OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Cleveland City Council Meeting Summary - November 24, 2025

City Council MeetingsMonday, November 24, 2025
BodyCleveland, Ohio
SessionCity Council Meetings
DateMonday, November 24, 2025
StatusFILED
Video Record

STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE

Transcript — Verbatim
12:06

Madam Clerk, please call the road.

12:08

Griffin here.

12:10

Bishop.

12:13

Bishop.

12:16

Cromwell.

12:27

Gray.

12:29

Harrison.

12:30

Harsh.

12:32

House Jones.

12:33

Jones.

12:34

Casey.

12:36

Kelly.

12:37

Moore, Polensick, Santana, Slife, Spencer, Star, Welch.

12:48

Well, everyone, please rise for a moment of silence, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance.

12:59

Thank you.

13:00

I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands.

13:07

One nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

13:55

Such disruptions may constitute a misdemeanor and a violation of Section Six O five dot oh four.

14:01

Anyone who disrupts this lawful meeting is in violation of the codified ordinances, commits misdemeanors, and is subject to prosecution.

14:11

The following is the first and only warning.

14:13

If this meeting is disrupted, I will gabble a halt to the proceedings and direct the assembled officers to escort any person participating in the disruption out of the chamber.

14:23

Once persons participating in a disruption are out of the chambers, the officers will close the doors and the disruptors will be handled as directed by the Director of Public Safety.

15:03

Thank you.

15:04

We will now move to public comment.

15:06

Once again, I'm asking all of the council to turn around and acknowledge the speakers, and I'm asking all of the speakers to acknowledge your time.

15:13

Many of you have uh spoken before, so you pretty much know the routine.

15:17

Yellow means to wrap it up, red means to abruptly stop.

15:22

Please come forward.

15:24

The first person that we have is Terry Wong.

15:26

She's from Ward 3.

15:28

Terry is here to talk about flock and other flock ups by the city of Cleveland.

15:33

She's not representing anyone and not being paid by anyone.

15:37

Ms.

15:37

Wong, you had the floor.

15:39

Good evening.

15:40

If Alfred Hitchcock were alive today, he wouldn't need to imagine a horror film about birds overwhelming a town.

15:47

He could just film Cleveland.

15:49

In August 2022, the first flock automatic license plate reader appeared, perched on a pole like a mechanical raven, silent and watching.

15:59

And then just like in the birds, they multiplied.

16:02

Within two months, nearly 100 had settled across the city, tracking our movements without a single public conversation.

16:09

And here's the twist Hitchcock would have loved.

16:12

I was serving on the community police commission at the time, and even I wasn't told.

16:16

The oversight body created by voters through issue 24, the one meant to shape police policy and protect civil rights, found out only after these machines were everywhere.

16:26

If the commission wasn't informed, the public was never meant to be.

16:30

Then came the horror level defects.

16:41

These aren't small bugs, they are structural flock-ups that create enormous legal liability for Cleveland.

16:48

If a hacked camera triggers a wrongful arrest or leaks personal information, it's Clevelanders, not flock, who will pay the price.

16:57

But instead of removing these invasive birds, the city seems eager to make a sequel.

17:02

Cleveland has recently spent 150,000 on a shot spotter study, even though decades of research already questioned its value.

17:10

And CSU researchers could barely reach conclusions because ShotSpotter and CPD couldn't provide full data sets.

17:17

Now, after Shot Spider failed to prove itself, the city wants to spend another three million to switch to Flock's gunshot technology detection tech system without testing it first.

17:28

We are literally buying the sequel before we understand the first movie.

17:31

And then comes the final plot twist.

17:34

City council persony McCormack left office early to work for Flock.

17:39

Ohio has a one-year revolving door law.

17:42

Why haven't you enforced it?

17:44

If council cannot oversee its own colleagues, how can it oversee a multi-million dollar surveillance network with known vulnerabilities?

17:52

Meanwhile, people sleep on bare concrete outside public auditorium.

17:56

Neighborhoods lack grocery stores, transit, and stable housing.

18:00

So I asked the central question.

18:02

Why are council and the mayor's office misspending public money on technology they don't understand that doesn't work and that exposes Cleveland to lawsuits?

18:11

And when we aren't even funding the things that make our community safe and livable.

18:47

So I'm gonna just babble today.

18:50

But I'll be back to talk about real issues after the holiday.

18:53

I think everybody deserves a break.

18:55

I don't watch all of y'all's body language for the last 12 months, and a lot of y'all are mentally tired.

19:00

Okay, rightfully so, because this is a hard job that you guys have in front of you to do.

19:05

But I want all you guys, everybody in this body to go home.

19:08

I want you to do some deep soul searching and ask yourself have I done enough for this paycheck that I'm receiving?

19:16

Have I served my community in the way that I was elected to serve my community?

19:21

Have I done enough to better people's lives that I've been placed in charge to do?

19:28

Okay.

19:29

And I have a long list of report cards of a lot of things that you guys are complicit with.

19:35

Okay.

19:36

You have to stop.

19:38

You're getting paid.

19:39

The people believed in you because they voted for you guys.

19:42

We don't deserve what we're receiving from all elected officials.

19:46

And I mean all elected officials.

19:48

There's nobody not complicit to what's going on in this city right now.

19:55

Okay.

20:00

I heard some good stuff today, but I can guarantee you a lot of people in 2029 will swallow that whistle.

20:05

And I hope some of you guys are still sitting here, so I can point out how you made the biggest mistake in the history of the city of Cleveland.

20:14

Because this is a mistake to let the Browns leave.

20:18

There's no other revenue that you can replace for the Brown Stadium, sir.

20:22

I don't care who in this body or who in the state of Ohio believe that they have a better idea to take the Browns to Brook Park.

