The Detroit City Council Committee of the Whole met on February 5, 2026, to receive a quarterly report from the Detroit Land Bank Authority, discuss property sales and development projects, and address public comments on a range of city issues. Key topics included the Land Bank's inventory and finances, a proposed fifth-year extension of a Neighborhood Enterprise Zone (NEZ) certificate for unsold condominiums, and updates on the Neighborhood Opportunity Fund (NOF) and private sewer repair programs. Public Comments & Testimony - Mr. Rue (in-person): Alleged corruption in the City Clerk's office and threatened to bring evidence against council members. He stated, "The city is corrupt. Janice Winfrey been cheating in elections for decades." - William M. Davis (virtual): Called for a detailed audit of drainage fee funds, renegotiation of the Great Lakes Water Authority lease, and more equitable use of tax dollars benefiting Detroit workers and retirees. - Cunningham (virtual): Requested more bus tickets and hand warmers for homeless individuals, citing unreliable DDOT service. He stated, "DDOT... is not on time, not convenient, and sometimes the bus doesn't even show up." - Jadante Smith (virtual): Accused Councilmember Johnson of failing to research a church with $89,000 in back taxes that received a Spirit of Detroit Award. He demanded accountability from the Council, particularly regarding the reappointment of Conrad Mallett, and called for affordable housing and jobs. - Lamont's iPhone (virtual): Questioned how county commissioners and legislators afford luxury items on public salaries and urged council to address social issues and suppress inequalities. - Betty A. Varner (virtual): Requested information about an upcoming DWSD meeting on water line replacement and a grant, urging its dissemination beyond the internet. She also promoted the MI Choice Waiver program for seniors. - Caller ending in 169: Pleaded for help for Cunningham, saying, "Cunningham is the underdog. The others are rich and powerful. Help the underdog, even if you have to help him behind the scenes." - DLBA Nuisance Abatement Program Caller: Stated that the DLBA's nuisance abatement program violates the U.S. Constitution, Michigan Constitution, and state law. He said there is a class action lawsuit regarding the land bank taking property without compensation. - Ruby Riley (virtual): Denied being prejudiced, criticizing the city's response to flooding in Southwest Detroit versus other areas. She said, "They rushed over to Southwest Detroit... I froze in my house for two years. I had no heat, no hot water tank, pipes busted." - Call-in user one: Complained about unshoveled sidewalks on Linwood and West Grand Boulevard, endangering children walking to school. They urged Councilmember Johnson to ensure code enforcement. Discussion Items - Detroit Land Bank Authority Quarterly Report (Q2 FY2026): CEO Tammy Daniels and staff presented the report. Key metrics included: 101 homes sold through auction, 90 through "Own It Now," 163 side lots, 272 neighborhood lots, and nearly 60,000 properties in inventory (mostly vacant land). The Land Bank reported success in increasing home values by $2 billion over 12 years. Councilmembers questions focused on: - Financial burden of accepting properties from Wayne County that require demolition. President Pro Tem Young expressed frustration: "We are basically receiving properties from the county, and they're not providing us with any sort of financial benefit... That's insane." The Land Bank acknowledged the need to reassess this strategy. - A single pending lawsuit against the nuisance abatement program (out of 300 active lawsuits against derelict property owners). - Expansion of the Finish Line grant program to assist homeowners with compliance. - A new affordable housing development in the Longview neighborhood (District 4), targeting 30 units for permanent supportive housing, with an RFP for partners. - NEZ Certificate Extension for Exchange Detroit LLC: Richard Barr (attorney for applicant) and Katie Long (corporate counsel) requested a fifth-year extension of NEZ certificates for two unsold condominiums (of 12) in the Greektown Exchange building. The three-year, state-extendable fourth year expired November 16, 2025. They stated the condominium market has been challenging, and the $625/month tax benefit is crucial for buyers. Justice Cook (Housing and Revitalization Department) noted no affordability agreement exists for marketing support. The council approved the extension. Key Outcomes - Consent Calendar: The following items were approved without objection: - Approval of minutes as amended. - Land Bank Quarterly Report (Item 6.1): Motion to receive and file passed. Council requested a breakdown of the 743 unsold salvage structures by district. - Revenue & Finance Items: - Item 6.2: Memorandum on property management agreements brought back in two weeks. - Item 6.3: Grand River Corridor business activity update brought back in one week. - Item 7.1: Contract for Gordie Howe International Bridge property rehab ($148,390) approved. - Item 7.2: Zoning map correction approved. - Item 7.3: Fifth-year NEZ certificate extension for Exchange Detroit LLC approved. - Item 7.4: Property sale at 1170 Whittier ($2,000) approved. - Item 7.5: Property sale at 7001 Finkel Avenue ($31,005) approved. - Item 7.6: Hance Farms LLC purchase agreement referred to the Detroit Land Bank Authority with a two-week bring back. - Neighborhood Opportunity Fund Update: Director Todd announced the NOF awards are ready for council action. The item was set to be pulled from committee for a vote at the February 11 formal session, with hearings and deliberations scheduled for February 23-26, 2026. - Member Reports: Councilmember Johnson reminded the public that the Private Sewer Repair Program (for 2021 basement backups) still has funding available in 97 neighborhoods. Chief Razo confirmed the 2021 program will serve over 1,500 households, a $356M CDBG-DR program will address larger infrastructure, and a $1M seawall repair program in Jefferson Chalmers is being developed. Council Pro Tem Young sought coordination across these efforts. - Upcoming Meeting: A special session for mayoral confirmation hearings was announced for 2:30 PM following the Neighborhood and Community Services Committee meeting.
