8:38Welcome to the meeting of the Chattanooga City Council for March thirty first, twenty twenty-six.
8:44Um, to get us started, I'd like to welcome Councilman Park and ask him to lead us in our Pledge of Allegiance and the invocation.
9:25Good afternoon, everybody.
9:29Enjoying this beautiful day that the Lord has made.
10:00Keep focus, let love abide.
10:03No matter what happens in this council, no matter who you disagree or how you agree.
10:09Keep love as the main focus.
10:12Let us bow into the Lord.
10:14Father God in heaven, as we come to you as the Lord of hosts, the Lord of Lord, the King of Kings in this beautiful season of hope.
10:24God, we just want to come and thank you, God, for the power of your grace upon your people.
10:30Now, God, we ask your blessings in this meeting, God, that every decision will be made unselfishly, God, and made in the power of progress, made in the positiveness of resurrection, God, that we all can do greater things.
10:46God, I just ask you, God, to give power unto your leaders that they may be focused by faithfulness to know that you will do everything that you promise.
10:56God, I just thank you, Lord, for this meeting.
10:59Let your spirit abide.
11:01Bless us in our communities.
11:03Bless us in this city.
11:06Bless us, oh Lord, in this great country.
11:09And it's in Jesus Christ's holy name that we pray, no other name we know, and we say amen.
11:17Thank you, Minister Smith.
11:18Madam Chair, you're back.
11:19Thank you very much.
11:22I'm looking for a special face in the audience.
11:24And I don't see him.
11:28Mayor Kelly was going to join us at 3:30.
11:31Madam Chair, he's held up about five minutes in a meeting with Mayor Wamp, but he'll be here very shortly.
11:35I'm sure we can proceed and just fit him in wherever is good for you.
11:38Okay, thank you very much.
11:39Councillor, can I get a motion on the minutes?
11:49Um by Cassie Klein on the historic guidelines.
11:52Cassie, could you uh join us up here and teach us many things, please?
12:05Okay, good afternoon, Council members.
12:07Thank you so much for having me today.
12:09I'm excited to talk to you about our new historic guidelines.
12:12This project has been going on for approximately two years, and here we are in the final stretch.
12:17So today I am going to talk about types of historic designation, the timeline of the guidelines update, what's changed, unchanged elements, and then leave some time for questions at the end.
12:28So to get us started, I'm going to do a brief overview of the different types of historic designation in the city of Chattanooga.
12:35We currently have two types of historic designation in the city, our local historic districts and landmarks and the National Register of Historic Places.
12:43Our historic zoning ordinance allows community members, city council, or local nonprofits to apply for local historic landmark or district designations.
12:52This type of overlay protects historic properties from demolition and inappropriate alterations.
12:57The city currently has four local historic districts, one loc and one local historic landmark.
13:02This includes Fortwood, St.
13:04Elmo, Fergor Place, Battery Place, and the Frank Lloyd Wright Shaven House on Missionary Ridge.
13:10The National Register of Historic Places is a national designation, hence the name, that mostly functions as an honorary distinction.
13:17The National Register does not protect historically significant properties from demolition or inappropriate alterations.
13:23There are some tangible benefits beyond the honorary distinction of being listed on the National Register.
13:29So if a property is listed on the National Register and it is income producing, it could be eligible for federal rehabilitation tax credits.
13:36But again, this distinction does not protect properties from demolition or inappropriate changes.
13:43Okay, so moving into the guidelines update.
13:46We've talked about the different types of historic designation.
13:48We're going to zoom into our local guidelines.
13:50Our local historic properties are governed by the historic zoning ordinance, which lives in chapter 10 of the municipal code.
13:56And we're going to talk about the and the applicable historic guidelines.
14:00Today we're talking about the update to those guidelines.
14:03These serve as the document that staff in the Historic Zoning Commission use to determine what is or is not appropriate for our local historic properties, including demolition, additions, new construction, and alterations.
14:15So the timeline of this project began back in 2023 under my predecessor who secured federal grant funding and matching dollars from the regional planning agency.
14:24I began working on this project at the beginning of 2024 when I started in this role as the preservation planner.
14:29We then finalized our contract with the consultant and began the update process in early summer of 2024.
14:35We um our consultant created a kickoff survey that we shared with all the residents of our historic districts requesting feedback.
14:42Our consultants then visited Chattanooga, conducted field work, and then we hosted individual public meetings with each of our neighborhoods in the fall of 2024.
14:51This feedback informed the initial draft of the guidelines, sent those individual chapters to our historic zoning commissioners as they were available during the fall, and requested feedback.
15:00We then released the first final draft of the document at the beginning of 2025.
15:05Staff set up a survey allowing the community to provide feedback on each chapter of the guidelines.
