OpenPublica

Accountability starts with access.

© 2026 · Filed for the public record

Use casesAboutAPIPrivacyTermsLinkedIn
Home/Carpinteria, California/City Council
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Carpinteria City Council Meeting – September 28, 2026

City Council — Monday, September 28, 2026
BodyCarpinteria, California
SessionCity Council
DateMonday, September 28, 2026
StatusFILED
Video Record
Meeting Thumbnail
⇩ GET FROM SOURCE

STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE

Original source
Transcript — Verbatim

Speaker numbers apply only to this recording. Names come from transcript evidence. “Possibly” marks uncertain attribution.

Speaker 1

0:50

Uh the to discuss one matter um with legal counsel regarding anticipated litigation and there is no reportable action this evening.

1:00

Thanks.

1:00

Great,

Speaker 2

1:01

thank you.

1:01

And if you are willing and able, please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance.

Unassigned speaker

1:09

I

Speaker 2

1:10

pledge allegiance.

1:28

And the first two items on our agenda are very exciting.

1:32

Um we will first recognize the retirement of Michael Hickey, who has been our part-time crossing guard for 40 years.

1:58

So in honor of your retirement and in recognition of over 40 years of dedicated and exemplary public service to the city of Carpenteria.

2:08

Since joining the city as a part-time crossing guard in September 1984, you have faithfully served the Carpenter community with professionalism, dedication, and unwavering commitment.

2:20

Through your care and vigilance, you have helped ensure the safety and well-being of generations of students, including mine, while making a lasting and positive impact on countless families throughout our community.

2:35

On behalf of the city council, staff and community, we extend our sincere appreciation and best wishes for a happy and fulfilling retirement.

Speaker 3

5:04

Okay.

5:04

Oh, okay.

Unassigned speaker

5:30

And

Speaker 2

5:30

our the next item on our agenda is a ten-year service award to Marisol Smith, who is our associate planner.

5:37

Um, I will first open up public comment.

5:39

I do not have any speaker slips.

5:41

Do we have anyone via Zoom?

Speaker 4

5:42

The mayor, we have no raised hands.

Speaker 2

5:43

Yeah, we'll close public comment and ask that.

5:45

Marisol, come to the podium while I share a few nice words about you.

Unassigned speaker

5:50

Okay.

Unassigned speaker

5:58

So

Speaker 2

5:58

your service embodies the values of our organization, significantly contributing to our mission and goals, leaving a lasting impact on our community.

6:07

And thank you for your outstanding service and continued dedication to the city of Carpenteria.

Rachel Murphy · Speaker 5Inferred

6:13

Thank you.

6:14

Thank you.

Speaker 6

6:19

And and Mayor,

Speaker 7

6:20

if it's okay, uh staff has some comments as well.

Speaker 2

6:22

Absolutely.

Speaker 7

6:24

Thank you, Mayor Alarcon, Council members.

6:26

Don't

Speaker 2

6:26

go anywhere, Money Soul.

6:27

You gotta stay in the front.

Speaker 7

6:30

So Marisol joined the city back in 2016 as an assistant planner.

6:34

And uh she was promoted in 2021 to associate planner position that she continues to serve in today.

6:41

Um the title, I think belies a little bit of how much she brings to the table.

6:47

There's a lot of work that Marisol does behind the scenes to keep our department running.

6:51

That is not reflected in the associate planner position that she officially uh you know holds.

6:58

So

Unassigned speaker

6:59

uh

Speaker 7

6:59

not only does she work on planning cases uh like our the rest of our planners, but she's also instrumental in helping a lot of the uh complete a lot of the technology work for our department.

7:10

So she's single-handedly or nearly single-handedly been our point person developing our new permit software with GovWell and getting that off the ground.

7:18

She's also uh doing a lot of work on a near-weekly basis behind the scenes to help us get our agendas up online and and and published out to the community for our various public meetings.

7:30

And she also does a lot of work up at the front counter to be one of the the faces of the department and the and the people one of those faces that the public interacts with on behalf of our department regularly.

7:40

And I can say just on behalf of our team, we really appreciate your dedication and your commitment and everything that you bring to our department, and we're happy to be able to recognize you for 10 years of service.

Speaker 2

7:59

Okay, we'll take a photo in the front.

8:01

We'd love for you to

Speaker 8

8:02

join

Unassigned speaker

8:03

us.

