0:00The Public Health and Safety Standing Committee will be called to order the clerk, please call the roll.
0:06Chair, the internal operations and the committee.
0:08Oh, internal operations standing committee.
0:11Okay, Angela Whitfield Callaway.
0:14Councilmember Scott Benson.
0:17Councilmember Renata Miller.
0:20Chair, you do not have a quorum present.
0:22All right, not having a quorum, we will go into public comments.
0:26Who do we have in person for public comments today?
0:29We have one in person.
0:32If you will please come to the microphone, and since we do not have a quorum, we can take public comments, just cannot respond.
0:39How many do we have online for public comment?
0:46We have three people with their hands raised for virtual public comment.
0:53And we'll cut off public comment at 9 05.
0:58Cunningham, you have two minutes.
1:17You can Google that and get articles written.
1:19You can get my Facebook, the Patreon, Cash App.
1:24I go to bus stops and give off hand warmers, gloves, bus tickets, ice water in the summer.
1:30The D dot services, which is the bus system, is still lackluster.
1:35Words during the weekdays after 6 p.m.
1:39Now, an example of powers that bees listening to peons, right?
1:45So I I will in my prayer time after that prayer time.
1:48I came up with we should have pizza and raffles for bus tickets.
1:53So we have 31 day pass, and it worked out three months ago.
1:57So now DR is continuing it, and that's this Thursday at 5 p.m.
2:02at the Rosa Parks Trans Center.
2:04There'll be two uh Raffledol 31 Day Regional Passes.
2:07Works on Smart and D dot and Pizza.
2:10Um, you feed them, they will come.
2:13We wanted new faces and we wanted new voices.
2:16People get tired of hearing the same person over and over again.
2:20And I just the Holy Spirit is came up with that, you know, that that thought and the powers to be listened.
2:27And so for regular PM folks like myself and you listening at home, you can make a difference.
2:34Keep fighting and keep working.
2:37Um the United Way 211.
2:40Um, I helped the young man um uh who has two children, they're living in a motel or whatever, and he tried to call 211 from his cell phone, but he doesn't have his phone on.
2:52He has the app, the app called Text Now.
2:55So they're unable to call two on one from their cell phone if they have the and those people are the most in need with their phones off.
3:04I don't know what we can do about that, but I called two on one from my cell phone and gave him the information and took him to get some food.
3:11Thank you so much, everybody.
3:13We have been joined by member Miller.
3:16We now have a quorum.
3:18Who do we have online?
3:21The first caller is Benny A.
3:24And so we will be closing public comment at 9 05 in one minute.
3:28Barner, you have two minutes.
3:31Good morning to all within the sound of my voice.
3:35Barner, president of the Soda Ellsworth Black Association.
3:39In regards to the 211 issue, if they uh have no problem with 211, you can call one eight four four eight seven five nine two one one.
3:53Again, one eight four four eight seven five nine two.
4:02This is a number you can call to get through to get the help that you need to get information.
4:08Also, you can text the code, your zip code, you would text your zip code to 898 211.
4:20Again, text your zip code to 89821 to receive information that is needed.
4:30Uh DeSoda Ellsworth Black Association is sponsoring a health fair.
4:37Um we partner with the MySEPs Mission Michigan Vision Doctors.
4:45It's going to be at the Mount Zion Missionary Baptist Church, 711 Finko Avenue, April 18th from 10 a.m.
5:00There will be a uh fire coming out in the near future.
5:04They're going to be offering uh eye screenings and eye exams.
5:12Uh DOC will be there to offer uh health services.
5:19There will be the um health community help connections in corporation offering health services.
5:28It's all free for adults and children in the Michigan.
5:33I mean the uh Metro Detroit area.
5:36So you can live in the suburbs in the city of Detroit, wherever these services will be free.
5:41Thank you for this time.
5:42I don't see the clock moving.
5:44So and thank you for the two minutes.
5:50And public comment was cut off at 905.
5:53How many do we have in the queue?
6:00And then councilwoman Callaway, the chair does have an excuse absence today.
6:17Oh, looks like we're having some technical difficulties.
7:59All right, we're back from pause and we're back online.
8:02Who's next in the queue for public comment?
8:07The next caller is number ending in zero three nine.
8:11Number ending in zero three nine.
8:12You have two minutes.
