OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Insurance/Litigation Committee Meeting - February 10, 2026

City Council MeetingsTuesday, February 10, 2026
BodyTuscaloosa, Alabama
SessionCity Council Meetings
DateTuesday, February 10, 2026
StatusFILED
Video Record
0:00 / 11:11

Transcript — Verbatim
0:00

I make a motion.

0:01

Motion to approve.

0:02

Now second.

0:03

All in favor say aye.

0:04

Minutes approved.

0:06

Okay, Mr.

0:06

Holmes.

0:07

Good afternoon, Council.

0:08

We are here on the rarest of council committees for you.

0:12

As you recall, this committee meets every fifth Tuesday, which there appears to be no rhyme or reason for when the fifth Tuesday of the month falls.

0:22

It tends to happen about four times a year.

0:25

I'm offended.

0:34

And we knew that there wasn't going to be another one until I mean May or June, except for one in I think of December that was canceled because of another holiday.

0:46

And so at that time, uh Mr.

0:47

Tiner, I believe you and Mr.

0:49

Busby asked if we would schedule a specially called.

0:52

We'd initially intended to do it kind of towards the middle of January, but we know that the our biggest insurance policy, our our general liability coverage and property insurance renews the end of February.

1:07

It seemed as though if we were going to have a specially called insurance litigation committee, we should we should have the big policy uh appear on it.

1:15

So we moved it back uh back to this week.

1:17

Sure.

1:18

Um the first item is that that big policy, and this covers our fleet, our uh our various assets, our property, our buildings, um, our general liability and is a beast of a policy.

1:35

Um this policy to quote takes probably somewhere in the neighborhood of a hundred uh staff hours between uh between our staff and other city staff members in Mr.

1:46

Mesco's time.

1:47

Um Hudson Cheshire has led this in OCA the last couple of years, and so I'm gonna let him uh take over here in a second, but this is something that goes through every department.

1:58

We've had great success with having our departments participate.

2:03

Um it's hard for us and for Mr.

2:05

Menesco to know when departments have bought new assets or disposed of assets that we're insuring without sitting down and going through them.

2:13

Um and so I will let uh I'll let Hudson kind of walk you through this.

2:17

Okay, Mr.

2:17

Manasco is is here, so if there's anything that that Hudson leaves out that you would like Mr.

2:23

Minesco to answer for you, then he's available to do that as well.

2:26

Thank you, Mr.

2:27

Chair.

2:28

Thank you, Scott.

2:29

Afternoon, council.

2:30

Afternoon.

2:31

Um as Scott said, this is the big policy.

2:34

It's fleet property liability and and a handful of other things.

2:39

Last year the premium was 1.95 million dollars.

2:44

This year it is 2.39.

2:47

So it's gone up.

2:48

I'm sorry.

2:49

Give me those numbers again.

2:50

Last it's in there.

2:52

Oh, okay.

2:54

The the change is 457,000 or 457, 581 dollars.

3:00

Um I don't want to get too far down into the weeds, but I did want to point out some big contributors to the to the uh increase in the premium.

3:09

The first is property value.

3:12

So in short, one of the big reasons the premium is up is because our property values are up.

3:19

There's a couple reasons for that.

3:21

One is that every year um we do what's called what we call the three percent inflationary adjustment.

3:29

So we take all of the properties that we're currently insuring and increase the property value by three percent to uh try to keep up with inflation.

3:39

The second is that we have added 28.4 million dollars in property to um to uh the city in the past year.

3:47

So you think about the improvements that we've made, Mr.

3:50

Tyner, to the tennis center.

3:51

Um think about the new warehouse that we just bought, fire station six, uh, all these add up and are reflected in the in the property schedule.

3:59

Um the second reason is that our general uh liability policy has gone up a little bit.

4:06

Um general liability is calculated by expenditures that the city makes.

4:12

And I'm I'm talking out of my depth here, but uh the more the money the more the city spends in certain areas, you're gonna see an increase in general liability uh in the premium.

4:24

So we were up by 5.6 million this year compared to the year before, and you're gonna see um uh a premium adjustment there.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Pending Litigation█████████████████████████████████████████████58%
Procedural███████████████████████30%
Budget Equity Analysis█████████12%
Summary of Proceedings

Insurance/Litigation Committee Meeting Summary - February 10, 2026

The Insurance/Litigation Committee of the Tuscaloosa City Council held a specially called meeting on February 10, 2026, to consider renewals of the city's general liability, property, and flood insurance policies. The meeting took place because the fifth Tuesday of the month fell in February, and the committee wanted to address the renewal of the city's largest insurance policy before it expires at the end of February.

