The Government Operations Committee met on September 2, 2026, to review the City of Houston's employee accountability and disciplinary procedures, specifically the Positive Corrective Action Program (AP 3-7). The session included a presentation from Human Resources and a public comment from a union representative highlighting challenges in the Houston Emergency Center. No consent calendar items were discussed.
And also from Councilwoman Twilight Carter, Councilman Castillo, and Councilmember. I forget. Peck. So thank you very much, and also the mayor of Pro Tem's office as well. So council members and staff, please hold your questions until the end of the presentations. If there are any members of the public that would like to participate in public comment, there's a sign-in sheet at the front of the table. And Director Cheeks, thank you for joining us. And you've got a presentation and uh also Elizabeth Rogers, Senior Division Manager of Employee Relations. We'll provide a review of the City of Houston's City Employee Accountability and Disciplinary Procedures. So thank you very much. Thank you, Chair. Staff. Thank you for allowing HR to present on the city employee accountability and disciplinary procedures. The positive corrective action program prioritizes improvements, accountability, and coaching. AP 3 7 outlines clear, informal and formal steps to ensure fairness and consistency. The goal is not punishment, but a meaningful behavioral change supported by leadership. It reinforces transparency and due process. It also encourages early intervention before issues escalate. And the beauty of positive corrective action program is it provides opportunity not only to address behavior, but it surfaces any underlying issue that requires additional support, accommodation, or resources. Using the policy properly protects both employees and city, ensuring all actions align with legal and HR standards. As I've stated to supervisors, managers, and executives, it is imperative that we give our employees every opportunity to be successful while improving employee performance and strengthening accountability. AP 3 7 steps are as follows. Level one and level two provide structure while allowing flexibility based on severity and history. Training is actively underway across departments, reinforcing correct application of the policy. Next slide. So part of understanding why we use our current discipline model is recognizing where we came from. For many years, the city relied on a traditional progressive discipline system built around unpaid suspensions. Those suspensions ranged from three days, five, seven, ten, and even fifteen days. And a 15-day unpaid suspension, if you think about it, is a whole paycheck. So the philosophy behind that system was what many described as a pound of flesh approach. The belief that if discipline was painful, employees would avoid future violations. But the results were negative and counterproductive. Fear, resentment, inconsistent improvement, and operational disruptions caused by removing employees from the workploy workforce for long periods of time. As the city evaluated this model, it became clear that it did not build a high performing workforce. It did not drive meaningful change in behavior, performance, or attendance. That recognition led us to pursue a better and more effective approach. Next slide. So recognizing the need for change, the city made a deliberate shift away from the punishment-based discipline and adopted a model rooted in Dick Groat's discipline without punishment. This model fundamentally reshapes how organizations think about corrective action by replacing traditional punishment with structured, respectful accountability. It encourages employees to change their behavior through commitment, not coercion. The Houston Airport system was the first department to pilot this approach, demonstrating that positive accountability can work effectively in a high demand operational environment. Houston Public Works expanded the concept through its superior performance program, confirming its effectiveness across diverse municipal functions. In 2015, this accountability based framework was adopted citywide, marking a major shift in how we manage performance and behavior. The city replaced punitive measures with a system grounded in respect, fairness, and constructive guidance, one that aims to help employees genuinely improve rather than simply endure discipline. Next slide. AP 3 7 reflected that reflects that shift. It's grounded in mutual respect, clarity, and employee growth. The policy sets expectations in a consistent, predictable way for our civil service workforce. And importantly, AP 3 7 does not aim to punish someone into compliance. It aims to help employees understand expectations and succeed in meeting them.