20:29

Brook Park don't even have a complete police station.

20:32

They don't have but one fire station.

20:34

There's a lot of red tape that's gonna come out that you guys have not considered.

20:39

There's a lot more money that's needed to fulfill that dream in Brook Park, and it's not being talked about.

20:48

Okay?

20:49

It's not.

20:50

There are too many entities that go to that.

20:54

You guys are just touching the surface of it.

20:57

Let's get to the pie.

20:59

Because the pie is there, and you won't fulfill any obligations out there in Brook Park.

21:05

And I'm willing to bet my finances on it.

21:08

Okay.

21:09

And I want you guys to think about these things because you do have some hard decisions to make.

21:13

And yes, the mayor did make a big mistake.

21:16

And I'm gonna publicly say he made the biggest mistake in Cleveland history.

21:21

Okay.

21:22

And I'm gonna stand on that one.

21:23

And I'm willing to stand on some other things too in the near future.

21:27

Because I don't think you guys understand that the power is always gonna be with the people.

21:33

I don't care what y'all think y'all are gonna do.

21:35

You're gonna do what the people want down here, or you won't sit in none of these seats down here.

21:40

And I can promise you that.

21:41

Okay?

21:42

Because I got my own money.

21:44

And I have a lot of supporters.

21:46

Time, thank you.

21:48

Houston, appreciate it.

21:49

Next, we have Dean Van Farrell from Ward 7 to talk about appreciation for outgoing councilwoman Jenny Spencer.

21:57

Uh Jean is not Dean is not representing anyone not being paid by anyone.

22:00

Dean, you have the floor.

22:02

Council President and Council members, I stand today during this Thanksgiving week to thank my council person, Jenny Spencer of Ward 15, who will be concluding her service next month.

22:13

She would be the last person to want public praise, and so it's ironic that I'm able to do this because of this public comment period, envisioned and created by Jenny.

22:22

It's a microcosm of what we appreciate so much about you.

22:27

Public comment reflects your passion for public participation in our government.

22:32

You want to hear from us.

22:33

You've always valued our feedback.

22:36

As my wife, Christine told me, Jenny engages with those who disagree with her to both learn and teach.

22:43

You don't listen carefully because it makes you look open-minded, but because you are.

24:27

Thank you.

24:27

We are grateful for you.

24:29

Happy Thanksgiving, and see you in the neighborhood.

24:32

Thank you.

24:33

Next, we have Norman Edwards.

24:37

Norman Edwards is from Ward 3.

24:39

He's here to talk about the lack of diversity and inclusion.

24:42

He represents the black contractors group, and he is not being paid by anyone.

24:46

There's Norman Edwards here.

24:48

Norman Edwards going once.

24:50

Norman Edwards going twice.

24:52

Mr.

24:52

Edwards is not here.

24:54

Next, we have Fauzi Badour, Frauzi Badours from Ward 11.

24:57

He is uh the topic he's talking about is the coalition.

25:00

Uh he's not representing anyone and not being paid by anyone.

25:04

Mr.

25:04

Vator.

25:05

Good evening.

25:05

Let me start by wishing you all, including Danny Kelly and Chris Harsh, the Lester Breacher of the Gaza Station.

25:12

He remained here.

25:13

Happy Thanksgiving.

25:16

Democracy.

25:18

Democracy start with people.

25:25

People are the source of democracy and the base of authority.

25:32

Any decisions made by any institution, by any legislation, including this council, must reflect the will of the people.

25:43

I mentioned that because today I just now I changed all my speech because I found out that the court of Judge Kevin Kelly, which I thank him, on behalf of our coalition and on behalf of our committee, rejected the gas cartel appeal to to change the zoning at 100 to Madison Avenue.

26:12

Now they lost us at the first.

26:17

They lost at the border zoning.

26:20

They lost at the Planning Commission.

26:22

And now they lost at the court.

26:29

Either they appeal to higher court, which they won't because they those people don't want to spend money, they want to make money.

26:36

Or they're gonna come back to this council.

26:40

Can we imagine how bad would it look for any member of this council to introduce, reintroduce the legislation to change the zoning?

26:54

Legislation 791 2024 to change the zoning to so they can put gas station.

27:00

Can we imagine how bad would it look for any council to vote yes to change the zoning after all the the I mean that location must be immune by you?

27:15

Every single member of this council.

27:19

Now they must realize that it was a reason why it was zoned pedestrian overlay.

27:29

Because it's important to the community, it's important to the children, it's important to the park, it's uh it's important to everything.

27:35

And the roads are not fit to put gas station.

27:39

As one councilman here who lost whose gun from this council want to destroy half the neighborhood to just to put the gas station.

27:48

Thanks God he's gone.

27:50

And the other one, I believe is going tomorrow.

27:54

And if if not, it's still the neighborhoods of Kudell, West Boulevard, and Edjuar voted clear and loud against the gas station.

28:03

Thank you.

28:05

Thank you.

28:06

Next we have Sanja Sanders.

28:08

Sanjay is from Ward 3.

28:10

She's here to talk about police third district, and uh, she's not representing anyone and not being paid by anyone.

28:16

Is Sonia Sanders here?

28:18

Sonia Sanders going once, Sonja Sanders going twice, Sonia Sanders is not here.

28:24

Uh, we will now move to Josiah Quarrells.

28:26

Josiah Quarles is from Shaker Heights, he's here to talk about Tanisha's Law.

28:30

He represents the Northeast Ohio Coalition for the homeless, and uh, he's not being paid by anyone to comment.

28:36

Mr.

28:37

Quarrels, you have the floor.

28:38

Uh good afternoon, Council, uh, members of the administration, community members.