15:10That survey was open for 30 days.
15:12We then worked with mayor's office to review the draft as well.
15:14Then we incorporated all of that feedback into another final draft of the guidelines in late summer 2025, and we had one more public hearing in early fall of 2025 to kind of close out any public comments that we had.
15:28And then most recently, the Historic Zoning Commission reviewed the final draft over the course of three meetings.
15:32We went chapter by chapter from November to December of 2025.
15:36And then the Historic Zoning Commission then voted to approve the final draft that you have in front of you back in January of 2026.
15:45So now I'm going to jump into the major changes of the guidelines.
15:49You have a summary of this document in the binder with the guidelines as well that highlights these kind of major changes.
15:55So the first one is formatting.
15:57It's maybe one of the biggest changes.
15:59We consolidated five guideline documents into one document.
16:02We went from over 350 pages to less than 200.
16:06And we were able to do this while still capturing the unique characteristics of each of our districts and landmarks.
16:12Another major change based on feedback that we received from the public.
16:16We developed a how-to-use guide, which you can see at the beginning of the document.
16:19Our consultant, our consultant created a great graphic of a Victorian home, which calls out the various components and materials of a historic building and references the specific chapter that a citizen would need to review for your project.
16:31So you can see that in the top left-hand corner of your screen.
16:34We also added a helpful appendices to the document, including highlighting local resources like Preserve Chattanooga and our local chapter of the American Institute of Architects.
16:43And we developed what we're calling our criteria quick guide that highlight the most important guidelines from each chapter.
16:49So this is an easy one to two-page reference that community members can flip to as they're beginning their project and looking to begin reviewing the guidelines, and you can see a snip of that at the bottom left-hand side of your screen.
17:02And then some other major changes.
17:05We also created an architectural styles chapter, which captures all of the historic architectural styles within our existing historic districts and landmarks.
17:13This chapter also includes mid-century modern styles, which were missing from our previous guidelines.
17:18And we removed any painting regulations except for requirements for unpainted masonry like brick or stone.
17:24Currently, our Fortwood guidelines do regulate painting.
17:28This has not been enforced historically, so we removed it to clean it up.
17:34Some other really exciting stuff in these guidelines are some new staff review functionality.
17:40This includes staff review of small outbuildings that are 120 square feet or less.
17:45The number is based on building code as outbuildings of this size do not require a building permit.
17:51Currently, citizens within our historic districts do have to get a commission review for any kind of outbuilding that they're proposing, which can take a lot more time and money.
17:59Similarly, additions that are 120 square feet or less and meet the other guideline criteria can be captured as a staff review, again, making it a quicker and more affordable process.
18:10Parking areas for residential lots can be reviewed under staff review for up to one additional parking space.
18:17And then we updated our accessibility guidelines, and now any accessibility feature like a ramp, etc.
18:23falls under a staff review as long as they do not permanently damage the historic structure.
18:28So again, all of these changes, all of these updates will make our process more affordable and quicker for our citizens within our historic districts.
18:36Some other major changes.
18:37We completely updated our new construction section of the guidelines to better serve the historic zoning commissioners when they are reviewing new construction proposal, including more visual aids and graphics, guidelines related to siting, massing, and form, acknowledgement of parcels with topography or slopes, and language that supports neighborhood context compatibility.
18:57So you can see some examples of those graphics on the screen.
19:01We also removed some earlier sections related to regulating yard equipment like play sets and then security equipment.
19:07Those have been completely struck from the draft, and we will not regulate them.
19:12And we have included an increase to front yard fence heights from 36 inches to 42 inches based on neighborhood feedback that we received.
19:20And again, all of these major changes were implemented to meet the intent of our historic zoning ordinance to continue to preserve our historic neighborhoods, but also allow reasonable flexibility to the residents that live there.
19:32So next, I'm going to talk about the unchanged elements in the new guidelines.
19:36So first thing is preservation best practices have remained generally unchanged.
19:41This means it's still recommended that historic windows be preserved rather than replaced.
19:46Generally, the best practice is to repair materials and building components in kind.
19:51This is still true of these updated guidelines.
19:54These best practices are based on the National Park Service Secretary of Interior Standards for historic preservation.
20:01The next item, demolition guidelines have remained unchanged.
20:05Demolition is a last resort in our historic neighborhoods, and we have retained the criteria for that.
20:10We did implement a note for staff level stabilization review of properties that are in disrepair.
20:15This is a practice that's already occurring, but will be codified in these new guidelines.
20:19So if we have someone that's going through the code enforcement process or has a condemned property, they can come work with staff to stabilize the property while they get through the other processes that are required to request demolition.
20:31And the other unchanged uh unchanged section, we have consolidated the building maintenance to one chapter within these guidelines.
