3:15I do want to see how this works.
4:13No, I think we had what you went two or three pieces.
4:26This committee of finance diversity, equity, and inclusion is called to order.
4:30Uh, Madam Clerk, please call the road.
5:00The first ordinance is ordinance number 1072 2025 as amended by Council Members Bishop and Griffin by Departmental Request and Emergency Ordinance to amend the fourth whereas clause and sections one, three, and four of ordinance number five forty-nine-2025 passed June 2, 2025, relating to an amendment to a contract with the Osborne Engineering Company to provide additional services relating to the North Coast Connector Project, aka Lakefront Pedestrian Bridge Connector.
5:21It also says there is no legal objection to this legislation if amended as follows.
5:27One in section one at amended section four, strike lines three and four in their entirety, and insert not exceed five million dollars, and shall be paid from the fund to funds two.
5:41And this was done 10925 by Jeffrey Marks, Assistant Director of Law.
5:49Johnson, you have the uh I'm sorry, assistant director.
5:53Um you had a full say Johnson Chambers.
5:55Okay, gotcha, Johnson Chambers.
5:57Um to the president to the um committee.
6:00Yes, this is to um make clerical changes in the already um amended ordinance 549, um those clerical changes remove the um assignment of fourth modification to actually read second amendment to the contract, um, and that is done twice as well as to um strike the request for um the five the four point the five million dollars okay uh councilman bishop you relieved this uh to our committee.
6:36Uh did you have any comments?
6:39We uh we reviewed this piece of legislation and uh we uh uh relieved it and it's fully supportive passion.
6:47I have a question, Mr.
6:48Uh councilman Michael Palensky.
6:50Yes, I'm just trying to get some clarification because my laptop is down.
6:53Uh is this the connector between City Hall and the courthouse?
6:57Yes, it's for work related to the connector, yes.
7:00So are there any no dollar amounts being changed, correct?
7:05Correct, no dollar amounts being changed.
7:07This is just clarification of modification versus amendment.
7:11Okay, that's all I'm trying to understand.
7:13Councilman Casey Thank you, Mr.
7:18President's assistant director, if you say no dollar amounts are changed, and we're changing the dollar amount from five million to four million five hundred thousand that was per the ordinance five four nine.
7:32We had initially requested the funding in that ordinance.
7:36So this actual change was to remove the request for the five million.
7:44So maybe this needs to be an amendment that I make here at the table.
7:49Um, is to change the five million from this ordinance.
7:56But I thirdly in the ordinance, right?
7:58It's it's I mean, to remove, excuse me, to remove.
8:02So maybe that's an amendment I need to make here.
8:04This was discussed, so I did not know this procedural part of this, but this five million is not to be included in the current legislation because in 549 we requested 5 million.
8:15So maybe I should make that amendment request that amendment here at the table.
8:21Well, if you have are you saying that in 549?
8:25Yes, that you have thank you $5 million for this, Mr.
8:30President, to the assistant director.
8:32So if you have five million dollars in 549, why would you need 4.5 million dollars in 1072?
8:39To the chair to councilman Casey, I do not need so I think I need to make a request to amendment.
8:48Okay, so let me let me do do this.
8:50I'll I'll make the amendment to scratch the 4.5 million from this legislation together.
8:55Chairman, I'll make uh an amendment.
8:58Uh sorry strike section four in its entirety or just the four point four.
9:08No, no, because it's just the cost of the there is there's an amendment there, but we're talking a second amendment cost the additional permanent house.
9:16All right, so then you want to clarify the amendment so that we could get a second.
9:19Yeah, so under section four, um after the amended second amendment, period, and then strike everything after uh shell in line two all the way to the to the rest in section four is that sufficient, Ms.
9:37Chambers Professional Service Plum Red Design Something right here No, let me let me correct that, Mr.
9:49Chairman under under line two after the amended second amendment period from shell all the way to line three, four, five, six, seven, eight to line nine after amended should be stricken from from the legislation, and then we keep no other funding sources.
