⬚ figure
HOCO BY DESIGN
EVERY VOICE, ONE VISION
Howard County's General Plan
⬚ figure
Howard County's General Plan
Calvin Ball
Christiana Rigby, Chair, District 3 Deb Jung, Vice Chair, District 4 Opel Jones, District 2 Liz Walsh, District 1 David Yungmann, District 5
Ed Coleman, Chair Kevin McAliley, Vice Chair Mason Godsey James Cecil Barbara Mosier
Lynda Eisenberg, Director Mary Kendall, Deputy Director Jessica Bellah, Deputy Director
DPZ Division of Comprehensive and Community Planning: Kristin O’Connor, Kate Bolinger, Sarah Latimer, Victoria Olivier, Morgan Gillard; DPZ Communications: Hanni Werner; DPZ Research Division: Jeff Bronow, James Wilkerson; DPZ Resource Conservation Division: Beth Burgess, Susan Overstreet, Joy Levy, Samantha Holmes; DPZ Zoning Division: Geoff Goins, Peter Conrad, Justin Tyler, Jeff DelMonico; DPZ Division of Land Development: Anthony Cataldo, Julia Sauer; DPZ Development Engineering Division: Chad Edmondson; Office of Transportation: Bruce Gartner, David Cookson; Department of Public Works: Yosef Kebede, Arthur Shapiro, Sithmini Meegoda, Bilal Sarayra, Robert ‘Zach’ Hollenbeck, Mark DeLuca, Mark Richmond; Department of Housing and Community Development: Kelly Cimino; Office of Community Sustainability: Tim Lattimer, James Zoller
Lead Consultant: City Explained, Inc.; Supporting Consultants: Mahan Rykiel Associates; Mead & Hunt, Inc.; RCLCO; TPUDC; Biohabitats; Agriculture & Community Design Services; Zanetta Illustration
Department of Public Works; Office of Transportation; Department of Housing and Community Development; Department of Recreation and Parks; Economic Development Authority; Office of Community Sustainability; Department of Community Resources and Services; Department of Inspections, Licenses, and Permits; Health Department; Office of Emergency Management; Department of Fire and Rescue Services; Police Department; Office of Budget; County Administration; Department of Technology and Communication Services; Office of Law
Tonya Aikens, Leslie Bauer, Jessica Bellah, Michelle Bilello, Meg Boyd, Steve Breeden, Brian Cornell, Vicky Cutroneo, Phillip Dodge, Mavis Ellis, Olivia Farrow, Tim Feaga, Elliott Finklestein, Joel Gallihue, Lori Graf, Robin Holliday, Cathy Hudson, Grace Kubofcik, Joan Lancos, Josh Lenes, Lori Lilly, Patricia Marshall, Kevin McAliley, Leonardo McClarty, Cole Schnorf, Jahantab Siddiqui, Sue Song, Chris Tsien, Larry Twele, Jason Van Kirk, Paul Verchinski, Christine Wells, Shari Zaret
Staff Advisors: Dan Lubeley, Howard County Public School System; Tim Rogers, Howard County Public School System
Group Members: Michael Bayer, James Cecil, Larry Cohen, Joel Gallihue, Ellen Flynn Giles, Elizabeth Homan, Steve Hunt, Pratima Lele, Dr. Yun Lu
Staff Advisor: Kelly Cimino, Department of Housing and Community Development
Group Members: Jackie Alexander, Paul Casey, Alicyn DelZoppo, Candace Dodson-Reed, Lisa Govoni, Bruce Harvey, Sherman Howell, Sean Hughes, Fran LoPresti, Paul Revelle, Jean Sedlacko, Josh Tzuker
Staff Advisors: Mark DeLuca, Department of Public Works; Joshua Feldmark, Office of Community Sustainability; Mark Richmond, Department of Public Works; James Zoller, Office of Community Sustainability
Group Members: Todd Arterburn, Jim Caldwell, Michael Calkins, Christine Conn, Kim Drake, Ann Jones, Erica Jones, Ned Tillman
Technical Appendix A: Environment Technical Appendix B: Character Areas Technical Appendix C: Focus Areas
⬚ figure
HoCo By Design is a visionary document that guides policy decisions for the next two decades. The General Plan is re-evaluated every ten years and provides general direction for a twenty-year horizon while recognizing that decision-making in the intervening years will be further informed by factors beyond these pages.