28:45

Um, firstly, I was supposed to give this comment last week, but I don't know, something was going on, a couple of us didn't get on.

28:53

So there'll be other folks who will be coming to speak as well.

28:57

Um, but I think that you saw that there is a community that is willing to do the work that is invested in this work, and I think that that's what this forum is for, um, for you to witness that, for you to hear that, for those voices to be given rise to.

29:12

Um, because we don't come here to grandstand, we come here because we believe in you.

29:21

Like we believe in democracy and that that the people's voices matter, and we when we look around the world and our heart is broken, it reminds us that something's right with us because our heart is still there when we feel unease, when we feel um dis-ease, it is because the world is a sick place, and we come here because we believe in each other and that we can find solutions together in community to protect one another, to heal one another, to show up for one another, and it may not be the same way that everybody likes, but it is a conversation, and we should not be cast out or castigated for showing up because what we're doing is showing up.

30:21

And that's what doing Tanisha's law now would create.

30:25

It would give us the runway that we need to engage with community around awareness, right, to engage around recruitment of the workforce that will need to commit the task, and there are already plenty of studies that show the need while we work through the bureaucratic mechanics of it all.

30:44

What should be centering us is the urgency of now.

30:49

And so I call on counsel and many others will call on counsel to pass Tanisa's law, and I would like to confirm that December 4th at 1 p.m.

31:00

is the hearing in the safety committee for Tanisha's Law.

31:03

If that can be confirmed, I would appreciate it.

31:06

Thank you.

31:07

Thank you.

31:10

Next, we have Evangelist Darlene.

31:13

Evangelist Darlene is from Ward 4.

31:15

Uh, Evangelist Darlene is here to talk about fairness and justice regarding the residents, and uh Evangelist Darlene is not representing one, not being paid by anyone.

31:23

You had the floor.

31:25

I am here tonight to speak on behalf of Anthony Connor, a Cleveland man who has spent over 12 years in prison for a crime he did not commit.

31:35

Anthony was convicted in 2013 for the shooting outside the Sarah House Nightclub.

31:43

But the evidence, the real evidence, has never supported the conviction.

31:49

There was no gun shot residue on his hands, no blood on his clothes, no fingerprints on any weapon, no forensic science tying him to any gun, not then and not now.

32:03

Three civilian witnesses, all independent of each other, all unknown to Anthony and all with nothing to gain, each described, a different man as the shooter, a light-skinned male wearing white, the same man seen assaulting others with a gun while Anthony was running for his life.

32:24

Anthony is a caramel colored man who was wearing red, two different outfits.

32:44

Anthony was unarmed and was not the shooter.

32:49

And yet none of their voices were heard during his trial.

32:54

Even more troubling, the key identification used against him came from a single photo show up, a method courts across the country has repeatedly condemned as unduly suggestive and unreliable.

33:12

The person shown the single photo was himself a suspect, being pressured while sitting handcuffed in the back of a police car.

33:24

And he later recanted his entire statement in open court.

33:30

In 2020, the Ohio Court of Appeals ruled that the trial court wrongly denied Anthony's request for DNA testing.

33:37

Testing that could finally reveal the truth.

33:50

Council members, our council has acknowledged wrongful convictions before.

33:56

We know the human costs, we know the damage it does, not only to families, but to the integrity of our justice system.

34:03

And we also know this when the wrong person is in prison, the real person is still free to kill again.

34:15

Tonight I ask this counsel for two things.

34:19

Use your voice and your platform to call for DNA testing for the court that the Court of Appeals ordered and encourage the Cuyahoga County prosecutors.

34:30

Time, please submit anything else.

34:31

We want to make sure we follow up at the time.

34:33

To review Anthony's.

34:34

Please give it to the safety director.

34:36

That's your time.

34:37

Thank you.

34:38

Next we have Vivian Connor.

34:40

Vivian Connor is from Ward 6.

34:42

Uh, Vivian Connor is here to talk about fairness in the community.

34:46

Uh, she's not representing anyone and not being paid by anyone.

34:49

Vivian Connor here.

34:50

Vivian Connor going once.

34:52

Vivian Connor going twice.

34:59

Thank you.

35:06

Good evening, everyone.

35:07

My name is Vivian Connor, Anthony Cobb and Mother.

35:10

He has spent over 13 years in prison where the higher court proved that he did not do the crime.

35:17

There's no blood on him.

35:18

Those no there's no gun residue or anything.

35:23

And they say, how is he in prison?

35:26

And the only thing we want to know is what could your platform do to help free my son who is innocent?

35:33

We have only but so much we can do.

35:38

Atheni has spent over a decade in prison for a crime he did not commit.

35:42

He deserved his name cleared.

35:44

He deserved a fair review.

35:47

He deserved justice.

35:48

Thank you for your time and for listening.

35:50

I pray this council will stand on the side of truth and help bring Anthony home.

35:56

Thank you.

36:00

Next we have Alexis Mason.

36:02

Alexis Mason is from Garfield Heights.

36:04

Alexis is here to talk about community fairness.

36:06

Alexis is not representing anyone, not being paid by anyone.

36:09

Lexus, you have the floor.

36:14

Good evening, everyone.

36:16

So I'll be here to reiterate about Anthony as well.

36:19

We just would like you all to use your voice in your platform to call for the DNA testing that the Court of Appeals has ordered.

36:27

Also encouraged the Hakayaka County Prosecutor's Office to review Anthony's case with fresh eyes in the interest of the truth and fairness.

36:35

He's like they said he spent over 13 years in prison now.

36:39

He's missed countless milestones with his children with his family, and he's in there.

36:44

He's an innocent man behind bars.

36:46

Thank you.