10:01To line nine after amended should be stricken from the legislation.
10:07And then we keep no other funding sources.
10:11Should be paid from if you're saying you don't need dollars for this amount for this.
10:17Well, she's looking at that.
10:18Do we have a second?
10:22But I have another question.
10:25Miss Chambers, is that any discussion on that amendment?
10:30Any uh any since there is no discussion?
10:33Uh all in favor say aye.
10:37Uh Councilman Kings, do you have anything else?
10:41I'm I'm a little confused here.
10:43Um it was my understanding that the connector was 284 million.
10:50Well, I see 447 million in here.
10:58Professional service preliminary design.
11:0311 million construction cost 447 million.
11:08How did we that's total project cost?
11:11Total project cost is 470 million.
11:15This portion that we're working to complete now is just phase one and two, which includes from West Third to East 9th Street.
11:24And that is the 270.
11:26So how much of the 447 million is in hand?
11:31We have 160 million in hand right now.
11:36So that'll help us with the first phase.
11:40We've estimated around 400.
11:41And where do you where do you um where do you think the rest of the money is going to come from to do this?
11:48This lake from there's a variety of different tools they're looking at.
11:51One is the TIFF, and I believe they presented that to council.
11:55And then additional grant funds.
11:57So this again from East 9th to where?
12:02From East 9th to East 18th Street is considered the second or third phase of the project that we that we do not have current funding for at the moment.
12:15But from West Third to East 9th, we have funded.
12:19Is and is there, Mr.
12:20Chairman, just a wrap up.
12:21Is there a is there a design for this entire lakefront plan?
12:26Is there a design that we could look at it and say here it is?
12:28Is there a design for that?
12:30There's a design for the bridge and for the shoreway realignment.
12:35No, we're not a design.
12:37We're still in pre-engineering.
12:39But from there north, which would include the Brown Stadium, President Brown State.
12:44There's a proposed master plan.
12:46And that's something we could look at.
12:50Can we get a copy of that?
12:51I don't know if all members have that, but I would request we make sure we request that full master plan.
12:56For that whole entire lakefront plan.
13:01I can see a lot of money going here on the lake front.
13:04And our neighbors and our residents at our neighborhoods are saying, Whoa, whoa, whoa, wait a minute.
13:08What about all these things we need in our neighborhoods?
13:11Um that are so um that are there is such need in the neighborhoods.
13:16Um that's a half a billion dollars going in the lake front.
13:22Okay, I'll look forward to getting that.
13:26All right, thank you.
13:27Uh any other questions regarding ordinance number 1072-2025.
13:34Seeing other questions, ordinance number 10 to 72-2025 as amended stands approved.
13:43Um, the next one is ordinance number 1223-2025 as amended by council members Harrison and Griffin by departmental request.
13:51An emergency ordinance authorizing the mayor and the commissioner of purchases and supplies to sell certain owned city city, certain city-owned property no longer needed for the city's public use, located on East 90th Street to Ortho School Properties LLC, or is designed for purposes of developing a hotel.
14:13Uh there is an amendment on this, and I would read as follows.
14:23One in section one at the end, add an additional legal description to read as follows.
14:30Parcel number one one nine-zero nine-zero four-one, situated in the city of Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, and state of Ohio, and known as being the northerly 30 feet of sub lot number 26 in the resurvey of S V Harkness subdivision of part of original 100 acre lot 400, as shown by the recorded plat in volume 31 of maps, page 8 of Cuyahoga County Records, and being 30 feet from 30 feet front on the easterly side of East 90th Street, formerly Harkness Avenue, and extending back equal width 141 feet as appears by said plat, be the same more or less, but subject to all legal highways, parcel number 119 09-041, address 1819 East 999.
