5:41Good afternoon, everyone.
5:42Welcome to the Temple City Council work study session agenda.
5:46Item number one is called to order council meetings.
5:48Can we watch in real time via Cox Cable Channel 11 and at Tempi.gov/slash Tempe11.
5:53Members of the public may also attend the meeting virtually through Microsoft Teams.
5:56Guidelines for conduct at City Council meetings are on the table near the entrance for those in attendance at tonight's meeting.
6:01We will now play a video with the proper protocol for ensuring the appropriate conduct at city council meetings.
6:12Disruptive behavior will not be allowed.
6:15Continued disruptive behavior will lead to removal from the council chambers.
6:19We need to be able to hear everyone in the room.
6:21Behavior that disrupts, disturbs, or otherwise impedes the orderly conduct of any city council meeting is not helpful and is not permitted.
6:29This includes behavior both inside and outside of the council chambers.
6:33Should individuals inside the council chambers become disruptive so that city business is not able to be conducted.
6:39The mayor will first ask that the individuals allow city business to be completed.
6:43There will be time for public comment during the call to the audience portion of the meeting.
6:47If no cooperation, the mayor will issue a verbal warning and let them know that the continued disruptive behavior will lead to removal from the council chambers.
6:55If there is still no cooperation, the mayor will issue a second verbal warning and let them know that the continued disruptive behavior will lead to removal from the council chambers.
7:04If there is no cooperation after asking and two verbal warnings, then the mayor will ask security officers to remove only those individuals who were causing the disruption.
7:12Security personnel should not engage in any way, but only escort them from the council chambers.
7:17If individuals refuse to leave, security personnel shall warn them that they are trespassing, and that the next step will be arrest by a Tempe police officer.
7:26Tempe officers may have to arrest if individuals refuse to leave.
7:29Charges for trespass and disorderly conduct may apply, as well as other charges.
7:34Should anyone be asked to be removed?
7:36The mayor will recess the meeting.
7:40Before we move into the call to the audience portion of the meeting, I want to take a moment to address campaign related activity, especially that we are now in the 2026 election season.
7:48City Council meetings are open to the public and are a vital form for civic engagement.
7:52We welcome all individuals, including candidates, to speak on matters of public concern during the public comment portion of the meeting.
8:00However, because this is an official city council meeting that is both televised and live streamed using city resources.
8:21Thank you for helping us maintain the integrity and neutrality of our public meetings.
8:39None received for this meeting.
9:01And I'm gonna see here.
10:00We're entering our second year, we're actually in our second year without supplementals, and also have only approved budget requests that have revenue offsets or expenditure offsets.
10:07Additionally, we um with the expenditure with the expenditure reductions we've implemented, all major funds are meeting their financial policies, so their fund balance targets.
10:25So we are seeing, particularly in the retail sales, some growth over the prior year.
10:32However, I want to be cautiously optimistic because the growth that we're seeing is not sufficient to offset the loss of residential rental residential rental tax.
10:42We are also closely monitoring the transit fund.
10:46We're ensuring that there's sufficient revenue in the fund to cover the to maintain the service levels that we currently have, and also to ensure that we have local match for the extension of the streetcar to Mesa and also for the pedestrian bridge on Rio Salado.
11:04With that, before I do that, lastly, I want to thank our budget team for all the work that they've done in preparing the presentation in front of you and the long range forecast.
11:15Specifically Scott Gruber, Kevin Di Dominico, and Venecia Benson.
11:20With that, I'll turn over the presentation to Robert to go over the first couple of slides.
11:25All right, good afternoon, Mayor and members of the councils.
11:28Today's presentation of the long range forecast directly aligns with the council strategic priority of financial stability and vitality.
11:35The goal is to maintain the highest general obligation bond rating by keeping the general fund within fund balance policy levels.
11:41The specific performance measures are 5.04 and 5.05.
11:49So I would like to just briefly review the public meeting dates for both the capital and operating budgets that we have.
11:56We've held our public forums and our online budget forum is open through March 1st.
12:02Today we are introducing the proposed capital projects along with the updated long range forecast.
12:08Then we have the initial recommended capital projects, which will be presented in March.
12:14We have two budget review sessions planned, one in April and another in May if needed.
12:19The tandem budget adoption is scheduled for May 14th.
12:22Final budget adoption is on June 4th.
12:24The property tax levy adoption is June 26th.
12:28And I will turn it back over to Lizette.
12:32So we'll start with the local economic update.
12:34State of Arizona economy remains overall stable.
12:38Household income in the state of Arizona is up over the prior year.
