12:14Would like to call this Court of Common Council public portion public comment portion meeting to order for today, March 9th, 2026.
12:24My name is Council President TJ Clark, and I'm joined by our majority leader, uh, Kelly Billerdew, uh, Councilman uh Madley Rosato, Councilwoman Marilyn Rossetti, our Tom La City Clerk, Eric Lusa, Councilman John Gill, Councilman Alex Thomas, uh, Councilman Josh Mitcham, and we have a special councilwoman that's joined us on the dais as well.
12:49Uh junior councilwoman.
12:51Um thank you for joining us tonight uh in person and for those who are viewing us virtually.
12:57Uh this committee committee meeting is being broadcast live by HBATV.org, Channel 96, Frontier Communications six zero three two, HPA TV Facebook, Page, HPA TV, YouTube, HBA TV, Roku TV, Apple TV, Amazon, and all apps.
13:20Public comments shall be conducted in accordance with the following procedures.
13:25Each person shall give his or her name, address, and if he or she represents a group, shall in addition state for the record the name and address of said group or organization.
13:38Each speaker shall limit his or her remarks to three minutes, and our timekeeper this evening is Councilman John Gale.
13:45All remarks shall be addressed to the council as a body and not to any member thereof.
13:53During the public comment, no member of the council may address the council as a member of the public.
14:00Any person making personal impertinent or slanderous remarks or who becomes boisterous while addressing the council shall forthwith bar be barred from further audience at said meeting unless permission to remain as granted by a two-thirds vote of the council members present in voting.
14:20During the public comment, there should be no debate by the council, although questions may be asked by council persons by council of persons making such presentations.
14:33And before I call our first uh speaker, I just want to read something uh to the general public uh this evening.
14:42Before we open tonight's public comment period, I want to take a moment to address the heavy cloud that is hanging over our city.
14:52Over the last few weeks, Harford has seen two deeply painful tragedies.
15:00The officer involved shootings of Everett Walker and Stephen Jones.
15:04Our hearts go out to their families.
15:09And we extend our condolences to all the families tonight.
15:14Our neighbors in Blue Hills and Parkville and across the city and the community who was feeling the weight of these losses.
15:21We, the council, hear your pain, and we recognize the trauma these incidents have reignited within our community.
15:31To those of you that are here to testify tonight, we are here to listen.
15:36Your voices are a vital part of how the city heals and how we can move forward.
15:43As council president, I want to be clear about where we stand and the work that we are doing behind the scenes.
15:50In the days following these incidents, I've had multiple conversations with Mayor Arvalampalam and many of my colleagues on this council.
15:59Our priority in every one of these discussions has been the same, ensuring a process that is fully transparent and holds our police officers to the highest possible standards of conduct.
16:13And to that end, we're actively exploring ways to better integrate mental health supports within our first response efforts, looking into whether our officers are equipped with the right non-lethal to de-escalate when responding.
16:28The State Office of the Inspector General is currently conducting its independent investigation into both shootings.
16:35By law, we must wait for the IG to conduct their investigation and take any disciplinary to conduct the investigation to work release their final findings before the City of Harvard can conduct its own investigation and take any disciplinary action.
16:55We ask tonight for your patience with that legal process, but please know that our patience does not mean silence.
17:03We are committed to using the findings of those reports to push for policy changes necessary to keep our residents safe, and that's every resident.
17:14We look forward to hearing your comments tonight, and please remember to always reach out to us when you are in need.
17:24With that said, uh the first person to speak tonight is Alyssa Peterson.
17:38All right, uh good evening, Alyssa Peterson, uh Grandview Terrace.
17:42Uh two months ago, one of your council members sought to have my free speech rights violated before this council.
17:48I even went to the extraordinary step of showing my pre-prepared speech to a member of the Hartford police who had very politely found the need to warn me ahead of time of my conduct before council.
17:59I had never had to do this in 35 years before coming for this body.
18:04To be clear, no council member has the right to deny a constituent of their free speech rights, especially when I use no profanity and name no specific member.
18:14All this venomous targeted action did was to cement my commitment to pursuing both criminal and civil remedies available to me.
18:24Tonight, however, I am not speaking of a polite member of Harvard Police, but I'm seriously, but a seriously compromised member who, by all accounts of public video footage, looks like he never set foot in our police academy.
18:39Of course, I speak of Officer Joseph Magnano, whose conduct against a mentally disturbed man has been ruled a homicide by the office of the medical examiner.
18:48Our police chief and our police union president wrongly got out in front of Officer Magnano's shooting by unnecessarily citing to criminal law cases or use of forced procedure.
19:00Their premature comments wrongly inflames staff and the public and only gives cause for future greater civil penalties.
19:09How will our city possibly afford millions in future lawsuit fees and settlement?
19:15As executive overseers of the city, the political response has been dismal.
19:20Where were the supervisors on this scene?
19:23We want to know the exact location of the supervising sergeant, the lieutenant, and the captain at the time.
19:30Why did Officer Pignano with 15 years of emergency response team training not have better control of the scene?
19:38Why didn't any officers see that McNado was out of control at this scene and warn him off?
19:45Or even warn they were trying to de-escalate.
19:48How many millions of dollars has this council spent on taser technology, but officers don't regularly carry them like other cities or have non-lethal combatants like beanbag guns or wood batons or a battering ram stored in their car trunks?
20:03What about possibly using a police car to pin this man down?
20:08We need action from this council.
20:10Last year, your public safety committee was canceled in seven different months.
20:16How irresponsible for Hartford's number one issue.
20:19I am calling for our new council public safety committee chair risotto to conduct its next meeting in person, not virtually.
20:28The public has a ton of questions that can be answered now.
20:32And such a council form is the lawful method of doing it.
20:36I as I've not heard of Mayor Olam Palam calling a critical town hall meeting.
20:41Thank you for listening.
