0:00And thank you for joining us for the internal operations standing committee meeting on today, Wednesday, September 17th.
0:08Madam Clerk, please call the row.
0:12Councilmember Letitia Johnson.
0:14Councilmember Mary Waters.
0:17Councilmember Angela Whitfield Callaway.
0:19Member Callaway did indicate that she would be a little behind this morning, but she's on her way.
0:24Madam Chair, we do have quorum.
0:28Having a quorum present, we are now in session.
0:32Good morning, Member Waters.
0:34Is there a motion on the minutes?
0:37Hearing no objections, that action shall be taken.
0:42We are going to move into general public comment.
0:46If there is anyone joining us in person or virtually who'd like to make a public comment, please raise your hand.
0:53Please raise your hand.
0:54Public comment will be cut off at 1007.
1:00So you have one minute to determine if you'd like to raise your hand to make a public comment.
1:06And good morning, Ms.
1:08How many hands do we currently have raised?
1:13Morning, madam chair.
1:14We currently have 10 hands raised for virtual public comment.
1:17All right, let's give everyone two minutes, and I will let you all know again when 1007 hits, and public comment will be cut off.
1:28Who's our first caller?
1:34Our first caller is Mr.
1:37Rue, you have two minutes for general public comment.
1:45Well, Letitia Johnson.
1:48The two minutes you give up for public comment is more than enough to articulate the state.
1:57Emphatically state that you're a cheated in public official.
2:02Now Angela Whitfield Callaway is cheated in.
2:23The rest of the Detroit City Council, right along with the school board.
2:28That's the school board.
2:31And also Board of Police Commissioners.
2:35Detroit Board of Police Commissioners, BOPC, and the mayor.
2:42And of course, some judges, all elected positions in the city of Detroit.
2:52Have been um tainted with City of Detroit has been took over by absentee ballot fraud, committed by Detroit City Clerk and Chairperson of the Detroit Election Commission, along with the director of the Detroit Department of Elections.
3:14Now your committee is internal operations.
3:18You need to call Gina Avery Walker before your committee to explain all these fraudulent absentee ballots, Detroit voting trap houses, and what has been taking place in the city clerk's office in the Detroit Department of Elections that she knows of.
3:42Going all the way to the mat with this one, Letitia.
3:48Thank you for saying my name correctly.
3:58Next caller is iPhone.
4:01iPhone, you have two minutes for general public comment.
4:14First of all, I want to say thank you.
4:16Um honorable uh councilmember Johnson and Chair for your information in regards to the neighborhood beautification grant.
4:24We are working on that.
4:27Um if you would like to donate to our uh association, you can do that by going to Zell and going to D as in boy, E as an at work, D.
4:41No, let me start that over again.
4:43D as in dog, E as an at word, D S M Boy, A, W E L, B S M Boy, E L at Gmail.com.
5:00Again, that is D as in dog, E as an At word, D S M Boy, A, W E L, B as in Boy, E L at Gmail.com.
5:09If you are a senior, 60 years of age or older, need assistance and services at your home, please go to the uh Franklin Wright Settlement Organization.
5:20You can call them at 313, 579 1000, extension 301, go to 313 579 1000, extension 301.
5:34They give extensive free services to help seniors.
5:38They replace faucets, light bulbs, door locks.
5:41They're gonna be trimming some branches for me.
5:44They remove uh snow and ice, uh seasonal work.
5:48They also re uh take care of your landscaping as far as leaves, they do carpet cleaning.
5:56Uh they do all types of things.
5:58They install scream doors, storm doors, weather.
6:03It's a good program, it's free for seniors.
6:06Please share this information.
6:07Thank you, and God bless you all.
6:11And before we proceed, I do just want to remind everyone that public comment is cut off.
6:17And Madam Clerk, if you will note that Member Callaway has been with us since public comment started.
6:28The next caller is not that, Karen.
6:31Not that Karen, you have two minutes for general public comment.
6:40Uh I'm a senior, but I'm unfortunately I don't qualify for any of these free programs.
6:47That's why the um fast track that city council resolution and city council passed doesn't really help me.
6:54But what would help me and um many other seniors are retired from the uh as Detroit city retirees is if we got made, uh we were restored and made whole.
7:06Most of us don't qualify, you know, to get on these lists, to be on list forever and still not get help if they call you.
7:14So we what we like is we like the clawbacks to stop.
7:17We'd like to be restored whole.
7:19We we would like for our pension and our health care benefits to be restored.
7:23Well, just as anyone would rightfully expect when they fulfill their part of a bargain of a contract.
7:30Uh homelessness is a huge issue.
7:34And we need to figure out how to get these families off the street before the snow sets in, before the cold sets in, because winter is coming, winter is coming, winter is coming.
7:43Uh 600 million dollars over taxation.
7:46We're still waiting for that, just like we're still waiting.
7:49It seems like the city pay plays a wait you out game with the majority of its issues, legal issues, and they seem the you know, people die off or whatever, and so they seem to get out of things situations just because the lawyers are crafty with waiting, not crafty with skill, but crafty with wait out.
8:08Um limits, we should have term limits for all elected officials, not just uh for the governor, and not just for the president, even though president is trying to illegally extend his.
8:21We need term limits, and we need you guys to rotate your committees, like the charter says, so you don't get dug in and get buddy buddy with a lot of the uh ill-to-do partners that you partner with to get city business done.
