0:02Good evening, everyone.
0:03I'd like to call the uh regular council meeting for Monday, June 17th, 2024 to order.
0:08Would you all please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance and a moment of reflection?
0:42As you all know, we have a new system up here.
0:44The big screens do not have touch screen capabilities any longer.
0:47So if you need to speak, please hit the um right side button, and tonight will be uh voice votes only.
0:59Here councilmember Malone.
1:02Councilmember Nielsen.
1:04Councilmember Solario.
1:11Ron, item number two A, please.
1:16Mayor, actually, I'm going to turn it over to Councilmember White.
1:21Thank you so much, Mayor.
1:22Thank you so much, Mr.
1:24I will be doing our Juneteenth proclamation.
1:27Whereas on January 1st, 1863, President Abraham Lincoln signed the Emancipation Proclamation, granting freedom to all those who were enslaved.
1:37And whereas the news of freedom did not become an immediate reality for more than 250,000 enslaved black people of Texas.
1:46And whereas on June 19th, 1865, over two years after President Lincoln signed the Emancipation Proclamation, enslaved Gal Americans in Galveston, Texas finally received word that they were free from bondage.
2:01And whereas those who were formerly enslaved were recognized for the first time as citizens, and black Americans came to commemorate June 19th as Juneteenth, with celebrations across the country, building new lives and a new tradition that we honor today.
2:16And whereas on Juneteenth, we recommit ourselves to the work of equity, equality, and justice as we celebrate the centuries of struggle, courage, and hope that have brought us to this time of progress and possibility.
2:30And whereas on March 17th, 2016, Governor Doug Ducy signed HB 2226, sponsored by Representative Reginald Bolding, recognizing June 19th as Juneteenth Day in Arizona, making Arizona the 45th state to recognize Juneteenth as a state holiday, whereas Avondale officially recognized June 19th as the Juneteenth holiday as of our February 22nd, 2022 meeting, which represents one significant step amongst many in our 76-year history, which commits the city to eradicating racism against the descendants of former enslaved black Americans of African descent.
3:12Now therefore, I, on behalf of the entire city council of the City of Avondale, Arizona, do hereby proclaim June 19th, 2024 as Juneteenth, and encourage all Avondale residents to reflect upon the value of freedom and join in Juneteenth celebrations across the valley.
3:34Max, do you want to touch on just quickly to go along with that what we're doing for Juneteenth?
3:39Yes, we will be hosting our second annual uh Juneteenth um event right here at the amphitheater outside of our city hall chambers.
3:47So we invite everybody to come out.
3:51I believe Mayor Weiss will be there as well.
3:53I will be there, yep, with you and other council members and members of the city.
3:57And guys, I was just taking a look at something really interesting.
4:01Juneteenth is actually my anniversary for being in Avondale resident, my home.
4:05I closed on it on Juneteenth in 2008.
4:08Are you having everyone?
4:10Are you having everyone over to your house after to celebrate?
4:13Everyone goes we're going to be able to do that.
4:16We can head over there if you find it, you'll validate it and be there.
4:21I really appreciate that.
4:22And we look forward to seeing everybody out at Juneteenth this Wednesday.
4:26Um Marcella, any unscheduled public appearances?
4:29I don't have any cards.
4:31I have not received any requests to speak.
4:33Item number four is consent agenda.
4:34Are there any counselors who wish to have an item removed for separate consideration?
4:40Can you voice your motion and second?
4:45I have a motion from Councilmember White.
4:47A second from Councilmember Salario.
4:49All those in favor say aye.
4:55Do we like that better?
4:56Do we like that better?
5:02Ron, the next two items are going to be I'm guessing we done together.
5:06Mayor 5A and 5B will be presented by Andy, our director of human resources.
5:23Good evening, Mayor, Vice Mayor, and Council members.
5:25Before you tonight are proposed amendments to the city's Chapter 5 classification and compensation policy.
5:31And Chapter 6, employee benefits.
5:35To give some background regarding uh Chapter 5.
5:37So human resources really conducted uh recently conducted a review of Chapter 5, and opportunities were identified to realign chapter and policy language.
5:47Some of the chapter language is mainly operational and administrative in nature, and this level of detail is more appropriately addressed in an administrative policy with city manager approval.
