OpenPublica

Accountability starts with access.

© 2026 · Filed for the public record

Use casesAboutAPIPrivacyTermsLinkedIn
Home/Battle Creek, Michigan/City Commission
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Battle Creek City Commission Meeting: Brownfield Plan, FOIA, and Ordinances - September 1, 2026

City Commission — Tuesday, September 1, 2026
BodyBattle Creek, Michigan
SessionCity Commission
DateTuesday, September 1, 2026
StatusFILED
Video Record
Meeting Thumbnail
⇩ GET FROM SOURCE

STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE

Original source
Transcript — Verbatim

Speaker numbers apply only to this recording. Names come from transcript evidence. “Possibly” marks uncertain attribution.

Speaker 1

5:56

Good evening and welcome to the city of Battle Creek, Michigan in the Battle Creek City Commission meeting.

6:01

We've been having some difficulties with our access vision hookup.

6:07

Are we okay tonight?

6:10

All right.

6:11

Very good.

6:12

This is our meeting for September 1st, 2026.

6:16

It is 7 p.m.

6:17

We thank everyone for being here tonight.

6:19

We're gonna start with a moment of silence for our invitation,

Unassigned speaker

6:23

and

Speaker 1

6:23

then we'll move into our pledge of allegiance.

6:25

I'll call upon Commissioner Patrick O'Donnell to lead us in the pledge.

6:29

Would you please stand for a moment of silence?

Unassigned speaker

6:44

A

Speaker 2

6:44

pledge of allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and history which is saying it's

Unassigned speaker

6:52

one

Speaker 3

6:52

nation under God.

Unassigned speaker

7:06

Thank

Speaker 1

7:06

you very much, Commissioner Patrick O'Donnell.

7:08

Next item on our agenda is roll call.

7:11

Madam Clerk, when you're ready.

Speaker 4

7:12

Commissioner Kotarski Smith?

7:14

Here.

7:14

Commissioner LaCos?

7:16

Yeah.

7:16

Commissioner Lance is running about six minutes late.

7:19

He'll be here.

7:20

Um Commissioner Morris here.

7:22

Mayor Bankey?

Speaker 5

7:24

Here.

Speaker 4

7:24

Commissioner Reynolds.

7:25

Present.

7:26

Commissioner O'Donnell?

Speaker 6

7:27

Here.

Speaker 4

7:28

Commissioner Simmons.

Speaker 1

7:31

Here.

Speaker 4

7:32

And Vice Mayor Sophia.

7:34

Here.

7:34

Thank

Unassigned speaker

7:35

you.

Speaker 1

7:36

And just so you know, Commissioner Simmons is participating in this meeting remotely.

7:41

Um not in the United States.

7:44

Next item on our agenda is chair noting any added or deleted resolutions?

Speaker 4

7:49

There were none.

Speaker 1

7:51

Next item is petitions, communications, and reports.

Speaker 4

7:54

We did receive two emails from people, and they were sent to all the commissioners.

Speaker 1

7:59

Thank you very much.

Speaker 4

8:08

This is a public hearing to receive comment on the Brownfield plan for the proposed the Fields at Battle Creek development project located within the city of Battle Creek at 15105 South Helmer Road.

Speaker 1

8:25

If you'd like to make public comment on the subject of this public hearing, then please raise your hand, and we will acknowledge you to come forward to the podium while you'll where you'll have three minutes to make your comment.

Speaker 7

10:00

I'm here today to express my opposition to the BCU proposal for subsidized apartments.

Speaker 8

10:09

We were invited to

Speaker 7

10:11

the first meeting where BCU was proposing the zoning ordinance change so that they could do their building.

10:19

There were a pretty good turnout, and the biggest concern was the possibility of subsidized housing.

10:27

We were told at the meeting not to worry, this development would be upscale.

10:33

I think they referred to it as a jewel in the crown of BCU properties.

10:40

And we were assured no subsidized housing would be built.

10:46

Here we are, that's the issue.

10:50

We were lied to.

Speaker 1

12:39

Thank you very much for your comments.

Unassigned speaker

12:40

Is

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Affordable Housing████████████████████████████████████36%
Public Engagement█████████████████17%
Transportation Safety█████████████13%
Procedural████████████12%
Public Safety████████8%
Fiscal Sustainability████4%
Technology and Innovation███3%
Community Engagement██2%
Environmental Protection██2%
Summary of Proceedings

Battle Creek City Commission Meeting Summary - September 1, 2026

The Battle Creek City Commission met on September 1, 2026, at 7:00 PM. The central focus of the evening was a public hearing and subsequent vote on Resolution 456, approving a Brownfield Plan for "The Fields at Battle Creek" development. Commissioners also voted on several other resolutions, including a contested FOIA request, introduced an ordinance amendment for a PILOT agreement, and heard extensive public comment on traffic safety, housing policy, and government surveillance.

Consent Calendar

  • The Consent Agenda was approved unanimously (9-0). It included the approval of the August 18, 2026 meeting minutes, the City Manager's Report, and Resolution 452 accepting a bid from Hunter-Prell Company for the Sidewalk Repair Program in an estimated amount of $92,551.00.

Public Hearing & Testimony: The Fields at Battle Creek

  • Opposition: A large group of residents from the surrounding neighborhoods (Jacaranda, Cherrywood, Huntington Hills) spoke in opposition to the Brownfield Plan for the 240-unit development at 15105 S. Helmer Road. Speakers including Jonathan Barnes, Dave Walters, Joe Harris, and others cited concerns over public safety, increased traffic near Lakeview High School, the density of the project, and the financial mechanisms involved. A prominent theme was that residents felt "duped" by prior outreach sessions where developers stated there would be no subsidized housing, whereas the current plan includes 48 income-restricted units.
  • Support: Kathy Antaya spoke in support, asserting that traffic is a normal part of city life and that the city is capable of managing resulting traffic issues.
  • Clarifications from Battle Creek Unlimited (BCU): John Hughes and Joe Sobieralski clarified that the project is income-restricted at 100-120% of Area Median Income (AMI), arguing it is workforce housing rather than subsidized low-income housing. They cited local salaries (starting teacher $48,257, police officer $63,000) to demonstrate the target demographic. They explained the Brownfield plan captures only the incremental increase in property taxes to reimburse the developer for eligible infrastructure costs, while base taxes continue to fund city services.