8:42The next caller is William M.
8:46Davis, you have two minutes for general public comment.
8:49Good morning, young ladies.
8:53I'll call to start off by saying that I do agree with not that Karen, the city does and should be doing more to help city chart retirees.
9:02I also would like to make a prediction that Mike Dugman is going to lose badly next year if he does not do something to help the city chart retirees.
9:13Because he has done very little in his 12 years.
9:16You know, in fact, during the course of his time in office, uh, a group of us put together a group that's gonna travel the state next year to make sure he's not he's not elected governor.
9:29Uh during the time he's been in office, the city of Detroit has went from the 18th largest city to the 26th largest city.
9:37You know, there's been property has never dropped below 30 percent.
9:41You know, we already have a list of over 100 failures of Mike Duggan.
9:47And we're gonna travel the state, myself and others, and we're gonna tell the everyone about his many, many failures.
9:54You know, I'm surprised, and I would not be surprised after we tell everybody his many failures, if other legal action might be taken against them.
10:04But you know, the city chart retirees, you know, we we we suffer, we suffered and we suffered, you know.
10:12When he was running, he said he's gonna do more to help us.
10:15That hasn't happened.
10:16He said he's gonna do something about property.
10:17That hasn't happened.
10:18You know, he said he was gonna make sure the city trait grows.
10:23Grow in the city's trait is not what's happening.
10:26He goes from the 18th largest city to the 26th largest city, and I think there's a whole lot of corruption, a whole lot of questionable practices.
10:35You know, the city excels and making rich people richer, but not retirees, not seniors, not middle class people.
10:43They that they just sent all too many tax abatements and exemptions to the rich.
10:54The next caller is Miko A.
10:58Williams, you have two minutes for general public comment.
11:06Can I be heard, please?
11:09Um, I want to address comments from yesterday uh from a community official that was speaking very anti-Semitic comments in regards to legal immigrants.
11:20No one is illegal on stolen land, okay.
11:24They once deemed black people illegal and not even an entity.
11:28So you may want to be careful with your comments, especially when you're representing a role to get homeowners uh they're just due back, which I don't understand what the uh what that group is even doing, and the housing activists of Detroit.
11:43Um it's just terrible.
11:45You know, Stephen Harwing comes up here and spews his mess.
11:49He still doesn't understand that political violence.
11:52I believe he will be a mass shooter, and he's gonna uh shoot all of us.
11:56And I don't ever want that to happen, but you need to heed the signs, city council.
12:01You need to heed the signs of people.
12:02You I could say the same thing.
12:04People can say the same thing about uh Motor City Rue and others making threatening comments in this body uh on this floor.
12:11We we all have a right to public speech and free speech.
12:15Truth telling is not hate speech.
12:17We telling the truth.
12:18Some of us here comes with facts, and it's ignored.
12:22But when it gets too extreme, when it gets too chilling, and when it goes too far, that has to be stopped and dead.
12:30You know, people can't just run up on you and characterly assassinate you every single chance uh they get and put you out there false of character.
12:38That's uh unacceptable, and it should be unacceptable in any public body governing or otherwise.
12:44We all should have civility towards one another.
12:48We are all broken, but the people across eight mile want to see us with corn and blankets.
12:53Remember all those comments.
12:55We were called monkeys and uh in a zoo for wanting to bail out.
12:59We were called every horrible name by people across eight mile who still want to see us going in a white supremacist mayor who would love to cast us all away.
13:07Thank you for taking my comments.
13:11The next excuse me, the next caller.
13:15The next caller is Cunningham.
13:17Cunningham, you have two minutes for general public comment.
13:26313, 444, 9114, 313, 444, 9114, 313, 444, 911.
13:36That member was made.
13:42You can remember it.
13:43And on Facebook, not enemy.
13:47Again, on Facebook, not enemy.
13:51As I go around the city, uh, you know, people tell me about the bus service, how uh the wait times are increasing, and I'm giving out the bus tickets and the ice water around the city, and then in the winter times, the bus chickens, the hand warmers and the gloves.
14:10And uh a lot of people come to me with their problems or issues.
14:15Um, just yesterday, a gentleman uh come here in voices, and he's office meds, and so I pray, you know, I'm a center saved by grace for sure.
14:28I'm very flawed, but I pray with him in the name of Jesus, and uh we call the police.
14:35Um, so you can get some assistance and hospitalization.
14:41Um medication is very important.
14:44Uh and people that care, um, are neither around this city.
14:50Uh so I just wanted to say that uh I hope that he's doing well.
15:00Um but these are luster and these prayer, and I want y'all to show some love either through me, uh, help me maintain the vehicle, the outreach vehicle, our purchase bus tickets and things of that nature, or just do it on your own.
15:11I may not be your cup of tea, but again, people need assistance, the buses are not on time, and everybody needs a little bit of love.
15:21And I want to thank both of these or all of these council members for the assistance and more assistance is needed.
15:38Ronald Foster, you have two minutes for general public comment.
15:42Good morning, uh, through the chair.
15:45Uh things um first thing I'll say I appreciate uh this body, although I continue to come down.
15:53I will continue to come down because it has been proven that this voice can um bring about change with the right ears in place and people that are passionate about the city.
16:08Um, I'm very happy the last few years.