8:18We have three hands remaining.
8:26You have two minutes.
8:28Yeah, hey, Scott Danson.
8:38You're a TV there public official here in the city of Detroit.
8:43The TV man a few times.
8:46Janice been cheating an election for I believe 15 years.
8:53I can only prove since 2020.
8:56And you're a scoundrel.
8:58You hear what I said clearly?
9:02You the district three representative.
9:07Well, I live in District Three.
9:16Now, and y'all are busted.
9:19You've been perpetrating a fraud.
9:29Daniel Baxter busted.
9:34And it's time for the feds to be called in.
9:47She wants a tag of Buffalo, her mama.
9:53Now District Three Representative Scott Benson.
10:05And Mimi wants what she wants.
10:07So I got to get all y'all out the way in order to get the little lady what she wants.
10:13Ask for requested and deserves.
10:16Did you hear that clearly?
10:32Let's go to our next caller.
10:33Who we have in the queue.
10:36The next caller is William M.
10:39Davis, you have two minutes.
10:46I like to start off by saying that I think uh Brother Cunningham is not a peon, and he shouldn't call himself that.
10:52He is a hardworking young man.
10:54We need more dedicated people like that.
10:56Like we need more dedicated people like Betty Verner.
10:58We need more people to be proactive in our city to help make our city better.
11:03Because our city can and should be better than it is.
11:05It should be cleaner and we should have less pollution.
11:09We should have more green energy.
11:12Also, we should be doing something about these indemnifications and uh these lawsuits that we're paying out.
11:19As a city trying to retire, I found that the gracious that we are constantly paying out huge sums of money to people that frequently violate city rules, policies, law, and you know, ethics.
11:31Um, don't get me wrong because I was uh a union steward and uh asked me for years, then I moved up and organize the UAW uh group, which I was there first, chief steward and town.
11:42So I'm a strong union advocate, and the unions are doing what they're supposed to do.
11:47But I think the city could be a little bit more aggressive about making sure we're not paying out so much money.
11:52Also, as it relates to uh elections, um we need to make sure we have more people voting.
11:59If we have more people voting in the city of Detroit, like we used to at one time, you know, we can help determine what goes on, put this whole state, determine who's the governor, who's the the senator, you know, and who's gonna be the congressional representatives.
12:13So we need to encourage more people to vote.
12:16There are lots of you know vehicles to help do that with us, but we need to make sure more of us start voting.
12:22Y'all have a nice day.
12:26Who do we have next?
12:31The final caller is number inning in one six nine.
12:35Caller number one six nine.
12:36You have two minutes.
12:46Can you guys hear me?
12:47Yes, you have two minutes.
12:50Um, I just want to say I agree.
12:52Um, Cunningham is not a peon.
12:56Yes, I'm talking to all of you.
12:58I appreciate you praying and helping help people.
13:01When I think of Cunningham, I think of the word gumption.
13:04Gumption is defined as bold initiative, courage, resourcefulness, and common sense combined.
13:13It refers to the drive and mental acuity to take action, especially in difficult situations, often described as having guts or spunk.
13:22It implies being a self-starter who possesses both practical understanding and the audacity to succeed.
13:29Thank you so much for my time and six D dot.
13:35All right, thank you.
13:36That will end public comment.
13:38Let's go into our agenda.
13:41Is there a motion to approve minutes?
13:51See that we do have Mr.
13:54Hollow in the gallery.
13:55If you could please come to the table.
14:32Hollow, please please introduce yourself and say what services you're providing to the residents of Detroit.
14:42My name is Melvin Butch Hollowell, and I'm the managing partner of the Miller Law Firm here downtown.
14:48And uh former corporation counsel for the city of Detroit.
14:52I'm here in front of the council uh today on the matter involving um the 1300 uh Lafayette um uh litigation.
15:00I'm here in front of the council uh today on the matter involving um the 1300 uh lafayette um uh litigation uh that we represent the historic district commission on and as well as the city of Detroit.
15:08Any questions for my colleagues?
15:10All right, motion to approve and send the formal objection.
15:15This body will send line item 7.5 to form with a recommendation to approve.
15:20Hollow, thank you for coming out today.
15:24Lozano, you are coming up.
15:26You can come to the table.
15:27We're gonna handle a little bit of housekeeping.
15:29Come on forward, sir.