HoCo By Design is the County’s growth Plan. It reflects a depth and breadth of public engagement that is unprecedented for Howard County. Throughout the planning process, stakeholders and participants collaborate to create a vision for what they consider to be the ideal future for Howard County. Residents describe Howard County as a welcoming place with thriving neighborhoods, innovative and prosperous businesses, and quality recreational, cultural, educational, and housing opportunities. They celebrate the County’s high quality of life, abundant natural resources, and self-sustaining economy. HoCo By Design reflects the values of process participants and seeks to preserve and protect the qualities of Howard County that make the community so special while tackling the challenges ahead.
HoCo By Design starts from the baseline of the previous General Plan – PlanHoward 2030 – and aims to define a growth and conservation path to 2040 that is more equitable, more predictable, more sustainable, and more achievable for the County and all its residents. While PlanHoward 2030 emphasized three pillars of sustainability, HoCo By Design aspires to improve upon PlanHoward with a four-pronged, aspirational approach toward greater equity, predictability, sustainability, and achievability.
The General Plan is a long-range, visionary document that outlines how and where the County should develop and grow as it adjusts to evolving economic, environmental, and social conditions over the next 20 years.
The Plan will help to inform subsequent decisions on land use, transportation, open space, agriculture, community facilities, community character, historic preservation, housing, economic development, and quality of life.
While the Plan describes future land uses, it does not change zoning—including what uses are allowed and not allowed—in any area. Changes to the Zoning Regulations occur as part of a separate process following the General Plan’s adoption, known as comprehensive rezoning.
HoCo By Design is unique in that it offers illustrative graphics for some focus areas as part of its character-driven approach. Graphics provided in the Plan are for illustrative purposes only. They are intended to convey a general approach or character rather than an obligation to a specific outcome.
Finally, HoCo By Design is an update to PlanHoward 2030. The Downtown Columbia Plan and Ellicott City Watershed Master Plan, which were adopted as amendments to the prior General Plan, are included in the update and will not be modified or replaced by way of this document.
HoCo By Design will be implemented through more detailed plans, studies, ordinances, and budgets that follow, which hone the vision in the General Plan into specific rules, requirements, or initiatives needed to guide future growth, development, or conservation efforts.
The General Plan should be used by County leaders, decision makers, appointed board members, and the community to assess future development policies and community-wide decisions. It should also guide the review of development applications, ordinance amendments, and future investments as the County implements HoCo By Design’s vision.
⬚ figure
HoCo By Design is the latest addition in Howard County's history of general planning efforts. The General Plan has been updated in Howard County approximately every ten years (1960, 1971, 1982, 1990, 2000, 2012) and each Plan has responded to the challenges and opportunities of its time. HoCo By Design starts from the baseline of the 2012 General Plan—PlanHoward 2030. HoCo By Design is character-based and focuses on redevelopment of a mature community that has a high housing demand and employment capacity but is constrained by limited remaining undeveloped land. HoCo By Design aims to define a path to 2040 that is more equitable, more predictable, more sustainable, and more achievable for the County.
1960 Howard County's first General Plan envisioned accommodating its growing population of 36,000 residents through a largely suburban, large lot development pattern. This Plan was adopted in an era when major highway connections were being planned across the region.
⬚ figure
⬚ figure
⬚ figure
1971 & 1982 By the second General Plan’s adoption in 1971, James Rouse's vision for Columbia as a planned city of 100,000 was well underway, with Columbians comprising nearly 15 percent of the County's population in 1970. Both the 1971 and 1982 Plans responded to the rapidly growing Columbia; they guided land development to locations with planned infrastructure, and established policies for agriculture and environmental preservation in the rural western portion of the County.
1990 In the 1990 Plan, policies were adopted to better manage growth, calling for the establishment of an adequate public facilities ordinance, and density sending and cluster development options in the Rural West. The Planned Service Area (PSA) boundary was introduced that bifurcated land development patterns between east and west.