16:11Uh, nearly everything that I've advocated for in this community have been heard.
16:16Messages have been shared, and there have been results.
16:20I continue to come down because we continue to have a lot more work to do.
16:25Um, just on the line item of day 8.4.
16:29You know, that's 250,000 and just one line item with police.
16:35We can no longer just conceal what it is that we're paying out.
16:40The public have a right to know.
16:42And if we have to change bylaws within the unions or whatever else, the public have a right to know, and more importantly, it is uh has to be open for discovery.
16:52Police can no longer get paid off settlements and everything, and it's not reflected within the judicial body when they are bringing on cases to where people discovery is vital, it is necessary, is the first point in bringing charges on anyone.
17:10That means the sculptory and impeachable discovery, and this city has been failing to do those things, which brings a great disadvantage to impoverished communities that cannot afford lawyers that cannot afford other things, and so we have to do better and being more transparent and holding accountable.
17:29Trump and Miss Blondie, one of the things they're doing is having law enforcement come in with shirts on that do not identify who they are.
17:37We have to be cautious about accountability within our communities on every level.
17:43Thank you all for listening.
17:51The next caller is owner Papa.
17:54Caller, you have two minutes for general public comment.
17:59Good morning, Carolyn Hughes, to the chairman, have you heard?
18:04Um, this is at the internal operations committee.
18:08This is the committee that's supposed to make sure that things are running in the different areas, departments effectively.
18:15Um we've mentioned about the 8.4, the 250,000, but that's that's just a drop in the bucket.
18:24My my question to this committee is why are we not calling the police here to ask why we have such an increase in the number of lawsuits uh perpetrated by the police, obviously.
18:37And um why isn't the police union giving them their representation?
18:45Why are we paying for legal representation for police officers and indemnification of police officers who have committed obviously atrocities sometimes or crimes against the actual citizens?
18:59Ums um uh Winston brings up a great point.
19:06We are a lawless city now.
19:10The charter says the committees should be changed every two years, and that is to that is to keep corruption down.
19:18Now, if you want to continue in the vein that you're continuing in, and and I see a contract on here with an amendment to change the contract, not just extend the time, but change the contract.
19:29Um I'm not sure how things are working in this city, but internal operations is it's under your purview to make sure that things are functioning the way they should be functioning.
19:39Hornsby, who just arbitrarily, unilaterally, um, forgave the land bank millions of dollars um that he doesn't have a right to do, and you should probably have an investigation on why and how he was allowed to do that.
19:56Um this city is has become a lawless city.
20:02We have them use them.
20:08And before we proceed, I'd like to call the 1025 interview to order and recess it to the call of the chair.
20:17Jackson, do we have any additional public commenters?
20:22Madam Chair, there are three more hands raised.
20:26Who's our next caller?
20:29Caller is caller ending in one two four.
20:32Caller ending in one two four.
20:33You have two minutes for general public comment.
20:47Um I just want to say how disturbing it was that I timely had my hand raised yesterday, but and I let Terrace Blossman know I was in timely, but I wasn't called on.
20:58Um, but thank you to this committee for not doing that kind of thing.
21:02Uh, regarding the person for the Brownfield CAC, will you please make sure to ask them what they will do to make sure that nearby impacted residents get notice of their meetings?
21:13Because in the past, my experience was we didn't get notice, except one person got notice like five minutes before the meeting, and then people scrambled to get on there.
21:24You're doing a right to counsel.
21:26But where was the right to counsel for the solar taking victims?
21:30I mean, some of those attorneys you hired are really cruising for a bar complaint.
21:34Like you can't not serve someone who's incarcerated and then take their property.
21:41Also, um, will you please have the city clerk explain how it is that Melissa Love ended up on the voter rolls, but she's telling you repeatedly she did not vote.
21:52Also, have the city clerk explain why is she not signing the record for BZA cases in third circuit if she's required to under uh court rules.
22:02Sheffield's office won't investigate the lies the law department told about me.
22:06Will you please do it, member waters?
22:09And they told lies about me and they told lies to me.
22:11They said they were full.
22:12I knew it wasn't true.
22:13I had a friend call in, he got hired and worked the election.
22:16And then last but not least, it's very uh I was in shock at Jamico in law school, but unfortunately, our law, our property law is based on the law of the conqueror.
22:29Johnson, the case was who had good title, the guy who bought it, the person who bought it from like a European settler or the Native American, and the court said that the person who got it from the settler had good title because our law is based on law of the conqueror.
22:50Next caller is to hear it amed.
22:52To hear Ahmed, you have two minutes for general public comment.
22:58Good morning, uh City Council.
23:00Uh, one program I want to highlight is, and I want to thank you, uh, member Callaway.
23:06You've been so helpful to me.
23:09Uh I was treated uh rawly and wrongly by Mary Sheffield um in terms of home repair, and I was treated uh horribly by Coleman Young and his mother, who uh his mother attacked me after Coleman Young told me to call.
23:30And then he's the one that said uh uh the reason why I didn't help you get home repairs is what you say in uh a public comment.
23:37Okay, so that's the kind of corruption we are talking about.
23:40Prevention from uh people from getting help from the city council.
23:45I pay taxes, I deserve the kind of help.
23:48Mary Sheffield has put me on a list.
23:50I've been on several different home repair lists, and thank you, Ms.