12:43Inflation has also moderated below the national average.
12:47I mentioned earlier that we're seeing an increase in retail sales tax.
12:51That's not specific to Tempe.
12:53We're seeing that statewide.
12:55Our other business categories are also coming in stable compared to the prior years.
13:00And I have a chart to show you here.
13:06So this chart, I'll orient you first on the information in front of you.
13:10So we have bar graphs.
13:12The information you're seeing in front of you goes back to four years.
13:16So you have four years of data, and the information is for the first half of the fiscal year.
13:20So the information is from July through December.
13:23The gold part of the bar graph you're seeing is the revenues for the other business categories with the exception of residential rental.
13:31So the business categories in the gold do not include residential rental.
13:35And if you have, if you add the blue to that, then you have the residential rental component.
13:40But if you just focus on the gold part of the bars, you can see the growth that I've mentioned.
13:46In fiscal year 2026, you see that the other business categories is much greater than the revenues we received from the prior year.
13:54However, as I mentioned earlier, the revenues are not enough to offset the loss of residential rental.
14:00As you can see, the total revenues compared to fiscal year 2025, fiscal year 26 is lagging.
14:06And again, that's because of residential rental.
14:11Also wanted to break down the sales tax by business categories.
14:15So you first see the retail, then you have rentals, and the very last bar graph you see is the hotel motel.
14:22Similar to the last slide, we have four years data going back to fiscal year 2023.
14:27I want to highlight the retail category.
14:30As you can see, the blue bar that you're seeing is fiscal year 2026.
14:34Retail overall is about 9% higher than last year.
14:39And included in that retail category is online retail.
14:42Online retail is actually up 19% compared to the prior year.
14:47So again, we're seeing growth in retail, all the other business categories, as you can see in this chart with the exception of rentals, are stable, about the same as last year.
15:00And then you see for the second bar graph component here, you see that rentals is down compared to last year, again, due to the loss of residential rental.
15:07Pressing the wrong button.
15:10Going back to the forecast assumptions, nothing's changed from this year from this presentation compared to last November.
15:17So we have sufficient revenues and also fund balance or reserves to maintain the current service levels in Tempe.
15:25In our forecast, we are continuing the salary plans and employee benefits that we've agreed to in our memoranda of understanding with our four labor groups that we have.
15:33We did have to lower our interest earnings because of the drawdown of fund balance and reserves.
15:40In this forecast, we did include the losses of revenue from again the incorporation of Santan Valley and also the federal income tax conformity.
15:50So those two components would be a reduction in our state shared revenues that we receive from the state of Arizona.
15:56As mentioned earlier, we have implemented proactive budget balancing strategies, which I'll go over a little bit more in the next slide here.
16:07Some of the strategies that we've implemented is to use our available resources and prioritize existing programs and services.
16:15And what that means is that we don't have a lot of capacity for growth or for implementing new services or programs.
16:22We're prior to prioritizing and completing the current five-year adopted CIP.
16:27And when I say the current five years, so the fiscal year 2026 adopted CIP.
16:33We're also using the reserves for public safety personnel retirement system for to fund public safety retirement contributions.
16:41Those reserves were set aside for that specific purpose.
16:44The same thing for the OPEB or the other post-employment benefits reserves.
16:49We're gonna draw down on those reserves to fund post-employment health benefits.
16:54We have reduced the transfer to the transportation fund and also suspended the municipal arts transfer from the general fund.
17:01So those two last the two, the last two bullet items that you see here, there's no legal requirements to do those transfers.
17:08And if there's capacity in the general fund, our intention is to bring forth the continuation of those transfers in future years.
17:18The forecast does not anticipate a recession or any economic slowdown.
17:23That's consistent with information we've received from our forecasting partners.
17:28So we do look at the finance advisory committee, that's through the state of Arizona, joint legislative budget committee for the highway use of revenue fund.
17:37We look at the forecast from the Arizona Department of Transportation, and we have other forecasting partners that we have information from.
17:46So if there is a recession or other economic slowdown, there are other considerations that we can do to balance our budget.
17:53We could freeze vacant positions to reduce our personal costs, which is our largest operating cost.
17:59Of course, we can implement a process to allow for crucial hiring of crucial positions.
18:05We can also reduce our service levels to mitigate cost, shift resources to the highest priority services and programs, and we can also continue to identify any economic opportunities to increase the tax base.
18:20So we're continuing to do that.
18:22As I mentioned earlier, though there is growth in our sales tax, still not enough to offset the loss of residential rentals.
18:31So we know that the work is not quite done yet.
