of a perspective, new governance structure.
But that's why even as the former author of that bill, I don't think I'm going out on a limb here.
That's why even the mayor and the former assembly member strongly opposes the bill the way he does.
So, again, Siobhan, I would like to hear from you just briefly that you acknowledge what I'm requesting.
And if Ms. Travis has any comments, I'd be pleased to hear from her as well.
Absolutely. I acknowledge and will work with Ms. Travis on this issue.
And I will take your request and implement that, certainly.
All right. Very good. And then finally, I know I've been long winded.
I'll end where I think Supervisor Desmond started, which is this is not about wanting to be at odds with our senator.
We welcome and would embrace having her and her staff very, very much involved, even leading us relative to collaboration and doing things better.
That's going to take time. This is the most complicated, complex matter in front of any local government, larger, small county or city.
And so just want to make it clear this is not about personality differences.
This is not about our histories, maybe being on different sides of things.
This is really about wanting to do it carefully, thoughtfully, collaboratively.
And so that welcome, Matt, remains open to the senator.
And we would hope that that she would avail herself to to that to that welcome.
OK, we do need to vote on this matter.
Madam Clerk, do we have anyone sign to speak on the matter from the public?
We do not have anyone signed up for this item.
Supervisor Cerner, before you make your vote, this David Villanova.
I just wanted to confirm that the letter stands as you would like.
I had two supervisors make suggestions or thoughts towards it.
And I just want to confirm that this is going to stand.
If those supervisors who may have made those comments that was lost on me that that was introduced as formal amendment,
but I don't think it was, you tell me it's difficult to assess that from afar here.
I'm seeing no additional changes to the letter. So thank you for confirming that.
I'll go ahead and move the recommended action.
Second.
OK, it's been moved and seconded. Roll call vote, please.
Supervisors Desmond.
Rodriguez.
Aye.
Hume.
Cerner.
Aye.
Unanimous vote with those members present.
Very good. Thank you.
Thank you.
All right. I believe that concludes our morning session, Madam Clerk.
Yes, it does.
Okay, we are scheduled for what appears to be a bit of a lengthy.
Closed session, and we do have a full afternoon calendar.
So it is currently 1215.
Again, I'm going to have to participate remotely.
I understand that the technology is all set up for me to do so in closed session.
I would suggest that we convene in closed session at 1230 if that's agreeable to my colleagues.
Sounds good.
Okay.
Okay.
With that, there's no further business before us for this morning session.
we stand in recess.
All right.
Mr. Chair, we're working on the audio.
Mr. Chair, we're working on the audio.
Mr. Cernik.
Can you hear me?
Yeah.
Okay, now we can hear you.
Okay.
Am I good to open the meeting or not?
We can go ahead and reconvene.
I'd like to call to order, back to order this meeting of the Sacramento County Board of Supervisors for Tuesday, July 8th, 2025, Manapur.
Can you please call the roll and reestablish a quorum?
Yes.
Good afternoon.
Supervisors Desmond Rodriguez.
Here.
Hume.
Here.
Cerna.
Here.
And you have a quorum.
Great.
Thank you.
And let me start by first offering my apologies to those that have been patiently waiting for us to reconvene.
We had a very full closed session.
We did not take any lunches.
So, lest there be any conjecture about us doing anything else other than participating in closed session, that's where we were.
And, again, my apologies for the lateness of the hour.
So, Madam Clerk, my understanding is we have one speaker, one member of the public that waited patiently this morning for off-agenda matters, and I believe she had to leave.
So, we are going to take up that one speaker first, and then we will go through our agenda as published.
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
I'm going to call up Barbara.
Thank you.
Thank you.
I feel really special.
So, thank you, Board of Supervisors.
So, I just wanted to say I recently was at the jail, and we were welcoming people who were being released from the jail, but we don't understand why people are being released from the jail between 6 p.m. and 11 p.m.
because if they need any resources, nobody answers their phone after, like, 5 p.m., so we're not able to really get them the resources they need.
But I have two stories, and one story is this man told me he was walking to his car in the morning, going to work, and it was parked next to a stolen car, a stolen truck.
And the police or the sheriffs, I don't remember which one, accused him of stealing the truck.
He's like, I have a truck.
Why would I steal a truck?
And they took him in, and so he was one of the people who was released, and he said to me, as his family was picking him up in their SUV, BMW, now I have to go save my job.
And this other woman told me that she was going to turn herself in.
She had missed her arraignment.
I don't even know what an arraignment is.
Most people don't.
She missed her arraignment period, or appointment.
And so she thought she was going to spend five days in jail.
And she's like, I'll spend five days in jail.
Weird, but okay.
But the sheriff told her if she turns herself in, she's spending 155 days in jail.
She's like, I have a daughter.
I have a job.
I have a house.
I can't spend 155 days in jail.
So the point of this is we're sort of creating homeless people.
If you lose your job, you lose your house.
And these two folks, I don't know what the woman was supposed to have done, but the man didn't do anything except walk to his car and end up in jail.
I just wanted to bring that to your attention.
Can we try releasing people during business hours so we can get them some help?
Thank you.
Thank you, Barbara.
I would suggest, and I don't know, Mr. CEO, if it's possible.
I can't see who from our executive team is in chambers or not, but in terms of the release times, there's a lot of nuance to it, some of which is actually constitutional.
So I would offer that Barbara should probably hear from, at least have maybe a phone conversation at the very least, someone from the public defender's office so that can be shared in terms of why releases happen when they do.
Supervisor, Deputy County Executive Eric Jones is also here, so we'll put them together too.
Thank you.
Very good.
Thank you.
Next item.
Okay, for item 52, this is the Sacramento County Youth Commission Annual Report.
Good afternoon, Chair Serna, members, board members, and County Executive David Villanueva and Executive Leadership Team.
My name is Rochelle Relanca, and I'm the advisor to the Youth Commission.
The Youth Commission is bringing forth their annual report and will be giving the board an update on activities related to racial and economic justice, civic engagement, public health, education, and environmental advocacy.
I would like to introduce the executive members who are with us today, Joyce Lynn, our Commission Chair, and Diana Hawes, Social Media Chair.
I'll turn it over to Chairperson Lynn, who would like to say a few opening words and introduce the other commissioners.
Thank you.
Good afternoon.
We are the Sacramento County Youth Commission, and we're excited to be able to report our accomplishments this past year, as well as inform you of our upcoming projects.
The Board of Supervisors' support is integral for our work, so we would like to thank you for your help and look forward to increasing amounts of collaboration in the future.
My name is Joyce Lynn, and I am the Chair of the Youth Commission.
I am proud to stand alongside another senior, Celine Kinn, who is a dedicated member of the Commission.
I know she will do amazing things in both her academic and community organizing careers.
Other commission leaders include Vice Chairperson Jolie Dang and Secretary Mackenzie Olmsted.
Some commissioners who have served the community this past year include Brooklyn Pruitt, Joy McDaniel, Jolie Dang, Diana House, Marissa Vaughn, and Mackenzie Olmsted.
Others include Emmanuel Emmanfore, Jamie Stevenson, Justin Huang, and Kushi Shukla.
The Sacramento County Youth Commission is a 15-member advisory board for Sacramento youth.
Three commissioners from each of our five supervisorial districts serve on the commission in three-year terms.
The commission was established as a leadership panel providing an advocating voice to the county's youth,
notifying the board of supervisors of youth-related activities and concerns.
In the past year, our commission aimed to build a more prominent presence within the community.
We initiated collaborations with local organizations and schools, including Three Sisters Garden and Helen Carr Castello Elementary School.
We also wanted to foster stronger social media networks that promoted youth events throughout the county,
including events that we could attend as individuals or table at as a commission.
The development of promotional materials also opens up opportunities to connect with youth across the county on an individual level,
promoting civic engagement with youth involvement in bureaucracy.
As a result of prioritizing collaboration and networking,
we have been able to establish connections with nonprofits and local youth for current and future projects.
We are also able to foster a larger online community of passionate youth interested in getting involved.
These new connections will allow us to build a larger audience and cause a larger impact in future newsletters and events.
We are extremely excited to see what we will be able to accomplish in the future as we build upon the progress we've made thus far.
Within the commission, we decided to focus on five prominent issues that impact youth across the county.
We continued racial and economic justice and education from 2024.
Environmental care was renamed to environmental advocacy, not to only bring awareness, but also to promote action.
Voter engagement became civic engagement to broaden our focus to youth participation in government as a whole.
And health and safety was renamed public health so we could focus on all perspectives of health, including physical, mental, and emotional.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
And now, people in Newży, you're there, and 1akers.
And it is an expansion of an existing land sea
road near the intersection with El Rio Boulevard. The area has a mix of uses in it including
agricultural residential, industrial, and our interim agricultural reserve. I would also
note that to the west there is an existing WAPA substation. So this Elverda substation
was established in 1954 and it is nearing the end of its service life. That expansion
is going to be on an AR parcel and they will be demolishing the existing home and
the associated livestock operation. So this item before the board is a board review
for consistency with the general plan, community plan, and zoning code. You aren't making any
determination on the substation just that it is consistent with our documents. So SMUD is the
Sequa Lead Agency. They have already prepared an initial study. It was adopted by their board.
This is a site plan. It gives you a look at what that is going to look like.
Landscape plan staff did work with SMUD to have enhanced landscaping along that Elverda
road frontage. And staff would recommend that you recognize that SMUD as the lead agency under
section 21067 of Sequa and that you adopt the attached resolution of the board of supervisors determining that the El Rio substation is consistent with the general plan, community plan, and zoning code.
I can answer any questions you may have. And SMUD representatives are also here if you have any questions of them.
Thank you. Thank you. Any questions from my colleagues?
Okay. Hearing none. Madam Clerk, do we have anyone sign up to speak on the matter?
We do not have anyone signed up.
Okay. Very good.
I will go ahead and move the recommended action.
Very good. It's been moved. Is there a second?
Chair will second. So we have a motion and a second. If there's no further questions, roll call vote, please.
Supervisors Desmond, Rodriguez, Hume, Serna.
Aye.
Unanimous vote with those members present.
Thank you. Next item, please.
Yes. Moving on to item 57. This is to approve the 2024 annual reports for the Antelope, Art and Arcade, Carmichael, Florin Road, Fulton Avenue, and Watt Avenue property and business improvement districts, and provide for the levy of assessments for fiscal year 2526.
Here we go.
Okay. Thank you very much. Good afternoon, Chair Serna, members of the board.
My name is Vanessa Lieberman. I'm your manager of special districts in the Department of Community Development.
Thank you for raising. Yeah, that's perfect. Thank you.
The item before you today is a request for approval of the annual reports for our six property and business improvement districts,
as well as the approval of resolutions to levy taxes for this fiscal year.
This year, with the direction and leadership of Tracy Shaw and her amazing team at Community Strong Strategies, who's here with us today,
we are piloting a more uniformed approach to our PBID presentations.
Each PBID executive director will speak on behalf of their district, and we will be doing so in alphabetical order.
But first, I will kick this off and eventually update my LinkedIn profile, because that's where that picture is from.
A little outdated.
For our districts, we are a combined size of over 337 million square feet, with a combined budget of 3.1 million.
For budget allocations, our districts spend on average of 70% of their budgets on clean and safe.
And just this last year alone, they produced over 225 tons of trash and had over 13,000 dispatch calls for service.
And now, it's my pleasure to introduce from 80-watt PBID, Mr. Spencer Eberle, who's our board chair and will be stepping in on behalf of our executive director, Jason Wendt.
Thank you.
Good afternoon. Thank you.
Thank you.
Unfortunately, our executive director, Jason, was unable to attend today.
He asked me to read this brief message for you.
Good afternoon, supervisors.
While I regret that I cannot be there in person to share my energy and volume to the chamber's proceedings,
I wish to thank each and every one of you for your support, especially Supervisor Rich Desmond of District 3, which our PBID resides.
Without your support, we would have not made the progress that we experience.
From the RT station to the complete streets to the safe say, we are making progress.
I wish also to thank all of our law enforcement and first responders who do such great work.
The various task force operations that have been conducted to help rescue trafficked individuals has made a real difference.
Supervisor Rodriguez, I was honored to see you at the Drive for Impact Celebrity Golf Tournament, which raises money in the fight against trafficking.
We have come a long way and we have a long way to go.
We will continue to fight and we will do it together.
Again, thank you all.
P.S.
I'm sure you received your gifts the next time we see each other.
Have a great day, Jason.
All right.
So I will be brief.
So our district, which is in District 3, bounds by Cap City Freeway and Roseville Road.
As you can see, most of our budget is allocated to security and maintenance, 75%, which we made a change in 2023.
It continues to be the priority of the board and the district to make sure that it is a clean and safe place for people to come.
Most of the properties in our district are made up of light industry, mixed warehousing, and other uses.
However, a great deal of them are front customer-facing on Want Avenue.
In fact, the majority of them are, which brings a great deal of commerce and visualization to our area.
Our board of supervisors, of which one of them is Mr. Desmond's chief of staff, which we very much appreciate her guidance and wisdom.
As always, in terms of safety, as you can see, we have a very high volume of officer observations and dispatch service calls,
as well as a great deal of cleanup that we do for the district.
I think it's important to know that working with our law enforcement partners, we continue to focus on augmenting safety and quality of life issues.
And hopefully, at some point, we will be able to concentrate on other factors.
But at this time, that remains our priority.
Some of the challenges and opportunities that we have is that while our district continues to challenge, be challenged by unfavorable reputation,
we see many future opportunities that have been mentioned.
The upgrading of the 80-watt RT station, the completion of the complete streets, which has been, as you may know, a long time coming,
and finally, the safe stay, which has an opening date, possibly later this year in our district.
Some of the successes we've seen is that in the last year or two, we have seen a huge increase of grants and outside funding to augment our county budget.
And we are very proud of our non-assessed benefits and in-kind donations.
Lastly, for next year, one of the most important things that we are looking forward to is the completion of the complete streets.
We feel this is an opportunity for rebranding and a remarketing of our area.