36:50

That concludes public comment.

36:52

Thank you to all the speakers.

36:53

Madam Clerk, please share communications.

36:59

File number 1527 2025 from Stephanie K.

37:04

Melnick, Chief Corporate Counsel, uh regarding the rules and regulations adopted by the city's Fair Employment Wage Board.

37:13

File number 1546 2025 from Sarah E.

37:17

O'Keefe, Director, Sustainability and Climate Justice.

37:22

The biannual report recently sent to John to Johns Hopkins University Bloomberg Center for Public Innovation pursuant to ordinance 1321 2024 from the Ohio Division of Liquor Control File number 1523 2025 regarding a transfer of location application at 2063 East Fourth Street Ward 3.

37:47

File number 1524 2025 regarding a transfer of ownership application at 1214 West 6th Street Ward 3 file number 1525 2025 regarding a transfer of ownership application at 3230 East 93rd Street Ward 6.

38:07

File number 1526 2025 regarding a transfer of ownership application at 2044 West 65th Street Ward 15.

38:18

Thank you.

38:19

Are there any condolence resolutions?

38:21

Resolutions of condolence by Councilmember Conwell for Salima Moya Smith.

38:30

My councilmember Hirsten for Ernestine Welch Baker.

38:33

My councilmember Polensic for Kenneth L.

38:36

Zoller.

38:38

My councilmember Starr for Richard Michael St.

38:40

Clair.

38:43

Thank you.

38:44

Are there any other condolence resolutions?

38:48

Will Council members please rise?

38:49

Oh, Councilman Brian Casey.

38:52

Mr.

38:52

President, can you please hold out a number for Bryce Dunlap?

38:56

Duly noted.

38:58

Are there any other condolence resolutions?

39:00

Seeing no other condolence resolutions.

39:03

Will everyone please rise for a moment of silence?

39:12

Thank you.

39:14

Are there any recognition resolutions?

39:17

Resolutions of recognition by Councilmember House Jones for the uh for the 82nd Lebanese Independence Day honoree Fahim Gamayo.

39:31

By Councilmember House Jones for Ram Honoree Alejandro Santiago, my councilmember Hirston for Rom Honoree Gabrielle Span by Councilmember Hirston for Rom Honoree Ishaan Kellum Brown by Councilmember Hirston for Rom Honoree Jamari Mason by Councilmember Hairston for Rom Honoree Edward C.

40:00

Banks DJ Fatty Banks by Councilmember Hairston for Rom Honoree for Zoe Wolf by Councilmember Hairston for Rom Honoree Trevon Davis by Councilmember House Jones for Cameo Honoree Dr.

40:15

Nasib Fawaz by Councilmember by Council Members Griffin and Palencic for Ingreta Ublis by Councilmember Palencick for Earl B.

40:29

Turner.

40:32

Thank you.

40:42

I want to remind all council members that you need to be in the will for your vote to count.

40:46

Councilman Starr.

40:47

I was trying to hold out a number for Chanel Greer.

40:50

Um sister of Sharonda Grill from CMHA.

40:53

Thank you so much.

40:54

Thank you for our member in that.

40:56

All right.

40:57

Are there any other uh recognition resolutions or anything else?

41:01

Okay.

41:02

No presentations.

41:03

Madam Clerk, please move to first reading emergency ordinances referred for administrative review and committee review.

41:08

Ordinance 1507 2025 by Councilmember Griffin by Departmental Request to amend Section 171.40 of the codified ordinances relating to use of city credit cards.

41:21

Ordinance 1508 2025 by Councilmember Griffin by Departmental Request to make additional appropriations of $1,200,000 to the Special Revenue Fund.

41:33

Ordinance 1509 2025 by Councilmember Griffin by Departmental Request to make temporary appropriations for the current payroll and other ordinary expenses of the City of Cleveland for the period from January 1, 2026 until the effective date of the annual appropriation ordinance for the fiscal year ending December 31st, 2026.

41:56

Ordinance 1510 2025 by Councilmember Griffin by Departmental Request to provide for the transfer and amendment to the general fund appropriations in the amount of $19,555,000 and $100,000 within the Small Enterprise Fund.

42:15

Ordinance 1512 2025 by Councilmembers Welch, Bishop, Slife, Harrison and Griffin by Departmental Request, authorizing directors of parks and recreation and port control to enter into a seventh amendment to the Lakefront Parks Lease with the Board of Park Commissioners of the Cleveland Metropolitan Park District to add the North Coast Inner Harbor and Marina to the lease.

42:41

Ordinance 1513 2025 by Councilmembers Casey and Griffin by Departmental Request, authorizing the purchase by one or more requirement contracts of hauling and disposing of residuals from Crown Waterworks plant and in emergencies other water treatment plants.

43:00

Authorizing the director of public utilities to enter into one or more requirement contracts without competitive bidding with polydyne ink for the polymer chemicals needed for dewatering crowns residuals for the division of water department of public utilities for a term up to two years.

43:20

Ordinance 1514 2025 by Councilmembers Slife and Griffin by Departmental Request authorizing Director of Port Control to enter into one or more contracts with Amadeus Airport IT Americas, Inc.

43:36

to provide common use self-service kiosks for the common use airport operations program, including hardware software installation and maintenance for the division of airports department of port control for a period of one year with four one-year options to renew exercisable by the director of port control.

43:56

Ordinance 1536-2025 by Councilmember by Council Members Hairston and Griffin by Departmental Request to amend 3103.21 of the codify ordinances relating to fees for hearings and time extensions before the Board of Building Standards and Building Appeals.