15:00Parcel number 119-09-041, situated in the city of Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, and State of Ohio, and known as being the northerly 30 feet of sub lot number 26 in the resurvey of SV Harkness subdivision of part of original 100-acre lot 400, as shown by the recorded plat in volume 31 of maps, page 8 of Cuyahoga County Records, and being 30 feet from 30 feet front on the easterly side of East 90th Street, formerly Harkness Avenue, and extending back equal width 141 feet as appears by said plat, be the same more or less, but subject to all legal highways, parcel number 119-09-041, address 1819 East 90th Street, Cleveland, Ohio, 44106.
15:42This request is by the Department of Community Development to sell five parcels now.
15:47You just read the amendment, thank you.
15:50To sell five parcels to Ortho School Properties LLC, uh so that they can build a hotel uh between the streets of East 90th and East 93rd Streets uh to the east and west, and uh Chester Avenue to the south, Huff Avenue to the north.
16:08Uh the request is to sell those parcels.
16:11The hotel development is uh for Marriott Affiliate, Spring Hill Suites.
16:17Bowen uh here who can speak more about the project if there are questions about it.
16:22Uh but with the amendment that you just read, um uh council president, uh there is a second amendment I need to request on this as well.
16:32Uh it's for the same parcels, but because the price has increased, and my my apologies first to uh development planning and sustainability chair, councilman Harrison.
16:43Uh when I was asked last week uh about a price on the parcel, I didn't have that available.
16:48The price is $13,000 for the parcel.
16:52So because the overall price for all five parcels now increases to $65,000.
16:58Uh I need to request uh a second amendment to add that price in.
17:03Pass it to councilman Harrison.
17:08If you would like to read that into the record and we get a uh move thank you.
17:19Um, this is the other parcel.
17:23Just the additional parcel, right?
17:25Uh yes, for the additional parcel.
17:27Yeah, this is the one that we amended to add.
17:29Uh I make a motion, Mr.
17:32Chair, uh number one in section one at the end, add an additional legal description to read as follows, parcel numbers 119-09-041, situated in the city of Cleveland, Cuyahoga, County of Cuyahoga and State of Ohio, and known as being the northerly 30-foot of sub lot number 26 in the resurvey of S V Harkness subdivision, uh part of the original 100-acre uh lot number 400, as shown by the recorded plat in volume 31 of maps, page 8 of Cuyahoga County Records, and being 30 feet front of the easterly side of East 90th Street, formerly Harkness Av Harkness Avenue, and extending back of equal width 14 141 feet as appears by said plat be the same more or less, but subject to all legal highways.
18:21Parcel number 119-09-041, address 1819 East 90th Street, Cleveland, Ohio 44106.
18:30And a second amendment, second part of that in section two, line three, strike 52,000 and inserts 65,000, Mr.
18:40Uh do we have a second?
18:42Councilman Mike Palencia seconded.
18:46Just a question on this.
18:47Councilwoman Jasmine Center.
18:49To the chair and to Mr.
18:51What's the appraisal value for these parcel parcels?
18:55Through the chair to the councilwoman, $13,000.
18:58Okay, that's so you're selling it at the appraisal amount.
19:01Through the chair to the councilwoman.
19:05Uh seeing other discussion.
19:06All in favor say aye.
19:10Councilman Michael Palency.
19:13Uh is this north of Chester or south of Chester?
19:18Through the chair to the councilman north of Chester.
19:22So I see the it's going around.
19:26It looks like two houses.
19:30Through the chair to the councilman.
19:33Uh through the chair to Councilman Palency.
19:36Yes, it currently is doing, it is going around.
19:40Um what I will say is is this is not a final plan here.
19:44So just to, if I if you don't mind, Councilman, let me back up a little bit on why we're here.
19:49For us to get financing for the project, we need to show some sort of control, and I'm using that very loosely, of the city land.
20:00So we have not started the planning commission process.
20:02We are not gone through all of that.
20:04This is just as simply the deed, and I'm sure Commissioner Green would say this.
20:08The deeds not being transferred toward to us until we go through planning commission, BZA, and all those other things.