It is moving at an extremely fast pace that I don't think we've all expected, and it is rather beautiful.
I am very impressed of how it looks so far.
And lastly, the safe stay.
We have been receiving it with open arms, we hope, in its success, and it is needed in our area.
It is something that we feel passionately about, that the people that are there need those services.
And if this can be an example of a place that things can get done, then I think that it will be a very positive thing to our district.
So, in conclusion, I would like to again thank Supervisor Desmond and his staff for his continued advocacy and support for our district.
Thank you.
Great. Thank you. Supervisor Desmond?
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
And I have to say I'm a little disappointed Jason isn't here because we were kind of hitting this afternoon lull, and I was hoping he'd be here to kind of pick us up, pick the energy up here.
But that's okay.
He brings a lot of energy.
And it occurs to me with those photos, there's only one person I know who takes more selfies than Jason Wendt.
He has that talent down.
That's for sure.
But I just thank you for the presentation, and thank you for your thoughts and sentiments about the SafeState community.
I mean, it's not just me, but I think my colleagues, we are all committed to making sure that's a success not only for the people who are going to help at that facility, but for the surrounding community.
And we will continue to partner with ADWatt to make sure we mitigate issues that come up, and it becomes a net positive for that surrounding community.
So appreciate your support.
Appreciate your continued partnership and openness to this.
Thank you.
Yours as well, sir.
Thank you.
Have a good day.
Great comment.
Thank you.
Supervisor Desmond?
Okay.
Next up, we have Executive Director from Antelope PBID, Mr. Chris Evans.
Thank you.
Good afternoon.
How are you?
I'm glad I'm not following Jason as well, by the way.
First of all, I want to start off by saying, as we always do, thank you so much for the services you all provide to us.
You know, the PBIDs rely on the supervisors on an ongoing basis, and I know that lots of times throughout the year we have issues come up.
We don't always even agree on the issues, but the one thing we always know about the five of you up here is that you're doing it with the best intentions for the community.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Okay.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
I've received consistent help every single year from Michael Middleton, and I just wanted to let you know today
that for six years now Michael has been an
unbelievable help to me as we've done these annual reports, and I appreciate his support and
This year has been great. The reports been great, but I just wanted to call up Michael personally and say thank you for that
The district footprint is very very simple
We have a budget about three hundred eighty five thousand dollars a year the footprint remains the same year after year after year
We renewed last year and the expansion was basically one additional property which included the
Library system so that we would have a meeting place. We only have three categories in the district. We have vacant
Apartment complexes and commercials, so it's really really simple and and very easy. We're a bedroom community
Our main focus is safety when this district was formed when the original board of directors got together and started forming this
It was all about safety so and that's why the board that we have now
Which is continuing on which is Steve is our current chair
And he's going to talk here in just a minute and then we have Rochelle Espinosa from Winco
Which is she's in charge of loss prevention and she's helping us and of course Sam Wingard who's now with Rome properties. He's our treasurer
the
Service impacts of this district and this is the one I'm really proud of eighteen hundred and forty calls for service within our district that represents
about 20 minutes per call
Which means about six hundred and thirteen hours of time that our security team spent handling issues that sworn officers
Didn't try to handle and that's one of the things. I'm very very proud of us
Our security team is constantly working in the district to handle the problems that sworn officers shouldn't have to handle
You know when Bob is asleep in front of a liquor store
We've got this problem or that problem. It just doesn't make sense to have a sworn deputy come out and do that
So our team really steps up and they work to make sure that every year we're doing that this last year. We saved four lives
We've with Narcan just as recently as about four days ago was the most recent time where we're rolling up on people and finding them passed out and
getting them the medical attention they need to save their life so that's very rewarding and then cleanliness wise you all know
as far as the clean team we were very privileged for many years to have the clean team program down in the river district and
And they that board of directors supported the the program and in January because of all the budget cuts and things had to change
So I've been very very fortunate that the Antelope PBID
Board of directors has continued the clean team program and now the Florin PBID has also got the clean team program
So we actually have people that were hiring other shelters who are now doing maintenance within the districts and restoring themselves to full-time employment
I've been able to take that program that we originally had in the river district and keep it going in Antelope and in Florin
And we're going to talk to a couple of the other PBIDs and see if we might start being able to put the program into their maintenance as well
And one last thing I'll say about that before I'm gonna let Steve come up here and tell you all the wonderful things we've got coming up in the district
But the other thing I'm very very proud of is you know
The city of Sacramento due to budget cuts had to cut the streets team program now the streets team was where individuals who are homeless
Could go out and work and they'd volunteer and then they receive gift cards in exchange for that work and unfortunately the city couldn't keep funding that because of the budget cuts
Well, we're very lucky that in Antelope and in Florin we're going to continue that program through the clean team program
And we're going to continue taking people who are on the streets and looking for a way back to recover
We're going to provide them with that opportunity
And that's one of the things I'm most excited about is we're able to take this particular program and expand it
So instead of doing maintenance in the districts, we're restoring lives as well
And that's what really excites me and what I'm looking forward to in the future
This district was originally formed by Jeremy Krug who was our original chairman
He spent about four years putting together and then three years serving as chairman and then he was followed up immediately by Steve from
Lischwab tires who's been an unbelievable help every single day
I'm bugging him about something different and he's answering a problem or solving a problem for me
And so it's my pleasure now to introduce to you Steve Amstutz and he's our chairman of the board
Thank you for making me sound good
Thank you number one. You guys are amazing at what you do for us
I've been in Antelope for 22 years. I moved there to open my store
And I watched all the years me calling the sheriff all the time because we had a huge problem
Because we had this big creek behind us and the homeless camping out and everything and
Jeremy came to me and Percy who owns the McDonald's and the three of us were kind of the ones that got this started going all those years ago and
initially like he said it was all about security and
I can't imagine
Antelope business community without having our P bid anymore. It just the
the difference that our security team does and how great they work with our sheriff's department and
We can call them and they're at our store immediately if we have a problem or whatever
But the biggest thing that changed now since we renewed and everything is our maintenance teams
our community is clean and our community looks great and
it's the the three guys two or three guys depend on the time of the year that we have in our maintenance team all being former homeless guys
And the pride those guys take and what they do in our community
They are antelope residents
Basically, even though they only work in our community right now
um
They are phenomenal and they take such pride and it's so much a joy for me watching these guys and they come in and they're so
respectful and they just want to be
Proud members of our communities that produce great work and that's what they do and that's what we're being able to give them and that's why I
Encourage the other p bits to jump on board and do this because the maintenance deal and getting these people off the street
It's a win-win for everybody
And so I appreciate you guys giving us the money to help this. I mean granted work paint your we're paying our tax on it
but it's it's still it's it's wonderful and
Encouraged to help get the maintenance going more because that is the biggest reward out of it
Yeah, the security has to be there, but the maintenance has been the neatest reward is seeing these people succeed
So thank you very much
You know once again super
We just want to close by saying thank you very much for what you do
We appreciate you and we look forward to the next year. We look for some really exciting things in antelope
I just have some comments now. I know who Jason is
And yes supervisor supervisor desmond. Yes, he has me beat. We're definitely more it's an art
Three seconds. Um, chris. I just want to say thank you for all the work that you do in antelope
And I got to learn um of antelope
uh in the middle of 2023 and got to really get to visit and study and um
learn of some of the challenges that the
That the town experiences, but you guys do really truly remarkable work in um, you're right in the safety
I think we have to in this next year work on the
Illegal firework issues that happen, but for them you guys just do phenomenal job
And I just want to thank you for that. Did you say you're with Les Schwab? Yes. Okay, so Les Schwab
Let me tell you, you know, I had it one of those encounters. I can't remember the gentleman's name
But my car sensor light went on I drove in and they had my tires checked and fixed and then I said, okay
What what what what's the charge and they're like no charge?
So I just got to say I really appreciated that and to do that in a community and not
Not know, you know, not know
Um, who they were who I was but it was it was a pleasure to
Um encounter and I would want to do business with Les Schwab just because of that it was
exceptional
Quickie little thing Les Schwab told us always years ago treat everyone like it's your grandparent
Because everyone loves their grandparents not everyone loves their parents
And so less had so many great things that he used to tell us and that was one of them
And that's one of the big reasons why we do those kind of things for people
Yeah, because that's what you would do for your grandparent and you know what I did I took a selfie with that salesman
And posted it and tagged Les Schwab. So thank you
appreciate it. Thank you very much
Okay, any other
questions
We have executive director from Arden arcade peepin mr. Dionne dyer
And i'm going to take full credit for mr. Middleton to all that praise so thank you chris
Well, that's a lot to follow all right, um, I would like to add robert height in the selfie competition for the metro chamber tubes
Anyways, okay. Good afternoon chair serna via video fellow board with supervisors. My name is deon dwyer
I'm representing the arden how business alliance today
And at first i'd like to run you through our district footprint
We start the county line arden and hurley running two miles down east to arden way to watt
And then roughly one mile south down howland hurley
This area encompasses about 13.5 million square feet with a total budget of 533 000 dollars
80 is dedicated to clean safe a constant theme around here
But that's really the public private partnership. I think the pbids provide
We represent 163 property owners who lease to 429 businesses
We are commercial centric district with nearly three quarters of the district commercial property
We have a very active board of directors
That was led last year by chris brocchini in 2024 and kevin fatt will be our board chair for 2025
As mentioned 80 of our budget is focused on clean and safe services a few highlights our security team
We utilize sacramento protective services is very active in district with an average of 645 interactions a month
And of those 32 have been elevated high-level incidences
On the clean side of the house our dedicated team from accurate cleaning
Has removed over 22 tons of debris from the district along with
217 large graffiti items mitigated and 86 illegal dumps removed
In 2024 we leaned into issues in the district that continued to cause harm for our groups
We helped to bring together an organized retail theft group comprised of national brand businesses and assisted in sting operations
With help from the sheriff's department that led to several successful prosecutions from the district attorney's office
To assist in these efforts. We also started a multi-agency communication network
Comprised of arden mall security sacramento police department cal expo police department the sacramento sheriff's department and the district attorney's office
One of the unique pieces of our pbid is right on many jurisdictional boundaries
And so we're trying to increase the communication within those groups
Some of our successes in 2024 was the support of the passage of prop 36 and the reduction of retail theft over the course of the year in december
We saw a notable notable decline in retail theft after hosting a press conference with supervisor desmond da ten ho and sheriff jim cooper
This effort also led to expanding our security network to include the greater ardent chamber of commerce in the sacramento chamber of commerce
In assisting and arming our businesses and local businesses with proper tools for combating retail theft
As we move into 2025 we're focused on expanding our outreach efforts continuing our branding as new district
This is a very key aspect for us and supporting our arcade events to bring people into the district to strengthen the safety and maintenance efforts through our existing partnerships
With that I would like to thank a few people county staff definitely troy and his team
With community development crystal and her team with economic development and of course supervisor desmond and his staff of whom vanessa does sit on our board
And is a great resource for our group
Last but not least i'd be remiss if I did not call out our sheriff command
Captain griddle stone he is a strong voice for law and order if you know him you know what i'm talking about
And our district attorney's office ron lithicum
He's been a linchpin in our efforts to help turn the tide of public safety in our area
So with that i'd like to thank you for your time today and think supervisor desmond for his support of this district
Thank you very much any comments from the colleagues
Mr. Chair i'll just get some obligatory comments here for the other people in my district. Thank you
Thank you
Dionne for all your work and and the same comments or similar comments to what i made to 80 watt
Is the the ardent pbid also the newest in sacramento county you're doing a great job so much potential
But also on the edge is some some big social services projects in the county permanent supportive housing projects behavioral health
Related projects and I know at times that can be a concern for some of your members
But the same commitment goes to you and and and your members that the county will
Remain a good partner with you to address issues that that come up
And we appreciate your support for these projects too because they do so much to improve the community. So thank you. Absolutely. Thank you supervisor
Very good. Thank you very much. Okay next up. We have our newest
Executive director with car michael peepin miss samantha beck
Hello, thank you so much for having me
Really excited to share all that we were able to accomplish in car michael through the past year and what we have coming up
If we have not yet met my name is samantha beck and I just started as the executive director in december
So i'm going to start with some district highlights
And as you can see our footprint is huge we have over
266 million square feet and with a total budget of just over
561 000 that means every single dollar is working very hard
The majority of our budget about 61 percent is focused on clean and safe efforts which really underscore our ongoing commitment to safety and maintenance
It's our belief that if clean and safe comes first the rest will fall into place
So from there we invest in streetscape economic enhancements advocacy and of course our contingency as we focus on our renewal in 2031
Our district serves about a thousand businesses and 363 property owners covering a diverse mix of property types
As you can see retails by far our largest sector at over 50 percent and that really shows the character and energy of car michael
The strong retail presence reflects a community of residents who love to shop and
play and live or excuse me and invest in where they live
They're really investing directly into the neighborhood's economy and our small business owners
And beyond retail we have a strong office and industrial representation which shows that car michael
Is not just living and shopping there, but they also work there. So they're truly investing in every part of local life
I also want to take a minute to recognize our board so we have a fantastic group of leaders
that volunteer and put their time and dedication and expertise into what we do
As you might know the cid was has been often on board and volunteer run since its formation
So every single name on this list has been a key played a key role in our organization and in our success
So I just definitely want to thank them for their expertise
Our clean and safe work continues to be the cornerstone of all that we do so on the safety side
Our officers are through the sacramento protective services and they take a proactive approach and work closely with the sac sheriff's department
To achieve our shared goal of public safety
Their partnership and strong presence which is from 7 a.m. to 7 p.m. Every single day and two night patrols
Help deter crime and keep a safe keep a safer environment for car michael
We've also started to include our community partners so we've included car michael heart community health works and the library in our monthly meetings
So that way we're you're ensuring that we're addressing community needs holistically
It's very heartwarming when you see someone who's been a security concern and in the security report almost every day
Start to accept resources like rehabilitation and housing and so we want to make sure that we're really celebrating those wins and that we're celebrating them together
And on the clean and maintenance side we've removed over
