OpenPublica

Accountability starts with access.

© 2026 · Filed for the public record

Use casesAboutAPIPrivacyTermsLinkedIn
Home/Alameda County, California/Board of Supervisors
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Alameda County Unincorporated Services Committee Meeting - October 29, 2026

Board of Supervisors — Thursday, October 29, 2026
BodyAlameda County, California
SessionBoard of Supervisors
DateThursday, October 29, 2026
StatusNEW · FILED
Video Record
0:00 / 1:34:41

Original source
Transcript — VerbatimClick a timed line to jump · ⧉ to share it

Speaker numbers apply only to this recording. Names come from transcript evidence. “Possibly” marks uncertain attribution.

Speaker 1

0:00

All right.

0:00

So good evening.

0:02

Let's get started.

0:03

Incorporated services meeting this evening.

0:06

Court want to take the roll.

Speaker 2

0:07

Supervisor Chan.

0:08

Present.

0:09

Supervisor Miley.

Speaker 1

0:10

Present.

Speaker 2

0:11

We have a quorum.

Speaker 1

0:12

Okay.

Unassigned speaker

0:12

Do

Speaker 1

0:13

we have to have any instructions?

Speaker 2

0:15

Stephen, can you give the instructions for a Spanish interpretation?

Speaker 3

0:34

Oh, if they abracy, I click in lackina con los tres puntos.

0:42

Selección interpretación.

0:44

Aga click in el idioma de escuchar que espanol.

0:47

Y después opcional is escuchar solo el idioma interpretado.

0:51

I got a click in silencial audio original.

Speaker 1

0:58

Thank

Unassigned speaker

0:59

you.

Speaker 1

1:01

Any other instruction?

1:02

Okay.

Speaker 2

1:04

For in-person participation, the meeting site is open to the public.

1:07

If you'd like to speak on an item, fill out a speaker's card at the table and hand it to the clerk for remote participation.

1:15

Follow the teleconferencing guidelines.acgov.org and use the raise your hand function.

Speaker 1

1:23

Right.

1:25

First item this evening is a potential minimum wage ordinance.

1:30

And we'll start with Eileen Dalton.

Speaker 3

1:33

And this is the interpreter.

1:35

Can I get put in the interpreter channel?

Speaker 2

1:38

Yes.

Unassigned speaker

2:05

Okay.

Eileen Dalton · Speaker 4Inferred

2:31

Good evening, everyone.

2:32

I'm Eileen Dalton.

2:33

I'm with the Alameda County Community Development Agency, the director of economic and civic development.

2:40

Tonight we will be providing a presentation on the proposed ballot measure for a minimum wage.

3:00

This is the same PowerPoint and presentation that was provided to the board at their September 15th hearing.

3:07

Paul Peninger from BAE provided the presentation.

3:27

Just as a very brief reminder, there's a voter initiative for a $30 minimum wage in the form of an ordinance.

3:36

The board directed the county to prepare a uh an analysis of the ballot measure, which was concluded and then ultimately presented to the board on September 15th.

3:50

At the conclusion of the presentation, the board did direct the item to be placed on the next uh statewide ballot, which is currently scheduled for March of 2028.

4:02

It would go sooner if there is a ballot that is a statewide ballot that comes to the voters sooner.

4:09

Um the board also voted to refer the issue of exploration and potential uh preparation of a competing ballot measure around a minimum wage, and it would come to the unincorporated services.

4:24

So we're here tonight based on that board recommendation, and that we would work with the unincorporated services committee to bring back to the board either a competing measure or the results of the effort into that matter.

4:39

So that was based on the recommendation from September 15th.

Unassigned speaker

4:43

So I'll ask Chelsea to come up and give the presentation, and um then happy to take direction uh from the board on this matter.

Unassigned speaker

4:54

Thanks.

Chelsea Guerrero · Speaker 5Inferred

4:59

Good evening.

5:00

I'm Chelsea Guerrero, Director of Research at BAE Urban Economics, and I'm here to provide this presentation that you heard from Paul Peninger last month.

5:09

Again, can you go to the next slide?

Unassigned speaker

5:13

Next one.

Chelsea Guerrero · Speaker 5Inferred

5:15

Oops, back, sorry.

Unassigned speaker

5:19

So

Chelsea Guerrero · Speaker 5Inferred

5:19

as you all know, BAE was retained to prepare an impact analysis for this proposed measure.

5:26

Our study did not provide policy or legal recommendations.

5:29

We were really focused on evaluating economic and fiscal impacts.

5:34

As directed by the board, we evaluated four different categories of impacts, the first being fiscal impacts to the county's budget.

5:42

We also looked at economic impacts to businesses, employees, and consumers.

5:47

We looked at other impacts of concern to the board, including impacts on nonprofits, collective bargaining agreements, and family child care providers.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Minimum Wage███████████████████████████████████35%
Transportation Safety█████████████████████21%
Public Comment█████████9%
Public Engagement█████████9%
Public Safety███3%
Public Transportation███3%
Community Engagement███3%
Active Transportation███3%
Procedural██2%
Summary of Proceedings

Alameda County Unincorporated Services Committee Meeting

Note: The meeting agenda and transcript list this meeting as Wednesday, October 28, 2026, but the provided timestamps indicate it took place on Thursday, October 29, 2026. This summary uses the date from the provided metadata.

The Unincorporated Services Committee, chaired by Supervisor Nate Miley with Supervisor Lena Tam, met to receive public comment and take action on two major items: a proposal for a voter-initiated minimum wage ordinance and the draft Bay Fair Community-Based Transportation Plan (CBTP). Both items received unanimous votes from the committee.