18:34So the budget team and I were continually looking at opportunities to reduce costs and also opportunities to increase our revenues.
18:44Here is the potential scenario for the general fund.
18:47You've seen this chart before.
18:49Focus on the left part first.
18:51So that top left, this is the chart for your revenues and expenditures.
18:56The red line that you see is the line for expenditures, and then the blue line that you're seeing below that is the line for revenues.
19:03As mentioned earlier, we are drawing down on our reserves or fund balance to balance our budget.
19:09But as you can see in this forecast, to the right, the chart to the right is the fund balance policy in the general fund.
19:16The yellow section is the policy, so it's between 20 to 30% of revenues.
19:21And throughout the forecast period, as you can see, our fund balance is uh at 22% in fiscal year 2930.
19:31I do want to focus a little bit on fiscal year 2025.
19:35We did close our books last December when the financial audit was completed.
19:41And I wanted to highlight again, we implemented proactive measures to reduce our budget.
19:47So for fiscal year 2025, if you go back to our presentation last year, so February 2025, at that time we forecasted unassigned fund balance to be at 35%.
20:00As you can see here, the actual fund balance actually came in at 38%, so higher than what we forecasted.
20:07Fund balance at the end of fiscal year 2025 was 10.6 million grade higher than what we had anticipated last year.
20:15And wanted to point that out is that's due to the fact that we reduce our expenditures and also revenues came in higher than what we had expected.
20:27I'll turn over to presentation now to Robert to go over the enterprise fund and also to other special revenue funds.
20:34So the enterprise and special revenue funds are consistent, which was uh presented back in November.
20:40With water, wastewater and solid waste, those funds are stable with fund balance remaining within policy throughout the forecast period.
20:48The revenues in those forecasts reflect anticipated future rate increases.
20:52For the emergency medical transport fund, that fund continues to have a stable outlook.
20:57The fund balance policy is still a work in progress as we work with FIRE on developing and refining that policy.
21:07Moving on to the special revenue funds.
21:10Um, first with transit.
21:12So transit does currently have a significant fund balance, but it is impacted by the loss of residential rental, just like the general fund.
21:20Um expenses in that fund are currently growing, and we are currently relying on fund balance to bridge the gap between expenses and revenues in that fund.
21:32We will continue to refine this forecast next November as we have more information on proposition 479 and the distribution of those funds.
21:41For the uh transportation fund, also known as the highway user revenue fund, um, that receives that fund receives the majority of its revenue from state shared highway user revenue funds, gas tax.
21:53Um, the fund balance remains within policy throughout the forecast period.
21:58As mayor and council are aware, future HERF revenues are subject to legislation and may increase or decrease the um legislation may increase or decrease the amount the the city receives.
22:09And we continue to monitor any pending legislation related to that fund.
22:14With arts and culture, um, despite the loss of residential rental sales tax in that fund, um that fund remains stable with revenues projected to be consistent with the November forecast.
22:24Fund balance remains above policy levels throughout the forecast period.
22:32And Mayor and Council, that concludes our presentation.
22:34We would be happy to answer any questions.
22:37Greatly appreciated.
22:38Uh, council, any comments or questions on item 3A.
22:52Well, no, I don't think so.
22:54I think you're good.
22:54I thought for a second there might be one, but I think great presentation.
22:58If there's no questions, you covered it exceptionally well.
23:02So I guess uh you're probably not going too far, I would imagine then, which will bring us to item 3B, which is in the introduction of the five-year capital improvements program project requests.
23:11And so I guess Robert, you're staying unless that's going.
23:15Yes, so uh long time no see.
23:17So good afternoon, Mayor and members of the council.
23:21Uh Robert Baer, municipal budget director.
23:24We are here to take the first look at the five-year capital improvement plan, aka the CIP.
23:30Um with the um the capital improvement plan and the operating budget, both of those items will come together on the April 23rd budget review session.
23:39The CIP is a planning document.
23:41Only the first year is adopted, but it's important to have a plan for all the city's capital and infrastructure needs so council and the public can see what those capital needs of the city are.
23:51Um, no formal approvals are being sought tonight.
23:53Rather, it is an opportunity to get familiar with what staff has put forward.
23:57The CIP document represents many months of work by departments.
24:02Um, and the department directors are available today to answer any questions you have on project specific questions.
24:08In addition to all the work by the departments, this document really only comes together through teamwork and the hours of work by our budget staff, specifically Kevin Domenico and Benecia Benson.
24:23So the CIP supports, I would say, all of the city council strategic priorities.
24:27This specific presentation is tied to strong community connections and uh financial stability and vitality.
