OpenPublica

Accountability starts with access.

© 2026 · Filed for the public record

Use casesAboutAPIPrivacyTermsLinkedIn
Home/Battle Creek, Michigan/City Commission
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Battle Creek City Commission Meeting Summary - November 10, 2026

City Commission — Tuesday, November 10, 2026
BodyBattle Creek, Michigan
SessionCity Commission
DateTuesday, November 10, 2026
StatusNEW · FILED
Video Record
0:00 / 2:05:43

Original source
Transcript — VerbatimClick a timed line to jump · ⧉ to share it

Speaker numbers apply only to this recording. Names come from transcript evidence. “Possibly” marks uncertain attribution.

Speaker 1

6:47

Good e good evening and welcome to the city of Battle Creek, Michigan, in the Battle Creek City Commission meeting for November 10th, 2026.

6:55

It is 7 o'clock PM.

6:56

We thank you for being here tonight, a very nice crowd.

7:00

We're gonna start with our invocation, and we're gonna have a moment of silence, and then I'm gonna call upon Commissioner Patrick O'Donnell to lead us in the pledge.

7:07

Would you please stand if you're able to for a moment of silence?

7:22

Commissioner Patrick O'Down.

Unassigned speaker

7:24

I

Speaker 2

7:24

pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America.

7:28

And to the Republic for which it stands.

7:31

One nation under God.

Unassigned speaker

7:40

Thank

Speaker 1

7:40

you, Commissioner Patrick O'Donnell.

7:43

Next item on our agenda is roll call.

7:45

Madam Clerk.

Speaker 3

7:46

Commissioner Katarski Smith.

7:48

Here.

7:48

Commissioner Lance?

7:49

Here.

7:50

Commissioner Morris?

7:51

Here.

7:51

Mayor Banke?

Speaker 2

7:52

Here.

Speaker 3

7:53

Commissioner Reynolds present.

7:55

Commissioner O'Donnell?

Speaker 2

7:56

Here.

Speaker 3

7:56

Commissioner Simmons.

Unassigned speaker

7:59

Here.

Speaker 3

8:00

And Vice Mayor Sophia.

8:03

Here.

8:03

Thank you.

Speaker 1

8:04

Thank you very much, uh, Madam Clerk.

8:06

Next item on our agenda is two proclamations.

8:09

First proclamation will be on diabetes awareness month.

8:13

And it's the World Diabetes Day.

8:15

And we're going to be getting some information from two individuals from the city of Battle Creek.

Unassigned speaker

8:19

And then

Speaker 1

8:20

secondly, we're going to have a proclamation for JV General Aviation Awareness Month.

Unassigned speaker

8:24

And

Speaker 1

8:25

we have a representative from the airport that will be uh assisting us on

Unassigned speaker

8:29

that.

Speaker 1

8:30

So I'll call the two individuals coming up first to the diabetes awareness month.

Speaker 3

8:48

Not yet.

8:50

It's close.

Speaker 1

8:53

Hi, how are you?

8:57

TR gonna give you the microphone first and tell us a little bit.

9:00

Uh don't be afraid not to uh give us some statistics.

9:05

So we better understand what we're dealing with here.

Unassigned speaker

9:09

Oh

T.R. Shaw · Speaker 4Inferred

9:10

good evening.

9:11

I'm T.R.

9:11

Shaw.

9:12

I'm uh with the Serial City Sunrise Rotary Club.

9:15

I also serve as a trustee of Lotary International's uh rotary action group for diabetes.

9:22

And uh this month, uh November is diabetes awareness month.

9:27

November 14th is World Diabetes Day, and uh that day is designated that for uh Dr.

9:35

Banting, who created who discovered insulin in 1920 and won the Nobel Prize in 1923 for uh making insulin uh widespread.

Unassigned speaker

9:46

Uh just uh quickly presently about 589 million adults worldwide, about twelve percent of the world population live with diabetes, and that number is expected to reach eight hundred and fifty-three million by twenty fifty.

