OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Detroit City Council Committee of the Whole Meeting – September 10, 2026

City CouncilThursday, September 10, 2026
BodyDetroit, Michigan
SessionCity Council
DateThursday, September 10, 2026
StatusNEW · FILED
Video Record
0:00 / 2:14:06

Transcript — Verbatim
0:00

Committee on today, Thursday, September 10th, 2026.

0:05

Madam Clerk, will you please call the roll?

0:07

Good morning.

0:08

Councilmember Letitia Johnson present.

0:10

Councilmember Gabriela Santiago Romero.

0:12

Present.

0:13

Council President Pro Temper Pro Tempore Coleman A.

0:17

Young.

0:18

Thank you for putting that pro tempere on there.

0:20

Here.

0:21

Madam Chair, we have quorum.

0:23

Thank you.

0:23

Having the quorum present, we are now in session.

0:27

And good morning, colleagues.

0:28

Welcome back.

0:30

Is there a motion on the minutes?

0:35

Hearing no objections, the minutes shall be approved.

0:40

We are going to move into public comment.

0:43

This is general public comment.

0:45

If there is anyone joining us in person or virtually who'd like to make a public comment, please raise your hand.

0:53

Please raise your hand.

0:54

Public comment will be cut off at 10.05 for general public comment.

1:00

Good morning, Miss Great.

1:02

How many hands do we have raised virtually?

1:06

Good morning, madam chair.

1:08

There are currently eight hands raised for virtual public comment.

1:11

Okay, we have eight hands raised virtually and one hand in the committee of the whole.

1:16

We are going to set the clock for two minutes.

1:19

We'll get started with the individual in the committee of the whole.

1:22

If you'd like to please take a seat and just make sure you touch the base of the microphone, the light will turn green.

1:32

And once you're ready, you can begin with your general public comment.

1:38

Make sure you turn the microphone on okay.

1:49

Uh good morning, everybody.

1:50

Um I'll be quick because we're limited on time.

1:53

It's only two minutes.

1:54

So I do not label myself a Marxist.

1:56

Uh I do, however, reject the lie of being a capitalist or pro-capitalist, especially when it's other workers who don't control our own community.

2:04

Uh saying it.

2:05

Dorian Ballard is a pleasant young woman, uh member of the D5 CAC, and in conversations, she uh she said to me that that that very same thing.

2:13

I'm a capitalist, but also admitted within that conversation that she's aware that that may be something she doesn't fully understand.

2:18

And see, once you do enough reading, it seems that you encounter our history from the fact that we took our freedom to the reality of capitalism from the Maroons to Peter H.

2:26

Clark, A.

2:27

Philip Randolph, Lucy Parsons, uh Malcolm X saying you can't have capitalism without racism.

2:33

And if that's too hot, Martin Luther King welcoming the nationalization uh of industry, right?

2:39

Public control of industry, right?

2:40

That radical history is also right here from the boat boxes to Kenneth Cockle Sr.

2:46

Right.

2:46

Uh Black Panthers, uh excuse me, Harry Belafonte, Tupac, Dead Prez, Muhammad Ali.

2:51

The history of understanding is with me and you is it's with us, and it's in our history culturally as well.

2:56

Um, so my question is is it here in the room in city council today?

3:00

Um, because and I do recognize uh Mr.

3:03

Kenneth Cockle uh Jr.

3:05

I wouldn't mention your father's name without looking into what you guys have said, kind of on this issue and trying to at least get an understanding of it.

3:11

Um, but because to circle back to King, trying to reform a burning house will only get us a cre a crematorium.

3:17

Uh again, trying to reform a burning house will get us nothing but a crematorium.

3:20

So um, and to everyone, I'd rather not die and leave my kids with the unfinished business left to us by our ancestors who chose a seat at the table rather than building a new one for us by us, so we could use the old one as kindling for the fireplace, right?

3:34

Um so in a nutshell, I'm um I think I'm clearly expressing what my question is.

3:40

Um, and I'm I'm asking it in this forum for the record, for an understanding of myself and for the your constituents as well.

3:46

Uh, what your understanding specifically in this body, economic development of capitalism and developers, developers, which are more so extractive and parasitic with your understanding of that that uh that whole situation is.

