OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Judiciary Committee Meeting - September 11, 2025

Council of Commissioners & CommitteesThursday, September 11, 2025
BodyButte Silver Bow, Montana
SessionCouncil of Commissioners & Committees
DateThursday, September 11, 2025
StatusFILED
Video Record
0:00 / 32:00

Transcript — Verbatim
3:06

I will call to order the judiciary committee meeting for September 10th, 2025.

3:15

Roll call present are um Michelle Shea, Hattie Thatcher, Dan Callahan, Trudy Healy, and Bill Anderson.

3:25

Um absent tonight and excused is Commissioner Eric Makins.

3:30

Um item number one, communication number 2025-310.

3:47

Uh, we have uh deputy county attorney Shea here tonight.

3:51

Is there a report on this one that you're aware of?

3:54

I'm not we're aware of any report um at this point.

3:57

So um I would entertain a motion so we can continue to hold this.

4:15

Anything on the question?

4:16

All those in favor?

4:18

Aye.

4:19

Opposed.

4:20

Motion passes.

4:35

A resolution of intent to alter the boundaries of the city county of Butte Silverbow, Montana's Solid Waste Special District to include the boundaries of Homesteak Meadows 2 subdivision and providing for an effective date herein.

4:51

I do not.

5:00

Thank you.

5:02

Go here for a quick minute.

5:04

Thank you.

5:09

Um the protest deadline was August 25th for um the expansion of the solid waste collection district uh to include Homestake Meadows 2 subdivision.

5:19

As of August 25th, the clerk and recorder did not receive any protests back from the 57 properties that are included in this expansion.

5:29

And I just have a sheet here for you that shows that thank you very much.

5:38

I will add this to um the materials for the meeting.

5:42

Um so it sounds like we could move this resolution to final reading.

5:48

I'd like to make the motion to move resolution number 2025-3-1 to final reading.

5:53

There's a motion and a second to move resolution number 2025-3-1 to final reading.

5:58

Is there anything on the question?

5:59

All those in favor?

6:01

Aye.

6:01

Opposed?

6:02

Motion passes.

6:08

We have one claim tonight.

6:10

Um, Casey Johnston in the amount of uh $35, which is a refund of a variance that's no longer needed per the planning director.

6:20

I'll make a motion to approve the claims as presented.

6:24

There's a motion and a second to approve the claims as presented.

6:28

Anything on the question?

6:29

All those in favor?

6:30

Aye.

6:31

Opposed?

6:32

Motion passes.

6:37

Communication number 2025-374, Trudy Healy, Commissioner District 8 requesting council of commissioners to look into concerns regarding urban camping on public streets and refer this matter to the Judiciary Committee and County Attorney Enruth to develop an ordinance to address this matter.

6:53

Um Commissioner Healy, do you have an update?

6:55

Did you come up with some ideas for the ordinance?

7:01

So, yeah.

7:02

So I'm gonna start with this.

7:04

As elected officials, we have a responsibility to protect our citizens, their children, and their homes and businesses from the increasing challenges posed by unauthorized camping.

7:14

I am asking that we move forward with clear protections, no camping in front of citizens' homes, no camping in city parks, no camping in front of schools, no camping in front of businesses.

7:27

There is plenty of land in the surrounding area where camping could be better managed.

7:32

What we need are clear and concise ordinances that strike a balance providing appropriate alternatives without compromising the safety and quality of life in our neighborhoods.

7:42

I have reached out to county attorney Enron to review the legal details, but but today I want to make it clear our citizens deserve action and they deserve it now.

7:53

Um County Attorney Enrique did tell me he did email me back.

7:57

He does want uh want to have a meeting and he did state that he would be gone this week.

8:01

So we are setting up a meeting.

8:06

Thank you, Commissioner Healy.

8:08

I assume the uh Judiciary Committee will be invited to that meeting and be publicly noticed.

8:14

Yes.

8:14

So are you calling for a special meeting?

8:16

Um today.

8:17

Well, first I gotta talk to Enrique gets back.

8:20

Okay, thank you.

8:21

Um I had asked um Parks and Rec Director Um Sean Frederickson to be here since his name came up at the last meeting.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Homelessness█████████████████████████████████████████████54%
Public Safety█████████████████████25%
Procedural██████████12%
Mental Health Awareness█████6%
Parks and Recreation███3%
Summary of Proceedings

Judiciary Committee Meeting – September 11, 2025

The Butte-Silver Bow Judiciary Committee met on September 11, 2025, under Chair Michelle Shea. Commissioners present: Michelle Shea, Hattie Thatcher, Dan Callahan, Trudy Healy, and Bill Anderson. Commissioner Eric Makins was excused. The committee discussed two communications: a resolution to expand the Solid Waste Special District and a proposal to address urban camping. One claim was approved.

