OpenPublica

Accountability starts with access.

© 2026 · Filed for the public record

Use casesAboutAPIPrivacyTermsLinkedIn
Home/Cleveland, Ohio/City Council Meetings
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Workforce Education Training, Youth Development Committee Meeting - September 24, 2026

City Council Meetings — Thursday, September 24, 2026
BodyCleveland, Ohio
SessionCity Council Meetings
DateThursday, September 24, 2026
StatusFILED
Video Record
0:00 / 3:34:33

Original source
Transcript — VerbatimClick a timed line to jump · ⧉ to share it
5:09

Good afternoon, everybody.

5:11

Thank you all for coming to today's um committee here, which is Tuesday, September 15th, and the committee is workforce education training, youth development committee.

5:21

Madam Clerk, can you call the row?

5:24

Here.

5:26

Present.

5:27

Ray Car?

5:28

Here.

5:31

Here.

5:33

Thank you so much.

5:34

We do have about five pieces of legislation that go through today.

5:38

We will go through the legislation pieces.

5:40

And then we also do have a presentation from equal opportunity.

5:45

No?

5:46

OEO is gonna be here.

5:48

So that'll be um following the presentation.

5:50

So I believe we do have the director um of HR here.

5:54

If you come to the table and we can start with your pieces of legislation.

6:04

Pretty good, pretty good.

6:06

Are you by yourself today?

6:08

No, I have I have a little little crew with the information.

6:11

Do you want them to come at the table?

6:14

Would you like them per piece or together?

6:17

Um together so we can roll it out, and as they go through those different ordinances, we can definitely obviously they can leave and things from that nature.

6:25

So it's them all stuff.

6:27

Yep, because we'd like to know who here.

6:31

Chair.

6:32

Yes.

6:33

Quick motion.

6:34

Are you okay?

6:35

Uh sorry, folks.

6:36

What'd you say?

6:37

Are you okay?

6:43

I feel like I'm gonna feel like I'm in a kid's chair.

6:47

Maybe I'm just shrinking.

7:10

Right.

7:12

Um, so first piece we will definitely hear will be orders number four sixty-six twenty twenty-six and emergency ordinance authorizing the director of human resources to employ one or more professional consultants to administer the city's Cobra program for a one-year period with two one-year options to renew, exercisable by the director of human resource.

7:38

Director, before you go into this, can you introduce everyone from your team that's here?

7:42

Sure, thank you, Chairman.

7:43

And uh committee to my left is Trisha Simon Webster, she is the benefits manager for the city.

7:49

To my immediate right is Patrick Lang.

7:52

He's uh the talent management coordinator for the city.

7:55

To his right is Kelly Smith, she's the wellness manager for the city, and to her right is Monique Young, and she is the employee relations manager for the city.

8:06

Uh right, so at the end.

8:10

Oh, I didn't, and some sorry I didn't see Angela come up.

8:14

That's Angela Tagler Ferry.

8:16

She is our fiscal manager for the HR department.

8:18

All right.

8:20

So with this ordinance, can you tell us or can you go ahead and present?

8:24

Uh sure, Chairman.

8:25

Thank you.

8:25

Um, this piece is requesting authorization to enter into a professional services contract with a vendor for the administration of our COBRA program.

8:34

Um they maintain our employer provided health insurance during situations such as job loss reduction in hours uh for a period of up to three years or 36 months.

8:45

Uh it falls under Cobra falls under uh IRS rule uh 125 related health care benefit can of cafeteria plans.

8:55

Um basically we offer employees um the plans that that they would be uh able to be enrolled in as as regular employees.

9:04

Um it it does fall under federal law, so this is something that we have to offer employees uh during those before mentioned uh uh situations.

9:14

Um just for a little bit of context in terms of numbers so far this year.

9:19

We've had 785 uh termed employees in which would have been Cobra eligible, of which uh 203 selected, and uh we have 62 that are currently enrolled in Cobra.

9:34

Um the vendor handles everything and anything related to Cobra once we notify them of of the uh change.

9:42

Um and just for for clarification too, for the amount, it is up to 499, but it's actually um uh a dollar forty-five per employee per month that is utilized in Cobra.

9:55

So it's not a uh guaranteed amount.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Personnel Matters██████████████████████████████30%
Procurement████████████████16%
Community Benefits Agreement████████████12%
Training And Development█████████9%
Economic Development█████████9%
Employee Assistance Programs██████6%
Racial Equity█████5%
Community Engagement████4%
Procedural██2%
Summary of Proceedings

Workforce Education Training, Youth Development Committee Meeting - September 24, 2026

This committee meeting, chaired by Councilmember [Chair], was held to discuss five ordinances from the Department of Human Resources and a presentation from the Office of Equal Opportunity (OEO) on Community Benefits Agreements (CBAs). The HR Director and team presented each ordinance, leading to votes, amendments, and one hold. The OEO presentation provided an overview of CBA implementation and sparked discussion on equity and payment challenges for minority contractors. Note: The transcript indicates the meeting occurred on Tuesday, September 15th, but the provided metadata states September 24, 2026; this summary uses the latter date as instructed.

Discussion Items

Ordinance 466-2026 (COBRA Program)

  • HR Director requested authorization to contract with WEX for COBRA administration at $1.45 per employee per month, not to exceed $49,999 annually, for one year with three one-year renewal options.
  • Statistics: 785 termed employees eligible year-to-date, 203 selected, 62 currently enrolled.
  • Councilwoman Stephanie House Jones moved to amend Section 2 to include a "not to exceed $49,999" clause; seconded and passed.
  • An earlier amendment changing renewal options from two to three one-year terms was also adopted.
  • Passed as amended.