15:30Then we'll have your interview.
15:32Um colleague, let's go ahead and take care of some do some housekeeping.
15:36There are a couple of bringbacks that we have today.
15:38That's line item 7.1, which is a proposed ordinance to amend uh numbers chapter 18 for fire prevention.
15:47Uh there's gonna be I'm gonna request a motion to bring back in three weeks.
15:51Uh bring back on 8th April 2026.
15:58This body will bring back line item 7.1 on April 8th.
16:04That will be three weeks.
16:05In addition, like to bring back line item 8.7, which is council member Mary Waters submitting memorandum relative to requests for information on status of the mayor appointments to the tenants rights commission.
16:18This is a motion to bring back in two weeks on one April motion without objection.
16:25This body will bring back line item 8.7 in two weeks.
16:29And we have a couple receiving files.
16:31First is line item 7.3.
16:34Stats of Councilmember Denzel McCampbell submitting memorandum regarding questions relative to the 2026 executive organization plan.
16:42My understanding is those have been received and he is okay.
16:45Motion to receive and file line item 7.3.
16:50That objection, this body will receive and file line on the 7.3.
16:53Next is line item 8.6, submitting report relative to memo regarding proposed modifications to the executive organization plan.
17:03Uh LPD provided a memorandum outline the process for making proposed modifications to the mayor's executive organization plan.
17:11Motion to receive and file.
17:13That objection, this body will receive and file line item 8.6.
17:18And this will take us to our 9 15 a.m.
17:21interview for the appointment of Mr.
17:23Raymond Lozano to the Detroit Land Bank Authority.
17:27This is a mayoral appointment as per the conversation in formal session yesterday.
17:33Just want to make sure everybody is aware that this is a mayoral appointment, and we're still looking to have a city council appointment coming later.
17:41Lozano, if you could please introduce yourself and just give us a brief uh background of who you are and why you would like this position.
17:48Thank you, Council Benson.
17:50Um good morning, everyone.
17:52My name is Raymond Lozano.
17:53I'm the executive director of Mexican Town Community Development Corporation in Southwest Detroit.
17:59Um I've been a lifelong resident of Detroit, and my wife and I live in the midtown area.
18:05Um I'm retired from DT Energy, and other than my military service, uh I've been here in Detroit.
18:11Uh fortunate to have uh positions that have worked in uh in and around a lot of the communities in in Detroit.
18:19Um also fortunate to be representing um folks on both sides, uh, either um you know, the uh constitut the um the clients of DT Energy and representing you know client interests, but also you know, making sure that the corporation and and the customers um got equal benefit.
18:42Um I also have been in other nonprofit organizations and uh like I said, other than my military service, have been fortunate to be working in a number of positions in and around Detroit.
18:57Um member Miller, do you have any questions?
19:03Yes, I would like to ask.
19:04Um, what do you think you would bring to the land bait regarding our Detroit residents?
19:11Um, a lot of my positions and my personality has been one that we always try to resolve uh issues, try to make sure that both sides get equal hearing and also um you know making sure that decisions uh aren't one-sided.
19:27Um as I said, I've been um working, fortunate to be working in a number of communities in Southwest Detroit through in and around Detroit uh throughout my my career.
19:42Lozano, hold on one second.
19:43If you will please push the red circle on a bot base, there we go.
19:48Does that make a difference?
19:51Yes, so um I um yeah, I I my positions I've worked with DT Energy, I worked with the Hispanic Chamber, I worked with the Michigan Veterans Foundation.
20:00I've worked with DT Energy, I worked with the Hispanic Chamber, I worked with the Michigan Veterans Foundation.
20:05Um spent some time with the phone company actually, yeah, in and around the time that uh we had our civil disturbances in around 12th and 14th Street, and so um I think my experiences have uh taken me through uh a a lot of what Detroit's had to offer, and I've seen all sides of it.
20:25I've seen the best of Detroit, and I've seen the worst of Detroit, and my whole mission during my career has been to try to make sure that um everyone gets heard and everyone wins.
20:39Thank you, Councilmember.
20:41All right, thank you.
20:42Lozano, so I've been in the CDC arena for a number of years before I took on this position, and the land bank was something that the CDC's advocated for as a way to get more land into their hands and to a way to dispose of the city's excess and unwanted vacant land, and they did that for a number of years.