126,000 pounds of trash that's 63 tons
So much trash and so much graffiti and stickers and everything in between you can see the numbers here
And our team is incredible at getting that done and I want to thank
Hillary gold and rich as meal for their consistent work and dedication to our district
So we've got some really great opportunities coming up, so we're going to keep focusing on business attraction and economic vitality
We're going to be building on our momentum that we've already
Completed with beautification projects and our safety improvements, but we're also going to be prioritizing strategic
Beautification and septet improvements septet stands for crime prevention through environmental design
We're really focusing on transforming our problem areas into safer spaces
These strategies they're really they're not just about aesthetics. They're truly about taking care of our business owners and our businesses and
Promoting investment getting more people to be interested in developing into our district
So this past year we've had some really great wins that we get to celebrate
So we maintain strong cleanliness and security throughout our whole district
We launched the smud utility box project which doesn't just brighten up the district but helps deter graffiti
We also completed significant septet projects and lighting and landscaping totaling
$21,000
And also on a personal note. I was honored to be appointed as ed this year and i'm really grateful
I get to serve I grew up in carmichael and I get to serve there every single day and it's really rewarding
So some goals we have for the upcoming year of course finishing our street banners and completing our smud box wraps
We are continuing to explore monument signage for carmichael and continuing frontage landscaping
And as I said earlier, we're going to be deepening our septet efforts
Working on those improvements and we're also working on expanding our engagement with
uh brokers and property owners through events and business walks so our next event is on august 26
It's called carmichael connect and it's in collaboration with the county office of economic development
We're hosting this event to bring together developers brokers and property owners and the county all in one space
So we can show them all that carmichael has to offer
And see what we can do to get them to invest get them to choose carmichael
So that's our next event on august 26
And again, all of these goals are
about
and advancing and uh, just boosting on the momentum that we already have we want to make carmichael more vibrant
We want to make it more sustainable and more safe for not just people who live there but the people who choose to visit
So I definitely I want to thank everybody all the uh
Each and every one of you. I especially want to thank our supervisor rich desmond. You have been key
And uh making sure that we're a success you have been incredibly supportive to us and we're very thankful for you
So thank you all
Thank you
All right comments from colleagues. Mr. Chair, I apologize. I have to thank sam sam. Thank you
We're so happy to have you in the district. I apologize that I live so close to the district
So you hear from me all the time
But I I really appreciate you calling out economic development and the partnership and and doing the business walks with
Property owners. I mean, I think that's you know something that we have really been striving for here is to really kind of find a way to crack
That nut and get more investment housing investment commercial investment business investment along these older commercial corridors
And really appreciate you calling that out highlighting that because uh, you know the county will do everything we can to help you in that regard and attract
Um these investors in these communities and fair oaks boulevard is a prime candidate for that. It is. Thank you so much
Thank you
All right another presenter yeah next up is corey drew our executive director from florin road
Peep
Got to make it short size
Oh, no, I got it. Thank you. I got it. Thank you
Uh, that's my glamour shot everyone
There you go
Straight from the 90s
District highlights. Um
Good afternoon board of supervisors. Thank you for having us here today
My name is corey drew and i'm the executive director of thornwood partnership. You'll have to forgive me. I'm a little bit tired
as you all are been here since
all after day, so
um, I wanted to start with some of our district highlights
um, this you'll have to forgive me this is my first time with a slide on
Doing this after nine years i'm used to a video and other things so
Um as you could see we have 25 million square feet our total budget
590 000 as with most everyone else 54
um
And more go into our clean and safe proposals. We have marketing capital improvements
advocacy and economic development and administration and then of course our contingency and reserve
Um, you could see our district map here. We actually span both city and county
With the largest white strip highway 999
If you look just to the left franklin boulevard everything to the left of franklin boulevard is all city jurisdiction
So we actually have almost half city and half county
So it's a very unique beast
We have 341 parcels
I think this one's working better. We have 341 parcels
Hello, okay, uh our top property types we have educational services health care and social assistance retail trade
and county and public administration
We have 215 properties and over 500 businesses last count it was something about 525
Our board of directors
long time board president barbara e trick
And of course our county supervisor
patrick kennedy's representative so chi comas he does an amazing job on our board of directors
So we have 3000 calls for service
What I want to say about this is that although we had 3000 calls for service our security provider
California patrol operations actually performed an additional
5400 patrol stops
Where they just go and check on the businesses without needing to be called
So that's 8 000
8 000 businesses and calls that we service
And in addition to our clean and safe numbers
We had over
We have over 58 000 pounds or 29 000 tons
But in fact
Our maintenance successes with the work with clean california. We had 121 additional cubic yards removed and out of the floor and light rail station
We had 226 cubic yards removed just not including what you're seeing in the numbers here. These are additional to our stats
So that's one of our big bellies
That used to be a trash can
um our budget i'd like to say that while the problems have increased the um
The budget hasn't quite followed it. So it really we have needs for security. We have escalating
labor and maintenance expenses
um with dumpster fees equipment and replacement costs trash cans right now
We're in the process of having to replace our entire fleet of trash cans in our district, which is a unit of 30
New trash cans cost on average a thousand dollars
So it's a 30 000 investment to replace the trash cans within the district
Here we go our successes i'm really happy about winter fest
We had uh, we had over 465 skaters
We had even four we had little two-year-olds and on out on the rink skating
We also had our first national night out and we also had our mixed in pink
um floor and road
um breast cancer walk which we did all along floor and road with um every banner marked down
So our goals for 2025 2026 is to continue to light up floor and road
We've already purchased these banners and these lights. Um, it was a hundred thousand dollar investment
So we look forward to installing them for the first time this year
We are also expanding our business navigator program
um with our profession preparation for renewal in 2027
um
We have
already outreached since january to over 250 businesses
With a personal touch and personal reach and ask them what they need and how we can support them better
um beautification we're going to be launching new banners
Which are on our city side currently we'll be putting those out. It's all youth
Led art so if you've seen the purple banners welcome to florin road, that's all art done by our local youth
So we'll be continuing that on to the county side now
Thank you
That's what I have to say for this the slideshow's got me a little off you guys, but I just really want to say that
As we go forward we're going to focus on long-term placemaking and economic development. We want to have a sense of neighborhood pride
Art expansion winterfest expansion our business navigator program and then as
um chris evans has already mentioned the job creation through the sac nav clean team
Which is now rolling on florin road
They have collected thus far
More than any record we've ever had in the history of florin or partnerships, so we're looking at
Probably the month of july will smash every record
of maintenance successes, and so i'm really looking forward to the numbers coming out
Um, we're working on job certification and programs for those folks in the sac nav program
and
Finally that's a aerial but it's the freeway and if you can imagine florin road goes all the way down
Both sides of highway 99
We wouldn't be where we are with the support of the sacramento county and the board of supervisors
And so I just wanted to say thank you very much for that
That's it thank you very much any comments
All right
Okay rounding out our presentations will be executive director melinda michael from fulton peabit
Good afternoon almost evening
Chairman cerna and members of the board of supervisors
Thank you for giving me the opportunity today to
Let you know what's going on in fulton avenue and how things have been going this past year our
Sorry, I also am not used to
this
um
Kind of used to freewheeling it but that's not going to happen today
All righty so our district
uh footprint is is really quite simple we we have a linear line of 2.8 miles
And that's all on fulton avenue between arden way and the cap city freeway
We do have some delineations and the major intersections
within that that distance
And that was something that was decided very early on in the formation of our district
Um, our district was formed in 1998 by a handful of very
uh
um
Invested and committed property owners that that
Had owned properties on fulton avenue for decades and
had
They just began seeing this antiquation of
Not only the infrastructure but
The properties and they'd had enough so they came to the county and said what do we do
And we've been um, I think one of the most one of the more successful pbids in terms of what we've been able to accomplish
um
since our inception
We renewed
in 2023
for
Another five years. We had an 82 percent
Approval rating and we were very excited about that. This is not a time for pbids to disappear.
This is a this is a time for pbids to emerge
And I think that certainly i've seen that over the last 22 years when I started this position in 2003
There were three of us in the county in the city and now I believe there are 19
So, um, it's a really good thing to do
We have a very high percentage of auto commercial property in our district
In 2011 when we put together in partnership with the county and shra and spa
um
It was estimated we had approximately 105 acres of auto commercial land
within our district alone now
Understanding that not all of that land is is car dealerships. It is also car repair and
car related businesses, but fulton avenue
Really since its development in the 40s and the 50s
Um, has remained an auto centric
Destination and we we hold to that to this day
We have 132 property owners that I will call my family
And they would call me their family. We work very closely together
And have for quite a long time
To do what to maintain our
Uh position in terms of revenue generation
Um to keep our long-standing businesses where they are
And to bring in new new business new diverse business. We've got a number of
of restaurants
um that are very popular we and they bring people in and out of the district every day in addition to the 35 40 000
Commuters that we have that go east and west and north and south
um
We have a wonderful board of directors
uh our leadership at the moment
uh
Includes mike grace mike is a retired general manager of fulton el community recreation and park district
And is currently the interim chair of the sacramento parks foundation. So he
He he's our he's our community green man
And then we have dave spencer who does a lot of automotive
uh
Internet sales and marketing he is his expertise has been very valuable tom chrisman
owner of jerry's paint and supply very high-end car
paint and body shop and then christine cahill reams ceo of charles c bell incorporated charles c bell is our number one property owner
um
Also members of our board very very helpful
with their ideas and their support with anything that is needed to
keep this organization healthy miss derek neelo teresa higgins
Felix lou larry fulkerson a local real estate agent jim pardone used to work for the department of economic development sacramento county
assistance league we have representation from
Um, um
Our big business our small business and we appreciate everything that each brings to the table
Service our our clean and safe programs along with our other
partners and friends here
um
It it it encompasses the bulk of our budget our security budget is
uh
About 60 percent and our our clean budget
budget is a little bit behind and those two are our two contractors work very closely together sps security as our security team
and
uh
district maintenance incorporated
uh... hillary gold and his staff take care of our clean up and our maintenance pamela and miguel
our our street walkers and picker uppers every day they do a fabulous
job and so does hillary managing them and everyone else that he has to deal with on a daily basis
Um, wow, well, there's no question that challenges that we've had are directly related to
uh, the unhoused and
um, and also just general criminal activity
I won't speak speak too much about retail theft we have town and country village which has some mid-box businesses in it
um, but it's really our mark
Walmart neighborhood market and the five below that get the most
uh, the most
Troublemakers and uh, there's a lot of you know to and fro between our security and those those properties
we're trying to
Minimize the calls for service that come in from those properties because we've got 132
properties that need attention
um
Public and private trash. I can't tell you we have a department of human assistance in our in our district
And at the end of the day 530 that parking lot is full of trash every people that pull in there to
avail themselves of the services
Avail the parking lot with their trash and take off
So that's something that we really don't deal with we don't clean up private properties
We clean up the street and the common areas
But I think we could we could work a little bit more closely with some of the property owners and tenants to clean up their own properties
Um vandalism we have an immense amount of vandalism that occurs
We know that a lot of it is is related to the unhoused not all of it
um, we're trying to keep a pulse on that
uh, we have a
I can't say enough for organization. We I would say that we're for we're thriving we struggle in many of the ways that other pbids struggle
um, but I would say we don't struggle in in the sense
That our property and business owners
um
Have any real beef with us we are all working together to
um
make things better and
They all understand that with the exception of a handful of folks. They all understand that and
uh, that makes life a little bit easier and a little bit better on Fulton Avenue
We have two signature events that I'll wrap up with one is the uh
Holiday tree lighting that we have the first Saturday in December
And this has been uh happening in our little local community of our arcade for
17 years now we started off in tognati's parking lot
We now are in the department of human assistance parking lot. We planted a sequoia
uh
Five years ago now and
It's about 52 feet tall now and we we decorate that tree
We call it the tree of grace and we light it up that first Saturday
It's a free event for the community. We have free food music
Entertainment and it's a it's a lovely uh revered event in our arcade
Especially there on Fulton Avenue and then cruise fest
We're in our 14th year this year cruise fest on Fulton Avenue
We have been in partnership with the California Auto Museum
That partnership
uh was very successful and they've decided to go their way and we've gone ours
And so we will be holding our 14th annual cruise fest
On Saturday, September 13th and the proceeds benefiting
Shriners children and
The Fulton El Camino Recreation and Park District programs for seniors and children
Uh, I'll make some models go to cruise fest on Fulton Avenue.com to register your car
And come out. It's a free event for the for the community and it's something that we look forward to every year
Few short goals
We're just going to keep doing what we're doing
Uh, we are creating a 501c3 and um, that will be something that greatly benefits us and thank you supervisor desmond for helping us with that
Budget item we appreciate that very much
Um, we've got in street monuments that need repair we're working on that
Uh, increasing our social media visibility that's somewhat related to our events too
Uh, decrease the number of security calls of course ideally that we would like to do that
Uh, develop an owner members only platform that is something we've never done because we're all pretty open with our communication
Thank you
Are there any questions for me or comments?
Thank you very much
Uh, any comments or questions from colleagues?
Uh, mr. Chair, thank you melinda
Uh representing the venerable fulton avenue association. I'm sure it's the is that that's the first, uh
PBIT forming unincorporated technical accounting correct?
Correct. I think it was really kind of the proof of concept
To show that this new model can be just a tremendous success in these unincorporated communities
So I thank you for your your experience there and what you've done has just been a tremendous asset
I was going to mention cruise fest and the christmas tree lighting those are those are great events for that art and arcade community
And I want to throw the gauntlet down to dion because you need to develop some of your own events
And the ardent peepid as well dion to match some of these and what melinda's done. Yeah dion
But I know you I know you also bring it on dion
You also have some some challenges that you face and you work with our office
Um a lot and I'll I I will commit to continue to work with you to address some of these things
I know it can be frustrating for you and your members, but thank you for taking care of the uh auto retailers who
Contribute so generously to the county coffers with that sales tax revenue that we need to preserve. Thank you
Thank you. Thank you supervisor. Thank you melinda
Okay, thank you to the executive directors and the board chair for what for the presentations today
So at this time staff would like to recommend the approval of the annual reports and resolutions to authorize the levy of assessments for fiscal year
2526 i'll go ahead and move the recommended action second
Okay, uh, we have a motion and a second. Uh, madam clerk. Do we have anyone from the public that has signed up to speak on the
matter?