24:36And you can see the performance measures we tie this presentation to on the slide.
24:42We have this slide in the last presentation.
24:44Um we included it in this presentation for posterity.
24:49Now moving on to public outreach.
24:51So you can see a lot of photos from our public outreach um events related to the budget.
25:00So this includes our Tempe Forum where residents can communicate their priorities by allocating 100 among different programs and services.
25:05This survey is open through March 1st, so it's open for a few more days.
25:10Going back, we went on January 24th to the regional unity walk where we had a booth there and provided information on the city's budget process and also saw public input on the city's priorities.
25:23On February 4th, we held virtual and in-person budget forums.
25:27This meeting was recorded and posted to the MBO website.
25:31On February 10th, we met with the mayor's youth advisory council and presented on the city's budget process and showed them results of online survey from MyAC members.
25:40We also have a public website, of course, that contains a lot of information resources for our residents on all aspects of the operating and capital budgets.
25:48And finally, we have continuous information going out via Tempe today, press releases, social media apps, and postcard mailings.
25:58So now I'll go a little bit into the CIP document that you have in your council packet.
26:04The public can also access this document via the agenda packet that is posted online.
26:08This document contains all the proposed projects for the five year CIP.
26:15Departments have submitted project requests totaling almost two billion dollars.
26:18To help you navigate this document, we have a table of contents that links to overall programs as well as the 13 program summaries in the document.
26:28So page one of the packet contains the summary of the entire five year capital improvement program.
26:35Page two has a summary based off of funding sources.
26:38And there are summary pages for each major program and bookmarks for each project request.
26:44So this is a little bit of an eye test, so this is not meant to necessarily be read.
26:50So in the next three slides, I'll kind of just walk through how the document is laid out.
26:56This is to get you a little bit more familiar.
26:58So this is the table of contents that is included in it.
27:01Each program has a hyperlink that takes you to the summary page for that program.
27:06Next, we'll go to a program summary.
27:08So this one is for the police program.
27:13So you can see all the capital projects underneath this program, the funding sources related to that, and the spend over the five years.
27:21And then finally, this is what a project detail page looks like.
27:24So for this one, we have the public safety communications equipment replacement program, but each program, each project in the CIP will have a similar page to this.
27:34The detailed page includes project description, council priorities that are addressed by the project, estimated budget and funding sources, and operating impacts if there are any operating impacts tied to that capital project.
27:44At any time, you can use the bookmarks in the packet to navigate back to the table of contents, project summaries, or any project detail page.
27:53So I want to talk about next steps with our capital improvement budget process.
27:59So really the next step is we need to determine the amount of resources we have available to fund all these capital requests, the $2 billion.
28:07One of the things that we have to consider is our bond capacity.
28:10The city's financial policies set a goal to limit the property tax levy growth, which is the total amount of property tax paid citywide, to 5% or less across all the properties of the city.
28:22So the amount of general obligation bonds we can issue is tied to that capacity within the property tax levy.
28:28We also need to maintain healthy debt to income ratios and coverage ratios to in order to maintain our bond ratings.
28:48This year we have also implemented a cross-departmental team to score and prioritize our CIP projects to help determine that prioritization of CIP projects.
29:01One other thing I want to highlight too is the organizational capacity.
29:06So not only does it require money to accomplish CIP projects, but also requires engineering staff, procurement staff, finance staff, staff all across the city to accomplish these projects.
29:16So when we're looking at the recommended CIP in a month, we will also need to consider what our staffing capacity or organizational capacity to accomplish projects are.
29:32And that concludes our presentation.
29:34Again, I am more than happy to take any input, questions, or comments.
29:37Uh, mayor and council may have.
29:40Council, uh, any comments or questions on item 3B.
29:48Once again, thank you.
29:51All right, that brings me to item 3C, which is the TEMPE Transportation Plan 2050 update.
29:58Eric Iverson with Lindsay Post.
30:04Members of the council.
30:05I'm just making a cameo here to introduce this item.
30:09I am Eric Iverson, the transportation and sustainability director.
30:13I am here with Lindsay Post, a senior planner on our transportation planning team who is going to be going through the presentation.
30:20This is the second time that this project is coming to you all.
30:24We kicked it off last fall, late summer, early fall.
30:29And we have been going through tons of public outreach.
30:32And what we're sharing here tonight is all the findings that we heard from the community, boards and commissions.
30:39Before we go into the development of the plan, we will be coming back to you for the draft plan and more details at uh in in the coming months.
30:48So just want to mention the importance of the transportation plan.
30:52We've been again doing tons of community outreach.