20:58Good evening, Council President and Council members.
21:01Again, I I read this earlier, but um, I think it's very important that I say it again here in this council chambers.
21:09My name is Corey Betts, and I'm president of the Greater Harford Branch of the NAACP, and I'm also first vice for the state conference of the NAACP.
21:18I am here tonight because our city has recently experienced two police shootings involving men who are in the grip of mental health crisis.
21:28These incidents have shaken our community and raised serious questions about how Harford responds when families call for help during moments of distress.
21:38Families in the city should never fail that reaching out for help and a mental health emergency could lead to tragedy.
21:46And while an investigation is underway, tonight is not just about a single incident.
21:51Tonight is about a system that our community has been raising concerns about for years.
21:57Harford is one of the poorest capital cities in the United States, and I'm gonna keep repeating that.
22:02And within this city, there are 19 census tracts that meet the federal definition of concentrated poverty.
22:10That reality matters because concentrated poverty brings with it trauma, instability, and a greater need for mental health support.
22:20Our neighborhoods are carrying the weight of decades of disinvestment, and those pressures show up in the form of crisis cause that families and first responders are forced to navigate.
22:32When those moments happen, the response should not rely solely on law enforcement.
22:37Our city must build a response system that treats mental health emergencies as a health emergency.
22:43Let me repeat that as a health emergency.
22:45Harford has faced questions about policing and accountability before.
22:50Fifty years ago, here we go again, right?
22:53This city was forced into a reform through the case of Centron versus Vaughn, when residents demand constitutional policing and greater accountability.
23:02Today, our community is once again asking leadership to rise to that moment.
23:08We need a coordinated crisis response team with trained mental health professionals are part of the first response.
23:16We need stronger investments in community-based mental health services so families have somewhere to turn before situations reach a breaking point.
23:26And we need a clear protocol that recognized that every emergency requires every emergency, not every emergency requires a law enforcement response.
23:38Members of the council, this is not just about reacting to tragedy.
23:42This is about building a system that prevents the next one.
23:46The people of Hartford deserve safety.
23:48They deserve compassion and they deserve leadership that is willing to confront difficult realities and work towards meaningful solutions.
23:56The Greater Hartford NAACP stands ready to work, right?
24:01But we must act with urgency.
24:22Can you state your address for the record, please?
24:31Next speaker, Elaine Hatcher.
24:40Good evening, everyone.
24:43I don't think personally that a decision you have to wait to fire this gentleman.
24:50And I you lose that word loosely.
24:53He came in like the Wild Wild West.
24:56He unloaded his gun.
24:57He only put nine bullets in the gentleman because he probably only had nine.
25:02When he arrived on the scene, Stevie was contained.
25:08Stevie never one time lifted that cleaver in a minute manner to anyone.
25:14And here is General Order 5.06, the Thody wrote in Section C.
25:22The first thing it says is take steps to calm the situation.
25:28The situation was calm when he when he rolled up in there, like he was some renegade cowboy and shot that man for no reason.
25:38Stevie wasn't doing anything.
25:41He was just being Stevie.
25:42I've lived in that Blue Hills area for 50 plus years.
25:46And as long as he'd been walking up and down that street, he's never bothered anybody.
25:51He's never injured anybody.
25:53The council should take steps to have the mayor enforced the chief of police the fire him.
26:02That was a homicide.
26:04He would, you don't even put they would not have even put nine bullets in a dog.
26:10And this is the second individual that got killed within eight days.
26:16And both of the gentlemen had mental illnesses.
26:19What if it was your family?
26:20What if my grandkids was walking down the street when this idiot rolls up and decides to put nine bullets in the hem?
26:30He endangered our whole community.
26:33And this happened right up the street from my house.
26:37So something needs to be done.
26:39Not saying, oh, we're gonna do this or we're gonna do that.
26:44There's no reason for him to be on the on the police force.
26:49He's gotta have he must have mental illness.
26:57Can you say for the record your address?
27:0383 East Morningside Street, Hartford, Connecticut.
27:09Don't be rolling by my house.
27:15Next speaker, Zoe Chaffield.
27:20Uh hi, so my name is Zoe Chatfield.
27:23I today was actually here in my capacity as president of the board of Hartford Decides.
27:30Um I have a few of my board members here with me, and they had expected me to read something that I prepared.
27:35Uh however, um, out of respect for the deep tragedy that our community is grappling with, and the fact that there are so many people here that deserve a chance to speak.
27:44I instead just going to keep it even briefer and say that um every year, council, mayor's office, you grapple with how to distribute the budget.
27:59We only have limited funds, and how we use those funds impact every single person in this room.
28:06Um I actually unrelated to this and prior to any uh police shootings, um, had a meeting with the um Office of Violence Prevention folks to talk about ways to collaborate because I do genuinely um believe, and not just blowing smoke up anyone's butts over here, believe that part of community safety is um how we invest in our resources in our communities, um which includes the capital improvement budget, um, which is the only piece of the budget that we have a small ability to control.
28:42So this is my abbreviated and um unprepared speech, uh basically uh plea to council to continue to allocate funds from the capital improvement budget to Hartford decides and to everyone in this room.
28:59Reach out to us, you know.
29:01We can't do everything, but we do have a small way to work with community members to improve your neighborhoods.
29:17For the record, does Harper Decides have an address?
29:21We do, but I forget what it is.
29:23My address is 32 Home Street Hartford.
29:26Ours is something else also in Hartford.
29:33Next speaker is Deborah Davis.
29:47Deborah Davis, 421 Blue Hills Avenue in Hartford.
29:52And yes, I am enraged.
29:55Yes, I do stand here because I know that this shouldn't have ever happened.
30:00Specifically in our neighborhoods.
30:04This is a neighborhood where everyone sort of knows everyone.
30:08And prior to this, even the officer that we had into the community, sometimes identified with folks.