44:18

Ordinance 1541 2025 by Council Members Bishop and Griffin by Departmental Request authorizing Director of Capital Projects to enter into an amendment to a lease agreement with the flats east bank management LLC, the designee for the flats east bank development LLC to authorize charging charging boat docking reservation fees.

44:46

Thank you.

44:46

First reading emergency ordinances to be passed.

44:50

Ordinance 1511 2025 by Council Members Hairston and Griffin by Departmental Request approving the tax incentive review council's year 2024 recommendations.

45:02

Ordinance 1515-2025 by Councilmember Palencick authorizing the Director of Department of Parks and Recreation to enter into agreement with Waterloo Arts for the Waterloo Art District Landscape Enhancement Project, providing a rehabilitation and maintenance project to the Waterloo Arts and Entertainment District through the use of Ward 8 Casino Revenue Funds.

45:25

Ordinance 1516-2025 by Councilmember Griffin by Departmental Request.

45:31

Approving the collective bargaining agreement with the International Association of Firefighters Local 93 ARFF and to amend Section 29 of Ordinance 194-2021 relating to compensation for various classifications.

45:53

Approving the collective bargaining agreement with International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers Local 38 and to amend Section 20 of Ordinance 194-2021 relating to compensation for various classifications.

46:07

Ordinance 1518-2025 by Councilmember Griffin by Departmental Request.

46:13

Approving the collective bargaining agreement with Plumbers Local 55 Plumbers Inspectors and to amend Section 21 of Ordinance 194-2021 relating to compensation for various classifications.

46:35

An emergency ordinance to amend the title and sections 123456 and 7 of ordinance 742-2025 relating to an agreement with Penrose Holdings or its designee for the redevelopment of the Warner Swayze building located at 5701 Carnegie Avenue and other associated costs necessary to redevelop the property.

46:58

Ordinance 1522 2025 by Council Members House Jones Hairston and Griffin by Departmental Request.

47:06

Authorizing the Director of Economic Development to enter into a loan agreement with Village of Joy Corporation or its designee to provide economic development assistance to partially finance the construction of a birthing center at 1802 East 65th Street and other associated costs necessary to redevelop the property.

47:28

Ordinance 1545 2025 by Councilmember Griffin by Departmental Request approving the collective bargaining agreement with International Union of Painters and Allied Traders District Council 6 AFL CIO Local 639 and to amend Section 13 of Ordinance 194 2021 relating to compensation for various classifications.

47:55

Thank you.

47:55

Read the motion to suspend the rules.

47:57

By Councilmember Casey that the rules be suspended and the legislation just read be placed on final passage.

48:03

Seconded by Councilmember Bishop.

48:06

Call to roll.

48:18

15 years.

48:20

Call to roll on passage.

48:22

Griffin Bishop Conwell Gray Harrison Harsh House Jones Jones Casey Kelly Moore Polensick Santana Slife Spencer Star Welch.

48:30

15 Yes.

48:32

Thank you.

48:32

First reading emergency.

48:34

First reading ordinance is referred for administrative review and committee review.

48:38

Ordinance 1520-2025 by Councilmember Kelly.

48:42

Establishing the Lorraine Antiques Design Review District, north and south of Lorraine Avenue between West 83rd Street and West 61st Place.

48:51

Ordinance 1521-2025 by Councilmember Spencer.

48:56

Expanding the West 117th Street Design Review District to include additional parcels north and south of Detroit Avenue between West 116th Street and West 107th Street and removing residential parcels of land along West 117th Street, south of Thornton Road and north of Lorraine Avenue.

49:21

First reading, emergency resolutions to be adopted.

49:25

Ordinance 1547-2025 by Councilmember Spencer objecting to the transfer of location of a C1C2 liquor permit to 8808 Detroit Avenue.

49:37

Read the motion to suspend the rules.

49:39

By Councilmember Casey that the rules be suspended and the legislation just read be placed on final passage.

49:45

Seconded by Councilmember Bishop.

49:47

Call to roll.

49:48

Griffin, Bishop Conwell Gray, Harrison Harsh, House Jones, Jones, Casey, Kelly, Moore, Palencick, Santana, Slife, Spencer, Starr Welch.

49:58

15 Yes.

50:00

Call to roll on adoption.

50:01

Griffin Bishop Conwell Gray Hairston Harsh, House Jones, Jones, Casey, Kelly, Moore, Polensic, Santana, Slife, Spencer, Star Welch.

50:11

15 YAs.

50:12

Thank you.

50:13

Second reading emergency ordinances to be passed.

50:17

Ordinance 1295-2025 as amended by Council Members Bishop and Griffin by Departmental Request.

50:24

Authorizing Director of Capital Projects to enter into an amendment to the memoranda memorandum of understanding with Greater Cleveland Regional Transit Authority to provide additional services for improvements and extend the contract.

50:38

Ordinance 1396-2025 as amended by Council Members Bishop and Griffin by Departmental Request.

50:45

Authorizing Director of Public Works to enter into a license agreement with a vendor to install and maintain an automated teller machine terminal located in room 122, vital statistics for the use and convenience of the general public for a period of one year with a one-year option to renew, exercisable by the Director of Public Works.

51:07

Ordinance 1400 2025 by Council Members Bishop and Griffin by Departmental Request.

51:13

Authorizing the Director of Capital Projects to apply to the District 1 Public Works Integrating Committee for state funding for the rehabilitation of a portion of Wade Park Avenue to apply for and accept gifts and grants from various entities for the improvement and authorizing the Commissioner of Purchases and Supplies to acquire, accept, and record for right-of-way purposes, real property and easements necessary to make the improvement.

