OpenPublica

Accountability starts with access.

© 2026 · Filed for the public record

Use casesAboutAPIPrivacyTermsLinkedIn
Home/Alameda County, California/Board of Supervisors
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Sunol Citizens Advisory Council Meeting – September 17, 2026

Board of Supervisors — Thursday, September 17, 2026
BodyAlameda County, California
SessionBoard of Supervisors
DateThursday, September 17, 2026
StatusFILED
Video Record
0:00 / 1:26:39

Original source
Transcript — VerbatimClick a timed line to jump · ⧉ to share it
0:05

Okay.

0:05

So we're going to call the meeting to order on Wednesday, September 16th, 2026.

0:11

And there were agendas on the table there.

0:14

You may have picked it up when you came in.

0:25

Council Member Cone.

0:26

President Councilmember Harrison.

0:29

Councilmember McLean.

0:31

Here.

0:31

Council Member Star.

0:33

Character Range?

0:34

Yeah.

0:35

We have a quorum.

0:36

Thank you very much.

0:37

Okay, the first order of business is public comments.

0:41

And um, we have two people who have signed it for public comments.

0:44

We'll limit the time to two minutes.

0:47

And um, you have down public comment and all items.

0:52

Um, if you don't mind, we'd like to a card for each item for our.

0:57

Um, it turns out the county told me I don't have to.

1:01

Okay, well, we'll go back to the county then.

1:03

Okay, okay.

1:05

So public comments.

1:07

First one, Andrew.

1:17

Thank you, everybody, Andrew Turnbull from Sennol.

1:22

92 residents divided by 1.7 million residents in Alameda County.

1:33

Uh, how do we even get any attention?

1:37

But we do.

1:39

And one of the reasons we get attention is the excellent work of our Sonola Citizens Advisory Council.

1:47

I would specifically like to thank the SCAC for the way they handled the issue of the Caltrans tree issue that we had.

2:00

It was some of the most backbone that I've seen.

2:04

This group stand up to what was a horrible situation.

2:10

We heard Caltrans give all kinds of excuses, but yet the SCAC stood up.

2:18

The other thing I want to do in my one minute is thank mobile citizen and thank the people of Alameda County who respond to mobile citizen.

2:29

We had an issue where a SNO Glen Parent asked me to turn in a mobile citizen report on that crosswalk within one day, that was solved.

2:41

Good on Mr.

2:42

Rosen, what dozenbeck, Dr.

2:45

Woodesenbeck, and his entire organization for that kind of response in our little section in our little uh portion of Alameda County Heaven.

2:56

With the 22 seconds left, I want to say thank you to Caltrans for spectacular implementation of the freeway between here and um and Little Valley.

3:11

So there's an opportunity to say thank you, and there's an opportunity to say we're not putting up with it.

3:18

Thank you to the SCIC for standing your ground.

3:36

Uh good evening, Tom Pittman.

3:40

Uh the number one responsibility of any government agency is to protect its citizens.

3:47

We had a situation this week where phone service was again out for the majority of the residents on Killcare Road.

3:56

Nobody could call in, nobody could call out.

3:59

If an emergency were to occur, that individual would have been uh at risk.

4:07

This failed uh siren system that was tried is obviously of no impact because it's only in one place.

4:17

I would urge this council to proceed on establishing some means by which communication can be conducted.

4:26

Mr.

4:27

Scott Sanders has attempted to put uh antennas on various places.

4:33

I would urge you to pursue that, and possibly as opposed to spending money on what I consider failed septic proposals.

4:43

You could buy radios for every citizen kill here.

4:48

And I would secondly, I don't know who timed these lights here on Main Street or Corners, but if you try to leave this community in the morning, you cannot.

5:02

And uh time it needs to go back to school because it is a fiasco trying to get out of here in the morning.

5:11

I would urge you to recontact Cal Train.

5:16

Yeah, try to fix.

5:21

We're supposed to be some panacea that oh it's gonna solve the problem.

5:26

It's done nothing but create.

5:29

Thanks.

5:32

Tom, I'm assuming you're talking about getting from Main Street on to 84 in the morning.

5:39

Uh yes, okay.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Procedural███████████████████████23%
Public Comment██████████████████18%
Community Engagement██████████████████18%
Historic Preservation█████████████13%
Parks and Recreation█████████9%
Public Safety██████6%
Traffic Safety███3%
Emergency Management███3%
Environmental Protection███3%
Summary of Proceedings

Sunol Citizens Advisory Council Meeting – September 17, 2026

(This meeting was originally scheduled for September 16, 2026 per the agenda and transcript, but the provided timestamp indicates September 17, 2026. The summary uses the given date.)

The Sunol Citizens Advisory Council (SCAC) met on September 17, 2026, to receive law enforcement and fire reports, discuss progress on downtown revitalization and wayfinding signs, consider a funding request from the Sunol Business Guild, review Caltrans' response to community concerns, and honor Fenestra Winery's 50th anniversary.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Andrew Turnbull thanked the SCAC for standing up to Caltrans on the tree issue, praised the quick response from Mobile Citizen for a crosswalk repair, and also thanked Caltrans for freeway improvements.
  • Tom Pittman raised concerns about repeated phone service outages on Killcare Road, urging the council to pursue communication alternatives (e.g., radios or antennas). He also criticized traffic light timing on Main Street and requested recontacting Caltrans.
  • Kelly A. Bruce commented on traffic light programming issues observed elsewhere, urged the council to verify project outcomes via satellite imagery, and reminded attendees of the Hotlock picnic on Saturday.

