OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Belmont Public Safety Committee Meeting - September 26, 2024

City CouncilThursday, September 26, 2024
BodyBelmont, California
SessionCity Council
DateThursday, September 26, 2024
StatusFILED
Video Record

STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE

Transcript — Verbatim
0:29

I'll just take a motion.

0:36

Second.

0:37

Thank you.

0:38

On to general business.

0:40

And this is the Chiefs quarterly update.

0:42

Yes.

0:47

It's truly the Chief update.

0:50

Yes.

0:52

And now for the Chiefs.

0:55

Can you start playing with the pressure at all stage?

1:12

Okay.

1:13

First off, thank you for uh for having us here.

1:16

Uh for a quarterly meeting.

1:18

We'll jump right into it for the sake of time.

1:21

Uh over the last quarter, we promoted two people, Corporal Ed Berry, Mike Checky to the rank of corporal.

1:26

Uh both uh actually Ed Barry was promoted last year officially, but this was a swearing in.

1:32

And we appointed dispatcher Christy Wing, she's currently in training, completed the uh dispatch academy and is working our way through the dispatch uh program.

1:44

Also during that night, we recognize three individuals for their stellar performance over the last uh year.

1:50

Uh professional staff and put in the year, she's she is a public uh police record specialist, Natalie.

1:56

Uh our officer of the year, Michael Checky, who was also uh promoting the rank of corporal the same night.

2:02

So he brought home a lot of hardware, and then our volunteer of the year, Cindy Birch.

2:06

She's a volunteer.

2:07

If you read her resume on what she does, plus her uh plus our day job as an engineer, we'd be here forever.

2:16

The amount of time that she puts in as a as a volunteer is pretty fascinating.

2:20

And that was you know, each year, this is probably the hardest one to pick because of some of the work they do on our own time and uh true value to the community, uh to take away from the you know the work that's done, but it's just uh what she does on our own time.

2:35

It's just truly extraordinary.

2:38

Uh overview our training continue to you know, we had 690 hours of training in the last quarter.

2:43

That's on top of normal uh hours of uh the regular patrol and other functions within the police department.

2:50

Those are just a few of the ones that uh that are listed.

2:53

Um that's pretty standard uh operating training for us throughout the course of the year.

3:02

Slide.

3:03

So one of the biggest updates instead of uh doing major incidents that occur, or we're just gonna kind of focus on this one for a little bit.

3:12

The O'Donnell Park homicide that occurred on May 24th, eight and nine.

3:16

Uh we some of the things that I you know, like I kind of said a few times we can discuss and uh happy to discuss somewhat things further, but really it's an ongoing investigation that is uh that continues to get more complicated as the days go along go longer.

3:33

Victim was specifically targeted that evening.

3:35

Uh there are multiple individuals involved.

3:38

We have written almost probably close to 50 search warrants regarding this uh the storm side in the last three to four weeks, and we've winged on all of our resources outside just the city of Belmont from the Crime Lab to the GA's office to multiple federal agencies and regional task forces.

3:55

It is you know, um you know, one of those shattering things that happens to a community uh each each time it happens, especially in Belmont, right?

4:05

We're we think we're a siloed community, but reality is we're just one of 101 cities in the barrier of encompassing 7.7 million people, and unfortunately, sometimes things fill over our community.

4:18

So we have to continue to be prepared for that and understand that you know how we how we respond, how our keep our community connected moving forward next slide, please.

4:32

This is what we did this last quarter regarding our engagement and outreach.

4:35

We had the flight safety day, we had our uh Easter egg hunt, uh autism awareness month, our youth advisory committee town hall, we have uh recognized mental health awareness month, and we had our community meeting regarding that uh the homicide and the home use story balance.

4:52

Uh great great uh great discussion um about the incident, unfortunately.

5:00

We came together under a uh an unfortunate incident to to do that.

5:06

Now, where do we have going forward?

5:08

Uh our disaster preparedness day on August 3rd.

5:11

It's a special day for me.

5:12

National night out, August 6th.

5:14

Our fourth community academy starts August 28th.