T.R. Shaw · Speaker 4Inferred

10:01

Here in the United States, uh 29 million people have been diagnosed.

10:06

Uh that's about 30 percent of our population, and probably another 11 million uh are undiagnosed or don't know they have it yet.

10:15

So it is a growing, growing problem.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Public Safety██████████████████18%
Water And Wastewater Management████████████████16%
Economic Development███████████████15%
Public Engagement█████████████13%
Procedural███████████11%
Fiscal Sustainability████████8%
Technology and Innovation██████6%
Engineering And Infrastructure██████6%
Mental Health Awareness██2%
Summary of Proceedings

Battle Creek City Commission Meeting - November 10, 2026

The Battle Creek City Commission convened on November 10, 2026, at 7:00 PM in its City Commission Chambers, chaired by Mayor Mark A. Behnke. All commissioners were present. The meeting featured a presentation on the Flock camera system, a public hearing on a tax abatement for Geislinger Corp, the introduction of an ordinance to establish an Administrative Hearings Bureau, and public debate and votes on several resolutions, including the reinstatement of a $60 water shutoff fee.

Proclamations & Presentations

  • Proclamations were issued for Diabetes Awareness Month / World Diabetes Day (November 14) and for General Aviation Awareness Month. T.R. Shaw (Rotary) and Dorothy Bossey (Lions Club) promoted a community health walk and fair. An airport representative highlighted the economic role of the Battle Creek Executive Airport.
  • Police Chief Shannon Bagley, Captain Jim Martins, and Deputy Chief Doug Bagwell presented the Flock camera system. They described the system as capturing license plate data at 10 major entry/exit points, without facial recognition, audio recording, or cell phone monitoring. They stated all searches require a case number and a justification code, and that quarterly audits are conducted. A public transparency portal was announced. Commissioner discussion focused on the accountability of outside agencies accessing the data and potential misuse.

Consent Calendar

The consent agenda was approved unanimously. Items included the October 20, 2026 meeting minutes, the City Manager's report, the September 2026 ambulance report, and resolutions authorizing permanent easements to Consumers Energy Company at 78 Fountain Street (Resolution 496) and 28 Oak Street (Resolution 497).

Public Hearings

Geislinger Corp Industrial Facilities Tax Exemption

  • Jason Woodard (CEO, Geislinger Corp) expressed support for the 12-year tax abatement, detailing a $3.2 million investment and a 19,000 square foot facility expansion. He stated the average manufacturing wage is $27 per hour (10% above the local average), the company pays 90% of employees' health insurance premiums (above the state's 75% average), and the project will create at least 10 new jobs.
  • Autumn Smith expressed opposition, arguing the Michigan Constitution requires strict public financial analysis of the abatement's cost to taxpayers and municipal operations, which she claimed was not provided.
  • Elizabeth Garcia offered conditional support, requesting stronger accountability language and demographic reporting in the final agreement.
  • Joe Harris questioned the scheduling of construction before the public hearing and requested firm, verifiable job creation requirements.
  • Heather Eggnash (Battle Creek Unlimited) expressed support, emphasizing Geislinger's 25-year community investment and the appropriate use of state economic development tools.
  • Barry Wayne Adams and John Kennefic expressed opposition, with Adams citing constitutional prohibitions and Kennefic arguing the tax burden shifts to residents.

Public Comments & Testimony

Comments on Agenda Items

  • Will (Resolution 504) argued the commission engaged in a procedural "bait and switch" by voting on a FOIA appeal extension at an earlier meeting than communicated, undermining his right to petition.
  • John Kennefick, Joe Harris, and Brian (Resolution 499) expressed opposition or concern regarding the $60 "service processing fee" for water shutoffs, arguing it burdens struggling residents. Joe Harris proposed an "Easy Pay" installment model similar to Detroit's.
  • David (Resolution 499) expressed support for the fee, stating people should pay their bills.
  • Barry Wayne Adams (Ordinance 16-2026) expressed concern that the Administrative Hearings Bureau could become a revenue-generating tool.