Discussion Items

  • Law Enforcement Report (Sgt. Franco, ACSO): Since July 15, 2026, deputies responded to 135 calls in Sunol, conducted 97 traffic stops, and handled a small fire and an incident on Niles Canyon (subject under influence in wheelchair). No major incidents. Franco noted a planned Caltrans closure on September 26-27 and coordinated notification.
  • CHP Report (Officer Landers): Low staffing levels and upcoming transfers will reduce presence; officer asked community to report issues and they will respond as able. Traffic light timing on Main Street was again flagged.
  • Fire Report (Chief Terra, ACFD): From July 1 to September 16, Station 14 handled 101 calls: 48% medical, 13% fires, 39% other. New federal reporting system (NERUS) delayed data. Defensible space rule changes pending.
  • Progress Reports:
    • Fire Safety Workgroup: No update.
    • Tree Advisory: Jim O’Laughlin unavailable; need volunteer. Planning department workshop on trees in unincorporated areas announced.
    • Downtown Revitalization Workgroup: Wayfinding signs in production; community voting on nameplates for two signs (at Foothill/Killcare and Main/Bond). Third sign at Main/84 delayed until construction finishes. Restrooms: Design made period-appropriate (1920s) using salvaged tiles from depot roof, coordinated with Niles Canyon Railway.
  • Proclamation: SCAC presented a proclamation to the Replogle family honoring Fenestra Winery’s 50 years of leadership in the Livermore Viticultural Area and Sunol. Family members spoke and thanked the council.
  • Funding Request ($1,000 from Community Improvement Fund for Sunol Business Guild’s Stroll in Sunol): Veena Rossler reported the event sold over 200 tickets, netting about $5,000. Several public comments opposed the request, arguing the fund was intended for physical infrastructure. Council debated semantics of “project” vs “physical improvements.” A motion to approve passed 4-1 (Councilmember Start opposed). The council noted approval with encouragement to contribute to park improvements.
  • Caltrans Response (Item 4C): Chair DeGrange summarized the 122-page response as dismissive—self-certifying “no effect” on cultural resources, ignoring concerns about traffic signal systems, heritage oak tree, and proposing a 42-inch concrete barrier at the Water Temple gate. Council members expressed frustration and recommended escalating to state legislators (Senator McDermott, Assemblymember Lee) and possibly involving Alameda Creek Alliance. No formal action taken, but next steps include contacting representatives.
  • Wayfinding Signs Location (Item 4D): Benjamin Harrison reported community voting results: top nameplates are Little Brown Church, Bosco statue, Elliston, and Sunol Train Depot. Signs will be placed at two locations; third location pending construction completion.

Key Outcomes

  • Funding Approved: $1,000 from the SCAC Community Improvement Fund to the Sunol Business Guild for the Stroll in Sunol event (vote 4-1).
  • Wayfinding Signs: Top five nameplates selected; signs to be installed at Foothill/Killcare and Main/Bond. Third sign deferred.
  • Caltrans Escalation: Council will contact state representatives (Senator McDermott, Assemblymember Lee) and explore legal options regarding Caltrans’ treatment of historical resources.
  • Minutes Approved: The minutes of July 15, 2026, were approved unanimously.
  • Adjournment: Meeting adjourned in memory of Al Ducharm, a volunteer at Sunol Depot Gardens.

Note: Date discrepancy – agenda and transcript state September 16, 2026; however, the provided timestamp indicates September 17, 2026. The summary uses the given date.

Meeting Transcript

Okay. So we're going to call the meeting to order on Wednesday, September 16th, 2026. And there were agendas on the table there. You may have picked it up when you came in. Council Member Cone. President Councilmember Harrison. Councilmember McLean. Here. Council Member Star. Character Range? Yeah. We have a quorum. Thank you very much. Okay, the first order of business is public comments. And um, we have two people who have signed it for public comments. We'll limit the time to two minutes. And um, you have down public comment and all items. Um, if you don't mind, we'd like to a card for each item for our. Um, it turns out the county told me I don't have to. Okay, well, we'll go back to the county then. Okay, okay. So public comments. First one, Andrew. Thank you, everybody, Andrew Turnbull from Sennol. 92 residents divided by 1.7 million residents in Alameda County. Uh, how do we even get any attention? But we do. And one of the reasons we get attention is the excellent work of our Sonola Citizens Advisory Council. I would specifically like to thank the SCAC for the way they handled the issue of the Caltrans tree issue that we had. It was some of the most backbone that I've seen. This group stand up to what was a horrible situation. We heard Caltrans give all kinds of excuses, but yet the SCAC stood up. The other thing I want to do in my one minute is thank mobile citizen and thank the people of Alameda County who respond to mobile citizen. We had an issue where a SNO Glen Parent asked me to turn in a mobile citizen report on that crosswalk within one day, that was solved. Good on Mr. Rosen, what dozenbeck, Dr. Woodesenbeck, and his entire organization for that kind of response in our little section in our little uh portion of Alameda County Heaven. With the 22 seconds left, I want to say thank you to Caltrans for spectacular implementation of the freeway between here and um and Little Valley. So there's an opportunity to say thank you, and there's an opportunity to say we're not putting up with it. Thank you to the SCIC for standing your ground. Uh good evening, Tom Pittman. Uh the number one responsibility of any government agency is to protect its citizens. We had a situation this week where phone service was again out for the majority of the residents on Killcare Road. Nobody could call in, nobody could call out. If an emergency were to occur, that individual would have been uh at risk. This failed uh siren system that was tried is obviously of no impact because it's only in one place. I would urge this council to proceed on establishing some means by which communication can be conducted. Mr. Scott Sanders has attempted to put uh antennas on various places. I would urge you to pursue that, and possibly as opposed to spending money on what I consider failed septic proposals.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com