30:17And that was sort of back in the day where people knew each other.
30:22So we should make sure that number one, that our particular officers that are coming into our communities, they become familiar right away because we have like a family in the Blue Hills neighborhood.
30:36And people know each other, and that's important.
30:41Unfortunately, this was a tragedy.
30:46And mental health has been undiagnosed in our community for such a long time, over 20 years, maybe even longer.
30:54Because people are undiagnosed, not having access to the resources, not being able to understand how individuals are coming to them and talking to them about services.
31:07We need folks because of what we do, mothers united against violence.
31:11We have boots on the ground.
31:13We know exactly sometimes where this person is spacing himself, or she is in terms of mentally.
31:22But we do know that there's a lot of people that have been diagnosed with they have trauma, trauma.
31:28So our services and the mental health need to be even more reinforced.
31:35Over the entire country, we're getting emails and individual comments about how does a person unload nine bullets into a person that was barely walking, and the individual walked up to him.
31:51That was the devastation of it.
31:54And I understand everything as it relates to oh, I'm going to make sure that this person doesn't get close to me.
32:03Um, they have this um, I want to.
32:05I didn't understand that part what he did because it was within 30 seconds that he was able to get it off.
32:16But more importantly, we need the council, council president, counselor members.
32:22We need you to beef up our our uh mental health services in our community.
32:27We need you to make sure that you are in front of this.
32:32We need the mayor in addition to help and to come to the community to communicate because this would have happened 10 days ago if it were somewhere else.
32:43We do know that, but at the same time, we want to make sure that we do our part as the community, but we want to make sure that we understand the power of mental health, the power that we need to keep those cameras in our community.
32:59We need to make sure that's important as well as making sure that we have more training for our police officers, and if they're going into the community, make sure they become familiar with the community that they're in, and not just come up and roll up on people and taking them out.
33:17That is unacceptable.
33:18We have a lot of work to do, and by having every item that we do with boots on the ground, violence prevention, intervention, what we do every day.
33:30We work with so many victims, and this for us is a tragedy.
33:36But I want to thank you for just listening because I know I could talk for a long time, but I also know that this is an issue that we need to deal with, and we want to be with in the front, we want to be on the side, and we certainly want to make that we get the reinforcements in every area.
34:00Next person, Henrietta Davis.
34:09Awesome, they got the wrong name.
34:20Umrietta Beckman, 211 Cleveland Avenue, Hartford, Connecticut.
34:26Um these recent shootings is very frightening as a citizen and as a mother and grandmother in the city of Hartford.
34:37We know that our police is here to protect us, but we also have to um they they need a lot of more training, and that was evident of what had just recently happened.
34:52And um these families shouldn't have to be going through what they're going through.
35:00I know that there's probably mental illness in our uh practically all of our families, somebody in our family has a mental illness, and they have to be treated differently.
35:10You have to be really patient with them.
35:13You have to understand them, and if the the officers that were um on the scene, if they worked in that area, then they should have knowledge of the persons or the people who live in that community.
35:26Therefore, they know how to escalate it, they could wait it out.
35:31But if you don't you don't know the community, then you're liable to react the way that the officer reacted the way he reacted.
35:39But we just want to say that you know we want our communities to be safe.
35:43We want the respect from the police, and we want our community to respect the police.
35:49So it goes both ways.
35:50So I just want to say that.
35:56Reverend Henry Brown.
36:12Good evening, counsel.
36:17For 25 years, I've been walking up and down the streets of Hartford, advocating for our citizens.
36:25And what happened to Mr.
36:27Walker, and what happened to Mr.
36:35Because we are talking about two innocent men that don't have police records, but they had an issue because they were sick.
36:44Now, either one of those men are going to be home with their loved ones tonight when we break up out of here.
36:51And in each instant, the family members saw them killed right in front of them.
36:57But I haven't heard anybody from the council from the mail office.
37:02I haven't heard not one comment.
37:04Where are you when these families need you?
37:07D families, these families need leadership.
37:12Because right now, they're broken, and who to say it ain't gonna happen to somebody in here?
37:17They're gonna be broken necked.
37:20You are our leadership.
37:22We've been talking about mental health for how many years, and it's rampant in our community.
37:27Practically everybody in our community is traumatized.
37:31They seem so much violence that then when it happened to them, it's just a numb.
37:38Something better got to happen here.
37:42Jones should be with his family.
37:44Walker should be with his family.
37:46Somebody dropped the ball.
37:48But we want to point it at the police.
37:50Yeah, they're involved too.
37:53And what happened to Mr.
37:55That cop should be fired immediately.
37:57It should be no discussion about it.
38:00You don't shoot a human being nine times at point blank range.
38:10He was a human being just like everybody else in here.
38:14And he didn't deserve what he got.
38:18He didn't deserve that.
38:19And if there's any ounce of humanity in any of you, he'll be gone.
38:26Yes, sir, thank you very much.
38:41Hello, my name is Laverne Terry.
38:43I'm a part of Mothers United Against Violence.
38:46Not because I lost a son or a daughter, but because I lost many family and friends.
38:52I want to take a moment to talk about something that attacks too many families.
38:57The loss of people experiencing mental health crisis during encounters with police.
39:05When someone is struggling, when someone is in crisis, they need understanding, care, and train, mental health support, not force.
39:14Across the country, families have lost loved ones who were in their most vulnerable moment.
39:19There were sons, daughters, parents, and friends who needed help, compassion, and patience.
39:25This issue is not about attacking every police officer.
39:29Many officers serve with dedication and want to help their community.
39:33But the reality is mental health crisis requires specialized training and involvement of mental health professionals.
39:42Communities need stronger crisis response teams, better mental health resources and systems systems that prioritize care over confrontation.
39:52Because when someone reaches their breaking point and calls for help, that call should lead to healing, not tragedy.