20:39This serves as a thorough resource for maintaining historic structures that can be used by any homeowner.
20:45This type of guidance is prevalent in our existing guidelines, but we have consolidated it to one section.
20:50You can see an example of that on the right hand side.
20:53So again, while these items generally are unchanged, they have been updated, obviously, to fit our new formatting of the guidelines, which will serve as a much more navigable document for our residents.
21:04And that's all I have for you.
21:05Thank you so much for your time this afternoon.
21:07Obviously, happy to answer any questions that you have.
21:10I have a couple questions for you.
21:12Thank you, Madam Chair.
21:13Cassie, uh two questions.
21:16How does this impact individual zoning guidelines for the four that we have existing or five?
21:23Like the underlying Euclidean zoning guidelines?
21:25Yeah, so no, each neighborhood has their own rule and uh specifications.
21:30How does this impact those?
21:32Yeah, so the well, the underlying zoning will remain the same, and that would still apply in addition to the historic district guidelines.
21:39As far as the existing historic district guidelines for for each of those neighborhoods, these will replace those, basically.
21:47For uh existing homes, are they grandfathered in if they are not uh in compliance?
21:54And how does that look like for sure?
21:57We don't have like a legal nonconformity clause in the guidelines, and we haven't had one in the past.
22:02Um the only time that the certificate of appropriateness process and using the guidelines would be prompt is is if someone is making a major change.
22:10If we're doing minor repairs or anything like that, it wouldn't be triggered.
22:13So residents would not be penalized if their current residents did not meet these guidelines.
22:26Um, this is something that I'm super interested in.
22:29Um at the beginning of the presentation, you mentioned that city council has some level of authority when it comes to this.
22:36Can you tell me what that looks like in terms of imposing some sort of historic zoning?
22:45So we have two governing documents.
22:46Essentially, we have the historic zoning ordinance, which lives in chapter 10 of the municipal code, and then we have the guidelines that are applicable to the specific lore local districts or landmarks.
22:56Within the uh chapter 10 municipal code historic zoning section, there are four different um groups that can be an applicant to make something a local historic landmark or a district.
23:07One of them would be city council through resolution.
23:10The other could be an individual within a district, like a property owner within a district, a property owner of a landmark, uh, local nonprofit group, and uh a neighborhood association is the fourth.
23:22So, what what does that look like for the city council?
23:25Say if I'm interested in in, for example, if I wanted to make the Tivoli or whatever, sure.
23:29A landmark, how does that is that the only thing we can do?
23:32I assume we can't take somebody's private property and for example, like the medical arts building that everyone is worried about.
23:40Um we couldn't say we're gonna put that on as a historic landmark for the city of Chattanooga, I'm assuming.
23:48So you yeah, so as city, we couldn't take it from like an individual city council member, is my understanding.
23:53We would want you all to adopt a resolution saying we would like to make this application, and then you would what for medical arts or like an individual landmark, you would make a historic local landmark application.
24:04We would then take it through the public process that's required to make it that landmark.
24:09So it would go, we'd have a couple public meetings, we'd go to historic zoning commission, and then we'd come back here and you would vote on it again.
24:16But you would have to decide to make that application initially as a body.
24:21Okay, so it wouldn't only be um condensed to city-owned properties.
24:28So what not that I'm aware of.
24:32This may be a legal question, but what sort of you know, rights do the property owners have to say thanks but no thanks.
24:39Yeah, so that would that's what the public process would be for, right?
24:43That's when the property owner could come out and say, This is my property, and I I don't agree with it, this is not something that I support, but that doesn't mean that they that the application couldn't move forward, is my understanding.
24:54So we could we would still take it through the entire process.
25:00Okay, whether or not it got the vote at the city council level would be kind of that final determining factor, or if that historic zoning commission they would serve as a recommending body similar to the way planning commission functions, and they would say, Yeah, which is what they did with these guidelines.
25:11We recommend that city council review this and say yes or no, basically.
25:15So under the City Code 10-14 of the city code provides for the city council neighborhood association, a property owner within the ProPros district or of the landmark or a historic civil, civic or professional society or group can make an application to have something brought in as a landmark, if that's what you're looking for.
25:35So any of those individuals can do so, they file an application with the land development office, and then it would be considered by the historic zoning commission from therefore a recommendation to y'all.
25:45Yeah, and I think generally, um I mean I can confirm with my colleagues at the state historic preservation office.
25:51But I think generally when we're looking at these kinds of ordinances across the state and the nation, we aren't necessarily seeing that you need like ownership signature or that kind of thing.
25:59You do if you're placing something on the national register of historic places, but because we have the public process that it would go through, I think that kind of serves as their opportunity to speak for or against it.