20:15We this is kind of getting us a letter to show the bank that we can then move forward to the next step.
20:21So from a design perspective, we have not even um started touching this project.
20:29Chairman, the so it it's not given.
20:33Uh through the chair to Councilman Palenzick, that's correct.
20:37So whose ward is this?
20:39This is Councilwoman House Jones.
20:41House Jones ward as of today, January 1.
20:46If less something happens, it would be council President Griffin's ward.
20:52So that was what is the council lady in support of this?
20:56Um the council lady, uh, I'm sorry, through the chair to Councilman Palenzick.
21:01The councilwoman has recused herself from this project because her mother's house is next to the project.
21:09Oh it's complicated.
21:12It is very complicated.
21:14I'm just trying to understand because you know you've got all these houses around it.
21:19Looks like single family homes around this.
21:22Uh at least that looks like this map here.
21:27I'm just wondering how you stick a hotel federal for all these houses.
21:31Yeah, through through the chair to councilman Palency.
21:34Um, we're gonna work through that with planning commission.
21:37We we pledged to that.
21:39Um, we actually did that through uh Chairman Harris's committee when we talked about this to walk through all of those things, but there is no property being transferred, and I think that's an important point to us until we get through planning commission, BZA, and other things.
21:56This is just a I don't want to call a letter of support, it's more than that.
22:00And community engagement and other things else.
22:03Yeah, it's all of that.
22:04So it's not like we're gonna get this sell the your lots to you.
22:13Yeah, that through the chair to councilman polenzick.
22:16It actually is a risk we're taking on this project.
22:19Um that that I'll leave it there.
22:24All right, any other questions on uh this ordinance?
22:30Uh Councilman uh Harrison.
22:33I think it's also uh of note worth noting that actually it's not two houses that sits there, it's actually one.
22:38They actually own one of the properties that sits there.
22:41Uh that's next to the development site.
22:43So not both houses are a residents.
22:46Uh the one house actually that they own, they have control over in the last house that's there that they are uh in negotiations, my understanding, uh, to try to um address that last parcel that sits there based on the comments that were given and share with us at the last uh DPS uh meeting.
23:03Yeah, and through the chair to Councilman Palenzik and Councilman Harrison, there's actually a land bank parcel in there too.
23:10So there's actually we actually control two of the three parcels in there.
23:15The design was made this way because of that last parcel, which we are very um well aware, and commissioner knows this as well, that we're gonna have to work through this with planning commission and and others.
23:28Um, but you know, in full transparency, I said this during DPS.
23:33The last um parcel was an absorbent or it was a very large amount of money that they were asking for, and it actually did not make the project pencil.
23:45So we are um trying to adjust accordingly.
23:59Any other questions regarding ordinance number 1223-2025 as amended?
24:05Okay, so ordinance number 1223-2025 as amended stands approved.
24:13All right, the last piece of legislation is ordinance number 1323-2025 by Councilmember Griffin by departmental request and emergency ordinance approving the collective bargaining agreement with the utility workers union of America, AFL CIO, local 270, and to amend Section 12 of ordinance number 194-2021 passed March 29th, 2021 as amended relating to compensation for various classifications.
24:41Thank you, Chairman Committee.
24:43Yes, this is uh request to ratify the successor agreement with um utility workers of America, FLCIO, local 270, and the city of Cleveland for the period uh incorporating April 1, 2025 through March 31, 2028, and then amend the uh associated pay ban, Section 12 with the uh the new rates.
25:07This uh contract affects approximately 60 employees, 60 bargaining unit members, uh including water plant operators, stationary engineers, and uh boiler room operators.
25:20Um certainly happy to answer any questions should anybody have any.
25:24All right, thank you.
25:25Uh are there any questions regarding ordinance number 1323-2025?
25:31All right, seeing no other questions, ordinance number 1323-2025 stands approved.
25:37It will be heard for consideration by the full body this evening.
25:42That being said, this committee of finance, diversity, equity, and inclusion is adjourned.