23:54Hughes, for explaining why I never came up on any of those lists.
23:58They stole our grants, our home repair grants.
24:01Uh, I want to highlight my her.
24:04Uh Michigan home repair, uh energy rebates program.
24:09That's the Michigan Home Energy Rebate Program.
24:14Get on there, you all you need home repair, they help with um electric electrical problems, reduce the energy use and enhance comfort and indoor and brother Miko.
24:30If somebody come in my home and take over my house, uh uh take my food, my energy, all my resources, and then demand and say that they have a right in my house.
24:46Miko, you are confused in more ways than I would like to say right now, but you are confused in this matter.
24:53No, illegal immigrants do not have a right to come here and steal our resources and push black people back.
25:06The last caller is Galaxy X22 Ultra.
25:12You have two minutes for general public comment.
25:26Uh, first of all, I'm um I'm praying for all y'all.
25:30You know, I'm not gonna bash you, I'm gonna pray for you that you get stronger and uh and and wave where we need you at.
25:39You know, it's no such as calling and bashing you, you know.
25:42I'm saying we just pray for each other.
25:45I I pray every morning at five o'clock in the morning.
25:49You know, even for the good, the bad, and everyone.
25:52One of the problems we have is uh people calling in after another person say something like that, Stephen yesterday, and bashing somebody for their comment.
26:04You know, I hear a lot of comments on here that I don't like, but I'm not gonna go bash them.
26:08That's their opinion, you know.
26:10And I know y'all take in a whole lot from folks, you know.
26:14We just gotta be strong.
26:17You know, we gotta work together.
26:19You know, I know people disagree, but we have to work together.
26:23You guys in that seat, we have to work with you, and you have to work with us.
26:28You know, I've been uh you know, I've been calling in about these fumes and about uh uh different uh problems we have on the east side, you know.
26:38Uh we have to we have to work at it together.
26:42So I'll just tell y'all, y'all gotta be strong, keep praying.
26:46We go keep praying because we know Doug and then and then messed over us, took money from the retirees.
26:52I don't know why they ain't gotta give the retirees back their money, but you can find money to give to billionaire, but you can't find money to set them whole again after they didn't sign the contract and went through it.
27:05It's sad that we have to go through this, but I'm just telling y'all keep fighting, keep being keep uh be strong, and uh I'm gonna keep praying for y'all.
27:14That's that's all I have to say.
27:17Thank you so much, Mr.
27:21It was nice to end on a good note.
27:24All right, that now concludes our general public comment, and we are now going to go back to the 1025 interview.
27:33I'd like to call it back to order.
27:36And the 1025 interview is for Kristen Lesson, I believe, uh, for the elected officials compensation commission.
27:45If you will please join us at the table.
27:48And once you get settled, if you wouldn't mind touching the base of the microphone, the light will turn green.
27:54And this is a mayoral uh appointment.
27:59Please introduce yourself for the record.
28:02Good morning, everyone.
28:03Uh, my name is Kristen Lessen.
28:05Um, I'm an attorney for about 20 years.
28:07I used to work in the law department.
28:09Um, and I formerly served on the board of ethics, but my term expired this past summer.
28:14All right, thank you for that.
28:15Because when I saw your name, I said, wait, she's on the board of ethics, but did confirm that your term had expired.
28:22Please share with the um general public information about who you are.
28:27You indicated you're an attorney, you worked for the law department.
28:30Um, tell us about who you are as an individual.
28:34Uh well, as an individual, um, I live in Detroit.
28:37Um, I've live, I bought a home in 2017.
28:41Uh, lived downtown since 2015.
28:44Um, I have a three-year-old son, and uh um what else?
28:49I don't know much personal life outside of having the son, but um, I wanted to continue to serve the city because I really enjoyed being on the board of ethics, especially during a transition time.
28:59Um, I served two terms, I served as many terms as you could, and um we were going through um finding a new executive director, so I was acting executive director for a while.
29:09I just found it to be really rewarding, so hoping to continue to serve, and there was an opening on this board, so I'm here to um hopefully serve again.
29:17All right, thank you.
29:18Um I do have a question for you.
29:21Do you or any immediate family members work for any position within the legislative, executive, or judicial branch of government?
29:31All right, okay, that is one um stipulation for individuals who serve on the elected officials compensation commission.
29:40So wanted to clarify that.
29:43Colleagues, any questions, comments?
29:47Um, thank you, madam chair, and good morning, ma'am.
29:49Um, you have my full support.
29:51Um, I know the work that you've done on the board of ethics.
30:00I've had personal experience with the Board of Ethics, and um you were um forthcoming, you were um very um proactive.
30:06Um you were not biased, um, you were very neutral, and you listened to both sides, and um I remembered you, and I just um am excited about um you possibly serving in this capacity, and again, you have my full support because I know that you um are able to look at both sides of an issue or situation and come back with a very balanced um fair determination.
30:37I know that to be true about you, and so again, um good morning, and thank you for your willingness to serve in another capacity.
30:45And how long is that term for directors on the board of ethics?
30:48Because I know you would know quicker than me.
30:50Um well, I fulfilled a term of someone that um Miss Alma Stalworth, who had left the board.
30:56Um so I finished out her term, but there are two five-year terms.
30:59So I served um the remaining three of hers, and then an additional five, uh, so seven years total.
