OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Sacramento Regional Transit Board Meeting - April 11, 2017

Sacramento Regional Transit Board MeetingsTuesday, April 11, 2017
BodySacramento County, California
SessionSacramento Regional Transit Board Meetings
DateTuesday, April 11, 2017
StatusFILED
Video Record

STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE

Transcript — Verbatim
1:01

I would like to like to have a lot of things.

1:04

Let's go.

1:08

Okay, good evening, everyone.

1:10

We're going to go ahead and call the uh board meeting for the Sacramento Regional Transit for Monday, April 10th, 2017, with this small but dedicated group of board members.

1:19

We do have a few others that will be uh that will be showing up.

1:22

So uh so Cindy uh carried away here.

1:26

Director Budge is marked as being absent.

1:29

Director Hansen Director Harris.

1:32

Yeah.

1:32

Director Hume is marked as being absent.

1:35

Director Jennings is marked as being absent.

1:38

Director Kennedy, Director Miller, Director Natoli, Director Shanier and Director Cerna are marked as being absent.

1:48

And Chair Moram Moran.

1:51

With that, we do not have a quorum.

1:53

Okay.

1:53

But I promise we will at some point here.

1:56

So with that, would everyone please rise and join me in the Pledge of Allegiance?

2:03

I pledge to the flag of the United States of America and the Republic for which it stands.

2:11

One nation under God, indivisible with liberty and justice for all.

2:20

This meeting of the Sacramento Regional Transit District will be cable cast without interruption on Metro Cable 14, the local government affairs channel, and will be streamed live on RT's website.

2:32

Tonight's meeting will air on Wednesday, April 12th at 6 p.m.

2:36

and replayed on Thursday, April 13th at 9 a.m.

2:40

on Channel 14 and webcast at WWW SAC Metro Cable.tv.

2:46

It is also closed caption.

2:49

Members of the audience wishing to address the board should fill out a speaker card located at the rear of the room and provide it to me or Adam.

2:57

Please speak into the microphone and state your name for the record.

3:00

We would appreciate everyone turning off their cell phones.

3:04

Thank you.

3:05

Okay.

3:05

Thank you, Cindy.

3:06

And one of the reasons we have a paucity of attendance here is the spring break has uh captured a number of our board members.

3:13

Um I think uh enjoying vacations and whatnot.

3:16

So uh so with that, Cindy, uh state.

3:19

Public addresses the board on matters not on the agenda.

3:22

Okay, thank you.

3:23

So to begin with, uh Mike Barnbaum.

3:27

Good evening, Mike.

3:29

Good evening.

3:30

Thank you for uh having us tonight uh before your board.

3:36

Uh just an announcement on Wednesday at 6 p.m.

3:41

Uh in the Elk Grove City Council Chambers located at 8400 Laguna Palms Way.

3:47

The comprehensive operational analysis for ETRAN uh is set to go before the council uh and forecast for adoption.

4:00

Uh the analysis highlights uh what a future e-trans system will look like both uh locally within Elk Grove and its connectivity to uh transit systems throughout the region, including but not limited to South County Transit and Sacramento Regional Transit.

4:21

Uh the forecast uh in the document calls for uh changes to their fare structure in January 2018 and July of 2020.

4:35

Uh staff is presenting to the council on Wednesday evening uh a base scenario um a seven percent 7.6 percent service reduction scenario and a 10 percent service reduction scenario.

5:00

This uh comprehensive operational analysis uh has taken many months uh to uh perfect and detail uh incorporating comments from the general public, uh key stakeholders, uh, and many of the council members that will both past and and present uh that will be making a key decision on Wednesday evening.

5:22

If you are anyone again or interested in going, it is uh this Wednesday, 6 p.m., 8400 Laguna Palms Way.

5:31

Uh staff has been in contact with us uh to consider but has not finalized the decision as of this moment uh of having an e-tran bus or shuttle available when the item concludes and the council votes on it to take folks back from the council chambers to the CRC station, the current hub of the e-trans service.

6:00

We say the current hub because the forecast in the COA calls for a grid system and commuter service uh uh following many of the local routes that are being presented in the grid network that you will see on Wednesday evening.

6:19

Great.

6:20

Thank you.

6:20

Thanks.

6:21

Thanks for the update there, Mike.

6:22

And uh just to note that the um arrival of um director Kennedy's powerful bloating voting block has put us put us over.

6:33

Unfortunately, Donatullies right behind me or so.