30:55Um, these are living documents that are really important to us, important to the whole community.
31:00Um, the previous iterations of this plan, we do it every every 10 years.
31:04It follows the adoption of the city's general plan.
31:08Um, so it fleshes out really what the vision is for transportation in our city going forward.
31:13Um, previous plans have been successful enough that we um have policies like the Vision Zero program that you're all familiar with, which is really addressing traffic safety in our city, and we've had um three years now of reductions in our serious and fatal crashes in our city, which is tremendous.
31:30Um we also arrive at this point in time with uh the highest per capita transit ridership in the state as well as the um highest bike ridership in the region.
31:41So these plans are important and they really do direct us towards what the future of our city is as it relates to transportation.
31:48Um wanted to emphasize that.
31:49And before I hand it over to Lindsay, I want to give make sure I give a shout out to the team that is working on this.
31:54We have our um deputy director, Shelley Siler, uh Chase Wallman who's with us today, um, runs our transportation planning team.
32:01Uh, Mitchell uh Mitchell Willard is not here today and um but but is working on this plan, and then Alex Phillips, who really has been um the right hand man for Lindsay on this on this effort.
32:12So um I wanted to say those words and we'll hand it over to Lindsay uh for the rest of the presentation, and we're all here to answer any questions uh that you may have after.
32:25Good afternoon, Mayor and Council.
32:27I'm glad to be back to update you on our progress with the Tempe Transportation Plan 2050.
32:32Today I'll provide a summary of what we heard from the public in the last phase, give you an idea of what we're working on internally, and provide a look at what we showed the public at last night's open house.
32:46This is our project timeline.
32:48Uh, we actually kicked off in March of last year.
32:51We are in shape up shape to wrap up phase two in March of this year and begin working on project recommendations and prioritization.
32:59We anticipate coming back to the public and to council with draft recommendations and prioritization and to present the draft and final plan later this year.
33:10The transportation planning, neighborhood services, and communication and marketing teams engaged the public in many ways.
33:17During phase one, we presented to various boards and commissions through the summer and fall, including neighborhood advisory commission, aviation commission, and others which you see listed here.
33:29We went to 29 tabling and pop-up events.
33:32We also had the pleasure of attending the regional unity walk.
33:36We had the booth next to Robert and Lissette, and I'm proud to have United Good and Evil here in that picture that you see at the United States at the regional unity walk.
33:45Uh, we were at Open Streets Tempe, Tempe Time Machine, Gain, and many others.
33:49We were invited to present to external partners like the Chamber of Commerce, the Centers for Habilitation, which provides residential and day program services for adults, and the McClintock High School Bike Club.
34:02Our team also sent over 7,000 uh postcards directly to uh homes and equity priority zones throughout the city.
34:10We also announced information about the plan in six newsletters and in various social media posts.
34:16We in total, we directly reached over 30,000 people to announce this plan.
34:23And we'll continue to engage the public throughout the planning process with eight eight scheduled events coming up through April.
34:29I look forward to engaging the public at Play Day this Saturday and these other events that you see here.
34:34All events like these are announced on our project website.
34:39And now I'd like to provide a summary of what we heard from the public last summer in our first open house.
34:46We received 400 unique survey responses in September.
34:51Seven survey questions had open-ended uh questions where respondents had unlimited characters to voice their thoughts.
34:58We got just over 700 unique responses to those.
35:01And I'll review the survey summary with you now.
35:05In the next three slides, I'll show you the top three responses to core questions in the survey.
35:10These were multiple choice questions where respondents can select more than one option.
35:14About 60% of the respondents drive as their primary mode of transportation.
35:20And you'll see there in question one that 14.5% of the respondents bike as their primary mode.
35:25And we can compare that to an urban national average being 1.1% of trips being taken primarily by bike.
35:3337% of respondents wanted us to prioritize bicycle travel with safety being a close second.
35:39And you'll begin to see a trend here with 67% of people saying they would walk more if there was more shade.
35:48When asked, what would make them bike more?
35:5052% of respondents said low stress bike routes and bike and vehicle separation being most important with shade being number three.
35:58Separated on street bike lanes came up again when asked how Tempe should improve the existing bike network.
36:04And of course, we recognize that the majority of roadway users are in their own cars.
36:08When asked when we asked respondents how they'd like us to focus on safety treatments in our network.
36:34In order to take transit more often, respondents indicated that they would need transit services expanded to new destinations and with faster service speeds.
36:43When we build new destinations and vital community services, we need to also ensure that we're connecting the public to those destinations multimodally.
