OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Charlotte City Council Zoning Meeting - February 17, 2025

City CouncilMonday, February 17, 2025
BodyCharlotte, North Carolina
SessionCity Council
DateMonday, February 17, 2025
StatusFILED
Video Record

STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE

Transcript — Verbatim
1:56

Studio.

2:05

Is the studio where we're should be, yeah.

2:08

Okay.

2:11

Okay.

2:11

Good evening, everyone, and welcome to the February 17th, 2025 zoning meeting.

2:19

We will start our meeting with introductions, and we will start with the city clerk.

2:24

Billy Tons, Deputy City Clerk.

2:26

Good evening, Dimple Ashmira at large.

2:29

Good evening, Marjorie Molina, I represent District Five.

2:33

Good evening, Renee Johnson, and I'm honored to represent District Four.

2:37

Good evening, Alison Craig, Assistant City Manager.

2:40

Good evening, Dante Anderson, Mayor Pro Tem, District One.

2:43

Malcolm Graham, District Two.

2:44

Ed Driggs, District Seven, Tar Bergard's 6.

2:49

Terry Hagler Gray, Senior Assistant City Attorney.

2:52

Excellent.

2:53

So we begin our meeting with an invocation as an expression and inspiration, all by the Pledge of Allegiance.

3:02

The invocation intended to underscore our proceedings, and we celebrate the religious diversity of our community, including those without a religious faith.

3:21

And so I'd like to share some thoughts with us all.

5:03

One nation under God and indivisible Liberty and Justice for all.

5:13

Excellent.

5:13

So I'm just going to provide an explanation of our zoning process and we'll get started.

5:19

The process begins with applications submitted to our planning staff for review.

5:24

And cases come in two types and that are on our agenda tonight.

5:29

We have decisions and we also have hearings.

5:32

Decisions are on cases for which a public hearing was previously held, and therefore there's no public comment this evening on those cases.

5:43

And then the hearings for anyone wishing to speak for a particular petition that has a hearing this evening, we ask that you see the clerk before the start of that particular hearing.

5:57

Staff will have a presentation, and there is no time limit for the presentation for staff.

6:04

And the petitioner for the hearing for those who are in favor, they will receive six minutes combined to present their case, unless there are two things that occur.

6:14

One is there are opponents that are signed up to speak against that particular petition, or if staff is in opposition of the petition, the petitioner will get 10 minutes.

6:27

The opponent will get 10 minutes combined, and then the petitioner will have a two-minute rebuttal.

6:33

If no one is opposed or no one is signed to speak against that particular petition, then staff proceeds with the short presentation, and the public hearing is closed, and we move on to the next public hearing.

6:48

The petitions go to our zoning committee of planning commission for review prior to this evening and for recommendation.

6:59

And I'm going to pass it over to the chair, Mr.

7:01

Blumenthal, so he can introduce that particular uh committee.

7:07

Thank you, Mr.

7:07

Blumenthal.

7:08

Thank you very much, Mayor Pro Tim, and thank you to council.

7:11

Uh my name is Andrew Blumenthal, and it's my pleasure to serve as the chairman of the zoning committee of the planning commission.

7:18

Uh first to introduce my fellow commission members here this evening.

7:21

We have Rick Winnaker, Aaron Shaw, and Shauna Neely, as well as a few tuning in virtually as well.

7:27

Uh the zoning committee will next meet on Tuesday, March 4th at 5 30 p.m.

7:32

At that meeting, the zoning committee will discuss and make recommendations on the petitions that have public hearings this evening.

7:38

The public is welcome to attend that meeting.

7:41

However, please note that it is not a continuation of any of the public hearings that are being held here tonight.

7:46

Prior to that meeting, you are welcome to contact us to provide input.

7:50

You can find contact information and information on each petition on the city's website at CharlottePlanning.org.

7:57

Thank you, Mayor Purto.

7:58

Thank you, Mr.

7:59

Chair.

8:00

Okay, so we have a number of withdrawn for this evening.

8:08

And I would allow Mr.

8:09

Petton to walk us through those, and then we'll need a motion all in one motion to either approve or deny the deferral.

8:18

Thank you, Mr.

8:19

Petton.

8:20

Thank you, Mayor Pro Tem.

8:21

Just to note we did have an additional item from uh earlier this afternoon.

8:26

So we have item number 12, uh which is 2024-130 by Abacus Acquisitions LLC.