21:03We're now in the situation.
21:04We've had approximately 12 years now of a very robust land bank.
21:09Do you see the need for any changes in the land bank and what in the way it currently operates?
21:14And will if so, what will you advocate for?
21:17Well, I I've heard that uh that its mission is one to make sure that we continue to get rid of blight, and the other is to make sure that uh properties and structures uh are sold to Detroiters.
21:30So that that's a strong mandate.
21:33Uh I want to make sure that that continues.
21:35I've heard that that doesn't always the isn't always the case, and that um I'm I'm not aware of anything specific, but um mindful that that kind of thing happens that we need to make sure that it doesn't take place.
21:50Okay, and just another issue that we've seen at the city council level is not a great level of communication from the board members.
21:58We would love to hear from you.
22:00If you if you are appointed by our colleagues, uh, then we would love to be able to hear from you.
22:05And I I would not hesitate to say, hey, city council, this is what I'm seeing.
22:08I would like to suggest that you all look at this, or maybe you maybe want to know about this going on.
22:14Please reach out to us, communicate with us.
22:16We're not mean people, and we would love to hear from members of the land bank.
22:19We get a lot of conversation at this table from people who don't typically use a land bank but have a lot to say about it.
22:25It'd be great to hear from those who are actually boots on the ground, and as an old military person, I'm sure you can understand there's a lot more going on on the ground than there is in the ivory tower um far away.
22:37So, and then do you have your jump wings?
22:41I was in the 173rd Airborne Brigade, but uh I was uh uh infantry on on the ground, boots on the ground.
22:48But understood, I understand the chain of command, and you know, throughout my career, I've also been asked to represent my community and and other developments and to you know come before city council, the planning commission, and um I also chair the Brownfield authority for Wayne County.
23:06And so uh, you know, I've been in positions where we do have to communicate uh effectively through government and through the public.
23:15Um being a uh activist and a and someone who has long routes in Mexican town area that you'll continue to uh advocate for uh land to be sold and get into the hands of the Detroit residents and dispose of that land as well.
23:30We would like the land bank to work itself out of a job one day.
23:36Any additional questions?
23:38Motion to recommend approval and send to formal the appointment of Mr.
23:45That objection, this body will recommend approval and send a formal Mr.
23:50No, thank you very much, have a good day, and thank you for your sacrifice as a service member.
24:00We're gonna close out our interview.
24:03Let's go back to our agenda.
24:08Let's take up line number 7.2 status of board of ethics request to lift privilege on legislative policy division memo in separate legal counsel for the board of ethics and responding memos from executive director Crystal Phillips and the law department motion to discuss.
24:27At this time, the chair entertain a motion to deny this request.
24:33That objection, this body will recommend denial to lifting privilege to the to LPD.
24:41Does this need to go to the full body for formal deny, or can we keep this here if we deny, make a recommendation to deny?
24:46Uh attorney Phil Kelly, LPD to the chair.
24:49This has to go before the full body.
24:50Motion to send to formal with recommendation to denial.
24:55That objection, this body will send line of 7.2 to formal with a recommendation to deny.
25:00All right, status line item 7.4, status of office of contracting and procurement.
25:06Contract number 6007 81 7184 TAC Alpha 1.
25:13100% city funding to amend to increase funds and extension of time for parking spaces for city employees.
25:20This is LAZ parking out of Detroit.
25:23The contract runs through this is an amended contract and will run through January 30th, 2029 with a contract increase of 791,000 for a 1.127 total contract.
25:37This is human resources.
25:45Without objection, this body will send to formal recommendation to approve line item 7.4.
25:50And I did hear from the councilwoman uh with Phil Callaway's office that her that she did receive her answers.
25:58Line item 7.6 will be our next status of office of contracting and procurement.
26:02Contract number 3091430, 100% city funding for proof point subscription renewal for email cybersecurity, contractor security solutions services, LLC.
26:14This is out of Howard Street in Detroit, Michigan.
26:16This contract period is city upon city council approval through 30 June 2026.
26:22This is only a about a three-month contract.
26:25Total contract amount 481,000 dollars for do it.
26:33Motion discussion on that motion.
26:35Uh this just so people understand there has been a correction letter that this contract runs through 2027.
26:44Additional discussion?