26:10So in order for the city council to uh put something on the uh local historic landmark, we would vote by resolution to do an application.
26:22That's how I would think we would handle it.
26:24So I'll divert you, but I I think um we've not seen it before, so it would be a fun test that we could all do together.
26:31Um but yes, that would be my understanding.
26:34Okay, yeah, all right, very good.
26:35I appreciate your should be something approved by the body.
26:38Yes, yes, all right.
26:39Councilwoman Dotley.
26:41Okay, thanks so much, Madam Chair Cassie.
26:43I just want to say this has been great.
26:44Uh I know we made about this a while back, and I'm glad to finally see it come to city council from um, and one of my favorite things here is the matrix.
26:52Sometimes city government, especially zoning, and then you get into historic zoning can be hard to navigate.
26:57Um, so that matrix that you have at the end of each chapter uh is really helpful along with the glossary, and then combining everybody together.
27:06Um, I just love the community feedback, just the process that you all understood.
27:10Because I get, you know, we all get all emails all the time, and I follow it when I get the historic zoning um agenda I look on it and see who is it?
27:17Let me see if there's anybody out, you know, what's going on.
27:20And so um, this has been very helpful, especially to say Elmo residents, the fencing, the increase in the fence.
27:28I know people like, oh, it don't matter.
27:30Oh, it does, it does.
27:31Uh so that is uh really I just really like the user-friendliness of the guy.
27:37Like I you I mean, just the flow chart, so it's just easy to follow, easy for anybody to follow.
27:44So I just appreciate you the work you and your staff have done on this, and uh I'm just I'm glad I'm excited someone who has the biggest one, right?
27:52Say almo it's the biggest historical district.
27:54Yes, I am uh even though some people have some three.
28:02Some uh we have the biggest, so I am uh grateful for this work because they they are very often St.
28:09Elmo is a community that participates heavily uh in a lot of uh community development and and feedback and things like that.
28:16So this is fantastic.
28:18And you can't even present to them, I believe, too as way up in a neighborhood meeting.
28:22So I appreciate you for that, and I'm just I'm excited about this.
28:26This is great, it's so user-friendly and I appreciate that.
28:28Thank you so much, Councilwoman Dotley, and thank you for calling out the matrix.
28:31I think I skipped right over that my presentation.
28:39For those of you who haven't seen it, you can see an example on the top right corner of your screen.
28:43At the end of chapters five through 12, we have a matrix that shows basically the proposed project on the left-hand side, and then whether or not it would be a historic zoning commission review or a staff level review, and then if there are conditional items um in that right-hand column that would maybe change which type of review it would be.
29:00This is really exciting because this is where we got to customize it for each neighborhood.
29:04It also I hope will serve for an easy way for other neighborhoods or landmarks to come online.
29:10They can kind of it's like a plug-and-play feature at the end of those chapters.
29:14So thank you so much.
29:15And thank you, madam chair.
29:18All right, thank you.
29:19A last question, Casey, thank you so much for this.
29:21Um, there I would say that this is probably a historic preservation-friendly council, councilman uh Harvey and I are actually working on some legislation we've been consulting with our city attorney about how to expand that because you're right, this would be a test.
29:37I know in Chairwoman Hills District of Lupton City is a historic area, and so we're very, very interested in exploring what that looks like to add things that are not added.
29:50We did a tour of the Tibley today, it's registered, but it's not protected.
29:55And so I want to thank Todd Morgan and his group of preserve chatting for educating us.
30:00Could you try again?
30:00It's okay, see what's going on there.
30:06So my question to you would be our ordinance, is it in step with state law that requires this council to apply to the zoning board, or is that something that we can amend instead of because the so when we vote to apply, it's a recommendation back to us anyway.
30:30Yeah, that's interesting.
30:30Is that redundant, or is that something that we can revise in our ordinance that would still keep us in compliance with state law?
30:39I think yes, we're in compliance with state law, is my understanding.
30:42Um, and I do see how there's a redundancy there.
30:45I'd like the city attorney to answer any questions about state law.
30:48Okay, so essentially sets up a local historic district for expert advice on whether that area does qualify as a uh you know, any area you're looking at would qualify as a historic district.
31:04And that's the reason you have special appointees to that historic zoning committee on there to give those recommendations back to you.
31:11So I think it's important to get their side of it here and then make a decision after you've heard all that in a public meeting.
31:17And you all have the ultimate authority.
31:21Okay, Cassie, that's all the questions.
31:23Thank you for the time.
31:27So council, that'll be coming up on an agenda in the future.
31:33Um, so we do have a special guest, Mayor Kelly is here.
31:37Come on up, Mayor Kelly.
31:38I believe you would like to chat with us about the uh the parking lot.
31:42Yes, I very much appreciate your time.