36:50For instance, with the continued development of Tempe Marketplace into more than just a retail space.
36:55We need to ensure that we're connecting people multimodally, like we did with the adjacent Smith Road streetscape improvements.
37:01And we are in the next phase of planning the extension of the streetcar, which would take people to and past Tempe Marketplace.
37:07When we asked how we should prioritize locations for improvement, respondents said they'd like us to focus on areas improving areas with the highest traffic volume first.
37:20And our plan complements and supports the circulation chapter of the General Plan 2050, and this is how we plan to put it together.
37:26Five chapters on mobility, safety, sustainability, and resilience, community and operations.
37:32There are 27 objectives and 122 strategies that we categorize from the general plan circulation chapter to ensure each was supported by this structure.
37:41And while not an exhaustive list, this slide shows how the council's strategic priorities and performance measures would fit into our proposed structure, which we color-coded here for you.
37:50For example, 4.11 tree and shade canopy would fit into the chapter on sustainability and resilience.
37:56The tree and shade canopy is one of council's current five priority measures, and the shade and heat mitigation was a need heard often by the public during outreach.
38:06Of those 27 objectives and 122 strategies, we worked with the core working group, which is internal transportation staff, and the technical advisory group consisting of representatives from various departments like public works, public safety, and community health and human services, to develop corresponding policy statements to support the goals and strategies and ensure that our plan can support the work done by our colleagues throughout the city.
38:30Project staff will continue to refine these policies and strategies, which will help us shape the structure of our plan.
38:36An example of a proposed policy is on your screen to expand safe, convenient, and accessible travel opportunities for all users of the roadways and paths in Tempe.
38:48And now I'd like to show you a sample of what we presented to the public in our second open house last night.
38:53Our goal this round was to report phase one feedback, inform the public on our gaps and needs report, and introduce how we propose to evaluate projects.
39:05This slide shows the projected level of service on our roadways, level of service, results describe how well a roadway operates from the perspective of drivers based on factors like speed, travel time, comfort, and delay, basically how our roadways perform and how traffic flows.
39:21This map is a sliding map the public can use to see the level of service projected for 2050 if we maintain current conditions.
39:28You'll see the most, and I'm let me play this for you now.
39:30What you'll notice is the slider map will move over and show you the projected level of service for 2050, and then I'll move back and let you see it a couple of times.
39:49The dark red, of course, is uh uh considered a level F level of service, lots of breakdowns, lots of delays.
39:56Uh light green is a level A with a free-flowing conditions.
40:00You'll notice most inefficiencies projected for level of service in 2050 being north of Apache on corridors like university along University, Rural McClintock, and Mill.
40:12Um, and as Eric mentioned, part of the plan is to update the Vision Zero action plan.
40:16The map on the right is a snapshot of a dynamic map highlighting the high injury network or the hen.
40:22We learned that just over 50% of the fatal and serious crashes were at mid-block locations.
40:28Using this map, visitors to our webpage can interact with the map to see different conditions around the city.
40:33With this information, the public can help us determine where and how to prioritize projects and identify improvements.
40:41What we learned when we analyzed gaps and needs in our current transit network is that we have the highest demand north of the US 60, which complements transit propensity areas.
40:50However, there are minor concentrations of high transit propensity south of the US 60, such as near Priest and Elliott.
40:57We found gaps in our transit frequency and weekday off-peak hours, which results in an unmet demand.
41:03The map you see here is a static image of another dynamic map that has multiple inputs the public can view and change so that they can easily take our survey on our website.
41:15We analyze gaps in needs in our pedestrian network using key indicators like distance from schools, parks, and transit.
41:21Various web map layers allow the public to see where there are sidewalk gaps impacting their travel and access.
41:28Of these, one of those maps that you don't see here, but is available on our webpage, is a pedestrian crossing spacing analysis, which shows areas where there are large different distances between roadway crossings.
41:40And if we consider the emphasis on the need for shade that we saw in the public feedback, a large crossing distance is especially uncomfortable and potentially dangerous in extreme heat.
41:48Showing this information to the public online and at the hope and at the open house helped them consider what they'd like prioritize in the next 25 years.
41:58And this is another map that viewers can interact with to turn on different layers showing the level of traffic stress for bicyclists around the city.
42:06It currently shows the low stress bike network, which is represented by blue and green.
42:11Areas without blue and green are those with a higher level of stress for bicyclists.
42:16Some needs we found in our analysis include the need to safely cross major streets and for more continuous, safe, comfortable routes.
42:24An example of a level one bike corridor would be Smith Road, where there is a physical separation on or on or on parts of country club way where bike lanes are totally separated from the roadway.