5:17

I'll put a shameless plug in for all the millions of people that are listening uh to go ahead and sign up for our uh community academy.

5:25

It's you know, can't say it enough, what we get out of that, and there are some people that uh that speak very highly of it, and it is something that we take very take it to heart because it really is an opportunity to engage with the community at all levels within the police department.

5:42

Pizza with the police, August 30th, we'll be in the senior center uh with our uh senior community.

5:48

Uh Biomont Waterdog Run October 12th, and then we have our school leadership luncheon for Public in September to be a term.

5:59

Councilman, any questions?

6:01

No, that's funny.

6:02

Um, I had two.

6:04

Um, I saw that as part of the training.

6:06

Um, and this was something actually that was really helpful doing some of the piece county uh last year.

6:11

Um I had a chance to see some of the training that your officers go through.

6:15

Um, I'm curious about the de-escalation courses, which is talking about.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Technology and Innovation█████████████████████████████████████████████47%
Public Safety████████████████████████████████████████42%
Public Engagement██████6%
Mental Health Awareness███3%
Personnel Matters██2%
Summary of Proceedings

Belmont Public Safety Committee Meeting - September 26, 2024

Note: The meeting agenda listed the date as June 17, 2024, but the user-provided date for this summary is September 26, 2024. The summary reflects the later date as instructed.

The Public Safety Committee met to receive the Police Chief’s quarterly update and to discuss the potential adoption of an Unmanned Aerial Systems (UAS) program. Public comments focused on privacy, scope, and accountability. The committee expressed support for starting a UAS program with careful oversight.

Consent Calendar

  • The committee approved the minutes of November 13, 2023, and March 18, 2024, by motion.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Gina questioned why law enforcement would lead drone use for fire or public works, asked whether drones would be marked as police property, and expressed skepticism about the benefit for missing persons searches.
  • Michelle Peters raised concerns about the availability of police officers to pilot drones for other departments, potential scope creep, and whether the supervising sergeant would be trained as a pilot. She requested well-defined use cases.
  • Beth on Emster asked which local agencies already have drones, and whether a written policy would govern drone usage to prevent privacy violations and mission creep.

Discussion Items

Chief’s Quarterly Update

  • Chief reported promotions: Corporals Ed Berry and Michael Checky, and dispatcher Christy Wing (in training).
  • Recognitions: Professional Staff of the Year (Natalie), Officer of the Year (Michael Checky), Volunteer of the Year (Cindy Birch).
  • Training: 690 hours completed in the last quarter.
  • Major incident: O’Donnell Park homicide (May 24, 2024) – victim specifically targeted, multiple individuals involved, approximately 50 search warrants executed, ongoing investigation with multi-agency support.
  • Community outreach events held (flight safety day, Easter egg hunt, autism awareness month, etc.) and upcoming (disaster preparedness day, National Night Out, community academy, etc.).
  • Councilmember questions: de-escalation training discussed; license plate reader program update – policy posted online, still working through budget and state constraints.

Unmanned Aerial Systems (UAS) Presentation

  • Captain Armando presented potential benefits: accident reconstruction, critical incident monitoring (fires, open space), industrial accidents, missing persons searches.
  • Examples of successful use by other agencies: Tesla crash at Devil’s Slide, July 4th mortar detection, residential burglary suspect location.
  • Missed opportunities in Belmont: Paul Farmer missing person search, Barrett Center roof replacement, Laurel Creek fire, Christoph Lichke missing person case, fatal DUI hit-and-run.
  • Cost: Free training for 4 officers + 1 supervisor (hosted by a training group). One US-made drone estimated at $7,000 (original non-US estimate was $3,000); total startup ~$15,000. Redwood City budgeted $150,000 per year for a full program.
  • Policy: Existing UAS policy on transparency portal; FAA regulations require coordination with air traffic control due to proximity to SFO and San Carlos Airport. Flight logs will be maintained and subject to public records requests (with investigation-related redactions).
  • Committee discussion: Councilmember McCune noted infrared capabilities, flight time improvements (now 30–40 minutes), and asked about FAA regulations. Vice Mayor Lennon asked about number of officers trained, budget sharing across departments, and transparency. Chief and Captain clarified that pilots would be on duty to avoid overtime costs and that internal and external oversight exists.
  • Public comments answered: Drone use for missing persons can quickly clear an area, freeing resources; police will pilot drones for city departments due to 24/7 availability; policy governs use to prevent surveillance beyond authorized purposes.