31:44I also want to take a moment the San Cassian staff as a Fortwood resident.
31:48Uh that was a labor of love and that's been going on for a couple of years, and uh again, there's a lot of you know, we started with the signed ordinance, we've been working through a lot of ordinance to try to make it more simple and approachable, and so I think Cassie and staff did a great job of that.
32:02Um, but I want to I'm here today really uh to talk to you about parking and about the parking ordinance that you're gonna consider.
32:09Um, you know, I'm I recently uh visited Greenville, South Carolina, and it was a vivid reminder of um what a healthy, vibrant downtown looks like and how important parking policy is to make that happen.
32:21Uh and you know, a lot you guys have been looking at a lot of parking stuff, and then the media's been full of a lot of stuff floating through, may seem unrelated, but they're not unrelated.
32:30Um it's been one of my projects since I was on the River City Board and a private citizen before I was mayor's office.
32:36But this ordinance you're considering today is going to be a really important part of that strategy.
32:42We need a healthy, vibrant downtown.
32:44Uh, and again, we're up against cities like Greenville where parking is free downtown.
32:50And so at a minimum, it needs to be affordable, it needs to be convenient, um, it needs to be you know as seamless as possible.
32:59And I think this ordinance will really uh help make that happen.
33:02Uh, part of it, frankly, is on the enforcement side, Carter's got to be able to uh to enforce.
33:07I mean, there's no point in issuing tickets if if it doesn't matter if you pay them.
33:11Uh, but uh, it's notable that you know, only serial offenders will be affected here, three or more currently delinquent parking citations, and frankly, for the foreseeable future, I think uh that people are be focused on you.
33:22May have seen or you would be shocked to see uh some of the lists and the the volume of of tickets that have piled up.
33:29Um, but I think the more important part of it really is that it will create this alignment uh of consumer alignment between public and private parking and provide consumer protections so that people just feel better.
33:42I don't you know again, I've talked to a lot of people from districts that aren't downtown, and and you know, they don't want to come downtown anymore because it's a pain.
33:50And we can't have that, right?
33:52Um, you know, and we live in a market where you can be at a strip mall in Red Bank and walk into a Mexican restaurant.
33:58Well, that's hard to compete against, you know, when when you're a restaurant downtown that's trying to attract people.
34:03So I just wanted to re-emphasize that this really is part of a larger strategy that we're working on, and kudos to Charles Frazier and his team uh for really spearheading this because again, they are the Chattanooga parking authority.
34:15This body you know divested this authority to them some years ago before many of anybody here was seated, maybe, maybe Councilman Anderson was here.
34:24But uh, but we've been working closely with them to craft this strategy, and I really really appreciate your support.
34:30Uh, and hope you'll vote for it.
34:32Thank you very much.
34:33Um would you be willing to entertain a question or absolutely certainly.
34:37Um I don't see that my colleagues have any, but I have one.
34:40Um, so we saw a pretty quick change in parking lot behavior in the last five, six years where we went from pretty pretty stable parking environment with not very many players to suddenly it was like there was a gold rush, right?
35:03And I can just imagine the salesman calling up and being like, Did you know you can monetize your parking lot?
35:10Um, so we've been this council is going to be asked to make a seemingly small change to this uh to this document.
35:20Um council, um, we have we've been asked to um just tweak the language in a small way.
35:27Um and we'll we'll talk about that more in a minute.
35:30But Mayor Kelly, when you think about that gold rush that happened in parking, would as part of that alignment, would it be ideal for us to be able to prevent new predatory parking um businesses from from setting up shop?
35:52I think I guess what I mean.
35:54I'm not trying to, I'm not trying to catch you in anything.
35:56No, no, no, I just I think about yeah, once we get this set up, that doesn't change somebody coming in and well, this is the issue that we've been considering all this time, right?
36:07Uh private property rights are pretty inviolable, right?
36:11That's that's really at the base of this.
36:12And so, you know, if you own a piece of property, you can do with it within reason as you wish, provided it's not in violation of zoning uh or any of the other things.
36:20There may be some things we can do there, but I think technology really is what is what caused that, right?
36:25Because now you can go in with an app and park, and you know, a lot of this has made it to the state level.
36:30We don't have the time to go through you know the the what's going on at the state, but I think the these consumer complaints have made it to the state level as well, uh, for better or for worse.
36:40So um I think this frankly will will help uh a tremendous amount, right?
36:46When people are able to see uh that that this parking provider is on board and that they've agreed to play by a certain set of rules, and frankly, uh Carta makes it clear that they are a trusted and friendly alternative, and they've got a lot of uh options downtown.
37:02I think you'll see things get a lot better.
37:04I think candidly from my perspective, I think that's that should be our near-term focus.
37:08Um if that doesn't do the trick, you know, we can take another bite at it.