51:41

Ordinance 1402-2025 as amended by Council Members Hairston, Bishop, Polensick and Griffin by Departmental Request, authorizing the Director of Capital Projects to employ one or more professional consultants for the construction of pedestrian enhancements along Euclid Avenue from Upper Valley Drive to Ivanhoe Road, known as the Euclid Avenue Pedestrian Improvement Project, to apply for and accept gifts and grants from any public or private entity, authorizing the mayor and the commissioner purchases and supplies as appropriate to acquire, accept, and record for right-of-way purposes, real property and easements necessary to make the improvement, and authorizing the director of capital projects to enter into any relative agreements.

52:30

Ordinance 1404 2025 as amended by Council Members Bishop and Griffin by Departmental Request.

52:38

Determining the method of making public improvement of implementing the active transportation program by repairing and constructing various safety improvements, including but not limited to pavement markings, delineator posts, sign fabrication material, traffic signal equipment, design and related improvements, and authorizing director of public works to enter into one or more public improvement requirement contracts for the making of the improvement.

53:08

Authorizing the director to employ one or more professional consultants necessary to design the improvement and authorizing the director to apply for and accept one or more gifts or grants or other funding from public or private entities to implement the ordinance.

53:24

Ordinance 1416 2025 as amended by Council Members Palencick Bishop Harrison and Griffin by Departmental Request to amend sections 2 and 11 of Ordinance 993 2025 relating to agreements with Cuyahoga County and Cleveland Metro and Cleveland Metro Parks for the Euclid Beach Trail Connector to add additional land to the submerged land lease and to supplement the ordinance by adding new sections 11ABCD and 11E relating to subleasing the land to the Northeast Ohio Regional Sewer District.

54:05

Ordinance 1418-2025 by Council Members Comwell and Griffin by Departmental Request, authorizing the Director of Aging to apply for and accept one or more grants from the Western Reserve Area Agency on Aging for 2026-28 Western Reserve Area on Aging Program, including supportive services and aging and disability resource center programs, and authorizing the director to accept gifts, grants, or services from any public or private entity for the purpose of the grant.

54:39

Ordinance 1446-2025 by Council Members Bishop and Griffin by Departmental Request.

54:46

Determine the method of making the public improvement of purchasing, repairing, constructing, and installing signal support polls, and authorizing director of public works to enter into one or more public improvement requirement contracts for the making of the improvement for a period not to exceed two years.

55:04

Ordinance 1448-2025 by Councilmember Griffin by Departmental Request.

55:10

Authorizing Director of Finance on behalf of Cleveland Municipal Court to enter into one or more contracts with Court Community Service for one professional services necessary to place criminal defendants in community service and two for placement of criminal defendants in Cleveland Work Crew Program, both as referred by the court for Cleveland Municipal Court, each for a period of one year with two one-year options to renew, exercisable by the Director of Finance.

55:47

Ordinance 1449 2025 by Councilmember Griffin by Departmental Request.

55:54

Authorizing the Director of Finance on behalf of Cleveland Municipal Court to enter into one or more contracts with Oriana House for professional services necessary to provide appropriate placement for defendants to be assigned into supervised pretrial release without sanctions of incarceration and to provide related services for the Cleveland Municipal Court for a period of one year with a one-year option to renew exercisable by the Director of Finance.

56:25

Ordinance 1453 2025 by Councilmember Griffin by Departmental Request authorizing Director of Finance on behalf of Cleveland Municipal Court to enter into one or more contracts with Cuyahoga County Public Defender Commission for legal services necessary to defend indigent defendants charged with violation of ordinances and city of Cleveland of the City of Cleveland that may result in incarceration for Cleveland Municipal Court for a period of one year with one option to renew for an additional consecutive year exercisable by the Director of Finance.

57:05

Ordinance 1458-2025 as amended by council members Star Bishop Harrison and Griffin by departmental request to amend the title and sections 4567 and 8 of Ordinance 738-2025 relating to an agreement with Penrose Holdings LLC or its designee for the sale of the Warner Swayze building and entering into loan agreements with Penrose Holding or its designee to provide assistance to partially finance the redevelopment.

57:51

Thank you.

57:55

I'm not there.

57:56

Okay.

57:58

I skipped the point of piece.

58:00

To vacate a portion 2.2987 acres of West Third Street.

58:08

Ordinance 1490 2025 by Council Members Welch, Bishop, Hairston, and Griffin by Departmental Request to vacate a portion.2990 acres of West Third Street.

58:41

Thank you.

58:45

Thank you.

58:47

Thank you.

58:47

Councilwoman House Jones.

58:53

Which number, Councilwoman?

58:55

1449.

58:57

So noted.

59:00

Okay.

59:01

Madam Clerk, read the motion to suspend the rules.

59:04

By Councilmember Casey that the rules be suspended and the legislation just read be placed on final passage.

59:10

Seconded by Councilmember Bishop.

59:13

Thank you.

59:13

Carteroe.

59:14

Griffin, Bishop Conwell Gray, Hairston Harsh, House Jones, Jones, Casey, Kelly, Moore, Polencick, Santana, Slife, Spencer Starr.

59:23

15 years.

59:25

Carteroe.

59:27

Griffin, Bishop Conwell, Gray, Hirston Harsh, House Jones, Jones, Casey, Kelly, Moore, Polency, Santana, Slife, Spencer, Starr, Welch.

59:36

On 1416, 2025, 14 years, no nays, one recusal.

59:42

On all others, 15 years.

59:44

Carter on passage.

59:46

That was it.

59:47

That was it.

59:49

Introductions.

59:50

Do we have any introductions?

59:52

No introductions.

59:54

We'll move to announcements.

59:55

Do we have any announcements?

59:57

Seeing no announcement.

59:58

Up councilman Kevin Conwell.

1:00:01

Standing man with the master plan still here.

1:00:04

Mr.