3:59

Two minutes have concluded.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Public Comment███████████████████████████27%
Zoning and Land Use███████████████████19%
Economic Development██████████████14%
Procedural█████████9%
Hotel Development███████7%
Public Engagement██████6%
Public Act 225 District███3%
Community Engagement███3%
Daycare Facilities███3%
Summary of Proceedings

Detroit City Council Committee of the Whole Meeting – September 10, 2026

The Committee of the Whole meeting of the Detroit City Council convened on Thursday, September 10, 2026, at 10:00 AM. The meeting included general public comment, two public hearings on tax abatement and rezoning, discussion of a zoning text amendment, and several agenda items referred for future consideration. Key actions included sending a hotel redevelopment tax abatement to formal session without recommendation, approving a rezoning for a daycare center, and scheduling a public hearing for secondary street signs.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • General Public Comment (9:00 AM–10:05 AM): Several speakers addressed the council. One speaker criticized capitalism and questioned the council's economic development approach, expressing a desire for community control of resources. Another speaker urged the city to retain more capital in Detroit and increase support for retirees, seniors, and the disabled. A third speaker requested that the city remove limits on how often residents can apply for home repair funding, citing past returns of unspent funds. Another commenter accused council members of election fraud and demanded audits. A speaker representing the Virginia Park Community Coalition called for continued investment in the I-94 corridor, including maintenance of vacant lots and park improvements. One speaker opposed a massive zoning text amendment (item 7.1), arguing it was too large and not understandable to residents, and requested separate consideration. Another speaker raised concerns about the amendment's size and urged compliance with the city charter. A resident described being followed by Detroit police and alleged a personal vendetta; he stated he was taking legal action.
  • Public Hearing: 1020 – Hotel Tax Abatement (Fort Shelby Hotel): Two speakers in person and three virtually addressed the 1020 public hearing on the PA 255 commercial facilities exemption for the Fort Shelby Hotel. One speaker raised concerns about soil contamination testing, ADA compliance, and affordability for residents. Another questioned why the city would give millions in tax abatement while receiving only hundreds of thousands in net benefit over 12 years, and argued that income tax revenue should not be relied upon to benefit residents. A virtual commenter called for a pause on the project until details on the general contractor and local involvement were provided. Another commenter asked about the developer's experience in other cities and the role of incentives. A final speaker urged the council to hold off on the project until a local contractor was identified and local vendors were engaged.
  • Public Hearing: 1045 – Rezoning for Daycare (Mack and Alter): Three virtual speakers and two in person commented. One speaker applauded the developer for reaching out to the Community Advisory Council but expressed hesitancy about rezoning from PD to B4, which could open the site to other uses beyond the proposed daycare. Another speaker criticized the developer as wealthy and out of touch, questioning their investment in the community and urging deeper outreach. A virtual commenter argued that rezoning was not needed and accused council members of being illegitimate. Another supported the rezoning, noting the need for daycare slots, and asked about cost to families. A final speaker said the B4 zoning seemed appropriate given surrounding uses.

Discussion Items

  • 1020 Public Hearing – Commercial Facilities Exemption (Fort Shelby Hotel, 525 West Lafayette): The committee considered a 12-year PA 255 commercial redevelopment certificate for the Fort Shelby Hotel, a $41.9 million renovation to rebrand from DoubleTree to Embassy Suites. The project includes 203 guest rooms (increasing to 204), a new Starbucks retail outlet, and improved ADA access. Presenters from Detroit Economic Growth Corporation (Alton Williams) and 6 PM Hospitality (Peter Bucuma) stated that the abatement would freeze taxable value at pre-rehab levels, with a projected net fiscal benefit of $432,000 over 12 years, including $158,000 in city income taxes, $260,000 in utility user taxes, and $102,000 in miscellaneous fees, less $88,000 in service costs. The existing annual property tax is $173,268; unabated new taxes would be $1.26 million; with abatement, $205,111. The project would create 30 temporary construction jobs, 10 permanent FTE jobs, and retain 80 existing jobs. Attorney Richard Barr added that additional property taxes on land would total over $30,000 in year one, not captured in the standard model. The developer noted that the abatement is contingent on bank financing for the renovation. Councilmember Santiago Romero questioned the choice of Starbucks over a local vendor and whether the hotel is unionized (it is not; no plans to unionize). Councilmember Johnson expressed concerns about the property's history and asked that the item be sent without recommendation. The committee voted to send it to formal session without recommendation.
  • 1045 Public Hearing – Rezoning for Daycare (Mack and Alter): The committee considered a rezoning from Planned Development (PD) to B4 General Business District for the Mac-Altar Square shopping center at 1463 Mack Avenue. The applicant, Michael Curris (Mac Alter Square), proposed to accommodate a commercial daycare (Kingdom Care) in a vacant space formerly occupied by Foot Locker. The daycare would have six classrooms for infants, toddlers, and after-school care, plus a 2,000-square-foot outdoor play area. CPC staff noted that the PD was originally used for aesthetic control, and the rezoning would allow the daycare and align with city efforts to reduce PD zones. The developer stated that the shopping center has a long history of community partnership, including with Warren/Conner Development Coalition and ECN. The daycare owners, Kingdom Care (13 years operating in Detroit), stated that about 60% of their families receive state child care assistance. Councilmember Johnson asked about traffic safety; the developer described a traffic safety plan with signage and curb cuts. Council President Pro Tempore Young highlighted the daycare shortage in the city and supported the rezoning. The committee approved sending the item to formal session with a recommendation for approval.
  • Discussion of Zoning Text Amendment (Item 7.1): Director Tide of the City Planning Commission presented the sixth general text amendment to Chapter 50 of the Detroit City Code (zoning). He explained that the amendment contains many housekeeping items and updates to reconcile previous council actions, and that the zoning code itself is the subject, not a single issue. He offered to hold additional community sessions and provide a summary. Councilmember Johnson asked how the public could provide input before the public hearing; Director Tide provided the CPC phone number (313-224-625) and email (CPC@Detroitmi.gov). Pro Tempore Young requested a two-week postponement for a committee presentation and to allow time for review, noting he would be absent the following week. The committee voted to send the item to formal session for introduction and setting of a public hearing, with the understanding that a detailed presentation would be given in two weeks.
  • Other Agenda Items: Several items were deferred or referred: a request for a report on property owners with 10+ residential/commercial properties (7.3) was moved back two weeks; a request on Detroit Housing issues (7.5) was moved back two weeks; a property sale of 16 homes by reverter (7.7) was moved back two weeks; a property transfer at 1728 Moran (7.8) was removed; and a report on secondary street sign locations (8.1) was received and filed, with a public hearing scheduled for October 23, 2026. A walk-on resolution setting that public hearing was approved.