37:13So kind of a first iteration of voluntary um standardization, and then if we were to see in increased predatory practices, then we could look at it again and see if we needed to have additional guardrails.
37:31I that would be my suggestion, and very frankly, I think a lot of those uh guardrails may wind up um getting bounced to the state level anyway.
37:38So I think working with our partners of the state on that probably makes a lot of sense as well.
37:42Okay, thank you very much for that.
37:44Thank you for your time.
37:47Um, you know, I we are now moving into um our discussion of our agenda since we're already talking about um the parking ordinance.
37:56I'm gonna skip over um that final read, and I can come back to it if we need to.
38:01Um, but we do have item A8A, um, the ordinance about um about the parking relative to booting and immobilization of vehicles.
38:12Um could you please, Phil, yes, share with the council the request by Carta Um for a slight change in the language?
38:23Um this afternoon, um, we currently have uh you've been provided version nine of this ordinance.
38:30There was one suggested uh change here this afternoon in 24512, and that one suggested change is merely to add the language of uh this ordinance will cover all people who engage in booting to be licensed and bonded, and then the language was suggested but shall not apply to commercial lot owners who do not engage in booting.
38:54And so that request for an amendment was made by Carta after some discussion with a number of the um parking owners here in the the city, and um just like they can provide you additional information about that whenever you talk, but that was the only suggested change to the ordinance that we have had in front of you and was read last week.
39:15And council, the way that it reads without that is that it's declared the intent of the chapter is that all commercial parking lot owners or all commercial parking lot owners the supplies be licensed, yeah, right.
39:31Um so that's that's the part of the question at hand.
39:35Councilman Henderson.
39:37Uh thank you about chair, and it doesn't have anything to do with this, but you you've always done very well at explaining to the audience about when they get to speak.
39:46And we didn't cover that didn't cover that.
39:48So at some point Okay, I'm gonna come back to that.
39:50After booting, we're in a rewind.
39:54Okay, so you don't have any questions about booting.
40:00Uh we do have Councilman Clark.
40:02Thank you, Madam Chair.
40:03Um, I do have a question about booting in the resolution or the amendment to the ordinance.
40:11And so are all commercial lights or all the private parking lots.
40:17Are they all would they be all considered commercial?
40:20Like if it's ran by Omega, like what so what would be the purpose of using that distinct language to specify that?
40:27Like what protection does that do?
40:29Do you understand what I'm saying?
40:30They would not be allowed to apply a boot in accordance with this new move state law here, unless they um at least were licensed here in the city to be able to do so.
40:40And conversely, if you choose not to participate in the in the booting in the licensing, if you choose not to participate in the licensing, then you can charge whatever you want.
40:54There's no regulation.
40:56So last week he mentioned that it was optional.
40:59So is this now requiring it because they're commercial?
41:02No, it's clarifying that it is fully optional.
41:05That it's a carrot, not a stick.
41:11I usually don't get the analogies, but I got that one.
41:13Okay, do we have any other questions or do we have any concerns about the proposed uh or the requested language amendment?
41:23Okay, looks like we're good on that.
41:27Um I think Phil, if if you could um distribute that language to the council and make sure our clerk has it for the for the voting portion of our meeting, that would be excellent.
41:41Yes, I sent that to Nicole earlier.
41:43Thank you very much.
41:45Okay, now we're getting in the way back machine, y'all.
41:49I'm Jenny, and I represent District 2.
41:52Um, thanks for being here.
41:54We're glad you're here at our council meeting.
41:56Want to give you just a brief um overview of how we do what we do because some of you this may be your first city council meeting, and if it is, it's your lucky day.
42:06Um, in part because our agenda is short this afternoon.
42:09Um, but so um our council meets um every week at 3 30, um, except for the 14th when we're meeting at two.
42:17Um, but we meet every week and we have a order of business in which we go over our agenda for today, and then we look at our purchases for today.
42:28We look at our um agenda for next week, and three to four weeks out.
42:33This is a council that does its homework that really is looking over the long term to make sure that we're well prepared when these votes come in front of us.
42:40Um so we are gonna go through all of that work.
42:42Um, we do not have a committee or department uh uh meeting today.
42:48Um, and then we will take a recess.
42:50That's typically a 45 minute recess because um, in as much as we've been in meeting since 9 a.m., we're gonna have more meetings with our attorney um on our break, and then we will come back for the voting portion of our meeting.
43:01At the end of that, anyone who would like to speak is very welcome to come and speak, and we will read the rules.
43:06You'll have three minutes to speak.
43:08So if you are here and intend to speak, just know that that is the order of our uh of our meeting today.
43:14So um going back to ordinances under final reading for today.
43:18That the only one we have is in district five, Councilman Clark.