31:06Okay, and through the chair to yourself, how long is the term?
31:09Because you would know this as well for the executive director of the board of ethics.
31:14Oh, I don't believe she has a term.
31:16She's just we just hire them.
31:19Um, and that's why when we had the previous executive director, um, we actually let her go, and it was a long process to do that to make sure we did it correctly and had all the information.
31:29So they're they're just they serve at the pleasure of the board.
31:33So as long as they are, you know, at the pleasure of the board, they stay.
31:38Through the chair to you, how long can they stay until they do something where they are no longer yeah, yes, I believe it's indefinite, you know, they can stay in the role as long as that needs to change.
31:48Um, so we can talk, have those conversations later.
31:51That absolutely needs to change.
31:53Um, and I don't know what we can do, but that needs to change.
31:58Um, and it should not be indefinitely that you're sitting there.
32:03Um, and that's just my opinion.
32:05So um I'll look into that in my second term starting in January of 2026.
32:11Thank you so much, and you have my full support.
32:12Thank you, madam chair.
32:15Any additional questions, comments?
32:22I appreciate that, Member Waters.
32:24Seeing none, is there any additional information you'd like to leave with us for consideration for the elected officials compensation commission?
32:33No, I'm just it's an honor to be considered, so thank you for having me today.
32:36All right, thank you.
32:37Thank you for your um support and assistance with the city of Detroit.
32:47Without objection, I'd like to combine line items five and eight point one.
32:55There's a motion to send line items eight point eight point one and line item five to formal with a recommendation to approve.
33:03We appreciate your service and your continued commitment to serve.
33:09All right, have a great day.
33:10That now closes out our 1025 interview.
33:17I'd like to call to order our 1035 interview.
33:21The 1035 interview is for Mr.
33:26He is being considered for the Detroit Brownfield CAC.
33:42Please touch the base of the microphone so that everyone can hear you.
33:46I'm sorry, can you hear me now?
33:48Uh good morning, Councilmembers Johnson Waters and Whitfield Callaway.
33:52I appreciate your invitation to speak with you this morning.
33:56Thank you so much for joining us in person.
33:58If you would please tell us about yourself, share with us who you are, your background, and how it may lend itself to the Detroit Brownfield CAC.
34:12Uh my name is John Barth.
34:14Uh, I received my master's of urban planning degree at the University of Michigan in 2011, and ever since then I have been a resident and worker in the city of Detroit.
34:24My specialty is in community and economic development work, where I have been fortunate enough to touch each and every city council district in Detroit in a variety of ways with a variety of different organizations.
34:35Um my work has primarily been with nonprofit CDCs and other organizations of that nature, um, where I have really been able to specialize in both community outreach and engagement as well as um data analysis, often going deep into the weeds in a lot of um tax-related issues.
35:02And I am also a co-founder and partner of Built by Many, which is a consulting cooperative that works citywide with a variety of organizations on community and economic development type work.
35:18So you indicated that you've done work throughout the city.
35:21Have you had have you worked on a project that's gone before the Brownfield development authority?
35:28I have not had the pleasure yet, no.
35:31All right, just curious.
35:34Um member Waters, any questions, comments, concerns.
35:39No, I took a look at this very extensive resume as well.
35:43A lot of good stuff here.
35:48And now this is the final interview for the Detroit Brownfield CAC.
35:54Um we have I believe three others, in addition to the two individuals who currently serve on the CAC.
36:02Is there anything else you'd like to share with us as we close out the interview?
36:08Uh, you know, I'm a tireless community advocate.
36:11Um, as I said, I am a very involved resident in my own community.
36:14I've been a resident of Corktown for about 13 years now.
36:19Um, and I think through my work I've always been a tireless advocate for community.
36:24I I understand the transformational nature of these brownfield redevelopment projects.
36:28I also understand how tax increment financing works, and I understand that sometimes you have to balance these things because, on the one hand, brown fields are a significant blight and harm to the communities that they are in, but also 30 years is a very long time, and so it requires a careful balancing of all the different factors and an in-depth understanding of how tax assessments work to understand whether some of these projects are worthy of moving forward or not.
36:57And I think that through my work, both engaging deeply with community as well as getting deep into the weeds of how these projects work financially, you know, would allow me to provide some very helpful perspective on you know uh possible projects that are coming before the the CAC and the Brownfield Development Authority in general.
37:23I do have a quick question for you.
37:25Um so, in the work that you've done on development throughout the city, can you talk about your level of community engagement within any of those projects?
37:37Yeah, uh I think that the best way to describe it is um I have been able to engage with both residents and businesses.
37:47I have done you know major canvassing projects where I've speaking where I've spoken with every single business and property owner along West Verner and Springwells as long as well as along the um West McNichols six mile corridor, and in doing so, I've been able to really dig deep with these individuals who have you know really in-depth lived experience in these communities and really understand what is going on on a level that others may not.
38:17Uh similarly, I have done extensive efforts going door-to-door leading canvassing drives in different communities, admittedly not around development projects, but around other community organizing type projects simply to gain information and insights from residents to then pass on to those in leadership positions who can then act upon that information.
38:46Um I see that you um do some grant writing as well.
38:52Tell us a little bit about that.
38:53Yeah, I I've done some grant writing.
38:55I think that my real specialty is in program evaluation as it pertains to grant writing.
