OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Budget and Finance Committee Meeting on R80 Financial Analysis - July 15, 2026

Meeting PortalWednesday, July 15, 2026
BodyAllentown, Pennsylvania
SessionMeeting Portal
DateWednesday, July 15, 2026
StatusFILED
Video Record
0:00 / 19:39

Transcript — Verbatim
1:02

No, that's where we're working on it, right?

1:05

Where's the one?

1:07

Where's the one?

1:13

Oh, you open uh space test.

1:28

No, okay.

1:29

One is proclamation and the other one is citation.

1:38

Uh by controller, I always although I've not had a citation for the positive thing.

1:47

I might do it to you.

1:48

I'll do it to chat.

1:50

No.

1:58

I think that's the one that's moving around.

2:11

Yeah.

2:13

So public works is up by the version.

2:20

Right with these case.

2:21

I am I'm probably gonna bring my control too because I have no starting.

2:24

The microphone is already on there.

2:26

There's a little button there.

2:29

It's already bringing like on and so I want to put it over here.

2:33

No, you don't have a whole engine.

2:35

Just let you know it's already on.

2:38

Okay.

2:40

All right.

2:41

We will get started with the budget and finance committee meeting for today.

2:46

Thank you all for being here.

2:48

Um so the main thing on our agenda is the discussion on R eighty.

2:53

Uh Mr.

2:54

Clerk, do you mind giving us a roll down of R eighty?

2:58

Uh R eighty authorizes the expenditure of council funds for an independent five-year financial analysis and providing for the temporary deferral of certain capital projects pending completion of the analysis.

3:13

Thank you.

3:14

Um so I know this was referred to the committee.

3:17

Uh I I guess I'll let council person uh vendor uh kind of introduced some of the thought process behind this and uh, you know, as a committee we can kind of review some of the thoughts and and the exploration that's been done today.

3:30

Thank you, Council Person Bongo.

3:32

So, yeah, the the goal of this resolution is really to evaluate well, evaluate is probably the wrong word.

3:38

Um to take in all of the um unknown expenses that we have that have um kind of popped up.

3:46

We have uh potential for a um uh a police draw program, we have a potential for other fees that we might be losing, as well as we have a whole bunch of capital expenditures.

3:56

And the thought process in this is to say, okay, let's take a moment here, have someone go through and and and gather all that data, put it together and present it in a way that we can have someone outside of our org look at it and say, yes, this seems like we're in a in a good place, or maybe we need to you know evaluate what sort of things we can proceed with from a capital perspective, um and just kind of just take all that data in and and and kind of do a health check, I think is is what that is.

4:21

So the point of this is to say, all right, let's let's pause here for a second on some of our large projects and let's have a third party just do an evaluation.

4:30

Now I know that we we outlined the uh cost in this uh for a not to exceed twenty-five thousand dollars.

4:36

Um this is a very scoped um uh review of this.

4:42

It is not gonna be I with that with that um budget item, there's not gonna be like there's a limit how much we can do both in um the scope of the of the agency doing this as well as we're bound by our timeline right now because we want to make sure we get this data in before uh budget season when we have to make some decisions.

5:01

So thought is this is to work um well with uh the finance department um to gather that data, take it, um, evaluate and then present back to us prior to uh budget time.

5:12

Um I don't think that they gave us an exact did they give us an exact time when they were looking to return by if we execute this?

5:20

We so Bita would remember we did talk about the April timeline, did we?

5:26

Yes, so the uh we had a conversation uh last week, and there um the uh uh firm Maroduso um is willing to work with us and provide this within the timeline um that would give you enough information to make decisions.

5:44

Okay.

5:44

So within within our um in other scope of work, uh we will provide the information they request, and they would provide the product with within the time frame, so it will be enough time um for you to help you and assist you in making decisions.

6:01

Okay, thank you.

6:02

So, yeah, I mean that's that's the frame of this.

6:05

It's trying to be pretty narrow in what it's what its uh focus and scope is, but it's really just to provide us with uh some meaningful information based on a lot of the new uh things that have come up since uh since this was evaluated last uh last fall.

6:18

Okay, thank you, Council Persian Binder.

6:20

Oh, Council Person.

6:21

Yeah, no, I'm glad that you put this forward because um I think at least for my perspective, um these in case I spit as I speak.

6:30

Um it seems like sometimes we have like there's a fire station, there's a police station, then there's parts and wreck, and then there's it's like a lot that happens and it happens like not in silos, but just at like various times, and it's hard sometimes to see the big picture, and then look at like okay, the interest rate for this loan versus and then the interest rate for this loan in five years and ten years, and just kind of looking at it from a big picture how everything works together, especially if we are asked once again to raise taxes.

7:05

Um it'd be great to be able to say to constituents, hey, yeah, raising taxes, and this is what you're getting for that, and this is how much money it's gonna cost.

7:13

So if your taxes are going up $2 or whatever, that that $2 is gonna contribute to these specific projects and be able to really paint a clear picture to people instead of just making vague statements, hey, we've got to raise your taxes so you can continue to get services.

7:30

No, specifically, this is what we need to do.

7:33

Um, so yeah, I think that would be helpful.

7:36

And again, just to have like a very um clear visual, like here's everything, here's the thing that we want to do, but we're not sure if we can do it, like that that would be cool.

7:49

I I completely agree with you.