General Public Comment

  • Shannon McCusky, Steve Koch, Joe Harris, and Barry Wayne Adams expressed opposition to the Flock camera system, citing Fourth Amendment privacy concerns, and referencing cases of misuse by other agencies and Flock itself, including an incident in Sheboygan, Wisconsin.
  • Autumn Smith delivered a farewell statement, criticizing the commission for lacking the courage to act on issues brought forward over 15 years.
  • Ryan criticized the quality of public sidewalk and road repairs.
  • John Kennefick criticized the city for not passing cost savings from automation on to citizens and for the cumulative impact of fee increases.

Discussion & Debate

Ordinance 16-2026 (Administrative Hearings Bureau)

  • The ordinance was introduced to establish an administrative process for addressing code enforcement matters such as blight, zoning, and property maintenance. It was approved for introduction (first reading).

Resolution 499 – Water Shutoff Service Fee

  • Commissioners extensively debated the $60 fee. Revenue Services Director Aaron Kuhn stated the fee is a renaming of a pre-COVID shutoff fee to clarify it covers administrative costs for managing the shutoff list, scheduling, and disconnection work, and is not a duplicate of the reconnect fee. Commissioner O'Donnell confirmed the fee was historically applied. Commissioner Simmons requested details on payment plan terms, with Kuhn stating 12-month, zero-interest plans are available and that the debt threshold for shutoffs is being reviewed upward from $25. Commissioner Morris stated she could not support the fee due to its impact on financially struggling families. Vice Mayor Sophia requested shutoffs not be scheduled on Fridays. The resolution passed 5-3.

Key Outcomes

  • Proclamations for Diabetes Awareness Month and General Aviation Awareness Month were formally issued.
  • Ordinance 16-2026 (Administrative Hearings Bureau) was introduced.
  • Consent Agenda approved, including easements for Consumers Energy.
  • Resolution 498 (Liquor License for Heritage Tower BC LLC) approved.
  • Resolution 499 ($60 Water Service Processing Fee) approved by a vote of 5-3.
  • Resolution 500 (Verona Pumping Station Check Valve Improvement, $456,413) approved.
  • Resolution 501 (ANYbodies Playground Bathroom Project, $599,900) approved.
  • Resolution 502 (Hydroexcavator purchase, $592,195.60) approved.
  • Resolution 503 (Corrected OPRA application for Watkins Development LLC) approved.
  • Resolution 504 (Partial grant of FOIA Appeal #26-2745) approved.
  • Commissioner Morris announced it would be her last meeting for at least four years.

Meeting Transcript

Good e good evening and welcome to the city of Battle Creek, Michigan, in the Battle Creek City Commission meeting for November 10th, 2026. It is 7 o'clock PM. We thank you for being here tonight, a very nice crowd. We're gonna start with our invocation, and we're gonna have a moment of silence, and then I'm gonna call upon Commissioner Patrick O'Donnell to lead us in the pledge. Would you please stand if you're able to for a moment of silence? Commissioner Patrick O'Down. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America. And to the Republic for which it stands. One nation under God. Thank you, Commissioner Patrick O'Donnell. Next item on our agenda is roll call. Madam Clerk. Commissioner Katarski Smith. Here. Commissioner Lance? Here. Commissioner Morris? Here. Mayor Banke? Here. Commissioner Reynolds present. Commissioner O'Donnell? Here. Commissioner Simmons. Here. And Vice Mayor Sophia. Here. Thank you. Thank you very much, uh, Madam Clerk. Next item on our agenda is two proclamations. First proclamation will be on diabetes awareness month. And it's the World Diabetes Day. And we're going to be getting some information from two individuals from the city of Battle Creek. And then secondly, we're going to have a proclamation for JV General Aviation Awareness Month. And we have a representative from the airport that will be uh assisting us on that. So I'll call the two individuals coming up first to the diabetes awareness month. Not yet. It's close. Hi, how are you? TR gonna give you the microphone first and tell us a little bit. Uh don't be afraid not to uh give us some statistics. So we better understand what we're dealing with here. Oh good evening. I'm T.R.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com