General Public Comments & Testimony

  • Flock Cameras (ALPRs): Laura Garbrech and Autumn Smith (candidate for City Commission) urged the city to terminate or strictly regulate its contract for Flock cameras, arguing the technology violates the Fourth Amendment and lacks independent evidence of crime reduction.
  • Meeting Process: Several residents, including David Moore, Joe Harris (candidate for City Commission), and John Kenefick, criticized the commission for not tabling the Brownfield resolution to allow for more thorough public input and due diligence.
  • Traffic & Safety: Tom Beuchler challenged the city to find innovative solutions for traffic congestion on Helmer Road.
  • Constituent Services: Sharlene Van Luven requested better follow-up from city staff on citizen inquiries and thanked the police department for their response.
  • Other: John Kenefick questioned the use of block grant dollars for New Level Sports. John Harper shared his history with the Community Leadership Academy and the city/township merger.

Discussion Items

  • Resolution 456 (The Fields at Battle Creek Brownfield Plan): The vote was 7-2 in favor.
    • Support: Commissioners O'Donnell and LaCosse argued the project brings needed workforce housing, utilizes state tools to fund infrastructure, and avoids a potentially worse development on the already-zoned land. Commissioner Simmons confirmed the project could proceed without the plan and that no Housing Commission vouchers were involved. City Manager Zimmerlin noted a traffic study showing 12,000 cars per day currently, with an anticipated increase of 1,400-2,000 trips.
    • Opposition: Commissioner Katsarsky-Smith argued the location and type of housing did not align with the city's recent Housing Strategy and noted the strong public opposition. She voted no, along with Commissioner Morris.
  • Resolution 457 (FOIA Partial Denial): The vote was 7-1 in favor.
    • Commissioners discussed the appeal of FOIA request 26-1592, which requested police reports and supplemental reports. City Attorney Kim confirmed all responsive records were provided with redactions. Public commenters argued the response lacked specificity regarding supplemental reports and proper legal certification. Commissioner Morris voted no.
  • Introduction of Ordinance 17-2026 (Liberty Commons PILOT): The commission voted unanimously to introduce an ordinance extending deadlines for the Liberty Commons Apartments project, allowing the developer more time to secure state LIHTC funding.
  • Resolutions 453, 454 (Lead Abatement & Radon Testing): Unanimously approved contracts totaling $516,760.33 for environmental assessment services and $107,500.00 for radon testing/mitigation for HUD lead hazard reduction programs.
  • Resolution 455 (Trommel Screen Purchase): Unanimously approved a $274,400.00 purchase for a portable trommel screen for the city's fleet department.

Key Outcomes & Decisions

  • The Fields at Battle Creek Brownfield Plan (Res 456): Approved (7-2). The plan for 240 units at 15105 S. Helmer Road will advance to state review and site plan approval. Developer noted the brownfield reimbursement was critical for the project's capital stack.
  • FOIA Request Upheld (Res 457): Approved (7-1). The partial grant/partial denial of FOIA request 26-1592 was affirmed.
  • Ordinance 17-2026 (PILOT): Introduced Unanimously. First reading given to extend the construction timeline for Liberty Commons Apartments by one year.
  • Contracts Approved: Environmental testing services ($516,760.33) and radon testing services ($107,500.00) were approved. Sidewalk repair bid ($92,551.00) was accepted. A Trommel screen purchase ($274,400.00) was authorized.
  • Meeting Adjourned: The meeting was adjourned at 9:08 PM.

Meeting Transcript

Good evening and welcome to the city of Battle Creek, Michigan in the Battle Creek City Commission meeting. We've been having some difficulties with our access vision hookup. Are we okay tonight? All right. Very good. This is our meeting for September 1st, 2026. It is 7 p.m. We thank everyone for being here tonight. We're gonna start with a moment of silence for our invitation, and then we'll move into our pledge of allegiance. I'll call upon Commissioner Patrick O'Donnell to lead us in the pledge. Would you please stand for a moment of silence? A pledge of allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and history which is saying it's one nation under God. Thank you very much, Commissioner Patrick O'Donnell. Next item on our agenda is roll call. Madam Clerk, when you're ready. Commissioner Kotarski Smith? Here. Commissioner LaCos? Yeah. Commissioner Lance is running about six minutes late. He'll be here. Um Commissioner Morris here. Mayor Bankey? Here. Commissioner Reynolds. Present. Commissioner O'Donnell? Here. Commissioner Simmons. Here. And Vice Mayor Sophia. Here. Thank you. And just so you know, Commissioner Simmons is participating in this meeting remotely. Um not in the United States. Next item on our agenda is chair noting any added or deleted resolutions? There were none. Next item is petitions, communications, and reports. We did receive two emails from people, and they were sent to all the commissioners. Thank you very much. This is a public hearing to receive comment on the Brownfield plan for the proposed the Fields at Battle Creek development project located within the city of Battle Creek at 15105 South Helmer Road. If you'd like to make public comment on the subject of this public hearing, then please raise your hand, and we will acknowledge you to come forward to the podium while you'll where you'll have three minutes to make your comment. I'm here today to express my opposition to the BCU proposal for subsidized apartments.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com