⬚ figure
⬚ figure
⬚ figure
2000 & 2012 The last two Plans—adopted in 2000 and 2012—further focused on managing growth and working toward a more sustainable future measured in terms of environmental stewardship, financial stability, efficient use of existing infrastructure, and emphasis on redevelopment in the Route 1 and Route 40 Corridors, Downtown Columbia, and the Columbia village centers.
⬚ figure
⬚ figure
Each decade brings a unique set of challenges. By early 2020, the County was already grappling with issues presented by the combination of a growing population, dwindling supply of undeveloped land, lack of affordable housing options, and shifting weather patterns associated with climate change. These challenges were then compounded by the unprecedented nature of the global Covid-19 pandemic and the resulting upheaval of daily life, locally and globally, that began in mid-March of 2020 and continued to influence behavior over the course of the planning effort.
Since the launch of the planning process in March of 2020, extensive community feedback, data analysis, and best practice research have coalesced to underscore five major issue areas for Howard County’s future. These are detailed in the “Planning Themes” chapters, which respectively outline:
⬚ figure
Ecological Health – this chapter identifies opportunities to deepen Howard County’s commitment to environmental stewardship, create better compatibility between the natural and built environments, and provide needed measures for climate change mitigation and adaptation.
⬚ figure
County in Motion – this chapter highlights the need to manage and provide a safe, equitable, and fiscally sustainable transportation system for all users that is responsive to changing local, regional, and national transportation trends.
⬚ figure
Economic Prosperity – this chapter highlights values, policies, and initiatives that continue strengthening Howard County’s position as a self-sustaining, diverse employment center for the region.
⬚ figure
Dynamic Neighborhoods – this chapter provides guidance on maintaining and supporting vibrant living that meets the needs of current and future residents with a focus on diversifying housing options, increasing housing affordability, creating amenity-rich neighborhoods, improving infrastructure in existing and new neighborhoods, and encouraging a balanced approach to residential development for all income levels and age ranges.
⬚ figure
Quality By Design – this chapter aims to preserve character in future developments and adopt design standards that are context sensitive for different areas and development opportunities. Historic resource preservation is emphasized as an important contributor to community character and tradition.
The County’s ability to address challenges is shaped, in part, by available land to accommodate new uses and associated buildings and spaces. Howard County has reached an inflection point, where limited land supply prompts new patterns of land development and natural resource conservation.
Historically a desirable location for households and employers, the County has continued to grow and is projected to witness strong demand for new spaces through 2040. Along with this growth comes the need for supporting infrastructure, such as schools, parks, and transportation investments. Meanwhile, approximately 98% of the County’s land supply is already developed, committed for development, or preserved via open space, agricultural, or other type of easement—leaving just 2% of land “undeveloped.”
Given the diminishing land supply, HoCo By Design explores redevelopment as a transformative opportunity for the future. Redevelopment can involve the demolition of existing buildings to make way for new, the addition of new buildings on lots that already have structures, or the re-use of a site (like a parking lot). HoCo By Design also embraces mixing uses, where places to live are located with places to work, shop, and dine. These types of mixed-use, walkable redevelopments are called “activity centers” in this Plan and are limited in number and location. While prior General Plans began the process of identifying certain areas for growth and revitalization, these areas were expansive in geography, which resulted in unpredictable growth patterns.
HoCo By Design outlines these redevelopment locations on its Future Land Use Map (FLUM), which categorizes the County into eighteen different “Character Areas.” This palette speaks to the wide variety of places in Howard County, from its rural crossroads to its historic communities and suburban retail, office, and residential neighborhoods. This Plan offers guidance for design as well as use in these Character Areas and organizes them under a framework of anticipated change—from “preserve,” to “strengthen,” to “enhance,” and finally, to “transform” (“P-S-E-T”). The FLUM, the Character Areas, and the “P-S-E-T” framework are more fully described in the Growth and Conservation Framework chapter.
An appendix on Focus Areas turns the spotlight to New Town Columbia, Gateway, and Rural Crossroads. Additionally, a plan for Route 1 accompanies the General Plan. Design considerations are provided with illustrative concepts and recommendations offered that are unique to each of these areas.
Planning with a redevelopment mindset requires cautious consideration of infrastructure needs, described in the Supporting Infrastructure and Managing Growth chapters. The Plan concludes with an Implementation chapter that includes a matrix of plan policies.