Speaker 9

9:11

Which is actually true, so it's good to see everybody here tonight.

Unassigned speaker

9:16

Uh

Speaker 9

9:16

let me start off by um kind of consolidate it for you here because it's been a long two months, but uh so for July and August of 2026, we have a revolver that was found wrapped inside a paper bag inside someone's trunk who was unaware it was there.

9:32

Uh not sure who it belonged to, so we have no uh information on how we got there.

9:38

We have a suspicious circumstance where uh somebody reported uh uh nine millimeter round lodge into the pavement at a crosswalk at Carp Av Av and Palm Avenue.

9:49

So we just collected uh the uh bullet and sent it off, but we have no information other than that.

Unassigned speaker

9:55

We have at least two reports of counterfeit 100 bills being passed out at local businesses.

Speaker 9

10:00

In one case, the suspect pushed the owner out of the way as the owner attempted to detain uh the suspect for re uh responding deputies.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Economic Development█████████████████17%
Community Engagement██████████10%
Public Engagement█████████9%
Planning And Development█████████9%
Public Safety████████8%
Arts And Culture███████7%
Procedural██████6%
Historic Preservation██████6%
Personnel Matters█████5%
Summary of Proceedings

Carpinteria City Council Meeting – September 28, 2026

The Carpinteria City Council met on Monday, September 28, 2026, at 5:30 p.m. in the Council Chamber. The agenda included recognitions, reports from the Sheriff and the First District Supervisor, a city manager's report, consent calendar items, selection of councilmembers for a beach resilience meeting, ratification of a regional winter storm preparedness letter, a proposed economic vitality services agreement with the Santa Barbara South Coast Chamber of Commerce (which failed on a tie vote), and an update on a proposed 10-panel mural by the Carpinteria Cultural Foundation (which was withdrawn by the applicant). The council also heard extensive public testimony regarding the proposed Red Tail development in the Baylard area.

Consent Calendar

  • Approved the minutes of the regular meeting held September 14, 2026.
  • Received and filed the Warrant Register for September 7–18, 2026.
  • Received and filed the Report of Contracts Executed by the City Manager for August 4 – September 7, 2026.
  • Adopted Resolution No. 6497, approving an amendment to the City’s Conflict of Interest Code.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Red Tail Development (Baylard Project): Multiple residents spoke against the proposed development, raising concerns about inadequate parking (1.5 spaces per unit vs. 2 in neighboring complexes), safety due to a single emergency exit, and potential impacts on existing affordable housing communities (Casitas Village and Villa del Mar). Speakers included Betty Jefferson, Jim Knuckles, Cindy Marcus, and Tristine Rayner. They urged the council to deny permits or require conditions to protect residents.
  • Surfliner Project: A commenter urged that the developer bear all costs for improvements to Elm Avenue caused by the project's alternative five, rather than the city.
  • Planning Commission Recusal: Catherine Sylent requested a public discussion of Planning Commissioner Van Antwerp's recusal from the Surfliner hearing, citing threats of lawsuit by the developer's attorney. The city attorney responed by explaining the legal standards for bias and dueprocess.
  • Mural Proposal: Several commenters opposed the 10-panel mural as proposed, citing cultural insensitivity, lack of community involvement from the outset, and compatibility issues with the existing plaza. One speaker supported the project but suggestedtext tweaks.
  • Other: A resident requested removal of story polls on a vacant property; another requested agendaizing of beach safety conditions; one speaker asked for clearer city budget information.

