OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Marine Advisory Board Meeting - September 9, 2026

Clearwater Municipal MeetingsWednesday, September 9, 2026
BodyClearwater, Florida
SessionClearwater Municipal Meetings
DateWednesday, September 9, 2026
StatusNEW · FILED
Video Record
0:00 / 1:16:47

Transcript — Verbatim
10:00

And it's not a good idea.

11:45

Yeah, just popped up there for a second.

11:49

Are we on?

11:50

Whenever you're ready, sir.

11:52

Okay.

11:52

We're on.

11:55

I would.

11:57

What is the date?

12:00

I would like to call the September 9th, 2026 Marine Advisory Board meeting to order.

12:10

First agenda item two point one.

12:14

The approval of the June 10th, 2026 meeting.

12:17

Has everybody had a chance to peruse those?

12:20

Yes.

12:21

Do I have a motion?

12:22

I'll make a motion.

12:23

Second.

12:25

All in favor?

12:26

Aye.

12:27

That is passed.

12:30

Right away, we can get to our citizen to be heard for things not on the agenda.

12:36

If you would like to take the stand and take the stand.

12:42

Please tell us and spell your name, please.

12:45

Mike Colby, C O L BY, current president of the Clearwater Marine Association, representing the charter boats in the Clearwater Beach Marina.

12:55

And I want to thank all of you for being here today.

12:58

It was airily quiet at first.

13:12

Now, it isn't my intention to come here and say we don't want an increase.

13:17

We're going to get one.

13:41

I'm speaking on their behalf.

13:47

Maybe in two to three year deposits.

13:50

So that does several things.

13:52

One, that gives our market time to respond to a drastic increase in our pricing.

14:09

So that's a concern.

14:11

So I would like to see maybe a memorandum of request or understanding sent to council that says if we're going to have this increase, can we do it incrementally?

14:23

So our operators can make plans and respond to it, and our market can respond to it.

14:46

Now a tour boat can put five dollars on a ticket and kind of overcome large increases.

15:00

And you know, it it would be very helpful for us to have that increase come in in increments.

15:06

So we can all adjust to it.

15:08

Our operators can set pricing where we think our locals and our tourists will respond to that.

15:15

Because they come, they're gonna come here to fish, but they're not gonna come here to lose money, a lot of money either.

15:22

And the other request would be, and I've talked with Mike about this, is possibly leveraging some of our fuel pricing when we do get fuel services back in the marina, leveraging that against the increases.

15:48

And I think that's still set around 45 cents a gallon, something like that.

15:53

So if we could trim some of that, leverage it against the increases, that would certainly help because well, obviously, right now fuel is hurting everyone.

16:03

It's hurting my customers, it's hurting you guys, hurting our operators.

16:08

So it's uh, you know, it may it may be reasonable for us to request some kind of leverage against increases by looking at how can we massage that uh surcharge that's on the fuel.

16:25

So that is my intent for you guys to hopefully inform along with Mike, and form counsel of those those two requests.

16:35

If you have any questions, I'm ready.

16:36

Thank you.

16:37

Any questions?

16:38

Yeah, I've got I've got a question.

16:40

How does and it's kind of to you and Mike, uh, how how does the slip rent at the marina compare to other similar facilities in the area, not statewide, but just in this area?

16:51

Competitive higher or lower?

16:53

Well, I I've been told that the there's been another survey uh on top of the one that was done, I think initially about a year ago, that showed that we're still under market.

17:06

Okay.

17:06

Now, does that mean we have to be over market or at market?

17:11

I I don't know.

17:12

I mean, if what we want as a collective, if we want Fort Lauderdale on the West Coast, but we're headed in the right direction.

17:22

We are but so uh I'm unsure, and the initial survey that was done, uh even the vendor that did that survey and one of their paragraphs in the survey admitted that they're not sure the economy would handle uh huge increases, and they did that survey based on property value in this area, not on it what will the market bear.

17:48

Right.

17:48

And those are two separate issues.

17:50

Now, unfortunately, I may have the resources, maybe not the time to engage uh a vendor or a firm that can provide a true market survey.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Marina Management█████████████████████████████████████████████48%
Marina Operations█████████████14%
Environmental Protection████████9%
Procedural██████6%
Parking Management█████5%
Public Facilities███3%
Legal Affairs███3%
Grant Funding███3%
Public Safety███3%
Summary of Proceedings

Marine Advisory Board Meeting - September 9, 2026

The Clearwater Marine Advisory Board convened on September 9, 2026, at the Main Library Council Chambers. The meeting included public comments on proposed slip rate increases, updates on marina reconstruction projects, discussions on the Stevenson Creek Manatee Protection Zone, and parking concerns at Seminole Boat Ramp.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Mike Colby (President, Clearwater Marine Association, representing charter boats at Beach Marina) requested that any future slip rent increases be phased in over 2-3 years to allow operators and the market to adjust. He also suggested leveraging the fuel surcharge (approximately $0.45 per gallon) against the increases. He expressed appreciation for the reconstruction project but stressed the need for incremental adjustments to sustain businesses.
  • Jack Mahoney (recreational boater, slip A5) strongly opposed the proposed 113% increase for recreational slip rates, arguing it would drive boaters away. He presented his own market survey showing that St. Petersburg Municipal Marina, a key competitor, offers lower rates and better services (e.g., free parking, fuel, docking assistance). He criticized Harbor Marina as a "parking lot for boats" and urged the city to match St. Pete rates.