1:00:04

Stan McBee, executive committee members here.

1:00:08

And he's been working in the community for decades, decades and decades.

1:00:12

And he's one of my best friends.

1:00:14

Matter of fact, you stole them away from me, man.

1:00:17

He'll be helping you in the community.

1:00:19

Isn't that right?

1:00:19

Standing man, master plan.

1:00:21

All right, thank you.

1:00:23

Thank you.

1:00:25

Uh Councilwoman Jenny Spencer.

1:00:27

Thank you.

1:00:28

I want to recognize Stephanie Morrison Herbeck from the community relations board among the many other community leadership roles you've held.

1:00:36

Thank you very much.

1:00:37

Thank you.

1:00:38

And uh just to add on to that, Councilwoman Spencer.

1:00:42

Um, I want to acknowledge that Stephanie's husband was one of the um very people that really advocated for um you know for public comment.

1:00:51

So uh Mr.

1:00:52

George Herbeck, legend in our city, and always had a privilege of working with uh you and George.

1:00:57

So good to see you, Miss Herbeck.

1:00:59

Thank you.

1:01:00

Uh are there any other uh miss uh announcements, Stephanie uh Councilwoman Stephanie House Jones?

1:01:05

Yeah, someone just asked um earlier in public comment uh to confirm uh the first hearing for Tanisha's Law will be here next Thursday, December 4th at 1 p.m.

1:01:14

But I know the dean will probably talk about it again next week, but just wanted to confirm that it is next Thursday.

1:01:19

Thank you.

1:01:19

Thank you, Councilwoman House Jones.

1:01:21

Councilman Conwell.

1:01:25

Mighty mighty mighty mighty top bloods.

1:01:27

Solomon, you can stand up.

1:01:29

He's he's the owner of the barbershop as well over there.

1:01:32

Top blooders.

1:01:33

You guys see him when we uh go out on trips.

1:01:36

He owns the barbershop in the airport as well.

1:01:40

And all right, brother.

1:01:43

He got some moves too.

1:01:44

I had a chance to hang out with him the other night.

1:01:46

And he got he could he got some good dance moves too.

1:01:49

I didn't know he could move like that.

1:01:51

Good to see you, brother Solomon.

1:01:52

Appreciate it.

1:01:53

Are there any?

1:01:56

Are there any other miscellaneous?

1:01:58

Any other miscellaneous?

1:02:00

Uh seeing other miscellaneous, madam clerk, please excuse the absences.

1:02:14

By councilmember Casey, that the absence of council members, Hairston.

1:02:23

I'm sorry, Santana and Welch are here by excuse, seconded by Councilmember Bishop.

1:02:29

Thank you.

1:02:30

Council is adjourned to the call of the chair.

1:02:33

The next meeting of council will be on Monday, December the first, 2025.

1:02:38

Thank you, Mm-hmm.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Procedural███████████████████████23%
Community Engagement█████████████████17%
Public Utilities█████████████████17%
Technology and Innovation█████████9%
Public Safety█████████9%
Public Health Awareness████████8%
Zoning And Land Use██████6%
Public Transportation█████5%
Economic Development████4%
Summary of Proceedings

Cleveland City Council Meeting Summary - November 24, 2025

The Cleveland City Council convened for a public session characterized by extensive public commentary on civil rights, surveillance technology, and wrongful convictions, alongside the unanimous approval of over twenty emergency ordinances and resolutions. Council members engaged in standard administrative procedures, including recognition of community leaders and condolences, while public speakers utilized the platform to urge the council on immediate policy reversals and ethical considerations regarding city spending and justice system integrity.

Consent Calendar

  • The Council reviewed and transmitted standard communications, including reports from the Fair Employment Wage Board, the Ohio Division of Liquor Control, and sustainability updates.
  • Condolence resolutions were adopted for Salima Moya Smith, Ernestine Welch Baker, Kenneth L. Zoller, and Richard Michael St. Clair.
  • Recognition resolutions were passed honoring the 82nd Lebanese Independence Day, various community award recipients (including Dr. Nasib Fawaz, Edward C. Banks, and Zoe Wolf), and Ingreta Ublis and Earl B. Turner.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Terry Wong (Ward 3): Spoke against "flock-ups" (systemic failures) regarding the city's surveillance technology. She expressed strong opposition to the purchase of shot spotter and Flock gunshot detection technology, characterizing it as a misallocation of public funds and a legal liability. She criticized Councilmember McCormack for leaving to work for a lobbying firm (Flock) and advocated for deep soul-searching among council members regarding their service to the community. She opposed the proposed move of the Browns to Brook Park, calling it the "biggest mistake in Cleveland history." She expressed a position that current elected officials are "complicit" and do not deserve their paychecks. She stated she will be back after the holidays to discuss "real issues."
  • Dean Van Farrell (Ward 7): Expressed gratitude and appreciation for outgoing Councilwoman Jenny Spencer, stating he values her passion for public participation and her ability to engage with those who disagree with her.
  • Norman Edwards (Ward 3): Representing the Black Contractors Group, he stated he is present to discuss the lack of diversity and inclusion in the city, though he was noted as not being physically present during the roll call.
  • Fauzi Badour (Ward 11): Expressed strong opposition to a gas station zoning appeal at 100 Madison Avenue. He stated that the court, Planning Commission, and border zoning decisions rejected the appeal, and he argued that reintroducing legislation for a gas station would look "bad" for the council. He asserted that the neighborhoods (Kuduell, West Boulevard, Euclid) voted "clear and loud" against the gas station.
  • Josiah Quarrells (Shaker Heights, representing Northeast Ohio Coalition for the Homeless): Called on the council to pass "Tanisha's Law." He expressed support for the law as a necessary runway for community engagement and workforce recruitment. He requested confirmation that the safety committee hearing is scheduled for December 4th at 1 p.m.
  • Evangelist Darlene (Ward 4): Representing Anthony Connor, she urged the council to use their platform to call for DNA testing ordered by the Court of Appeals and to encourage the Cuyahoga County Prosecutor's Office to review Connor's case. She described the evidence against Connor as non-existent and the identification methods as unduly suggestive.
  • Vivian Connor (Ward 6, mother of Anthony Cobb): Expressed a desperate need for justice for her son, Anthony Cobb, who has spent over 13 years in prison for a crime he did not commit. She asked the council to use their platform to help free her innocent son.
  • Alexis Mason (Garfield Heights): Reiterated the call for the council to use their platform to demand DNA testing for Anthony Cobb and urged the Prosecutor's Office to review the case with "fresh eyes" in the interest of truth and fairness.