5:57Administrative policies are dynamic and able to be modified to align with changing operational needs based on the foundational framework established by council in in chapters.
6:08So based on what I'm what I'm proposing, uh the this allows the city to be flexible and responsible and responsive to operational needs or market conditions that require new or enhanced classification and or compensation strategies.
6:22So our proposal associated with chapter five is to retain the foundational framework, which really includes and is reflective of council's philosophy and priorities associated with the city's classification and compensation program, which again will provide that that next level or that next step for the administrative policy.
6:41So we'll retain foundational framework related to the purpose of the classification plan, which includes definition and authority, the purpose of the compensation plan, which outlines the philosophy, the purpose objectives, establishing that an administrative policy would be created, and then the maintenance of the plan, which also makes reference to cost of living and merit pay increases as budget permits that that council has traditionally supported.
7:08We also recommend the addition of the following language, which really outlines the authority of the city manager.
7:14Um so allows for flexibility, uh establishing new or modifying existing compensation strategies based on operational needs or market conditions.
7:22And it's important to note that it it's everything that exists within the current budget.
7:26So it's not something that would go beyond the budget that's been approved by council.
7:30Anything like that would have to come back to council for discussion and approval.
7:35Um so anything related to modifications or or um modifying strategies would be within the current allocated budget for the city.
7:45Um and then we would transition the operational and administrative aspects of uh the language that's in the current chapter five to an administrative policy titled compensation.
7:55Um and I believe a copy of the proposed administrative policy was included in the agenda materials for council's reference.
8:01Um and then if council is supportive of this approach between chapters and administrative policies, uh the goal would be that HR would continue to review the remaining chapters and propose additional amendments for council approval kind of in the same vein or the same nature.
8:16Um so before I move forward with outlining chapter six, I'm gonna pause here to ask if there's any questions related to the chapter five amendments.
8:23Are there any questions from council on this?
8:25For me, I think this is a positive move.
8:27I think I think it gives city leadership the chance to make decisions when it comes to these items more quickly.
8:33There's times we might not have a meeting for two weeks or a month by the time we get on an agenda, and we're behind the eight ball at that point.
8:40So uh not seeing any objection.
8:42I think this is a a good move, and I think it puts us ahead of other cities in this.
8:45Can I get a motion on this item then?
8:48We have a motion from Councilmember Nielsen, a second from Councilmember Saloria.
8:53Actually, Mayor, I believe we have uh kind of a combined motion at the end.
8:57Is that is that right, Marcella?
8:59Yes, that is correct.
9:00We'll take the motions at the end.
9:02Um but I do have the motion screen.
9:04I just have it separately.
9:08So regarding chapter six, um, most of the proposed amendments are in preparation for the new benefits being offered for fiscal year 25.
9:14So uh previously we we had I had uh completed a presentation to council about paid parental leave, personal leave bank, public safety retention program, and some other um items that we would be rolling out for FY25 and subsequent administrative policies with city manager approval are being implemented specific to these topics.
9:32Um so in chapter six, we're just outlining that these are new um leave programs or new uh benefits that are being that that are being offered with really the the meat of the policy uh existing in an administrative policy.
9:47So the reference in chapter six would go back to an administrative policy that has more detail about the operational and administrative aspects of that policy.
9:54The one difference is um holiday leave.
10:00So currently holiday leave exists in chapter six and in an administrative policy, um, which increases the potential for inconsistencies and confusion.
10:05So an employee might look at a chapter uh at a chapter language and and not know that there's an administrative policy that exists that may have what we found is is there's some language open to interpretation when we have two areas that exist.
10:18Um so our recommendation is to really remove that holiday leave section from chapter six and really rely on the administrative policy.
10:25And so part of what we've provided for council's reference is what that administrative that revised administrative policy would look like as part of this change.
10:34And then there's just some other non-substantive updates that are being proposed to better clarify chapter six language.
10:40So there were just some wording things that we felt would be better as far as um enhancing clarity and and and what policy was intending to indicate as as part of chapter six.
10:55So uh our proposal is to add and revised language to chapter six, establishing the following for FY25.
11:00So pay parental leave, personal sick lead bank.