Ordinance 752-2026 (FMLA Administration)

  • Request to contract for FMLA administration at a cost of $350,000 (increase from $250,000) for one year with three renewal options. RFP in progress.
  • Statistics: 1,193 open cases; program expanded citywide in May 2025.
  • Councilwoman House Jones requested data by department, leave type, and gender to inform future paid family leave legislation.
  • Councilman Time Shaw raised concerns about outsourcing leading to loss of internal expertise and ability to negotiate with vendors.
  • Councilman Joe Jones pressed for information on minority-owned and local contractors used by HR, including their ownership and equity structures.
  • Passed without formal amendment.

Ordinance 914-2026 (Fire Chief Assessment with PRADCO)

  • Request to amend a contract with PRADCO for assessment of five fire chief candidates, increasing amount from $46,370 to $75,870. Work had already been completed.
  • Original estimate assumed three candidates; five applied. An additional assessment step was added.
  • Multiple council members (Joe Jones, Chris Harsh, Nikki Hudson, Tem Shaw) questioned the lack of an RFP, the firm’s minority status, and whether civil service had approved the process. Civil Service Director confirmed PRADCO was used previously for the last fire chief selection.
  • Chair announced the ordinance would be held for further discussion; no vote taken.

Ordinance 751-2026 (Employee Assistance Program – EAP)

  • Request to contract for EAP services at $250,000 (reduced from $300,000) for one year with renewal options.
  • Utilization rates: 6.4% (2024), 9.5% (2025), 9.3% (2026 to June). Six free sessions per employee per event.
  • Councilwoman House Jones requested an annual performance report to council before renewal.
  • Councilman Joe Jones moved an amendment requiring a performance review prior to renewal; seconded and passed.
  • Councilman Chris Harsh moved to add a "shall not exceed $250,000" clause in Section 2; seconded and passed.
  • Passed as amended.

Ordinance 750-2026 (Training & Professional Development)

  • Request to contract for organizational development, coaching, and training services at $100,000 (comprising $50,000 reallocated from EAP and $50,000 new funds) for one year with renewal options.
  • Councilman Harsh expressed concern over reliance on consultants and moved two amendments: (1) require written notice to council of cooperative purchases, and (2) add "shall not exceed $100,000" to Section 2. Both seconded and passed.
  • Chair encouraged council members to use this program for staff development.
  • Passed as amended.

OEO Presentation on Community Benefits Agreements

  • Director Tyson Mitchell, Assistant Director Michael Curry, and CBA Administrator Terrell Knight presented.
  • Overview: 52 signed CBAs since 2023; $1.3 billion total construction; $259 million in city incentives (TIFs, abatements, loans, grants); $217 million in certified spend commitments ($89M MBE, $47M FBE, $80M CSB). Also 72 mentor-protégé relationships, 117 paid internships, 5,000+ intern hours.
  • Councilman Joe Jones highlighted systemic issues: lack of minority participation across city departments, payment delays crippling small contractors, and need for a permanent fix.
  • Director Mitchell discussed a new $5 million revolving loan program (ARPA-funded) for subcontractors on the airport project and plans to accelerate payments via ACH.
  • Councilman Tem Shaw raised philosophical concerns about whether the incentives (e.g., $259M) are net beneficial, suggesting direct investment in local contractors might be more effective.
  • Chair emphasized collective responsibility to ensure CBAs meet community needs.

Key Outcomes

  • Ordinance 466-2026 (COBRA): Passed as amended.
  • Ordinance 752-2026 (FMLA): Passed unamended.
  • Ordinance 914-2026 (Fire Chief Assessment): Held for further discussion; no vote.
  • Ordinance 751-2026 (EAP): Passed as amended (with performance review and not-to-exceed $250,000).
  • Ordinance 750-2026 (Training): Passed as amended (with notification and not-to-exceed $100,000).
  • OEO will provide additional data on FMLA and contractor equity, and schedule follow-up meetings on payment reform and CBAs.

Meeting Transcript

Good afternoon, everybody. Thank you all for coming to today's um committee here, which is Tuesday, September 15th, and the committee is workforce education training, youth development committee. Madam Clerk, can you call the row? Here. Present. Ray Car? Here. Here. Thank you so much. We do have about five pieces of legislation that go through today. We will go through the legislation pieces. And then we also do have a presentation from equal opportunity. No? OEO is gonna be here. So that'll be um following the presentation. So I believe we do have the director um of HR here. If you come to the table and we can start with your pieces of legislation. Pretty good, pretty good. Are you by yourself today? No, I have I have a little little crew with the information. Do you want them to come at the table? Would you like them per piece or together? Um together so we can roll it out, and as they go through those different ordinances, we can definitely obviously they can leave and things from that nature. So it's them all stuff. Yep, because we'd like to know who here. Chair. Yes. Quick motion. Are you okay? Uh sorry, folks. What'd you say? Are you okay? I feel like I'm gonna feel like I'm in a kid's chair. Maybe I'm just shrinking. Right. Um, so first piece we will definitely hear will be orders number four sixty-six twenty twenty-six and emergency ordinance authorizing the director of human resources to employ one or more professional consultants to administer the city's Cobra program for a one-year period with two one-year options to renew, exercisable by the director of human resource. Director, before you go into this, can you introduce everyone from your team that's here? Sure, thank you, Chairman. And uh committee to my left is Trisha Simon Webster, she is the benefits manager for the city. To my immediate right is Patrick Lang. He's uh the talent management coordinator for the city. To his right is Kelly Smith, she's the wellness manager for the city, and to her right is Monique Young, and she is the employee relations manager for the city. Uh right, so at the end. Oh, I didn't, and some sorry I didn't see Angela come up. That's Angela Tagler Ferry. She is our fiscal manager for the HR department. All right. So with this ordinance, can you tell us or can you go ahead and present? Uh sure, Chairman. Thank you.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com