Key Outcomes

  • The committee received the Chief’s quarterly update and the UAS presentation with no formal vote.
  • Consensus to proceed with a phased UAS program: start with one drone, train 4 officers + 1 supervisor, and develop a clear policy with public transparency, including a public log of drone flights (subject to investigatory exceptions).
  • Staff will refine cost estimates and bring back a proposed policy for further committee input.
  • The committee acknowledged the need for independent verification of drone usage and committed to incorporating community feedback on privacy and accountability.

Meeting Transcript

I'll just take a motion. Second. Thank you. On to general business. And this is the Chiefs quarterly update. Yes. It's truly the Chief update. Yes. And now for the Chiefs. Can you start playing with the pressure at all stage? Okay. First off, thank you for uh for having us here. Uh for a quarterly meeting. We'll jump right into it for the sake of time. Uh over the last quarter, we promoted two people, Corporal Ed Berry, Mike Checky to the rank of corporal. Uh both uh actually Ed Barry was promoted last year officially, but this was a swearing in. And we appointed dispatcher Christy Wing, she's currently in training, completed the uh dispatch academy and is working our way through the dispatch uh program. Also during that night, we recognize three individuals for their stellar performance over the last uh year. Uh professional staff and put in the year, she's she is a public uh police record specialist, Natalie. Uh our officer of the year, Michael Checky, who was also uh promoting the rank of corporal the same night. So he brought home a lot of hardware, and then our volunteer of the year, Cindy Birch. She's a volunteer. If you read her resume on what she does, plus her uh plus our day job as an engineer, we'd be here forever. The amount of time that she puts in as a as a volunteer is pretty fascinating. And that was you know, each year, this is probably the hardest one to pick because of some of the work they do on our own time and uh true value to the community, uh to take away from the you know the work that's done, but it's just uh what she does on our own time. It's just truly extraordinary. Uh overview our training continue to you know, we had 690 hours of training in the last quarter. That's on top of normal uh hours of uh the regular patrol and other functions within the police department. Those are just a few of the ones that uh that are listed. Um that's pretty standard uh operating training for us throughout the course of the year. Slide. So one of the biggest updates instead of uh doing major incidents that occur, or we're just gonna kind of focus on this one for a little bit. The O'Donnell Park homicide that occurred on May 24th, eight and nine. Uh we some of the things that I you know, like I kind of said a few times we can discuss and uh happy to discuss somewhat things further, but really it's an ongoing investigation that is uh that continues to get more complicated as the days go along go longer. Victim was specifically targeted that evening. Uh there are multiple individuals involved. We have written almost probably close to 50 search warrants regarding this uh the storm side in the last three to four weeks, and we've winged on all of our resources outside just the city of Belmont from the Crime Lab to the GA's office to multiple federal agencies and regional task forces. It is you know, um you know, one of those shattering things that happens to a community uh each each time it happens, especially in Belmont, right? We're we think we're a siloed community, but reality is we're just one of 101 cities in the barrier of encompassing 7.7 million people, and unfortunately, sometimes things fill over our community. So we have to continue to be prepared for that and understand that you know how we how we respond, how our keep our community connected moving forward next slide, please. This is what we did this last quarter regarding our engagement and outreach. We had the flight safety day, we had our uh Easter egg hunt, uh autism awareness month, our youth advisory committee town hall, we have uh recognized mental health awareness month, and we had our community meeting regarding that uh the homicide and the home use story balance. Uh great great uh great discussion um about the incident, unfortunately. We came together under a uh an unfortunate incident to to do that. Now, where do we have going forward? Uh our disaster preparedness day on August 3rd. It's a special day for me. National night out, August 6th. Our fourth community academy starts August 28th. I'll put a shameless plug in for all the millions of people that are listening uh to go ahead and sign up for our uh community academy.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com