OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Finance Committee Meeting – July 14, 2026: Shared Revenue Presentation by Rep. Scott Allen

Public MeetingsTuesday, July 14, 2026
BodyWaukesha, Wisconsin
SessionPublic Meetings
DateTuesday, July 14, 2026
StatusFILED
Video Record
0:00 / 45:43

Transcript — Verbatim
0:02

All right.

0:03

Good evening.

0:04

We'll call the July 14th, 2026 meeting of the Finance Committee to order.

0:08

We do have a quorum this evening.

0:09

Alderman Anderson is out of town.

0:11

Next on our agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance.

0:14

Please rise.

0:23

One nation, under God, indivisible with liberty and justice for all.

0:31

Next item on our agenda is public comment.

0:33

Are there any members of the public that wish to address the finance committee this evening?

0:38

All right.

0:39

Seeing none, we'll move to item number 4A, which is approval of minutes for the meeting on the 30th.

0:45

Are there any changes to those minutes from the committee?

0:48

All right.

0:48

Seeing none, those minutes are approved through unanimous consent.

0:52

Our business item tonight, item number 5A, is a matter of report.

0:56

And this is a shared revenue presentation by Representative Scott Allen.

1:00

Scott approached me a couple months ago and asked to come in to speak to the Finance Committee to give the committee a little bit of background on shared revenue and give give us an opportunity once Scott is done with his presentation to certainly ask questions that we may have around funding formulas and perhaps things that we'd like to see changed as it relates to how municipalities are funded.

1:21

The mayor is also here this evening, so thank you for joining us, Alicia.

1:25

So with that, Scott, you are our sole agenda item this evening.

1:29

The floor is yours, and like I said, once you're done, we'll certainly take it take any questions from the committee as we have them.

1:35

So thank you for coming this evening.

1:37

And again, the floor is yours.

1:39

Oh, thank you.

1:40

And uh is your mic on, Scott?

1:42

I don't know.

1:42

Is there a way to turn it on?

1:44

Should be a button at the base.

1:48

There we go.

1:49

There we go.

1:50

Testing.

1:51

There we go.

1:52

Well, thank you.

1:52

And thank you for your hospitality.

1:54

Uh thank you for certainly putting me on the agenda.

1:57

I never expected to be the only item here.

2:00

Um, but that's great.

2:01

And uh hopefully uh this begins a conversation, uh, begins to spark some ideas where some there can be a broader conversation, uh, not just within the city hall confines, but uh maybe throughout our state, because uh certainly uh there's a there's a need for awareness of what's going on.

2:21

Uh this uh this presentation is titled Walkshaw is getting squeezed out of shared revenue formulation formulations, which you guys are all very familiar with.

2:30

Um I don't think I need to introduce myself.

2:33

Uh I think you all know me, uh, but there are extra handouts over here, so if anybody wants to take another one, feel free.

2:41

Uh I'm about to give you a uh about 175 years worth of Wisconsin history compacted into about 20 minutes.

2:51

So you can imagine it's pretty high level.

2:53

Uh this is the history of shared revenue in the state of Wisconsin.

2:56

Wisconsin as a state has been sharing revenue with its local units of government since 1911.

3:04

It was a challenge to get to that, and it's been a challenge ever since.

3:10

There are primarily five eras to uh the shared revenue funding and sharing of revenue in our state, but we have to go back really before that to understand how we got to this point.

3:24

And we all know our nation's history from the Boston Tea Party to today.

3:28

Uh we as a country revolted against taxation without representation.

3:33

From our founding, we have had a disdain for large administrative states who exert authority through taxation, whether it be the Sugar Act, the Stamp Act, or the Townsend Act, from the very beginning, we have disliked taxation and the administrative state that comes with it.

3:50

Since its founding in 1848, Wisconsin started with taxation only at the local level and taxed all personal property.

4:00

What resulted was a disaggregated taxing system that experienced, quite frankly, discrimination against foreigners, uh, biased valuations, and ineffective tax collections.

4:16

In the late 1800s and early 1900s, we had in this country an overall progressive shift.

4:23

Perhaps it was accelerated by the panic of 1893, in which we saw a four-year depression with unemployment rates reaching as high as 25 percent.

4:34

The Republican Party was largely split between traditional conservatives and progressives at the time, or progressive Republicans.

4:42

The re progressive Republicans believed it was the government's responsibility to create jobs.

4:48

As a result, we saw a coalition between the progressive Republicans and the Social Democrats around the topics, including taxation and redistribution of wealth.

5:00

During this era, Wisconsin's governors served, if you recall, a two-year term.

5:05

In 1894, Nils Haugan, who you see on your screen, was the candidate for the progressive Republicans.

