0:00
Welcome back to this weekly meeting of the Community Planning and Housing Committee with Denver City Council.
0:09
Your Community Planning and Housing Committee starts now.
0:24
Today is January something, 2026.
0:27
It's definitely Tuesday and we're here in our planning and housing committee.
0:36
Hopefully we'll have more council members trickling in and I will introduce them as they do.
0:40
But for starters, I'm Sarah Parity, one of your council members at large.
0:45
I'm Flora Alvides with Lucky District 7.
0:48
I'm Daryl Watson from District 9.
0:51
We will pause in case we do have anyone online and I also hear footsteps.
0:55
So I will introduce this to you.
0:57
So we have to start your district five.
1:04
With that, I will go ahead and turn it over to Edson Ibanez from Community Planning and
1:09
Development for 260062, a rezoning on North District Street.
1:14
Councilmember Watson.
1:18
Thank you so much, committee chair.
1:20
And thank you to my colleagues for allowing me to present.
1:24
And really, thank you, Edson and CPD, for the good work that you are doing on this.
1:30
I want to share a few words before we turn over for the presentation for Edson.
1:36
This rezoned, from my perspective and from the community's perspective and the applicant's perspective,
1:43
is about repairing harm, restoring housing, and keeping neighbors rooted in Elyria-Swansea communities.
1:50
A few blocks from this site, families once lived on streets that no longer exist.
1:56
Kids walked to school.
1:58
Neighbors watched out for each other.
2:00
Then the I-70 expansion came through Elyria and Swansea neighborhoods.
2:04
Fifty-six homes were removed and families were forced to leave through no fault of their own, based on their positioning.
2:12
What remains are vacant parcels and a promise we still owe this community.
2:18
4631 Josephine Street is one of those vacant.
2:20
parcels left behind. The rezona has four family-sized homes with multiple bedrooms. It is
2:27
one small but meaningful step toward fulfilling the promise the city owes this community.
2:33
This rezone is led by our good friends at Tierra Collectiva and you'll be able to hear from a few
2:38
of them as this process goes along and they'll be available to answer questions from our council
2:43
members. A little bit about Tierra Collectiva. From my perspective, Tierra Collectiva is a
2:48
a trusted community-led partner in Global Air and Swansea.
2:52
They have already delivered 14 permanent homes.
2:58
Ownership homes from families of color and over half the residents being children, which is phenomenal.
3:03
They have 23 more ownership homes and about 220 rentals in a pipeline.
3:09
At 4965 Washington Street, that council members are fully aware of,
3:13
They are delivering 170 affordable apartments, community space, and a library in collaboration with the city.
3:21
Tierra Colectiva's homes stay affordable forever through a 99-year renewable ground lease.
3:27
And this ReZone matters because it allows for affordability, affordability decided by the community through Tierra Colectiva and their amazing community-informed process.
3:37
This Rezone Alliance and Blueprint Denver, it supports Comprehensive Plan 2040, goals for equity and housing stability.
3:44
It follows the Gilarious Swansea neighborhood plan.
3:47
The Rezone also supports missing middle housing on local streets and matches the scale of nearby homes.
3:53
These homes include yards and spaces for kids to grow up because this housing is built for families, not investors.
4:00
Our office has collaborated throughout the process with Tierra Colectiva, not just on this, but on other rezones.
4:07
And we look forward to hearing your questions from Council and look forward to hearing the presentation from CPD.
4:13
Thank you, Madam Chair.
4:15
This is Edson Ibanez with CPD.
4:17
Thank you, Council Member Watson, for that introduction.
4:20
So this is one property that was impacted by the I-70 expansion.
4:24
It's currently vacant.
4:25
And so the request is to go from former Chapter 59 PUD into the Denver Zoning Code URH 2.5, which is a row house up to 2.5 stories in height.
4:36
So I'll go through the request.
4:37
We'll look at the location and context, and we'll review the process and jump into the review criteria for this rezoning.
4:44
So the request is a row house up to 2.5 stories.