26:46Motion to approve and send to formal with a rec motion to approve with recommendation to approve.
26:51That objection, this body will send line 7.6 or formal recommendation to approve.
26:56Line item 7.7 status of lawsuit of Kimberly Roblet Roblouski v City of Detroit.
27:06This is a $50,000 payment and full claims against the city of Detroit.
27:42Motion and then lineup 7.9 is that a law department settlement and lawsuit manuel Gibson v.
27:48City of Detroit, Department of Transportation in the amount of 10,000 dollars.
27:52Motion to recommend approval and send a formal line item 7.8 and 7.9.
27:58That objection, this body will recommend approval for line of 7.8 and 7.9 and send a formal.
28:04Line item 7.10 is a representation and dimnification.
28:097.11 representation and demnification.
28:12Line of 7.12 representation and demnification.
28:1714 15 are all representation and dimnification.
28:22We'll take those together.
28:24Line item 7.10 is driver Corey Mann in the lawsuit of Charles Victor Huggins the third versus city of Detroit.
28:33Line of 7.11 is representation, dimnification of firefighter EMT Lucas McCarthy Gray in lawsuit of Rico Sutton v.
28:42City of Detroit Fire Department.
28:457.12 is representation demification of Superintendent Ronald Albert in lawsuit VM Kampara v.
28:57That's demolition department.
28:59Line 7.13 is law department legal representation notification for construction inspector Cappy Williams in lawsuit with citizens united.
29:09Reciprocal exchange doing business as cure auto insurance.
29:15This is public works.
29:17714 is representation, demnification of refuse collection supervisor Mark Jackson in lawsuit, TELUS Sabol versus City of Detroit.
29:29That's public works.
29:30Then line item 715 is status of law department legal representation demnification for vehicle operator Aaron L Dama.
29:45I've said that wrong, I'm sure.
29:47Aaron L Dumatef in lawsuit, Deanna Riley et al.
29:51V City of Detroit et al.
29:53case number 25 Tag 007441 TAC uh November India.
30:00Motion to approve and send a formal line item 710 through 715.
30:11I object to line item 7.14.
30:18Got it and without any further rejections.
30:21This body will recommend approval and send a formal line item 7.10 through 7.15 noing the objection of council member Scott Benson to line item 7.14.
30:39Graham Anderson Law Department.
30:41For 7 port 14, if the item is to be recommended to not represent the individual, typically this body asks the item to be brought back for a date to be determined, so we have an opportunity to have a closed session.
30:58In addition, um item 713 is a strange set of facts, and really it would not be best to uh the I would ask for this item to be removed.
31:12The relief that's being asked in this case is not for monetary damages.
31:18Thus, an RI is really inapplicable in this matter.
31:22So it's the reason it was brought before is kind of in mistake.
31:27I would ask for this item to be removed.
31:30If potential uh monetary damages get brought against this individual, it would change the analysis.
31:37But as of now, that is not what is happening with um what Cura Auto is seeking in their lawsuit.
31:45Uh and I don't want to get too into the details beyond that.
31:48Graham, I'm gonna I'm not gonna make a request of motion to remove, I'm gonna request a motion and bring this one back.
31:54I'd like to get more information.
31:56And this is for pu future reference.
31:58I would like to have this request maybe prior to the motions being made.
32:02So we don't have to do this.
32:03Motion to reconsider the vote for line items 7.10 through 7.15.
32:10Motion to recommend approval and move to formal item 7.10, 7.11, 7.12, and 7.15.
32:25Without objection, this body will recommend approval and send a formal line of 7.15, 13, excuse me, 12, 11, and 10.
32:36Is that clear, madam clerk?
32:39Motion to bring back in one week line item 7.13.
32:45That objection, this body will bring back line item 7.13 in one week.
32:50And then motion to bring back line item 7.14 TBD at a date after we can schedule a closed hearing to discuss motion.
33:07And that will take us down to line item 8.1 and motion to remove line item 8.1 that interview has taken place or motion to receive and file.
33:21That objection this body will receive and file line item 8.1.
33:24Line item 8.2 contract.
33:28Um actually the appointment should actually move to formal.
33:31The interview took place, but this is the resolution.
33:33So the resolution should move forward.
33:35We'll need to move the resolution to formal as well.
33:36Motion to move line motion, that was a script here.