Public Meetings - Detroit, Michigan
Public Meetings - Detroit, MichiganThe Neighborhood Community Services Committee of the Detroit City Council met on February 5, 2026, in a formal session to discuss routine approvals, hear public comments, and review a contract for the Joe Louis Greenway project. The meeting included a call to order, roll call, approval of minutes, chair remarks, and public comment. Public Comments & Testimony - Betty A. Varner (President, DeSoda Ellsworth Black Association) : Encouraged seniors and disabled residents not eligible for Medicaid to contact the Detroit Area Agency for the Aging (DAA) at 313-446-4444 for the MI Choice Waiver program, which allows individuals to earn up to $2,900 per month and qualify for Medicaid. She described the program as providing in-home assessments and support, including home repairs, at no cost. - Caller ending in 169: Urged support for "Cunningham," described as an underdog, asking for help even behind the scenes, and quoted Arnold Palmer: "Always make a total effort, even when the odds are used." - Caller Cunningham: Did not speak when called; the chair stated they could send a message to the office. - Dante Smith: Criticized the council's "fake grilling" of appointees Tammy Daniels and Langbank; reported that a woman named Ariel with six children was evicted that morning, with a scramble to rehouse her; accused Mary Waters' office of being "graciously racistly existing"; criticized Councilmember Coleman Young II for having the "worst staff in city council" and failing to respond to messages about "Colonels Concrete" since December 14; praised a staff member named "Casely" as the only worker in Young's office who seemed productive; requested Councilmember Scott Benson to show up more for work, claiming Benson missed many days; and urged the council to stand up against Conrad Mallet, who he said usurps the power of the Board of Police Commissioners and the Board of Ethics. Councilmember Young responded, stating that the allegation of non-response was "simply not true," noting that they provided over 100 pages of documentation on Chrono's Concrete; he listed his accomplishments: appropriating $800 million to create 10,000 jobs before joining council, passing the Green Grocer program (building more grocery stores with $850,000), and appropriating $23 million into the general retirement fund. He invited further calls to his office at 313-224-4248. - William M. Davis (District 7 resident) : Called for more community resource centers, such as converting old schools or restoring neighborhood city halls and police precincts; noted that District 7 lacks a functioning recreation center despite having the most school-age children; expressed opposition to Conrad Mallet as corporation counsel, stating Mallet should not sit on the Board of Police Commissioners; encouraged council members to attend Board of Police Commissioner meetings and to direct residents to document complaints about police. - Caller (stop illegal DLBA nuisance abatement): Stated that if the land bank took property through nuisance abatement, residents may be eligible for compensation via a class-action lawsuit by the firm Margolis and Cross; argued that the practice violates the Takings Clause of the U.S. Constitution and Article 10, Section 2 of the Michigan Constitution, as well as the Michigan Fast Track Land Bank Authority Act (which prohibits the authority from using eminent domain or condemnation); noted that Councilmember Mary Waters, who was in the state legislature when the act passed, has been raising this issue; thanked Councilmember Young for calling out Wayne County for dumping demolitions on Detroit; and requested a legal opinion from Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel that was asked for in 2024. - Caller (Papa): Accused the council of knowing that houses were being pushed onto the land bank for demolition; referenced a previous investigation into a realtor or person named "Munes" that yielded no results; stated that the Plant Moran audit found non-compliance regarding this issue; criticized the Neighborhood and Community Services Committee for failing; and expressed that seniors are living in squalor while the council considers nominating those who created the environment, noting ARPA money was provided due to COVID but no health report was done. - Caller ending in 039: Alleged that all elected officials of Detroit are "cheated in" by someone named Janice Want Street; claimed that Charmaine McLeod is responsible for the death of Kenisha Coleman, citing a gunshot with no gun or siblings on entry and a suicide weapon not at the scene; stated he would provide details to someone named Nini on February 18, 2026; and said all council members must go, specifically addressing Councilmembers Coleman Young II, James E. Tate Jr., and Carl Kenneth. - Cecily McClellan (Director of Waterworks, We the People of Detroit) : Reported that in December 2025, the water department shut off 900 residents, with about half restored; advocated for a water affordability program at the local level, referencing state legislation (House Bill 455 and 5170–5173); urged Councilmembers Coleman Young II, Vincent, and Renata Miller to champion an ordinance for water affordability that would be codified into law; supported the RIA and the city's efforts regarding retirees; and supported Mr. Davis's call for community resource centers and recreation centers. Discussion Items - 6.1: Petition of Fraternal Order of United Irishmen to host the Corktown Races on March 15, 2026, from 9 a.m. to 1 p.m. at Roosevelt Park, with setup beginning March 4, 2026, and tear-down from 12 p.m. to 3 p.m. on March 15. Moved to formal session with recommendation for approval. - 6.2: Petition of Detroit 300 Conservancy/Downtown Detroit Partnership to host the Grand Circus Park Opening Day 2026 on April 3, 2026, from 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. at Grand Circus Park East, with setup April 1–April 3 and tear-down from 6 p.m. to 5 p.m. on April 4. Moved to formal session with recommendation for approval. - 6.3: Petition of SHAR Incorporated to host the 5th Annual SHAR/Echo Juneteenth Community Celebration on June 13, 2026, from 2 p.m. to 6 p.m. at 1851 West Grand Boulevard, with setup from 8 a.m. to 1 p.m. and tear-down from 6 p.m. to 8 p.m. Moved to formal session with recommendation for approval. - 6.4: Petition of the March Dunan Rush to host an event on March 22, 2026, from 12 p.m. to 8 p.m. at Canfield between Cass and Sacket, Second between Canfield and Temple, and Temple/Cass Park, with setup from 8 a.m. to 11 a.m. and tear-down from 5 p.m. to 8 p.m. Moved to formal session with recommendation for approval. - 6.5: Contract 67645 ($1,165,149.89 from 100% grant funding) with Major Contractor Group Inc. for site renovation of the Joe Louis Greenway in the area of Junction and Clark. Councilmember Scott Benson requested an update. Alex Weatherup, Assistant Director of General Services, provided details: the project includes a shared-use path along the I-75 service drive (north side, westbound from Clark Park to Junction Avenue), new lighting, new trees, and a trailhead at Clark Park with seating and signage. The path will connect to the Gordie Howe International Bridge via a pedestrian bridge at Junction, approximately a quarter-mile away, with signage highlighting the connection. Councilmember Benson asked about amenities; Weatherup did not have a rendering or full specifics but promised to provide them. Construction is expected to start in April 2026 and take 18 months, finishing around spring 2027, with a contract end date of February 2028. The Gordie Howe Bridge is expected to open in late 2026. Moved to formal session with recommendation for approval. Consent Calendar - The minutes from the previous meeting were approved. - The chair reported no remarks. Key Outcomes - The committee voted unanimously to move agenda items 6.1 through 6.5 to the formal session with recommendations for approval. No objections were heard on any items. - The meeting adjourned without objection after member reports (no reports were given). Note: The transcript did not include an agenda or minutes; the summary is based solely on the raw transcription.