Discussion Items

  • Beach Marina Reconstruction Project Update: Kelly Petrich (Engineering Division Manager) reported the project is on schedule for completion by end of September. Remaining work includes fuel line installation and electrical conduit on Dock A, plus extension of catwalks for the Queen Fleet and Double Eagle vessels. An artwork unveiling is set for September 24, with a ribbon-cutting ceremony in late October/early November.
  • Harbor Marina Repairs Update: Two separate projects – the South End (Kelly Brothers) is in submittal phase with construction expected in spring 2027; the North End contract has not been awarded. Staff hopes to combine both projects before the next storm season. Wave attenuation attenuators are included. A broken dock remains due to permitting delays and high mobilization costs.
  • Seminole Boat Ramp Updates: The project will go out to bid in 4-6 weeks, with construction expected in spring 2027. The scope involves repairing ramp bottoms from waterside down; staff will evaluate doing all work at once to save mobilization costs.
  • Stevenson Creek Manatee Protection Zone Update: Mike McDonald (Aviation Director) reported that City Council approved both readings of the ordinance establishing the zone, developed with FWC and advocacy groups. Next steps include permitting and installing markers, then removing existing slow-speed zone signs near bridges. A board member expressed concern about a news story tying the zone to a private dock project, emphasizing they are unrelated; the board urged swift implementation.
  • Parking at Seminole Boat Ramp: A board member proposed angling some parking spaces for personal watercraft trailers to accommodate increased jet ski traffic, as Dunedin plans to make its launch resident-only and may ban personal watercraft. Discussion included possible lease of an adjacent vacant lot. No decisions were made.

Key Outcomes

  • Approved the June 10, 2026 meeting minutes (unanimous).
  • Board will consider drafting a recommendation to City Council for incremental slip rent increases and fuel surcharge adjustments for commercial tenants, based on public comments.
  • Noted that recreational slip rates were already approved by Council effective October 1, 2026; the board will review Mr. Mahoney's data for future consideration.
  • Directed staff to explore grant opportunities for manatee sign rejuvenation.
  • No formal vote on rate changes; these remain under Council purview.

Meeting Transcript

And it's not a good idea. Yeah, just popped up there for a second. Are we on? Whenever you're ready, sir. Okay. We're on. I would. What is the date? I would like to call the September 9th, 2026 Marine Advisory Board meeting to order. First agenda item two point one. The approval of the June 10th, 2026 meeting. Has everybody had a chance to peruse those? Yes. Do I have a motion? I'll make a motion. Second. All in favor? Aye. That is passed. Right away, we can get to our citizen to be heard for things not on the agenda. If you would like to take the stand and take the stand. Please tell us and spell your name, please. Mike Colby, C O L BY, current president of the Clearwater Marine Association, representing the charter boats in the Clearwater Beach Marina. And I want to thank all of you for being here today. It was airily quiet at first. Now, it isn't my intention to come here and say we don't want an increase. We're going to get one. I'm speaking on their behalf. Maybe in two to three year deposits. So that does several things. One, that gives our market time to respond to a drastic increase in our pricing. So that's a concern. So I would like to see maybe a memorandum of request or understanding sent to council that says if we're going to have this increase, can we do it incrementally? So our operators can make plans and respond to it, and our market can respond to it. Now a tour boat can put five dollars on a ticket and kind of overcome large increases. And you know, it it would be very helpful for us to have that increase come in in increments. So we can all adjust to it. Our operators can set pricing where we think our locals and our tourists will respond to that. Because they come, they're gonna come here to fish, but they're not gonna come here to lose money, a lot of money either. And the other request would be, and I've talked with Mike about this, is possibly leveraging some of our fuel pricing when we do get fuel services back in the marina, leveraging that against the increases. And I think that's still set around 45 cents a gallon, something like that. So if we could trim some of that, leverage it against the increases, that would certainly help because well, obviously, right now fuel is hurting everyone. It's hurting my customers, it's hurting you guys, hurting our operators. So it's uh, you know, it may it may be reasonable for us to request some kind of leverage against increases by looking at how can we massage that uh surcharge that's on the fuel. So that is my intent for you guys to hopefully inform along with Mike, and form counsel of those those two requests. If you have any questions, I'm ready. Thank you. Any questions? Yeah, I've got I've got a question. How does and it's kind of to you and Mike, uh, how how does the slip rent at the marina compare to other similar facilities in the area, not statewide, but just in this area?

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com