We do not have anyone for this item
Okay, very good motion a second. Please, uh
Do a roll call vote supervisors desmond rodriguez. Hi hume cerna
Hi, and the motion passes unanimously with those members present
Thanks again to all of our
PBID executive directors and staff and
Institutions like hillary
Wanted to make mention of that after the last presentation
Appreciate our long
Histories together in some instances and the new ones that have
Recently
Initiated all the great work you do to help us
Help the public
Enjoy a clean and safe environment along our quarters. Thank you
Okay, um for item 58 i'll read this item into the record and then i'll also take
The oath of the folks who have signed up to speak right now. We have about 18
Public comments so item 58 is the 5204 marion drive wireless communication facility
This is an appeal of the planning commission's approval of a use permit special development permit
And design review for a property located at 5204 marion drive
This is in the carmichael old foothill farms community the environmental document is a mitigated negative declaration
So at this time if you have signed up i'd like to take your uh oath so that you can address the board
Please raise your right hand and the appropriate response as I do
Do you swear that the testimony you are about to give this board is the truth so help you god if you do not swear do you so affirm?
Thank you and when you come to the podium, please state your name for the record and if you could say the statement
I have been sworn. Thank you
Madam clerk, could I also respectfully offer to our speakers?
Thank you for your speakers. Uh, we're certainly uh interested to hear what you have to share on the on this agenda item
I would uh again respectfully suggest that if your comment is likely uh consistent with or um
The same as others, uh, it's okay not to use the full two minutes
um, and um, uh, just
Be cognizant of that if you would please that would help us get to our deliberations a little quicker
um, it's already been a long day and uh, well, I just want to make sure that you understand what that we certainly want to have your
testimony affect uh our consideration
uh, but
um, uh, we are
registering everything you say on the record for the record
um, but if it is uh similar to a person next to you, um, it's okay to abbreviate. Thank you
All right, good afternoon. Um chair cerna and members of the board kimber gutierrez with planning and environmental review
Um before I begin just want to give a quick shout out to christian balthazar who's the project manager for this project and has worked really hard to get the project to this point
Um, also want to thank members of the public and the applicant for hanging on with us, uh for the whole day
Okay, so the subject site is located at 5204 marion drive which is approximately
249 feet east of the intersection of fair oaks boulevard and marion drive
The site is also within the car michael community and is currently vacant
The subject site is zoned rd2 and surrounding uses include single family residential zoned rd2 to the north and east
multi-tenant retail zoned lc to the
West and an apartment complex zoned rd20 to the south
Um the subject site has had one previous planning entitlement which similar to the proposed project today
Um is for was for a wireless communication facility called william pond cellular facility the previous project
proposed the construction of a 78 foot tall monopole and was
To be located on the southwestern portion of the lot
The project was presented to the planning commission in 1997 where it was ultimately denied
And that denial was appealed by the applicant
To the board of supervisors which held their hearing on february of 2001
And the board did uphold the planning commission denial of the project and determined that the site was not suitable for a cellular communication facility
Besides that previous entitlement staff has confirmed that there are no active code enforcement cases for the site
The entitlements being requested for this project include a use permit special development permit and design review the use permit is to allow a new cell tower within the rd2 zoning district
The special development permit would be to allow deviations to the maximum height
requirement and the separation requirement from group one zoned
And then lastly design review to determine substantial compliance with the countywide design guidelines
On screen now is the site plan for the proposed project the project is proposing a new 74 foot tall wireless communication facility
a diesel generator and an accompanying equipment cabinet all within a
576 square foot lease area near the southwest corner of the property
The lease area would be accessed via a new 20 foot wide gravel driveway from marion drive
Which is along the north of the project site and then the drive will run along the western boundary
Here is an enlarge site plan one of the requested deviations is for the separation from group one zoned properties
In this case that would include the residential properties
The proposal is meeting the separation requirements to the north
So keeping distance greater than what is required which is
236 feet
They're also meeting this to the west given that the lot to the west is zoned for commercial
There is no um that 236 foot is not required on that property line
Where they are deviating is the south property line excuse
Excuse me
Excuse me
Excuse me
Excuse me
The south property line and the east property line
Thank you
Thank you
Okay to the south
They are proposing 25 feet separation and to the east 69 feet separation
Um here are the elevations for the proposed cell tower
They are proposing a mono pine stealth design
And as previously mentioned it would be 74 feet in height which is a 19 foot deviation from the 50 foot
tall standard
And then also this shows that the lease area will be secured by a six foot tall wooden fence
The next couple of slides cover some photo simulations that were taken from different viewpoints to the site
Top images will show the existing condition without the tower and the bottom images will show what the area would look like
With the tower at the proposed 74 foot tall height
This photo simulation is looking south the project site and provides an unobstructed view from marion drive which the project fronts
This one is from the looking southeast at the project site from the intersection of marion drive and fair oaks boulevard
This is looking north at the project site from ardent way
From the front edge of the apartment complex to the south
And lastly this is a view from the intersection of walnut avenue and fair oaks boulevard
There are five additional photo simulations that are included in the board packet
So that's the applicant that is looking for the project site as attachment seven
The applicant also provided three different coverage maps
The first one here shown is the existing service in the project area with no tower
Areas in green show reliable coverage both indoors and outdoors
Yellow shows reliable coverage in transit so meaning those who are driving through the area
And then the blue indicates reliable service only when outdoors and indicates less reliable coverage indoors
The applicant's goal would be to reduce the areas in the blue as much as possible
so the red circle indicates the coverage objective and
Then here we have two additional coverage maps the left is the 55 foot tall tower which is
The other one here is permitted and then the 74 foot tall tower which is what is being proposed
The maps were provided by the applicant as part of their justification for their request to ask for a deviation from the maximum height requirement
An initial study mitigated negative declaration was prepared for this project and was released for public review on february 21st of this year
The document discussed the topics listed on the slide and concluded that the project would result in less than significant impact with the implementation of mitigation measures
To go over a couple advisory recommendations
So the design review advisory committee did meet on january 23rd of this year and they do recommend that the project be found in substantial compliance with the design guidelines
And then the former carmichael old foothill farms community planning advisory council did meet on january 8th of this year
And they do recommend they did recommend that the planning commission deny the requested entitlements
We did have seven members of the public speak in opposition to the proposed project concerns raised included health and safety in terms of rf exposure
sensitive groups residing in the surrounding area
over concentration of cell towers in the area
Potential decrease in property values increased traffic
Noise from the black backup generator and concerns that this site was not adequate for the proposed use
As part of their recommendation the c pack also voted to pre-authorize a community-wide
Interest appeal in the event that the project was approved by the planning commission
In response to the comments received at the c pack the applicant did provide a property valuation report
Which looked at property values for
property specifically within the carmichael community and that is included as attachment 10 of your hearing packets
They also provided an alternative sites analysis, which is included as attachment 9
For just kind of going over a brief overview of that analysis. There were a total of 10 sites
Including the project sites that were selected as candidate locations
For either co-location on an existing tower or as new tower locations
Of the 10 sites five sites were considered for co-location and the reason that they weren't selected included
owners not being interested in expanding the lease area and sites not suitable for the coverage needs that they were seeking
The other five sites were selected as candidates for new towers
However, four of those were not selected because the property owners were not interested and then also
Some of them were included some of them included county park sites as well
So the project was heard by the planning commission on march 24th of this year
There was several discussion topics by the commissioners
And several concerns shared including over concentration of cell towers in the area
As well as kind of what changed between the last denial of the project and the proposed project
Before them this year
Potential site constraints for future development concerns with the removal of trees as well as the noise impacts from the backup generator
As well
We did have 12 members of the public provide verbal testimony at that hearing
Largely in opposition and cited public health risks associated with the proposed project and the negative effects as property values
As well as all of the concerns that I
went over during the cpac meeting as well
After the hearing the
After deliberations the commission did vote to approve the project with a three yes to no vote
And following that hearing the carmichael old foothill farm cpac did file an appeal with the clerk of the board's office on april 1st
And the appeal form did provide a number of justifications
including better alternative locations
Were more suited than the proposed area including the county park sites
Deviation from the height limit of the proposed tower to 74 feet
Saturation of cell towers in the area and close proximity of the tower to the neighbors
And a copy of that justification statement and appeal form is included as attachment 14
I'm going to go over the next couple slides will kind of touch on the various points made by the appellants
So the first being the better alternative locations and kind of the proximity to residential development
so
following the
Filing of the appeal by the cpac the applicant team did provide additional materials in response to the justifications
So one of those is on the screen now
This is a map provided by the applicant depicting the boundaries of their alternative site analysis, which is the red line
And then attachment 15 of your hearing package does contain the revised
Alternative site analysis that was prepared by the team as well
The revised site analysis contains an additional site which is the sewage treatment plant adjacent to the american river
Which i'll go over in a little bit more depth on the next slide
But there were justifications included for why all 10 candidate sites were not selected
The analysis also includes email communications for some of these sites specifically with county parks
And this material was provided in response to the appeal justification
The next point is on the alternative location so
As previously mentioned the applicant did add a new site to the alternative site analysis, which is the sewage treatment plant adjacent to the american river
That is this site over here
um on the bottom of the screen
um
This coverage map depicts the um
uh
And 135 foot tower at that additional site location
um
The applicant has indicated that as shown on the coverage map even at that height of 135 feet
The targeted gap that they are looking to close so the again the red circle the coverage objective
Um would not be met by doing the larger taller tower at that
waste water treatment or sewage treatment plant location
through the chair
Thank you camera. I have all some comments and questions at the end, but since you're on this I had a question about this and
um
I met with the the applicant um with todd and we discussed this very thing
I i'm just i'm a little confused because I think in um, I don't know what year was it was it 2020 or there was a proposal at one point
for a um a cell tower
not too far from this location
Uh-huh is that correct?
I'm not sure
uh
Supervisor desmond todd smith planning director, uh, you are correct
I can't remember the number of that site, but it was the one I think at jed's trail pond or something
It was that just to the north slightly northwest of this
I think the applicant might be able to answer in more detail if you have further questions on that one
I'll wait to the app but just just a preview. I mean I'm curious
Why that site was proposed
several years ago as being a potentially viable site, but now it's not even though this this site at the
uh um um
Suits treatment plant which is now the sheriff's academy is not suitable so I'd like I would like an answer to that question when the applicant comes up here
Okay
All right
Um, I'll go through these fairly quickly, but in in response to the appeal as well the applicant did provide some revised um photo simulations that were showing
the tower at 55 feet
Um, which would no longer require the special development permit for that maximum height deviation
Um, so these are the same viewpoints that we went over before just with 55 feet
I also wanted to note that at that planning commission hearing the applicant did
Indicate that they would be willing to lower the height of the cell tower to 55 feet
However, the planning commission did move forward with the approval of the 74 foot height
Kimber excuse me and
Mr. Chair if you don't if you don't mind I
Had a follow-up question about this as well at the at the 55 foot level
If they're not asking for a variance and it's at 55 feet
Could an applicant whether it's this applicant or another applicant later on raise the height
Yes, tower. Can you explain that to me? Yeah, there are um allowances to raise the height on
a ministerial level
um, and I believe it is
20 feet 20 percent or 20 feet
You're allowed to go up
Um on just a staff level review
Um, so they wouldn't be required to come back and receive discretionary
Entitlements to raise the height
That much if they go beyond that 20 feet then they would be required to come back
So in other words if it were
if they agreed to
Located at 55 feet
Um, they could later come back add 20 feet without having to come back to correct the board. Okay, thank you
Okay
So following staff's review
It was determined that the project remains consistent with the general plan
Carmichael old foothill farms community plan and action plan as well as the zoning code
the environmental document did conclude that the
Project would there would be no significant environmental concerns
And although the project was not supported by the c pack the proposed project would provide better emergency services
Increasing network coverage in the area and is designed as a mono pine tree to blend in with the surrounding trees in the area as well
So the and then lastly the project was supported by the drac to be found consistent with the design guidelines
So based on that staff is recommending that the board take the following actions
deny the appeal
Upholding the planning commission's approval of the project
Determine that the environmental analysis prepared pursuant to sequa is adequate and complete and adopt the mitigated negative declaration
Adopt the mitigation monitoring and reporting program approve approve the use permit special development permit and find the project in substantial compliance with the design guidelines all subject to findings and conditions
And that concludes my presentation and I believe the applicant is available
Um, I believe the appellant had to leave
Yeah, just real quick on that front, uh, the appellant the chair of the car michael seeback mike, uh, roenstein had to leave earlier today
But he had identified a member of the public
Uh, he gave his notes to that person. So he she is able to speak on behalf of the appellant
Okay, thank you, uh, kimber and thank you todd
And again, I would just remind those that have already been sworn, uh
In anticipation of your testimony the appropriate
Uh
Initiation of your comments is that you have been sworn we need that for the record, please
Um, uh, and uh before we get to our speakers, uh, do we have any further questions comments for
any of our staff?