The Detroit City Council held confirmation hearings on February 5, 2026, for seven mayoral appointments requiring council approval: Corporation Counsel Conrad Mallet, Chief Financial Officer Tanya Stodemyer, Planning Director Alexa Bush, Housing and Revitalization Director Julie Schneider, Police Chief Todd Bettison, Fire Commissioner Charles Sims, and Human Resources Director Denise Starr. The council also briefly discussed the proposed Executive Organization Plan (EOP). The meeting began with public comment and included individual interviews with each appointee, followed by votes. Public Comments & Testimony - Adam Barrett (Southwest Detroit) opposed the reappointment of Conrad Mallet, citing high settlement costs, solar farm lawsuits, nuisance abatement program issues, blocking grassroots reforms, and conflicts of interest. - Dr. Smith (caller) opposed Mallet and Julie Snyder, alleging Mallet's conflicts of interest and Snyder's failure to address homelessness. He threatened to pursue Mallet's law license if reappointed. - William M. Davis opposed Mallet, stating he is not effective and has made the Board of Police Commissioners less effective. He advocated for the board to have its own attorney. - Molly Menning (ABA Legal Education Police Practices Fellow at Wayne Law) urged council to ensure the Board of Police Commissioners can have independent legal counsel. - Tyson Gersh opposed Mallet, citing law department dysfunction, FOIA denials, and the need for a fresh start under the new mayor. - Anonymous caller alleged election fraud and criticized the handling of voter allegations. Discussion Items - Executive Organization Plan (EOP): Chief of Staff David Bowser presented proposed amendments to the EOP, including the creation of a Department of Human, Homeless and Family Services (HHFS) to consolidate quality-of-life services, transferring the Office of Immigrant Affairs from HRD to the mayor's office, establishing Neighborhood Affairs in the mayor's office, and moving homeland security under DPD. No net budget impact was noted; the EOP becomes effective April 7, 2026. - Conrad Mallet (Corporation Counsel): Mallet defended his record, highlighting increased blight enforcement (from one to eight lawyers), work on quit claim deed fraud, and ethical conduct. He addressed questions on reducing lawsuits (citing improved DPD and DDOT practices), independent counsel for the Board of Police Commissioners (expressed openness), and legal opinion turnaround times (promised to provide benchmarks). - Tanya Stodemyer (CFO): Stated her goal to maintain fiscal discipline and strategic investments. She noted discussions on revenue growth and confirmed overtime costs at DPD are decreasing due to filled vacancies. - Alexa Bush (Planning Director): Discussed efforts to attract national retailers (e.g., Target, Walmart) to Detroit, noting challenges with corporate metrics and vacant homes. Emphasized neighborhood retail studies, streetscape investments, and the Master Plan update (halfway complete, last comprehensive update in 2009). - Julie Schneider (HRD Director): Described HRD's expanded role (from 120 to 330 staff) and focus on affordable housing. Addressed support for residents with eviction histories, CDOs (noting 25% of $200M investments went to CDOs), single-family rental improvement programs (250 landlords trained), and Palmer Park redevelopment. - Todd Bettison (Police Chief): Reported 2025 crime reductions: homicides down 18.7% (from 203 to 165), carjackings down 46% (from 142 to 77), non-fatal shootings down 25%, motor vehicle thefts down 2,000. Announced expansion of mental health co-response to 24/7 within 60 days. Reaffirmed policies: DPD does not assist evictions or enforce immigration law. - Charles Sims (Fire Commissioner): Highlighted accomplishments: lowest response times to medical calls (7 minutes 30 seconds), largest HeartSafe City in the U.S., 450+ firefighters cross-trained as EMTs, first paramedic class graduated 23, nurse navigation implementation by July 2026, and plans for new fire stations. Acknowledged need to increase African American representation (currently 33%) and revive apprenticeship programs. - Denise Starr (HR Director): Noted accomplishments: transition to UKG payroll system, bi-annual engagement surveys, paid parental leave (300+ employees used), and over 100 hiring events. Discussed H1B visa policy: no active removals, but new hires paused due to high federal fees. Addressed out-of-state employees (five individuals retained for specialized skills) and vacancies (400). Promised to work on return-to-work policy. Key Outcomes - Votes on Appointments: - Conrad Mallet: Approved with objections from Councilmembers Santiago Romero, McCampbell, and Miller. (Motion passed) - Tanya Stodemyer: Approved unanimously. - Alexa Bush: Approved unanimously. - Julie Schneider: Approved with objections from Councilmembers Whitfield Callaway and Johnson. (Passed 6-2) - Todd Bettison: Approved unanimously, with a waiver motion approved. - Charles Sims: Approved unanimously. - Denise Starr: Approved unanimously, with waiver approved. - Waivers: Waivers for immediate effect were requested for all approved appointments. Objections noted for Mallet (3.2) and Schneider (3.4) on waivers; those waivers were rejected. Other waivers approved. - Next Steps: Full EOP discussion to continue in the Internal Operations Committee. Budget amendments related to EOP will be presented to council prior to the April 7 budget vote.
The Internal Operations Committee of the Detroit City Council met on February 4, 2026, to address public comments, interview candidates for reappointment to several city boards and commissions, discuss a contract amendment for H1B visa sponsorship legal services, and approve numerous lawsuit settlements and administrative items. Public Comments & Testimony - Janie Smith criticized Councilmember Angela Calloway for her interaction with a resident, praised Councilmember Renata Miller but called for follow-up action, opposed the reappointment of Conrad Mallard, citing unpaid $1.5 billion and damage to the city, and criticized low compliance (15%) for rental certificates of compliance. - Betty A. Varner (President, DeSota Elsewhere Black Association) provided information on the Detroit Community Health Connection, including sliding fee services and a 24-hour doctor line. - Cunningham criticized DDOT bus service, called for undercover ride-alongs, and promoted a District 7 meeting. - A caller (ending 039) made personal threats and accusations against a district 2 council member, referencing case numbers and text messages. - William M. Davis advocated for paying Varner and Cunningham as community advocates, criticized the Law Department under Conrad Mallard, and urged more community engagement and voting. - Rene Warwick (District 6 resident, organizer of Detroit People's Platform) criticized the lack of systemic snow removal at bus stops, calling it a legal and access issue for ADA riders and seniors. She opposed reappointments of Mallard, Bush, and Snyder. - Renard Monaski (District 6 resident, Detroit People's Platform) elaborated on snow removal problems, asking for a systemic solution rather than a phone number. - Michael's mama (attempted, not heard) - Owner Papa (not heard) Discussion Items Reappointment of Melvin Butch Hollowell to the Public Lighting Authority - Melvin Butch Hollowell (managing partner, Miller Law Firm; former city corporation counsel) discussed his work on street lighting, including 65,000 new LED lights since 2014, bond refunding in 2025, and plans to add mid-block lights and rationalize alley lights. He emphasized safety protocols for arc wire removal and supporting Detroit-based businesses and youth skilled trades. - Councilmember Calloway asked about youth engagement; Hollowell said interested parties can contact PLA via its website. - Councilmember Miller raised historic district lighting costs and requested cooperation. Hollowell pledged to work on the issue and noted the Puritan Street lighting outage (from Greenfield to Southfield). - Outcome: Motion to send the reappointment to formal session with a recommendation to approve passed without objection. Reappointment of Charlotte Wright to the Human Rights Commission - Charlotte Wright served four years, chaired the bylaws committee to improve quorum. She cited low attendance (only 5 of 11 members) as the biggest challenge and the need for community outreach. Commission meets third Thursday of each month, hybrid. - Councilmember Miller asked about handling of discrimination complaints; Wright said they partner with CRED. Wright identified transportation and building accessibility as top disability complaints. - Outcome: Motion to draft a resolution and send to formal session passed. Reappointment of Osvaldo Rivera to the Historic Designation Advisory Commission - Osvaldo (Ozzy) Rivera (retired social worker, teaches at Wayne State and U of M) focused on Southwest Detroit history and national designation of the Bagley-Warren district. He expressed interest in continuing work citywide. - Councilmember Calloway asked about inventory of city artifacts (e.g., a bronze bus and a