42:35A level four corridor for bicyclist stress would be on a major arterial road with higher traffic speeds, like on Priest Drive.
42:44And finally, these are the factors to consider when assessing and prioritizing a project or corridor.
42:49Our goal with these evaluation criteria is to identify projects that can be evaluated using measurable quantitative and qualitative data.
42:56Criteria selected should align the goals and policies that define the transportation plan.
43:01This evaluation criteria will be influenced by feedback from the collected from the public in collaboration with the core working group and the tag, the technical advisory group.
43:12And we got a chance to see what the public uh wanted to prioritize last night at our open house.
43:21And finally, here are our next steps.
43:23The public survey is open now through March 18th.
43:26We added an extra week to our normal survey period to accommodate spring break.
43:30On our project website, transportation plan 2050.tempe.gov is now updated with the needs and gaps report, including all the information you saw and heard about today.
43:39Our consulting partner, HDR, will summarize what we heard from the public open house and from the survey and post to our project website.
43:46Phase three, project recommendations and prioritization will kick off next month, and we anticipate coming back to the public and council with draft recommendations and prioritization, as well as the draft and final plan later this year.
43:58You can reach me or and the transportation planning team about Tempe Transportation Plan 2050 with the information that you see here.
44:05Mayor, I welcome any comments or questions.
44:08Really appreciate it.
44:09Let me look to the council here.
44:10Uh, council, any comments or questions on item 3C.
44:20Very thorough presentation.
44:24All right, the brief item number four called the audience.
44:27The city council welcomes public comment at this time for the committee of the whole items on this work study session agenda.
44:32There is a three-minute time limit per speaker.
44:33Madam Clerk, do we have any cards?
44:38I'll move to item number five, then committee of the whole 5A or proposed council subcommittees.
44:43For City Council Rule 7, subsection 2B, any two members of the council may propose the formation of a subcommittee at a work study session of the council by identifying the purpose of the proposed subcommittee and the proposed members of the subcommittee and obtaining approval of the majority of the council.
45:00So are there any proposals currently, Council, for a new council subcommittee at this time.
45:06All right, seeing none.
45:10I'll go down the list of the current existing council subcommittees in the order listed on the agenda, and ask the subcommittee chair if they have any updates, which means I'll start with item 5b1, age-friendly Tempe Council Subcommittee.
45:23Okay, thank you so much.
45:24I want to first thank my uh co-chairs on this committee.
45:27I have uh Councilmember Nikki Amberg and Councilmember Randy Keating, so thank you so much.
45:31Um I want to say that our subcommittee um also is made up of Dr.
45:37Johanna Glover, Lisa Zyrix, um Susan Stephenson, James Devray, and our um staff that has been working with us on our committee is Mary Macey, Megan Wilson, and Camden Salinger.
45:49And I just want to say thank you so much to them for all the work that they have put into this.
45:53Um, since uh we have um met our goal, um I want to actually also thank our action team that has done a lot of the work that that brought back to our committee so that we could be researching and um and really paying attention to what our community wants.
46:08So our city um departments was community services.
46:11It's Mercedes Payne and Shelby Meyer, Community Health and Human Services, Murray Raymond, Martha Williams, Melissa Leathers, Camden Shellinger, Megan Wilson, and Mary Maisie, Transportation, Kathy Hollow, Diversity Office, Monique Perry, Communications is Susie Steckner, community development is Lucas Jensen, and strategic management and innovation with Stephanie Martinez.
46:32Our partners in the community that we have been working with to work on this plan is AARP, Ability 360, ASU Age-Friendly University Global Network, Tempe Community Action Agency.
46:43We have a resident, um, Emma Emma Herring, who is also on the committee, um, duet, uh, Tempe Community Council, Maricopa County Depart Department of Public Health, Maricopa Human Services, one community, U.S.
46:56Department of Veterans Affairs, and Astor Aging is also a part of that.
47:01So I just want to just shout out of all those people.
47:03Thank you so much for all those organizations that have helped us.
47:05And I also want to say a special um thanks to Parrish Spice, my assistant, who's been kind of keeping us all together.
47:11So this Cub Subcommittee subcommittee's objective was to update the five-year age-friendly Tempe, Tempe Age-friendly action plan.
47:19And that final draft will be presented to the council on May 4th for approval and then adoption.
47:25Our subcommittee's work has been achieved, so I will close our committee.
47:31Thank you, Vice Mayor.
47:33All right, that brings me to item 5B2, Animal Welfare and Cruelty and Tempe Council Subcommittee.