40:00Every life matters, every person deserved dignity, and together we must work towards a future where mental health crises are met with compassion, safety, and support.
40:12For the record, what is Mothers United?
40:16Mothers United's address.
40:30I can't pronounce the first name, last name, Saiz.
40:44Hi, my message isn't that fiery.
40:47I think I'm more just tired.
40:49Um good evening, members of the city council, community leaders and neighbors.
40:54I first want to say thank you.
40:55Thank God that we have the energy and resilience to show up here time after time in the face of adversity to seek and receive justice.
41:04Uh justice from Malachi and all families and victims who lost their lives due to violent acts.
41:09Every person in our city deserves to know that when someone is in crisis, the response they receive will protect their life, their dignity, and their humanity.
41:18My name is Roy Al Saez, inaugural flow artist for the city of Hartford, and I'm here this evening in support of the community in Mauve, Mothers United Against Violence, an organization committed to keeping our community informed, aware, and engaged in the issues that affect our safety and well-being.
41:36Recently, many Hartford residents have been having difficult conversations about how situations involving mental health crises unfold when emergency services are called.
41:46These moments are often emotional, complex, and fast moving, and the outcomes can deeply affect families and entire communities.
41:53When these situations arise, our police officers are often the first people called to respond.
41:58That reality makes it even more important that our city continues to strengthen collaboration between law enforcement, mental health professionals, community organizations, and residents, so that responses in moments of crisis prioritize safety, care, and understanding.
42:15But tonight, I also want to focus on something equally important the role of the community.
42:21Real change does not happen through policy alone.
42:23It happens when communities become informed, prepared, and engaged.
42:27When we learn to recognize signs that someone may be in distress, when we check in on our neighbors and loved ones, and when we support families before situations escalate into emergencies.
45:00There are mitigating circumstances where you don't shoot the kill.
45:03This man took nine bullets, one bullet in his kneecap would have brought him down.
45:09So what I'm saying is uh if you don't address the police academy, which trains police officers to do exactly that, you're not going to make any progress.
45:20So don't just cry to city council, take your issues to the police academy, or this is never going to change.
45:29Bottom line, call up the police academy and ask them how they train their young cadets, and they will they will uh justify a shoot the kill.
45:39So now do I have some minutes left?
45:44Uh I'm I'm glad that Lynn Bestoff did a an interview with me and others about these polls that are dangerous to everybody.
45:52That this poll on Hillside Avenue remained sticking out of the ground for five to ten years.
46:00Miraculously after this interview, before it was even shown on uh uh uh channel 30, the poll was removed, and another one was removed on Hills uh on uh Linmore and Maple Avenue.
46:12This is a problem throughout Harford and throughout Connecticut.
46:15It's a bifurcated system.
46:17When a new pole is placed, the old pole has to be removed.
46:21But the you but the electric company is only obligated to change their wires to the new pole.
46:27So that's a broken system.
46:28Next, up to 40 percent of all the street signs are missing on our streets.
46:34Get them done, get them fixed.
46:36I mean, you know, we don't even know where what street we're driving down.
46:40Um 911 first responders.
46:43When the fire department was tasked with being first responders, uh they did not uh allow every time uh a fire uh personnel goes out on call, they send their truck and ladders out to service a call.
47:02Those trucks and ladders cost uh um at least a half a million dollars.
47:07West Harford from the beginning put out a small uh vehicle to go out to calls.
47:15We've been wasting tens of millions of dollars with the waste of of these uh truck and ladders, and it's time to invest, buy a fleet of small vehicles to go out on 9-11.
47:28My next door neighbor had two truck and ladders go out to her car her house, and it was a false alarm.
47:41Our next speaker is Iva Lisa Carrera.
47:56Um thank you for the console for meeting us here today.
48:02I wish the mayor was here.
48:03He um canceled that forum, you know, he had to address the public and then went to go film something promoting um soccer watch parties.
48:14So um it is my hope that he does reschedule that.
48:17But thank you for being here to see you guys.
48:20Um it's very disappointing that I have to be here, but I mean not only was a man shot down on Blue Hills Avenue, which you'll be hearing about from almost everyone else in the room, but um you have Everett Walker who um his family called for mental health, and um 11 officers bum rushed his house.
48:45Um I don't know what's going on with that, and the city and the mayor's response was so poor that the police union was emboldened to ask for more money, despite the fact that they get new take-home vehicles every year.
48:59So um I'm thinking maybe they can you know hold on to their vehicles for a year and probably invest that money in training instead.
49:07So um I will give council back their time.
49:12I'm disappointed, and it's my hope that this officer gets fired.
49:18So you're gonna pay him one way or another.
49:21You can pay him retroactively, or you can pay him now.
49:24Um sending a sign would be to fire him now and just pay him later.
49:38Can you state for the record your address or organization you're representing?
49:42Um BLM 860 is located um or where headquartered on Clark Street.
50:14My address is 990 Capital Av.
50:20Um so I just really wanted to come here to speak today because you know, my dad, he lived in Harford since he was 18 years old.
50:32Um, he worked since he was 18, so he was working in Harvard for over 35 years.
50:38Um he went to school and he got his CDL license.
50:44He also raised all his children in Harvard and encouraged us to help the community go to school and pursue our dreams.
50:53Um each of us have our own separate careers.
50:56My sister's going into nursing.
50:59I'm in social services right now, but I also have my own business in Harvard, and my brothers is getting his CDL license.
51:08Um my dad lived a very simple life.
51:12Um, he didn't believe in material things, but he always wanted us to have the best things and what we wanted.
51:19Um he's been a huge part of my life, and now he's not here anymore.
51:25Um, he's always my biggest supporter, and you know, he always encouraged us to do good and not get in any trouble.
51:35He's never gotten any trouble, he's never got arrested or had a police record.
51:41He would have been the model man for Harford, and especially since there's such a stereotype that everyone is in Harford is so bad.