4:47
So the site itself is 16,000 square feet.
4:51
But like I mentioned, it was impacted by the I-70 expansion.
4:56
The site is vacant, and the request is for row houses up to 2.5 stories.
5:03
The applicant, Tierra Colectiva, is looking to construct four row houses here with parking on the alley.
5:14
So looking at the location context, it's located in Council District 9, Councilmember Watson District.
5:18
and it's in the heart, kind of in the middle of the Alara Swansea neighborhood there.
5:24
Like I mentioned, the zoning is PUD 335, but it's surrounded by ETUB, which is highlighted in yellow.
5:31
ETUB is a two-unit zone district.
5:34
And then directly to the west of the site is URH 2.5, which is the same zone district this property is applying for,
5:40
which is at Row House, up to 2.5 stories in hell.
5:43
To the south, we have EMX2, which is a mixed-use up to two stories,
5:47
but it's predominantly residential here. PUD 335 is a former Chapter 59 zone district
5:55
that was for an auto body repair shop, which was previously here, but it also allowed for
6:01
commercial uses. And now it's just vacant. So like I mentioned in the land use, this site is
6:07
currently vacant. To the north and mostly to the east, we have a single unit residential,
6:15
but the zoning is two unit, and it's predominantly single family here.
6:21
So the site is highlighted on the bottom right corner, as you can see,
6:25
closed off by a fence there, which is vacant.
6:29
And then to the north of the site, we see single family houses,
6:33
which predominantly range from one story and two stories.
6:37
And then just wanted to highlight some of the affordable housing for this specific site.
6:40
So G.S. Coalicentera Colectiva Community Land Trust will develop, like I mentioned, four affordable home ownership units.
6:49
They will be income restricted of up to 80% of the AMI, Area Medium Income, with a 99-year land lease.
6:58
So jumping into the process, there was an informational notice sent out in November.
7:02
It went before the planning board this month on the 7th, and it's before you today,
7:08
and tentatively scheduled to go before City Council Public Haring on March 9th.
7:13
We've notified all the R&Os as part of this process.
7:16
We did receive one letter of support from the Nularis-Swanzae R&O.
7:20
Additionally, we received 22 letters of support.
7:23
The letter of the R&O as well as the letters of support all highlighted its support for affordable housing.
7:31
It's consistent with plan guidance and having a diversity of housing options and home ownership in the neighborhood and how this will help attain that.
7:41
Now, jumping into the review criteria, the Denver zoning code highlights three review criteria that every rezoning have to follow,
7:47
which is consistency with adopted plans, public interest, and how the rezoning is consistent with the neighborhood context, zoning district purpose, and intent statements.
7:55
So the first one, consistent with adoptive plans.
7:58
It's consistent with three specific plans, which is Conference and Plan 2040, Blueprint in Denver, and the Alara-Swanzee Neighborhood Plan.
8:07
So the staff report highlights multiple strategies that this rezoning is consistent with, but I want to highlight a few under equity goals,
8:13
such as equitable, affordable, and inclusive goal-to-strategia, create a greater mix of housing options in every neighborhood for all individuals and families,
8:20
and encourage quality infill development that is consistent with the surrounding neighborhood
8:25
that offers opportunities for increased amenities.
8:28
And under climate goals, under environmentally resilient goal A,
8:31
strategy A, promote infill development where infrastructures and services are already in place.
8:35
When we jump into Blueprint Denver, it's classified as urban and neighborhood context,
8:39
which this is predominantly single and two-unit uses on smaller lots.
8:45
And within place type, it's classified as low residential,
8:47
which is predominantly single and two-unit uses on small and medium lots.
8:51
And building heights are generally up to 2.5 stories in height.
8:55
Now, Josephine Street is a local street, but you do have York and 46 South in close proximity
9:04
that are collector streets, like mixed-use collector street there on York Street.
9:12
In terms of the growth area strategy, it's classified as all areas of the city
9:15
where we anticipate 20% of new housing growth and 10% of new employment growth by 2040.