8:33

And then we have item 13, 2024 116 by Fevon Nagesh.

8:38

Uh both of those decisions deferring to March 17th.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Land Use and Development█████████████████████████████████████████████57%
Procedural█████████11%
Community Engagement██████8%
Environmental Protection██████7%
Affordable Housing██████7%
Transportation Planning███4%
Transportation Safety██3%
Public Engagement██2%
Public Transit1%
Summary of Proceedings

Charlotte City Council Zoning Meeting - February 17, 2025

On February 17, 2025, the Charlotte City Council held a Zoning Meeting in the Council Chamber of the Charlotte-Mecklenburg Government Center. The meeting began at 5:00 PM and covered deferrals, a consent agenda, two decision items, and nine public hearings. Key actions included approvals of consent items, a text amendment to comply with Senate Bill 382, a rezoning for a future greenway connection, and multiple hearings on various rezoning petitions. Notably, the transcript does not record final votes on the hearing items after their public hearings were closed, though staff recommended approval and council typically votes after closing.

Consent Calendar

  • Items 3-12 (except pulled items): Approved unanimously. Items pulled for individual votes:
    • Item 4 (2024-099): Mecklenburg County – 24.75 acres for a community resource center. Approved unanimously after Councilmember Molina highlighted amenities including dentistry.
    • Item 5 (2024-103): Rocky River Road Partners – 24.46 acres for townhomes. Approved unanimously. Councilmember Johnson noted community support and improvements (road widening, sidewalk, multi-use path).
    • Item 6 (2024-105): Angelo Tillman – 1.99 acres to N1-F(CD). Approved 10-1 (Councilmember Mayfield opposed). Staff explained the jump from N1-B to N1-F due to lot configuration; the Hidden Valley Neighborhood Association supported.
    • Item 9 (2024-122): Mintworth Commons Holdings – 0.33 acres to CG(CD). Approved unanimously. Councilmember Molina clarified that uses are consistent with the 2040 policy map and no opposition was recorded.
    • Item 10 (2024-123): QCRE Investments – 0.30 acres to N1-D. Approved 10-1 (Councilmember Mayfield opposed). No discussion recorded.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Item 21 (2024-125, Tay Holdings): No opponents spoke. Petitioner described 39 townhomes and a change from a concrete median to a left-turn stripe based on community feedback.
  • Item 22 (2024-126, Greystar): No opponents spoke. Petitioner proposed 306 multifamily units with a leasing office. Councilmember Mayfield questioned compatibility with airport noise overlay and proximity to highways; she suggested a policy referral for environmental considerations. Councilmembers Johnson, Ajmera, and Watlington supported further study.
  • Item 23 (2024-131, Pulte Homes): Janaris Washington, an adjacent property owner, spoke in favor contingent on an increased buffer. Petitioner committed to an 80-foot building separation, privacy fence, and extra landscaping.
  • Item 24 (2024-133, Kenjoh Outdoor Advertising): No opponents. Petitioner listed prohibited uses; Councilmember Graham asked about nearby billboards.
  • Item 25 (2024-134, St. Charles Avenue LLC): No opponents. Petitioner David Murray explained the lot split. Councilmember Molina expressed concern that neighbors may not understand the process; she sought more community input.
  • Item 26 (2024-135, Harold Carrillo): No speakers. Staff noted a community meeting with no attendees.
  • Item 27 (2024-136, Keen Building Company): No opponents. Petitioner David Murray noted the adjacent property owner attended the community meeting.
  • Item 28 (2024-140, Urban Trends Real Estate): No opponents. Petitioner Matt Langston and Chris Ogon Rinde (Urban Trends) described a mixed-use building with workforce housing near the Gold Line. Councilmember Graham supported the project.
  • Item 29 (2024-148, CSE Communities): No opponents. Petitioner Tim Cinema (Crosland Southeast) presented an 80-unit affordable senior housing development (30-80% AMI) using housing trust fund financing. Councilmember Watlington questioned the sunset clause if HTF funds are not secured; staff explained it avoids a future rezoning. Councilmember Mayfield requested additional community outreach due to traffic and pedestrian concerns.