missing plaque); Rivera said that is not part of his role. - Councilmember Miller praised his background and noted positive feedback from colleagues. - Outcome: Motion to draft a resolution and send to formal passed. Appointment of Alethea Carr to the Board of Zoning Appeals - Alethea Carr (lifetime Detroiter, retired public health dietitian) expressed interest in learning about zoning appeals and ensuring equity. - Councilmember Miller raised concerns about developers using "wraparound" applications to bypass BZA denials. Carr agreed to be vigilant and promote equity. - Councilmember Calloway requested Carr speak at a District 2 community meeting about BZA’s work; Carr agreed. - Outcome: Motion to draft a resolution and send to formal passed. H1B Visa Contract Amendment with Clark Hill PLC - Daryl Conrad (Chief Recruitment Officer) and Mike Nolan (Clark Hill attorney) presented a $50,000 contract amendment (100% city funded) for legal services for 10 H1B visa holders (9 from India, 1 from Nigeria; none live in Detroit). Conrad announced a hold on new H1Bs and renewals exceeding $100,000, and formation of a task force to transition to local hires over 12–24 months. - Councilmember Calloway emphasized hiring Detroiters, cited partnerships with Lawrence Tech, Oakland University, Wayne State, Kettering, Western, and Michigan Tech. She also noted the city's home inspector program with Wayne County Community College. - Councilmember Miller asked about fees; Nolan stated legal fees are about $3,950 per person plus filing fees ($780, $600, $1,500, $500). Two employees are close to obtaining green cards. Miller expressed concern that no H1B holders live in Detroit. - Outcome: Motion to approve the contract extension passed. Other Discussion Items - Status of Office of Contract and Procurement (Direct TV franchise) – brought back one week at request of Councilmember Benson. - Settlements approved: seven DDOT-related settlements (totaling $32,500, $52,500, $12,000, $450,000, $11,375, $30,000, $9,163) and one DPW settlement ($9,163). One settlement (Auto Rehab/Steen) brought back due to amount discrepancy. - Legal representation/indemnification: items for police officers (Corey Pierce, Malika Bennett, Yesinia Vellanueva, Taisha Scott, Daryl King/Keith East) and one for a firefighter (Michael Russell) – Russell item brought back for closed session; others approved. - Human Resources: Compensation schedule amendments approved. - Inspector General’s 2025 fourth quarter report received and filed. - Mary Waters memorandum on law enforcement identification deferred four weeks. - Calloway memorandum on Rule 15.5.8 deferred two weeks. - Walk-on appointment of Maria Mohammed to Board of Tax Review approved without interview. Key Outcomes - Reappointments sent to formal session: Melvin Butch Hollowell (PLA), Charlotte Wright (Human Rights Commission), Osvaldo Rivera (Historic Designation Advisory Commission). - Appointment sent to formal session: Alethea Carr (Board of Zoning Appeals). - Contract approved: Amendment to Clark Hill PLC for H1B legal services ($50,000). - Settlements approved: $32,500 (Robbins), $52,500 (Dahomey/Abner), $12,000 (Finish Line), $450,000 (Walker estate), $11,375 (Morey), $30,000 (Richardson), $9,163 (Murphy). - Brought back: Auto Rehab/Steen settlement (amount discrepancy), Direct TV franchise, Law Department ordinance (11.4), PLA additional interviews, legal opinion on renters commission stipend, executive organization plan, and law enforcement identification memo. - Walk-on appointment: Maria Mohammed to Board of Tax Review approved. - Rental compliance: BC confirmed 15% compliance of estimated 82,000 rental properties; council will follow up on revenue and enforcement.
The Budget Finance and Audit Standing Committee met on Wednesday, February 4, 2026, to discuss property tax assessments, public comments, a neighborhood enterprise zone application, and the upcoming fiscal 2027 budget process. The meeting was called to order by the chair, with Councilmembers Denzel McCampbell, Letitia Johnson, and Mary Waters present. Consent Calendar - Approval of Minutes: The committee approved the minutes of previous meetings without objection. Public Comments & Testimony - Jadonte Smith (District 4 resident) criticized Councilmember Johnson for giving a Spirit of Detroit Award to a church with $69,000 in unpaid taxes. He urged keeping the Cover Girl Strip Club closed due to crime and prostitution concerns, and opposed the re-election of Conrad Mallet. - Veronica Smith (Coalition for Property Tax Justice) presented a five-pillar plan for property tax reform in the first 100 days of the new administration, including replacing the assessor with a qualified one, enforcing the 2023 tax reform ordinance, stopping overassessment of lower-valued homes, protecting owner-occupant exemptions, and returning money to overtaxed homeowners. - Betty A. Varner (President of DeSoda Elsewhere Black Association) advocated for the revitalization of the Finkel Corridor, including a new business and expansion of Diva Community Park. - Brother Cunningham reported unshoveled bus stops and unreliable bus service, and recommended Peer Transit for seniors. - William M. Davis (former city employee and police commissioner) called for transparency in the drainage fee and criticized police union contracts for superseding the city charter. - Caller (Linwood area) reported unshoveled bus stops near Northwestern High School and complained about unresponsive council offices. - Rada Caralho (Coalition for Property Tax Justice) again urged implementation of the five pillars. - Damon (District 3 resident now in District 4) shared his family's foreclosure due to overassessment and called for compensation and protection of owner-occupant exemptions. - Caller (referencing city code) warned about a class action lawsuit against the land bank for illegal nuisance abatement, and urged stopping land bank overreach. Discussion Items - Presentation by Office of Assessor: Deputy CFO and Assessor Alvin Horn and Deputy Assessor Cynthia Burton presented property tax assessment data for 2026. Key points: - Residential assessed values increased by 10% on average, but taxable value is capped at 2.7% for properties not sold in 2025. - 267 of 286 neighborhoods saw value increases; declines in areas near the airport and Packard plant due to demolitions. - The city uses a 24-month sales study (April 2023 to March 2025). Distress sales are excluded from valuation but inform neighborhood condition adjustments. - A 14-year data gap (mid-1990s to 2011) contributed to past overassessment issues. - The assessor's review appeals process runs February 1-22; the March Board of Review is required for further appeals to the Michigan Tax Tribunal. - Mayor's executive order mandates a mass appraisal report by 2027 and a complete economic condition factor (ECF) review by 2026. - The office is working on a public affairs position and social media outreach. - Q&A with Councilmembers: Discussion covered: - Differences between assessed value and appraised value; persistence of biased appraisals. - Principal Residence Exemption (PRE) audits and LLC verification processes. - Impact of high millage rates (82.2 mills) stifling homeownership and small businesses. - The Hope program application process; the Board of Review's independent role. - The need for pre-sale inspections to protect first-time homebuyers. - Unfinished Business - 6.1 (NEZ Certificate): Craig Jenkins proposed a rehabilitation of 250 Elliott Street into six rental units under the Neighborhood Enterprise Zone (NEZ). After Councilmember Johnson noted high proposed rents ($2,500-$3,000), Jenkins revised to $1,500/month. The item was postponed to bring in HRD. Later, Rebecca Labove (HRD) confirmed an affordability agreement could be drafted to codify the $1,500 rents at 80% AMI for the abatement term. The committee approved sending the item to formal session with a recommendation to approve, noting the pending agreement. - New Business - 7.1-7.4 (Budget Process Resolutions): Councilmember Corley presented four resolutions: 7.1: Mayor's budget address on Monday, March 9, 2026 (moved from March 7 due to weekend). 7.2: Committee start times shifted to 9 a.m. and meeting durations to one hour from March 11 to April 6. 7.3: Public hearing on the budget set for 5 p.m. on Monday, March 30. 7.4: Final budget calendar to be set by February 25. The committee approved all four resolutions to formal session with unanimous recommendation. Key Outcomes - NEZ Certificate (6.1): Approved to move to formal session with recommendation to approve, contingent on an affordability agreement limiting rents to $1,500/month for six units at 80% AMI, to be finalized by Tuesday, February 10. - Budget Process Resolutions (7.1-7.4): Approved for formal session, setting the 2027 budget process timeline. - Long-Term Financial Obligation Memo (6.2): Postponed for two weeks pending review of OCFO information. - Assessor's Office: Council requested district-level assessment data, copies of PRE audits, and continued outreach. The office committed to filling a public affairs position and improving social media presence.