Uh, mr. Charris is uh supervisor desmond again, and I don't know I guess the applicant is just available for for questions
Is is
Were they gonna yeah, so typically after in the case of an appeal hearing we'll hear from staff then the appellant
And then the applicant and then public comment is that correct? Okay. Okay. So then are we gonna hear the uh, the appellants?
um
So substitute for lack of a better term sorry no disrespect. Yes, that's correct. Okay, very good
That's you
I I want to um
Adhere to the chairman who said do not repeat you did a very good job going over
um, mr. rockenstein's
Appeal so i'm just going to highlight um he was here for two and a half hours waited
I think it was wonderful for him to
Come um
And he said the c pack at the january 8th meeting recommended denial five to one
Of the proposed use permit for the wireless communication facility
The reasons being
Better alternative locations more suited than the proposed area
Including county areas
Um
Deviates from 55 feet as proposed to 74 feet
And there is a saturation of cell towers in the area
I imagine he
Um, he um is referring to five points
Um, and it's too close to the neighbors in the area
Um
He also said that the
equation for the setbacks should be
um
Um
The height times three which would put that at 222 feet
I believe there's um asking they have 67 feet on one side and 25 feet on another side which is
quite a bit
um
less than 225 feet so
And we want to thank him for coming and speaking today and I hope I did him justice on his
And thank you and before you leave you have been sworn correct I have been sworn thank you
Is the applicant uh approaching the podium yes
Good uh good evening uh
Chair cerna
Uh good evening vice chair rodriguez uh supervisors desmond and hume
My name is nicholas tagus uh with 51 wireless uh agent on behalf of at&t
uh
As the agent on behalf of at&t we do support staff's findings um the drax findings as well as the planning commission's findings
And i'm here to answer any questions address any comments or concerns
Uh raised by the public or uh any questions that um supervisors have
Okay, and you and you have been sworn correct?
I have been sworn correct. Okay, that's that's what i'm asking for for from uh
Speakers at the beginning of your testimony
Again respectfully. Thank you any questions for the applicant
Uh, yeah, mr. Chair if you don't mind um, please
Um, so thank you. Mr. Tagus tagus tagus tagus. Okay, um, so you you heard the question I I asked and I just because we
You we met in my office and we had a discussion about this and I told you I had a discussion with uh sheriff cooper
about would he be amenable to
Potentially exploring a a cellular tower on the sheriff's academy property, which as you know, he leases from sac sewer
um
And it was my understanding that
That location there is is
Pretty close in close proximity to
The former william pond proposal correct
Which at the time was going to improve coverage, but but now you're saying it would not improve coverage at that location
Can you explain that to me? Yeah, so uh at that time, uh the uh coverage and goal objectives
uh was for that specific area
uh southwest of the current um coverage objective area
And when that project was denied
AT&T had asked our office to find a location
Uh just southwest of that location along fair oaks boulevard which we were able to successfully do
Uh if you look just uh adjacent to jesuit high school
There is the fair oaks pet clinic
And there is a second story penthouse you wouldn't even know there's a cell tower on top of that pet clinic
We were able to get that successfully approved
Uh and designed so that fills the coverage gap and objective of all that residential area
Uh including jesuit
Southwest of this current objective ring and because of the economic development that is happening along fair oaks and ardenway
Specifically in this new area. This is a wholly new coverage objective area that we're trying to
Help at t's customers fill
As you stated earlier fair oaks boulevard is a prime location for economic development
That's exactly what this location is trying to cover and again being at its location just 249 feet from
Uh fair oaks and ardenway
Uh that's exactly what this is trying to accomplish
Now going back to the two deviations
There was two of them uh that were requested for this project the first one was a height deviation
Of 74 feet versus 55 at the planning commission
And again today I will affirm that AT&T is willing to lower the height of their uh proposal to that 55 feet
As related to the second deviation of the setbacks there's two parcels that this deviates from
The first one is to the south which is an apartment complex the owner of that property isn't here today
But he was at the planning commission and he has affirmed his support for the project
The second uh property uh is 67 feet to the east
That is the property owner mr drew bay who's here tonight who is uh leasing this portion of this other parcel to
AT&T so the two property owners that are would be uh quote affected or impacted by this deviation for setbacks are both in favor of this project
And the specific location of this tower was specifically located to be closest to the commercial corridor
furthest away from every other uh residential parcel in this neighborhood
And i believe in your packet we added additional photo simulations that we had our engineer go around the entire horseshoe of marion drive
And take pictures from all of the different areas to show that uh once you drive past this for a matter of seconds
Your front yard and backyard you will not have uh uh any visual obstructions or use or enjoyment of your property
By seeing this tower because the trees in the area are so tall and the distance from their properties
How they did that was they put a drone up in the sky with a gps location exactly where the tower would be
At the exact height that they were requesting and they just walked around the properties and took photos
If you can see that drone then you can see the tower if you can't see that drone you can't see that tower
Uh and again those photo simulations those additional ones were at 74 feet not the 55
Uh so uh with that if there's any other questions i'd be more than happy to answer them supervisor no thank you
I appreciate the the long response to my very limited question relating to the william pond uh site you're welcome
but uh um
But just to get back to that and i'll respond to a few other things or comment on a few other things
Um there was still a service need at that location at william pond has is that is there a service need
Is there no longer a service need in that area?
Uh that's correct that that was that was filled with that
Spot behind jesuit. Yes, sir. Got it. Yep, and then you brought up the um
Willingness to reduce the height to 55 you heard my exchange with our planning director and kimber about that very issue
What would prevent at t from coming back and seeking approval on a ministerial basis to raise it back to the 20 feet
To which they would be entitled so once at&t invests their their infrastructure improvements here
Uh, the only reason uh if a future applicant would request increase that height is if they wanted to co-locate on it
Uh one of the questions or not questions, but concerns was a quote saturation of cell towers in the area
There's only one other cell tower and that's at five points plaza
Uh at&t attempted to get on that tower. However, there's already three carriers on that dish
verizon and t-mobile
And there's no uh amount of space on that tower on the ground
Existing that would have allowed at&t on there. So to answer your question
One of those carriers would want to leave that location and co-locate on at&t's tower
In order to then request that
6409 a
Eligible facilities request to do that otherwise it would just be a single uh
Carrier uh tower unless some of those other carriers across the street would like to uh co-locate on this tower
So just want to be clear though if if someone wants to co-locate on an at&t tower
And at&t can earn more revenue by co-locating wouldn't they be amenable to that?
AT&t by by law and by the code is
Uh supposed to allow for co-locations whether they get a financial uh response from that or not your code
Specifically says that towers must be designed to be co-locateable
So then what that says to me is if someone wants to co-locate
And it means at&t raises this 20 feet to which they'd be entitled I could see that happening
Regardless of whether you agree to 55 feet today. That's kind of how I I see that of course
Of course. Yes. Yes, uh, and again, they're they're uh following the rules and regulations
I appreciate that
The other thing this this board and maybe this is more for todd and kimber
There was a proposal for a tower at this very location. What year was that?
97 and both the planning commission and this board denied that application is that correct
So what has changed in their intervening time?
So in 1997, I believe it was sprint at that time they might have had a different subsidiary name
They were attempting to to design a monopole. So not a tree just a standard metal steel structure
Uh, and at that time there was different technologies
Different abilities or the lack thereof to design something that blends in with the natural topography and vegetation of the area
And when they were denied they moved across the street. I believe in 2002 or 2004 in that shopping center
So what's changed since then is uh
One the economic development of the area
To the amount of folks that have moved into the area
Three the amount of emergency 911 calls
The amount of safety calls
Annually just in Carmichael alone
And then now with at&t
They have proven their significant gap in coverage and capacity
That's what's changed in terms of them trying to fill that gap for the the customers of at&t in Carmichael
Okay, um
I want to respond to that
uh, uh
But first with respect to the monopole and you talked about you know hiding it
I
I mean even just looking at your photos you say that people can't see it
Well, I can just I can see it from the photos that you've provided
And it's not fooling anybody. I mean we know what that is
It doesn't look like, you know a native redwood tree or something in the neighborhood, which I suppose they're not native
Um
But with respect i'm glad you brought up the 911 thing because I was a first responder for 24 years
And I worked in the area I've born and raised in Carmichael
I'm very familiar with kind of some of the
the the quirks of cell coverage in that community, you know, I've never heard from
Sheriff CHP
Metro fire that it is a real issue their coverage. Do you have any?
Testimony to the contrary or any any documentation to the contrary that they're that they're in support of this because they have gaps in coverage
So what we have is just the actual uh list of dropped calls in the area for at&t's customers
I can't speak to how many first responders are at&t customers. I don't have that data
All we can say is there is a clear defined gap in coverage and capacity for at&t's
customers
In this area that includes first responders if they do have at&t as their coverage provider
That includes the small businesses in that area as well as the residents who live nearby
AT&t is not in the business of building towers that are on top of their existing towers where they're already providing coverage
And in order to maintain their competitive advantage with their competitors as well as provide
competition and lower prices for the residents they're looking to expand their
um uh coverage and capacity in this specifically defined targeted area and yes when you come off of fair oaks and arden way
You will see this tower
After you as you are on that commercial corridor
But again once you get into the heart of the neighborhood you will not be seeing this tower and it's it's shown by those photo simulations
And one last thing mr.
Chair and i'll you know mention the
You mentioned the um, I guess the owner of the apartment complex
Yes, sir
Um, I also see a letter that we all received signed by several tenants of that apartment complex
That are against this and they'd be looking
Directly at that tower if they're on the I think on the north side of that apartment complex
So I just want to point that out as well. Okay. Thank you. Thank you very much
Again in closing this this is really just about economic
Development
um, it's about equal access to
Reliable cellular service and just the ability for at&t to not only compete with the other competitors in this area, but to demonstrate
Not only after five years of trying to find a location
But meeting the strict guidelines of this code and providing these services that are going to not only help the citizens
Visitors uh and first responders
Great. Thank you very much. Thank you. Okay. Madam clerk next speaker, please
Okay, let me pull up that list
Okay, paul paul d
yes
Good evening i'll try and be brief my name is paul drubay i've been sworn in and thank you
um
um
My family's uh had this property for 75 years. This was my grandparents home and
uh, they raised their family in a
Menagerie of animals and I have a privilege of doing the same
uh, my family lives there and
And as we talked about
A previous tower was proposed as far as the setback that I might have had a hand in that I wanted this pushed as far
Back as possible. Um, so you might see that deviation
uh, to quote one of my neighbors
At and t coverage in our area sucks
Um I was an at and t customer when i moved there i switched to verizon
Um, there is definitely just a hole
WE TALKED ABOUT WHAT HAS
CHANGED SINCE 1997.
MY GRANDPARENTS, A LOT OF MY
NEIGHBORS HAD LAND LINES AS A
BACKUP.
NOW WE ALL HAVE CELL PHONES.
A LOT OF US DON'T HAVE LAND LINES.
IN AN EMERGENCY, IF WE HAD A
FIRE OR FLOOD ON, SAY, THE
AMERICAN RIVER PARKWAY THAT WE
ARE CLOSE TO AND LOST POWER,
NOT ONLY WOULD YOU NOT HAVE AT&T
COVERAGE, YOU WOULDN'T HAVE
VERIZON, T-MOBILE OR I BELIEVE
DISH BECAUSE THERE IS NO BACKUP
POWER AT FIVE POINTS PLAZA.
SO JUST TO ILLUMINATE, LIKE, NOT
ONLY IS THIS AN ISSUE FROM MY
STANDPOINT THAT AT&T IS NOT
ADEQUATELY SERVICED, THERE IS
NO BACKUP POWER, THIS IS AGING
INFRASTRUCTURE.
SO TO SPEAK TO WHY WOULD SOMEBODY
WANT TO COLOCATE, WELL, THEY
DON'T HAVE BACKUP POWER AT FIVE
POINTS PLAZA.
SOMETHING THAT I WANT TO POINT
OUT IS JUST WHEN WE MET IN YOUR
OFFICE, SUPERVISOR DESMOND, YOU
WOULDN'T HAVE TO GO TO THE
HOME.
SO I THINK IT'S REALLY IMPORTANT
TO ME TO PUT THESE LOCATED
FURTHER FROM SINGLE FAMILY
HOMES.
WE TALKED ABOUT TWO LOCATIONS.
ONE WAS AT FIVE POINTS
PLAZA, WHY COULDN'T ANOTHER
TOWER GO THERE?
WHY COULDN'T ONE GO ON TOP OF
THE HOME?
WHY COULDN'T ONE GO ON TOP OF
THE HOME?
WHY COULDN'T ONE GO ON TOP OF
THE HOME?
WELL, THIS TOWER LOCATION IS
THE NEAREST HOME IS 400 FEET
OVER 400 FEET AWAY FROM ANOTHER
SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTS OTHER
THAN MY OWN.
THEN THOSE TWO OTHER LOCATIONS
HAVE EIGHT HOMES AND 11 HOMES
RESPECTEDLY WITHIN THAT AREA.
SO THAT'S WHAT I WANTED TO ADD.
THANKS FOR YOUR TIME.
THANK YOU.
THANK YOU.
THANK YOU.
OKAY, OUR NEXT SPEAKER IS
JERRY CAMPOS.
MY NAME IS JERRY CAMPOS, AND I'VE
BEEN A RESIDENT IN MARION DRIVE
SINCE 1992.
THE REASON I MOVED HERE WAS
BECAUSE OF FAMILY ISSUES.
IN 1989, MY SON CONTRACTED
CANCER.
HE HAD GONE THROUGH TWO
SURGERIES AND RADIATION, AND
WE WERE LOOKING AT A THIRD
SURGERY.
IN DISCUSSION WITH THE
NEUROSURGEONS AND THE
RADIATION ONCOLOGIST, I ASKED
HIM AS MANY QUESTIONS AS
POSSIBLE FOR THE SURVIVAL OF
MY SON.
MAINLY, WHAT CAN I DO TO KEEP
MY SON HEALTHY?
BESIDES DIET AND THINGS OF
THAT NATURE, I WOULD HAVE
RADIATION AND RAIS.
HE SAID, THE LESS RAYS THAT YOU
WILL HAVE, THE LESS LIKELY
THERE WILL BE A RETURN OF
CANCER.
IT WAS A MEDULLOBLY STOMA, THE
BRAIN CANCER.
I IMMEDIATELY LOOKED FOR AREAS
IN THE AREA THAT MIGHT BE THE
BEST SUITABLE FOR THE SURVIVAL OF
OUR OLDEST SON, WHO WAS FOUR AT
THE TIME.
THE LESS RAYS THAT I FOUND A HOME
FOR SALE ON MARION DRIVE.
WE BOUGHT IT.
IT NEEDED A LOT OF WORK.