51:50But my dad worked very hard to go against that, and for us to not go against that.
51:57Um, I do a lot of community events outside of Hartford, and many people ask me where I'm from, and I say proudly that I'm from Hartford, and they are very shocked because of the way that I carry myself and the way that I act.
52:14But it's not like you know, everyone in Harford is a bad person.
52:21And my dad wanted people to know this whenever they looked at us because he didn't care how he looked, but he said we are a reflection of him, and that's all that mattered.
52:32And he didn't even get a chance to retire or buy his house, which he was planning on doing at the end of this month when his lease was up.
52:42So it's like we have to rearrange our whole life without our father, and we've never had to live like that before.
52:50Um, yeah, so my auntie's gonna say something now.
52:57In the words of Bob Marley, get up, stand up, stand up for your rights.
53:02State your name and your address.
53:04My name is Sarika Walker, and Everett Walker was my brother.
53:08As my niece was saying, he was a hardworking man, and you know, just doing his hustle.
53:13He would have hurt no one, but he had to die the way he did.
53:18So my question is to the council is like, what are we gonna do to prevent this happening from any other family?
53:25I don't want another family to feel the pain that we feel.
53:29We really need to make a change and make a difference.
53:32We need to be to see a change.
53:35We want to see a change that's in the world today.
53:38We can't let it keep happening.
53:40It has to stop somehow, somehow.
53:43We can't repeat history like this.
53:45We've been fighting too long.
53:48So when is it gonna stop?
53:58It's not just us, it's justice.
54:02Thank you for your time.
54:13Our next speaker, Shamar Logan, good evening, uh, Shamar Logan, 196 Trumbull Street, Harford, Connecticut.
54:31So the public was asked tonight to be patient, as the public is always asked to be patient in moments like this.
54:38But patience is a strange thing to ask for when a man's life has already been lost.
54:43At this point, two men's lives have been lost.
54:45So patience, I feel like is a strange thing to ask for.
54:48And really, when the community is told to be patient, what we actually hear is accountability can wait.
54:54Men are a mental men are in mental distress and they need help, but instead of receiving care, they receive bullets.
55:01And as quiet as it's being kept, and we haven't said it yet, implicit bias can indeed turn a moment of crisis into a moment of perceived threat.
55:10Now the medical examiner has already ruled this cleaning a homicide, yet the officers are still employed.
55:16So what the public is being asked to accept is something that is fundamentally unacceptable.
55:22That even when the system recognizes a death as a homicide, accountability is still delayed or avoided altogether.
55:30And what makes us even more painful is that Harford had a system in place and had a model for something better.
55:36There was a program that could send social workers and crisis responders to certain calls and set up police, which gives more opportunity for care instead of escalation.
55:46But funding runs short, but funding never runs short when it comes to police escalation.
55:51So now we're standing here in the aftermath of a tragedy that might have been prevented.
55:56So the questions that are being asked of this council in the city, it's not complicated.
56:01Will the city choose real accountability?
56:03Will this city choose to fully fund mental health response response systems that actually save lives?
56:10Or will we continue accepting a system where people in crisis are met with force instead of help?
56:16And the public is watching you all.
56:18And as long as I have a voice and a platform and the stamina, I will make sure the public continues to watch you all.
56:25And we will remember what's gonna happen next.
56:28Because accountability delayed is absolutely accountability denied.
56:32And this community is not going to forget who chose to delay that accountability.
56:58We're tag teaming tonight.
57:08This afternoon at Phillips Metropolitan CME Church on Main Street in North Hartford, Ben Crump, the Attorney General of Black America, came to our city to announce that he was representing the Jones family.
57:31If y'all don't know who Ben Crump is, and I think every black person in the audience certainly does, but I'm not sure that every white person on the council does.
57:40You need to learn, and you need to learn fast.
57:44Ben Crump was the attorney who more than any has delivered settlements to families who were victimized by police misconduct, notably 45 million dollars to the family of Randy Cox in New Haven just a few years ago.
58:00So study up, council members.
58:02Ben Crump is coming to town.
58:13Bring it down just a little.
58:15The meeting was overflow.
58:18125 or more people there.
58:21I'm embarrassed for my race.
58:23Five percent, if you discount the media, were white people.
58:32The media were everywhere.
58:34I'm surprised that the council didn't show up.
58:37Not one of you came, and it was noticed.
58:40I encourage you to watch the video because you were called out multiple times by the leaders of that meeting, including Corey Betts.
58:48I'm not sure if Corey's still in the room.
58:51Including Scott Estale, the head of the statewide NAACP, including Michael Ferguson, the attorney, the principal attorney for the statewide NAACP, and other attorneys.
59:04Michael Jefferson, did I say Michael Jackson?
59:08Sorry, first Michael Jackson.
59:10Michael Jefferson, thank you, TJ.
59:13The silence was deafening.
59:15And by that I mean that the mayor, the council members, and of course the HPD were completely absent.
59:21You need to watch this.
59:23You came off as completely disconnected.
59:25I also find comments from this body promises of transparency and accountability to be disingenuous.
59:34Let's look at the history.
59:35First, transparency.
59:37This policy 5.06 that Elaine held up a moment ago, which directly addresses the question of how the police are to interact with people experiencing mental illness has been deliberately and intentionally withheld from the public for more than five years.
59:55If you go on the HPD website now, it's missing.
1:00:01Then you find 5.07.
1:00:05I'll take just 30 seconds if you'll get if you'll grant me that.
1:00:09Accountability comes down to a number of things.
1:00:17And one of the ones that's gonna come up also, and I think the NAACP is going to take an interest in this, is the favorite topic of the union contract, which, as you probably know, those of you on the public safety and quality of life committee know is coming up for renegotiation.
1:00:35There'll be more on that to follow.
1:00:38Thank you for your attention.
1:00:45Little, can you please stay for the record your address?