The name, HoCo By Design, was derived with the following in mind:
"HoCo" is a colloquialism used by those with ties to Howard County. It makes the "new" General Plan feel familiar and underscores the importance of thinking locally and from within the community about the best path forward.
"By Design" was included in the name as it succinctly demonstrates that the Plan is crafted and shaped with great intentionality, and its development and implementation will require just as much art as it does science to protect and promote the character of Howard County.
The project’s slogan, "Every Voice, One Vision" set the tone for the planning process.
County officials wanted to hear from every voice in Howard County to forge a collective vision for the future of the community.
To maximize participation in the planning process, the HoCo By Design project team took a comprehensive approach to engagement and used various mediums—advisory groups, focus groups, public meetings, and online surveys—to reach numerous community organizations, interest groups, government boards and commissions, and the general public.
Throughout the HoCo By Design planning process the community was asked about what was most important to them. Engagement initiatives were customized for both populations traditionally engaged in planning processes, and for people and organizations historically under-represented in planning.
Throughout the process, materials documenting the engagement efforts and feedback were posted on the project website, including: an Engagement Summary encompassing the variety of public involvement activities; a Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Focus Groups Summary showcasing this central effort to ensure the Plan reflected a cross-section of voices from the community; and a Comment Log listing the many thousands of thoughts received through the process. While the Department of Planning and Zoning made many efforts to engage the community, only 3,000 individuals (1% of the County's population) actively engaged in the process.
⬚ figure
To initiate the planning process, a 33-member Planning Advisory Committee (PAC) was appointed by the County Executive and Council, which represented community leaders, service providers, industry groups, and the general public. They served as a sounding board to the project team about the community’s needs and desires in the development of the General Plan. PAC members assisted in developing and identifying planning themes, reviewing data and recommendations, and serving as ambassadors for the process.
The PAC also assisted in developing the Future Land Use Map (FLUM) and contributing to recommendations in this General Plan. Specific topics to which members contributed include: the Preserve-Strengthen-Enhance-Transform (P-S-E-T) framework, character area typologies, transportation and water-sewer infrastructure, a growth allocation framework, and growth management strategies.
The Technical Advisory Group (TAG) consisted of Howard County department staff and partner organizations who are considered subject matter and institutional experts. The HoCo By Design project team consulted with TAG members regularly to verify and validate key findings, ideas, data, and reports.
During the Spring of 2021, three Strategic Advisory Groups (SAGs) were formed to delve into specific opportunities and challenges identified through the planning process. Each SAG comprised a multi-disciplinary group of experts that acted as advisors to the project team, similar to policy think tanks. The SAGs addressed the three different topic areas listed below.
⬚ figure Schools: Planning for School Capacity and Growth
⬚ figure Environment: Examining Climate Change and Natural Resources
⬚ figure Housing: Diversifying Housing Stock and Creating Opportunities for "Missing Middle Housing"
The concept of missing middle housing is referenced throughout the Plan. It is a housing strategy that is intended to create more diverse housing opportunities for our increasingly socioeconomically diverse County. Providing more housing choices is important to support the County's workforce and its future economic development. For the purposes of the General Plan, missing middle housing refers to a range of small- to medium-size home choices that seek to offer different price points for residents living in Howard County. Homes are compatible in scale and character with surrounding neighborhoods, or integrated into new or existing activity centers throughout the County as a transition between different land uses or building types. Missing middle homes may be represented by a single, multi-unit building on a single lot, a multi-unit building on multiple lots, or a cluster of homes oriented around a common green space.
⬚ figure
⬚ figure
Howard County continues to be a racially and ethnically diverse place with a growing multicultural community. According to the latest American Community Survey (ACS) (2019), 49.8% of Howard County residents are White, 20% are African American, 19% are Asian, and 7% are Hispanic. Within each of these racial groups, various ethnicities and identities are represented.
⬚ figure
Source: American Community Survey , 2019
As the County becomes more diverse, elected officials have responded by committing to initiatives such as the Racial Equity Task Force and establishing the County's first Equity and Restorative Practices Unit.
