OpenPublica

Accountability starts with access.

© 2026 · Filed for the public record

Use casesAboutAPIPrivacyTermsLinkedIn
Home/Heber City, Utah/City Council
OPENPUBLICA · PUBLIC MEETING RECORD
Record of Proceedings

Heber City Council Truth in Taxation Public Hearing - August 5, 2026

City Council — Wednesday, August 5, 2026
BodyHeber City, Utah
SessionCity Council
DateWednesday, August 5, 2026
StatusFILED
Video Record
Meeting Thumbnail
⇩ GET FROM SOURCE

STREAMING COPY IN PREPARATION — RECORDING AVAILABLE FROM THE ORIGINAL SOURCE

Original source
Transcript — Verbatim

Speaker numbers apply only to this recording. Names come from transcript evidence. “Possibly” marks uncertain attribution.

Speaker 1

0:02

So we

Speaker 2

0:02

can hear you.

0:03

This conference will now

Speaker 1

0:04

be recorded.

Speaker 2

0:06

I

Speaker 1

0:06

can't hear you,

Speaker 3

0:07

Aaron.

0:07

Sorry.

Speaker 1

0:08

Testing, testing, talking.

Speaker 3

0:11

Okay.

0:12

Everyone, everyone, please.

0:14

We're going to get started.

0:16

Everyone.

0:17

Everyone, please.

0:19

Everyone, we're going to get started, please.

0:22

We're working now.

0:24

Thank you.

0:25

Aaron, can you come off mute so we can make sure that we can hear

Unassigned speaker

0:28

you?

Speaker 1

0:29

Yep.

0:29

Trying again.

Speaker 3

0:32

Did you guys hear that?

0:33

I can barely

Speaker 1

0:34

hear Aaron.

0:36

Testing, testing.

Speaker 3

0:38

There is some kind of static going on, please.

0:44

Oh, thank you.

0:45

It's the vacuum cleaner.

0:46

Sorry, everyone.

0:47

All right.

0:48

Today is August 5th, 2026, and this is a meeting of the Hebrew City Council.

0:53

This is a special meeting.

0:55

It's called The Truth in Taxation.

0:57

And I want to welcome all of you that have come.

0:59

We we really appreciate your time.

1:02

We're here to listen to you.

1:18

I'm trying to see

Unassigned speaker

1:19

if

Speaker 3

1:19

anyone else has joined us online as far as the council.

1:22

All right, we're going to start off today with a pledge.

1:25

Would all of you please rise?

Speaker 4

1:33

I

Unassigned speaker

1:34

am interested in the United States of America.

Speaker 3

1:48

Thank you very much.

1:50

Everyone, this is uh what's going to happen tonight.

1:54

We're first going to have our finance manager, Sarah Nagel, give a statement about the proposed property tax increase, and she will present uh materials that she's gathered to explain the property tax impact schedule and more about the property proposed property tax increase.

2:15

Once she's done, the council can ask any questions that they want and have some discussion, but then we're going to turn it over to you, where the public hearing will be held to provide feedback to us on the city's consideration to levy the increased property tax rate, or that exceeds the current certified tax rate.

2:36

I want all of you to know that the city council is not voting on this tonight.

2:40

The vote will be on August 18th at the regular next regular city council meeting to adopt the final budget with the final property tax rate.

2:51

So lots of discussion, lots of questions that we want to hear.

2:55

Uh, and we want to have answered tonight, but no vote.

Unassigned speaker

2:58

All

Speaker 3

2:58

right, so Sarah, we're going to turn this over to you and thank you for your work and presentation.

Unassigned speaker

3:05

Uh

Speaker 5

3:05

thank you, council.

3:06

This is Sarah Nagel Finance Director.

3:09

Uh we are going to first fulfill our compliance with once again.

3:15

We're going to read this statement.

3:16

We have read this at every meeting that we have discussed the budget, and we'll do it at least tonight, and maybe again at the next city council meeting when we adopt the budget.

Speaker 3

3:30

We turn up her mic.

Discussion Breakdown — Share of Meeting
Fiscal Sustainability█████████████████████████████████████████████75%
Public Engagement█████9%
Procedural█████8%
Economic Development███5%
Public Safety█1%
Community Engagement█1%
Affordable Housing█1%
Summary of Proceedings

Heber City Council Truth in Taxation Public Hearing - August 5, 2026

The Heber City Council held a special Truth in Taxation public hearing on August 5, 2026, at 7:02 p.m. to discuss a proposed property tax increase of $174,000 (a 4.8% increase over the certified tax rate) to maintain current service levels due to inflation. No vote was taken; the council will vote on the tax increase and final budget adoption at the regular meeting on August 18, 2026.