9:21
Additionally, it does fall under more of our equity goals and concepts within Blueprint,
9:27
such as the land use and bill form housing goal to diversify housing options
9:31
by exploring opportunities to integrate missing middle housing
9:34
into low and low-medium residential areas,
9:37
as well as increase the development of affordable housing and mixed income housing.
9:40
And then, you know, in terms of climate impacts, multi-unit buildings are more energy efficient than low-density residential development types.
9:52
When we look at the Alaria-Swansee neighborhood plan, it's classified as single-family duplex with heights up to 2.5 stories in height.
10:00
But when we go into the definition of what is a single-family duplex, it's residential areas that are moderately dense areas that are primary residential.
10:08
This has a mixture of housing types, such as single-family houses, duplexes, row houses, and small apartment complex.
10:16
So the definition does allow for row houses.
10:19
Additionally, when we're looking at policy, let's talk about explore opportunities to introduce building forms that are consistent with a single-family duplex.
10:27
Land designations, such as duplexes, tandem houses, and row houses.
10:31
and then as well as encourage investment of new housing to expand the total number of residents
10:37
and to provide for a diversity of housing types to bring more people of all ages and income levels into the neighborhood.
10:44
In terms of public interest, it's consistent as specified in the staff report
10:48
as the goals and policies as found in the small area plan and blueprint Denver income plan
10:53
and it's consistent with the neighborhood context on district purpose and intentments as specified in the staff report.
10:58
Therefore, CPT recommends all approval based on all the findings of the Rookertur have been met.
11:04
I'm available for questions.
11:05
The applicant can get up with the Divas here for any questions.
11:09
Thank you so much for your time.
11:12
I would like to welcome Council President Sandoval and Pro Temer Mel Campbell to the meeting.
11:16
And the queue so far is Council Member Sawyer followed by Council Member Alvedrez.
11:19
Thanks, Madam Chair.
11:21
Really appreciate you bringing this forward.
11:23
This is really, really exciting.
11:25
I think it meets all of the criteria.
11:28
I'm happy to move it forward.
11:31
But I do have a question.
11:33
I've never seen one of these come through before, right?
11:36
Like these, we always hear about the eminent domain that happened with the I-70 project,
11:40
but I've never actually seen it mapped like this before where the property is half in the street now.
11:47
Um, so I'm curious when you say that it's a 16,000 square foot, a little over 16,000 square foot property, does that include the part that's in the middle of the street now?
12:00
Um, the parcel itself is the GIS mapping is still being fixed for these areas.
12:06
And so, so technically the parcel is significantly less than 16,000 square feet.
12:12
It's not, but that's how the records show.
12:17
Nola and Danny, or...
12:18
Do you know what the square footage is?
12:22
You've got to come up to the mic and introduce yourself.
12:24
Just so the people, if there's anyone online, can hear you.
12:27
Thanks so much for both of you being here as well.
12:29
Hi, I'm Nola Miguel.
12:30
I'm the Executive Director of the GS Coalition and Tierra Colectiva Community Land Trust.
12:34
And this is Danny Slebo, who's our Real Estate Director for Tierra Colectiva.
12:39
So I want to say it's about 9,000-something.
12:43
Hi, Danny, real estate development director for Tierra Colectiva.
12:51
Y'all got me so flustered.
12:52
I can't even say my own name.
12:54
I would need to look at the survey to be accurate and really know.
12:59
But I think it's roughly half of 16.
13:02
So probably around 9,000 to 10,000 square feet.
13:05
9,000 in one of the PowerPoints that's in the documents.
13:10
Yeah, I didn't pull up the staff report to look in it
13:13
because I usually wait until the hearing to do that.
13:15
But I've never seen this come through before.
13:19
And so when you said 16,500 square feet, I was like,
13:22
it's a little big parcel, and that doesn't look like 16,000 square feet to me.
13:28
That's really, really interesting.
13:30
So the property, do you pay full property tax on that?
13:39
Let me, if I can back up just a step.