The Detroit City Council held a formal session on February 3, 2026, beginning at approximately 10:00 AM with a quorum present. The meeting opened with an invocation by Reverend Lawrence Rogers of Second Baptist Church and included extensive public comment, discussion of multiple agenda items, and votes on resolutions and contracts. Notable actions included the approval of seven appointments to be confirmed at a special session on February 5, 2026, and a motion to hold a closed session at 2:30 PM to discuss independent legal counsel. Public Comments & Testimony - Rosanna Perkins: Lifelong Detroiter; presented a cancer awareness book titled Motown Melody Loving Bumblebees and requested to dedicate it to the city in honor of the women who raised her. She also provided honey to council members. - Kenneth Smith / Sharon Richardson: Residents of the Camper Stevens Apartments (1410 Washington Boulevard). Mr. Smith described serious security concerns due to propped-open stairwells and a single working elevator, urging the council to hold owners/management responsible for tenant safety. Ms. Richardson added that she has had to walk 21 flights of stairs, has received a cortisone shot in her knee, and requested immediate attention. - Claude Norwood: Expressed community fear regarding ICE encounters and referenced the death of a woman named Miss Cook who froze after being turned away from a shelter. Noted that the District 7 Community Advisory Council (CAC) is not funded per the city charter. - Josh Mann: Criticized former Mayor Duggan's anti-graffiti laws, arguing they criminalize aspiring muralists. Called for the creation of legal practice spaces for street art and voiced concerns about the Flock Safety camera system. - Michael's Mama: Criticized the Detroit Police Department for inadequate staffing and response after her son Michael went missing; was told she had to organize a search party herself. Council President Tate committed to following up with Chief Bettison. - Betty Lyons: Complained about over $600 million in overpaid property taxes she says were stolen by former Mayor Duggan. - James Chandler: In support of his petition (2026-009, Agenda 20.1) on price gouging and home-rule authority. Asked the council to process the petition fully. - Shar Williams: Criticized the condition of homeless shelters, alleged police housing is taking up bed space, and objected to a contract going to an out-of-state firm. - Ruby Riley: Expressed frustration with the city's flood response, claiming that while Southwest Detroit residents received hotel accommodations, she was left without heat for two years. - Brother Cunningham: Reported giving out hand warmers, bus tickets, and gloves to the homeless. Councilmember Callaway provided a box of hand warmers. Discussion Items - Senior Building Conditions / Elevator Safety (Camper Stevens Apartments): Councilmembers raised concerns about non-working elevators and security. Director David Bell of BSEED reported that inspectors were en route to 1410 Washington Boulevard. He outlined a new initiative: monthly inspections of senior housing buildings, elevator inspections at least four times annually (double the current requirement), fines up to $2,000 for violations, and a goal of having 65 senior buildings up to code by August 2026. - Snow Removal at Bus Stops: Jenny Whitfield (DDOT) and Alex Wetherup (GSD) explained that DDOT oversees all bus stops and GSD is responsible for the 153 city-owned shelters, with additional support from a private contractor for 120 advertising shelters. They are working to improve ADA compliance. - Deed Fraud Prevention: Councilmember Waters announced a series of town hall meetings on deed fraud, held at multiple locations on February 4, 12, 24, and 26, 2026. The first meeting at the Northwest Activity Center had standing room only. - Equitable Development Task Force: Councilmember Johnson moved to re-establish the task force and later to add Councilmember McCampbell as a member; both motions passed. - Flock Safety Data Privacy (Line Item 19.7): Councilmember McCampbell objected to the contract, citing concerns about data use, while Council President Pro Tem Young supported it, noting the contract already includes prohibitions against use for ICE or private surveillance. Consent Calendar - Approval of the journal of January 20, 2026. - Numerous routine resolutions and contracts passed unanimously. Key Outcomes - Line Item 17.1–17.5, 17.10, 17.11: Postponed to a special session on Thursday, February 5, 2026, at 2:30 PM for confirmation hearings. - Line Item 17.29 / 17.31: Appointed Julie Castone to the property tax board of review and removed Maria Mohammed from the same board – both approved. - Line Item 17.35: Re-established the Equitable Development Task Force, amended to include Councilmember McCampbell. - Line Item 19.7 (Flock Safety contract): Approved 6–1 with McCampbell the sole dissenting vote. - Line Item 20.1 (petition re: Wayne County Treasurer): Postponed one week for a legal review. - Line Item 20.2 (James Chandler petition): Approved and referred to the Neighborhood and Community Services Standing Committee for a speaking opportunity. - Line Item 21.8: Approved by a vote of 7–0 to hold a closed session at 2:30 PM to discuss independent legal counsel. The closed session will be part of this formal session. - Water Shutoffs: Deputy Director Sam Smalley of DWSD confirmed that water service is not interrupted during freezing temperatures. Councilmember Callaway's motion to research a moratorium on evictions in extreme cold was passed. - Member Reports: Included town halls on deed fraud, a community kickoff in District 5, and a District 6 skate night.