11:03Um we have the two programs for our police officers and sergeants, the sick leave sellback program and then sick leave compensation program for officers and sergeants upon retirement.
11:13Um we also modified language to um indicate that the benefits effective date for new employees would now be the first of the month following their higher date.
11:22Um we are proposing to remove holiday leave language and then again the details will exist in administrative policy and then implement the not some the non-substantive language revisions to add clarity.
11:33Um I believe again we're we're set to go.
11:37So if if this uh proposal is adopted, we have the administrative policies ready to implement for July 1.
11:46So on the screen there are the recommendations.
11:48Um again, I believe they have to be two separate motions.
11:53So any discussion on items uh uh A or B.
11:58So the first motion was uh Councilmember Nielsen, the second was from Councilmember Shallorio.
12:03Can I get a uh voice vote on that, Marcella?
12:07Councilmember Condi.
12:09Aye, Councilor Malone.
12:12Aye, Councilman Solario.
12:14Aye, Councilmember White?
12:15All right, Vice Mayor Paneda.
12:20Uh motion 1074-0624.
12:23Can I get a motion on that one, please?
12:26I have a motion from the Vice Mayor, a second from Councilmember White.
12:31Councilmember Conde.
12:39Councilmember White.
12:44So thank you, Council.
12:45Andy, Ron, thank you for all the hard work on that.
12:48Ron, next item, please.
12:51Next up, we have a presentation by uh Renee, our director of finance and budget, I believe will be our last piece of the puzzle for this next year's budget.
13:04Is that a little Renee?
13:06Good evening, that is true.
13:07Good evening, Mayor, Vice Mayor, and Council.
13:09I am here to present the fiscal year 2025 final budget.
13:16So the final budget did not change from what was last presented to council for the tentative budget.
13:22The total stayed the same at 443 million, 221,000 dollars.
13:28So as we've been um doing all along, we are keeping up with any changes from the last version.
13:35So in this final budget, the total didn't change, but we do have some revisions that took place within so a total of five.
13:43The first two are carryover adjustments for vehicle replacement and some um fire inspector services.
13:50What that means is that monies were appropriated in fiscal year 24 are being pushed into 25, and therefore we're making the adjustment in the final budget.
14:00The next one is just a funding change.
14:03So community development block grant monies are being appropriated to the old town Avondale project.
14:09And the last two are changes from department to department.
14:13So in the first case, from parks to marketing and from finance to the non-departmental.
14:20So any adjustment here was offset in the unanticipated revenue to ensure that the total budget limit did not change.
14:29I do want to point out along with the actual um budget documents, we do have some other documents.
14:35One being a final budget summary, this is the narrative that was attached.
14:39We did it for the tentative and updated it for the final.
14:42The others are administrative awards over 50,000.
14:45This is for procurement to give them the authority to execute contracts and such in the new fiscal year.
14:51Some schedules for interfund transfers and loans, as well as the five-year capital improvement plan.
15:00So with that, our recommendation is to conduct a public hearing for the fiscal 2025 final budget to adjourn from the regular council meeting and convene in a special council to take action on resolution 1056-0624, setting forth the final budget for fiscal year 2024-2025.
15:20Let me go ahead and open up this for the public hearing.
15:22Is there anybody in the audience or online who'd like to speak on this issue?
15:26I have not received any request to speak.
15:28Thank you, Marcella.
15:28With that being noted, I'm going to go ahead and close the public hearing.
15:31Open up to council for any questions or comments.
15:33I'd like council to note on this.
15:35When you look at the budget from this year to last year, it's actually 22 million dollars less than it was last year.
15:40Um and a significant part of that, part of that, 179 million dollars was capital improvement projects, which is the commitment that council made to many years ago to catch up on those things.
15:50Um we have the aquatic center off our backs right now, but there's big projects that are coming forward, and um I'm glad that we took a very conservative approach to budgets.
15:59I see cities out there that are doing five to ten percent increases, um, and that that makes me nervous for them, but I'm very happy with this budget and where we're at right now.
16:07Ron, any comments on the budget at all?
16:09Was your second budget with us?
16:12No, uh again, a big thank you to uh Renee and I saw Rob there, Rob and the team and all the department directors.