5:13

Robert LaFollett was the candidate in 1896, 1898, winning the elections in 1900, 1902, and 1904.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Fiscal Sustainability█████████████████████████████████████████████83%
Procedural██████11%
Public Safety2%
Community Engagement2%
Engineering And Infrastructure2%
Summary of Proceedings

Finance Committee Meeting – July 14, 2026

The Finance Committee of the City of Waukesha met on July 14, 2026, with a quorum present. The sole business item was a presentation by State Representative Scott Allen on the history and current challenges of Wisconsin's shared revenue system, particularly its impact on mid-sized cities like Waukesha. Committee members expressed frustration with the formula and discussed potential legislative solutions, including adjusting for landlocked communities.

Consent Calendar

  • Minutes from the June 30, 2026 Finance Committee meeting were approved unanimously with no changes.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • No members of the public addressed the committee.

Discussion Items

  • Representative Scott Allen delivered a 20-minute presentation titled "Waukesha is getting squeezed out of shared revenue formulations." He traced the history from the 1911 creation of Wisconsin's income tax (originally 70% returned to local governments under a "return to origin" model), through the 1970s shift to complex need-based formulas, to the decline in shared revenue from nearly $1 billion in 2003 to $753 million in 2019, and the 2023 Act 12 that created a supplemental aid program tied to sales tax growth. Allen noted that while rural communities and Milwaukee benefited, mid-sized cities like Waukesha saw little benefit.
  • Committee members expressed concerns about levy limits tied to net new construction (1.66% in 2025), rising costs (labor 3–10%), and the city being landlocked. Alderman Dale Matthews asked about the history of formula favoring rural areas. Alderman Doreen Wiggerson criticized the lack of advocacy from Waukesha's legislative delegation. Chairman Eric Rand Piper highlighted the Expenditure Restraint Program (ERP) disincentivizing intergovernmental cooperation and invited Allen to help define "landlocked" for potential legislation.
  • Finance Director Kevin Brown noted that property taxes make up 60–65% of the general fund and that shared revenue and ERP funding have not kept pace with inflation.

Key Outcomes

  • No formal votes were taken; the presentation was informational.
  • Representative Allen invited city staff to collaborate on defining a "landlocked" community for potential legislation that could adjust levy limits or supplemental aid.
  • The committee discussed the need to build coalitions among similarly situated mid-sized cities to advocate for formula changes.
  • The committee noted that the August 25th capital budget "show and tell" at the City Garage is scheduled; Rep. Allen was invited to attend.

Meeting Transcript

All right. Good evening. We'll call the July 14th, 2026 meeting of the Finance Committee to order. We do have a quorum this evening. Alderman Anderson is out of town. Next on our agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. Please rise. One nation, under God, indivisible with liberty and justice for all. Next item on our agenda is public comment. Are there any members of the public that wish to address the finance committee this evening? All right. Seeing none, we'll move to item number 4A, which is approval of minutes for the meeting on the 30th. Are there any changes to those minutes from the committee? All right. Seeing none, those minutes are approved through unanimous consent. Our business item tonight, item number 5A, is a matter of report. And this is a shared revenue presentation by Representative Scott Allen. Scott approached me a couple months ago and asked to come in to speak to the Finance Committee to give the committee a little bit of background on shared revenue and give give us an opportunity once Scott is done with his presentation to certainly ask questions that we may have around funding formulas and perhaps things that we'd like to see changed as it relates to how municipalities are funded. The mayor is also here this evening, so thank you for joining us, Alicia. So with that, Scott, you are our sole agenda item this evening. The floor is yours, and like I said, once you're done, we'll certainly take it take any questions from the committee as we have them. So thank you for coming this evening. And again, the floor is yours. Oh, thank you. And uh is your mic on, Scott? I don't know. Is there a way to turn it on? Should be a button at the base. There we go. There we go. Testing. There we go. Well, thank you. And thank you for your hospitality. Uh thank you for certainly putting me on the agenda. I never expected to be the only item here. Um, but that's great. And uh hopefully uh this begins a conversation, uh, begins to spark some ideas where some there can be a broader conversation, uh, not just within the city hall confines, but uh maybe throughout our state, because uh certainly uh there's a there's a need for awareness of what's going on. Uh this uh this presentation is titled Walkshaw is getting squeezed out of shared revenue formulation formulations, which you guys are all very familiar with. Um I don't think I need to introduce myself. Uh I think you all know me, uh, but there are extra handouts over here, so if anybody wants to take another one, feel free. Uh I'm about to give you a uh about 175 years worth of Wisconsin history compacted into about 20 minutes. So you can imagine it's pretty high level. Uh this is the history of shared revenue in the state of Wisconsin. Wisconsin as a state has been sharing revenue with its local units of government since 1911. It was a challenge to get to that, and it's been a challenge ever since. There are primarily five eras to uh the shared revenue funding and sharing of revenue in our state, but we have to go back really before that to understand how we got to this point. And we all know our nation's history from the Boston Tea Party to today. Uh we as a country revolted against taxation without representation. From our founding, we have had a disdain for large administrative states who exert authority through taxation, whether it be the Sugar Act, the Stamp Act, or the Townsend Act, from the very beginning, we have disliked taxation and the administrative state that comes with it.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com