1:00:50I'm here representing American Justice Project.
1:00:53I live at 42 Kenmore Road in Bloomfield, Connecticut.
1:01:04Next speaker, Laquisha Jenkins.
1:01:27Hi, um, I'm Haley Kinable.
1:01:29I live at 338 Asylum Street in Hartford.
1:01:32Um, I've dealt with mental illness for most of my life, and I love people who deal with mental illness, and I've been on both sides of a crisis call.
1:01:41And there just really needs to be better options for people who are struggling than police.
1:01:46People who are mentally ill do not need police in their face.
1:01:50There used to be a crisis team, and even then when you would call the crisis team, you'd still get police.
1:01:58And that there just needs to be other options.
1:02:02People can't keep being injured and dying, and they're struggling.
1:02:08Like people are struggling, and there's no options other than calling the cops.
1:02:14I shouldn't be scared that if I call for help for someone that I love, that I'm gonna lose them.
1:02:23Like that should not be something that I have to think about when I'm already dealing with mental illness and people that I love.
1:02:30It's absolutely ridiculous.
1:02:32They're like there needs to be better options.
1:02:35That's all I have to say.
1:02:43Our next speaker, thank you very much.
1:02:45Our next speaker is Reed Hopkins.
1:02:53Hello, my name is Reed Hopkins.
1:02:55I live at 79 Orange Street in New Britain.
1:02:57I concede my time, but I stand uh I stand with the families that were murdered by the police, and what's happening is wrong, and this all needs to stop.
1:03:07And I'm not seeing action being taken here.
1:03:12So uh in New Britain, we've all been affected, and in Hartford, people are continuing to be murdered by the police.
1:03:19This is not okay, it needs to stop.
1:03:28Next speaker, Kamora Harrington.
1:03:37We're all here for the exact same thing tonight.
1:03:40Zoe, I like what you did, right?
1:03:42Um, and maybe about 18 years ago, Zoe's mom hired me when she was working with the police sergeants, when it was understood.
1:03:52We all know, right?
1:03:54We're gonna talk in euphemisms, that the human beings who you hire to police us are inferior when it comes to understanding humanity.
1:04:02And I was hired, there were eight sergeants, and those are the sergeants who are going to try to step into what being a part of a community could look like.
1:04:11Thank your mom for that, because it gave me a window.
1:04:15It gave me a window into what we've got, right?
1:04:18I have spent my entire life coming into this room after the people who you hire murder us.
1:04:26That's my lifetime, right?
1:04:27I'm looking at y'all.
1:04:29You say I can't address each of you as people.
1:04:33I've known y'all since you were born, and we have a commitment to our city and our people.
1:04:39And this week has been hell.
1:04:42And I swear a lot, but I'm not going to tonight, right?
1:04:44We're going to do some weird roll shit.
1:04:46Oops, there I go, right?
1:04:48But the God people show up and do what the God people do because that's what they're supposed to do, right?
1:04:55And the state shows up and does what the state's supposed to do because that's what they're going to do.
1:04:58And the activist is supposed to show up, right?
1:05:00Last week, your mayor wrote the most mealy mouth, let's just wait and pray statement that he sent out to all of our faith leaders who stood in their pulpits and read the words of the state when they're supposed to be representing God.
1:05:20I am not a God person.
1:05:23This is our Garden of Gethsemane week and moments.
1:05:26And those of you who understand what I'm saying, you understand what I'm saying.
1:05:32We are better than this.
1:05:35We're thinking about y'all are thinking about the law.
1:05:39They killed Menon's daddy.
1:05:40Do you know Menon?
1:05:41Did you see that, sweet baby girl?
1:05:47And your employees murdered her daddy.
1:05:53Look at our leadership.
1:05:56And look at our moral leadership.
1:05:57So this is why I'm asking y'all to step into that moral place.
1:06:00Because when the God people recite the words of the state on Sunday morning to their congregations, we have lost.
1:06:09Asylum Avenue is named Asylum Avenue.
1:06:12The Institute of Living takes such pride in their incredibly long journey here.
1:06:18They've been doing it for the longest.
1:06:23Drive down Park Street, drive down Broad Street.
1:06:27Y'all know we are nuts.
1:06:29They take over our communities, they separate us, they scatter us, they build big old parking garages for themselves.
1:06:36They have wonderful ad campaigns talking about all the wonderful stuff that they do, and we are nuts.
1:06:42Do something about them, make them stand in their truth and understand we have lost it.
1:06:46Because when the God people say what the state says to do.
1:06:59Our next speaker, Sharika Walker.
1:07:23I um would love to have some questions to you all.
1:07:28But I don't think your answers would matter.
1:07:31No disrespect to the assembly.
1:07:34My name is Rashawn Lee, and I am the executive director of Clarissa Lee Law Group.
1:07:42My wife is Clarissa Lee.
1:07:44She couldn't be here today.
1:07:46So I had to come stand in the gap.
1:07:48I was at the press conference as well.
1:07:51I'm very familiar with Ben Crump for all the matters.
1:07:54I'm a kid from East New York, Brooklyn.
1:07:57I'm one of them dudes that was running around shooting people.
1:08:01I know what it is.
1:08:04I know what it is.
1:08:06I've been incarcerated.
1:08:08I've been on both sides of the law.
1:08:10And I'm 50 years old now.
1:08:12So I'm going to tell you something.
1:08:14That young lady changed my whole purpose of being here tonight.
1:08:19Because I have five sons.
1:08:22And I have two daughters.
1:08:24And let me tell you something happened to me.
1:08:26The whole trajectory of my family changes.
1:08:30There's nothing they can do that is really, really gonna be effective to replace me.
1:08:36There's no money that Brent Ben Crump could even bring.
1:08:40Because I know he's gonna get at it, so be prepared.
