4:05Welcome to the Board of County Commissioners Comprehensive Plan Amendment Public Hearing.
4:09The Board of County Commissioners will consider the adoption of text and map amendments to the Hillsburg County Comprehensive Plan.
4:16Following the comprehensive plan amendment public hearing, the board will hold a hearing for consideration of the adoption of a proposed amendment to the land development code.
4:28It says, please be advised that I am unable to attend today's public hearing due to a scheduling conflict.
5:00Do I have a motion to continue?
5:03I think it just happened.
5:05It says we have to have a motion.
5:07Does require um motion in order to motion notice I have a motion by Commissioner Cohen and a second by Commissioner Bowles.
5:15Uh please record your vote.
5:24Commissioner Cameron Cepeda.
5:33Motion carried six to zero.
5:35I will now request that the planning commission staff introduce the first item on this evening's agenda.
5:41Uh good evening for the record.
5:42This is Gillian Massey with Planning Commission staff.
5:45Um first on the agenda would be the consideration of the adoption of large-scale uh comprehensive map amendments.
5:53Um item B1 is HCCPA 25-16 and will be presented by Diego Guerra.
6:04Can you turn on your microphone, please?
6:09No, yeah, there we go.
6:11Good evening, ladies and gentlemen.
6:12The Regina Planning Commission staff.
6:14Again, this item is CPA 2516.
6:16Uh updates to the surface water resource protection areas and wellhead um wellhead resource protection areas uh update.
6:25Uh again, this item was transmitted uh by you to the state for further review back at October's hearing.
6:31Uh to recap, this is a publicly initiated amendment specific to two maps within the future land use map series.
6:37The request was to update the surface water resource protection map with the latest data uh and remove zone one and redefined zone two on the well head resource protection areas map.
6:48Ums or wellheads be connected to the public to the public portable water system uh in the future.
6:56Those maps would be updated accordingly.
6:59Uh that concludes my presentation.
7:01Myself and county staff are available for any questions you may have.
7:08This is a public hearing.
7:10Anyone wishing to speak to CPA 2516, please come forward.
7:20What's the pleasure of the board?
7:24I have a motion by Commissioner Cohen, a second by Commissioner Wolstow.
7:27Please record your votes.
7:34Motion carried six to zero.
7:38Uh next up is item B2, which is HC CPA 25-17, presented by Miss Katrina Corcoran.
7:47Good evening, Katrina Corcoran Planning Commission staff.
7:50I'm here tonight to present uh the text amendment to the quarter preservation plan map and text of the mobility section.
7:56As a reminder, this is a privately initiated text amendment that would be adding a quarter, Fort Hamer Road, to the adopted quarter preservation plan map.
8:03There is also a staff recommended policy addition to the mobility section.
8:08This slide shows the uh mobility sections map series, including map one, which is the adopted quarter preservation plan map.
8:15Uh this map is utilized to protect future right-of-way from encroachment, provide connectivity, and ensure transportation quarters are adequate to serve plan growth and development patterns as defined in the future land use section.
8:27This slide shows the proposed change with the uh Fort Hamer Road proposed alignment.
8:31Uh this is in southern Hillsborough County.
8:34It's outside of the coastal high hazard area and the urban service area.
8:40This slide shows that the proposed roadway alignment is within the Little Manatee South Community Plan and the urban expansion area or UEA study boundaries.
8:49The applicant provided noted and provided um documentation of significant uh uh entitlements in Manatee County um abutting the potential roadway.
9:02This slide shows the map with the addition of the proposed Fort Hamner Road.
9:08This shows this slightly more zoomed in.
9:10Uh note that the roadway is orange, indicating that it is a maximum of six lanes.
9:16We did receive comments, um agency comments from the following uh agencies that are listed on this slide.
9:21We also received comments from state agencies post-transmittal.