47:39I know Councilmember Hodge is the chair, but she's having audio issues, so I'm gonna frankly cover this.
47:43The animal welfare and cruelty subcommittee will hold its next meeting on Friday, March 6th at 2 p.m.
47:48at Tempe City Hall, and a virtual attendance option will also be available.
47:53Which brings me to item 5B3, Community Engagement and Connection Council Subcommittee, Vice Mayor Garland.
47:59All right, thank you so much.
48:00Um so I want to um thank Councilmember Amberg and Councilmember Chen for being a part of this subcommittee.
48:06We are currently doing focus groups um going out into the community to talk to them and um about community engagement and connection.
48:14We have five questions that we're asking the same questions everywhere.
48:16Um so we are not gonna be meeting in March because we are gonna be working on pulling all of this data together.
48:22Our next meeting will not be until April.
48:27Next up, item five, before drink spiking education and prevention council subcommittee.
48:31Councilmember Keaton.
48:33Uh thank you, Mayor.
48:34Though though the ordinance has passed, we'll be keeping the committee open for a little bit longer during uh implementation and planning, the logistical things that the committee would want.
48:44Just involvement in in case the vice mayor needs a crack any skulls.
48:48So we're gonna keep it open for a little while, but we'll no longer be meeting unless there is a reason to.
48:53Thank you, Councilmember Keating.
48:55All right, next up, item 5B5, federal and state advocacy review council subcommittee.
48:59Councilmember Amberg.
49:02Mayor, I chair the subcommittee and I'm joined by uh my colleagues, Vice Mayor Garland and Councilmember Keating.
49:07We met on February the 20th and talked about our outline for what we're gonna accomplish in the subcommittee and uh kind of split up the split up the uh topics so that uh staff doesn't have to go to every single meeting.
49:19So thanks to everybody that attended.
49:22Our next meeting is gonna be March 24th at 1230.
49:26Thank you very much.
49:27Next up, item 5b6, mixed use space council subcommittee, council member Chin.
49:32I am honored to chair this subcommittee and joined by Councilmember Amberg and yourself, Mayor Woods on this subcommittee.
49:41We are currently scheduling out meetings and working with some um pretty crazy schedules, but we will we're hoping to get out the next few meetings um soon.
49:55So other than that, no other report.
50:00Next up, item 5b7, motorized and electric mobility device council subcommittee.
50:04Councilmember Adams is not present this evening, so we're going to go ahead and skip over that one and go to item 5b8, revitalization of Tempe Town Lake Council Subcommittee.
50:13Councilmember Amberg.
50:15I chair this and I'm joined by my colleagues, Council Members Adams and Hodge.
50:19Our next meeting is going to be on April the 20th at 2 p.m.
50:24Next up, item 5E9, Tempe Term Limits Policy Review Council Subcommittee.
50:29Councilmember Keating.
50:31We're going to have our first meeting at some point in March.
50:33Uh Keaton's going to work with Councilmember Amberg and uh Vice Mayor Garland's AIDS to get that scheduled.
50:41That brings me to item number six, future agenda items.
50:44Uh council members may request that an agenda item be added to a future issue review session, but in accordance with the open meeting law, there should be no discussion on the item other than to clarify the request.
50:53Would any council members like to add an agenda item to a future issue review session?
50:58Councilmember Amberg.
51:02Um I'm not sure if anybody's aware of this, but our Colorado water uh river water compact is expiring this year, and uh we failed uh to come to a consensus with the upper basin and the lower basin states to figure out what we're gonna do.
51:19We had a February the 14th deadline, which we did not meet.
51:22So the federal government released some environmental impact study drafts, which I have to say are all bad for the state of Arizona.
51:31So I was hoping maybe Tara and her team, who are absolutely fantastic, would be able to come and kind of do just a little update like hey, this is where we're at from a hydrology standpoint in the Colorado River because we are not doing very well.
51:45Um, and also what is going on uh with the compact.
51:51Mayor, Council Member Amberg, we would be happy to.
51:56Um, anyone other council members have any future agenda items you'd like added to a future issue review session?
52:04All right, seeing none, I will go ahead and close that item out and go to item number seven.
52:09Announcements from the mayor and or city manager.
52:11I don't have any announcements this afternoon.
52:14Nothing this evening.
52:15The less I talk by, the better.
52:18Thank you, Madam City Manager.
52:20Uh that brings us to item number eight, which is adjourned.
52:23The next scheduled work study session will be on Monday, March 23rd, 2026.
52:27We are adjourned at 4 51 p.m.
52:29Thank you, everyone.
52:30Have a good evening.