On Monday, February 2, 2026, the Health and Safety Standing Committee met with Councilmembers Gabriela Santiago Romero (Chair), Denzel McCampbell (Vice Chair), and Mary Waters present. The meeting covered emergency demolition contracts, water infrastructure improvements, a vehicle repair contract, fire department uniforms, lactation pods, and a report on utility shutoffs. Public comments addressed police oversight, water shutoffs, affordable housing, and deed fraud. The committee approved several items and deferred others. Consent Calendar - Minutes from the previous session were approved without objection. Public Comments & Testimony - William M. Davis (former Detroit Board of Police Commissioner, District 7) argued that the Board of Police Commissioners needs its own attorney and raised concerns about surveillance techniques and the city's health offerings under the Duggan administration. - Dr. Denise Dornell (District 2) praised the deed fraud town hall and requested a dangerous tree removal at Mount Elliott and Charles. - Owner Papa recited a Langston Hughes poem, criticized the agenda for lacking health-related items, and demanded a health report mandated by the city charter. - Cecily McLellan (We the People of Detroit) reported that DWSD shut off over 900 residents in December 2025, with over 400 restored. She urged support for state water affordability legislation (HB 4555, HB 5170-5173) and noted the Detroit Lifeline H2O program no longer covers arrearages. - Betty A. Verner (President, Soda Elsewhere Black Association) promoted the MI Choice Waiver program for seniors, noting income eligibility up to $2,900/month. - Jadante Smith (District 3) advocated for downzoning near the Coronel's Conquer facility, requested a reduction in downzoning fees, and questioned the cost of demolitions, specifically the $2 million renovation at 5811-5817 Concord (Packard Plant). - Caller ending in 169 thanked the council for supporting Brother Cunningham and highlighted his volunteer work at transit centers. - Caller citing Detroit City Code 50-2-6 demanded that the Board of Zoning Appeals produce transcripts of public proceedings, alleging the city is now charging for them and that the law department is involved. Also raised concerns about eminent domain for solar farms, calling it a repeat of 1951 slum clearance. - Caller ending in 039 complained about deed fraud and election integrity, referencing a previous town hall. - Mr. Cunningham was the last caller before public comment was cut off at 10:05 AM. Discussion Items - Unfinished Business – Emergency Demolition Contracts (5.1-5.9): These contracts were brought back after the committee previously flagged the funding source. The administration clarified that $12 million is available from neighborhood improvement bonds. The committee approved all nine without recommendation. - Vehicle Repair Service (5.10): Contract with Jefferson Chevrolet for police vehicle repairs, with a $90,000 increase. Captain Jason Adams (DPD) confirmed unused funds return to the city and that projections are based on historical data. Approved. - Resolution Supporting Michigan Bills (5.11): Memo supporting SB 508, 509, and 510 (limiting ICE activity, privacy protections, and officer mask transparency). Brought back in one week for drafting. - Russell Ferry Truck Wash Project (6.1): Extension of time (no cost increase) due to a 28-32 week lead time for a pump replacement. The facility will wash heavy-duty vehicles. Approved. - Packard Plant Commercial Alteration (6.2): $2.43 million contract for debris removal and subgrade structure work at 5811-5817 Concord, funded by a state land bank grant. The work will make the site safe for future development. Approved. - Water System Improvements (6.3): $12.9 million contract with Major Contracting for replacing 22,000 linear feet of water main in Districts 1 and 5, funded by state revolving funds. Deputy Director Sam Smiley noted 51% Detroiters will be assigned. The committee inquired about the comprehensive plan for flooding and water infrastructure. Vice Chair McCampbell requested a report on water shutoffs and the lifeline program. Approved and sent to new business. - Fire Department Uniforms (6.4): $700,765.52 three-year contract with Phoenix Safety Outfitters (Southfield, MI) for station wear, dress uniforms, and PPE. No Detroit-based vendors submitted bids despite outreach to over 100. Approved. - Lactation Pods (6.5): $149,000 grant-funded contract with Space Works (Maryland) for six lactation pods. Director Leah Smith (Health Department) explained the pods will be placed at recreation centers and partner hospitals (Henry Ford, potentially DMC). They will use QR code smart locks for access. The committee discussed accessibility for those without smartphones and plans for usage tracking. Approved. - Dangerous Buildings Findings (6.6): Received and filed. - Deferral of Property at 11945 Lane (6.7): Approved. - Report on Natural Gas and Electricity Shut-offs (6.8): Legislative Policy Division confirmed that the city council cannot impose a moratorium on DTE shut-offs; that power rests with the Michigan Public Service Commission. Regarding water, the analysis differs due to the Great Lakes Water Authority and bankruptcy bond obligations. Received and filed. - Memo on Public Restrooms (6.9): Requested information on accessibility. Brought back in three weeks. Key Outcomes - Approved without recommendation: Emergency demolition contracts (5.1-5.9). - Approved: Vehicle repair contract (5.10), Russell Ferry truck wash extension (6.1), Packard Plant alteration (6.2), water system improvements (6.3), fire department uniforms (6.4), lactation pods (6.5), property deferral (6.7). - Brought back in one week: Resolution supporting Michigan bills (5.11). - Received and filed: Dangerous buildings findings (6.6), report on utility shut-offs (6.8). - Brought back in three weeks: Memo on public restrooms (6.9). - Member Reports: Councilmember Waters announced a deed fraud town hall on February 4 at Crowwell Recreation Center. Vice Chair McCampbell and Chair Santiago Romero celebrated Black History Month and encouraged community engagement.
The Detroit City Council Neighborhood Community Service Standing Committee met on Thursday, January 29, 2026, at 7:23 PM. The meeting included a special presentation to community volunteer Michael Cunningham, approval of minutes, public comment from residents and advocates, and discussion and advancement of five contracts for city services. Committee members focused on increasing Detroit-based vendor participation in city contracts. Special Presentation to Michael Cunningham - Committee President Pro Tem Colleen Young presented a donation of winter gear to Michael Cunningham of D Dot Riders. The donation included: 320 lip balms, 100 pairs of large socks, 100 pairs of extra large socks, 150 pairs of hand warmers, 100 beanie hats, 100 matching scarves, and 60 pairs of gloves with touch-screen capability. Cunningham expressed gratitude and noted that he runs low on hand warmers during cold weather. Council members praised his service to vulnerable residents, especially bus riders. Consent Calendar - The committee approved the minutes of the previous meeting by motion with no objections. Public Comments & Testimony - Charles Miles (in-person) – Expressed frustration about a property tax issue since 2017 where his payments were misapplied. He said he has not received resolution from multiple city departments. Council Member Miller offered to assist personally. - Reuben Prowley (in-person) – Supported Miles, alleging city officials mishandled the matter. He called for a halt to an upcoming eviction hearing and referenced a pending circuit court case. - Tina Lewandowski (in-person) – Thanked the committee for the donations to Cunningham and said she partners with him to serve the community. - Michael Cunningham (in-person) – Thanked the committee and urged continued support. He provided his contact number (313-444-9114) for donations and collaboration. - Virtual callers: - Caller 169 – Thanked the committee and promoted Cunningham's transportation services. - Betty A. Brown (President, Soto Elswork Block Association) – Thanked the committee and provided information about Nolan Family Health Center, a sliding-fee clinic on Seven Mile Road. - William M. Davis – Thanked the committee and advocated for recreation centers to be open six days a week with extended hours, especially during extreme weather. He also urged more support for city retirees. - Roshella Stewart (DPP) – Thanked the committee and called for improved transit and more housing at 30% AMI. - Caller 124 – Congratulated Cunningham, urged people to layer up in cold weather, and criticized the city's solar initiative, alleging bullying of residents. - Caller 1 (user number one) – Complained about uncleared snow on walkways leading to Northwestern High School and asked for fines against property owners. Also expressed dissatisfaction with Council Member Miller's responsiveness, noting she has been in office only 19 days. Council Member Miller apologized and offered to meet. Discussion Items - Office of Contracting and Procurement – New Business (Items 6.1–6.5) - The committee discussed five contract amendments and new contracts: - 6.1 – Amendment to fleet vehicle upfitting contract with Canfield Equipment Services (Warren, MI) – extension of time only, total amount $12,249,360.40. - 6.2 – Amendment to pump repair/maintenance contract with Phoenix Environmental (Plymouth, MI) – increase of $418,000 for DDOT and DDC sites, total $1,043,000. - 6.3 – New heavy-duty truck repair contract with Southern Truck Equipment (Alma, MI) – $250,000, three years. - 6.4 – New athletic equipment contract with BSN Sports (Rochester Hills, MI) – $750,000, two years. - 6.5 – New irrigation system repair contract with American Sprinkler and Landscaping (Livonia, MI) – $295,000, two years. - Council Members Benson and Miller raised concerns about the lack of Detroit-based prime contractors in several items. CPO Sandra Stahl explained that equalization credits are applied and that the city actively recruits Detroit vendors. She noted that for contract 6.3, one of the four awardees (Kerry Brothers) is Detroit-headquartered. For 6.4, only two bids were received. For 6.5, two Detroit-certified bidders submitted but were not competitive. - Member Benson requested quarterly reporting on Detroit vendor participation and subcontracting metrics. Member Miller asked for a list of all bidders for the contracts. Stahl agreed to provide the information. Key Outcomes - The committee approved the minutes by unanimous consent. - All five contracts (6.1–6.5) were moved to the formal session of the City Council with a recommendation for approval. - Council Member Benson announced upcoming Life and Legacy Planning sessions for estate planning. - Council Member Miller reported a successful District 5 community kickoff event with over 100 attendees despite cold weather.