9:29I will note that the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission conducted a GIS analysis of the roadway for wildlife and noted that it is uh has habitat for several federal and state listed species, and they recommended wildlife surveys and use of wildlife crossings.
9:45All of that would come after in engineering and design after the comprehensive plan amendment process.
9:53The uh interchange that is proposed in this roadway, which is not a part of this amendment, is noted in the TPO's long-range transportation plan.
10:02There are wetlands near the proposed alignment, which is uh noted in your staff report.
10:07However, um, this is not a uh concern in terms of moving this forward with the uh quarter preservation plan map.
10:15There's also significant wildlife habitat near the proposed alignment, and again, the environmental protection commission noted uh wildlife crossings in the area for the potential roadway.
10:25Uh Planning Commission staff did find the amendment consistent with the objectives and policies of the comprehensive plan listed here.
10:34There are a few other related policies noted throughout, um, including the environmental and sustainability intergovernmental coordination section in terms of coordination with the EPC and the mobility section speaking to future land use in looking at projecting future roadways.
10:55With that, there is a proposed policy addition to the mobility section that reads enable infrastructure planning to occur concurrently with or in advance of the adoption urban expansion areas as outlined in the future land use section.
11:08Preliminary planning efforts may include but are not limited to updates to the quarter preservation plan map and/or the LRTP.
11:14Again, this was staff recommended, um, but the applicant agreed with adding it to their amendment.
11:21With that, the planning commission found HCCPA 25-17 consistent with the goals, objectives, and policies of the unincorporated Hillsborough County Comprehensive Plan with the addition of the proposed mobility section policy 4.2.6.
11:34Uh, this item is up for your consideration for adoption.
11:36I'm happy to answer any questions that you may have.
11:43Is the applicant here?
11:54I'm very sorry for that slow reaction, Madam Chair.
11:58You have 15 minutes.
11:59I want to take 30 seconds.
12:02Um Madam Chairman, members of the commission, my name is Pat Neal.
12:05Uh, we've built about 27,000 homes, mostly in Manatee and Sarasota County.
12:11As you know, Northern Manatee County is a uh the center of the universe for those of us who live in Southwest Florida.
12:19The property to the north is a completely uh pristine space that we're gonna make a beautiful community out in due course.
12:28We have a major road, uh six, two, four and six-lane road called Ford Hamer Extension, which goes across the Manatee River and stops, as you can see on the green graphic right at the Hillsborough County line.
12:40The very short version is that should go somewhere.
12:43If we can give an uh if we can get it across to Ruskin, that would be an important thing for the people of Hillsborough County.
12:50And in due course, we'd like to be able to plan a community around these two green and uh yellow lines.
12:57So we've had a very good experience with your staff.
13:00We like working with Hillsborough County.
13:02I can say as briefly as I can say, Madam Chair, we hope you'll go forward with this amendment.
13:12Is there anyone else with the applicant?
13:15If not, this is a public hearing.
13:17Anyone wishing to speak to CPA 2517, please come forward.
13:26Good evening, Commissioners.
13:27My name is Greg Horwidell.
13:28I'm Deputy County Administrator for Hillsboro County for the record.
13:32And I did want to note while this is a privately initiated amendment, there are some things that do belong in tandem.
13:41And part of the reason that I'm up here is to uh let you know that we're going to have a publicly initiated county-initiated amendment to add Fort Hammer I-75 interchange uh to the comprehensive plan.
13:55That is going to be part of this coming cycle, and you'll hear more about that when it's time to make that presentation.
14:01I believe that that provides a very thoughtful opportunity for planning.
14:06We think at the staff level, it gives us an opportunity to get uh ahead of some of the development pressure that may occur with roads and other infrastructure.
14:16We think the applicant has made a very thoughtful and wise decision to collaborate early on with the county, and we're happy to support this.
14:25I should also remind you that uh as you may recall back in July, you authorized us to submit a letter to the state for the uh land reserve stewardship district that is House Bill 4061 filed by Representative Michael Owen.