Consent Calendar

  • Claim for Casey Johnston: Approved unanimously. Refund of $35 for a variance no longer needed per the planning director.

Discussion Items

  • Communication 2025-310 – Solid Waste Special District Expansion: This resolution intended to alter the boundaries of the Solid Waste Special District to include the Homestake Meadows 2 subdivision. The protest deadline was August 25, 2025, and the Clerk and Recorder received no protests from the 57 affected properties. The committee voted to move Resolution 2025-3-1 to final reading.
  • Communication 2025-374 – Urban Camping Ordinance: Commissioner Trudy Healy presented a proposal to prohibit unauthorized camping in front of homes, schools, parks, and businesses. She cited 85 police calls in one neighborhood near Emma Park over the past year. Parks and Recreation Director Sean Frederickson described recent camp clearouts at Father Sheehan Park, noting that parks employees lack enforcement authority and that most campers comply when asked to leave. Sheriff Lester explained enforcement challenges, including the lack of a law against homelessness, limited jail capacity, and the difficulty of fining indigent individuals. He noted that case management funding was cut in 2017, leaving about 400 individuals without support. Bozeman and Missoula have faced similar issues without clear solutions. The committee discussed potential sanctions such as warnings, citations, and trespass orders, but acknowledged the cycle of displacement. No formal action was taken on the ordinance.

Key Outcomes

  • Resolution 2025-3-1 (Solid Waste Special District expansion) was moved to final reading on a unanimous vote.
  • Claim for Casey Johnston was approved unanimously.
  • The committee agreed to adjourn and reconvene after the full council meeting to continue discussion on the urban camping ordinance.

Meeting Transcript

I will call to order the judiciary committee meeting for September 10th, 2025. Roll call present are um Michelle Shea, Hattie Thatcher, Dan Callahan, Trudy Healy, and Bill Anderson. Um absent tonight and excused is Commissioner Eric Makins. Um item number one, communication number 2025-310. Uh, we have uh deputy county attorney Shea here tonight. Is there a report on this one that you're aware of? I'm not we're aware of any report um at this point. So um I would entertain a motion so we can continue to hold this. Anything on the question? All those in favor? Aye. Opposed. Motion passes. A resolution of intent to alter the boundaries of the city county of Butte Silverbow, Montana's Solid Waste Special District to include the boundaries of Homesteak Meadows 2 subdivision and providing for an effective date herein. I do not. Thank you. Go here for a quick minute. Thank you. Um the protest deadline was August 25th for um the expansion of the solid waste collection district uh to include Homestake Meadows 2 subdivision. As of August 25th, the clerk and recorder did not receive any protests back from the 57 properties that are included in this expansion. And I just have a sheet here for you that shows that thank you very much. I will add this to um the materials for the meeting. Um so it sounds like we could move this resolution to final reading. I'd like to make the motion to move resolution number 2025-3-1 to final reading. There's a motion and a second to move resolution number 2025-3-1 to final reading. Is there anything on the question? All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? Motion passes. We have one claim tonight. Um, Casey Johnston in the amount of uh $35, which is a refund of a variance that's no longer needed per the planning director. I'll make a motion to approve the claims as presented. There's a motion and a second to approve the claims as presented. Anything on the question? All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? Motion passes. Communication number 2025-374, Trudy Healy, Commissioner District 8 requesting council of commissioners to look into concerns regarding urban camping on public streets and refer this matter to the Judiciary Committee and County Attorney Enruth to develop an ordinance to address this matter. Um Commissioner Healy, do you have an update? Did you come up with some ideas for the ordinance? So, yeah. So I'm gonna start with this. As elected officials, we have a responsibility to protect our citizens, their children, and their homes and businesses from the increasing challenges posed by unauthorized camping. I am asking that we move forward with clear protections, no camping in front of citizens' homes, no camping in city parks, no camping in front of schools, no camping in front of businesses. There is plenty of land in the surrounding area where camping could be better managed. What we need are clear and concise ordinances that strike a balance providing appropriate alternatives without compromising the safety and quality of life in our neighborhoods. I have reached out to county attorney Enron to review the legal details, but but today I want to make it clear our citizens deserve action and they deserve it now. Um County Attorney Enrique did tell me he did email me back.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com