16:19Also, in addition to that uh lower budget that uh one of the reasons we were able to accomplish so much was because almost every department, I think minus one, but I won't call out the fire by name, uh, gave back money from their budget, so had a fire ahead of uh reduction.
16:32I'm I'm sorry that was slipped.
16:36Um but he and him and I know the reasons, very valid reasons.
16:39He's absolutely a big team player.
16:41But um uh so every department gave back uh uh we cut over two million dollars from department operational expenses so that we could afford to program uh positions and priorities that council believed in and uh to meet the needs of our community, so it could be more uh appreciative and thankful to uh the whole uh leadership team in making this budget, and a lot goes to say by getting uh uh to council a lot of thank yous to council for clear direction, clear setting of priorities, uh putting our community first, and I'm grateful to to work in such a wonderful place.
17:14And I think when you look at this budget and you look at last year's budget, which which was also a very mild when you when you take inflation into account, I don't even think it was an increase.
17:23But you look at the what we've done this year with uh taking care of our employees, police and fire on pay raises the investments we've made in the city.
17:31I think this will pay off for councils going forward, especially in those lien years that are coming up in 26 and 27.
17:37So public hearing is closed.
17:39Um we're gonna have the we're gonna come back to this in about three minutes uh for a special meeting.
17:44So uh with that being said, um next item is the summary of current events from from us.
17:49Anything, council you guys want to update us on?
17:52Anything happening out there?
17:54Um today was my last meeting on the MAG Executive Committee.
17:58Uh so that was that was uh I've been on there for a while.
18:01I know I have my TPC meeting tomorrow.
18:05Are you who's taking over that role?
18:06Max, you're taking over that role for TPC going forward.
18:11Uh the MAG Transportation Policy Committee.
18:13So it goes hand in hand with what we do on RPTA.
18:16So tomorrow will be my last meeting on that board.
18:18I've been on that board since I was a council member.
18:20Um, but it's gonna be in really good hands, and I think Max brings that knowledge of how RPTA and TPC mesh together for cities.
18:30I just have one thing.
18:31Um, I wanted to thank city manager's office.
18:34Um, I had the opportunity to to attend um NLC summer meeting in Rancho Cordova, and I did convene with the Transportation and Infrastructure Policy Committee.
18:43So we're doing a lot of work trying to hone down how we make our policy statements, and really it was really great and refreshing to go visit Caltrans just to give you guys a heads up.
18:53Our um station right across the street.
18:57We won't even talk about it too much, but it looks much better than the Cal Trans dispatch area, um, much less our own police department.
19:04So you guys were kind of leaps and bounds way ahead of what they need in regards to dispatch actually.
19:09Caltrans and CHP and Sacramento share a dispatch area.
19:13So I know we have shared services here.
19:15Really won't go further than that, but it's really amazing.
19:17So thank you, council, for allowing me to sit in the space of transportation.
19:21I feel like I got the opportunity to learn a lot, see a lot, and safety is first.
19:25So when we talk about transportation, we'll make sure we keep that first here as well.
19:33All right, can I get a motion to adjourn?
19:37I have a motion from Councilmember Salario, a second from Councilmember Malone.
19:41All those in favor say aye.
19:46I'm going to go ahead and close the regular meeting.
19:48I'm going to go ahead and open up the special meeting.
19:50Marcella, do you mind doing roll call, please?
19:51Councilmember Condy here.
19:53Councilmember Malone.
19:55Councilmember Nielsen.
19:57Councilmember Solario.
19:59Councilmember White.
20:03Can I get a motion on resolution 1075-0624, please?
20:11It was a tie on second.
20:13Um a motion from Councilmember White, a second from Councilmember Solorio.
20:17I'm gonna do a roll call vote, Mayor.
20:19Councilmember Condi?
20:20Councilmember Malone?
20:22Councilmember Nielsen?
20:24Councilmember Solario?
20:25Councilmember White?
20:30Thank you, everyone.
20:31Our budget passes for this year, Renee.
20:39Can I get a motion to adjourn to executive session?
20:42I move we adjourn the executive session.
20:44All right, Mayor Max?
20:46Motion for Max, second from Mike, Marcella?
20:48All those in favor say aye.