Key Outcomes

  • Minutes Approved: The minutes from the previous meeting were approved without objection.
  • Item 5 (1020 Public Hearing – Hotel Tax Abatement): Sent to formal session without recommendation.
  • Item 6 (1045 Public Hearing – Daycare Rezoning): Sent to formal session with recommendation for approval.
  • Item 7.1 (Zoning Text Amendment): Sent to formal session for introduction and setting of a public hearing; committee to receive a presentation in two weeks.
  • Item 7.2 (Good Faith in Housing): Referred back one week.
  • Item 7.3 (Report on Large Property Owners): Referred back two weeks.
  • Item 7.4 (Obsolete Property Rehabilitation District): Referred back at a date to be determined.
  • Item 7.5 (Detroit Housing Issues): Referred back two weeks.
  • Item 7.6 (Property Transfer to Land Bank): Removed.
  • Item 7.7 (Sale of 16 Homes by Reverter): Referred back two weeks.
  • Item 7.8 (Property Transfer at 1728 Moran): Removed.
  • Item 8.1 (Secondary Street Sign Report): Received and filed; public hearing set for Friday, October 23, 2026 at 10:00 AM in the Irma Henderson Auditorium.
  • Item 8.2 (Detroit at Work Report): Referred back one week.
  • Item 8.3 (Tax Incentive Background Check): Referred back three weeks.
  • Walk-on (Secondary Street Sign Hearing): Approved to set public hearing for October 23, 2026.
  • Meeting Adjourned: Without objection.

Meeting Transcript

Committee on today, Thursday, September 10th, 2026. Madam Clerk, will you please call the roll? Good morning. Councilmember Letitia Johnson present. Councilmember Gabriela Santiago Romero. Present. Council President Pro Temper Pro Tempore Coleman A. Young. Thank you for putting that pro tempere on there. Here. Madam Chair, we have quorum. Thank you. Having the quorum present, we are now in session. And good morning, colleagues. Welcome back. Is there a motion on the minutes? Hearing no objections, the minutes shall be approved. We are going to move into public comment. This is general public comment. If there is anyone joining us in person or virtually who'd like to make a public comment, please raise your hand. Please raise your hand. Public comment will be cut off at 10.05 for general public comment. Good morning, Miss Great. How many hands do we have raised virtually? Good morning, madam chair. There are currently eight hands raised for virtual public comment. Okay, we have eight hands raised virtually and one hand in the committee of the whole. We are going to set the clock for two minutes. We'll get started with the individual in the committee of the whole. If you'd like to please take a seat and just make sure you touch the base of the microphone, the light will turn green. And once you're ready, you can begin with your general public comment. Make sure you turn the microphone on okay. Uh good morning, everybody. Um I'll be quick because we're limited on time. It's only two minutes. So I do not label myself a Marxist. Uh I do, however, reject the lie of being a capitalist or pro-capitalist, especially when it's other workers who don't control our own community. Uh saying it. Dorian Ballard is a pleasant young woman, uh member of the D5 CAC, and in conversations, she uh she said to me that that that very same thing. I'm a capitalist, but also admitted within that conversation that she's aware that that may be something she doesn't fully understand. And see, once you do enough reading, it seems that you encounter our history from the fact that we took our freedom to the reality of capitalism from the Maroons to Peter H. Clark, A. Philip Randolph, Lucy Parsons, uh Malcolm X saying you can't have capitalism without racism. And if that's too hot, Martin Luther King welcoming the nationalization uh of industry, right? Public control of industry, right? That radical history is also right here from the boat boxes to Kenneth Cockle Sr. Right. Uh Black Panthers, uh excuse me, Harry Belafonte, Tupac, Dead Prez, Muhammad Ali. The history of understanding is with me and you is it's with us, and it's in our history culturally as well. Um, so my question is is it here in the room in city council today?

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com