OpenPublica

Accountability starts with access.

© 2026 · Filed for the public record

Use casesAboutAPIPrivacyTermsLinkedIn
Home/Detroit, Michigan/City Council
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Detroit Budget, Finance and Audit Committee Meeting – October 7, 2026

City Council — Wednesday, October 7, 2026
BodyDetroit, Michigan
SessionCity Council
DateWednesday, October 7, 2026
StatusFILED
Video Record
0:00 / 3:50:28

Original source
Transcript — VerbatimClick a timed line to jump · ⧉ to share it

Speaker numbers apply only to this recording.

Speaker 1

0:08

October 7th to order with a clerk, please call the roll.

Speaker 2

0:12

Councilmember Denzel Anton McCampbell.

Speaker 1

0:15

Present.

Speaker 2

0:16

Councilmember Letitia Johnson.

Speaker 1

0:18

Virtue Johnson did indicate it that she'll be a few minutes behind, but she will be here.

Unassigned speaker

0:23

Clerk

Speaker 2

0:23

was so note.

0:24

Councilmember Mary Waters.

Unassigned speaker

0:26

Mr.

Speaker 2

0:26

Chair, you have a corn present.

Speaker 1

0:28

Thank you so much.

0:29

Uh Madam Clerk.

0:30

They'll move us along to the approval of the minutes.

0:32

Members of the committee should have received a copy of the minutes.

0:36

And with that, is there a motion to approve the September 30th minutes?

0:41

It's been a motion to approve the minutes, seeing no objections, that action shall be taken.

Unassigned speaker

0:48

For

Speaker 1

0:48

the chair remarks, I will just mention that I know I mentioned this for the past few weeks, but I will have to keep us on time because we do quite have quite a long agenda today.

1:03

So just want to make that note, and I would be, it's not to interrupt folks,

Unassigned speaker

1:07

but

Speaker 1

1:07

we'll be letting you know when your time is coming to an end.

1:10

And if there's further discussion needed, we can bring it back or you can follow up via memo.

1:15

All right, with that, we will move ahead to uh public comment.

1:19

Request for public comment will close at 110 p.m.

1:23

Um please limit your remarks to two minutes.

1:26

We'll start with those in the room and then move to those participating remotely.

1:30

So we have one person in the room so far.

1:32

Um, and I believe we have a seven online.

1:35

Uh we'll start with Mr.

1:37

Carly if you could come forward.

Unassigned speaker

1:51

All

Speaker 1

1:52

right, Ms.

1:52

Crow, you have two minutes.

1:54

Good afternoon.

Speaker 3

1:58

Uh I don't know how good it is, but it's afternoon.

2:02

And Denzel McCampb, District 5 representative, you're cheated in public official, along with uh Letitia Johnson, who's not here, cheated in public official.

2:19

Dennis is busted, busted, busted, busted.

2:22

And Gina Avery Walker, you need to call her before this committee and ask her what has the money been going to that y'all been sending over to the Detroit Department of Elections.

2:36

And that Daniel Baxter, her and Daniel Baxter busted, busted, busted.

2:41

Absolutely ballot fraud is real in Detroit.

2:45

And international absentee ballot fraud.

2:49

Very first case I've ever heard of it in my life,

Unassigned speaker

2:53

is

Speaker 3

2:54

real dinner MFR.

2:56

Now you a teeth in public official.

2:58

You know how I know?

3:00

Because I don't know what I don't know.

3:03

Just like I'm gonna tell you this.

3:06

Dodo was my dude dude, and Mr.

3:09

Robert Carmack was my NYGDA, NYGGA.

3:14

And he asked me to do him a favor in regards to Michael Edward Duggan.

3:20

And I keep my word.

3:23

Stand up 100 for real, for real.

3:26

Now the president of the Detroit City Council, J.

3:31

Tate Jr.

3:32

Didn't got on my last nerve.

3:33

He called Kenisha Coleman's mother two times November of 2023.

3:38

Kenisha was murdered.

3:42

July 18th, 2020.

3:46

Shot July 16th, 2020.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Affordable Housing██████████████14%
Audit████████8%
Audit Oversight████████8%
Budget███████7%
Public Transportation███████7%
Personnel Matters███████7%
Public Safety██████6%
Public Comment█████5%
Procurement█████5%
Summary of Proceedings

Detroit Budget, Finance and Audit Committee Meeting – October 7, 2026

The Budget, Finance and Audit Committee of the Detroit City Council met on October 7, 2026, at approximately 1:00 PM. Chair Denzel McCampbell presided, with Vice Chair Letitia Johnson joining later. The meeting included public comments, a discussion on fiscal year 2027 budget implementation (focusing on transit, substance use prevention, language access, and senior food access), presentations of the financial statement audit plan and the payroll performance audit for public safety, and several new business items including a neighborhood enterprise zone application and two workforce housing pilot proposals.