IT STRETCHED US FINANCIALLY, BUT
WE DID IT BECAUSE WE WANTED THE
SURVIVAL OF OUR CHILD ABOVE
EVERYTHING.
WE EVEN PUT EXTRA FUNDS TO PUT
ALL OF THE WIRES THAT WE HAD ON
THE PROPERTY TO GO UNDERGROUND TO
LIMIT THOSE RAYS.
THANK GOD HE IS HEALTHY TODAY.
AND I THINK IT'S BECAUSE OF ALL
OF THE THINGS THAT WE DID TO
KEEP THAT AREA LIKE IT WAS IN
1992.
IT WAS TRANQUIL, SERENE, QUIET,
AND NOT WITH A LOT OF THE NORMAL
NEIGHBORHOOD NOISES AND THINGS OF
THAT NATURE.
I HOPE THAT THE BOARD, WHICH
YOU'VE TAKEN A LOT OF YOUR TIME,
I HOPE THAT YOU CONCUR WITH THE
CPAC, WHAT THEY VOTED ON, AND
WHAT THEY VOTED BACK IN 1987 OR
WHATEVER YEAR THAT WAS.
AND WITH THE OVERWHELMING
MAJORITY OF THE RESIDENTS OF
MARION DRIVE.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
THANK YOU.
MARIANNE CAMPOS.
HI.
MY NAME IS MARIANNE CAMPOS.
I'M MARRIED TO THAT GUY.
AND WE HAVE LIVED ON THAT STREET FOR 32
YEARS.
AND BACK IN 1997, I STOOD RIGHT
HERE AND I SPOT THE CELL TOWER
THEN.
AND I'M STANDING HERE AGAIN TO FIGHT
THE CELL TOWER.
WE DON'T NEED A CELL TOWER IN A
RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBORHOOD.
I TAKE GREAT OFFENSE THAT AT&T DID
NOT SHOW ONE OF OUR HOMES.
THEY ONLY SHOWED A VACANT LOT.
WE LIVE ON THAT STREET.
OUR CHILDREN ARE ON THAT STREET.
WE HAVE GRANDCHILDREN THAT VISIT.
I DON'T UNDERSTAND WHY THEY WANT TO
ENCROACH ON RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY.
THE COUNTY TURNED THEM DOWN.
EVERYBODY'S TURNED THEM DOWN.
RAILY SAID NO.
IT'S NOT THAT IT WASN'T FEASIBLE.
THEY'VE BEEN TOLD NO, NO, NO, NO.
I WANT TO BE ABLE TO SAY NO, NO, NO, NO, NO.
THEIR SETBACKS ARE REALLY 60% LESS
THAN WHAT ANTIQUATED REGULATIONS TOLD
THEM IN 1996.
THEIR SETBACKS ARE REALLY 60% LESS
THAN WHAT ANTIQUATED REGULATIONS
TOLD THEM IN 1996.
THEIR SETBACKS ARE REALLY 60% LESS
REGULATIONS TOLD THEM IN 1997.
NOTHING'S BEEN CHANGED SIN 1997.
AND THEY'RE ASKING FOR LESSER
SETBACKS.
AND THOSE ARE ANTIQUATED, ANTIQUATED
GUIDELINES.
I DON'T UNDERSTAND THAT, HOW THAT
COULD EVEN BE POSSIBLE.
AND TO ASK FOR A TOWER TO BE 55.
AND THEN THANK YOU, MR. DESMOND,
FOR LETTING US KNOW THAT THEY COULD
COME BACK, PUT THAT TOWER UP 74,
COLOCATE FOUR PEOPLE, AND WE
WOULD NEVER, EVER KNOW.
THAT IS UNACCEPTABLE.
WE LIVE ON A QUIET, SERENE STREET.
WE HAVE NO STREETLIGHTS.
WE HAVE NO SIDEWALKS.
AND WE HAVE BEAUTIFUL MATURE
TREES.
I TAKE OFFENSE THAT THEY'RE GOING
TO TAKE DOWN 14 TREES.
SO THE PICTURE THEY SHOWED YOU
DOESN'T ACCOUNT FOR THE 14 TREES
THAT THEY'RE TAKING DOWN.
SO I WANT TO SEE THAT PICTURE
AS WELL.
AND I WANT TO SEE MY HOUSE AND
TELL THEM HOW CLOSE IT IS TO ME.
AND I JUST WANT TO SAY THAT I
TOTALLY AGREE WITH THE CPAP.
THEY SAID, WOW, THIS IS NOT A
SUITABLE AREA.
WE AGREE, IT'S NOT SUITABLE.
WE LIVE THERE.
AND THEN THEY SAID, THERE'S TOO
MANY.
YEAH, WE DIDN'T EVEN KNOW THERE
WAS ONE TWO BLOCKS DOWN.
AND WHY?
WHY MARY OWN DRIVE?
I DON'T SEE A LOT OF PEOPLE GROWING
AND MOVING AROUND.
AND A LOT OF AT&T DOESN'T HAVE
COVERAGE.
I GUESS VERIZON MIGHT AT&T.
SO WHY ARE WE DOING THIS NOW?
AFTER WE WERE TOLD, NO, NO, NO.
AND THE CPAP SAID, NO.
THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME.
I WOULD ORDER PIZZA IF I COULD.
THANK YOU.
THANK YOU.
OKAY.
OKAY.
JOHN, JOHN.
JOHN.
IT'S OKAY.
IT'S OKAY.
IT'S OKAY.
HE'S CUT.
OKAY.
MY NAME IS JOHN HAMMOND.
I HAVE LIVED ON MARION DRIVE LONGER
THAN ANYONE ELSE.
OVER 50-SOME YEARS.
AND I AM AGAINST THIS TOWER.
I WAS AGAINST IT 20 YEARS AGO.
AND I LOVE OUR STREET THE WAY IT IS.
I LOVE THE PEOPLE ON OUR STREET.
AND I WANT TO GIVE ANY REMAINING
MINUTES I HAVE TO CARLOS.
IS IT POSSIBLE TO USE ONE OF HER
MINUTES?
SORRY.
WHENEVER HE GETS UP TO TALK.
OKAY.
WHENEVER YOU GET UP TO TALK.
OKAY.
I'M UP.
OKAY.
I'M ACTUALLY TAKING MICHELLE'S
PLACE BECAUSE I'M TAKING
MICHELLE'S PLACE BECAUSE I'M
TAKING MICHELLE'S PLACE.
IS THAT A FINE?
OH.
DO YOU WANT ME TO GIVE YOU?
NO.
IS THAT A FINE?
WE'LL UPDATE YOUR NAME.
SO IS MICHELLE NOT HERE?
MICHELLE IS NEXT.
OKAY.
I DON'T KNOW IF I'M ABLE TO TALK
BECAUSE I TOOK THAT GENTLEMAN'S PLACE.
AM I ABLE TO TALK?
SHE READ THE LETTER FROM CPAP.
OH, YES.
YES.
OF COURSE SHE CAN.
AND THEN I'M GOING TO ASK IF
CLERK STAFF COULD ASSIST TO GET HIM
INTO THE C-PAP.
AND THEN I'M GOING TO ASK IF
CLERK STAFF COULD ASSIST TO GET HIM INTO THE
PUBLIC COMMENT.
OH, YOU'RE ALREADY ON HERE.
I HAVE THAT, YEAH.
OKAY.
DID YOU WANT US TO MOVE YOUR NAME UP?
THAT'S FINE.
OKAY.
THANK YOU.
SO I'M MICHELLE.
I HAVE BEEN SWORN.
WE'VE LIVED ON THE STREET SINCE 1996.
I TOO WAS PART OF THE FIRST ROUND OF SPRINT,
FIGHTING SPRINT.
I ALWAYS WRITE THESE LETTERS THAT I JUST DON'T
WANT TO READ.
WHAT I WANT TO SAY IS MY HUSBAND AND I LOVE
OUR HOME.
WE CHOSE IT BECAUSE IT'S A RESIDENTIAL
AREA.
IT'S NOT AN URBAN AREA.
IT'S NOT A COMMERCIAL AREA.
IT IS A RESIDENTIAL AREA.
WE HAVE NINE GRANDCHILDREN.
THEY COME ALL THE TIME.
THEY PLAY.
WE HAVE A WONDERFUL TIME.
THE KIDS RUN AROUND ON THE STREET.
THEY DON'T HAVE TO WORRY ABOUT BIG COMMERCIAL TRUCKS
COMING ON THE STREET.
I ASK THAT THE SUPERVISORS PLEASE THINK ABOUT JUST
REALLY ONE THING.
WHAT RESIDENTIAL MEANS AND WHAT IT MEANS TO FAMILIES
WHO ARE PAYING THEIR TAXES, TRYING TO MAKE THEIR
HOMES THE BEST PLACE FOR FAMILIES.
IT'S OUR PEACEFUL PLACE TO COME HOME TO.
AT&T IS A CONGLOMERATE.
IT IS A MASSIVE COMMERCIAL ENTITY.
AND THERE IS A PLACE FOR THEM.
IT IS NOT ON OUR RESIDENTIAL STREETS.
AND I JUST ASK THAT YOU SET A PRECEDENCE FOR ALL OF THE
NEIGHBORHOODS IN SACRAMENTO COUNTY THAT WE KEEP THEM OUT OF
THERE.
THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME.
THE HOMES AND THEY ARE GOING TO, OR I'M GOING TO
THAT, WE ARE HAVING SOME TECHNICAL DIFFICULTY.
AND I'M GOING TO, LET ME PULL UP THE LIST, SO I CAN
SEE THE NAMES.
OKAY.
SANDRA?
Okay, Sandra?
I'm Sandra Wiedemann, and I agree with the opposition that I've heard,
and I would like to relinquish my minutes to my husband, Jeffrey.
Good evening, ladies and gentlemen.
My name is Jeff Wiedemann.
I am a retired hand surgeon with hand surgery associates here in town.
I'm now doing the IT work for them.
I'm also a retired Air Force two-star general.
After 34 years in the Air Force, I functioned as the senior medical officer for the Air Force Reserve.
I've lived on Marion since 1988 with my wife, and we raised our two kids there.
I'm one of two physicians who live on the street as far as I know.
Dr. Hoon is the other physician.
He has written a letter, which I commend and recommend that you read if you have not already,
because it really outlines the issues that we have.
From a historical standpoint, I had AT&T once it became live after Cellular One went away,
and that was before we had, when we had beepers.
AT&T worked adequately for me when it was at the lower G ratings, but as it got higher,
it became inadequate.
And I was, by calling and speaking to AT&T and telling them of the issue,
they said, well, let's fine, pay us $110, and we'll give you a little mini cell booster,
which I did buy, and it worked great.
And then at some point in time, I'm a Mac guy with an iPhone.
It started not to work as well because Apple changed the setup.
However, it's my understanding, Audrey, who lives back door to me, has a booster,
and she says it just works fine.
Unfortunately, she's not here to validate that.
But that was encouraging for me to hear.
But I ultimately left AT&T for this reason, and I hope I get back into the green.
I went and got T-Mobile as a trial, so I had two cell carriers at the same time.
Sir, if you could wrap up your comments, please.
Well, I'm taking my wife's time.
There's no family.
We don't do that, sir.
I'm so sorry.
All right.
I will echo what has already been said.
AT&T is a huge conglomerate.
They've got a lot of ammunition.
It's a shame on them for not having the negotiating skills to deal with businesses in the area
so that they could pay enough money to convince them.
Sir, we're going to need you to wrap it up.
Agent Orange was not a problem until it was.
The affluent from 9-11 was not a problem until it was.
Sir, your time is up.
And the burn pits in Iraq were not a problem until it was.
Sir, your time is up.
I hope the supervisors make the appropriate decision.
And for the record, can you state that you've been sworn?
Yes.
Can you state that you've been sworn?
Yes.
Yes.
In many ways.
Okay.
I'm Matt Baskin.
I'm the owner of the shopping center on the other side of the fence.
But I want to do something.
And I want to tell you that you three are going to run on a post.
Nobody has to work as many hours and have as much work as you three.
My heart goes out to you because I know you started early this morning.
And you're sitting there trying to stay awake.
And I wish you my best if you'll just bear with us just a little longer.
Thank you, Matt.
We're going to make it.
There are two immutable facts in this world.
You throw a ball up in the air and it comes down every time.
And the second thing is if you put a 74-foot cell tower in a residential area,
the quality of life and possibly the quality of health will come down also.
And that we don't want.
So I'm asking you, please, at this time, there are many, many opportunities for AT&T to find
a regular location.
Many of my colleagues don't want it.
I've got location that would be perfect and they can't put it on my property.
And I think you should logically deny it in the residential for what it is.
The U.S. government is studying right now the effects of these telephone towers.
And I think we should put off this answer until they come up with an answer of whether it's safe or not safe.
And I'm hoping that you three are half asleep and I put you more asleep.
Thank you, Matt.
I hope that you'll be sitting there long enough to give us one no each.
Thank you very much.
Matt, for the record, can you state that you've been sworn?
I don't hear well either.
I only talk well.
What did you say?
Can you please state that you've been sworn?
Have you been sworn?
You've been sworn.
Pardon?
Say I have been sworn.
Pardon?
Say I have been sworn.
I have been sworn.
I've been sworn.
Thank you.
What did I swear at?
Thank you.
And have a good evening.
What did I swear at?
I swear at?
And for the remainder of the speakers, if you can please start off with that you've been sworn.
It helps us on our end.
Thank you.
I'm Carlos Kozlowski.
I have been sworn.
I live at 5224 Marion Drive.
I'm going to take an extra one minute, okay?
I want to address first the property evaluation report that the gentleman mentioned.
With 10 properties in Carmichael, I have the actual addresses of each of those properties
from the report that they have.
None of them are in a residential property.
They're all on large pieces of property.
Two of them are on county parks.
Three are on commercial properties.
One is in a shopping center.
One is in a church.
Two are on school properties of San Juan Unified School District.
And one is in a huge public storage facility.
None of them on a residential property.
This particular parcel is a zone RV2.
It's a 0.73 acre lot.
