Development, Planning, and Sustainability Committee Meeting - March 24, 2026
Development, Planning, and Sustainability Committee Meeting - March 24, 2026
The committee met on March 24, 2026, at 1:25 PM (UTC) to consider two zoning ordinances: one expanding the West 117th Street Design Review District and removing residential parcels, and another rezoning a parcel near Herman Avenue for a mixed-use development. No public comments were presented.
Discussion Items
- Ordinance 1521-2025 (Council Member Spencer): Xavier Bay of City Planning presented Map Change 2683 to expand the West 117th Street Design Review District to include parcels along Detroit Avenue between West 107th and West 116th Streets, and to remove residential parcels along West 117th Street south of Tower Thornton Road and north of Lorraine Avenue. The addition aims to preserve urban fabric along the transit corridor, while the removal relieves homeowners of extra design review for routine repairs. Council members asked about demolition oversight and the impact on residents. The ordinance was approved.
- Ordinance 185-2026 (Council Members Davis and Ornus): Xavier Bay presented Map Change 2697 to rezone a parcel north of Herman Avenue between West 65th and West 58th Streets from semi-industry (G2) to local retail (G2) with a zero-foot setback, incorporating a previously approved site plan. The project includes 135 residential units, 11,000 square feet of amenity space (office, pool, fitness, cafe), 127 parking spaces, and a transit demand management strategy (drop-off zone, repair stations, improved streetscape). Council Member Austin confirmed the project is separate from the Community Benefits Agreement. The ordinance was approved.
Key Outcomes
- Ordinance 1521-2025 was approved, expanding the design review district on Detroit Avenue and removing residential parcels.
- Ordinance 185-2026 was approved, rezoning the Herman Avenue parcel to allow the approved development to proceed.
Meeting Transcript
Good morning. Today is March 24th, and I would like to call the meeting for development, planning, and sustainability to order. Madam Clerk, can you please call the role? Present. Here. Here. Here. Thank you. Members, we have two zoning pieces today. Madam Clerk, do we have anyone sign up for public comments? Okay, we're gonna start with ordinance number 1521-2025 by Council Member Spencer. An ordinance expanding the West 117th Street Design Review District to include additional parcels north and south of Detroit Avenue between West 116th Street and West 107th Street, and removing residential parcels of land along West 117th Street, south of Tower Thornton Road, and north of Lorraine Avenue. Xavier. Thank you for having me. And today we're presenting uh Map Change 2683. And so uh I'm gonna start off explaining the uh addition to the design review district. And so uh the next few slides you're gonna see are gonna be centered around Detroit Avenue, uh and really the length between West 107th Street and West 116th Street. And so we're proposing to uh add this uh area onto the currently existing West 17th Street Design Review District. And the purposes here are really to uh save a lot of the uh context and the urban fabric along a transit corridors. And so as I just mentioned, we're speaking about uh we're focusing on the area of Detroit Avenue between uh West 107th and West Hundred Sixteenth Street. Uh next you're gonna see uh a bunch of context photos going up and down the corridor to really uh show you the urban fabric that we're hoping to retain. And so um, you can see there's a lot of commercial uses, a few uh apartment buildings, some mixed use uh uses as well along the corridor. Um so uh another purpose of design review districts uh is to really uh allow city planning um to have more oversight uh when there's demolitions being proposed or additions uh and things of that nature, changes to the exterior being proposed. And really, uh as I mentioned, uh the goal here is to save a lot of this urban fabric that you see along the transit corridor. Uh very straightforward um proposal here. Uh there's the excerpt of Detroit Avenue we're speaking to add to the design review district. Uh the next few slides you're gonna see are gonna be the parcels that we're uh proposing to remove from the design review district. And so a lot of these streets are mainly residential streets uh between uh going up and down West 100 first to West 19th, as well as art interest, good Cloverdale and West 116th Street. And um really uh this is helpful for the residents as it uh takes away an additional uh step of review when uh resident is simply trying to uh you know uh repair their roof, um, do some extra work on their siding and things of that nature. And so here's a map where you can see the entire design review district of West 17th and in blue and purple, and then the red highlight are the uh areas that are being removed. And so these next uh photos you're gonna see are gonna be the context that we're proposing to remove. Uh this slide we had uh pulled some data uh explaining a lot of the permits that we're coming through. Um and so you can imagine, you know, with these 52 examples that we have there, the exterior permits, uh it adds more time for the resident to really get through the process of permitting. And so here's uh the first chunk that we're proposing to remove here, uh up and down the streets. I'll show you are mainly single family, two-family, a few four plexus. Um this next section is uh West 116th Street. Again, a lot of single family, two-family uh uh uses along this corridor next uh West 117th Street. Uh this portion of 117th is mainly residential. Uh this portion, we are keeping that chunk that's highlighted in yellow there. Uh and so you could see to remain right. And so these are those uh larger apartment complexes. Um things like this, you know, we'd want to see the demolition proposal come through city planning with some type of you know plan for redevelopment. Uh and so that's the main purpose there uh for the removals, as you see on the screen. Uh I thought I did have one. Okay, yeah. Here you can see on the left is the Detroit Avenue section that we're adding to the design review district on the right, the red highlights are the parcels that we're removing from the design. Oh, sorry, design review district. That about sums it up from Ed Change uh 2683. Um again, really just we're trying to preserve that urban fabric along the transit corridor on Detroit Avenue and removing a lot of the single family, two-family residential uh parcels from design review districts in residential streets. Got it, thank you, Xavier.
openpublica.com