Discussion Items

  • Item 11 – Selection of Councilmembers for BeachSMART Community Meeting: Councilmember Myers expressed interest, then deferred to Vice Mayor Solorzano as district representative for Ash Avenue Beach. The council selected Mayor Alarcone and Vice Mayor Solorzano to attend the October 1, 2026 meeting on beach resilience and sediment management.
  • Item 12 – Ratification of Regional Winter Storm Preparedness Letter and State of Emergency Update: The council ratified the Interim Public Works Director's signature on a September 18 letter to Governor Newsom requesting state assistance for the 2026–27 winter storm season. They also received an update on the Governor's September 21 statewide State of Emergency proclamation and the city's preparedness activities (storm drain maintenance, sandbag availability, emergency notification system). The council approved the ratification and received the update unanimously.
  • Item 13 – Economic Vitality Services Agreement with Santa Barbara South Coast Chamber of Commerce: Councilmember Mayor recused herself due to endorsment and contribution concerns. The chamber presented a 12-month pilot program for $30,000 to provide business outreach, data collection, and resource connection. After deliberation, Councilmember Myers moved to approve; Councilmember Clark seconded. Roll call: Councilmember Myers – aye, Councilmember Numata – no, Councilmember Clark – no, Mayor Alarcone – aye. The motion failed on a 2-2 tie. Councilmember Numata suggested the chamber return with more detail on projected economic impact.
  • Item 14 – Update on Preliminary Review of Carpinteria Cultural Foundation's 10-Panel Mural Proposal: Staff reported on public outreach (150 attendees at two events, 59 survey responses) and subject matter expert reviews from four scholars (including UCSB professors and the Carpenteria Valley Museum of History). Experts raised concerns about historical accuracy, stereotypical depictions, and omission of women and Native California experience. After discussion, councilmembers expressed concerns about content, placement (on the grapevine trellis vs. the wall), and the need for further work. Councilmember Numata moved to forward to the Architectural Review Board with feedback; no second. The applicant then withdrew the application.

Key Outcomes

  • Consent Calendar: Approved unanimously.
  • BeachSMART Attendees: Mayor Alarcon and Vice Mayor Solorzano selected.
  • Winter Storm Letter: Ratified unanimously. The city will continue tracking costs for potential state/federal reimbursement.
  • Chamber Agreement: Motion failed (2-2). The item may return after further refinement by the Economic Vitality Committee.
  • Mural Proposal: Withdrawn by the applicant. No further action taken.
  • Red Tail Development: Council consensus to send a letter to Supervis or Lee requesting that the housing authority and developer hold a community meeting before the end of 2026 to address resident concerns.
  • Other: Staff will follow up on removal of story polls on Linden Avenue property.

Meeting Transcript

Uh the to discuss one matter um with legal counsel regarding anticipated litigation and there is no reportable action this evening. Thanks. Great, thank you. And if you are willing and able, please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance. And the first two items on our agenda are very exciting. Um we will first recognize the retirement of Michael Hickey, who has been our part-time crossing guard for 40 years. So in honor of your retirement and in recognition of over 40 years of dedicated and exemplary public service to the city of Carpenteria. Since joining the city as a part-time crossing guard in September 1984, you have faithfully served the Carpenter community with professionalism, dedication, and unwavering commitment. Through your care and vigilance, you have helped ensure the safety and well-being of generations of students, including mine, while making a lasting and positive impact on countless families throughout our community. On behalf of the city council, staff and community, we extend our sincere appreciation and best wishes for a happy and fulfilling retirement. Okay. Oh, okay. And our the next item on our agenda is a ten-year service award to Marisol Smith, who is our associate planner. Um, I will first open up public comment. I do not have any speaker slips. Do we have anyone via Zoom? The mayor, we have no raised hands. Yeah, we'll close public comment and ask that. Marisol, come to the podium while I share a few nice words about you. Okay. So your service embodies the values of our organization, significantly contributing to our mission and goals, leaving a lasting impact on our community. And thank you for your outstanding service and continued dedication to the city of Carpenteria. Thank you. Thank you. And and Mayor, if it's okay, uh staff has some comments as well. Absolutely. Thank you, Mayor Alarcon, Council members. Don't go anywhere, Money Soul. You gotta stay in the front. So Marisol joined the city back in 2016 as an assistant planner. And uh she was promoted in 2021 to associate planner position that she continues to serve in today. Um the title, I think belies a little bit of how much she brings to the table. There's a lot of work that Marisol does behind the scenes to keep our department running. That is not reflected in the associate planner position that she officially uh you know holds. So uh not only does she work on planning cases uh like our the rest of our planners, but she's also instrumental in helping a lot of the uh complete a lot of the technology work for our department. So she's single-handedly or nearly single-handedly been our point person developing our new permit software with GovWell and getting that off the ground. She's also uh doing a lot of work on a near-weekly basis behind the scenes to help us get our agendas up online and and and published out to the community for our various public meetings. And she also does a lot of work up at the front counter to be one of the the faces of the department and the and the people one of those faces that the public interacts with on behalf of our department regularly. And I can say just on behalf of our team, we really appreciate your dedication and your commitment and everything that you bring to our department, and we're happy to be able to recognize you for 10 years of service. Okay, we'll take a photo in the front. We'd love for you to

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com