And I did a quick review of the Sacramento County zoning laws.
And the code for RV2 zoning is intended to protect the rural, small town character of a neighborhood.
A maximum of two detached single family homes per acre.
A smaller scale uses that will support residential living, such as ADU or a limited agricultural facility.
Nowhere in the county zoning language, nowhere, is there an indication that a cell tower disguised as a fake tree
and surrounded by industrial equipment is compatible to an RV2 or RV2 zoning.
Let's be honest.
Calling a tree is an insult to the beautiful natural landscape that we have lived alongside for decades.
It will tower over, whether it is 55 or 75, it will tower over the one strip mall next door
and above every actual tree in the area.
Becoming the defining visual landmark of our neighborhood for all of the wrong reasons.
Then there is the 25-foot wide access road proposed to connect the street to the tower site.
Carlos, you need to wrap it up, please.
That's more than twice the size of a standard residential driveway.
Once this structure is in place, the property will make no zoning.
Thank you.
I'm sorry.
This is not a change of use permit.
Sorry, you need to wrap it up.
This is a factor re-zoning of the property without a proper transparency process.
Thank you.
John, Randy.
Hello.
My name is Randy Bryan.
I've been in this industry for a very long time.
I helped put backup battery systems.
I've been sworn.
Backup battery systems in cell towers all over the place.
I've watched generators fail.
I've watched batteries leak.
This is not for a residential area.
We're going to be emitting diesel fume for an hour every month.
I have not seen anywhere that there's any type of electronic backup systems to any computers
anywhere that are saying there's any kind of a leak, there's any kind of a problem.
This does belong, as all that I've worked on, in a commercial area so that if there is any
type of a problem, not 50 feet away from a home, not 50 feet away from a business, but
in an area that is safe in case there is an explosion, a battery fails, or anything else
happens.
I have not heard whether this is a 3G or a 4G tower.
Do we know which this is going to be?
What we do know is that about seven to ten months ago when they started turning on 4G towers,
there was a big concern at the airport and every place else.
What do we know about the health issues of 4G?
In the submissions that I sent to you all, I included websites from 2024 on reports of
cancer and all kinds of health issues in the immediate area and within many, many, many
feet, not just feet, under the tower.
We're talking about what these 4Gs are emitting out into the neighborhoods.
Cars that are driving by are the problem that we have.
That's the big problem.
I had AT&T for a long time.
I got rid of it because when I drove by, it didn't work in certain holes.
One hole for 50 yards.
Health of the neighborhood is a big problem, and that's my whole complaint, is that I do
not believe that the environmental impact study on this was complete.
It was just rubber stamped, and we're talking about 4G, not 3G, not what we had in 1995.
Thank you, Randy.
Linda?
Hi, I'm Linda Collins, and I've been sworn.
I'm not going to repeat what everybody has said.
I just wanted to reiterate or actually pick up where Carlos left off about the driveway
that's going to lead into the lot there.
It's, there's, you know, Marion Drive is a single horseshoe-shaped street that starts
and ends on Fair Oaks.
It doesn't lead anywhere else, so there's not traffic coming in and going to other neighborhoods
or going to other retail.
The only place you can go is in and out.
And so if we have this driveway and new service trucks coming in and out, it's going to add traffic
to our neighborhood that it's not equipped to handle.
And also, you know, we have a lot of children in that area.
My husband and I are both cyclists and walkers, and we value not having trucks going by all the time
and cruising through that loop.
So I'll leave it at that.
Thank you very much.
Thank you, Linda.
Thank you.
Let's start with I've been sworn.
Okay, got that out of the way.
My name is Woody Hubbell.
I'm the guy that lives 400 feet away from this, okay, the next house over.
So I'm going to talk about the financial ramifications of this because I've asked.
I've asked.
I have many clients.
I'm a landscape contractor for many years in the area.
A lot of them are either developers or real estate agents.
Every last one said you're going to lose $100,000 the second that's approved.
You may lose $200,000 if you try and sell any time after it's built.
Okay, that's a hell of a ramification if you look at it from the other end of the deal.
Now, Paul here, my neighbor, he's a nice guy, but, you know, he could build this tower,
and then what if he leaves?
So he goes away.
The house gets rented or something else, but he's not living there.
We're living there.
Now, I built this knowing that I was going to sell one day as part of my retirement package,
and that's going to happen probably in the next three, four years, whatever.
It's just not right.
I'm not messing with anybody.
Why is somebody messing with me?
You know, if you think about it, nobody in this room wants that tower next to him.
You guys don't want it next to your house.
I guarantee the AT&T guy doesn't have one next to his house.
Why am I getting one next to my house?
Thank you.
Thank you.
Okay.
And so our next speaker is Ken Payne.
My name is Ken Payne, and yes, I've been sworn in.
I've probably been a resident of that area longer than anybody else here.
My parents bought our house on Meredith Way in 1965.
So I watched that whole intersection develop.
The most disturbing thing I heard from the staff presentations was the omission of two large complexes
just south and southeast of the proposed site.
There's not just one apartment complex.
There's two apartment complexes, and there's a complex of condominiums just southeast of this site.
My three points were going to be initially the fact that I spent 22 years in the Department of Toxic Substances Control,
and in that department we regulated hazardous waste,
and we learned that the three pathways for health effects were dermal absorption, inhalation, and ingestion.
And along with that goes two other items, and that's the duration of exposure and the concentration of exposure.
So my concern is for the concentration of the residential just south of the proposed site.
I heard that the apartment complex was 67 feet away from the tower,
but that the permit or the authorized distance was supposed to be 236 feet,
and those three large complexes would all be within that 236 feet, I think.
So currently I know that the new secretary of HHS is reviewing all the 5G stuff,
and I would suggest that the board wait to see what the official results of those findings are.
I know that Mr. Kennedy was concerned about 5G and has been for a long time, along with a lot of other things.
So I would respectfully request that you guys, you know, deny the approval of this project
for the reasons that I mentioned earlier, not to mention the reduction in property values,
and the fact that you've got really an industrial item going in a residential neighborhood.
Thanks very much.
Thank you, Ken.
Next we have Dr. Joseph Cave.
Good afternoon.
My name is Dr. Joseph Covill.
I'm a psychologist.
My issue is one I would like the board to consider is to testing, more testing before they erect that tower.
On the minds, on the physical body of those residents,
and anyone that is affected by the noise, the radio waves, and the electromagnetic waves.
I think more testing can be required, and I would request this board to vote for that.
Also, someone could explain to me why these wonderful gentlemen can have Clark Bosh to tell you everything,
but these people who are impacted get two minutes.
Now, does that seem fair to you?
And does it seem fair that their homes should be impacted?
And these folks aren't.
They just make money.
Come on.
Dr. Joseph, if you could please wrap it up, please.
I pray you could hear this.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you for your service, sir.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you for your service, sir.
Good afternoon.
Good evening now.
I'm Warren.
Hello.
My name is Dr. Hong Truk Nguyen.
I just want to express my opposition to these projects along with different tenants.
My health clinic is just barely 40 feet away from these proposed projects.
And, you know, as a health care provider committed to the well-being of all my patients and the community,
I believe it is very important to consider both the long-term and short-term implications to these projects on the neighborhood.
Because, you know, firstly, the long-term effect, you already know and hear a lot of people saying already,
it greatly affects the health of everyone who lives in too close to a proximity, especially the electromagnetic field,
affect from this project here.
So please, especially for those who want to have the health clinic here, most people is coming with illness,
and we want to have the safe environments around the communities.
And especially that the population where children and elderly who live close by to these projects can be also affected by this health.
So please, yeah, I'm just going to reconsider these projects where you prioritize the health and well-being of the community
over the interest of the commercial development.
And thank you for your time today.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Okay, Mike.
Oh, that was probably Mike Ryanstein, the CPAC chair.
Okay.
Mary Jane Bryan.
Yes, good evening.
I'm Mary Jane Bryan, and yes, I am sworn.
Anyway, I am here to present to you the letter that Dr. Hoon Lee had written.
However, what he has done is he's listed.
Let me just start it, and then I'll just summarize the stuff.
I hope this letter finds you well.
I'm writing to formally express my strong concerns regarding the proposed installation.
And after careful consideration, I must respectfully oppose the installation of the tower in our neighborhood.
And then he lists the reasons that we've kind of talked about already with health concerns, environmental impact, property values, lack of community consultation.
And then he summarizes and says,
And then he summarizes and says,
As for these reasons, I respectfully request that the proposal of the 5G cell tower be reconsidered.
I urge you to explore alternative locations, particularly less populated or environmentally sensitive areas that do not compromise the well-being of its residents.
As a physician, my foremost concern is the health and safety of my family and my community.
I would appreciate your consideration of solutions that meet technological needs without compromising public trust or welfare.
And I would also just to thank you for your time and consideration.
I know it's been a long day.
And please join us in opposing this project to place the cell tower on that lot.
Thank you.
Thank you, Mary.
Eric Gomez.
Hi.
I've been sworn.
My name is Eric Gomez.
I'm a college student and a resident of Carmichael.
Now that I'm back home for summer, I have without a doubt noticed the continued poor wireless connectivity around Carmichael.
I've only been back for summer break for one week, and it has already affected me quite a bit.
Examples of these are difficulty contacting friends and family, working remotely, and basic internet searches that everyone should be able to do.
I was a student at Jesuit High School and I remember the extreme poor connection during school hours while simply trying to get my schoolwork done.
I can only imagine how bad it affects people, not just students, but everyone, who live here full-time.
I can say with the most confidence that the addition of this cell tower will improve the lives of everyone around it.
Prior to this hearing, I spent the past week walking around my neighborhood, getting supportive signatures from residents who also wanted better cellular service.
I'll tell you that it did not take any convincing at all, since everyone I spoke to is on board and supportive of the tower.
And since everyone is supportive, who I spoke to, I can only imagine how many more people would be.
Because everyone who lives in this area knows how beneficial this addition would be.
To answer the question, why are we doing this now?
I bring up my main point.
Carmichael needs to progress to modern technology to keep up with the 21st century lifestyle.
Carmichael as a city is already growing and cannot be left behind the modernization of cellular communication.
Strong internet connection is a crucial part of our daily lives and without it, we simply won't thrive.
Thank you all and I hope you will support the development of the tower.
Thank you, Eric.
Okay, that concludes public speakers.
That does conclude your public speakers.
All right, any other questions or comments from the board?
Oh, Mr. Supervisor Hume.
Thank you, Madam Vice Chair.
Thank you for everyone for coming out and taking time to stick around.
You know, it's been a very long day for all of us and appreciate the patience that's involved.
And, you know, cell towers are kind of a reoccurring sticky widget.
And in that we all recognize the need for them as we become more and more connected with the internet of things and our fridges and our vacuums and our cars and everything rely on that bandwidth.
However, despite whatever is happening with the current HHS secretary, the FCC has very specific parameters or guardrails with respect to how we can approve or deny communications facilities.
We cannot factor health risks.
That's not within our purview.
The federal government has forbade that.
We cannot factor property values, perceived or real or otherwise.
What we can do is stand steadfast to our standards as we have put forth in our code.
And so I've had cell towers being proposed in my district that also look to have deviations for the standards that our code calls for.
And because that is all we can hang our hat on, my feeling is if we make exceptions, and I will say this would probably be a high candidate for a potential exception, given its proximity to commercial, given the fact that it's been tried to be pushed as unobtrusively as possible.
But the reality remains that it does not fit within existing county code requirements.
And I believe if I make an exception in any case, I lose the moral high ground to stand fast to those standards in any future denials.
Therefore, I will not be supportive of the—or I guess I should say I will seek to uphold the appeal of the Planning Commission decision.
And I defer to my colleague whose district represents this.
Supervisor Desmond.
Thank you, Madam Vice Chair, and thank you, Supervisor Hume, for that.
I appreciate that.
I know you have been through this a lot more than many of us here.
I also want to thank everybody for coming, all the neighbors here on Mary Owen Drive.
I'm very familiar with the community.
I'm a lifer, Carmichael Kidd, as you know.
I appreciate the applicants being here as well.
And appreciate—always appreciate staff, our amazing staff that we have.
I am—you know, I agree with Supervisor Hume in terms of we have set standards.
I am not prepared to support this application and this deviation from standards.
I think it does not fit in with the aesthetics or the character of the neighborhood.
And I don't think the impacts can be appropriately mitigated.
I think even at 55 feet or 74 feet, that would not be mitigated.
And I think a 55-foot—if you lowered it at 55 feet, that's almost like a false concession
because they can come back and change it, I think, so easily.
So I am—I would move to deny the application and approve the Carmichael CPAC's appeal.
But before I—but before we vote or if anybody wants to make a second, I will say this.
You know, there are other—there are certain circumstances where I would be willing to deviate from standards
if it's some kind of compelling need, like housing.
You heard another item we heard today.
There may be a time I come back to you in the community and say,
look, we have a desperate need for more housing.
You're not going to like it.
We may want to put it in some of these locations.
So keep that in mind before you thank me for—for making this motion and voting the way I'm going to vote.
But with that, Madam Vice Chair, I would move to approve the CPAC's appeal and deny staff recommendations.
I will second that.
Okay.
Will the clerk please call the roll?
Yes.
And let the record reflect that Supervisor Kennedy and Supervisor Cerna are now absent.
So I'll call the roll call vote.
Supervisor Desmond?
Aye.
Rodriguez?
Aye.
Hume?
Aye.
And the motion carries with those members present.
Okay.
And will the clerk please call the next item?
Okay.
Our next item is item 59.
Item 59, Madam Vice Chair.
This is your nominations.
You're continuing to July 22nd.
The Carmichael Recreation and Park District.
County Service Area 4B, Slough House, Wilton, Cosumnes.
County Service Area 4C, Delta.
Natona's Community Plant—
I want to come back here for one more time.
Oh.
I want to say this.
25 years ago, I asked for a zoning situation.
And they gave it to me over duress.
A lady named Sandy Smalley was the supervisor at the time.
At those days, you could walk around, and after they voted it, I walked around and gave
her a big smooch, and they gave me a standing ovation.