Minimum Wage Ordinance Discussion

  • The committee heard a detailed presentation from Eileen Dalton of the Community Development Agency and Chelsea Guerrero of BAE Urban Economics on the economic and fiscal impacts of a voter initiative that would raise the minimum wage to $30 per hour in unincorporated Alameda County. The presentation, previously given to the full Board of Supervisors, projected significant costs, including $33 to $34 million annually in direct county personnel and facility costs, largely because the measure applies to public agencies, a feature not found in similar ordinances in other counties like Los Angeles and San Mateo.
  • Consultants noted risks including potential business relocation to neighboring cities like Hayward or San Leandro, negative impacts on nonprofits and childcare providers (citing fixed budgets and Measure C revenue constraints), and difficulties attracting new businesses. The measure's unique application to county-leased properties in incorporated areas was also highlighted as a legal and operational concern.
  • Supervisors Miley and Tam expressed hesitation about the broad impacts of the ballot initiative, particularly its effect on the county's budget, which recently closed a $185 million deficit, and on social service nonprofits. They discussed the need to align with neighboring cities to avoid competitive disadvantages for local businesses.

Public Comments on Minimum Wage

  • Warren Cushman (unincorporated community leader) expressed the need for a full and open community engagement process to avoid voter confusion.
  • Nara Dalwaka raised concerns about the heavy unintended consequences for social service agencies and small business franchisees, as well as restaurants.
  • Diane Widley (San Lorenzo) highlighted the potential hardship on fixed-income seniors and homeowners associations.

Bay Fair Community-Based Transportation Plan (CBTP)

  • Angelica González (Assistant Planning Director) and Molly Sun (Fair and Pierce) presented the draft CBTP, a collaborative plan between Alameda County and the City of San Leandro. The plan was funded by a $350,000 grant from the Alameda CTC and involved extensive community engagement, gathering input from approximately 440 community members.
  • The plan recommends projects in seven categories: safer neighborhood/school streets, safe routes to Bay Fair BART, I-580 crossing improvements, complete streets on major corridors, sidewalk gap closures, bus stop improvements, and a transit/street ambassador program.
  • Discussion focused on the lack of full funding for several key projects (e.g., the East Bay Greenway multimodal project still awaiting construction funding) and the importance of the plan as a framework to pursue future grants and align with other county efforts like the Transit Oriented Communities policy.
  • Public speakers Warren Cushman (steering committee member) and Michael C. Williams (HARD Trails Program Manager) praised the robust, inclusive, and collaborative planning process as a model for multi-jurisdictional work. Diane Widley supported the ambassador program and raised concerns about accommodating newer forms of personal transportation.

Public Comments on Non-Agendized Items

  • A speaker representing environmental groups (Save Sky West, local food sovereignty) advocated for preserving open space and integrating ecological oases into transportation corridors.
  • Aaron Panfilio (Alameda County Fire) provided an update on El Niño weather preparedness, listing specific sandbag locations at the Public Works yards in Dublin and Hayward, and Fire Stations 6 and 14.

Key Outcomes

  • Minimum Wage Ordinance: The committee unanimously voted to direct county counsel and the Economic Development Department to develop a competing minimum wage ballot measure for the March 2028 election. Chair Miley announced the formation of an ad hoc working group to provide input on the alternative measure. Staff is scheduled to report back on the process and timeline on January 27, 2027.
  • Bay Fair CBTP: The committee unanimously voted to forward the draft Bay Fair Community-Based Transportation Plan to the full Board of Supervisors for adoption. The public comment period for the draft plan ends on November 2, 2026.

Meeting Transcript

All right. So good evening. Let's get started. Incorporated services meeting this evening. Court want to take the roll. Supervisor Chan. Present. Supervisor Miley. Present. We have a quorum. Okay. Do we have to have any instructions? Stephen, can you give the instructions for a Spanish interpretation? Oh, if they abracy, I click in lackina con los tres puntos. Selección interpretación. Aga click in el idioma de escuchar que espanol. Y después opcional is escuchar solo el idioma interpretado. I got a click in silencial audio original. Thank you. Any other instruction? Okay. For in-person participation, the meeting site is open to the public. If you'd like to speak on an item, fill out a speaker's card at the table and hand it to the clerk for remote participation. Follow the teleconferencing guidelines.acgov.org and use the raise your hand function. Right. First item this evening is a potential minimum wage ordinance. And we'll start with Eileen Dalton. And this is the interpreter. Can I get put in the interpreter channel? Yes. Okay. Good evening, everyone. I'm Eileen Dalton. I'm with the Alameda County Community Development Agency, the director of economic and civic development. Tonight we will be providing a presentation on the proposed ballot measure for a minimum wage. This is the same PowerPoint and presentation that was provided to the board at their September 15th hearing. Paul Peninger from BAE provided the presentation. Just as a very brief reminder, there's a voter initiative for a $30 minimum wage in the form of an ordinance. The board directed the county to prepare a uh an analysis of the ballot measure, which was concluded and then ultimately presented to the board on September 15th. At the conclusion of the presentation, the board did direct the item to be placed on the next uh statewide ballot, which is currently scheduled for March of 2028. It would go sooner if there is a ballot that is a statewide ballot that comes to the voters sooner. Um the board also voted to refer the issue of exploration and potential uh preparation of a competing ballot measure around a minimum wage, and it would come to the unincorporated services. So we're here tonight based on that board recommendation, and that we would work with the unincorporated services committee to bring back to the board either a competing measure or the results of the effort into that matter. So that was based on the recommendation from September 15th. So I'll ask Chelsea to come up and give the presentation, and um then happy to take direction uh from the board on this matter. Thanks. Good evening. I'm Chelsea Guerrero, Director of Research at BAE Urban Economics, and I'm here to provide this presentation that you heard from Paul Peninger last month.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com