Consent Calendar

  • Approval of the September 30, 2026 minutes was moved and adopted without objection.
  • Several items were received and filed on consent, including the July 2026 one-month financial report (6.2) and the budget implementation follow-up (6.6).
  • Motions to receive and file the payroll audit report (6.3 and 7.8) and the grant opportunities memo (6.8) were approved.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Mr. Carly (in person): Accused councilmembers of being “cheated in public official” and alleged ballot fraud in Detroit, specifically naming the Detroit Department of Elections and Daniel Baxter. He also criticized Council President J. Tate Jr. for contacting a murder victim’s family inappropriately.
  • William M. Davis (remote): Requested more information on the income tax collection discrepancy between July 2025 and July 2026, specifically regarding partnerships. He suggested that the city adopt a procurement policy similar to Dearborn, allowing municipal bidders to match the lowest bid. He also reminded attendees of retiree meetings.
  • Cunningham (remote): Praised Councilmember McCampbell for his community engagement during a bus ride-along, distributed bus tickets and low-income housing lists. He highlighted the National Week Without Driving and urged council to consider bus ride-alongs.
  • Betty A. Varner (remote): Promoted free hearing-assistance phones through Captail and advocated for help with the I-94 corridor and land use hearing fees.
  • Carolyn Hughes (remote): Criticized the audit reports and the pilot programs, particularly a pilot with 81%–120% AMI affordability, calling it “stealing from property tax.” She alleged a police officer driving drunk was under-bonded and claimed the council and agenda are fraudulent. She also mentioned the city owes $650 million plus interest.
  • Cindy Dara: Did not speak; no-show after two calls.

Discussion Items

  • Fiscal Year 2027 Budget Implementation – Community Services (120 Discussion)

    • Transit Infrastructure (Item 36): Director Robert Kramer of DDOT reported on bus stop amenities. Currently 5% of stops have shelters; with 100 new shelters (to be installed by 2027) that will rise to 7%. A pilot bench program of 200 benches is one-third complete (80 installed). 18% of stops have trash cans. District-specific data: after current projects, district 3 will have one more shelter-eligible stop and 22 bench-eligible stops; district 7 will have two and 27 respectively. Council discussed ADA compliance, partnerships with private property owners, and cleaning/maintenance via the Improved Detroit app.
    • Youth Substance Use Prevention (Items 2&3): Deputy Director Alicia Farr of the Health Department presented a three-part program: education (reaching nearly 2,000 youth as of July 1, 2026, goal of 5,000), youth ambassador network (goal of 10), and distribution of 1,000 lock boxes. Deputy Director Megan Maslamani of CRIO reported that revenue from the homegrown fund is not yet affected by the new excise tax. Director Fred Durhal of the Mayor’s Office noted the state’s 24% wholesale cannabis tax was underperforming by about $70 million in the first quarter, and the mayor is leading a tax reform package. Council discussed the Good Neighbor Plan options and encouraged reporting of unlicensed cannabis shops via the Improved Detroit app.
    • Language Access Services (Item 72): Deputy Director Maslamani stated that two positions are dedicated to language access: one filled (Amiya Berner), one to be filled by end of October. The job description for CRIO specialists is being updated to include language access duties. The current translation contract with Language Line expires in January 2027; a new RFP was posted on September 11, 2026, with proposals due October 19. The department receives an average of 60 service requests monthly (53 interpretation, 15 document translations).
    • Senior Food Access (Item 90): Director Brian Peck and Paul of the Department of Neighborhoods reported on the senior fresh fruit program. A pilot at 7 buildings expanded to 25 after finding weekly was too frequent; now biweekly. The Health Department also hosts a program at 100 Mack Avenue. The city is exploring grocery store trips via DDOT and integrating the program into planned opportunity hubs.
  • Audit of Financial Statements (Item 7.2): The Auditor General and Plant Moran presented the audit plan for fiscal year 2026. Risks include income tax receivables, claims and judgments, pension liability, and a new accounting standard on classification. The federal single audit is delayed due to the 2026 compliance supplement not yet published by OMB; the financial statement deadline is December 31, 2026, and the federal deadline is March 31, 2027. Council was invited to share any additional concerns.

  • Payroll Performance Audit – Public Safety (Items 6.3 & 7.8): Ray Roth of Stout presented the third interim report covering DPD and Fire. 11 observations: 47% of DPD and 46% of Fire transactions had unsupported time. Five observations specific to DPD, five to Fire, one on overtime. Three recommendations from DPD (manual timekeeping, lack of support for overtime/shift premiums, and standby time conversion) remain unresolved because DPD did not respond. Other recommendations (courtesy relief, out-of-class premium, comp time lump sums, overtime clarity, excessive overtime oversight) were accepted or noted. The administration plans to upgrade the UKG time and attendance system for sworn officers over two years. Council discussed the high amount of overtime, burnout, suspended-with-pay duration, and residency numbers (578 sworn Detroit residents, 1,976 non-residents as of a recent report). The Auditor General offered to follow up with DPD on the three unresolved items.