43:21Do you have anything you need to discuss?
43:22Are we good to move forward?
43:23We're good to move forward.
43:25Thank you very much.
43:26Okay, resolutions council item A under resolutions.
43:30Uh, the administration has requested that this item be withdrawn.
43:38And then uh we have two other resolutions today.
43:42Does anybody have any questions about those?
43:45Looks like we're good.
43:46Okay, let's go ahead and take a look at our purchase request for today.
43:49Council, we uh we have a handful of purchases, but we don't have any um yeah, Phil's swapping out.
43:58Okay, um, don't worry, we're not here with our without our I will be back.
44:02Our what are those wheels called?
44:06Um we have no uh we have no renewals, we have no RFP format requests, we have no emergency purchases or sole source purchases.
44:15If you have any questions about these handful of purchases, please hit your light.
44:20All right, seeing none, let's take a look at our two-week agenda, please.
44:27Umrdances under first reading.
44:33We have one resolutions.
44:35We have a handful of resolutions next week, some appointments.
44:41And council, I would like you to note that starting on the Tuesday, April 7th agenda that the administration has expanded the description of on the captions to help us understand where what fund and cost center each of these purchases are are part of.
45:01So be pay paying attention to that, and we can give some feedback in the next couple of weeks about how that's working for us.
45:17Okay, I do have one question on public works item J.
45:24So this is resolution authorizing an increase to the detail experts custodial cleaning of downtown campus buildings.
45:43And so I wonder if we've had a scope of work change on that contract that would drive that cost increase.
45:48No, ma'am, it's an extension portion.
45:58Thank you very much.
45:59All right, looks like we're good on that.
46:01Okay, council, let's take a look at future considerations.
46:06Does anybody have questions about future considerations if you do hit your light?
46:14Okay, right now I don't have anybody, so I'm gonna make uh make an observation.
46:19The economic development item one A related to the waiver of park rental fees for nightfall and three sisters.
46:26We have a we have a math error there.
46:30Um we've got um it's actually fifteen days at one thousand dollars and two days at four thousand dollars for a total of nineteen.
46:42Um it's uh there's it within the caption, um it reads a total of seventeen dates at one thousand dollars per day, but it's actually fifteen.
46:53So there's just some tweaking to be done there, y'all following what I'm saying.
46:57We'll have the attorney amend that, thank you, madam chair.
47:00That's the only one with a math error that I could tell.
47:03The total ends up being the same.
47:05It's just the date count is off.
47:08Council, do we have any other questions about future considerations?
47:13Lots of board appointments.
47:16Okay, looks like we're great.
47:22So now I have to look at my own situation here.
47:26Okay, so we're all set.
47:28So council, uh, since we don't have a committee or uh department report, we will uh reconvene at five o'clock.
47:37We do have a um, we do have an attorney client meeting.
47:40Please meet us in the conference room.
47:42We're recessed until five.
1:38:06All right, we are back in session.
1:38:08Madam Clerk, please read uh ordinances under final reading item seven A.
1:38:13In order to amend Chattanooga City Co, Part Two, Chapter Thirty Eight zoning ordinance last three zone property located at thirty eight eighty six Agawella Drive from R in one six residential neighborhood zone to R and three residential neighborhood zone sub to certain conditions.
1:38:28Council, can I get a motion?
1:38:35All in uh do I have any questions or comments?
1:38:37I've got a motion and proper second.
1:39:03Thank you, Council.
1:39:04We have a motion on the floor to approve with a proper second.
1:39:07We did have a request to make an amendment.
1:39:11Do I have someone who would like to make that amendment?
1:39:23And the language in the record is a change to uh section twenty-four five twelve of the version that you have.
1:39:30And uh the specific language will be it is declared to be the purpose and intent of this chapter that all contracted property and commercial property commercial parking lot owners in the city of Chattanooga who engage in booting, be licensed and bonded, and meet the minimum requirements as set forth in this chapter for the protection and welfare of the public.
1:39:51The provisions of this chapter shall regulate the use of boots and bootings within the city, but shall not apply to commercial lot owners who do not engage in booting.
1:40:01Second okay, council.
1:40:03We have a motion on the floor to amend with a proper second.
1:40:06Do I have any questions or comments?
1:40:08All in favor of the amendment.
1:40:13Can I get a motion to approve his amended?
1:40:15So thank you, council.
1:40:18We have a motion on the floor to approve as amended with a proper second.
1:40:21Do we have any questions or comments?
1:40:26Motion to approve is amended passes.
1:40:28Thank you very much.
1:40:30Um item 9A, please.
1:40:34Resolution authorized the mayor is designed to execute a memorandum of understanding between the stadium corporation and city of Chattanooga government regarding the general expectations and responsibilities concerning the city's provision for Finley Stadium Tourism Development Zone Sales Tax Payments.