39:00I'm very deep into the data, so I've been part of a number of teams that have applied for um hundreds of thousands of dollars in successful grants.
39:09I think where my strength really lies is in the data.
39:12It's in understanding not just numerical data, though I'm very comfortable with that and digging into numbers, but then also coupling that with people's lived experiences.
39:23I'm a big believer in the fact that the most compelling cases are made when you're able to combine people's lived experiences with data to really illustrate the point that you're trying to make.
39:37And so uh in general, I would say that you know, I'm very familiar with the entire grant-making process.
39:47Okay, but you know, what I am really uh an expert in is kind of demonstrating the impacts.
39:55Okay, and that's really good as as well.
39:58I see that you have both blue and green.
40:07Thank you, madam chair.
40:10Any additional questions?
40:12All right, seeing none.
40:15You gave us final thoughts already.
40:17Any additional final thoughts?
40:23I think I'll just one last time kind of underscore that.
40:28I can see the revent real value of these Brownfield redevelopments.
40:31You know, I like I said, I'm a very active person, especially in Southwest Detroit, seeing the transformation of the area around the Michigan uh welcome center and Mexican town Mercado, and also seeing you know Ducharme Place on the east side and a lot of other projects, big and small, and the impact that they've made.
40:50Um, I really see the ways in which this can significantly benefit community.
40:55And then similarly, I've seen other projects that have kind of stalled out and understand that perhaps if more questions have been asked early on, then you know, maybe we wouldn't have gone down that road, and maybe the city wouldn't have dedicated resources to you know administering and and processing these things in the first place.
41:14Development is very challenging in this city.
41:19Uh all right, colleagues.
41:21Is there so this is the final uh nominee that we have for the Detroit Brownfield CAC?
41:28Uh with that being said, without objection, I'd like to combine line item six as well as line item seven through seven seven point one through seven point four, which are the resolutions for the prior interviews.
41:45Um is there a motion to send line item six as well as line items 7.1 through 7.4 to formal with a request to LPD to draft a ballot motion.
41:59The motion has been made.
42:02Hearing no objections, that action shall be taken.
42:08Barth, thank you so much for uh joining us here in person.
42:11We appreciate your uh consideration and your interest.
42:16You've got that now closes out our 1035 interview.
42:21Quick question for you, madam chair.
42:22How many vacancies are on the Brownfield CAC?
42:26Because I see four candidates here, but how many?
42:29Well, actually, five for how many um openings or vacancies?
42:37Good morning, Edward King LPD.
42:40Uh, through the chair, there are five candidates for four positions.
42:51Any additional questions?
42:53But yeah, I'm trying to clarify something here.
43:00I I thought the recommendations were made from each district or something like that.
43:10District and at large.
43:15Uh I'm not I'm not aware of that.
43:18So, Member Waters, I wonder if you are thinking of a different board or commission.
43:23This one, there are only four positions on the board.
43:30Uh well, yeah, maybe I am.
43:31I it's only one brownfield CAC, right?
43:34There's only one Brownfield CAC, but there is also a Brownfield board.
43:40Yeah, I yeah, I'm familiar with the board.
43:44Um so if I had a vacancy from the person that I so for example, uh I guess you can say two years ago, I guess it was maybe a year ago, I'm not really sure what it what it is now.
44:04I recommended a person I believe for this Brownfield CAC.
44:09And I don't know if if their term has expired, if in fact they're planning to still serve.
44:17So how does that work?
44:18Do you just go in and take the vacancies and send in names?
44:26Is that is that what you do?
44:30Uh through the chair.
44:31The um all council members are or any member of the public is welcome to present a name to fill any of these four seats.
44:43And this is uh appointment of the city council as a whole.
44:50I I don't know what I'm thinking about then, but okay, thank you.
45:00Um, I see that we have a formal resignation from Ponce D.
45:03Clay, my Moorehouse brother, and a district two resident.
45:07And I just want to publicly congratulate him on being appointed by Governor Gretchen Whitmer to serve as a judge of the 36th District Court of Detroit, and want to thank him for his service on the Detroit Brownfield Redevelopment Authority Community Advisory Committee.
45:28So if you're listening, Mr.
45:29Clay, my Moorehouse brother, congratulations on your appointment.
45:33Thank you, Madam Chair.
45:35Congratulations are in order.
45:41Um all right, colleagues.
45:44We are going to move into new business.
45:50Beginning with line item.
45:53We've already addressed line item 8.1.
45:57Line item 8.2 is contract number 6006065-83, 100% ARPA funding.
46:07Amendment number three to provide an extension of time and to amend contract terms for the right to counsel information and portal.
46:18Contractor Lakeshore Legal Aid, contract period through June 30th, 2026.
46:29Contract increase amount zero dollars.
46:32Total contract amount 252,060.
46:37Colleagues, is there a motion to discuss very briefly?
46:43All right, discussion.
47:08Through the chair Graham Anderson Law Department, I'm joined by Attorney Diamond Conley here to speak on the matter as well of the amended contract terms.
47:20Good morning, honorable council members.
47:22Diamond Conley, Executive Director of the Right to Council.
47:26Good morning, Attorney Conley.
47:28If you can just share what the amended contract terms are for this contract.
47:34So you may have heard me talk about the intake and verification system in a prior meeting.