1:08:42And you know, if you don't spend if you would have spent the money up front to make sure that people come to the scene that really care.
1:08:56We'll be it, we'll be in a different position.
1:08:59Now, it's important that I'm uh also clarify that I'm not pointing fingers.
1:09:05So when I say if you, I'm not meaning you per se, but I am going to say you're in a position of leadership.
1:09:13And see, at my home, I have to be accountable for what happened in my house.
1:09:20I can't point the finger nowhere else.
1:09:23And when you think of, when you think of Mr.
1:09:26Jones and think of Mr.
1:09:28Walker, you know, try to think of them as your brother, your cousin, your father, your son.
1:09:34Try to think of it that way, and you'll start looking at things a little bit different.
1:09:39Clarissa was a part of the police accountability review board.
1:09:43Somebody reminded me of that today.
1:09:45And I told my wife, I said, get off the board.
1:09:49They're wasting our time.
1:09:50We run a personal injury law firm.
1:09:52We got money to go get.
1:09:54They have a meetings about meetings.
1:09:56They never meet in decorum.
1:10:00They somebody got caught up doing this and doing that, so they couldn't be around.
1:10:03If you look at Harford, again, I'm from Brooklyn, but I live here.
1:10:09My family is here.
1:10:10My mother died in St.
1:10:11Francis from pancreatic cancer.
1:10:13I said, wherever I go, I can't say I'm not around from Harford.
1:10:17I know I'm running out of time, but I'm gonna give you this one thing.
1:10:20You have to understand that these people are hurt.
1:10:23And if you walk through the streets of Harford, I've been here 25 years.
1:10:30I've drove down Main Street, Albany Ave 25 years.
1:10:35And when I first got here, I got to Harvard.
1:10:38I said, damn, this shit is fucked up.
1:10:42And I'm from East New York.
1:10:43I can't, how can I say that?
1:10:45And then guess what?
1:10:46I rolled down Main Street and Albany Avenue again.
1:10:51And guess what I said?
1:10:52I ain't gotta say it again.
1:10:54So something gotta give.
1:10:56Because if we're I was in the same room for the 119 commission, we was complaining about you know children being lost and not being available and not going to school and not getting an education, and nothing got repaired.
1:11:09It's 119,000 youth that are not being able to connect.
1:11:14So then now I'm gonna say that if we can't get youth right, if we can't get mental health right, if if the organizations that uh the businesses are leaving Harford, we can't get that right, it's empty.
1:11:27This becomes Gotham.
1:11:29It looked like something out of Batman.
1:11:31Something has to give, and the old guards has to be removed and replaced because they don't got no great ideas, and you gotta put people in play that really care.
1:11:46If you're doing an interview, you shouldn't just look at my resume.
1:11:50You need to do an assessment of how much I care about the community that I'm in.
1:11:55People not not coming because they don't care, people not coming because they don't believe anything gonna be done.
1:12:33And Royale had spoke already, right?
1:12:40We do not have any more speakers who are signed up tonight for our republic.
1:12:52I'll let you go ahead.
1:12:53I'll let you speak.
1:12:55Go ahead and speak.
1:12:59Thank you for having me.
1:13:02Please state your name and address for the record.
1:13:05Yes, three minutes.
1:13:06Yes, my name is Howard Fair.
1:13:09Uh I'm an uh advocate, public service to the uh city of Harvard and all surrounding towns, because it's not just all about Harford, it's about all our cities and all our towns.
1:13:20Let's get it right.
1:13:21So, about uh our people.
1:13:23Um, I've been working as a coach for over 35 years with young people in Hartford.
1:13:27I've been dealing with young people all my life.
1:13:31Um I for the most part, I think Harford police department up to this point was doing a good job.
1:13:39I didn't, you know, me myself, I seen Harvard police very visual, doing a lot of social outreach to people, but in this case, I think they dropped the ball.
1:13:48I don't know who was uh behind these two officers and uh training, but I think the training they did was subpar.
1:13:56And I think they had no idea what they was getting yourself into, you know, as far as dealing with people with mental illnesses and mental substances.
1:14:05I think that we all are accountable for what's going on in our community.
1:14:09Am I right though?
1:14:10We as a people we all accountable, and we need to see something, we say something.
1:14:14I don't care if your kids or not, because right now in this society, our kids are misguided, they have no idea where they're going.
1:14:21And you know, all our people are caught out on substances, mental health, and it's not being addressed.
1:14:27We're not addressing the mental illness or the substance abuse in our in our city.
1:14:33And with that said, we we have to all take a self-preservation of ourselves.
1:14:40And ask each other, what can we do to make Harford better?
1:14:43We can't know it takes a team.
1:14:45It's we just can't leave it up to y'all.
1:14:47We can't leave it up to the police department, we can't leave it up to the teachers in the school, we can't leave it up to the prep to the parents.
1:14:53It's a collective body, collective body.
1:14:57We all have to be a collective body here to do to issue to deal with these issues right now.
1:15:02So my thing is this officers needed to be held accountable for the actions.
1:15:08Um I'm sorry it happened.
1:15:10Uh I love the Hartford Police Department, but on this matter right here, um, I'm really like taken back, and it puts a black eye on the rest of the the officers who do good jobs out here.
1:15:22There's a lot of officers that do good work out here.
1:15:24And but guess what?
1:15:25We all have to have accountability, sir.
1:15:28And everybody has to have accountability until you wake up this morning, till you go to bed at night.
1:15:32You ask yourself as a Christian person, what did I do to make my community a better place?
1:15:38What did I do to make my city a better place?
1:15:41What did I do to make the world a better place?
1:15:44We gotta all self-check ourselves, people.
1:15:46Thank you so much.
1:15:53Cynthia, I got it.
1:15:56I'm gonna call you.
1:15:57I just need him right quick.
1:15:59What's your address, please, sir?
1:16:02Uh I'm uh 450 Barbara Street, Hartford, Connecticut.