Discussion Items

  • Emergency Ordinances: The Council considered a large batch of emergency ordinances (1507–1545) related to:
    • Credit card regulations and appropriations.
    • Transfers of liquor license ownership and location.
    • Leases for parks, marinas, and airport kiosks.
    • Contracts for water treatment chemicals, polymer, and hauling residuals.
    • Collective bargaining agreements for the Firefighters, Electrical Workers, Plumbers, and Painters Local unions.
    • Tax incentive reviews and the Waterloo Art District project.
    • Redevelopment of the Warner Swayze building and the Village of Joy birthing center.
  • Design Review Districts: Discussion on establishing the Lorraine Antiques Design Review District (Ordinance 1520) and expanding the West 117th Street Design Review District (Ordinance 1521).
  • Infrastructure and Public Works: Approval of contracts and grants for the Euclid Avenue Pedestrian Improvement Project, Euclid Beach Trail Connector, signal support polls, and active transportation programs.
  • Court Services: Authorization for contracts with Court Community Service, Oriana House, and the Cuyahoga County Public Defender Commission for the Cleveland Municipal Court.
  • Street Vacations: Ordinances to vacate portions of West Third Street (Ordinances 1490 and 1492).

Key Outcomes

  • Unanimous Passage of Emergency Ordinances: With Councilmember Starr recusing himself on Ordinance 1416-2025, the Council voted 14-0-1 (for 1416) and 15-0 for all other emergency ordinances and resolutions listed on the second reading and first reading, placing them on final passage immediately.
  • Specific Vote on Ordinance 1416: The vote on Ordinance 1416-2025 (Euclid Beach Trail Connector) resulted in 14 Yeas, 0 Nays, and 1 Recusal (Starr).
  • All Others: All other emergency ordinances passed on final passage with a 15-0 vote tally.
  • Scheduling Confirmation: Councilwoman House Jones confirmed via announcement that the first hearing for "Tanisha's Law" will be held on Thursday, December 4, 2025, at 1:00 p.m.
  • Acknowledgments: Council members recognized community figures including Stephanie Morrison Herbeck, her husband George Herbeck, and local business owner Solomon.
  • Adjournment: The meeting was adjourned to the call of the chair, with the next meeting scheduled for Monday, December 1, 2025.
  • Recusal Note: Councilmember Starr recused himself from the vote on Ordinance 1416-2025.

Meeting Transcript

Madam Clerk, please call the road. Griffin here. Bishop. Bishop. Cromwell. Gray. Harrison. Harsh. House Jones. Jones. Casey. Kelly. Moore, Polensick, Santana, Slife, Spencer, Star, Welch. Well, everyone, please rise for a moment of silence, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance. Thank you. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands. One nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Such disruptions may constitute a misdemeanor and a violation of Section Six O five dot oh four. Anyone who disrupts this lawful meeting is in violation of the codified ordinances, commits misdemeanors, and is subject to prosecution. The following is the first and only warning. If this meeting is disrupted, I will gabble a halt to the proceedings and direct the assembled officers to escort any person participating in the disruption out of the chamber. Once persons participating in a disruption are out of the chambers, the officers will close the doors and the disruptors will be handled as directed by the Director of Public Safety. Thank you. We will now move to public comment. Once again, I'm asking all of the council to turn around and acknowledge the speakers, and I'm asking all of the speakers to acknowledge your time. Many of you have uh spoken before, so you pretty much know the routine. Yellow means to wrap it up, red means to abruptly stop. Please come forward. The first person that we have is Terry Wong. She's from Ward 3. Terry is here to talk about flock and other flock ups by the city of Cleveland. She's not representing anyone and not being paid by anyone. Ms. Wong, you had the floor. Good evening. If Alfred Hitchcock were alive today, he wouldn't need to imagine a horror film about birds overwhelming a town. He could just film Cleveland. In August 2022, the first flock automatic license plate reader appeared, perched on a pole like a mechanical raven, silent and watching. And then just like in the birds, they multiplied. Within two months, nearly 100 had settled across the city, tracking our movements without a single public conversation. And here's the twist Hitchcock would have loved. I was serving on the community police commission at the time, and even I wasn't told. The oversight body created by voters through issue 24, the one meant to shape police policy and protect civil rights, found out only after these machines were everywhere. If the commission wasn't informed, the public was never meant to be. Then came the horror level defects. These aren't small bugs, they are structural flock-ups that create enormous legal liability for Cleveland. If a hacked camera triggers a wrongful arrest or leaks personal information, it's Clevelanders, not flock, who will pay the price. But instead of removing these invasive birds, the city seems eager to make a sequel. Cleveland has recently spent 150,000 on a shot spotter study, even though decades of research already questioned its value. And CSU researchers could barely reach conclusions because ShotSpotter and CPD couldn't provide full data sets.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com