47:39As the executive director of Right to Council, I'm always trying to think about how to make this program more efficient.
47:45And one of the ways to do that is to try to have tenants reach our attorneys a lot earlier.
47:50And so that is what this intake and in uh income verification system would do.
47:55Um the goal is to when tenants get their documents, they upload those documents into the intake system.
48:01Um they give us a little insight into what's going on with their case, but then they also may need to provide some personal uh information so we can make sure that they're eligible.
48:11So that may be their name, in some cases social security number, date of birth, benefits information, all of this information that really should be attorney client privileged um information.
48:22And so my initial thought was that the city of Detroit should own this system, but after talking with the attorneys, there was some concern that if I had access to all of this information, if my office had access, if the city of Detroit, that would break attorney client privilege in some places in some spaces in a lot of spaces, right?
48:39If we have all of that, um and we have thousands of tenants who are going to be accessing this system.
48:45I'm a three-person office.
48:47We have way more attorneys who can handle that backlog.
48:50And so the amendment at this point is that the Lakeshore Legal Aid and our attorneys will own and operate this data system and protect the tenants and their information as much as possible.
49:00What they will do is continue to take direction from the city of Detroit.
49:04And so if we roll out this intake system and there are concerns about how it's operating, they will take direction from us to repair that.
49:12Um I need data, you know, at least some amount of data to answer questions that you all have for me and to complete an ordinance report um every year.
49:20And so it they will continue to provide me with what I need, but the amendment at this point says just that they will continue to take direction from us, but they are uh best equipped to own and operate this system.
49:31All right, thank you.
49:33Colleagues, any additional questions?
49:36Is there a motion on line item 8.2?
49:40There's a motion to send line item 8.2 to formal with a recommendation to approve.
49:46Hearing no objections, that action shall be taken.
50:00Line item 8.3 is the monthly report of contracts that were approved administratively for the months of July and August.
50:11These are contracts between 25 and 50,000 dollars.
50:21Colleagues, I do have uh questions about one or two of the contracts that were administratively approved and actually reached out to the law department to get some insight on how council can actually um work with the contract that there are questions relative to and how we might be able to address it with the administration.
50:50Um I was not able to get an answer.
50:54Um with that, I think they need to do some research.
50:58Um with that, is there a motion to bring line item 8.3 back in two weeks to allow them to do the research?
51:06Um, and we will submit a memo asking for how council can address these contracts that are approved administratively.
51:15Motion there is a motion to bring line item 8.3 back in two weeks, and a memo will be sent.
51:23Hearing no objections, that action shall be taken.
51:33Line item 8.4 is a settlement request in lawsuit of Philip Leonard versus City of Detroit Police Department file number 1507 in the amount of 250,000 dollars.
51:47Colleagues just want to share that this is a workers' comp claim just for the general public.
51:54Uh is there a motion on line item 8.4.
51:58There's a motion to send line item 8.4 to formal with a recommendation to approve.
52:04Hearing no objections, that action shall be taken.
52:09Line item 8.5 is a settlement request in lawsuit of all ways on time transportation versus city of Detroit.
52:18Case number 25-144 216-GC.
52:23This is for the Department of Transportation in the amount of $4,000.
52:34There's a motion to send line item 8.5 to formal with a recommendation to approve.
52:39Hearing no objections, that action shall be taken.
52:45Line item 8.6 is a settlement request in lawsuit of Atia Hunt versus City of Detroit.
52:51Case number 24-01035-NI.
52:57This is for the fire department in the amount of $14,500.
53:03Is there a motion to approve?
53:06There's a motion to send line item 8.6 to formal with a recommendation to approve.
53:12Hearing no objections, that action shall be taken.
53:17And line item 8.7 is a settlement request in lawsuit of Cornell Jackson versus City of Detroit and Darrell Russell.
53:26Case number 24-000 256-in I.
53:33This is for the Department of Transportation in the amount of $310,000.
53:51Hearing no objections, that action shall be taken.
53:58Line item 8.8 is a settlement request in lawsuit of Jill Babcock, Marguerite Maddox, and Ashley Jacobson versus State of Michigan, County of Wayne, City of Detroit, and Detroit Wayne Joint Building Authority.
54:12Case number 22-12951 in the amount of $75,000.
54:21Is there a motion to approve?
54:25There's a motion to send line item 8.8 to formal with a recommendation to approve.
54:30Hearing no objections, that action shall be taken.
54:40Submitting report relative to City of Detroit, Office of Inspector General debarment report for Lucas Enterprises.
54:52Colleagues, is there a motion to receive and file or discuss?
54:57Motion to receive and file.
55:00There's a motion to receive and file line item 8.9.
55:04Hearing no objections.
55:06That action shall be taken.
55:12Councilmember Angela Whitfield Callaway submitting memorandum relative to request for a report and a resolution establishing a domestic violence task force.
55:23Colleagues, is there a motion to discuss?
55:27Motion to discuss, madam chair.
55:32Madam Chair, can we have one week on this item, please?
55:36Colleagues, there's a request for a one-week bring back.
55:39Motion to bring this back in one week, madam chair.
55:42There's a motion to bring line item 8.10 back in two weeks, actually.
55:50Uh this committee has been canceled for next week.
55:56There's a motion to bring line item 8.10 back in two weeks.