6:41

Okay, next uh Jeffrey.

6:43

Jeffrey Tardi Gia.

6:54

Good evening, Jeffrey.

6:56

Um, and as I see Don Natoli coming through the door through here, um, to add on to uh the Elk Grove uh two things for regional transit to be it, should we say I'm hoping they have uh are well informed of is dealing with the I and J Street proposal of a single route of P and Q also going through.

7:18

This is where they are looking at realigning the Elk Grove coming through, and that will be likely that there will be need to be for the reverse a better, should we say signal signifying of where you pick up e-trans than the little signs that are currently available to get allow you to know where you pick up e-tran to go the other direction.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Public Transit█████████████████████████████████████████████50%
Budget and Finance█████████████14%
Public Engagement████████9%
Procedural██████7%
Contracting██████7%
Miscellaneous█████5%
General Manager Report████4%
Technology and Innovation██2%
Public Comment██2%
Summary of Proceedings

Sacramento Regional Transit Board Meeting - April 11, 2017

The Sacramento Regional Transit (RT) Board met on April 11, 2017 (the transcript notes the meeting was called for April 10, but the official date is per the instruction). The meeting began without a quorum due to spring break absences, but a quorum was later achieved. The board approved the consent calendar, heard public comments, received reports on SB1 passage, bond rating improvement, ridership successes, a transit-friendly drinking map, and the preliminary FY2018 budget.

Consent Calendar

  • Items 1–9 were approved as a block. Board member Natoli requested discussion on Item 5 (1225 R Street Interior Remodel contract). He noted that the single bid from RBH Construction Inc. was approximately 40% over the estimate ($145,000 vs. $82,000), attributing the difference to market conditions. After staff confirmed the market was driving prices up, the board moved and seconded the consent calendar. The motion carried (8 aye, 0 no, with abstentions not recorded).

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Mike Barnbaum provided an update on the Elk Grove Comprehensive Operational Analysis (COA) for e-Tran. The COA will be presented to the Elk Grove City Council on Wednesday, April 12, at 6 p.m. It forecasts fare structure changes in January 2018 and July 2020, and includes a base scenario, a 7.6% service reduction, and a 10% service reduction. He urged board members to attend.
  • Jeffrey Tardigia raised multiple concerns: inadequate signage for e-Tran reverse direction pickups, insufficient attention to bus ridership during arena events, a coding issue with the Connect Card quad-core processor, lack of disclosure of bus shuttle costs for I-80 and Roseville incidents, and the need for line-item detail in the budget. He also asked about ticket distribution for upcoming events.
  • Adam Wong, a Sacramento City College student, presented his "Transit-Friendly Drinking Map" showing alcohol-serving locations near light rail stations. The map had surpassed 4,000 views. He expressed support for RT and noted that the map promotes transit use and prevents drunk driving. Board members praised his work.

Discussion Items

  • General Manager's Report (Henry Li):
    • Announced the passage of SB1, which will provide approximately $5.2 billion statewide for roads and transit (85% roads, 15% transit). RT expects about $10 million annually, to be used for contingency reserves, reducing a $29 million line of credit, replacing lost federal CMAC funding for the Blue Line extension, and offsetting lower cap-and-trade revenues.
    • Reported an upward change in RT's revenue bond rating from a lactive to a stable outlook by Moody's, achieved after seven months of data preparation.
    • Noted progress on the strategic vision and route optimization, with community surveys and 20–30 scheduled presentations. Mentioned new labor agreements that reduce pension contributions from 26% to 3% for new employees and a transition from contracted security (G4S) to internal transit agents, saving $200,000.
    • Announced that the FY2018 proposed operating budget is 1% less than the prior year without changing service or fares, due to efficiencies. A tentative agreement with Paratransit Inc. will save $3.5 million annually while maintaining service.
  • Financial Report (Brent Burlinger): Provided February 2017 financials: revenues $13.3 million, expenses $13.2 million, surplus of $100,000. Fare revenues exceeded budget by $160,000 due to a one-time SAC State payment. Sales tax growth (4.5%) offset an STA loss of $770,000. Federal revenues are expected to decrease by $500,000 annually. Ridership remains a concern, and Moody's recommended building a 60-day cash reserve (currently 23 days). The board discussed reserve policies.
  • Media Presentation (Deborah): Played a news clip highlighting RT's free rides during the NCAA tournament and St. Patrick's Day, noting that 20% of arena attendees used light rail and many were new riders.
  • New Business – Item 11: Preliminary FY2018 Budget Release (David Goldman): Presented the operating budget of $160.9 million (down from $162.5 million) and capital additions of $195 million (mostly for the downtown riverfront streetcar, funded by federal and state grants). The budget maintains service levels and fare structure. A 60-day public review begins, with a public hearing on May 8 and adoption on June 12. Board member Natoli clarified that the streetcar project is not RT money, but may fund RT staff. Public commenter Jeffrey Tardigia requested more line-item detail. The board approved the resolution (motion carried 8-0).
  • Item 12: San Joaquin Joint Powers Authority Meeting Report (Director Natoli): Summarized the March 24 meeting, which included a lengthy discussion on single-source contracting for advertising. He noted that Director Hume frequently attends.