Discussion Items

  • General Liability, Property, and Fleet Insurance Renewal: Hudson Cheshire, representing the Office of City Auditor, presented the renewal for the city's comprehensive insurance policy covering fleet, property, buildings, general liability, and other assets. The premium increased from $1.95 million last year to $2.39 million this year, a net increase of $457,581. Key drivers of the increase included:

    • A 3% inflationary adjustment on existing property values.
    • Addition of $28.4 million in new property (e.g., tennis center improvements, new warehouse, Fire Station 6).
    • A rise in general liability premiums due to a $5.6 million increase in city expenditures.
    • A rate increase from 13 cents to 16 cents per $100 of insured value, which was noted as consistent with broader commercial property and casualty market trends.
    • Council members asked about the rate determination; Rick Manasco of the city's insurance brokerage explained that the increase is market-wide and that the city continues to work with departments to identify and adjust coverage (e.g., reducing contents coverage at the Gateway from $2 million to $250,000, and dropping collision coverage on older vehicles). The renewal amount remained within budget.
  • Flood Insurance for Mercedes-Benz Amphitheater: The committee also considered renewal of flood coverage for the amphitheater, which sits on the Black Warrior River. The policy, obtained through the National Flood Insurance Program, increased from $17,775 to $20,661 (an increase of approximately $2,886). No competitive alternatives exist. A council member asked whether the forthcoming savings center would require similar coverage; the response indicated it would be evaluated based on elevation.

Key Outcomes

  • Motion to approve the general liability, property, and fleet insurance renewal: Passed unanimously by voice vote.
  • Motion to approve the flood insurance renewal for the Mercedes-Benz Amphitheater: Passed unanimously by voice vote.
  • The committee adjourned, noting it would not meet again for about five months.

Meeting Transcript

I make a motion. Motion to approve. Now second. All in favor say aye. Minutes approved. Okay, Mr. Holmes. Good afternoon, Council. We are here on the rarest of council committees for you. As you recall, this committee meets every fifth Tuesday, which there appears to be no rhyme or reason for when the fifth Tuesday of the month falls. It tends to happen about four times a year. I'm offended. And we knew that there wasn't going to be another one until I mean May or June, except for one in I think of December that was canceled because of another holiday. And so at that time, uh Mr. Tiner, I believe you and Mr. Busby asked if we would schedule a specially called. We'd initially intended to do it kind of towards the middle of January, but we know that the our biggest insurance policy, our our general liability coverage and property insurance renews the end of February. It seemed as though if we were going to have a specially called insurance litigation committee, we should we should have the big policy uh appear on it. So we moved it back uh back to this week. Sure. Um the first item is that that big policy, and this covers our fleet, our uh our various assets, our property, our buildings, um, our general liability and is a beast of a policy. Um this policy to quote takes probably somewhere in the neighborhood of a hundred uh staff hours between uh between our staff and other city staff members in Mr. Mesco's time. Um Hudson Cheshire has led this in OCA the last couple of years, and so I'm gonna let him uh take over here in a second, but this is something that goes through every department. We've had great success with having our departments participate. Um it's hard for us and for Mr. Menesco to know when departments have bought new assets or disposed of assets that we're insuring without sitting down and going through them. Um and so I will let uh I'll let Hudson kind of walk you through this. Okay, Mr. Manasco is is here, so if there's anything that that Hudson leaves out that you would like Mr. Minesco to answer for you, then he's available to do that as well. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Scott. Afternoon, council. Afternoon. Um as Scott said, this is the big policy. It's fleet property liability and and a handful of other things. Last year the premium was 1.95 million dollars. This year it is 2.39. So it's gone up. I'm sorry. Give me those numbers again. Last it's in there. Oh, okay. The the change is 457,000 or 457, 581 dollars. Um I don't want to get too far down into the weeds, but I did want to point out some big contributors to the to the uh increase in the premium. The first is property value. So in short, one of the big reasons the premium is up is because our property values are up. There's a couple reasons for that.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com