56:00Hearing no objections, that action shall be taken.
56:06And that now brings us to member reports.
56:10Member Vice Chair Waters.
56:15Just a reminder today is a skilled trade task force meeting, which is from 4 to 6 p.m.
56:25at the Cockpiters and Miller Rights Training Center, located at 11687 American Street.
56:34That's today from 4 to 6 p.m.
56:37Copper to Mirror Rights Training Center.
56:4111687 American Street.
56:48Thank you, Madam Chair.
56:50Just left the some unions.
56:55IBEW, the sheet metal workers, transportation, electrical, Persian High School.
57:02We were out there protesting the project going on on that campus over there on Ryan Road.
57:10They're using using non-union workers.
57:14And so I joined those union workers this morning to protest that effort.
57:20And that development is going on right now with non-union workers.
57:24And we I personally support union workers, come from a union family, and also was a member of two unions during during my career.
57:34So I absolutely support unions being on these projects in the city of Detroit.
57:40And that's not happening at Persian High School on Ryan Road.
57:44This Saturday, we will be at the Northwest Activity Center, the Detroit Women's Commission from 10 a.m.
57:55They are hosting their first resource fair and networking event for women in business.
57:59So if you are a woman in business or wanting to go into business, this is your opportunity to get resources and network.
58:06So please come out, Northwest Activity Center from 10 a.m.
58:09to 1 p.m., which is on Myers at Curtis, September the 20th.
58:14It is a free um resource fair and networking event.
58:19Also, from at the same time, 10 a.m.
58:22until this is an outdoor event at the Judge Greg Mathis Community Center at 1930 Greenfield Road with Jake Mathis, attorney, and some other speakers and myself.
58:34We will be there at the expungement clinic at that community center.
58:39You hopefully you can have the opportunity to pre-register.
58:43You can call my office at 224535, and we can give you some instructions on how to pre-register.
58:48But even if you don't pre-register, we still want you to come out if you know that you need assistance with expunging your record.
58:55All right, that is again September 20 from 10 a.m.
59:00And that is at the night um 1930 Greenfield Road, the Judge Mathis Community Center in District 2.
59:06Then also on September the 17th, there will be a business financial management luncheon and learn at 7525 West McNichols at the first merchants bank.
59:19And then we want to also invite you to people for Palmer Park is hosting their annual harvest fest at Palmer Park on Saturday, and that will be from 1 to 4 p.m.
59:32There'll be hay rides, pony rides, petting zoo, donuts, cider arts and crafts, etc.
59:37That's open to everyone in the city of Detroit.
59:41We want you to come out and enjoy all the festivities at Palmer Park this Saturday from 1 to 4 p.m.
59:47Then we will be having our um evening meeting on September the 23rd at Fellowship Chapel on West Outer Drive, and that will be at 7 p.m.
59:58September the 23rd, Tuesday.
1:00:00So we have a lot of things going on in District 2, and then also we want to thank GSD and Director Crystal Perkins for all of your hard work in getting the banners on the historic Avenue of Fashion installed yesterday.
1:00:14It was a wonderful, wonderful celebration on the Avenue of Fashion, Donuts, Coffee, Music, and our business owners and property owners came out to celebrate the installation of the long-awaited banners on all the light poles on the Avenue of Fashion, and it is absolutely beautiful.
1:00:34It's just amazing to my colleagues what banners can do to a corridor.
1:00:40It just unified it, it is vibrant, and we're really excited.
1:00:44I want to personally thank two of you and my other colleagues for making it happen and supporting that effort.
1:00:51It's a long time coming for those business owners over there.
1:00:53Some of them have been over there.
1:01:04So thank you all so much.
1:01:05That completes my members' report.
1:01:08And that's that's awesome.
1:01:10Glad to hear the banners made such a difference, but that's just a in addition to all of the amazing businesses that are there that have been there for so long.
1:01:22That's that's phenomenal within itself, and we need to have them working with our uh Motive City Match uh businesses to help them understand how they've been able to stay uh open and be successful in the city for so long.
1:01:37So kudos to you all.
1:01:40And I just want to remind everyone that the neighborhood beautification grant uh is open and available.
1:01:48It closes October 24th, 2025.
1:01:53That is for neighborhood associations, block clubs, community organizations throughout the entire city of Detroit.
1:02:00There is a special um allotment of funding that came from the FCA community benefits agreement that is for District 4 and any block club, neighborhood association, community organization within the FCA fiat Chrysler, Stellantis, whatever we call them within their footprint.
1:02:23If you are in their footprint, there is a special allotment of funding that is being provided five between five and up to 10,000 for those organizations to do neighborhood beautification work.
1:02:35So want to encourage everyone to apply for those resources.
1:02:41The Wayne Metro is facilitating the program, so just want to encourage everyone to seek that information out.
1:02:49Feel free to reach out to us if you do not have the information.
1:02:53Our office number 313-224-484-1.
1:02:58Um I will just say that I've seen some amazing work being done throughout the city of Detroit with the neighborhood beautification grant program.
1:03:07And I know it was an initiative of Council President.
1:03:11So thank you so much for fighting for our neighborhoods and working with our neighborhood associations to help improve our communities.
1:03:22It looks like my colleagues are ready to go.
1:03:24So if there's nothing further to come for us, we shall stand adjourned.
1:03:29I'm just listening to you.