13:41
Um, so there were a bunch of remnant parcels all along the highway, predominantly on the
13:47
north side of the highway.
13:48
Um, so we worked with director Lou of CDOT, um, to figure out, okay, which of these parcels
13:55
would be good for housing.
13:57
Um, and, but then they couldn't just sell them to us or just give them to us.
14:02
We had to actually buy them and we had to buy them for market rate value.
14:05
So we worked with Senator Hickenlooper's office to get congressionally designated funds to purchase the properties.
14:19
So yes, it took many steps.
14:20
So this is one of three parcels that we're purchasing.
14:24
This is potentially the only one that needs rezoning.
14:27
There's another one that might.
14:30
But it's a different issue.
14:32
So Habitat for Humanity, we've been incubated under the Colorado Community Land Trust, and then Habitat for Humanity, Metro Denver, and Colorado Community Land Trust merged.
14:47
So right now, Habitat for Humanity still owns these.
14:51
We normally apply for a tax exemption for all of our properties, just the land portion of the properties.
15:00
And then the home buyer pays taxes, but they only pay taxes on what they could resell the home for.
15:07
So they don't pay taxes at a market rate.
15:10
So we're not going to, I just want to kind of, like I said, I've never seen one of these come through before.
15:18
And I just want to make sure that we're not paying, we're not setting a future homeowner of an affordable property up in a situation where they are going to be paying property tax for a portion of the property that is road now.
15:38
Is there anything else you wanted to add?
15:40
I pulled up the survey for the, you know, record or whatever.
15:44
It's about 9,484 square feet.
15:48
Okay. Got it. Thank you very much. Really appreciate that clarification.
15:54
But this is an interesting one just because these remnant parts, this is the first remnant parcel that's come through like this.
15:59
So that's it for me. Thanks.
16:01
And what we'll do, Council Member, sorry, this goes to the floor.
16:04
We'll preempt in a presentation the clarifier of this, the things that you just kind of clarified.
16:11
we'll preempt in a presentation the sizing and all that stuff so that folks
16:16
know on record on beforehand and of course on Danny and Nolo be there answer
16:20
questions again. Awesome thanks thanks you guys. Well thank you great questions and
16:24
the only other member I have in the queue is Council member I'll be addressed so let me know if anyone else wanted.
16:28
Thank you. Thank you for bringing this forward to everyone. Always excited to see
16:32
more housing this is much needed family housing is something that I continue to
16:37
say that we need. And I appreciate the story because part of one of the questions is going
16:42
to be how to pay for it. But I am curious about, and I really appreciate Nola, you asking for that
16:50
comparison just to see, but what would the resale value look like? And have you done any type of
16:56
analysis of who would potentially qualify to purchase these parcels eventually?
17:03
um maybe i'll take the so um we we do orientations um in the neighborhood to work with people families
17:14
in the neighborhood that are interested in purchasing a home and go through all the details
17:18
of um the process of buying a home um the requirements for getting onto our wait list
17:25
and also the restrictions that exist with the community land trust as compared to a traditional
17:30
home. So we go over all of that and then prepare folks that they, in order to get on our wait list,
17:36
they need to do a CHFA certified first time home buyers class and qualify for or pre-qualify for
17:44
a loan on the home, which sometimes is the hardest part. So then we have a wait list of folks.
17:53
And as homes come up, we ask on our wait list, would you like to buy this home? And they take
17:58
a look at it. And if they want to buy it, then, um, then we move forward and we have to income
18:03
qualify folks. So they do have to be below 80% of the AMI. That's what I was wondering, like
18:09
who, what is the scenario where an individual would qualify? So I'm guessing around 80,000,
18:15
what would the family size be at 80,000? I'm guessing based on AMI being around a hundred
18:21
thousand. Um, and how many people are there that may have a specific amount of money and can
18:27
qualify to buy a home. Usually it's between about 50 and a hundred thousand is kind of just
18:32
depending on how many people are in the household that are qualifying. I don't know if you would add.