14:42So we're continuing to work on that with the applicant.
14:46We think that is another extraordinarily proactive step for us to have and to take to make sure that these types of developments integrate well with the county.
15:00Anyone else Commissioner Wistel, you're recognized.
15:05I just wanted to point out that over the past three years, I've berated all of you with all of my grout gripes about the many decades of backlogs of unimproved roads that we have mismanaged here in Hillsborough County, including things like Lithia Pinecrest, all things that were supposed to be done two decades ago when they were initially advertised.
15:27And I think this might be the only road that's been planned for ahead of time since I've been here.
15:32And I don't know if further to be happy or sad about that reality, but um, not only do I think that it's a good thing, I think it should be the model as we go forward.
15:41So I will move for approval.
15:45I have a motion by Commissioner Whistle and the second by Commissioner Cohen.
15:50Seeing no one else in the queue, please record your vote.
15:58Motion carries six to zero.
16:04Next on the agenda is section C, which is the consideration of adoption of small scale future land use amendments.
16:11Um item C one is HCCPA 25 19, which will be presented by Lillian Linahan.
16:19Good evening, Commissioners.
16:20Lillian Lennihan, Planning Commission staff here to present HCCPA 2519 located at 4950 Saffold Road.
16:28This is a privately initiated map amendment that is small in scale and approximately 10.01 acres.
16:34The applicant is requesting to expand the urban service area, and this amendment is associated with HCCPA 2520, which is a request to change the future land use category from agricultural rule one to five to residential four.
16:48This is the general location map.
16:50As I mentioned in the previous slide, this applic application is associated with HCCPA 2520.
16:55It is located within the rural area, and it is also within the limits of the South Shore Area Wide Systems Plan and the Wai Mama Village Community Plan.
17:03It is located north of Saffold Road and west of County Road 579.
17:09Here is an aerial of the site.
17:10The site is outlined in pink, and the blue line indicates the existing urban service area boundary.
17:16This is looking north of the subject site from Saffold Road.
17:20This is looking north from Saffold Road to the single family use that is currently on the subject site.
17:26This is looking west of the subject site from Saffold Road.
17:30And this is facing east of the subject site from Saffold Road.
17:33And lastly, this is look on the subject site looking north.
17:39This at a minimum, this amendment would bring approximately 10.0 acres into the urban service area, which requires at a minimum connection to public water and sewer.
17:49The proposed amendment received no formal objections.
17:51However, it did receive a few comments from the following agencies, which are important to note.
17:55The public utilities administration uh stated that this system currently has sufficient potable water capacity to accommodate the proposed land use change.
18:03However, public potable water service does not exist within a quarter mile from the subject property.
18:08Additionally, the system also has sufficient wastewater capacity to accommodate the proposed land use change, but public water wastewater service does not exist within a quarter mile from the subject property.
18:17Community infrastructure planning staff analysis on traffic impacts would be addressed in the report for the accompanying plan map amendment HC CPA 2520, and based on that traffic analysis, there's adequate capacity to accommodate the additional trips generated by the proposed future land use change under HCCPA 2520.
18:35And Hillsboro County Public Schools stated that Wimama Elementary, Shields Middle, and Sumner High Schools are projected to be overcapacity given the existing approved approved development and proposed amendment.
18:45Currently, additional capacity exists in adjacent concurrency service areas at the high school level.
18:50However, there is no adjacent capacity available at the elementary and middle school levels, and the applicant was advised to contact the school district for more information.
19:00The proposed amendment is consistent with the following objectives, policies and objectives and policies of the comprehensive plan.
19:07The proposal meets the intent of Flu's Objective 1.1 and Flu's policy 1.1.9, which directs 80% of the population growth into the urban service area and establishes the criteria for publicly and privately initiated USA amendments.
19:19In this case, the subject site is adjacent and contiguous to the established urban service area.