In 2020, the County Council voted to approve CR142-2020, legislation establishing the first Racial Equity Task Force for Howard County. The Task Force was charged with recommending legislation to the County Council to address racial disparities and inequities in Howard County. Comprised of over 60 experts, community leaders, students, and activists, the Racial Equity Task Force identified and evaluated actions that the County Council could pursue to advance racial equity in Howard County. The Task Force focused on racial equity in personal and public safety, land-use and housing policy, economic and workforce development, public health and environmental policy, education, and legislative processes.
The Equity and Restorative Practices Unit, established under County Executive Calvin Ball, uses an equity-centered lens to infuse concepts of equity in the County's service delivery, decision-making, and resource distributions. In collaboration with an Equity Advisory Committee, established in 2021, the Unit will be developing a 3-year strategic plan to help make Howard County Government a more equitable and inclusive workplace and service provider to County residents.
It should also be noted that diversity, equity, and inclusion are being integrated into various County policies, plans, and departments. A few examples include the Howard County Complete Streets Policy, which incorporates an Equity Emphasis Area Index, the Howard County Climate Action Plan, and the 2022 Howard County Recreation and Parks Land Preservation, Parks and Recreation Plan (LPPRP), which incorporated an equity lens for making recommendations about park access. Generally speaking, both the Complete Streets and LPPRP initiatives focus on ensuring equitable access to County resources. Additionally, the Department of Community Resources and Services has been leading various efforts and programs to better serve the needs of the County's diverse population.
Across the region, jurisdictions are leveraging planning, decision-making, and resource allocation processes to create more equitable policies and programs.
Anne Arundel: Plan2040’s policies work together to shape a future for Anne Arundel County that is “Green, Smart, and Equitable”. Social and racial equity concerns are addressed throughout the goals, policies, and strategies in a way that is inclusive of all residents, prioritizes investment in historically underserved and under-resourced communities, and removes barriers that limit people’s opportunities based on who they are or where they live in the County.
Baltimore City: The Planning Department created an Equity in Action Plan in 2017, which will inform their forthcoming comprehensive plan update in 2022. Since 2019, staff have assessed the equity of the Baltimore Capital Improvement Program, the capital budget of the City, by analyzing investments using neighborhood and demographic indicators.
Baltimore County: Master Plan 2030 will be built around the following principles: equity, sustainability, and vibrant communities. The Plan defines equity as “Being inclusive in our decision-making, ensuring equitable distribution of resources and creating opportunity for all” with a focus on vibrant communities, which ensures all residents have access to high-quality, accessible, and affordable housing.
Montgomery County: Thrive Montgomery 2050’s three outcomes are economic health, community equity, and environmental resilience, which have specific recommendations to support them woven throughout the Plan. The outcome of Equitable Communities aims to create a place where all residents have equal access to attainable housing, healthy foods, employment, transportation, education, and more.
⬚ figure
⬚ figure
⬚ figure
⬚ figure
To ensure that the HoCo By Design planning process reflected the values, needs, and priorities of all residents, a specific focus was placed on diversity, equity, and inclusion. This meant that greater efforts were made to ensure that diverse perspectives and voices were heard, people felt included and a part of the planning process, and the outcomes of the process (policies and implementing actions) provided more equitable opportunities for all.
To ensure historically under-represented and diverse groups and communities were reached, the HoCo By Design project team conducted a series of focus groups that targeted specific segments of the population. In total, 15 focus groups were conducted in collaboration with 18 community-based organizations. The project team spoke with more than 100 participants who represented people with disabilities, small business owners, renters, students, young adults, nonprofit service providers, and people with different racial and ethnic backgrounds. Key findings from these focus groups have been highlighted in the “What We Heard” section in the five planning themes—Ecological Health, County in Motion, Economic Prosperity, Dynamic Neighborhoods, and Quality By Design. However, the complete list of findings can be found in the Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) Focus Group report available through the Department of Planning & Zoning.
HoCo By Design aspires to be a plan that creates a future ripe with opportunities for all people in all communities. Findings from focus groups that were held with diverse populations were shared with the Planning Advisory Committee, Strategic Advisory Groups, and the public so that all perspectives could be considered throughout the planning process. In this Plan, policies and implementing actions that could contribute to a more equitable future have been highlighted and are based on the findings from the focus groups, best practices, and other engagement activities.