The Planning and Economic Development Standing Committee of the Detroit City Council met on Thursday, January 29, 2026, under the chairmanship of Councilmember Letitia Johnson. The committee addressed a range of items including zoning changes, contracts for housing and development services, and landmark authority updates. Public comment featured 10 virtual speakers who raised concerns about city debt, land bank property management, downzoning fees, disaster preparedness, and service equity. The committee approved several items for formal council consideration and deferred others for further review. Public Comments & Testimony - Caller ending in 169 expressed gratitude for prayers for a community member and promoted Cunningham transportation services, urging residents to consider them over rideshare companies. - William M. Davis argued that the city must pay its debt to retirees, stating that the recovery has unfairly burdened them. He called for the land bank to drastically reduce its property inventory, especially side lots and occupied structures, to reduce blight and improve safety. - Jadante Smith praised Councilmember Santiago Romero’s office for responsiveness on downzoning inquiries. He requested a fee discount for community downzoning applications (current fee: $1,500 for first acre, $50 per additional acre) and noted ongoing lawsuits against the city that could be avoided. - Betty A. Varner (President, Soda Ellsworth Block Association) provided information about the Detroit Community Health Connection clinics, including the Noland Family Health Center at 111 West Seven Mile, which operates on a sliding fee scale with a $20 flat rate for services. She shared contact numbers for medical and dental care. - Owner Papa criticized the dismissal of problems with HOME funds and the lack of resolution from a previous audit meeting. He urged the committee to plan for disaster recovery, noting that residents need to know where they would go in a crisis. Chair Johnson clarified that she responded to audit concerns and that a disaster recovery task force (co-chaired by Johnson, Santiago Romero, and Waters) is actively working. - Tahira Ahmad expressed concern about inequitable FEMA relief after the 2021 flooding, stating Black homeowners were snubbed. She called for clawing back $600 million from Dan Gilbert’s Hudson project due to alleged breach of contract (failed to bring promised 2,500 new jobs) and urged use of the former mayor’s “Progress Fund” for home repairs. - Michelle (caller) reported that sidewalks on West Graham Boulevard near Northwestern High School are not shoveled, causing injuries to children and elderly. She also requested a ban on retaliatory evictions by landlords, stating she has filed multiple complaints with Councilmember Miller’s office without response. Chair Johnson (also liaising with DPSCD) assured escalation to the school district; Councilmember Santiago Romero countered that her office is highly responsive to this caller. - Inclusive Community Engagement Matters (caller) criticized the Board of Zoning Appeals for imposing high transcript fees, arguing that the city code requires transcripts regardless of appeal, and that the Law Department is interfering with residents’ right to petition. They urged the committee to exercise oversight. - Cunningham requested that the city provide bus tickets or validate parking for residents attending public comment. He also highlighted the need to keep transit centers open overnight for the homeless and described charitable efforts distributing warm items. - Caller ending in 039 made unfounded accusations against Councilmember Santiago Romero, alleging election interference, and claimed a property foreclosure was mishandled. The caller became agitated and was not called to order; their time concluded. Discussion Items - 5.1 – Status of Councilmember Santiago Romero’s memorandum on tax abatement in District Six: On motion, brought back in two weeks for further discussion. - 6.1 – Lease agreement (Contract 6007573): 931 Selden as construction staging area for 900 Tuscola development. Discussion included dust mitigation during construction, parking plans, and the $500/month rental fee. Staff explained the gravel site and that the lease accommodates simultaneous use by Invest Detroit. The item was sent to formal agenda with a recommendation to approve. - 6.2 – Home Repair Loan Program Design Consulting Services (Contract 6007618): $108,000 contract with The Ownership Initiative LLC for one year to redesign the zero-interest home repair loan program. Chief Rico Rizzo (HRD) reported that over 10 years the program served 825 households with $16.7 million loans, average income $41,000, default rate 2%, and average age 58. Councilmember Santiago Romero raised concerns about contractor quality and inspector misconduct, urging a patient satisfaction evaluation. Chairman Johnson requested her office be included in the design process. Motion to approve passed. - 6.3 – Rezoning former Alice Burney Elementary site (4094 DeWayne) from R2 to SD1: To permit senior housing by Presbyterian Villages of Michigan. CPC staff recommended setting a public hearing. Motion approved. - 6.4 – Rezoning from R2 to R3 for Northwest Goldberg CARES nonprofit center (seven parcels near 15th & Marquette): Staff explained that R3 allows the proposed schoolhouse-style center by-right, avoiding a variance needed under R2. Councilmembers noted the area needs both housing and community services. Public hearing set. - 6.5 – Rezoning from R3 to B4 for expansion of The Schwitz health club (656-662 Melbourne): Owner plans to add HVAC equipment and an outdoor lounge for the historic bathhouse, now open to all. Councilmembers praised the business and discussed economic impact. Public hearing set. - 6.6 – CDBG NOF 2026-2027 list of applicants and conflict disclosure: Staff requested council offices review the list for conflicts. Received and filed. - 6.7 – CDBG NOF schedule: Deferred for two weeks pending review by the new administration. - 6.8 & 6.9 – Community Benefits Ordinance biennial reports: Brought back, date to be determined. - 6.10 – Detroit Land Bank Authority quarterly report (Q2 FY2026): Brought back in one week for discussion. - 6.11 – Planning & Development annual sign waiver hearing report (2025): Edwina King (PDD) reported 27 applications, 24 eligible, 20 hearings, 13 approved, 7 with conditions; signs approved in all seven council districts. Staff recommended amending the sign ordinance but referred to law department. Received and filed. - 6.12 – Councilmember Benson’s memorandum on M4 Green Buffer Text Amendment timeline: Referred to City Planning Commission, bring back in four weeks. - 6.13 – Council President Tate’s memorandum on Graham River Corridor update: Brought back in two weeks. - 6.14 – Councilmember Waters’ memorandum on negotiations with Michigan Land Bank Authority over DLBA intergovernmental agreement: Removed from agenda to allow internal work on amendments concerning board makeup and residency. Key Outcomes - Approvals for formal agenda: Items 6.1 (lease), 6.2 (home repair consulting), 6.3, 6.4, 6.5 (zoning changes with public hearing settings) were all approved unanimously. - Deferrals or bringbacks: Items 5.1 (two weeks), 6.7 (two weeks), 6.8/6.9 (date TBD), 6.10 (one week), 6.12 (four weeks), 6.13 (two weeks) were deferred as noted. - Received and filed: Items 6.6 (CDBG NOF list) and 6.11 (sign waiver report) were received and filed without objection. - Item removed: Item 6.14 was removed to allow council to develop proposed amendments prior to sending to the Michigan Land Bank Authority. All actions were taken without objection unless otherwise noted. The committee adjourned after member reports.