19:24Additionally, the site is adjacent to a publicly initiated amendments that the Board of County Commissioners directed staff to initiate.
19:30And the request meets the criteria in Flu's policy 1.1.9.
19:34According to FLUS policy 3.1.1, 3.1.2, and 3.1.3.
19:40Compatibility and gradual transitions of intensities and densities between different land uses shall be provided for as new development is proposed.
19:46The residential for future land use designation surrounds the site, and there are lower density residential developments on all sides.
19:52The transition to residential residential for on the subject site with an urban service area expansion would allow for density intensity that is compatible with the existing area.
20:02Flu's objective 4.4 and its associated policies seek to protect protect existing neighborhoods and communities and those that will emerge in the future.
20:10The request is consistent with the neighborhood community development objective and policies as the surrounding land use pattern is comprised of mostly single family residential and agricultural uses and south of Saffold Road.
20:20There are mainly public quasi-public institutional uses.
20:23The proposed request complements the existing community character and development pattern.
20:26And lastly, the proposal meets goal five of the Waiamama Village Community Plan.
20:31Goal five of the plan seeks to encourage housing to accommodate a diverse population and range of income levels.
20:36The expansion of the urban service area and change of the future land use designation increases the type of housing allowed on the subject site, as well as allows for housing on a smaller lot size, which can be more affordable for the residents of the Wimama village area.
20:49The planning commission recommends that the proposed map amendment be found consistent with the goals, objectives, and policies of the unincorporated Hillsborough County Comprehensive Plan.
20:57And this concludes my presentation.
20:59I'm here if you have any questions.
21:18This is a combined public hearing for HCCPA 2519 and HCCPA 2520.
21:24If you're wishing to speak, please come forward.
21:29Good evening, Cammy Corbett with the law firm of Hill Ward and Henderson.
21:32I don't really have anything else to add here.
21:33It's pretty straightforward.
21:34These are little add-on pieces to the council zoning that you've already approved, and you'll see our rezoning in a few months that shows that we're not adding any units actually to the PD.
21:43We're just kind of adding the acreage.
21:44So I'm here to answer any questions.
21:46Should you have any questions?
21:52Not seeing anyone else.
21:53Um we do have to vote on these separately.
21:55What's the pleasure of the board?
22:00So we have to vote on them separately.
22:04Please record your vote.
22:05We had a um motion by Commissioner Wistel and a second by Commissioner Myers for HCCPA 2519.
22:17Motion carried six to zero.
22:29Sorry, the confusion was we thought the presentation was for both.
22:32That's what I was advised.
22:33So that's why I moved forward.
22:34So I'm sorry if you would like this second one presented.
22:39Um that's the decision of the board.
22:40If you'd like to hear the presentation, then staff can give the presentation.
22:45I thought it was uh combined, but if you'd like to proceed with the presentation, they can okay.
22:55I think we should no one come back and say we did not.
22:58Okay, so then item C2 is HCCPA 25-20, which will be presented by Alexis Myers.
23:04Good evening, Commissioners.
23:05Alexis Myers Plan the Commission staff here to present HCCPA 25 uh 20 located at 4950 Southworth Road.
23:14This is a privately initiated map amendment that is small in scale and approximately 10.01 acres.
23:19The applicant is requesting the change of future land use designation from agricultural rural one to five to residential four.
23:27This is the general location map.
23:29Uh, this amendment is associated with HCCPA 2519 to expand the urban service area.
23:34It is in the rural area and within the limit the limits of the South Shore Airwise Systems Plan and Wawama Village Community Plan.
23:40It is located north of Saffold Road and west of County Road 579.
23:46Here is the area of the site.
23:47The site is online in pink, and the blue line indicates the urban service area boundary.
23:52Here's some photos of the site.
23:54This is looking north of the subject site from Saffold Road.
23:57This is looking north as well.
23:59Um, to the single family use on the subject site.