Public Comments & Testimony

  • Stacy Haines (resident): Expressed frustration with a 72% property tax valuation increase this year and a 14% increase two years ago. She asked the council to encourage county transparency in valuation assessments.
  • Gary Fredericks (resident): Questioned the county's spending and noted that growth in new developments provides additional revenue (approximately $190,000 in property tax from growth). He suggested that state and county take too large a share of local property taxes.
  • Linda Middleton (resident): Cited the principle that taxing something reduces it. She expressed concern that developers can add units and HOA fees without public hearings, while existing residents bear infrastructure costs. She asked about the commercial vs. residential tax burden.
  • Patti Sprunt (speaking for Wasatch County Republican Party Leadership): Opposed the increase, stating that Heber City taxpayers have the highest tax burden in the county and that this year Heber is the only city in the county raising taxes. She urged council to direct staff to find spending cuts and criticized the planned council trip to Sacramento.
  • Rick Anderton (contractor): Noted his income had declined due to inflation and suggested cutting salaries of higher-budgeted staff to subsidize the budget.
  • Kevin Payne (Midway City Council member, speaking as a citizen): Argued that the $174,000 shortfall is caused by $330,000 in tax increment diverted to the Community Reinvestment Area (CRA), not inflation. He claimed the CRA is capturing all valuation increases without improvements, and urged the council to return the diverted funds, lower the property tax rate, and terminate the CRA.
  • Keaton Hansen (resident, nurse with five children): Expressed that he is already struggling financially and cannot afford any additional taxes. He asked the city to focus on basics rather than luxury projects.
  • Kelly Mayoh (former VIPS officer): Questioned the level of police service, citing an incident with an officer who misapplied a tint law. He opposed the tax increase.
  • Scott Phillips (resident): Expressed support for the tax increase, praising the finance director's presentation and calling the budget needs-based and not frivolous.
  • Jami Hewlett (resident): Raised multiple questions including how bonds will be repaid, why residents are expected to cut budgets while the city does not, why the city needs more engineers and planners for developers, and whether cows cost the city money. She opposed the increase and proposed using CAMS volunteers to reduce costs.
  • Jenna Strom (resident): Agreed with previous speakers that she is stretched thin and cannot afford more expenditures. She criticized government employee pay increases when many in the community are not receiving raises.
  • John Heine (resident): Cited $12.5 million in delinquent property taxes in the county, estimating $480,000 owed to Heber City from developers. He opposed the increase, urging the city to collect unpaid taxes.
  • Chris Provost (lifelong resident): Stated that costs have doubled since 2020 and proposed that the city live within its means.
  • Catherine Moore (resident): Reported that her property taxes doubled this year due to a 61% valuation increase. She questioned whether taxpayer money is funding council trips to Sacramento.
  • Tracy Taylor (Heber City citizen and Wasatch Taxpayers Association): Opposed the increase, stating that comparing the increase to a pizza or coffee is disrespectful. She criticized the cemetery building as over the top and opposed subsidizing developers. She noted that growth does not pay for itself and that small decisions throughout the year could have covered the $174,000 deficit.

Discussion Items

  • Finance Director Presentation (Sara Nagel): Nagel presented the required Truth in Taxation 101, explaining that property taxes are a stable but small portion (23%) of general fund revenue. She detailed that the proposed increase of $174,000 (a 4.8% increase) would cost the average homeowner $16.83 annually on an $850,000 home. She showed that the city's certified tax rate would drop without an increase, and that the increase is needed to maintain services due to inflation. She also addressed the CRA, noting that Central Utah Water Conservancy District's truth in taxation was independent of Heber's CRA.
  • Council Discussion: Council members asked about the amount of new growth revenue (estimated at 5-6% of property tax revenue) and whether cutting the increase would reduce services. Mayor Franco stated she is against the property tax increase, suggesting deferring vehicle purchases to cover the deficit. Council Member Barney emphasized that administrative costs are allocated across multiple funds. Council Member Johnston noted the last truth in taxation was two years ago (9.4% increase) and that over 30 years there have been only five increases.
  • City Manager Matt Brower: Clarified that the CRA is a policy decision to reinvest in downtown and that the first CRA payment was received this fall. He also corrected misinformation about the Central Utah Water Conservancy District's tax increase.
  • Council Member Cheatwood: Stated he intends to pay his own way for the Sacramento trip to avoid using taxpayer money.
  • Council Member Ostergaard and others: Expressed empathy for residents' struggles and noted that valuation increases by the county are a major factor in rising tax bills, not just the city's proposed increase.

Key Outcomes

  • No vote was taken on the proposed property tax increase or the final budget. The council will hold two votes at the next regular meeting on Tuesday, August 18, 2026: one on the property tax increase and one on final budget adoption.
  • The public hearing was closed at 9:17 p.m., and the meeting adjourned at 9:27 p.m. by unanimous motion (5-0).
  • Council members pledged to research questions raised by the public and provide answers at the August 18 meeting or in written form.
  • Mayor Franco reiterated her opposition to the increase, while other council members indicated they are still considering the issue.

Meeting Transcript

So we can hear you. This conference will now be recorded. I can't hear you, Aaron. Sorry. Testing, testing, talking. Okay. Everyone, everyone, please. We're going to get started. Everyone. Everyone, please. Everyone, we're going to get started, please. We're working now. Thank you. Aaron, can you come off mute so we can make sure that we can hear you? Yep. Trying again. Did you guys hear that? I can barely hear Aaron. Testing, testing. There is some kind of static going on, please. Oh, thank you. It's the vacuum cleaner. Sorry, everyone. All right. Today is August 5th, 2026, and this is a meeting of the Hebrew City Council. This is a special meeting. It's called The Truth in Taxation. And I want to welcome all of you that have come. We we really appreciate your time. We're here to listen to you. I'm trying to see if anyone else has joined us online as far as the council. All right, we're going to start off today with a pledge. Would all of you please rise? I am interested in the United States of America. Thank you very much. Everyone, this is uh what's going to happen tonight. We're first going to have our finance manager, Sarah Nagel, give a statement about the proposed property tax increase, and she will present uh materials that she's gathered to explain the property tax impact schedule and more about the property proposed property tax increase. Once she's done, the council can ask any questions that they want and have some discussion, but then we're going to turn it over to you, where the public hearing will be held to provide feedback to us on the city's consideration to levy the increased property tax rate, or that exceeds the current certified tax rate. I want all of you to know that the city council is not voting on this tonight. The vote will be on August 18th at the regular next regular city council meeting to adopt the final budget with the final property tax rate. So lots of discussion, lots of questions that we want to hear.

SUMMARIZED BY OPENPUBLICA AI
TRANSCRIPT VIA PUBLIC VIDEO
openpublica.com