18:38
Yeah. Tierra Collectiva works because our mission is anti-displacement focused.
18:44
We work with who's interested in becoming a homeowner and we help them get prepared
18:48
and repair their credit and do everything else that they need to do. And often that means that
18:54
We're also looking at what's reasonable for them to actually afford and what's truly like a reasonable purchase price.
19:02
So we actually provide our homes at a purchase price between $200,000 and $225,000 for a three-bedroom house in Denver County.
19:12
That's about a third of the market rate currently.
19:14
We also help folks access down payment assistance resources so that they can reduce that purchase price even more.
19:23
And actually right now we have a small two-bedroom that we're looking at listing slightly below $200,000.
19:29
So that allows a pretty deep level of affordability.
19:33
We aim to support homeownership for folks between 50% AMI and 80% AMI,
19:40
understanding that when we go below that, we can sometimes create a vulnerability for folks
19:45
who might not be able to keep up with maintenance costs or tax increases over time,
19:52
even though there are very limited tax increases because of the limited increase in resale value.
20:00
And I understand also that they don't pay on the land.
20:03
So how much is your land lease fee?
20:05
And are you planning on having an HOA for these?
20:08
Yeah, that's another aspect of the affordability.
20:12
We very specifically design our development to avoid the necessity for an HOA
20:17
because that's when we really get into challenges with affordability
20:20
because of insurance requirements because Colorado is super fun with condos.
20:26
Our land lease fee is $90 a year.
20:29
We have no, oh, I'm sorry, $90 a month.
20:33
And we have no intention of increasing that anytime soon.
20:38
Thank you for answering all that.
20:39
I appreciate the thought you've put into this.
20:42
I was also going to add that one of the things Danny and Nola also share
20:46
is that the targeted community or folks that live in global air response
20:50
So the workshops, I mean, they're not saying folks from outside can't come and participate in the workshops.
20:56
But it is when you look at the households, I don't know if you all have the percent, so I'm not going to ask you.
21:00
But from the households, it's a very large percent of communities that live in G.S.
21:06
that would either have to be displaced and go to another city, not even another neighborhood in Denver, to be able to live and own.
21:14
and they're doing it for folks who live there now who are paying rent,
21:19
and then they're getting an out to home.
21:21
I was able to go on the bus tour with you all,
21:24
and that was really meaningful to meet some of the people that you have helped with housing
21:27
and hearing you explain how when Habitat was doing it,
21:31
they weren't able to really necessarily get people from community.
21:34
So I think all that is really important and commend that work.
21:37
So thank you for all you're doing.
21:44
Thank you committee chair. That's all I have. Yeah, great questions to both of you. We always learn a lot when you guys are in the room. Council president is next in queue. Thank you. Just want to say thank you. I know you've been working on this, but you love this area with every fiber of your being, Nola.
21:59
From when we started as councillors in 2012 together, you've been diligent, steadfast, and just thank you so much for your leadership figuring out how CDOT, I mean, we couldn't even figure out how to put a mural.
22:13
on CDOT when you and I were working together and then you figured out a bureaucracy of how to
22:18
buy a parcel of remnant land from CDOT. I couldn't even figure that out. I ended up putting,
22:24
because I-70 goes into Northwest Emberies, you know, I ended up having to put a community garden
22:29
there, a Doug community garden, because I just got so tired with the bureaucracy that I was told no,
22:35
no, no, no. And it's really hard when you get told no so many times and to figure out how to
22:41
So, just thank you for your commitment to this neighborhood. Thank you council member Watson for sponsoring this. This is what democracy in a good way looks like and putting trust back into our local government is exactly what you all are doing. So, bravo.
22:54
Thank you, Madam chair.
22:57
Well, I'm going to president. Anybody else have any questions? All right. Can I get a motion? Second?
23:04
I'll move seconded by Pro Tem.
23:07
I don't think anyone needs a voice vote. Thumbs up to go to the floor.
23:11
We will joyfully see you there. Thank you guys.
23:13
And that is it for committee today. Nothing on consent.