Discussion Items

  • Item 14 (2024-121, Text Amendment): Staff presented changes made after the Zoning Committee to comply with Senate Bill 382 (downzoning restrictions) and minor administrative updates. Councilmember Driggs noted the committee found changes non-material and emphasized the amendment leaves room for future legislative adjustments. The motion not to send back to committee passed unanimously; the amendment was approved unanimously.
  • Item 15 (2024-102, Drakeford Communities): Staff outlined changes to clarify a future greenway connection with Mecklenburg County Park and Rec, including dedication prior to first certificate of occupancy. Motion not to send back passed unanimously; the rezoning was approved unanimously.

Key Outcomes

  • Deferrals: Items 13 (2024-116, Feven Negash), 16 (2024-073, CLT Operations), 17 (2024-112, Dreamkey Partners, deferred to June 16, 2025), 18 (2024-124, Aviation Metals), 19 (2024-137, Wilkes Asset Management), and 20 (2024-138, Peak Development) were all deferred to March 17, 2025 (except item 17). Approved unanimously.
  • Consent Agenda: Items 3, 7, 8, 11, 12 approved as a block unanimously. Pulled items voted individually (see above).
  • Decision Items: Item 14 (text amendment) approved unanimously. Item 15 (Drakeford) approved unanimously.
  • Hearing Items: For items 21 through 29, the public hearings were closed unanimously. However, the transcript does not record subsequent votes on the petitions themselves. According to the agenda, staff recommended approval for all hearing items. Council typically votes after closing hearings, but this was not captured in the provided transcript.

Meeting Transcript

Studio. Is the studio where we're should be, yeah. Okay. Okay. Good evening, everyone, and welcome to the February 17th, 2025 zoning meeting. We will start our meeting with introductions, and we will start with the city clerk. Billy Tons, Deputy City Clerk. Good evening, Dimple Ashmira at large. Good evening, Marjorie Molina, I represent District Five. Good evening, Renee Johnson, and I'm honored to represent District Four. Good evening, Alison Craig, Assistant City Manager. Good evening, Dante Anderson, Mayor Pro Tem, District One. Malcolm Graham, District Two. Ed Driggs, District Seven, Tar Bergard's 6. Terry Hagler Gray, Senior Assistant City Attorney. Excellent. So we begin our meeting with an invocation as an expression and inspiration, all by the Pledge of Allegiance. The invocation intended to underscore our proceedings, and we celebrate the religious diversity of our community, including those without a religious faith. And so I'd like to share some thoughts with us all. One nation under God and indivisible Liberty and Justice for all. Excellent. So I'm just going to provide an explanation of our zoning process and we'll get started. The process begins with applications submitted to our planning staff for review. And cases come in two types and that are on our agenda tonight. We have decisions and we also have hearings. Decisions are on cases for which a public hearing was previously held, and therefore there's no public comment this evening on those cases. And then the hearings for anyone wishing to speak for a particular petition that has a hearing this evening, we ask that you see the clerk before the start of that particular hearing. Staff will have a presentation, and there is no time limit for the presentation for staff. And the petitioner for the hearing for those who are in favor, they will receive six minutes combined to present their case, unless there are two things that occur. One is there are opponents that are signed up to speak against that particular petition, or if staff is in opposition of the petition, the petitioner will get 10 minutes. The opponent will get 10 minutes combined, and then the petitioner will have a two-minute rebuttal. If no one is opposed or no one is signed to speak against that particular petition, then staff proceeds with the short presentation, and the public hearing is closed, and we move on to the next public hearing. The petitions go to our zoning committee of planning commission for review prior to this evening and for recommendation. And I'm going to pass it over to the chair, Mr. Blumenthal, so he can introduce that particular uh committee. Thank you, Mr. Blumenthal. Thank you very much, Mayor Pro Tim, and thank you to council. Uh my name is Andrew Blumenthal, and it's my pleasure to serve as the chairman of the zoning committee of the planning commission. Uh first to introduce my fellow commission members here this evening. We have Rick Winnaker, Aaron Shaw, and Shauna Neely, as well as a few tuning in virtually as well. Uh the zoning committee will next meet on Tuesday, March 4th at 5 30 p.m. At that meeting, the zoning committee will discuss and make recommendations on the petitions that have public hearings this evening. The public is welcome to attend that meeting. However, please note that it is not a continuation of any of the public hearings that are being held here tonight. Prior to that meeting, you are welcome to contact us to provide input. You can find contact information and information on each petition on the city's website at CharlottePlanning.org. Thank you, Mayor Purto. Thank you, Mr. Chair.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com