On January 28, 2026, the Detroit City Council's Budget, Finance, and Audit (BFA) Committee met to receive the city's annual comprehensive financial report (ACFR) and single audit report for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2025, and to discuss a Neighborhood Enterprise Zone (NEZ) certificate application. The committee heard public comments, received a presentation from the Auditor General and Plante Moran, deliberated on the NEZ application, and referred a report on a local option admissions tax to a future Committee of the Whole. Public Comments & Testimony - Mr. Davis: Expressed concerns about the city's treatment of retirees post-bankruptcy, urged renegotiation of the Great Lakes Water Authority lease (claiming the city is underpaid), requested a physical copy of the Plante Moran report, and called for re-establishment of the retiree task force. Councilmember Waters responded that the task force has been re-established and will meet next month. - Jadante Smith: Called for the removal of Corporation Counsel Conrad Mallett and Gary Brown, citing 51 water main breaks across the city and a scandal in Southwest Detroit. Also criticized Councilmember Benson (District 3) for inadequate advocacy on issues including homelessness, water main breaks, abandoned homes, sewer issues, land bank problems, and police issues. Councilmember McCampbell noted that the committee received an update from DWSD the previous day. - Betty A. Verner (President, Soda Ellsworth Block Association): Provided information on the Detroit Community Health Connection and Nolan Family Health Center (111 West Seven Mile), which offers health and dental services on a sliding fee scale. Councilmember Waters thanked her and pledged to share the resources. - Brother Cunningham: Solicited hand warmers and bus tickets for those waiting at bus stops in the cold, citing inadequate bus service. Also thanked Councilmember Waters' office for constituent assistance. - You Matter: Raised concerns about the Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA) charging appellants for transcripts (citing costs of over $4,700 in one case) and questioned a proposed rule change requiring appellants to pay. The caller criticized Conrad Mallett's leadership of the Law Department. Councilmember McCampbell asked the caller to contact his office directly for follow-up. - Charlotte: Seconded comments from a previous caller (presumably "Joanne") and thanked the committee. Presentation: Annual Comprehensive Financial Report (ACFR) and Single Audit Presenters: Laura Goodsby (Auditor General), Ali Hajazi (Partner, Plante Moran), Amanda Ward (Partner, Plante Moran), Josh Ed (Principal, Plante Moran), Veronica Twazan (Senior Manager, Plante Moran). - Audit Opinion: Plante Moran issued an unmodified (clean) opinion on the city's financial statements for FY2025, the highest level of assurance. The city has received the Government Finance Officers Association Certificate of Achievement for Excellence in Financial Reporting for eight consecutive years (FY2018–FY2025). - Financial Highlights (General Fund): - Revenues increased 3.7% to $1.45 billion. Property tax revenue rose 14% (due to increased taxable value, despite a slight millage rate decrease); wagering tax revenue rose 18% (due to increased activity); other revenue decreased 13% (largely due to shifts in investment income). - Expenditures increased 3.4% to $1.381 billion, within budgeted appropriations. Development and management costs rose significantly due to increased required contributions to pension plans. Public protection costs rose 6% to $643 million. - General fund balance decreased 7.7% (approximately $85 million) to $1.029 billion. The decrease was driven by a $52 million drawdown from the Retiree Protection Fund for pension contributions and a $42 million addition to a corporate income tax reserve due to future uncertainty. - Audit Findings (Financial Statement): - Two material weaknesses were reported (up from one in FY2024). - Finding 2025-001 (Repeat): Lack of proper controls to ensure timely and accurate financial reporting, encompassing 15 individual items (down from 17 the prior year). City staff stated these items were not individually material. - Finding 2025-002 (New): Lack of proper controls to prevent possible misappropriation of assets at a component unit (identified as the Detroit Transportation Corporation, DTC). This finding stems from a lack of segregation of duties that led to improper payments. - Single Audit (Federal Expenditures): - Federal expenditures were approximately $508 million (a significant increase from prior years), with $291 million from ARPA (State and Local Fiscal Recovery Funds). Six major programs were audited, and all received unmodified opinions. - Four findings were reported (two repeat from FY2024), all classified as material weaknesses. - HOME Program (Repeat): (1) Failure to ensure timely inspections, deficiency communication, and corrective action. (2) Failure to implement controls to ensure eligibility reviews were performed in compliance with award terms. - Ryan White HIV Emergency Relief Program (New): Sub-recipient payments were not made within 30 days of reimbursement requests, as required. (Payments were 31–32 days late due to a system setting.) - WIC Program (New): A material weakness was reported (specific details not provided in the transcript). - Question Costs: None were reported. Discussion Items - 6.1 NEZ Application – 1257 Bagley (Corktown): The committee considered a Neighborhood Enterprise Zone certificate application for the rehabilitation of an existing duplex at 1257 Bagley. Discussion focused on the tax valuation basis (capped vs. uncapped) for the NEZ. Vice Chair Johnson emphasized that the city needs to ensure the uncapped taxes (based on current property values) are collected to support revenue growth. Councilmember Waters raised concerns about property appraisal accuracy. The property owner, Matt Cassidy, was present. The assessor’s office (Deputy CFO Assessor Alvin Horn) clarified that under a rehab NEZ, the value is based on the pre-rehab assessed value as adjusted by the assessor, and the State Tax Commission makes the final decision based on the local assessor’s recommendation. - 7.1 CRC Report on Local Option Admissions Tax: The committee received a report from the Citizens Research Council (CRC) of Michigan evaluating a local option admissions tax on sports and entertainment venues. The committee voted to postpone the item to a future date (to be determined) after a scheduled Committee of the Whole discussion, where CRC will present both the admissions tax report and a separate report on a local option sales tax. The item will return to the BFA committee after that discussion. Member Reports - Councilmember Waters: Announced a town hall on deed fraud on Saturday (date not specified) from 10 a.m. to noon at the Northwest Activity Center (18100 Meyers Road), co-hosted with Councilmember Callaway (District 2). The event will be hybrid. - Councilmember McCampbell: Announced a District 7 swearing-in and visioning session at 5:30 p.m. at St. Suzanne and expressed appreciation for the committee’s work. Key Outcomes - The ACFR and single audit reports were received and discussed. No formal action was required. - 6.1 (NEZ Application): Moved to Formal Session with a recommendation to approve. - 7.1 (CRC Report): Postponed to a future date (to be determined) after a Committee of the Whole discussion, with the item to return to the BFA committee thereafter. - The committee stood adjourned at 2:53 p.m.