24:02This is looking west of the subject site from Saffold Road, and this is facing east of the subject site from Safford Road.
24:10And then this is on the subject site looking north.
24:13Currently, the future land use designation is agricultural rule one to five.
24:18Um, the agriculture rule one of five category allows one uh dwelling unit per five gross acres, and a maximum fluoride ratio of 0.25.
24:26This does a designation allows for the consideration of farms, ranches, V lots, residential neighborhood commercial offices, uh, industrial uses related to agricultural uses and mining related activities.
24:37Other future land use categories shown in this map include natural preservation and agricultural one at 10.
24:44The applicant is opposing to amend the future land use category to residential four.
24:48The residential four category allows four dwelling units per gross acre and a maximum flora ratio of 0.25.
24:55This designation allows for the consideration of agricultural, residential, neighborhood commercial, office uses, and multi-purpose projects.
25:03Next are the impacts.
25:05As far as the existing conditions, currently under AR 1 to 5, the site could consider up to two dwelling units or 109,08 square feet of non-residential uses.
25:15Under the proposed future land use designation of res four, the site could consider up to 40 uh dwelling units or 109,000 and eight square feet of non-residential uses.
25:25During the rezoning process, uh commercial and locational criteria may affect the allowable square footage for potential non-residential development.
25:33The proposed amendment will result in the increase in development potential by allowing higher residential density.
25:40This is the consistency review.
26:06The proposed amendment is also consistent uh with South with the South Shore Airwise Systems Community Plan and Waiwamid Village Community Plan, as well as the livable communities element.
26:18With this, planning commission recommends that the proposed map amendment be filed consistent with the goals, objectives, and policies of the unincorporated Hillsborough County Comprehensive Plan.
26:26And this concludes my presentation.
26:28Again, thank you, Miss Myers.
26:30Uh, sorry for the confusion.
26:31Um, would the applicant like to come forward?
26:34This is a public hearing.
26:35Anyone wishing to come forward and speak on CPA 2520.
26:41Seeing none, what's the pleasure of the board?
26:44I hear a motion by Commissioner Cohen and a second by Commissioner Myers.
26:48Please record your vote.
26:53Motion carried six to zero.
26:58We will now adjourn the comprehensive plan amendment public hearing and begin the land development code amendment public hearing.
27:04The board of county commissioners will consider the adoption of the amendment to the land development code.
27:08The board will vote on the proposed amendment after the close of the public hearing.
27:12I will now request that the development services department staff introduce the land development code amendment of this evening's agenda.
27:21Uh Israel Monsanto Development Services.
27:24Um land development code 25126 updates to the well head and surface water protection area.
27:31This uh the purpose of this proposed land development code amendment is to update regulations associated with the well head on surface water protections to reflect the proposed updated maps requested in AC CPA 2516 that were um adopted earlier by this board today to provide clarity to the existing land development co-language and align the review frequency with the Tampa Bay Waters Master Plan uh updates.
27:57Uh these will consolidate the regulations of the for the removal of the uh WRPA zone one, improve the current land development code text from 30500.
28:06Um it will also remove the WRPA zone one areas delineated in the map since there has been no new public portable water supply wells constructed in this zone since its adoption 2021 years ago, uh, nor are there any future plans to do so.
28:21And lastly, we'll provide flexibility for the county to review and provide map updates between review cycles to propose the rule RPA or or SWRPA designation for future or additional sources of drinking water when discovered.
28:34Uh, no significant changes since the first public hearing, and this concludes my presentation.
28:38Um Savi Savel, if you have any questions.
28:41Thank you very much.
28:42This is a public hearing.
28:43Anyone wishing to speak, please come forward.
28:48Seeing no one in the queue for discussion, pleasure.
28:53I have a motion by Commissioner Whistle, second by Commissioner Cohen.
28:57Please record your vote on LDC 251126.
29:04Motion carried six to zero.