  • Contract Award (Item 6.1): Contract 6007256 for car washes. The administration reported progress with an east-side contractor and negotiations with others in districts 3, 4, and 5. A motion to approve the contract passed.

  • Neighborhood Enterprise Zone Application (Item 7.3): Applicant Brandon Dallas proposes a new single-story, 2,000 sq ft, three-bedroom house at 2431 West Forest Street in Core City. Estimated cost $300,000. It will be his primary residence. The planning commission recommended approval. Motion to approve passed.

  • Workforce Housing Pilots (Items 7.4 & 7.5):

    • 7.4 – 2028 Hyde Park Drive: Developer Kipling Development (represented by Cecily King) seeks a 15-year, 7% pilot for a 43-unit market-rate apartment building (all two-bedrooms). Current rents $1,500–$2,000; under pilot, rents would be $1,125–$2,000, with some decreases. Average AMI 81%–120%. Property taxes currently ~$75,000; would drop to ~$57,000 under pilot. Council expressed concerns about potential displacement of tenants above 120% AMI and the reduction in tax revenue. Motion to send to formal without recommendation passed.
    • 7.5 – 632/634 Apprentice: Developer Zane Miko seeks a 15-year, 7% pilot for an 8-unit rehab (all one-bedrooms). Current rents $1,195–$1,995; under pilot they remain the same but are restricted to 80%–120% AMI. Property taxes currently ~$48,000; under pilot ~$14,000. The developer stated the property faced a tenfold tax increase after rehab, threatening foreclosure. Council again expressed concerns. Motion to send to formal without recommendation passed.

Key Outcomes

  • Approved Motions:
    • Minutes of September 30, 2026.
    • Contract 6007256 (car washes) with recommendation.
    • NEZ application 7.3.
    • Receive and file items: 6.2, 6.6, 6.8, 6.3 and 7.8.
  • Brought Back in Two Weeks: Items 6.5, 6.7, 7.1, 7.6, 7.7.
  • Sent to Formal Without Recommendation: Items 7.4 and 7.5.
  • Follow-ups: Director Kramer to provide district-wide data on shelter/bench eligibility and a list of pending eligible stops. Deputy CFO Greer to provide a status memo on the citywide payroll audit. Director Patillo provided residency and medical leave statistics for DPD. Committee will receive updates on the UKG implementation and the auditor general’s follow-up on DPD’s three unresolved recommendations.

Note: The meeting adjourned shortly after 4:05 PM.

Meeting Transcript

October 7th to order with a clerk, please call the roll. Councilmember Denzel Anton McCampbell. Present. Councilmember Letitia Johnson. Virtue Johnson did indicate it that she'll be a few minutes behind, but she will be here. Clerk was so note. Councilmember Mary Waters. Mr. Chair, you have a corn present. Thank you so much. Uh Madam Clerk. They'll move us along to the approval of the minutes. Members of the committee should have received a copy of the minutes. And with that, is there a motion to approve the September 30th minutes? It's been a motion to approve the minutes, seeing no objections, that action shall be taken. For the chair remarks, I will just mention that I know I mentioned this for the past few weeks, but I will have to keep us on time because we do quite have quite a long agenda today. So just want to make that note, and I would be, it's not to interrupt folks, but we'll be letting you know when your time is coming to an end. And if there's further discussion needed, we can bring it back or you can follow up via memo. All right, with that, we will move ahead to uh public comment. Request for public comment will close at 110 p.m. Um please limit your remarks to two minutes. We'll start with those in the room and then move to those participating remotely. So we have one person in the room so far. Um, and I believe we have a seven online. Uh we'll start with Mr. Carly if you could come forward. All right, Ms. Crow, you have two minutes. Good afternoon. Uh I don't know how good it is, but it's afternoon. And Denzel McCampb, District 5 representative, you're cheated in public official, along with uh Letitia Johnson, who's not here, cheated in public official. Dennis is busted, busted, busted, busted. And Gina Avery Walker, you need to call her before this committee and ask her what has the money been going to that y'all been sending over to the Detroit Department of Elections. And that Daniel Baxter, her and Daniel Baxter busted, busted, busted. Absolutely ballot fraud is real in Detroit. And international absentee ballot fraud. Very first case I've ever heard of it in my life, is real dinner MFR. Now you a teeth in public official. You know how I know? Because I don't know what I don't know. Just like I'm gonna tell you this. Dodo was my dude dude, and Mr. Robert Carmack was my NYGDA, NYGGA.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com