1:16:08Councilwoman and thank you.
1:16:10Councilwoman and attorney Cynthia Jennings.
1:16:18Thank you so much.
1:16:20Um, one of the things that I think is critical.
1:16:23All right, I'm sorry.
1:16:24I'm Cynthia Jennings, and I'm a civil rights attorney and an environmental attorney, and I'm also a former member of the Hartford City Council for five years.
1:16:35I live at 86 Hartland Street in Hartford.
1:16:39I'm here tonight because two Hartford families are grieving loved ones whose lives ended during mental health crises.
1:16:49This is not only a public safety issue, it is a civil rights issue.
1:16:56We have an affirmative obligation as a city to ensure that individuals with mental health disabilities are not subjected to discriminatory treatment based on their race, based on their their occupation, based on their lives and what's happening in their lives at this time.
1:17:17I would beg to differ and say that 99% of the people that live in Hartford have been faced with so much trauma that we all have mental health disabilities.
1:17:34When a police officer or any government person interacts with a member of this community, they have to remember you are interacting with taxpayers, and the taxpayers have a right to a reasonable accommodation, de-escalation, and appropriate crisis response whenever they are interacting with people that work for them.
1:18:00When that obligation is ignored, the consequences are not only tragic, they may also be life-ending and life-threatening.
1:18:10When I listen to Mr.
1:18:12Walker's daughter, and what it is that that daughter is facing now.
1:18:19You better believe that it's hard to replace a black man in this community.
1:18:27It is hard to replace a father that loves their children, who who gives up their his life to make sure that they can eat and they can sleep and live in an appropriate place.
1:19:10The question before this council is simple.
1:19:14And it's are we prepared to ensure that Harford's policies reflect modern crisis intervention practices, or will we consider and continue to accept the discriminatory and very racist treatment that people are receiving in this city.
1:19:37Had it been a white person, things might have turned out differently.
1:19:44Had it been a person that didn't have mental disabilities, things might have turned out differently.
1:19:52Other cities have implemented behavioral health crisis teams, co-responder units, and non lethal intervention protocols that reduce the likelihood of deadly consequences.
1:20:05Hartford must do the same.
1:20:08Because the measure of justice in a city is not how it responds when people are at their best, but how it protects them when they are at their most vulnerable.
1:20:22Walker's daughter at one of the events that I went to talked about why he was having mental disability.
1:20:30He watched his daughter die from cancer at an early age.
1:20:36And she said for days he couldn't get up off that floor.
1:20:40This man was going through a crisis that no one knew about but the family, immediate family and friends.
1:20:48But that's not what we've hired our police to do.
1:20:52It is their job to do use non-lethal force.
1:20:56They could have taken uh they could have they could have sprayed him with pepper spray.
1:21:01That he that man would have succumbed.
1:21:04There's so many other non-lethal ways to deal with someone who's in a mental health crisis.
1:21:13The beanbags, they have beanbags now.
1:21:16They could have called the fire department and you had them do what they used to do to us in the 60s with a fire hose and knock that man over.
1:21:28It is my sincere hope that Hartford acts proactively to ensure that this kind of a tragedy never happens again.
1:21:39And that the legal consequences never occur again.
1:21:43Because when you're dealing with people that are that are working and paying taxes in this city, who do you think is gonna pay for the legal fees that come out of this?
1:21:55And we should, because we have allowed someone to lose their father, their husband, their brother, their uncle.
1:22:03It is an injustice, and it is up to the council and the other leaders in this city to come together and make sure that the police department represents the people that it serves, that they treat people with justice and and of and and instead of um treating them as if they were working for them.
1:22:26I think it's very important that we take this into consideration.
1:22:29I think it's when when this obligation is ignored, the consequences are only not only tragic, but they are also a true liability for this city.
1:22:41Thank you very much for the opportunity to speak to the council.
1:22:51All right, justice!
1:22:54Thank you very much.
1:22:55Uh, this concludes our public comment.
1:23:15She I am going to speak.
1:23:19I'm sorry, are you about to speak?
1:23:21Yes, she was about to speak.
1:23:25I am going to speak for her.
1:23:26Miss, I we called Miss Holloway to come.
1:23:29This is Malachi James's mom.
1:23:32And you know we've been working on the resolution.
1:23:35But when we told her what had happened, she's seen what had happened.
1:23:38This is a movement, non-violence, non-violence, auto accidents, non-they're all violent, everything is violent, and people are coming together because they know that at some point this has to stop.
1:23:53And so, whatever we do, the moms and the dads and the sisters and the brothers, we ought to think about them like they're your relatives too.
1:24:01Because we're an extended family, but she came all the way from Middletown.
1:24:05I said, You have to stand because she's representing another child that we lost senselessly, and we're hoping that that resolution will pass because we need the reinforcement to let people know that you're not gonna sit, but you're gonna act.
1:24:22You're gonna act and you're gonna put some teeth in it.
1:24:24And this mom is gonna have tears for the rest of her life, for the rest of her life, because that's what grief does to you.
1:24:31As long as it doesn't take her out, that will be our only consolation to make sure that we're doing things continuously.
1:24:39She also supports cameras, she said they needed to have more visibility when that accident happened by a Tesla, which was like a truck hitting that kid.
1:24:51And if you think about it, you think about that impact, as that kid died instantly.
1:24:56We have to have heart.
1:24:58We have to have action.
1:25:00And now, with an addition to two more families, we have families across the board hurting the Walker family.
1:25:08And then we have Mr.
1:25:11We have so many families that haven't even stepped up.
1:25:14So I had to make sure that her voice was heard.
1:25:18She came all the way from Middletown to be here.
1:25:21And whatever we have to do across the state, we're going to do it.
1:25:24But this is our city.
1:25:26We need to make sure we work together to make sure we get action.
1:25:31That's really key.