HoCo by Design’s overall engagement approach was to ensure that all residents and stakeholders had an opportunity to engage and feel included in the process. The project team chose to use a variety of forums and tools to engage these populations, such as On the Table informal discussion sessions, translated materials administered through the Howard County Library system, and focus groups. Our team found using an informal group format effective, as it allowed for greater flexibility in scheduling; more open, informal dialogue with trusted community-based organizations and government staff; and improved accessiblity for residents with less experience participating in local government activities.
⬚ figure
What Are Best Practices for Equity in Planning?
Traditionally, comprehensive plans have focused broadly on elements such as transportation and housing, but many contemporary General Plans have explicitly started to address equity considerations within those and other elements.
With increasing national and local attention on deeply rooted inequities in communities, plans can play a role in creating more equitable outcomes through all aspects of the built environment. The project team used guidance from local and national leaders in the community planning field, including the American Planning Association, to identify best practices in equity planning and incorporate them into HoCo By Design. Because General Plan updates occur at most every ten years, it is a crucial opportunity to confront disparities and create actionable approaches that will help level the playing field.
The best practices listed below were used to help to identify which HoCo By Design polices and actions would contribute to a more equitable future, as it relates to land use, growth, and development.
⬚ figure
Shortly after the HoCo By Design planning effort commenced, the entire County began to experience shutdowns due to the spread of COVID-19. This upheaval to daily life simultaneously provided both opportunities and challenges for engaging the community. Plans for public engagement were already heavily focused on the use of digital engagement tools. As the pandemic progressed, the project team continued to adapt to working in a virtual world and maximized the opportunities and benefits that this cultural shift offered.
Virtual meetings were well-attended, with participation far exceeding typical levels at pre-pandemic, in-person planning meetings. Project awareness was bolstered by a robust project website and social media presence. To supplement the digital outreach, fliers inviting public participation in the planning process accompanied approximately 80,000 water bills, yard signs were posted in County parks, and postcards were placed in local library pick up bags and Roving Radish meal kits.
⬚ figure
⬚ figure
⬚ figure
Between July 2020 and February 2023, HoCo By Design engaged a wide spectrum of community stakeholders through its website, social media, email list, marketing materials, and public involvement activities. Details of the extensive public engagement used to inform the Plan are outlined in an Engagement Summary available on the project website.
The metrics below offer a snapshot of the results of the engagement:
Howard County is a welcoming and inclusive community that residents are proud to call home. People are drawn here by a top-tier school system, thriving neighborhoods, an abundance of open space, innovative and prosperous businesses, and quality recreational, cultural, and housing opportunities accessible to all. An increasingly diverse community works to ensure Howard County remains inclusive and accessible to all.
Howard County offers “a little of everything” from the old to the new—historic crossroad hamlets and rural landscapes, working farms and natural open space, thriving suburbs and walkable neighborhoods, community-serving village centers, and a growing urban downtown. The eclectic mix of environments offers access to shopping, restaurants, and a wide range of activities. In less than thirty minutes, residents can pick produce in an orchard, drive through rolling pastoral hills, visit local small businesses on a quaint, historic main street, view a concert in a large outdoor amphitheater, enjoy a world-class library, or visit a well-maintained public park.
Our collective vision is to accommodate future growth in a manner that retains and improves upon the unique and diverse community character of Howard County. We will continue to support, promote, and act toward creating a community grounded in civility, sustainable development patterns, environmental stewardship, and well-maintained supporting infrastructure.
Policies and investments in the Rural West and the Planned Service area in the east will respect and prioritize the natural environment, historic resources and agricultural heritage, diverse cultures and people, and established community character in an equitable, predictable, sustainable, and achievable way for generations to come. Commitments to renew, reinvest, or rebuild targeted areas of the County must be balanced with the infrastructure needed to support communities in a timely, and fiscally-responsible manner.
Ultimately, the General Plan’s relevance will be measured by its implementation. The County is committed to making this vision and its supporting principles a reality.
⬚ figure
⬚ figure
⬚ figure
⬚ figure
⬚ figure
⬚ figure
⬚ figure
⬚ figure