33:39Motion to move line 8.1 to formal recommendation to approve.
33:43That objection that this body will recommend the resend resolution to formal uh with a recommendation to approve line 8.1.
33:50Line 8.2 submitting resolution authorizing contract number 600 3545 TAC alpha 9, 100% city funding amendment 9 to add title funds reserve conviction cases and other related legal services.
34:05Contractor Cummings.
34:07This contract period runs through June 30, 2027, with an increased amount of 500,000.
34:18Discussion on that motion.
34:20Who can speak to this half million dollars and where we are on these uh conviction cases?
34:25Through the chair, Graham Anderson Law Department.
34:29Um, thank you, Councilmember Benson.
34:31Yes, these are in regard to our reverse conviction uh matters that are being handled by uh this particular law firm.
34:38Um, as we've talked in the past, these are very high stakes, uh slow moving uh litigious matters.
34:46We um obviously want to proceed with the most and best resources possible to be successful in these matters.
34:56It as we've talked about in the past, too, success might not always feel like success in these matters.
35:02There's a potential that we could still have very high settlements.
35:08However, uh the the potential risk of gigantic jury settlements against the city make this a very difficult waters for uh the law department in the city of Detroit as a whole to uh to navigate really and uh Bob, because of that, we we are lucky to have um uh talented outside counsel to assist us in these matters.
35:37Uh but when going through litigation, uh I can assure I was just talking to um uh a litigator, um uh a body of mine who was saying that you know these guys do fantastic work, no stone is left unturned.
35:52They are uh doing every uh piece of discovery imaginable to make sure that we have every single fact when uh moving forward and figuring out what's the best decision for the city.
36:10Any additional questions, discussion?
36:13All right, motion to send a formal recommendation to approve has been made without objections.
36:18This body will send line item eight point two to formal the recommendation to approve.
36:23Line item eight point two, submitting resolution authorizing contract number six zero zero three five four five TAC alpha nine, one hundred percent city funding.
36:31Uh, that's where we just work.
36:32Yes, eight point three.
36:34That's eight point two.
36:35Let's go to eight point three.
36:36Submit resolution authorizing settlement and lawsuit of Clark Joseph via John Williams and City of Detroit.
36:42Case number 24 Tech 01297, TAC November India, file number Lima 24 Tag 01303, SVD 8200 Department of Transportation and the amount of ninety-five thousand in full payment for any and all claims with Joseph A.
36:59Clark may have against the city of Detroit.
37:02Motion to approve and send a formal motion.
37:06That objections body will move to form the recommendation to approve line item 8.3.
37:11Line item 8.4 is we don't see often submitting resolution authorizing resciss of settlement of auto-rehab LP.
37:20Charmaine Steam v City of Detroit.
37:23Uh this file resolve that the resolution regarding auto-rehab LP approved on February uh 17, 2026, is hereby rescinded and be it further in the amount of four thousand five hundred dollars in a full payment for any and all claims which auto rehab built may have against the city of Detroit.
37:40Motion to discuss through the chair, Graham Anderson Law Department.
37:45Or we get it gotta be motion has to be closed.
37:49Thank you, Councilmember.
37:50Um in this case, I actually um was just informed by um our uh support staff that there has been uh significant typo in the resolution.
37:59We'd ask to remove this item, and we look forward to discussing it uh the rescission in more detail next week when it is uh properly addressed.
38:07Okay, so you're suggesting we remove this today, and when you will resubmit this correct to the clerk, it'll be referred back.
38:14Uh any further discussion concerns?
38:17Motion to remove line item eight point four motion.
38:25That objection, this body will remove line item 8.4.
38:29This takes us to our last item, which is line item 8.5.
38:32Submit resolution authorizing request to accept and appropriate the fiscal year 2024 election security reimbursement grant.
38:40The Michigan Bureau of Elections has awarded City of Detroit Department of Elections with a fiscal year 2024 election security reimbursement grant for a total of 257,000 dollars.
38:51The federal share of 257,000 of the approved amount, and there is no match requirement.
38:56The total allowable project cost is 256.7,000.
39:01Motion to approve and send a formal.
39:04Without objection, this body will send a formal recommendation to approve line item 8.5, and that is our last item of the day.
39:19There is no report from the chair.
39:21Without any additional business coming for this body, this meeting shall be adjourned.