Key Outcomes

  • Approved the consent calendar (including the 1225 R Street contract) with discussion on item 5.
  • Approved the release of the preliminary FY2018 operating and capital budgets for public review (Item 11), with a public hearing set for May 8, 2017.
  • Heard the general manager's report and financial updates; no formal votes were taken on those items.
  • Received reports from advisory committees and public testimony; no immediate board action required.

Meeting Transcript

I would like to like to have a lot of things. Let's go. Okay, good evening, everyone. We're going to go ahead and call the uh board meeting for the Sacramento Regional Transit for Monday, April 10th, 2017, with this small but dedicated group of board members. We do have a few others that will be uh that will be showing up. So uh so Cindy uh carried away here. Director Budge is marked as being absent. Director Hansen Director Harris. Yeah. Director Hume is marked as being absent. Director Jennings is marked as being absent. Director Kennedy, Director Miller, Director Natoli, Director Shanier and Director Cerna are marked as being absent. And Chair Moram Moran. With that, we do not have a quorum. Okay. But I promise we will at some point here. So with that, would everyone please rise and join me in the Pledge of Allegiance? I pledge to the flag of the United States of America and the Republic for which it stands. One nation under God, indivisible with liberty and justice for all. This meeting of the Sacramento Regional Transit District will be cable cast without interruption on Metro Cable 14, the local government affairs channel, and will be streamed live on RT's website. Tonight's meeting will air on Wednesday, April 12th at 6 p.m. and replayed on Thursday, April 13th at 9 a.m. on Channel 14 and webcast at WWW SAC Metro Cable.tv. It is also closed caption. Members of the audience wishing to address the board should fill out a speaker card located at the rear of the room and provide it to me or Adam. Please speak into the microphone and state your name for the record. We would appreciate everyone turning off their cell phones. Thank you. Okay. Thank you, Cindy. And one of the reasons we have a paucity of attendance here is the spring break has uh captured a number of our board members. Um I think uh enjoying vacations and whatnot. So uh so with that, Cindy, uh state. Public addresses the board on matters not on the agenda. Okay, thank you. So to begin with, uh Mike Barnbaum. Good evening, Mike. Good evening. Thank you for uh having us tonight uh before your board. Uh just an announcement on Wednesday at 6 p.m. Uh in the Elk Grove City Council Chambers located at 8400 Laguna Palms Way. The comprehensive operational analysis for ETRAN uh is set to go before the council uh and forecast for adoption. Uh the analysis highlights uh what a future e-trans system will look like both uh locally within Elk Grove and its connectivity to uh transit systems throughout the region, including but not limited to South County Transit and Sacramento Regional Transit. Uh the forecast uh in the document calls for uh changes to their fare structure in January 2018 and July of 2020. Uh staff is presenting to the council on Wednesday evening uh a base scenario um a seven percent 7.6 percent service reduction scenario and a 10 percent service reduction scenario. This uh comprehensive operational analysis uh has taken many months uh to uh perfect and detail uh incorporating comments from the general public, uh key stakeholders, uh, and many of the council members that will both past and and present uh that will be making a key decision on Wednesday evening. If you are anyone again or interested in going, it is uh this Wednesday, 6 p.m., 8400 Laguna Palms Way. Uh staff has been in contact with us uh to consider but has not finalized the decision as of this moment uh of having an e-tran bus or shuttle available when the item concludes and the council votes on it to take folks back from the council chambers to the CRC station, the current hub of the e-trans service. We say the current hub because the forecast in the COA calls for a grid system and commuter service uh uh following many of the local routes that are being presented in the grid network that you will see on Wednesday evening. Great.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com