1:40:53Second, thank you.
1:40:54Council, we have a motion on the floor to withdraw with a proper second.
1:40:57Do you have any questions or comments?
1:40:58All in favor, uh opposed.
1:41:01Motion to withdraw passes.
1:41:04A resolution authorized the mayor, his design to enter into a third interlocal agreement for cooperative grant funds to River City Company for the design, implementation, and construction of Chattanooga Riverfront Parks between the River City Company, the City of Chattanooga and Hamilton County, Tennessee, for the evolving our riverfront parks project.
1:41:26Second, thank you.
1:41:27We have a motion on the floor to approve council with a proper second.
1:41:29Do you have any questions or comments?
1:41:31All in favor, aye.
1:41:34Motion passes item C.
1:41:36Resolution authorizing revisions to the employee information guide EIG policies 14.0 injury on duty to comply with current standards to be effected upon approval.
1:41:50Second, thank you.
1:41:51Council have a motion on the floor to approve with a proper second.
1:41:54Do I have any questions or comments?
1:41:59We are ready for purchases.
1:42:01That was three minutes.
1:42:05Good evening, council.
1:42:08We have five purchase recommendations for approval this evening.
1:42:11First item is a year three renewal with Volcan Materials that's requesting a 4.2% increase due to the increased cost of materials.
1:42:18The annual limit amount will be $1,022,000.
1:42:23Item number two is with wastewater.
1:42:25It's a new agreement for mixer gear reducer services.
1:42:28This will be a four-year agreement with an annual spend limit of 150,000.
1:42:33The award will go to SPX Flow Technologies as the best bid.
1:42:39Item number three is with public works.
1:42:40This is a one-time purchase for a Peterville recycled truck to be used by Solid Waste.
1:42:46This purchase from environmental products group will be in the amount of 421,891 dollars using the source well contract.
1:42:54Item number four is with public works.
1:42:56This is a one-time purchase for an international hook hoist truck to be used by street maintenance.
1:43:02This purchase from Thompson Truck Group will be in the amount of 259,999 and 97 cents using the source well contract.
1:43:12And our last items last item is with public works.
1:43:15This is a one-year extension to agreement PA 100118 and PA100119 with Pitney Bowes through March 14th, 2027 to coincide with the state of Tennessee contract.
1:43:30The annual limit will be 190,000.
1:43:35Council, we have a motion on the floor to approve with the proper second.
1:43:38Do we have any questions or comments?
1:43:44Thank you very much.
1:43:48We've reached the point we're gonna have some committee reports.
1:43:51Councilman Henderson.
1:43:54Councilman Harvey.
1:43:57Councilman Elliott.
1:43:58Thank you, Madam Chair.
1:43:59Next week we'll have economic development committee meeting where we will hear from our restorative ventures uh for update regarding what is happening with our bin project.
1:44:12Councilwoman Dotley, thanks so much, Madam Chair.
1:44:14We did have a budget work session this morning at 9 a.m.
1:44:17where we discussed uh four financial policies, uh our uh potential uh budget framework as well as the budget analysis of review uh report that the ACUV did for us.
1:44:30So uh we do plan to have those financial policies on our two-week agenda and uh of course I'll be sending you out the framework information as well, and we'll be looking at some follow-up items specifically dealing with peer cities, and that is all.
1:44:43Thank you very much.
1:44:46Thank you, madam chair.
1:44:47We will have a planning and zoning committee meeting next week, and the items that we'll be reviewing are will be at that point on our two week agenda.
1:44:56Thank you very much.
1:44:57Vice Chairwoman Noel.
1:45:00for us so uh we do plan to have those financial policies on our two-week agenda and uh of course i'll be sending you out the framework information as well and we'll be looking at some follow-up items specifically dealing with peer cities and that is all thank you very much okay thank you councilwoman burrs thank you madam chair we will have a planning and zoning committee meeting next week and the items that we'll be reviewing are will be at that point on our two week agenda thank you very much vice chairwoman no report all right and just i will note that we did do a Tivoli tour today and I'll say that um we've got a lot of exciting projects in the in the hopper for Chattanooga it's a neat time um to to be here and live here and be a leader here so thank you all for all your hard work um okay we have now reached the point in our meeting where we are happy to hear from persons who are here who would like to address the council if you are here and you'd like to address the council please go ahead and line up behind the podium and listen while our attorney reads the rules if we have anyone that's going to get in line our attorney will read otherwise he will not go in once going twice going twice all right council I do not see that we have anyone here who would like to address the council what is your prejust can I get a second yes council we have a motion on the floor to adjourn with the proper second all in favor of adjourning all right we're adjourned