7:52

I think definitive um that this funding is supporting this project is I think what you are saying, and that um brings clarity, transparency uh for us, for you, for taxpayers.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Fiscal Sustainability█████████████████████████████████████████████64%
Budget Equity Analysis███████████████22%
Procedural██████████14%
Summary of Proceedings

Budget and Finance Committee Meeting on R80 Financial Analysis - July 15, 2026

The Budget and Finance Committee met on July 15, 2026, to discuss Resolution R80, which authorizes the expenditure of up to $25,000 from council funds for an independent five-year financial analysis and provides for the temporary deferral of certain capital projects pending completion of the analysis. The committee unanimously voted to forward the resolution to the full council.

Discussion Items

  • Council Person Binder introduced the resolution, explaining that the goal is to evaluate unknown expenses that have recently arisen, including a potential police draw program, other possible fee losses, and numerous capital expenditures. The analysis would be performed by an outside firm (Maroduso) to provide a third-party health check of the city's finances, with a narrow scope and a timeline aimed at delivering results before budget season.
  • Council Person Garlok expressed support, noting that the analysis would help the council see the big picture of projects like fire stations, police stations, and parts and wreck, and would allow the council to clearly explain to constituents why tax increases are needed and what they would fund.
  • Council Person Bongo emphasized that the analysis would bring clarity and transparency for the council and taxpayers, and that the data would be provided by the finance department but presented in a different manner.
  • The Director of Finance (identified as Bita) confirmed that the firm Maroduso is willing to work within the timeline to provide information for decision-making. The Director also noted that the analysis would incorporate both capital and operational expenses, including healthcare cost trends (projected 9–12% increase) and other unexpected costs.
  • Council Person Binder clarified that the $25,000 cost would come from the council's own budget line item, not from other city funds.
  • The committee discussed that the engagement letter would be drafted and signed by the City Controller (Santo) before any expenditure, and that the deliverable would include Excel worksheets to allow for future adjustments (e.g., incorporating Supreme Court decisions on stormwater fees).

Key Outcomes

  • The committee voted unanimously (all in favor, aye) to forward Resolution R80 to the full council for approval.
  • The resolution authorizes up to $25,000 from council funds for an independent five-year financial analysis by Maroduso, with a temporary deferral of certain capital projects until the analysis is completed.
  • The engagement letter will specify the scope and deliverables, including Excel worksheets, to be provided before budget season.

Meeting Transcript

No, that's where we're working on it, right? Where's the one? Where's the one? Oh, you open uh space test. No, okay. One is proclamation and the other one is citation. Uh by controller, I always although I've not had a citation for the positive thing. I might do it to you. I'll do it to chat. No. I think that's the one that's moving around. Yeah. So public works is up by the version. Right with these case. I am I'm probably gonna bring my control too because I have no starting. The microphone is already on there. There's a little button there. It's already bringing like on and so I want to put it over here. No, you don't have a whole engine. Just let you know it's already on. Okay. All right. We will get started with the budget and finance committee meeting for today. Thank you all for being here. Um so the main thing on our agenda is the discussion on R eighty. Uh Mr. Clerk, do you mind giving us a roll down of R eighty? Uh R eighty authorizes the expenditure of council funds for an independent five-year financial analysis and providing for the temporary deferral of certain capital projects pending completion of the analysis. Thank you. Um so I know this was referred to the committee. Uh I I guess I'll let council person uh vendor uh kind of introduced some of the thought process behind this and uh, you know, as a committee we can kind of review some of the thoughts and and the exploration that's been done today. Thank you, Council Person Bongo. So, yeah, the the goal of this resolution is really to evaluate well, evaluate is probably the wrong word. Um to take in all of the um unknown expenses that we have that have um kind of popped up. We have uh potential for a um uh a police draw program, we have a potential for other fees that we might be losing, as well as we have a whole bunch of capital expenditures. And the thought process in this is to say, okay, let's take a moment here, have someone go through and and and gather all that data, put it together and present it in a way that we can have someone outside of our org look at it and say, yes, this seems like we're in a in a good place, or maybe we need to you know evaluate what sort of things we can proceed with from a capital perspective, um and just kind of just take all that data in and and and kind of do a health check, I think is is what that is. So the point of this is to say, all right, let's let's pause here for a second on some of our large projects and let's have a third party just do an evaluation. Now I know that we we outlined the uh cost in this uh for a not to exceed twenty-five thousand dollars. Um this is a very scoped um uh review of this. It is not gonna be I with that with that um budget item, there's not gonna be like there's a limit how much we can do both in um the scope of the of the agency doing this as well as we're bound by our timeline right now because we want to make sure we get this data in before uh budget season when we have to make some decisions. So thought is this is to work um well with uh the finance department um to gather that data, take it, um, evaluate and then present back to us prior to uh budget time. Um I don't think that they gave us an exact did they give us an exact time when they were looking to return by if we execute this? We so Bita would remember we did talk about the April timeline, did we? Yes, so the uh we had a conversation uh last week, and there um the uh uh firm Maroduso um is willing to work with us and provide this within the timeline um that would give you enough information to make decisions. Okay. So within within our um in other scope of work, uh we will provide the information they request, and they would provide the product with within the time frame, so it will be enough time um for you to help you and assist you in making decisions. Okay, thank you. So, yeah, I mean that's that's the frame of this. It's trying to be pretty narrow in what it's what its uh focus and scope is, but it's really just to provide us with uh some meaningful information based on a lot of the new uh things that have come up since uh since this was evaluated last uh last fall. Okay, thank you, Council Persian Binder.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com