Note: The meeting agenda and transcript indicate the meeting was called on Tuesday, September 1, 2026, at 6:00 p.m. However, this summary uses the date provided in the instruction (2026-09-02).
This regular meeting of the Fairview Municipal Advisory Council (MAC) covered three main agenda items: an informational update on affordable housing production policies, and two site development review action items for new housing in the Fairview area. The council also received public comments from community members, a CHP officer, and county staff, and approved the July 2026 minutes with a correction.
Presenters: Angelica Gonzalez (Assistant Planning Director), Olivia Ortiz (Planner III), Rick Jacobis (Street Level Advisors)
Staff presented an update on two proposed policies: inclusionary zoning (requiring affordable units in market-rate developments of 11+ units) and expanded ministerial approval (streamlined staff-level approval for projects meeting objective standards). A financial feasibility analysis showed that rental housing is currently unfeasible in unincorporated Alameda County, even without affordable requirements, while for-sale housing has some capacity for modest affordable requirements. The presenters suggested a phased implementation, prioritizing 50-60% AMI for rental and 80-100% AMI for ownership, with the option to pay in-lieu fees. Ministerial approval would be offered as a bonus for projects providing deeper affordability.
Council Discussion: Members expressed significant concerns about ministerial review, citing past experiences of developer errors (e.g., traffic studies, soil reports) that were caught by the community. They emphasized that removing local review processes undermines community trust and the purpose of the MAC. Vice Chair Rhodes noted the council did not support the previous housing element (6th cycle) partly due to ministerial review. Chair Filbin questioned the accountability of in-lieu fees, referencing past issues with park fees. Members asked for data on how in-lieu fees have been spent in the county and sought evidence of mobile home parks as an affordable housing option. Councilmember Higgins questioned why Fairview is grouped with the Eden General Plan, which has more urban standards.
Presenter: Aubrey Rose, Alameda County Planning Department
Proposal: Construction of a new 1,698 sq ft one-story, one-bedroom, one-bath home with a 516 sq ft attached two-car garage on a 1.77-acre downslope lot. The lot is conforming (grandfathered from pre-1975 zoning that required 5 acres). The project meets all development standards and requires fire sprinklers. No variances are needed. The staff recommended approval.
Public Comments: Jill Angel and Richmond Von Wave, both neighbors on Arbutus and Quercus Ct, expressed concerns about construction traffic damaging the narrow private roads (already in disrepair), staging of equipment, and future parking overflow. The applicant assured that six off-street parking spaces would be available (two in garage, four on-site) and that any road damage would be repaired by the contractor.
Council Discussion: Councilmember Higgins asked about the conforming lot status and visited the site. Council asked clarifying questions about road access and parking. No other concerns were raised.
Vote: Motion to approve as presented by Councilmember Farmer, seconded by Councilmember Higgins. Roll call: Farmer – yes, Higgins – aye, Rhodes – aye, Philbin – aye. Unanimous approval.
Presenter: Michael Fleming, Alameda County Planning Department
Proposal: Convert the existing first floor into an 813 sq ft ADU (with separate exterior entrance and kitchen), add 1,386 sq ft to the second floor (master suite, two additional bedrooms, office, kitchen/dining/living), 292 sq ft to the first floor (storage/utility), and an 860 sq ft three-car garage. Total building area is 3,265 sq ft plus garage, well under the maximum FAR. The project meets all development standards. Staff recommended approval.
Public Comments: Kathy Langley questioned the property's historical significance (claimed it was owned by the Bruchard family) and expressed suspicion about future development of the adjacent empty lot. She argued parking would be inadequate for a four-bedroom home. Helen Yang Fung (applicant) corrected that the property is not historic, the owner does not own adjacent land, and the family needs more space for their young son.
Council Discussion: Concerns centered on parking in the neighborhood, which is already congested due to nearby assisted living facility and school. Councilmember Higgins noted the large lot allows for ample off-street parking (e.g., 25-foot side setback, rear lot). Council clarified that the ADU is created by keeping the existing kitchen and adding a separate entrance, which is an innovative way to provide additional housing. Fire sprinklers are required; water pressure concerns from a previous development are not relevant here as it's a single home on an existing water line.
Vote: Motion to approve as submitted by Councilmember Farmer, seconded by Vice Chair Rhodes. Roll call: Farmer – yes, Higgins – aye, Rhodes – aye, Philbin – aye. Unanimous approval.
Ladies and gentlemen, I would like to call this evening's meeting of the Fairview Municipal, yeah, Fairview Municipal Advisory Council to order, and then I'll do this. May we may we have the roll. Council Councilmember Farmer. Here. Councilmember Higgins. Here. Vice Chair Rhodes. Here. Chair Filbin. Here, we have a quorum. Thank you. We will now you need to turn that off, please. Okay. Well, I did. About now. All right. Uh can we all please stand for the pledge of allegiance? All right. Good job, Ashley. Ready? Begin. I pledge allegiance to the flag. United States of America. I now like to open for public comment. Jimmy Dang. Oh, I'm sorry. Hold on. Um seeing none. Am I right? Seeing none? Uh no, we have no public comments for uh the roll call and the pledge. All right. Seeing none, I will close public comment. Actually, there's two up. So we have two forms of public comment. One on what we just did, and then the next one on items that are not on the agenda. So now I'm going to open public comment for items that are not on the agenda. Okay, so our first speaker is Jimmy Dang. Hello. Hi. Um thank you for allowing me to speak today. I just want to come and introduce myself to people who don't know who I am. My name is Jimmy Dang. I'm the general manager of Oraloma Sanitary District. I want to come and provide information about who we are. Uh and just so that you know, I left business cards on the table over there in case you guys have any questions about what we provide you. And what we do provide you is your sewer service and also your garbage recycling organic screen cart collection as well. Uh lots going on at the district. Uh recently we're going through elections now, so we recently went from at-large representation to districting. Uh that transition is happening currently.