Well, I'm not going to bearish you by this old guy giving you a smooch.
But thank you very much for your wonderful support.
Thank you, sir.
I can't thank you enough.
All right.
You're continuing to July 22nd.
The Carmichael Recreation and Park District.
County Service Area 4B.
Slough House, Wilton, Cosumnes.
County Service Area 4C, Delta.
Natomas Community Planning Advisory Council.
And the Sacramento Environmental Commission.
You're continuing to August 5th.
The Cemetery Advisory Commission.
Cosumnes Area Community Planning Advisory Council.
Local Child Care Planning and Development Council.
Orangeville Community Planning Advisory Council.
And the South Sacramento Community Planning Advisory Council.
Continuing to August 19th.
The Assessment Appeals Board.
Delta Citizens Municipal Advisory Council.
Public Financing Authority of the County of Sacramento Metro Air Park Enhanced Infrastructure
Financing District.
Southeast Area Community Planning Advisory Council.
And the Vineyard Area Community Planning Advisory Council.
Your first board is the Antelope Community Planning Advisory Council.
Vice Chair.
Please reappoint David Huber and continue the remaining seats to August 5th.
Thank you.
Foothill Farms Community Planning Advisory Council.
Please nominate Diane Kiefer and continue the remainder to August 5th.
Thank you.
Maternal Child and Adolescent Health Advisory Board.
Chiefs recommend nominating Watona Eidson-Tan to the Maternal Child and Adolescent Health Advisory Board and continue the remainder to August 19th.
Thank you.
North Highlands Community Planning Advisory Council.
Please continue to July 22nd.
Okay.
So that's for.
D4.
D4.
Okay.
And then for Supervisor Desmond.
Continue to August 5th, please.
And then for the first district, I chiefs recommend continuing to August 19th.
Okay.
Public Health Advisory Board.
Chiefs recommend continuing the item until August 19th.
Thank you.
Rio Linda Elverda Community Planning Advisory Council.
Please continue to July 22nd.
Okay.
Sacramento Housing and Redevelopment Commission.
Supervisor Hume.
Please continue to August 5th.
Thank you.
Sheriff Community Review Commission.
We'll start with Vice Chair Rodriguez.
Please nominate Paul Bonaventure.
And Supervisor Hume.
Please continue to August 19th.
Thank you.
Sunrise Recreation Park District.
Please reappoint Tim Berga.
All right.
Thank you.
And that concludes your nominations and appointments.
Okay.
Will the clerk please call the next item?
That would be county executive comments.
Thank you, Flo.
No comments today.
Thank you.
Okay.
Board of Supervisor comments?
Any comments?
No?
Okay.
I actually do have a comment, and I'll make it really quick.
I just wanted to take a moment to address the issues generated over the weekend with the amount of complaints in our communities with the illegal fireworks around the 4th of July weekend.
Every year, it seems like we hear a lot of frustrations and frightened residents with the scale of illegal fireworks.
I know in the past we've had concerns about using code enforcement to break up large gatherings for safety reasons, which is totally understandable.
But what I'd like to propose is something that doesn't involve direct communication at all.
I'd like to ask staff to bring back a plan for next year that utilizes our code enforcement team to document illegal fireworks activity in real time,
especially at parties where the social host ordinance applies, and then follow up with issues fines through the mail.
This would allow us to hold people accountable.
If we do this, I think it will be critical that we have clear advertisement, the enforcement efforts in advance,
so that people know that if they use illegal fireworks, they are likely to get a fine in the mail right afterwards.
I'd also like to see a plan that contemplates issuing a significant number of citations next year to really send the message that if you are going to shoot off illegal fireworks in Sacramento County,
you will pay the consequences.
Over the weekend, I saw a segment of Chris Vestal, who is a Sacramento Metro Battalion chief,
and he stated that normally on a call, a normal night, they get somewhere between 15 and 20 calls,
and on the evening of July 4th, there were over 300 calls.
And so it really shows that there is a problem countywide on this issue,
and it would be great to get ahead of it for next year and plan.
Madam Vice Chair?
Oh, yes.
Supervisor Desmond.
Thank you.
Supervisor, just real quick, are you going to comment on this?
I was going to say something else on that, but I mean, first thing, thank you, Supervisor Rodriguez.
I couldn't agree more.
I think we all followed the coverage.
Something we've been working on a lot with passing the social host ordinance that we passed here,
and working with code enforcement, it's an incredibly frustrating thing.
I would like to hear in the report back some statistics about the fires, number of calls,
because I suspect that they are dramatically going up.
And if there's a way to quantify the cost of this to the county,
particularly unincorporated Sacramento County, but maybe seeing some of the costs of the other jurisdictions as well.
And I just, you know, I know we have tried to tackle this over the years,
and it's a really challenging thing.
It's just such a proliferation.
But I appreciate you raising it.
I had a couple other things.
I don't know.
I would just address that.
We can absolutely look at that, Supervisor.
I think you're aware that there is a fireworks task force that Deputy County Executive Jones is on,
and that group will be bringing forward a report, after action report, after the 4th of July.
I believe it will include a lot of the points that you're asking for,
but we'll absolutely look at those for next year.
Thank you.
And so one other thing, I do have a German memory, if you don't mind indulging me.
Oh, absolutely.
Before I get to that, I do want to thank staff.
On June 12th, right when we started our break, we had a SACOG meeting,
an off-site SACOG meeting where we actually had a tour in West Arden Arcade,
and Supervisor Hume and Supervisor Kennedy, who serve on the SACOG board with me, were part of that.
And county staff was heavily involved in both planning that and presenting on behalf of the county to the entire SACOG board.
I think there were, I don't know, between 32 and 35 SACOG board members.
We highlighted some of the inherent challenges of unincorporated Sacramento County,
specifically West Arden Arcade area, highlighted some of the great partnerships that we have forged with SACOG in that area,
the Complete Streets Project on Arden Way, on Watt Avenue.
Did a tour of the safe stay, and I heard feedback from so many members that this was the best off-site tour that SACOG had ever done.
And we do have a lot of challenges in these unincorporated areas, but we are doing amazing work.
And I could not be prouder of the staff who presented.
I mean, just consummate professionals and just really, I think, impressed our colleagues on that SACOG board.
So just wanted to pass along that thanks, and please pass it along to the staff that were involved.
Okay, finally, I'd like to adjourn in memory today, in memory of a lifelong Sacramento resident
and dedicated community member, Mr. Rich Lawrence, who passed away on June 17, 2025.
Born and raised in Sacramento, Rich graduated from Sacramento High School in 1956
and went on to serve proudly in the U.S. Army alongside childhood friends.
He spoke often and fondly of his time in uniform, especially the memories of jumping out of airplanes.
After returning home, Rich married the love of his life, Mary Amy, in 1961.
Together they built a family rooted in love, hard work, and service.
Professionally, Rich was a trained electrician who joined the family business, Amy Hardware, in 1969.
Under his leadership, the store moved to its current home on El Camino Avenue
in the heart of Sacramento County's District 3,
where it remains a trusted neighborhood institution, beloved neighborhood institution.
Many will remember Rich on the sales floor or over the PA system,
always committed to great service.
Rich was also a devoted fan of the Kings, the Giants, and above all, the San Francisco 49ers.
His home was filled with memorabilia and cherished memories of family trips to the Super Bowl.
Rich was preceded in death by his beloved wife, Mary, in 2024.
He is survived by his children, Brian and Stacy,
his grandchildren, his sisters, and many extended family and friends.
His warmth, humor, and dedication to community will be deeply missed.
In honor of Rich Lawrence's life and legacy,
I ask that we adjourn today's meeting in his memory.
Thank you.
All right.
Any thoughts?
You good?
All right.
Well, then we will adjourn in memory of Rich Lawrence at 658.
Thank you.
Discussion Breakdown
Summary
Sacramento County Board of Supervisors Meeting - July 8, 2025
The Sacramento County Board of Supervisors convened on July 8, 2025, with Chair Serna participating remotely due to ongoing labor strikes and picketing. The meeting lasted approximately 11 hours, from morning session through evening adjournment at 6:58 PM.
Opening and Labor Relations Context
Chair Serna opened the meeting remotely, explaining his decision not to cross picket lines during active strikes by county bargaining units. The board maintained a quorum with Supervisors Desmond, Rodriguez, Hume, and Serna present, while Supervisor Kennedy was absent.
Public Comments and Labor Strike
The morning session featured extensive public comment from United Public Employees (UPE) members conducting a one-day strike. Over 20 speakers addressed the board regarding:
- Demands for a 5% minimum wage increase versus the county's 2.8% offer (below the 3.28% national inflation rate)
- Opposition to proposed healthcare benefit cuts
- Concerns about losing negotiation rights for classification studies
- Reports of employees unable to afford rent despite working multiple jobs
- Criticism of management salary increases while workers struggle financially
Key Personnel Actions
Service Recognition: John Kozitsa received recognition for 35 years of county service, having worked in various departments including Public Works, IHSS Public Authority, and recently completing his MBA.
Appointment: The board approved Florence Evans as the new County Clerk Recorder, succeeding Donna Allred who is retiring after 34 years. Evans previously served 9 years as County Clerk and 22 years total with the county.
Major Financial Actions
Airport Bonds: Approved issuance of up to $800 million in airport system revenue bonds for SMF Forward projects, including new gates at Concourse B, baggage handling improvements, and apron space expansion.
Assessment Districts: Approved multiple assessment levies including:
- Zone 13 Sacramento County Water Agency ($2.3 million)
- CSA 10 Benefit Zone 3 (trip reduction services)
- Landscape Maintenance District Zone 4 (requiring $768,920 road fund transfer)
State Fair Presentation
CEO Tom Martinez presented the 2025 California State Fair updates:
- 171st anniversary celebration running July 11-27
- First year without horse racing due to horse availability
- Modified hours (4 PM opening Monday-Thursday) to address heat concerns
- New entertainment lineup including Ludacris, Shaquille O'Neal as DJ Diesel
- New California Lowrider Exhibit featuring cars from across the state
- $2.25 million investment in major concert entertainment
Property and Business Improvement Districts
Six PBIDs presented annual reports with combined budgets of $3.1 million:
- Combined 337 million square feet coverage
- 70% average budget allocation to clean and safe services
- 225 tons of trash removed, 13,000+ dispatch calls handled
- Individual districts: 80-Watt, Antelope, Arden Arcade, Carmichael, Florin Road, and Fulton Avenue
Legislative Opposition
The board unanimously opposed Senate Bill 802 by Senator Ashby, which would create a state-mandated joint powers authority for housing and homeless programs. Concerns included:
- Loss of local control over decision-making
- Potential constitutional issues with funding transfers
- Lack of consultation with affected jurisdictions
- All Sacramento County cities and organizations in opposition
Controversial Cell Tower Appeal
The board heard an appeal of a Planning Commission approval for a 74-foot cellular tower at 5204 Marion Drive in Carmichael. After extensive public testimony:
- 18 speakers testified, mostly in opposition citing health concerns, property values, and residential character
- Applicant AT&T offered to reduce height to 55 feet
- Supervisor Desmond noted the tower could later be raised 20 feet ministerially
- Decision: Board voted 3-0 to approve the appeal and deny the cell tower application
Key Outcomes
- Labor Relations: Strike occurred with no immediate resolution to contract negotiations
- Infrastructure: Approved major airport bond financing for expansion projects
- Governance: Strongly opposed state legislation threatening local control
- Community: Denied controversial cell tower in residential neighborhood
- Personnel: Successfully transitioned key leadership positions
Adjournment
The meeting adjourned at 6:58 PM in memory of Rich Lawrence, a lifelong Sacramento resident and owner of Amy Hardware, who passed away June 17, 2025.
Meeting Transcript
I call to order this meeting of the Sacramento County Board of Supervisors for Tuesday, July 8th, 2025. Madam Clerk, will you please call the roll and establish a quorum? Yes. Good morning. Supervisors Desmond? Here. Rodriguez? Here. Hume? Here. Cerner? Here. And you have a quorum. And let the record reflect that Supervisor Kennedy is not present today. This meeting of the Sacramento County Board of Supervisors is live and recorded in closed captioning. It is cable cast on Metro Cable 14, the local government affairs channel, on the Comcast and direct TVU versus cable systems. It is also live streamed at metro14live.saccounty.gov. And today's meeting will be repeated Friday, July 11th at 6 p.m. on channel 14 and viewed at youtube.com forward slash metro cable 14. The Board of Supervisors fosters public engagement during the meeting and encourages public participation, civility and use of courteous language. The Board does not condone the use of profanity, vulgar language, gestures or other inappropriate behavior including personal attacks or threats directed towards any meeting participant. Seating is limited and available on a first come, first serve basis. Each speaker will be given two minutes to make a public comment and are limited to making one comment per agenda or off agenda item. Please be mindful of the public comment procedures to avoid being interrupted while making your comment. Comments made by the public during Board of Supervisors meetings may include information that could be inaccurate or misleading, particularly concerning topics related to public health, voter registrations and elections. The County of Sacramento does not endorse or validate the accuracy of public statements made during these open public forums. The recordings are shared to provide transparency and access to the proceedings of public meetings. To make a comment in person, please fill out a speaker request form and hand it to clerk staff. The chairperson will open public comments for each agenda or off agenda item and direct the clerk to call the name of each speaker. When the clerk calls your name, please come to the podium and make your comment. If a speaker is unavailable to make a comment prior to the closing of public comments, the speaker waves their request to speak and the clerk will file the speaker request form in the record. The clerk will manage the timer and allow each speaker two minutes to make a comment. Off agenda public comments will take place for a maximum of 30 minutes and the remainder of the agenda comments will take place at the conclusion of the time matters in the afternoon. You may also send written comments by email to boardclerk at saccounty.gov and your comment will be routed to the board and filed in the meeting record. If you need an accommodation pursuant to the Americans with Disabilities Act or for medical or other reasons, please see clerk staff for assistance or contact the clerk's office at 916-874-5451 or by email at boardclerk at saccounty.gov.